The Rose - "Sour" - Former Boyband Member Reacts!

My reaction to hearing and watching "Sour" by The Rose.
Thanks for watching! 🙌🏼 Subscribe & turn on notifications to find out when I upload new videos! bit.ly/SubNathanWalters
Follow me:
Instagram: / nathanwalters
Facebook: / nathanwaltersofficial
TikTok: / nathanwaltersmusic
Spotify: tinyurl.com/jf2mw2us
Apple: / nathan-walters
Website: nathanwalters.com
#reaction #kpop #indierock

[@Taera1230]

OMG as an ARMY and Black Rose your channel really make me happy!! I love your honest reactions,,hope you keep going,,i rose you 🥀

[@Maria-wr6sx]

Army and Black Rose here too! 💜🥀

[@beanism12]

Army and Black Rose as well!!!💜🖤🌹

[@mandeefarley1399]

Yes! ARMY and Black Rose!

[@katb7996]

ARMY and BLACK ROSE here 💜🥀

[@zeinabali7978]

Mee 3 😂

[@arzupan]

The rose is so underrated they are amazing

[@jenniferclark1258]

I love The Rose! They have 3 new songs, Alive, Back to Me and You're Beautiful. My favorites include Time live from Joshua Tree, She's in the Rain, The Definition of Ugly Is, Beauty and the Beast, Sorry and Insomia. I could literally go on and on but would then be naming all of their songs 😂. I hope you are able to do more reactions. The lead singer Woosung also does a song with Agust D, aka Suga of BTS called Snooze and it is also amazing!

[@antalwyn8738]

All of that. Love The Rose and BTS.

[@clbock1227]

Yes, they did write it! You made me so happy with this reaction! Thank you for giving the Rose a try. They are awesome. I'm a Black Rose/Army and I'm really enjoying your journey!

[@Maria-wr6sx]

The Rose!!! I love them! I'm 57 , have been an Army for 7 years & a Black Rose for 4 years. Both bands are amazing. I went with my teen daughter to BTS' concert in Brazil in 2019, and last December we went to The Rose's concert in Argentina. .... we had a blast, best concerts ever! Both are astonishing live. Woosung's voice (leader of The Rose) is so unique... he sings in cursive! Thanks for your reactions! You should check their debut song "Sorry" & also " She's in the rain" (beautiful lyrics) Thanks again 🥀💜

[@bulletproof_hope]

Yeah, love his voice! I also suggested'Sorry' and 'She's in the rain ' under another video. And I would add 'Snooze' Woosung's Collab with SUGA !

[@psin4953]

We have so much in common! I am 41. I have been an ARMY for 7 years as well and been a black rose for almost 4 yrs. I've seen BTS twice before with my oldest daughter, but I was fortunate enough to take all 3 of my daughters to their PTD concert in Vegas last year. And I was also fortunate again to be able to take my oldest daughter to the Rose's concert in Chicago last October. I love both groups!! And am so proud of all their accomplishments. Not to mention, both groups are amazing live!

[@Maria-wr6sx]

@@psin4953 Indeed we have a lot in common! So lucky you were able to see BTS that many times. I'm from Uruguay (South America) and they usually don't tour here. I was lucky enough in 2019 to fly to Brazil but don't see that happening again in future tours. The tickets fir The Rose were also very hard to get, they sold out in less than 2hs. They had to upgrade the venue cause it was too small. I believe they had no idea that there are a lot of Black Roses in South America

[@psin4953]

@Maria-wr6sx I always feel bad for ARMY who live far from where they will tour. We are very lucky that BTS comes to America. We went to their Love Yourself and their Speak Yourself Tours. BTS concerts are really on another level. Don't get me started with The Rose. Lol we bought tix for the Chicago show even though it landed on the same day we would go to see Enhypen. So after I bought the Rose tix, I resold our Enhypen tix(which got bought up right away). Then couple days later, they switched to a bigger venue with a different date. 😭 They didn't anticipate the demand in Chicago either. Needless to say, we could've gone to Enhyphen and the Rose, but our tickets were already sold. Anyways, it was still worth it to see the Rose.

[@Maria-wr6sx]

@@psin4953 OMG! My daughter & I are ENGENES too! THIS IS TOO MUCH! If you tell me that you are also obssesed with kdramas I'm done

[@heySTOBIT7583]

I'm glad you found the ROSE. They make their own music. All four of them can sing. The main vocalists Woosung has a distinctive raspy voice. Dojoon's vocals complement Woosungs. I recommend their debut song SORRY, BEAUTY & the BEAST. SHE'S IN THE RAIN , BABY.

[@amymerrill5758]

I love The Rose!!! The lead singer is Woosung and he has great solo work too. I would recommend Jackson Wang if you haven't listened to him before. Songs and MVs are fantastic.

[@bl00dFairy]

Omg one of my other favorite bands outside of BTS! My friend's hubby is their manager and creative director. Super talented. I recommend their new song "You're Beautiful", and a song the main vocalist Woosung did with Suga from BTS called "Snooze!" Also if you want to hear the Rose live, their song "Sorry" or Woosung's cover of "ILYSB" live is soooo good. His voice is def insane.

[@ktay2124]

Yes, they write all+, compose, and arrange most of their music. They are an amazing band very talented!

[@loftyradish6972]

Oh and The Definition of Ugly live. They are just freaking beautiful live.

[@loftyradish6972]

Childhood by The Rose is hands down one of the most beautiful songs I have ever listened to. Been a fan since they first released Sorry, just always release incredible music, and the vocals are to die.

[@ericweinman9447]

Watching The Rose bloom has been a joy. As an ARMY I do have to say a talented group rising from busking on the streets to going on global tour inspires me much as the BTS story of rising within a near bankrupt small company. Woosung (Sammy) in particular is a Korean American who went to Korea to become an Idol but found it not a good fit so did a number of things before finding other future bandmates who similarly wanted to be something other than corporate Idols. This K-Pop group fronted by a remarkably personable natural English speaker brings rock instrumentation so I think is quite Western ready. Side note, Woosung sung the chorus on BTS Suga's Agust D song Snooze.

[@anyelicontreras4430]

They are awesome! I met them recently and fell in love immediately. You should react to their recent realeases BACK TO ME, ALIVE and YOU'RE BEAUTIFULL from their album DUAL, you will not regret.

[@christelbodin3948]

This band is a gem, and the Voice of the Singer Woosung gives me chills.. I think you would love the collab with August D/Suga of BTS, the song Snooze. Combining the best of two worlds👌♥️

[@anniebeemusicetc]

Nathan, thanks so much for checking out The Rose!! Other fans are suggesting great songs from them, such as "Time" (live from Joshua Tree), but I'd like to add "RED" to the list. They have a new album coming out soon called "Dual" and have already released MVs for 3 of the songs: "Alive" (my fave!), "You're Beautiful" and "Back To Me." I've seen The Rose in concert, and they're fantastic live!!

[@psin4953]

Thanks for reacting to the Rose!!❤🥀 I would recommend their debut song "Sorry", cover of "ILYSB", and "She's in the Rain". Their newer stuff "Back To Me" and "Alive" are awesome as well. They do write their own stuff. I think it was Woosung who said that if they were not able to write their own stuff, then they would not still be a band. Looking forward to more reactions to BTS and the Rose. 💜🖤❤️

[@agustinabonoficio5118]

The rose is touring the United States. Yo army and black roses do not miss the opportunity to see them live

[@carlaminut]

They're amazing, you should jump and dive all their music and Woosung's solo too👍🏻💯

[@evelynhong2909]

I discovered The Rose through BTS and they are really underrated! I love their Heal album and recent single releases - worth checking out

[@filanthi3660]

Yes The Rose write their own stuff. If you look into their story you’ll see they went through some really tough times. The lead singer is Woosung, he’s Korean-American so his English is excellent, he released a solo album a while back while the other members were doing their mandatory military service in Korea (about 18-24 months I think). One of their hits from a while back is Sorry.

[@a.k.a.b-hope1088]

I am so glad you got into The Rose! They are my second favorite group after BTS. I fell in love with their song She's in the Rain and then I became Black Rose with their album Heal which is amazing! Should check out Childhood as well. They compose, write and produce their own songs, just like BTS. Look forward to more The Rose as well.🌹❤

[@christinab1288]

How is no one liking you reacting to The Rose?!?!?! Love The Rose, seeing them in concert soon!!! Also check out their new song Back To Me!!! Love me some indie rock, and yes they write all their own music

[@rjbirmingham]

I agree how does this not have more - wonder if it notice did not go out - I did not see it - they had a great set at lollapalooza last month

[@stillwithyou7072]

I am a massive The Rose fan. Saw them live at BST Hyde Park, they were outstanding! They all sing and are so incredibly talented.

[@marionperhonita2731]

One of my faves. The rose's discography is insane. Seeing them live was one of my highlights this year.

[@sarahjane86guitar]

I would love to see your reaction to “Back to Me” and “Alive”. I’m so excited to see them live in October.

[@sarahjane86guitar]

Woosung-the first person to sing-had some great solo work too. I got into The Rose from his solo stuff.

[@lisarogerio9249]

Woosung from The Rose sings a song called Snooze with Suga of BTS- you need to check it out! It it one of my favs from Suga’s latest album!

[@Krystal109]

Yup. The Rose write and produce all their own music. They used to be under a Korean label, but the sued a few years ago to get out of their contracts. After 2 years of battle and 2 of the members going through mandatory military service they came back as independent artists. You can actaully see a huge shift in their music from their Korean produced stuff, which is predominately sung in Korean, and their independent stuff that is a mixture of English and Korea between "Beauty and the Beast" (a song they held on to for 2 yrs during their struggles) and their HEAL album.

[@evycc4772]

That song is so beautiful...

[@dariajustdaria2292]

The Rose is a gem, many armys are at least casual listeners of this band :) Woosung (the lead vocalist) is friends with Suga from BTS and they have an amazing song together called Snooze, highly recommend!

[@tammarabg8174]

I did not find The Rose until last spring when Woosung (the first vocalist) did a duet with Suga called Snooze. I recommended them before... a female vocalist I like is Aurora (Murder song, Runaway...). a vocalist that thoroughly leaves my jaw on the floor is Dimash Qudaibergen (SOS).

[@fanofvann]

Love this group. So many good tunes: face, phase me, lazy, sorry, she's in the rain, back to me. My favorite is childhood

[@samsunggood8680]

Thank you for the reaction❤they have three new ones but actually any of their songs is great, i can't even choose between them. And Woosung's solo stuff is also so good😊

[@simon17sez]

I do love The Rose...they're great. I'm a Black Rose/Army. I am excited to see you watching all different groups.

[@jaelaapplegate8218]

The Rose is my 2nd fav after BTS of course Woosung the lead singer wrapped me in w his amzing vocals and they are coming to my home town in october i can't wait!!!!!

[@debs6225]

Thank you so so much for reacting to The Rose, they are awesome. Their latest sons is You’re Beautiful, another love song ❤

[@sandrine1797]

Happy you discover them !! They are amazing. I recommend “the definition of ugly is” live and “the beauty and the beast”. Love from France 🌸

[@poppinpmrey]

I am an army and a new black rose so this makes me so happy 😊

[@Sujan_Draws]

Their writing process is actually quite collaborative which is insane. They all contribute and the lyrics have to be agreed on by each member. So if someone wants one word vs another they have to kind of appeal to the group and everyone has to agree to the change or it doesn’t happen. They’re so unique in everything they do. Woosung (the guy in the middle) could easily be a solo act but he won’t do anything without his band in mind. Even his solo album when they were in the military (he’s American) was to promote the band, not himself. He was talking to a company about getting signed and as soon as he found his band he refused to sign without them. Why? Because on the first chord he played with them as a group he knew that was the musical fate he had been looking for. Their Dusk/Dawn album is a whole vibe. Each song is super strong but heard as a whole, with the intentional “side a/b design, it becomes a whole different beast. You should really check out Alive. It merges 80’s synth dance and …well…I’ll let you discover the other genre on your own. 😂

[@ARMYGUL89]

I am an ARMY who loooooove The Rose ....such a pleasur to hear their Music 💜🫰🌹

[@kailycooper6575]

Honestly, you can't go wrong with The Rose. Woosung (main singer, lead guitar), Dojoon (singer, guitar, keyboard), Hajoon (drums, vocals), and Jaehyeong (bass, vocals) are top tier talent on their own and together. They had a very rocky path early on in the career due to crappy circumstances with their label, but they are independent now and are able to write, produce, and market all of their own music. They are powerhouses and severely underrated. All of the songs mentioned in other comments are sure to wow you, as I said you can't go wrong with The Rose, but one song that always hits me hardest, and I think is just an absolute work of art, is Beauty and the Beast. Lyrics aside, this song emotes so well through the melodies and harmonies, which I know you really resonate with, and the voices of Woosung and Dojoon are magical on this track. 10/10 recommend you check this song out!!

[@dalladalla-mt4ep]

Please they are literally so fckn amazing 😭♥️ they deserve more recognition

[@lilyduck4538]

The Rose! They are underrated but so good! And the lead singer is an amazing actor who has been in a bunch of stuff

[@JeonJungkook-wr4yr]

Im a 32 year old Army and i really love the rose im forever a fan they are so good

[@debraramos5805]

I'm a Black Rose 🌹 this song is one of my favorite❤. Their debut son Sorry, She's in the rain, Red, Beauty and the beast are amazing. From the new album Dual a love wonder and alive. Thanks for the reaction.

[@karinacasco1895]

So glad you reacted to the Rose ….. just love their music. Their new album is amazing ❤❤❤❤

[@ellie_jeann]

#TheRose Woosung is the leader and he grew up in California …. their debut song is SORRY followed by RED, Alive, Back To Me, Beauty & the Beast, Baby, You’re Beautiful (new), etc. They have many great songs you could check out!!!

[@lindahughes4991]

Childhood is beautiful and a message we all should hear.

[@michellecagbay2050]

They’re so good live 🥹🥹🥹🥹

[@scarleth1928]

I love love love that you got to listen to the Rose, they sound even more amazing live, suggestions for your next reaction; she's in the rain, seesaw (all of them sing this one) and black Rose (which is also the name of the fandom

[@LMPZ23]

The roseeeeeee !!!! Omg the rose is AMAZING Live

[@cathou-quebec8544]

My ultimate combo! BTS & The Rose❤

[@nina_wantstofly4570]

I love The Rose, my favourite at the moment are She's in the rain and Back to me. I cannot stop listening to those songs 💜💜💜

[@generacion7174]

Woosung (leader voice) made a collaboration with Suga's last project, amazing

[@JoSedunary]

Oh Nathan I'm so happy you're reacting to The Rose !! They are awesome... and four of the most humble people on the planet... so talented and they write such great music !! Thank you ! 🖤

[@jasonandlorislate2511]

They write everything!!!! Love The Rose!!!

[@adrianamartinez4268]

Nathan, I'm glad you took my suggestion about The Rose into account. I knew you would like it!!!

[@anniebeemusicetc]

Gangstagrass!! They're a Nashville-based band that combines bluegrass and rap. They are so fun, especially on-stage live!! Songs by them to check out: "All For One," "Ain't No Crime" and "I Wanna Ride With You."

[@vernaengelmann2594]

Love, love The Rose, so sad I won’t be able to see them again.😢

[@BangtansMomma]

I have recently become a rose fan, maybe a few months before Woosung did the song with Suga. I just love their songs and they sound great live too!

[@birsuarjmy1438]

Omg beautiful band beautiful voice 😍

[@diatima]

Yay the Rose! I don't know much about them yet, but I love the song "phase me"

[@fiavit8011]

The rose is spectacular! So happy you were able to react to them!

[@oceanminded0134]

OMG, I remember seeing Plus One perform live. I just found this reaction video. Loved it. Thank you for reacting to The Rose!

[@brianal1808]

This guys are amazing!! Their raspy, musky and yet sweet voices are incomparable. Reminds me of early 2000’s bands.

[@vanesacarrasco246]

Love the rose ❤! Maybe you should check out DPRian, more experimental but equally awesome, his later single it's call "peanutbutter and tears"

[@CarolineForest]

I remember seeing them live in Oslo! As ARMY and BlackRose. I loove that you checked them out too! They recently released a new album and I recommend checking out the lead song on it " Back to me"

[@IM.nam1]

Another The rose song that I recommend to you it's call "childhood" Love it

[@amjwoodal]

Early last summer they asked fans to send in stories from the pabdemic and they wrote the Heal album based on those. It is a masterpiece. ❤❤❤

[@lelmdrWHO]

Yes! The rose is so amazing!!

[@brionyfakatou1620]

I have tickets to see them live in 2 weeks! If you like this one you should check out Back to Me, Alive, She’s In The Rain, and Cure.

[@dagalas]

WOOSUNG's 'Phase me' and 'Lazy' are awesome

[@yulidiaz2142]

Oh the rose!!!! Amazing! I love it!!!! I love bts and I love the rose! Woosung is a beautiful vocalist, you must listening back to me, red, ILYSB 😍😍😍😍😍😍

[@biancajoycelandia]

Love them too..they do sound 💯👌 awesome live like Bangtan 💜🖤

[@jasperavelis9678]

So happy you found The Rose!

[@jassypr]

Legit gave me goosebumps first time hearing them in ur channel!

[@Morrigan591]

Wow!!! The Rose 🌹 I’d be happy to listen to a playlist curated by Nathan. You’ve great taste and as I said before your take as a producer in the reviews give me deeper knowledge on what I already love

[@nicolecmke]

I'd never heard of this band before. I've since listened to a few more of their songs. I like them! They just released a new album this year. It's decent.

[@mdzwonkowska]

I got to know The Rose shortly after I became an ARMY, just like BTS, they are an inspiration to me. I had the great pleasure of attending The Rose's concert as well as Woosung's concert. They are fantastic live! If you'd like to listen: there's a song by Agust D (Suga from BTS) featuring Woosung (from The Rose) - "Snooze" (they are friends, support each other, and respect each other). Thx!

[@jendiademalleyhart3027]

The ROSE is amazing and their new stuff is really pushing the guys over into experimenting with heavier sounds than their early stuff. I waited 2 long years for them to finish their mandatory military service and to break from their old, toxic company and it was well worth the wait. I love their entire discography, but HEAL and now DUAL are nothing short of 🔥 Thank you for reacting to THE ROSE, they are sorely under appreciated!

[@jermanijohnson.3481]

YESSSSSSSS I LOVE THE ROSEEE

[@colettemr]

I am so glad you took my suggestions.... I am going to see them in Oct and they are GREAT. At the age of 53, and discovering them via SUGAs collab on the song Snooze. I was like WHO IS THIS GUY???? Like BTS, they write and produce their own `music. They are independent after leaving their old agency. Lead singers are Woosung (Sammy) and Dojoon (Leo - one on keys and acoustic) Drummer is Hajoon (Dylan) and the Bass is Jaehyeong (Jeff).

[@zuzu8660]

Oh!! Thank you for reacting to The Rose. I love The Rose. They have so many good songs, but firstly, I would like to recommend you these She's In The Rain, Sorry, ILYSB (cover), BABY, Back To Me Their live performances are also very good but usually their lyrics are touching, so for the translations, I think if there is a music video, watching the music video or reading the lyrics if you want to watch the live version might be a better idea.

[@Nikki1249g]

They do a cover of ILYSB that blows my mind every time I watch it. Highly suggest it (not the recorded version, just the live version). But their original songs are all amazing. Very talented group. Alive is my current obsession. I hope you react to it.

[@naatusska4545]

I love The Rose!! I'm so happy of your reaction 😊

[@zari.9237]

I love them 🌹🥰

[@reid8262]

You should listen to back to me by the rose.

[@adenaballegeer6701]

The Rose is amazing!! Some suggestions - She's in the Rain, Back to Me, I.L.Y, the list could carry on! I'm so excited to meet them and see them perform in Vancouver in October!!!

[@adenaballegeer6701]

Oh! And Woosung, the lead singer and guitarist released a song with Agust D (aka Suga from BTS) called Snooze - which is incredible!

[@eyjey96]

Thank you for reacting to the rose!

[@lizgraham4871]

Love The Rose ❤

[@ibethvalencia5596]

The rose 💜

[@mjn4589]

The Rose are amazing, so talented and funny in concert. Love them. Ty ❤💜

[@TheLornaRebecca]

Yes they write their own music :) also you can listen to a group called HYUKOH "jesus lived in a motel room" "tomboy" or "love ya!" they make amazing music

[@nannaiversen5406]

yeahhhhh. The Rose. Please react to "shes in the rain". The song is AMAZING

[@Mikayla_DeAnne]

I love BTS and The Rose! I'm a fan of pretty much all the boy groups(like Stray Kids, TXT, EXO, SuperM, NCT, Day6, GOT7, PLT, etc.) from Korea, lol 😅 I hope you check out more from The Rose in the near future though! My recommendations would be for their newest songs "Alive" and "Back To Me" and slightly older would be "She's In The Rain", "Red", and "Sorry". Me personally, I've been streaming Alive and Back to me on repeat since they came out! Thank you for reacting to some great bands and artists! 💜💜

[@Dreamingbig2294]

Ahhh the Rose. Love them!! My fav song by them is Sorry. Please react to it when you get a chance. 🙏🏾

[@mariasolaguirre7797]

Hello The Rose is a great band, they have a song with Suga from BTS. Greetings 💜🇦🇷

[@Lisathom22_Seven]

Please do more "The Rose" songs!!

[@dr.sharmavet]

They are GOOOOOOOOOOD❤

[@bobbijoisaacson4754]

Love woosung , check out out Snooze by Suga featuring woosung of the rose

[@marionsineux1875]

Hello, thank you for your reaction to the Rose :) it's a great band, even though they're not always working together and i find quite underrated. As an army and kpop fan, your reaction are really enlighting and I'm glad i discovered your channel ! If you like the Rose, i recommend Lee Hong Gi(이홍기), Yoo Hwe Seung(유회승) _ Still love you(사랑했었다), they're also a cover just by Yoo Hwe Seung. This man voice is incredible, like angelical, powerful one of the most beautiful I've ever heard. As a singer and musician I think you'll appreciate the technic and emotion and I would love to hear you react to it ^^