The Secret Agreement That Shaped the Middle East | History of Israel Explained | Unpacked

[@UNPACKED]

Want to learn more about what Judaism has to say on things? Check out our other channel Big Jewish Ideas! kzbin.info/door/cAK9Kt7zg_FfDM3hTTearA

[@Dangreenwatson]

@@user-ts2jk2xe3m I support BDS and a one state solution where are Palestinians and Israelis live in one multicultural society, but your pseudo-history is nonsense

[@michaelsmullen9891]

You missed out the creation of Transjordan which was created on land that was ¾ of the British Mandate for Palestine. Empirical British tactics of divide and conquer. Part of this land was considered part of Greater Syria but there has never been any request for it's return. It was also the sight of the greatest massacre of the people that chose the nomenclature 'Palestinian' in Black September 1970 with the now deceased leader of the P.L.O. Yasser Arafat claiming that 25,000 of them were killed. This was carried out on orders of King Hussein of Jordan, the father of the present king. Unfortunately this land is the secret key to peace in the Middle East. Incidentally, the total of Arabs killed by Israel in more than six wars and all other 'Palestinians' killed by Israel since 1948 till today is thought to be close to double the figure that Jordan killed in Black September. Perspective!

[@michaelcanning2204]

If Jews are so self-dependent on American taxes to support their nation, then what am I working for?!

[@dorjedriftwood2731]

I believe the ottoman ruler was literally sick, and expected to die, which is why it was called the sick man. They saw it as politically unstable because it’s rulership was in question.

[@lmartin461]

good morning 😊I hope you have a great 😊week too well ée RT w refer rŵw😮😮

[@TheMaxreuben]

I like how you conveniently missed mentioning the Hussein-McMahon correspondence which is the other side of the Balfour declaration & Sykes-picot, where the British supported the Arab revolt, and promised them self-rule of their dominions. That agreement was never fully realized while the Balfour declaration essentially was realized by the creation of a Jewish state, post-WWII. Hence, why many Palestinians and Arabs felt betrayed by the allied powers. So long story short, colonial powers played regional powers and peoples against each other in order to further their own selfish ambitions in the region.

[@davidroscoe3815]

Really, so Arabs get 99.9% and that's still not enough? that's really the crux of the conflict, even one square kilometre of a Jewish homeland is a square kilometre too much.

[@yo7anan]

I'm not sure I understand. Arabs do have their own states and self rule, no?

[@EiChing123]

Exactly!

[@smartandhandsome]

Israel forced independence, it wasn't as if the British picked sides. They even stopped Jewish migration into the region.

[@meirm471]

Yep, they conveniently forgot to mention the British empire agreed to build pretty much an ISIS state after WW1 in exchange for Sheikh Hussein betraying the Ottoman empire... Sheikh Hussein though did not go home empty handed in the end, check out the kingdoms his sons established... As for colonizers, isn't it strange how "colonization" is a word used only when it's done by western powers, when it's done by others this word is not used too often, strange isn't it...

[@tylergagnon1613]

It all started with the assassination of Franz Duke Ferdinand. The fall out of that assassination led to events that are still felt today. Franz death led not only the outbreak of world war 1, which paved way for the Nazis and world war 2, but also created many events that led to treaties that caused complete turmoil in the Middle East. This ultimately paved way to the creation of the Taliban, 9/11, and eventually the creation of Isis. It actually makes me wonder if Ferdinand wasn’t killed would world war 1 happen and ultimately all the fallout that was caused by it?

[@casuallavaring]

If it wasn’t Franz Ferdinand it would have been something else. The world before WWI was a powder keg waiting to explode and the world powers would have found some other excuse to go at it

[@VALKORION3621]

One man changed the course of history.

[@eerycar7381]

Butterfly effect

[@BenDover-wb6si]

That just means it started before that 😂😂😂 tell me, what happened before ARCHDUKE Franz Ferdinand was assassinated and why was he assassinated 😂

[@BenDover-wb6si]

​@orion9884 lol history is scripted, they're lying to us.

[@frankinmyrrh330]

Another important detail is that Sykes Pico determined the borders and flags of Arab states, something that wasn't too common before the European intervention. So groups like ISIS want to recognize that Jordan for instance, is not any different to Syria in terms of its nationality. The Arabs were used to tribes and villages rather than "states" "countries" which is a western idea of self determination that wasn't so common in the Middle East.

[@Nitzanw2009]

and thats why there wasnt ever a "palestinian people", these were just familes (in the arab meaning) who lived in the region. israel or better put the "zionist" united them (as much muslims can be).

[@tc7500]

Disagree! The Moors Caliphate was an Umayyad Caliphate last stronghold after the civil war against the Abbasids centuries before the Ottoman Turks last Islamic Caliphate. So they were very well aware of independent Muslim state or country!

[@NoahBodze]

What you have to understand is that the colonial powers that made any of that land worth anything drew those lines ON THE ADVICE of those tribal leaders. Don’t you think it’s telling that even as the cOLiNiZeRS are gone they still can’t agree on borders. Has it ever occurred to you that the borders they drew PREVENTED more bloodshed than it caused?

[@yousefabdelmonem3788]

@@Nitzanw2009 lmao

[@MothOnWall]

@@yousefabdelmonem3788 You laugh, but yet don't think Palestinians may have included Jews, Christians, Yazidis, and Zoroastrians back then.

[@shelshant]

Why are you saying that Sykes picot did not have any effects, when it clearly drew the borders for the nations today?

[@عليياسر-ذ5ب]

Where is Rothschild?

[@Jay_in_Japan]

Because only people who don't actually understand the Middle East would say such a thing. It's not the silly lines in the desert.

[@عليياسر-ذ5ب]

@@Jay_in_Japan Why did the Rothschild family fund the plans of the British government? Is it so rich?

[@resistthenewworldorder4050]

Oy vey!

[@puraLusa]

Nope, the lines in skykes picot were different from the ones of the league of nation who were based upon administrative regions of the ottoman empire and took into consideration the lobbying of different middle eastern groups. It's the xxi century, time has come where fishing for lies to blame others stops being a solution. The problem with these or any other line in the middle east took effect with the baath party dictators who were thirsty for more, nothing historical about it, with exception of the kurds ofcourse.

[@The85F0X]

Yeah, as someone who was in Iraq when IS hit the scene, this had little impact as to why IS stood up. Their issues mostly centered around them being Sunni and being marginalized by Shia. Al Qaeda (shia) were miss treating the Sunni and leaving them out of nearly everything. This had more to do with the fact that saddam was Sunni and had oppressed the shia. I conducted the first actual reports of IS now ISIS in the diayala province in 2008/2009. They were fighting AQ in the area and were mostly “The sons of Iraq”. In the end what this boiled down to was the fact that Sunnis were not being represented.

[@johnjames5842]

Israeli Secret Intelligence Service (ISIS)

[@Andomalo]

The USS liberty. Remember that one?

[@mutalix]

They will never speak on it, goes against the motives of this channel.

[@ren2871]

The favorite thing by the anti-Israel zealots to always bring up. There was a senate investigation that found no intentional wrong doing by the Israelis. Israel paid out nearly 50 million$ to the victims. I'm still waiting for Saudi Arabia, Egypt, Libya, Qatar, PLO to pay out and apologize for 9/11, the American embassy bombing in Beirut, Lockerbie, shooting down civilian aircrafts, the Munich games massacre.

[@dm-hn2wt]

​@@mutalix just like how muslims would never speak against the terrorist organizations such as Taliban, ISIS, Hezbollah, jaish e Muhammad , lashkar e tayiba , Boko haram etc.. as they all support this ideology. Of torturing non muslims.. right?? Their behaviour just proves this correct that not all muslims are terrorists but all terrorists are muslims..

[@TheRaggedroad]

Hey this is a Masood channel, easy Bro.

[@TheRaggedroad]

Israel is an Allie ...sort of.

[@serpent645]

An excellent book on this subject: "A Peace to End All Peace: The Fall of the Ottoman Empire and the Creation of the Modern Middle East" by David Fromkin. It's a scholarly document that qualified as a source when I was working on my PhD.

[@SpringerA1984]

Found it in audiobook format!!!

[@hanojo6098]

Actually in 1908 British promiseed the leader in the arab world (Hussein bin Ali al-Hashimi ) that he will be the king of arab lands in the middle east if he fights the Ottoman Empire .wich he did bin Ali al-Hashimi ) started a war The Great Arab Revolt against the Ottoman Empire and he won and kicked the ottoman out of arab lands . Hussein bin Ali al-Hashimi ) thought that he will be not only the king of hijaz but will be king of Palestine, iraq Syria and all gulfe countries all wil lbe Sharifian Caliphate as the British promiseed him. However British betrayed( Hussein bin Ali al-Hashimi ) . He sun Prince Faisal, the King of Iraq and Syria lost his kingdom. ( Hussein bin Ali al-Hashimi ) family now only have Jordan but lost thier rule in iraq and Palestine and arab gulfe area .British Exile (Hussein bin Ali al-Hashimi ) to Cyprus island and when he died his funral was in Jerusalem . Imagine if Hussain becomes king of all arab countries today! How the arab world will be united and strong

[@puraLusa]

​@@hanojo6098 the whole mena region turned against its monarcs (with exceptions), who told u that one guy would survive? Baath party is very much an arab idea and it is anti-monarchy being socialist and all. Imagine and utopias- the go to place when reality causes too much pain.

[@lauroandrea3241]

All of Fromkins books are good.

[@tylergagnon1613]

I was assigned a history paper in college on “What was the greatest event in modern history?” Everyone chose things like 9/11 and world war 2. I chose the assassination of Franz Duke Ferdinand. My argument was that events like 9/11, the Cold War, and world war 2 were all fallouts of world War 1, which was a retaliation war for the Dukes assassination. I even added how secret agreements like this in the Middle East were linked to World wars 1 and 2, and the Cold War. I ended up getting an A on the paper

[@jrs4321]

A point of clarification, the British mandate originally covered from the Mediterranean sea to current Iraq. British cut 70+% of that to create (trans) Jordan. The remaining slice was to be Israel. That, post WW2, they were going split again for the remaining Arab and Jewish populations.

[@leontrotsky8505]

Yep Transjordan was supposed to be the Arab half and IP was supposed to be the Jewish half, this sit has kept repeating, here's your half! Here's your half of their half! Here's your half of their half of their half! The eventual goal is no Israel at all

[@revenuepath6858]

Seconding this - this video is great except that treating Transjordan as separate to, rather than part of the mandate significantly alters the ability to understand the history of the israel/Palestine conflict

[@tc7500]

Yeah!

[@tc7500]

So basically the Rabbi Jesus Christ nations created Israel, proving again that Jesus Christ is the TRUE Jewish Messiah who restored the Kingdom of Israel! See YAWEE works in mysterious ways! If the Christian nations, UK, France, USA and Russia had not destroyed the Last Islamic Caliphate, there wouldn’t have been an Israel nation today. The Ottoman Caliphate lasted over 600 years and the Jews couldn’t find a Leader or liberate themselves! 😮see😊!

[@tc7500]

The problem is that the Hashemite kingdom got defeated by the house of Saud, so they only stayed in Iraq and Jordan and even the Iraqi got deposed. So I guess Jordan is there as a favor or as a future instrument to be brought back to Arabia as legitimate descendants of the Mecca Quraysh dynasty! And that’s why every Muslim ruler in the ME falsely claim to be descendants of Muhammad HBUH for legitimacy! All Liars! Muhammad didn’t even existed! A men created Muslim Superman warrior to compete with the Jewish David and the Christian Jesus Christ!

[@rirri2386]

So fascinating that many people weren't taught this in school, but then again it's not like we were taught much american or canadian history lol

[@dylanhealy8126]

Because well educated subjects, I mean citizens, are easier to control.

[@Bell_plejdo568p]

Well this video isn’t the truth ethier this is a pro-isarel propaganda channel

[@dylanhealy8126]

@@Bell_plejdo568p Then what is the truth? WW1 and Treaty of Versailles absolutely fucked the Middle East and Africa when all the European colonies were dismantled and removed from their colonial territories, leaving dozens of power vacuums and spiraling the country into chaos. I’m not saying you’re wrong, but surely you can back your comment up. I’m a WASP, White Anglo-Saxon Protestant, not an Israeli simp or defending them, but you can’t make a claim like that and then not give any supporting evidence.

[@spinrash6000]

@@Bell_plejdo568pI’m lost his information seems biased. I’m anti religion. Why is it this war continues till today. As an outsider looking in it seems like the Palestines are locked down to one location. I also watch a documentary of Canada America are purchasing homes That belongs to the Palestine. Where are the supposed to live.

[@bryanbulmer6716]

Yeah complete trash

[@thepilgrimofinfinity4830]

They hate Sykes-Picot because it divides arab and muslim inhabited lands between artificial nation-states which were historically united in a califate state ruled by an arab or at least a muslim ruler. Modern borders of Iraq, Syria, Jordan, Lebanon never existed before the Brits and the French traced borders. The Brits promised these lands to the Hashemite Sharif of Mekka if he revolted against the Ottoman Turks while they promised Eretz Israel to the Jews in the same time. They created a pretty balagan... At least the Abraham Accords negociated with the leadership of President Trump give me hope for peace in the region!

[@higherresolution4490]

Some of the comments here, yours being one excellent example, are more insightful than the original video itself! I've actually learned a lot, not so much from the video, but from the comment section. Most comments on KZbin videos are so dumb it's hard to imagine how current culture could have declined so much. In this case, it's just the opposite.

[@NoahBodze]

They were Christian for centuries before that. Muslim savages always leave that part out. So do the Jews who waited for the pagans to build what is there to live in it. You’re more alike than you’d care to admit - both of you fight for the scraps for what the Christians create.

[@Jay_in_Japan]

A divided Arab world is a desirable thing, for the peace of the rest of the world. I say this as an Arabic speaker myself. The last thing the world needs is a resurgent caliphate

[@thegeneral2330]

We Assyrians fought for the Allies. Then we were betrayed. Isis killed thousands of Assyrian Christians and burned our pre Christian and Christian historical sites. This happened because we were not given what we were promised by the British.

[@shekhonl3542]

As I know, Kurdish are fighting Isis, not you

[@sweetsamjam1039]

Thank you so much for this one Unpacked.

[@jpmcsweeney7156]

I don't agree with all that you have said, but you have been very informative! I thank you for that.

[@scottmason5371]

As a firm supporter of the west, this really feels like some weird western propaganda

[@aslamstudio558]

5:49 League of Nations: "i like big buts and i cannot lie"

[@davesradiorepairs6344]

What is Mandate ? It's a euphemism for when you implement Sykes-Picot, to allocate and control land that is not yours, in the name of recovering the cost of the war that you wanted in the first place, without the consultation of the existing residence of those lands.. The US calls it by another name; Manifest Destiny...

[@doorhinge2039]

The territories were distributed according to the sykes picot but the sanremo agreement only changed them into temporary mandates. The territorial distribution still happened according to sykes picot.

[@markrobertson2052]

Long enough to install puppet politicians and quell political dissidents. He tried so hard to make them seem so distinct from one another lol. Seems to me the Sanremo agreement was a more sophisticated attempt to control the region. "Secret plans" vs taking over the area but then "giving it back" when they are ready for them. They didn't want to assimilate to the west. That's the beef issue ISIS has with Sykes picot, it represents the original intent of colonial power.

[@puraLusa]

No, it didn't. Sanremo agreement took into consideration the borders of ottoman administrative reagions and sykes picot was basicly straight lines.

[@matthewgabbard6415]

Lots of people got screwed after WW1. But with limited land that doesn’t really respect ethnic populations, nobody will be totally happy. Human migration and empires have spread people out all over other regions. Ukraine and several Eastern European nations got screwed too

[@piekarzpaola]

Uhm, I thought it's simple: By Sykes-Picot ISIS meant Syrian-Iraqi border which divided sunnis of both countries

[@LordCristianWaters]

ISIS was created by Saddam's loyalists. No, their motivation was limited to Iraq and Syria. Pan-Baathist vision. Read over any Hizbut-Tahrir communiques concerning ISIS, Iraq and Syria. The consensus was not in the creation or recreation of any pan-Islamic state from the past Ottoman empire.

[@stefa4013]

Hmmm I have never heard of either of the two agreements so thanks for the history lesson :)

[@Coohy]

Be careful, this is likley zionist propoganda

[@Ard-gf9kt]

He’s sugar coating* most of the stuff don’t listen to him or this channel for historical accurately

[@hockeyislife2]

@@Ard-gf9kt*sugar coating

[@flytoheights1]

Amazingly explained ❤. Thank you

[@ianblake815]

Great presentation. I didn’t know that Sykes Picot was never fully implemented. And I’ve never heard of the Sanremo agreement.

[@peteyoung9850]

😭This notion that this problem goes back thousands of years is ludicrous... It started less then a hundred years ago thanks to the British

[@hockeyislife2]

‘Less than 100 years?’ This was presented in 1916 and put in place to 1920 with gurney officially become a country in 1923 so almost exactly 100 years

[@gnlout7403]

What problem specifically?

[@Jay_in_Japan]

More like it started about 1400 years ago with a certain Meccan merchant

[@BaronEvola123]

Yeah. Blame the British, right? How long were they there, really? Anyone else around. who aren't Arab and don't even speak Arabic? The area was controlled by the Ottoman Turks. "This" problem is you focus on the thinnest slice of history.

[@gnlout7403]

Bad ideologies produce problems. This goes back over a millenia.

[@haltersweb]

Thank you for this very informative video.

[@Swolenio]

Misinformative video*

[@fatoush24]

he didn't talk about how in 11 years of war, ISIS never attacked Israel. How Israel was treating the ISIS injured in their hospital to send them back to fight in Syria.

[@fatoush24]

@@megamind1359 for the fun of it, I'll send you the video by Israelis themselves in their hospitals showing how they were healing isis fighters and interviewing them

[@fatoush24]

@@megamind1359 i tried. youtube deleted my messages 2 times. 🤷🏻‍♂️ life works in mysterious ways

[@dkerr4077]

It's really good information, and accurate. As an old guy I find it refreshing to see younger people getting it out. It's not being taught in school. Thank you

[@lisalynnn]

My kids literally learned about all of this in school, and they're gen z 😅

[@Triharyanto1968]

The Ottomans would not lose their Middle East territories should they never plunge themselves into the unnecessary war: the World War I.

[@knockemoutjohnjustjohn2763]

Loved the video. Here in America most Christian's know next to nothing about Jewish history after 70 A.D. Everything that has happened to the Jewish people has just confirmed for me that they are truly Gods chosen people. They belong in the land and the land, all of it belongs to them. The only mistake they made was not driving out ALL of the Palestinians in 1949 and 1967 respectively. Until the modern Zionist movement in the early 20th century, Palestine was nothing but a sparsely populated Turkish and then British backwater. The Jews started moving back and literally started to make the desert bloom. They started farming, started commerce and industry, brought modern medicine ect. and arabs from all over started moving there for work as all the surrounding Arab areas were hopelessly near medieval, impoverished territories. The arabs resented the jews, taking every opportunity to steal or murder them. There was mostly in Jerusalem, a local educated Arab elite, but they had little to do with poorer Arab farmers and tradesmen. The mufti of Jerusalem was clearly a horrible,evil schemer who cared only for increasing his personal power and prestige and the destruction of theJews. The British mandate of Palestine was a fornicating abortion from day one. They placated the Palestinians and barely tolerated the Jews. The Jews suffered and ultimately persevered. What magnificent people! They have earned this American Christian's undying admiration and affection Sorry to just prattle on. ........John.

[@maestroaxeman]

Pretty much agreed. I look at it in a less eloquent mindset: The Europeans saw easy control of the backwater, superstitious, short-minded middle-east & did it without hesitation & shame. I think "the chosen" have already done their part & are "chosen" NO LONGER. You say you're an American Christian (I happen to be a follower of Jesus), so I will retell an instance said to have been spoken by Jesus: "A king desired to hold a great feast & invited everyone in his kingdom...but NOBODY from the king's country came. So, he told his servants to go as far out into the countryside as possible...to the highways & byways & bring any who would come. That became the feast of the king." Pretty much...the Jews blew it. Chosen at one time, but NO LONGER special. They will find the promise...but ONLY in the "end times" written about in revelation prophecy. Unique people, yes. Above others...NO MORE. Some would be foolish enough to call me "antisemite" (I AM NOT)...but I pay attention to scriptures. As for the rest of the arab nations...what a conglomeration of uneducated neanderthals...not to mention their archaic religion is FULL TO THE BRIM with contradiction, misinformation & superstitious fantasy of a barbaric nature. The European nations are setting the groundwork for the one-world-order that brings about the "order of the beast" & the antichrist. Time is short.

[@apachewraith]

The land was here 40 bazillion years before any of us. It doesn't belong to anyone.

[@apachewraith]

@@maestroaxeman This is actually correct. "Israel" is the Church. Open to any and all who are willing to be baptized in His name. The door is open, please come in and accept the gift of Grace.

[@laylaali5977]

Palestinians lived there millions of years

[@eastwaters4082]

What if I destroyed the history and texts of other nations and their beliefs, only to replace it with my own, without you ever knowing?

[@damienroberts5081]

Amazing video I’m a new subscriber and love the content!!

[@UNPACKED]

Thanks for subbing!

[@a7a416]

We kurds paid the altimate price because of this

[@Franciscoflores-si2dz]

how.the kurds paid?

[@higherresolution4490]

No joke! What happened to your historical land and it's enshrined culture? Oops! We forgot that one. We'll let the Turks and the Iraqis figure that one out. But let's take this piece of land and call it Kuwait! Then we'll take another piece of land and call it Bahrain. And then another piece of land and call it the United Arab Emirates. And then another piece of land and call it Qatar. And then another piece of land and call it the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia.

[@KnivingDispodia]

Long live the Rojavan Revolution.

[@mustsphamatto3601]

@@Franciscoflores-si2dz what u got offended by the truth by what the man stated huh

[@ereshkigalningalnanna8899]

@@Franciscoflores-si2dz Kurds were brought by Ottomans to help k!|| n displace Armenians Assyrians and Greeks, In Ottoman Empire the map called Middle East (Palestine Lebanon Iraq Syria) were actually the Land of Assyria , Officially Internationally known as Assyria and the citizens were called Assyrians, Under the Ottomans the Assyrian cities were turned into ولايات States (An Islamic States), The three states of Mosul Baghdad and Basrah were ruled by Arabs (Assyrian’s Gypsies) and the people of the country majority were Assyrians, After many Genocides done on Assyrians by the occupiers the population of the Assyrian people decreased, Am with kurds to have their own country but not on the Assyrian land, Let’s be honest in here, North of what is called Iraq today is Assyria, Assyrian lands , These people still exist, A huge amount of them were forced to convert to Islam and thousands of thousands were k!||ed and displaced from their homeland, Kurds originally comes from Persia they persian gypsies and it’s nothing wrong with it , have your country in Mahabad /Kurdistan Iran not on the Assyrian land and I will be the first to congratulate them, What these four musl!m groups have had done and still doing on the indigenous people is absolutely unfair, On media they angles in reality will defeat dev!l 9 for 0.

[@ryanunruh2683]

Thanks for the historical video. Loved the crazy comment section even more. Certainly the God of Israel is the ultimate colonizer, claiming dominion over every piece of matter (land) we've ever laid eyes on. I, personally,think Everyone is better off letting the Messiah of Christianity colonize their hearts and minds.

[@atidfelixcastillo-najerala6891]

I am from Latin American. Christians burned, tortured & destroyed entire nations, in the name of Christian love

[@accountforcommenting]

You didn't talk about how france and UK divide middle East and create syria and iraq and how Turk got current terroritory

[@AnonymousPerson-h5z]

syria litteraly kicked both the british and french out the sane way algeria kickd the french out

[@AnonymousPerson-h5z]

syria established themselves that is why mad europeans supported the terrorist groups andhid their money through saudi arabia qatar and abu dhabi

[@Chrstnrchrdsn]

I’ve always wondered why we were never taught anything about the Middle East during my 12 years of schooling. I believe it’s because our leaders didn’t really understand what was going on and certainly not our teachers. Our schooling, mostly concentrated on Europe, and our own country, which has led to woefully uneducated people concerning current events. Thus College students demonstrate without knowing the facts, it’s all emotionally banding together for camaraderie with ignorance.

[@deborahquinn483]

This is probably the best video I have seen explaining how these present day countries came to be. Thank you so much for explaining this in such an entertaining and fair way.

[@kimwhatmatters4085]

Why did the Jews have to go to Palestine why not somewhere near Serbia or something ??? There’s a lot of places with a lot of land why was it okay to misplace Palestinians?? They just hit lesser and lesser land why is that okay

[@theindian2226]

Insightful discourse

[@BrabyTheCool177]

I FOUND IT!!!! I seen this video a week ago but I accidentally refreshed the page and I couldn’t find it

[@lenr7068]

Learned something new. Thank you. So what about the Saud Family, who controlled them?

[@HarmonyandPeace6494]

One Word " Islam" True definition, submission. How Muhammed truly was.

[@Seven_1865]

@NasiSSGermanIslam is about as peaceful as the Nazis. The word Islam means surrender or submission. Salaam means peace.

[@amsellem]

Shouldn't you have made the différence between 1920 British Mandate on Palestine that was TransJordan ( Israël + Jordan) that was then clarified as distinction between jewish and arab state Israel in one hand and Jordan in another one... We could as, talk about the 1st real partition plan of Palestine between Jews ans Arabs.

[@nizzam1]

No it wasn’t I guess you forgot the Churchill white paper which formulated British policy in Palestine. “The white paper, formalized as a Palestine Order in Council in August,[33] reaffirmed the British commitment to a national home, promised that Palestine would not become a Jewish State and that Arabs would not be subordinated to Jews. Fieldhouse further says that the white paper "interpreted and subtly modified the harshness of the mandate." It pointed out that the Balfour Declaration did "not contemplate that Palestine as a whole should be converted into a Jewish national home, but that such a home should be founded in Palestine" and affirming the right to Jewish immigration but subject to the concept of "economic absorptive capacity".[34]”

[@Jay_in_Japan]

*difference *Israel ces ne pa la lang fransais

[@aaronfrizzel3821]

As a fellow human I enjoyed your content . Lots of facts very little feeling

[@margaretfarrell5137]

He forgot to mention the indigenous people of Palestine's right to self-determination.

[@naphataliheimann9281]

They have the right to self determination, they took that right and started 3 wars, countless terrorism campaigns and have terrorists for leaders. Makes you question there ideas on democracy

[@jamesr8584]

You forgot to mention Israel's right to exist.

[@margaretfarrell5137]

@@jamesr8584 The state of Israel does exist at the expense of the indigenous people of Palestine or not? Whether it is a right or not is a question for experts on international law to answer.

[@jamesr8584]

@@margaretfarrell5137 If Palestinians accept Israel as an independent state, then there is no reason the Palestinians can't have autonomy. There have been peace plans that Israel accepts, but the Palestinians keep walking away.

[@margaretfarrell5137]

@@jamesr8584 At the Oslo Accords Arafat, who went there without lawyers, recognised Israel as a state. In return Israel recognised Arafat as leader of the PLO! The two state solution has been rendered impossible due to the thousands of illegal settlements eating up tbe West Bank. Israeli members of the Government make no secret of the fact that they are not interested in a two state solution. The aim is a greater Israel. East Jerusalem was supposed to be the capital of a Palestinian state. Hence the continuing evictions of Palestinians from their homes to be occupied by illegal settlers. Trump did his bit by deciding to transfer its embassy there (under the influence of Jared Kushner) and Biden hasn't changed that. The Israeli Human Rights Group, B'tselem regular reports on human rights violations against Palestinians. In fact, I learned what was going on in Israel from jewish journalists and intellectuals like Gideon Levy, Noam Chomsky; Naomi Klein, Norman Finkelstein, Ilan Pappe., Max Blumenthal, Aaron Mate. Judaism is a religion; zionism is an ideology which many jews oppose.

[@matthewcoveney4380]

This is not exactly right. Oil was not extracted in any meaningful quantity until much later. Except perhaps in Iran which had little to do with the Sykes Picot agreement

[@SionTJobbins]

It's not an "obscure" or "random" or "inconsequantial" agreement - you're doing a disservice to your channel by making our S-P Agreement was nothing less than a historic agreement. But interesting video and interesting take on San Remo and ISIS.

[@TheBerkTuz]

The visual with Mr.Inoun on 5:05 is very likely to be from the hotel beau rivage in Ouchy, Switzerland, where treaty of Lausanne was signed. The rest is history.

[@rosinaldomorales3406]

Good video, however, you sound like you’re selling me an idea. Thanks for bring the information forward to examine!

[@timbernie]

That's some funny stuff. Winston Churchill made the Borders of the Near east and far East.... Egypt to India. 1920. Borders, races, rivers, and mountains did not matter. Churchill started it all.

[@عليياسر-ذ5ب]

No, this is Rothschild

[@NoahBodze]

Isn’t it telling that Churchill has been dead for over 60 years and they still can’t agree on borders? It’s almost as if the cOLiNiZeRS prevented more death than they’re blamed for.

[@عليياسر-ذ5ب]

@@NoahBodze Churchill, is it the population who drew the borders, or the English?

[@cbel888]

@@عليياسر-ذ5ب are you saying Rothschild financed Churchill? Wow...why is my writing switched like this I didn't typed it this way.

[@ticenits3426]

Looking at how horribly it’s run now the Brit’s shoulda just kept it.

[@cjones3093]

The entire Earth is the Holy Land. One region has zero claim to being Holy. That’s all made up.

[@rasheedjamal9091]

I being Muslim don't even get upset about who prays where or what they pray to. In the end none of this bull💩 even matters.

[@TheAkuaman]

Thank you so much for the explanation and clarity of it

[@tkoshannahan3215]

A mandate means "because I said so and circumvented legislative process".

[@apachewraith]

This was very informative!! I look forward to watching your work on the Lavon Affair and the USS Liberty!!

[@johndoe-cv8pr]

Don't forget about Israel's failed assassination attempt on the German chancellor Konrad Adenauer in 1952. Israel has still to answer for that crime.

[@ren2871]

@@gregwallace6159 The Palestinians danced and burned the US flags after 9/11. That was on video for everyone to see. The dancing Israelis is a made up conspiracy by the anti-Israel zealots.

[@UNPACKED]

You got it! kzbin.info/www/bejne/envClppjntKDg80

[@timbaland916]

The war in Iraq and Afghanistan can be traced back to the moment Gavrilo Princip assassinated Archduke Franz Ferdinand in 1914.

[@tomislavnagy8715]

This was a Realy Good Video. Keep making more Videos about Israel!

[@anonkarma2.027]

Nice one 👍🏻

[@jamiegrieve5875]

Hi Bro I just wanted to say thank you for your help and great information on all things Jewish... myself I'm not Jewish just a regular guy from Blackburn Lancashire England and a Christian... However I've been really interested in Jewish history and Israel as a nation of which I have huge respect and love for.... I've also noticed the current cool cause of the left in particular and the college campus is to support Palestine and hamas wave your flag and pretend you know everything about it whilst really knowing nothing.... so I wanted to know why.....i first found out that because the media tells lies... but anyway yes been enjoying your channel... peace Jamie 🙏

[@RedLogicYT]

Weird how you didn't bother discussing the Allies' promises to Italy for Turkey's Southern Coasts and the promises to Saudi Arabia. Also that agreement was leaked by Trotsky & the Soviet Union during the war. Saudi Arabia was MAD.

[@JovanieRuizPerez]

Pointless after the 2:00 mark, now if they just knew that they’re in Africa, they’d both should behave as visitors in someone else’s home, instead taking over ungraciously, like Heathens!

[@HELLH0WND]

Strange- I never heard the word Rothschild once when it came to Palestine.

[@charlesdayon8420]

Virgin Mary appeared in Necedah, Wisconsin, USA in 1950 to 1975 and she said many things over the 25 years about the Rothschilds London Banking House. Or if you will Redshield , or Amschel Meyer family. A so called conspiracy to destroy Christianity and establish a One World Government and One World Religion. Virgin Mary said in Necedah, Wisconsin that the Rothschilds conspired to kill 10 European Kings and I think 5 or 6 Czars. Virgin Mary said the Rothschilds smuggled Lenin into Russia to overthrow the Czar and establish Communism in Russia, and of course destroy the Russian Orthodox church. Virgin Mary said John Wilkes Booth was acting on behalf of the Rothschilds when he murdered Abraham Lincoln. Abraham Lincoln was using his good offices to unite the Russian Orthodox church to the Roman Catholic church. The Rothschilds did not want this because it would strengthen Christianity. Virgin Mary said Freemasonry was started by the Rothschilds. She said the people who murdered and tortured the Czar and his family and servants were all non Russian so-called Jews. Virgin Mary also said that Adolf Hitler was murdered in 1939 , by his top henchmen because he wouldn't bomb the Vatican. So if this was true then, it was possibly Goering who probably murdered a good portion of the Jewish people and decided to invade Russia. Sorry! The Necedah Shrine. Org. Has 2 books that detail the so called messages, not approved by the Catholic church of course ! Revelations and Messages 2 volumes 4.50 each.

[@josephnommensen4025]

You are attributing want for oil to before it was valuble. It was not heavily mined in the middle east until after 1945. Was there another "reasorce" that you never mentioned?

[@eastwaters4082]

*How does a group of nations not from specific region, culture, or it’s customs determine who gets to live in that region?*

[@bluebomber-]

Ask the The Royal Empire....and of course,the Rothschilds

[@PeruBolivia2004]

Its called history on repeat

[@BenDover-wb6si]

​@@PeruBolivia2004it's not on repeat😂 no es que se repita, es que los elite siguen haciendo las mismas huevadas

[@jgalt5002]

Money talks

[@Arlecchinofan97]

Might makes right, that’s why empires formed. The weak and the losers get pushed around, it still happens today like with how the Kurds are often treated.

[@tete4350]

Thank you for this video! I did not know abt this.

[@UNPACKED]

Glad it was helpful!

[@curtisthomas2670]

What actually contributed much more to the formation of lS-lS was the illegal invasion and military occupation of lraq, with the total disbandment of its military and security forces and sending hundreds of thousands into unemployment and anger, the devastation of lraq economy, infrastructure, utilities and society, leading to bitter hatred for the occupying forces and it's allies..... as well as the gathering together (suspiciously conveniently) of the leadership of Al Qaeda together with 25,000 bitter detainees - many of whom became the leadership and core cadre of what would morph into lSIL/lSlS - in one facility, Camp Bucca, where most of the experienced and best trained former lraqi military ended up, where a terror;st training school was ran under the eyes of US military, where lS/lSlL/lSlS was actual created

[@itamarka1]

The San Remo accords were based on the Sykes Picco agreement maps and confirmed the divsion of area of influence between both countries as mandates. This division did not take in consideration the various Arab tribes that live in region. Is resulted in the Kurd's been divided between Syria, Turkey, Iraq, and Iran (Persia). The British tried placing foreign rulers (The Hashemite family from Saudi Arabia) on people that did not know them or want them (Syria and Iraq), this led to creation of Trans-Jordan with King Abdullah I as its ruler. The British tried delaying the formation of the State of Israel.

[@nigeldeforrest-pearce8084]

Excellent and Outstanding Analysis!!!

[@Brickbybrickmentality]

No offense cause I’m technically Jewish though I don’t recognize my self as any made up group of people buuut like you stated!…my question is where did the Jewish people live before WWI????

[@eastwaters4082]

They won’t answer that one. They lived in Europe as they always have.

[@daglobe]

thank you Noam this clarifies so much!

[@whatif4502]

Great video Noam. Now do the Greater Middle East project please.

[@auslander1026]

it is fascinating that Romans took the Land and another Romans gave it back 2500 years after...

[@beautyzline5194]

Englishs are not romans.

[@mazinal-siyabi2719]

Free Palestine 🇵🇸 from the occupation

[@davidkuder4356]

Just found your channel. Great stuff--including the visuals & film clips. Will look for more episodes!

[@nneely613]

Yeah a caliphate sounds a lot like the Greater Israel project. Have you covered that? I wonder.

[@dogman-fx9ub]

Alt right bullshit

[@nneely613]

@@dogman-fx9ub thank you for revealing what you don't know. More informed and less emotional will help you in the long run.

[@dogman-fx9ub]

@@nneely613 Dude you're citing a conspiracy found on racist messags boards and from far right commentors. Get off your high horse.

[@dogman-fx9ub]

@@nneely613 I get it you have bad critical thinking skills and developed some kind of unhealthy resentment against Jews.

[@barncaleboy]

The production quality you guys have doesn't really match the amount of views you get per video, are you not at a loss on each video??

[@tentwoXII]

i believe they are subsidised by someone idk if it’s a nonprofit or like israeli ministry of tourism or something but they are fs subsidised.

[@Coohy]

Propoganda is always well presented

[@banjonotkaz00ie64]

this channel is literally hasbara pullshit no different than gobbles so desperate for views they pay for ads so ppl have to see it

[@deborahfreedman333]

@@Coohy That explains al jezera.

[@saardfetner8620]

The Jesuits have all the answers.

[@drknockers5716]

Great video

[@TWOofEACH]

This is false information.

[@danielcraft3727]

Lawrence of Arabia pretty much forgotten.

[@raz1616]

Good video, many people seem to think Sykes Picot was what created the border between Iraq and Syria but as you go over this is just wrong. But anyways, I find the whole narrative that Middle Eastern states are "artificial" to be a very bad argument. The borders already had some historical precedent for one, and it would have been impossible to divide the region into uni-ethnic states without widespread ethnic cleansing. Issues with sectarianism had completely different causes than borderd alone, and a solution to it is nationalism rather than balkanizing the region. All borders are arbitrary, and Iraq is no less arbitrary a state as Britain. Borders were far from the most pernicious aspect of Western colonialism in the Middle East. Ironically, the British actually tried to justify its rule in Iraq by calling it a "fake nation".

[@عليياسر-ذ5ب]

Why lie in history

[@NoahBodze]

An ocean around an island isn’t arbitrary. Please join us in the real world, ok?

[@InésVillalvaGándara]

Differentiating between Arabs and Jews as distinct and opposing groups creates a misleading narrative that overlooks the existence of Jewish Arabs, who are both ethnically Arab and religiously Jewish. In Avi Shlaim's book, Three Worlds: Memoirs of an Arab-Jew, he highlights this nuanced identity, challenging the simplistic dichotomy that portrays Arabs and Jews as inherently conflicting. This oversimplification obscures the shared cultural and historical connections between the two groups, reinforcing unnecessary and extremely toxic divisions. If anyone wants a more nuanced perspective on this topic, I can really recommend that book!

[@deerman420]

Unpacked is my favorite KZbin channel! I LOVE Every video. Learning about every topic is trememdous

[@Kevinjohnson34567]

Ancient history makes my head hurt. Can you make another video about how our Saipan ancestors oppressed the Neanderthals?

[@ariifik9357]

The end got me! So it's all about supporting Israel😆😆

[@عليياسر-ذ5ب]

Rothschild is rich my friend

[@amandahayat1893]

unsubscribed just now for presenting distorted and misleading events of history for a few likes

[@UNPACKED]

What did you find distorted or misleading? (We definitely don't make videos for likes, if we did - do you think we would have chosen the topics we discuss on the channel of all things?)

[@amandahayat1893]

@@UNPACKED sykes picot aggreement had a lot of consequences but to say it prodcued isis is far fetched and ludicrous.

[@AdamAdamHDL]

@@amandahayat1893 I agree. To say it created Isis is beyond a stretch.

[@apachewraith]

@@amandahayat1893 If anything the US under Obama created ISIS to overthrow Assad, an ally, in Syria to seize control of Russian oil.

[@gdesilva77]

Next video... Israel the peacekeepers of the middle east...LOL

[@johndoe-cv8pr]

Could you also explain why Israel assisted isis by giving them fuel and military supplies while they were terrorizing Syria? The world would really like to know Israel's excuses for aiding one of the most abominable terror organizations in recent history.

[@johngalush8790]

And why did Israel organize the 911 attacks? Please explain it to us. Please.

[@deborahfreedman333]

They didn't. They did give medical aid to any wounded, mostly women and children, no questions asked.

[@cherylcooper1885]

I see why it’s important to have a Palestinian place - it’s so the World can come in to invade Israel. Not good to mess and dividing Israel, it comes with consequences!

[@عليياسر-ذ5ب]

The Pharaohs are the ones who, for God's sake, have prostrated themselves to the Pharaohs and killed them again

[@sharkquisha3407]

Or maybe its because they are european invaders that shouldnt be taking over Palestine.

[@عليياسر-ذ5ب]

@@sharkquisha3407 Is it because modern Jews are more like Europeans than the Semites of the Middle East?

[@danielapazamat3529]

Thank you for amazing video I love history

[@westwild75]

👀 I ...Israeli S ..secret I ...intelligence S ..service 😁

[@MariselEnovegas]

Sobrang ganda ng pagkakagawa ng qoutes totoong po talaga

[@rileycooper7664]

Free Palestine

[@deborahfreedman333]

Free all of Israel, both banks of the Jordan, from ar ab occupation.

[@hockeyislife2]

No

[@Rudster14]

To be fair a limited mandate makes sense because many of these peoples were aligned with specific tribes or small kingdoms and not modern day nation states. To this day many Arabs are still loyal to their tribes. Saying to them okay you are independent now figure it out would have been a terrible idea. By having a mandate for a limited period of time it allowed those disparate tribes to unite into a single people and gave them a set of prexisting laws to work with.

[@JamaluddinAlMuqdishaawi]

Might you be a banker.

[@internetstrangerstrangerofweb]

This absolutely did not lead to ISIS. The invasion of Iraq and failiure to rebuild the country did.

[@roniberahaquartet477]

You forgot borders ,common long lines in desert

[@mousemd]

What I think is sad is that after WWII some Jews tried to return to Israel. Britain's Navy fired on them. That's one reason so many wound up in USA

[@عليياسر-ذ5ب]

Britain what a lie

[@lanxy2398]

I feel like european meddling is underrated when it comes to the middle east. Africa we all know was shafted by Europe but the Middle East got eternally thrown into conflict

[@earlycuyler9760]

I feel like zionist pigs would be more accurate and truthful. Europeans don't care about those deserts.

[@robertpatterson9943]

I feel like Jew meddling is underrated when it comes to wars

[@arimoff]

I feel like arab colonization and conquest of the Middle East is extremely underrated and ignored. The historical fact of middle east not being endigenous to arabs who claim everything is theirs. Arabs can go fq themselves. No one owes them anything

[@bluebomber-]

Yeah the queen and the rothchilds got Isreal....and now they want to make it the throne of the antichrist

[@Kjai537]

It’s not Israel. It’s Palestine.

[@batmanrobin6848]

Romans renamed it Palestine while they were kicking out the Jews, we just got the Jewish empire rolling again.

[@scouter6926]

The USSR had a huge impact on how the Arabs saw and reacted to Western imperialism.

[@elcanalderebeca]

Saludos hola chicos bellos hermosos maravillosos

[@clatonbigsby662]

Tim Kennedy actually talked about the Nazi influence over the terrorist groups in the Middle East