The Strange Case of Nancy Pfister

Nancy Pfister was a well known socialite in Aspen. When she got into arguments with a couple renting her house, she returned from vacation early. A few days later, she was found tied up in her closet. But who could be responsible for this? An unlikely suspect would confess, but was he taking the wrap?
Patreon► / thatchapter
Twitter► / that_chapter
Instagram► / that_chapter
Merch►teespring.com/stores/that-cha...
Sources►pastebin.com/axTFSXeF
Music►
• Music from That Chapter

[@jeannetterw]

We need a shirt that reads "Let's give it a goo" but the o's are Mike's glasses. Available in maroon, navy, and blue plaid.

[@UrrmmWut...]

Aside from the color choices not including black I completely agree tho I get what u were goin for lol

[@WonderWhatHappened]

Definitely should do.... I bought one of his t-shirts a few months ago.. I really could use another...

[@andrewcrenshaw2459]

and on the back, at the bottom- (I did it)

[@fungussf]

I'll take tree of them.

[@Simplyblissfull]

Sounds great. Let’s give it a goo!

[@bunberrier]

Hey at the end when Mike said "I love ya!" he was talking to ME, so I don't want any of you other people to get any weird ideas.

[@lizgirlliz]

🤣🤣🥰🥰

[@DontBanNida]

Those are fighting words

[@agirly1503]

Lol

[@Jonni1027]

But he winked at ME

[@Rotter-u8c]

Ha

[@TahtahmesDiary]

"My mom could never hurt anyone." It sounds like she hurt everyone around her tbh.

[@thomasschroeder480]

Like Mum, like me.

[@ms.krueger2660]

Sounds like she hurt everyone. She was verbally abusive. Sometimes that hurts worse than being punched. 😢🤔. I was married for a year to a man that was verbally abusive. I felt so small. Useless. He had me believing I was used goods and no other man would ever want me. Words cut deep!! 😢

[@SNP-1999]

God I hate these condescending bastards who think they are better than 99.9% of humanity, just because their grandaddy lived in a wood hut on worthless land that - Oh lucky me ! - became part of a boom town and struck it rich. Hobnobbing with the rich and famous ("My Daddy sat on Bing Crosby's knee when he sang 'White Christmas'"), they treat all the rest as lackies and slaves ("Fetch the Champagne, mon cher....mais rapide, vite vite !"). Ugh !

[@ninnywaggon3470]

“she’d never hurt anyone” *extorts her elderly tenants*

[@Mistshock]

lmfao when the news called her a "philantropist", more like a parasite.

[@mola55e5]

I love when interrogators say, “the quicker you admit this, the better it will be..” Yeah, for the COP. Sure, if the guy admits it, then the cop has less actual work to do. NEVER speak to the cops without a lawyer present.

[@Rottweilerz]

Well... If you murdered someone then you should probably just admit to being a murderous piece of shite.

[@jerichohill487]

Amen

[@Prince-jb7pv]

I've spoken to cops without a lawyer present and have never received any charges in my life. Your narrative only works with people who have something to hide for the most part.

[@nymel2008]

@@Prince-jb7pv lol yeah ok. Live in fairytale make believe land do you?

[@Prince-jb7pv]

@@nymel2008 No i live in real life, i'm assuming by your username you have barely experienced a decade of life so i understand your ignorance

[@wanderinghistorian]

"Everyone in Aspen hated her because she was bossy and condescending." Also: "I can't think of anyone who would want to hurt her."

[@Tracymmo]

It's a nice change from the usual "everybody loved her! she had a smile that could light up a room!"

[@sam7259]

@@Tracymmo ah yes, the lame and sensationalized crime watch daily. You can tell alot of their viewers/commenters aren't too bright either.

[@kaseycavazos9775]

Thought the same thing lmaoo

[@JK-gm6kk]

The parent/kid relationship is often delusional af, each member choosing to be oblivious to red flags or lack of moral fiber.

[@lynnpurcell5225]

@Jason I know, right? It really doesn't make sense.

[@aurtisanminer2827]

Can you imagine landing on hard times and having to move into a measly $4k a month rental?

[@bettywith2girls]

LOL!!!

[@TK2692]

This shows the mentality these kind of people have. "I'm so poor, I only have a several million in the bank."

[@PlsWaLuigiDomMe]

@@TK2692 because they’re rich. They probably were very poor but they didn’t want to give up the lifestyle. It’s really sad. A lot of rich people sink the moment their met with financial difficulties because of this; their pride not allow them to downsize. What’s crazy is that Nancy house doesn’t even look like 4K a month. If anything it maybe looks like 1.2k where I live

[@zipzip8239]

and in the slums of aspen...shudder

[@aurtisanminer2827]

@@PlsWaLuigiDomMe yea, it’d be around that most of the time here in alaska. Location can be pretty crucial!

[@moongod5013]

I don't know if the Stylers did it, but I definitely think Trey is taking the fall for it and they were being set up. Either to protect his wife or Kathy. A very weird case. Thank you, Mike. Take care of yourself, love ya.

[@dididothat2245]

You can’t know how

[@PoptartParasol]

You should listen to the wife's interview. She straight up said she wishes she did it herself, but unfortunately not. She really oozes honesty, and that's a bit how I would speak if I didn't do something but kinda wish I did. He wasn't really frail enough to not be able to do what he did though, you should definitely look more into it it's very interesting.

[@joshlewis575]

Cathy definitely had something to do with it, that interrogation vid she was faking that sadness so hard.

[@kimmyfreak200]

yah i think it was one or both of the women or he is covering for his wife... the hammer and key thing is beyond strange though

[@BiancaVie]

I think it’s so Kathy can get the life insurance and split it with them. But the daughter wasn’t having it

[@yagesh287]

Conclusion: Old man knew he was dying and saved his wife who divorced him later and married another man, while the old man killed himself in the prison.

[@austins.2495]

That's why you don't sacrifice yourself for a woman, or even help them at all. They are "independent and want equality" after all...

[@Swagaito_Gai]

@@austins.2495 Found the incel!

[@-._.-KRiS-._.-]

@@austins.2495 Men never get help with anything? Anything at all?

[@LeonardoDaVinciLulz]

Conclusion: A woman was murdered, and the self confessed murderer, killed himself.

[@LeonardoDaVinciLulz]

@@austins.2495 Same can be applied to a man Austin. Think before you type 😅

[@jonasking9587]

I live in Denver. If I was doing bad financially, the LAST thing I'd think was "I better move to Aspen!"

[@clpr2023]

😂😂😂 right???!!! It’s madness

[@steverogers2603]

Or rent a house at 4 grand a month

[@scroogemcduckrich9705]

this made me 🤣🤣😂

[@timbreljedi]

Exactly! Try Breckenridge, it's cheaper?

[@katherinegriswold2471]

Yeah, i am from Gunnison. If i where broke and trying to get on my feet, going to Aspen would be the last place to go. (And dude it's Basalt, not Basil. That was for the narrator)

[@kaykepop4084]

How "dire" could your situation be if you can afford $4,000 a month for rent😑. It seems more like they did not want to down grade their lifestyle and live more efficiently.

[@Spthomas47]

I'm fine enough living within my meager means. I'll also take my neighbors over theirs any day. ✌🏽🤘🏼

[@luciferlampmuffin2879]

I know man! And theres me bitching about my £800 a month rent!

[@tophers3756]

I saw a Dateline episode about this. Apparently they used all their funds to move and start their business.

[@jeffmead4670]

4K a month is basically free in Aspen, everyone is broke on different levels.

[@Sao_Cheech_79]

@@jeffmead4670 For sure! ✌️

[@EB1493]

I remember seeing an American Greed episode on this and from the sound of it, Pfister herself had a horrible reputation around town despite her charisma and philanthropy. It really baffles me how the people that know an individual who is known to be of poor character and/or horrible reputation can memorialize them as a saint when they’ve passed when knowing that was not who they were when they were alive. Still sad that Nancy was killed but given the factors and circumstances that lead up to that point, her death could have been avoided.

[@El_Ophelia]

Kind of like George Floyd. Tragic and unlawful death, but a drug addict and career criminal has been made into a saint and memorialized.

[@blossomentrails3398]

​@El_Ophelia The law isn't morality, being a drug addict doesn't mean you deserve to die

[@-._.-KRiS-._.-]

"Aspen was famous for those trees." Those three WHAT, Mike?! Those three what??!

[@dortesandal4303]

😂😂😂

[@M4CH1N3_M4N_]

kinda funny that before he confessed the police were telling Trey he did it and he wasn't as weak as he said but once he confessed they were like nah, you're too weak for that

[@LeeDee5]

There's no way that old guy flipped the mattress by himself. Some mattresses are heavy as shit.

[@mylesepps4950]

leila no it’s crazy how you people don’t realize the police just look for a person to blame. Each arrest, each prisoner, each fine is money it’s all money to them

[@mylesepps4950]

It’s because the police don’t look for the truth they look to paint what picture they feel would be best for them or easiest for them

[@gaaraxnaru]

@@mylesepps4950 Normally, I would agree with you, but in this case I think they were right on the money. There is no way he did this alone. He was way too old and frail. I don't think Kathy was involved, or else they would've turned on her when she "turned on them", but his wife definitely was. If it was just him, why wait so long to confess? No. They were trying to hold out, maybe use Kathy as a scapegoat, but when things were looking better for Kathy, they decided (or he decided) that they really weren't getting out of this, so better the one with much less to lose takes the wrap for it all. It all fits. Nancy got away with murder. And that's the truth.

[@dascorncakes1151]

@@mylesepps4950 I need to correct you here because this is damaging information. Police do not benefit from arrests, fines or anything like that. They are payed a standard wage /w benefits like most other decent jobs. The money from fines is collected by the government, and when people are arrested they may preform prison labour in private prisons which go directly to the private owner, which usually they use to pay the wages and what not. In both of these cases the money is taxed, in the case of fines I believe it all goes directly to the government, which a small portion does go to the police, bust most of it goes to other sectors. In the case of prison labour it goes again either directly to the government or the owner of the prison.

[@bri_guy508]

The fact that the victim's daughter is like "my mom would never hurt a fly" made me cringe so bad. What type of person are you when your BEST FRIEND says she was talked down to and treated like a slave? Def no angel...

[@A_YouTube_Commenter]

Definitely not. She was a bee. Got killed because of it. It happens.

[@lindasue8719]

Sadly, this may well be a case of the acorn doesn't fall far from the tree.

[@whitedragoness23]

Her mother was no saint, I get the feeling her self entitled attitude caused her death. I doubt the guy would be able to take on Nancy by himself. His wife seems questionable writing a book, cashing in on her ex husband...I think she killed Nancy and her husband took the fall

[@bakerzane3055]

Tbh I would never agree with murder, but I also wouldn’t say she didn’t deserve it.

[@JohnJohnson-hu3um]

look at the daughter again, she's obviously an opiate addict. I bet her mom messed her up real good.

[@Floridaman1780_]

Daughter doesnt seem too heartbroken. Nice 'lil inheritance, I'm sure.

[@coldbringer9545]

As the granddaughter of Art Pfister, she is surely an heir to the empire. Being an unplanned child, she may have had more of a business type relationship with her mother. The number of lawyers waiting to represent her in a wrongful death suit probably rivaled the lines at the ski lifts.

[@Matilda-y]

Chip off the old block, and the rich get richer.

[@isuckatlife27]

the Dumb & Dumber references are a perfect example of why I love this channel

[@sylvia106]

What about Salmon of Capistrano comment?

[@isuckatlife27]

@@sylvia106 yea from Dumb & Dumber 😂

[@dr.loomis4221]

simp

[@mariapalladino2473]

His wife’s phone also pinged at Nancy’s house and he claimed he accidentally grabbed her phone.....we all know she was there and helped.

[@annereidy7981]

Yes, pretty hard to believe that he could have done all that on his own, in his condition.

[@Peoples_Architect]

Yeah, I guess I saw that on True Crime Daily.

[@ivanasukjadic1423]

No, we don't all "know" that she was there. It can't be proven. It is speculation. How would you feel if you got charged with murder because someone took you phone with them to go commit a crime?

[@miaouew]

Don't forget about that Turd Person they found (probably in the sewer system) to help them.

[@justiceforall3889]

No we don't know she was there. The problem with assumptions is that you're assuming based on what you are hearing and not on facts and evidence. Too many people do that and it ends in wrongful convictions and sometimes wrongful deaths. Too many cases are tried in the court of public opinion and by the time the case goes to trial the defendants have only a slim chance of getting a fair trial because the media love to put a sensational spin on these types of stories and that's what the jurors judge them by instead of on facts and evidence. BTW: Men, especially frail looking elderly men, are often a lot stronger than they seem.

[@NBDYSPCL]

She rented out a broken house for 4 grand month and has the nerve to call the tenants con artists?

[@TonyGearSolid]

Given their lawsuit history and the fact that they had no business renting a 4k a month house given their financial situation, I wouldn't doubt that they were trying to pull a fast one on her. I mean they were living there for months and even with her briefly, then suddenly everything is broken and the house is falling apart the moment she leaves the country.

[@expressivepets1]

Location. Location. Location.

[@christian_traxler]

@@expressivepets1 Haha! Right! Even our ancestors choose their caves very well. But maybe they thought they could give their business a good starting push by renting a private house from a socialite even it was bombing their budget at first.

[@ssmith968]

Almost like my landlord 😆😭

[@kimmyfreak200]

exactly..the home isn't exactly a million dollar home.. it was average! and broken down! 4 grand????????????????? was she serious??????????????

[@haji818721]

Those detectives need to take remedial classes in interrogation. That was pathetic.

[@ruthlody7300]

That female detective was an outright B and rude as he🏒🏒.

[@pabbischannel8812]

I met Nancy Pfister once several years ago when i lived near Aspen and my experience was that she deserved her terrible reputation. So often in murder cases the victim was a sweet high school girl or woman just walking home from work and it really makes you mad, but in this case, is was a spoiled rich-bltch who finally pushed the wrong people and ate some Karma in the form of a hammer. No tears shed for her as this was avoidable by simply acting like a decent person.

[@Exxtol1]

Dang she sounds horrible!!

[@alrightyru]

That still doesn't make murder okay .... You know that, right?

[@barrettorth8413]

​@@alrightyru I don't think the OP was saying that the murder was justified; rather, that the victim isn't deserving of sympathy by virtue of being such an awful human being to begin with. It sounds like she kind of brought it on herself.

[@TallulahFoxxx]

@@alrightyru of course not 🙄 murder isn’t ok but equally, not every “victim” deserves any sympathy or to be remembered as an innocent angel 🙄🤷‍♀️ It’s not ok to murder someone but when you act like Nancy did, you can’t be shocked when you eventually piss off the wrong person. She didn’t deserve to die but she also doesn’t deserve a re-writing of history to make out that she didn’t create the conditions for what happened.

[@willissudweeks1050]

If you dislike someone you just leave them alone and ignore them you never have the right to kill them.

[@joanbaczek2575]

They were paying 4000 until she refused to do essential repairs I’m not paying 4000 for a place with no heat either

[@MartineH1]

yes. it is why it is important to know what you are going in, signing a contract. The lady came from a rich family that knew how to make business and money. She learned well.

[@BikingVikingHH]

There are actually things like water, heat, a leaking roof, that is if not fixed immediately, the tenant can withhold rent from the homeowner, and is actually entitled to spend the rent money on repairs themselves

[@tryingtobebetter7235]

@@MartineH1 She learned well from the hammer.

[@mildredpierce4506]

Nancy didn't deserve to be murdered but she ticked off the wrong people with her "I'm rich and my poop don't stink" attitude.

[@mildredpierce4506]

𝕮𝖚𝖈𝕶 𝕮𝖗𝖚𝖘𝖍𝖊𝖗 , tenant/landlord rights are not the same in every city or states. You can still be a slumlord in some places because landlords have the upper hand.

[@breelauren3748]

I literally choked at “he looks like he has one foot in the grave.”

[@quickchris10]

Their greed ruined them. I am sure they made a very comfy life as a head of anesthesiology and nursing, but he had to go and sue for someone not sharing credit for some software he had input on. Let it go! When you're working for someone (Anesthesiology Consultants,) your work is generally theirs, anyway. So he loses the suit, but got gouged by a lawyer for $600,000 (karma?) So then he goes and gets involved w/Nancy Pfister. Wow. Love of money is the root of all evil.

[@vitologroupielts7044]

Me too 😂😂

[@cococrooks2638]

Mike gave no fucks and I'm so living for it 😂😂😂💀

[@MarianaNv]

I chocked on my quesadilla lol

[@andrewjhollins]

"Pfister? I hardly even know her!" Lmfao... you wouldn't believe how long I've been waiting for that.

[@JGreen1]

I understand now one of the reasons why rich people aren't normally friends with people who aren't.

[@skateywatey]

"you absolutely bombed the polygraph" lmao idk why that cracked me up how he said that

[@bettywith2girls]

That was interesting...did she really "bomb" or fail the polygraph test? But then again, you usually never voluntarily take a polygraph test unless you thought you were innocent and could pass it (innocent). But she failed it (guilty).

[@MolokoDolamo]

Same!!! 😂

[@CandyBookGirlz]

@@bettywith2girls Polygraph are literally the worst and aren’t reliable to prove innocence or guilty. Not to say she didn’t have involvement, polygraphs are just useless.

[@17thknight]

@@CandyBookGirlz Yup, they're pure bullshit. You may as well ask tea leaves and look for a groundhog's shadow to determine guilt

[@scavenger6576]

@blake bishop I don't get it, why do they use it then? I know they can't use it as evidence but if they don't even work why bother?

[@Adrian-zd4cs]

I always chuckle over this story because Nancy was such a kind, caring, "philanthropist" 😏🤣🤣

[@GardenGuy1943]

Yeah, it’s weird how Nancy Pfister’s daughter is the one being charged for murder now. She must’ve really hated Nacy

[@SuperNuclearUnicorn]

Can't say I've watched too many episodes of true crime shows that say "those around them said the victim was a miserable bitch and that the world is better with them dead", it's always how they lit up a room with their smile

[@Adrian-zd4cs]

@Callum Lambkin yeah that's where my sarcasm was leading 😏🤣 I was originally intrigued by this case and read up on it quite a bit and she was a pretty nasty (evil) woman but nowadays if you state the truth people say you're victim shaming, etc 😒🤣

[@crossthreadaeroindustries8554]

Yeah, the press.

[@Scorch428]

She was basically Mary Swanson from Dumb and Dumber :P

[@davidcrossfield6943]

Old Trey is the definition of a Stand Up Guy(you know, without being able to stand). I bet the 2 ladies killed her, but he was like, "I'm dying anyway."

[@kimmyfreak200]

yah i think he is covering for one or both of them... it takes a lot of strength to move a dead body this guy doesn't look like he can even lift 50 pounds

[@alicecuriosityoftenleadsto6288]

exactly. Im guessing the wife and he didnt want the other lady to pay for something she didnt do, and out of love for his wife. If he hadnt they all 3 probably would have gotten convicted.

[@Secret_Soul_Survivor]

Yeah, he was being a gentleman, as you say a 'Stand Up Guy,' deciding to take the rap since he was dying.

[@Feral_Waifu]

I was thinking more of a simp

[@dannybob]

@@Feral_Waifu you win. there's nothing praiseworthy about covering for a murderous woman

[@teegee2374]

pretty sure those 2 women killed her & the old man knowing he's dying took the wrap to keep them out of prison... the so called "friend" of the victim is one of the worst liars & actors on the planet... love ya Mike!

[@davidschnare9945]

I had the same conclusion

[@somethingelse4424]

The people who are supposed to take care of my house and pay me 4000$ per month aren't doing their job, and now I have to leave my extended vacation early. Damn Nancy, you're making it difficult to feel as terrible as I should for you.

[@NinJestre]

Yes this, never worked a job where I had to pay my employer

[@MartineH1]

you don´t need to feel terrible for her in what concern her businesses. But because she was killed by the very people that couldn't do their (agreed) part in the business.

[@emmabbyreborns341]

Your kind of humor is the reason why we're all here, and absolutely love this channel. True that x 10!!

[@bebe553]

She should have stayed down under, better yet she should had let her house stay empty while she was on vacation, it was not like she needed money 🤔

[@kalinnavyacheslavovna2760]

@@bebe553 technically she is still down under....the accommodations are much smaller though

[@GarySuley]

“Pfister...well gotta buy her dinner first.”- Mike 😂

[@tonymattsson7385]

Hilarious, but not many people got that :)

[@KashXan]

Savage I love it 😭😂

[@sourgummyworms8069]

Took me a moment but I got it 😂

[@Christine_G129]

I was wondering how many caught that! He’s so hilarious!

[@MarijnvdSterre]

I must say, from the first time he said that name, my mind went there and stayed to walk around and see the sights.

[@andreaquidd7645]

Damn you mike . I spit out my coffee when you mentioned the "hey at least buy me dinner first " omg

[@RayBetterThanEvilCanival]

One of the few That Chapter videos where I don’t feel sorry for the victim

[@balletwb94]

“She looks like a kindly old lady- and he looks like he’s got one foot in the grave.” 💀💀💀😂

[@chanted1558]

One foot in the grave......but it wasnt his own👀

[@nargesalove228]

🤣

[@allencollins9951]

lmao

[@irisenamorado]

Jajajaja jajaja 😂😂😂

[@GardenGuy1943]

Yeah I thought that was mean

[@jaybeam1466]

Can we talk about how that man threw away his life to protect his wife and then how she subsequently divorced him and wrote a book pinning all of the blame on him? I know they're both guilty, but I would have much rather seen his wife go to prison.

[@jaspermeade1419]

Agreed...think maybe that was the plan from the start? He knew he was close to the end. Love will make ya do some crazy things...just something to think about.

[@nicolenotizieeamici]

Totally

[@fit_spoonie6760]

I was thinking the same thing. I mean I think it's pretty ballsy to divorce the man that is covering for you. If I was him I'd be like Man I was just lying to save her ass. This is really what happened.

[@comonena]

@@fit_spoonie6760 thats why he killed himself

[@archaichermit3566]

Also how she was happy to take that million $ life insurance policy after she divorced him and let him take the fall. I’m glad a lawsuit kept her from obtaining that $$$. Seems obvious to me he really loved her, but she didn’t reciprocate that. F’ing sad 😔

[@dustin628]

That woman interrogator at the end was awful! She was so full of emotion and hate she couldn't even see he was lying straight to her face 🙄

[@Floridaman1780_]

"Gotta buy 'er dinner first, amirite?" F***ing hilarious!!!!

[@drewmadenew3000]

Heeeey, my favorite Irishman is going to tell me a depressing story!

[@ThatChapter]

Enjoy the good and bad!

[@assbat1205]

He's quite majestic at it

[@e4unow421]

So he is Irish! :O

[@luanaalves2021]

So true 😂😂

[@bigredswife4646]

@@ThatChapter Mike I'm your 15th sub and absolutely love you and your stories...

[@samyolevich8897]

“Gotta buy her dinner first, am I right?”😂😂

[@KMTSports21]

Funniest thing mike has ever said. Today.

[@deez2569]

BEST.JOKE. EVER. 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏

[@notbonsai671]

Caught me off guard, great stuff

[@jenniferholden9397]

Perfection. Laughed my head off.

[@tanzanitebutterflyart9636]

I was already giggling like a school girl at the name then he threw that in 🤣🤣🤣

[@Boodoo4You]

I’m just happy that Mike finally gets to use his amazing French. Good on ya Mike! I’m sure it was amazing!

[@KyaniMosaic_Crone]

I used to live in Denver & Golden Colorado, I moved away a few years before her murder. I was nowhere near as wealthy as Nancy & they say you shouldn't speak ill of the dead. However, I've long been a believer in death does not improve one's disposition & reputation lives forever. There were definitely 2 sides to Nancy. The side rich people saw & the side those she viewed as beneath her saw. Allegedly I moved away from Denver before she was murdered but even having never worked for her myself I'd heard enough about her that I wasn't surprised when it happened.

[@MyCovertNarcissism]

1:32 Nancy "Pfister'. "Hey buy her dinner first, am I right?" LMAO Mike that was funny.

[@homieharsole9970]

Hahahaha I totally missed that.

[@TheKingOfTrolls]

Lol

[@TalairanPerigord]

Definitely the high point of the video. Well, one of them.

[@ggggggggggsf]

Pfister? I barely know 'er!

[@MyCovertNarcissism]

@@ggggggggggsf Hahahhahha

[@ingabiretetalilian5141]

That chapter is the only consistent thing in my life

[@ktcooki276]

Aww...😚

[@sentance578]

He’s not a narcissist like our real boyfriend is

[@christophercantwell5410]

Right

[@melissajacobs5822]

Ben & Jerry's has been here for me lately

[@cavemanlovesmoke4394]

@@melissajacobs5822 bruhh their strawberry cheesecake and the Half baked ice creams ? Ohhh mannnn they are my fav ! 🤤 so expensive but dang B&J's makes the best ice cream

[@michiwu17]

“We gonna give it a gooo” love it! Lol

[@Pellerin1031]

"Uh, I do mind you touching me, quite frankly." "There are a lot of things I will do in this court room but I will not compare a mother saving her child to you murdering Nancy. So let's not go there." That got a chuckle out of me.

[@whade62000]

She was uptight as heck, damn her.

[@swiftay12]

@@whade62000 you serious? she was literally talking to a man admitting to a murderer. Now even if she was uptight, and I thought her lines were pretty on-point, I wouldn't blame her in the slightest

[@LinusVinnportlaced]

She wasn't having any of his nonsense, I love it 🤣

[@charmolettafranquestafiestayam]

@@swiftay12 touch grass and a woman simp

[@cedrickroy3667]

She was irritating and redundantly aggressive. Clearly, the old/frail man was trying to explain to her, that humans experience a sudden cortisol/epinephrine dump while under extreme stress, which could have, from his perspective, given him the extra strength he needed to commit the murder on his own - he merely used the mother and car scenario to validate his point.

[@nandarox528]

I'm a simple woman. I see Mike uploads, I give it a "Goo."

[@jessicaxhanning2111]

@@fu_247 I bet $2,000,000 that you got a little bit of hair down there.

[@l.k.1111]

💯😎💯

[@l.k.1111]

@@jessicaxhanning2111 😭😂😭

[@comonena]

Here’s your like

[@allencollins9951]

lol

[@janaicr9629]

20:45 "if you don't mind" "I DO mind😐" Why did he think she would be OK with that?😂

[@kavinm3659]

😂 Ikr, thing is you can't associate these people with us regular people and our way of thinking. If he were that way, he wouldn't even be there in the first place

[@elishh8173]

I started rewatching Mike's videos! That's how good quality they have! He deserves all the views he gets!! Greetings to all Mike fans 😀

[@alician_stump]

“He looks like he’s got one foot is the grave” I spit coffee everywhere 😂🤣 omg! Your humor is so perfect to lighten up these sad stories.

[@haileygrey5047]

I never understood rich people like that...just so miserable and cruel.

[@pommiebears]

Because rich people, inherited wealth, have never had to want or earn....anything. I should imagine that is a miserable life, tbh. Think about it...when you can have anything you want, where’s the fun, or value, in any of it?

[@ritaheilig6671]

So ungracious. Nancy sounds dreadful rude and disrespectful. I bet she had many people who had enough of her appalling behaviour.

[@egregiousqueef7781]

welcome to earth: rich people are cruel.

[@vladdydaddygrenadez7349]

They think because they have so much money they are owed some kind of respect. But dont realize its earned not bought.

[@countryfrau8328]

I watched another report on this and they talked about Nancy P's wild parties, sexual entanglements, and daily drug and alcohol abuse. I think she was just bombed all of the time.

[@wanderinghistorian]

Mike: "My entire knowledge of Aspen comes from Dumb and Dumber." Me: "You know I'm something of a scientist myself."

[@GardenGuy1943]

What kind of scientist are you? Can you help me if I have questions about a rash?

[@Holocaustica]

@@GardenGuy1943 only I have the power to master the Raaaaaash.

[@dreamsofsnow6521]

Fun fact : they actually did not film in Aspen, it was Breckinridge CO. I lived there when they made that movie. Dont know why they didnt film it in Aspen. That Hotel they stayed in was actually the Stanley Hotel in Estes park CO. That's where Stephen king came up with the idea for his book THE SHINING.

[@Ali-kb8gr]

Haha 😂

[@hermionestranger4964]

@@dreamsofsnow6521 Aspen residents like their privacy, so they probably won't allow anything being filmed except maybe glamour shots to entice tourists. I read a lot about Aspen from Hunter S. Thompson, the gonzo journalist that Mike mentioned in the vid. According to Hunter, a bit over half of the residents are wealthy conservatives that enjoy defiling nature in the name of farms, fishing and skiing, and that hate hippies; a large chunk are lukewarm democrats, also wealthy, but the quiet type that like nature, don't like anything raucous, but have tempered reverence for people like Thompson (so, drugged-out, wigged-out hippies); and a smaller percentage of residents are the aforementioned drugged-out, wigged-out hippies that are left-leaning nature lovers who do wild things like gift each other raw animal meat and blow off fireworks without permission. (then there's the less wealthy margin, which mostly exist there to serve all the rich residents). Maybe things are different today, but from the 1970's through to the 2000's that was how Aspen was according to Thompson. A strange haven where corporatists and acid-trippers were neighbors. Lots of Hollywood people like to live there (or used to at least), not just Jack Nicholson but also quite a few others, like the screen writer Dale Launer (until he sold his Aspen mansion a few years ago). It's curious that Nancy or her daughter (or whoever) wrote that she was a friend of Thompson, given that Thompson never mentioned her in any of his writings, and he had a habit of name-dropping every body that he shared drinks with, did drugs with or generally commiserated with. I also find it hard to imagine that Thompson would be friends with somebody like that lol.

[@Dogsrule777]

This channel is the perfect mix of crime & comedy. We love your work Mike!

[@annalise1139]

You’re telling me there is a town called “Bath Salt”

[@jenee2395]

Basalt lol , he’s pronouncing it incorrectly but we gotta love Mike for it 😂 Bah-salt (coming from someone who literally lives here lol)

[@kimmyfreak200]

lol

[@UpasanaGayan]

Last summer, KZbin recommended That Chapter to me and there was no looking back 🤭🙌🏼

[@AtiyabZafar]

You're not alone there. I Introduced him to my sister and another friends. There's no going back.

[@fabianrojas9028]

Philanthropist: a person who seeks to promote the welfare of others, especially by the generous donation of money to good causes. That Is like the total opposite of what she was really like

[@MsSwitchblade13]

Someone who uses the facade of contributing generous donations to promote the welfare of others, to write off deductions.

[@sethsha7826]

Thanku I made a similar comment as soon as I heard the media calling her a philanthropist! Lmaooo!

[@snookies1224]

pppft, she was just another elite SCAB

[@HarryAirborne]

WTF would you know what she was like? what from this gibberish report? I knew Nancy, she was an extremely generous, big hearted loveable person, who like anyone else got pissed off at being taken advantage of. She was well off, not wealthy nor rich. Seems that Kathy might of been the one taking advantage, making up most of the narrative & pinching the $4k p/m rent, creating the animosity... still has the most to gain.... worth wondering what else went missing, she had pretty unfettered access.....

[@snookies1224]

@@HarryAirborne From what I've read around the traps she made other people buy her things - dinners, flights, gifts. She may have insinuated that she would return the money or pay them back but she never had any intention of that. I've known two people like that: one was a drug addict, the other was hoarding an obscene amount of money but still pretending to be richer than she actually was and conveniently never had any money on her.

[@mumtazsheikh690]

"My mom could never hurt anything or anyone" except everyone in her life

[@tirzeh]

Proud member of the Cult o' Mike~💜

[@Darkey320]

Thank god...I was just about to quit my job but then Mike came through

[@ThatChapter]

I got your back

[@paninii500]

I'm right there with ya

[@hildy208]

Same. Mike’s videos always bring me back off the ledge.

[@clearcomm]

@@hildy208 facts, failing my ochem exam doesn't sting as much with Mike

[@VampirusX]

We are all family! 🤞

[@Roman7-]

Doing a translation for non french speaker at 2:35 '' I will show you the house of Jack Nicholson '' * cut to her saying good morning in the front porch. '' Good morning! Behind her relaxed appearance, Nancy Pfister have of the biggest fortune of Aspen '' Nancy in the cart : '' We call Aspen the Disney Land for Adult! Everything is possible here now, but you need a lot of money... and a lot of free champagne! '' There goes my contribution Mike, absolutely love your videos ♥ Hi from france!

[@gidget3467]

Thanks 🙏

[@aircastles1013]

Thanks Naki, appreciated that!

[@FC-hj9ub]

I saw this on forensic files or something and they totally skimmed over Nancy's behaviour and the best friend's interrogation. They focused more on the evidence found. I think all 3 of them acted on it somehow and he took the blame to get taken care of in prison, and the wife divorced in order to protect their assets, as is common practise. Sounds like the best friend had a bigger role than she's letting on.

[@mydesignerlife]

The humour and narration in this one were some of the best so far for me. Literally, LOL'd a good many times.

[@Kwastaken]

Our boy just couldn’t resist throwing in a “ tree” ...

[@Digitalhunny]

Mike would make the greatest middle school math teacher. Fractions, tree & a turd = 3 1/3 🤣🤣🤣💖

[@robinallen9537]

I know... I love that he has embraced it and made it his own. Its almost like his catchphrase now. LOL

[@michaelmccray8026]

He's giving the audience what they want

[@sylvainfalquet6350]

I really want to hear "dirty tree" (33) 😂😂

[@keychain3039]

@Cory Dinsmore they dont seem to be a douche just pointing out an observation.

[@taylorhamblin1540]

"You absolutely bombed the polygraph" Haha!

[@TahtahmesDiary]

I thought you were going to say "Pfister? I hardly know her!" 🤗💜

[@jz55859]

Brilliant

[@Meenadevidasi]

When things start to go down hill, they just keep going for some until they hit the bottom

[@frankpost62]

The news report said he is 66, he looked more like 86. By the way, no way he could have done this alone.

[@billybobbobson3797]

He didn’t do anything. Wife did it and he took the fall cause he was near death anyway. He was useless to her. As soon as he took the fall she ghosted him and then wrote a fucking book to make money off it. The wife is pure evil

[@stadiumarcadium2351]

@@billybobbobson3797 normal woman things

[@joelr.9743]

Mike told me he loved me! I mean, I knew it... have you seen the way he winks at me at the end of every video?!

[@saltshakerfee]

🤣

[@KW-kr9gh]

😂😜

[@ealeu1]

Nuh uh, he was talking to the guy behind you... You know, the one who makes his vids possible.

[@bobbymenon4057]

🤦😅

[@UrMomGoes2College]

Mikie, I said it when you had 30k subscribers and I'll say it again...you've always got a cold beer and a place to stay at the beach in South Carolina! Its crazy to see how quick you've blown up. Godspeed man!

[@TheAngelgirl7]

I think it was her friend, she saw an opportunity when her was having trouble with the couple so she could make it look like it was them, the key being left at their motel seems too obvious of a set up… I feel terrible for the man who took the blame and had to spend what little time he had left in prison, then enduring a divorce from the person he sacrificed for… truly unfair, no wonder he killed himself. RIP

[@skylahproductions]

The “love yah” made me smile irl

[@SPARKLEPANDA4LIFE]

I'd pay good money to hear Mike say "Thirty three thousand three hundred and thirty three"

[@kenbrunet6120]

You mean Turty Tree Touzand Tree Hundred Turty Tree lol

[@mamiemonrovia7654]

U know I'll bet he was teased immensely as a kid. Now look a the dude. Now that's what I call LOL

[@kenbrunet6120]

@@mamiemonrovia7654 That depends. If he went to school in ireland. Everyone talked like that lol

[@mamiemonrovia7654]

@@kenbrunet6120 Uh, no they don't. AndI I think Mike is Candian, his French is very, very good.

[@aprilhylan]

@@mamiemonrovia7654 🤣🤣🤣Mike is Irish through and through. I’m sure they teach French there just like everywhere else.

[@jimrossi7708]

This guy “Mike” should have a show on a major station, he is awesome, it’s like he’s telling you and friends a story over a beer 🍺 ! Sounds like a set up to me !!!

[@8inary]

It amazes me, when I see these videos from Mike, I look at the time running, be it 30mins or 45mins long, I always think, I will just skip parts as I do not have time to watch it all, however once it starts, I always watch the whole thing till the end, that shows how good these videos are put together, and with the addition of Mike's commentary.

[@azurecielo52479]

And then I just watch 6 more

[@amyrose6793]

What I love about Mike: his accent, the content, his presentation, sense of (dark) humour, his respect for the victims. What I hate about Mike: that I don't know him personally and probably never will! Thanks for all your hard work. You're amazing.

[@a.d.h5635]

One more thing to hate Mike for... He only posts twice a week, we need more of his TREEmendous narrating skills 😂

[@LadyPamela63]

he's on twitter too Amy, posts daily usually and as hilarious as always lol

[@bwj4893]

Does Mike have a That Chapter T-shirt for sale? One with his pic on it? I'd give it goo! I'd even pay turdy-tree big ones for it!

[@Nik.No.K]

Yeah I’m confident mike and I would be great friends. Too bad he’s in Ireland and probably not interested in hanging out with some rando from the internet😝

[@readysaltedfart2121]

@@Nik.No.K thinks absolutely everyone..... 😂

[@KCsFunHouse]

🤣😂 my dogs name is Aspen, every time Mike said “Aspen” she tilted her head confused lol

[@marctronixx]

username checks out...

[@northerngirl1637]

What a sweetie!🐾💕

[@aircastles1013]

That’s adorable 💖🐶

[@cecemepls0]

“they were having financial problems” *puts a $12k down payment on a $4k/month house in Aspen* 😳 my broke brain cannot compute this situation at all

[@KK-dw1wq]

Famous for those trees......what are they called again..? You're so precious 💗.

[@ryanelliott4538]

I have the worst habit of reading the comments and spoiling it for me, while he still saying. “Hey you and welcome.”

[@blahblahblahblah2837]

I almost did it too this time, but scrolled back before the damage was done!

[@bobbymenon4057]

Count me in, too

[@paiiininthebuttt2477]

Touché 😂

[@karobythell4425]

I wish i could be number " tree " sayingbi do this too , but alas Im number four .

[@martinverner5670]

its cray because what happens is most likely now that you already know the outcome. you can pay closer attention to details. it just makes it harder to play detective 😆

[@AntonioGee]

"So how many strands would you say that you saw?" Lmao this guy.

[@mariapalladino2473]

3 strands lol I mean seriously?!??

[@stephanieann8115]

I know right?! I’m sure the lady didn’t count whether she is guilty or not!

[@VestinVestin]

​@@stephanieann8115 Spoiler alert: she couldn't have seen the hair, since the body was more wrapped up than King Tut. Thus, her continued vivid descriptions of hair must've been lies. Every additional statement she makes on seeing the hair moves her a step closer from "might've misremembered" to "making shit up".

[@pink_sock]

It's almost as bad as that one detective who was clearly on the rag. You don't talk smack to someone who's confessing to a crime. What an absolute moron.

[@ToyokaX]

He's using the baiting tactic of making her commit to specific details. It's a tactic used in implicating those who could be considered suspects and to cross-examine them later when/if they testify. Pretty bog-standard interrogation technique.

[@jaymeister4850]

Okay so .... Usually I feel for the victims in these and in some tragic cases I feel for the perp who had a moment of insanity too. But this time... Not condoning what happened, but I am kind of thinking that she had it coming.

[@MsSilverTulip]

I agree!

[@queajy3952]

yup, sooner or later someone was gonna geg fed up

[@mariakelly1059]

@@queajy3952 But was killing Nancy worth going to prison for? No she wasn't, regardless of how horrible she was.

[@queajy3952]

@@mariakelly1059 Well someone thought it was worth it, that's why you should live a kind life.

[@vincentsablan732]

"Nancy Pfister--Hey, hey!!! Gotta buy her dinner first!!! Am I right?". Mike is SO quick... I love this guy!!

[@hookemdevildog]

It's VERY rare... But every now and then, I can't help but think: "yeah, she had it coming". This is one of those cases.

[@spaztor7723]

rich people...no responsibility. weak.

[@addie_is_me]

Some people are not great losses. It’s sounds horrible and it doesn’t mean we think she deserved it, just everyone killed is not an angel. Lol

[@dor4376]

Roses are red Mike t-shirt is blue Oh look it's friday! So let's give it a goo!

[@harveydent5334]

I got some "goo" 👁👄👁

[@sentance578]

Love ya

[@samclarn]

Ok this is pretty cute

[@louiseyoung9112]

Nice!

[@sabrinapittsley2304]

I love this channel because it gets right to the point without becoming boring. And of course, Mike is quite the story teller.

[@tomwolfe9358]

Mike I love your channel and have just pressed the subscribe button. First time I’ve ever done that to any I’ve watched before. You are brilliant at what you do and you have unknowingly helped me through lock down. Thanks Tommy.

[@potloodpencil]

Oh man this is a perfect present. I just got an a+ on my thesis!! I'm finally a certified nurse!! Thanks for bringing me happiness when I needed it the most!

[@ani6830]

Congrats.🤧🤒🤕

[@matthewschmoyer8552]

Congratulations!

[@missriss3377]

Wooo!!!

[@kem1691]

Congrats! 👍

[@Hey___you]

Well done! 🎉

[@irstat1c383]

One of the most heartbreaking things for me to endure recently was when I came to the realization that I’ve watched all of Mike’s past content... Now here I am... Two new episodes a week isn’t enough. :(

[@lindasmal5051]

I’m in the same boat as you.....started rewatching videos just to get my Mike-fix in.

[@Gagliano17]

@@lindasmal5051 exactly this, i've seen so much that i dont even remember some by titel and thumbnail and only realize 10 mins in that i've already seen all this, and now i'm sad =P

[@mrsrock7641]

I leave it two weeks per time and binge. Caught up now and I’m sad I have to wait two weeks for my next binge 😭

[@memelordzuckerberg4186]

"JCS" Does similar stuff if you're looking for more to check out! He barely ever uploads though :(

[@lindasmal5051]

@@memelordzuckerberg4186 I’m up to date with JCS too. 🙁

[@philiparroyo832]

Netflix needs to give this man a show...like for reals!

[@humixmusic4lyf]

Nuuuuu. They’ll ruin it if they do.

[@opiecunningham1570]

In this instance I find myself rooting for the murderers.

[@frankie1012]

👍🏽

[@reignman30]

Yeah not all murder cases are treated equally lol. Well at least 2 of them got away with it.

[@hollyerorabaugh4406]

“Let’s give it a goo” will NEVER GET OLD. Ty Mike for making our lives less shite.

[@alizajohnny6422]

HAAAAA good one.

[@kellihs7506]

If Mike ever stops saying, “Let’s give it a gooo”” I will set myself on fire.

[@donovanguerin2124]

I'm with ya!! Lol

[@lkdelaney6222]

Lol I'm with ya !

[@susanjohnson318]

I want a T-shirt that says that!

[@spa-peggymeatballs4861]

😅 well that went from 0-100 real fast.

[@kellihs7506]

Go z as i

[@lizperrella666]

I'm sorry - great video, Mike, as always.....but I'm ROFL at "eh gotta buy 'er dinner first, right?" OMG I'm dead LOLOL

[@TR-IRL]

Mike just found your channel and it's well done and fascinating. Thank you for creating awareness.

[@susanwinter2896]

My favourite Tuesday and Friday evening entertainment. Nobody can ever get enough of Mike!

[@yup_its_ME.512]

@@manoerinafanchannel3196 that one made my blood run cold with how evil people can be when breaking up!! My son and his ex were splitting up and I kept up on *both* of them!

[@sebastianfryc5236]

So fax bro

[@maram3800]

.".. And she was born in the family... I believe the term is RICH AS SHIT"... Much love Mike.

[@GardenGuy1943]

Were her parents farmers? I don’t understand why Mike would compare wealth to feaces unless they had a manure business.

[@6G6O6F6]

@@GardenGuy1943 if you don´t understand figures of speech you should go to your doctor. It´s a brain condition

[@GARY84ROCKS]

@@6G6O6F6 If you don't understand metaphorical comedy you shouldn't embarrass yourself.

[@35PHaaton]

It's Aspen. Most people there are rich or at least above average.

[@GARY84ROCKS]

@@35PHaaton Everybody gets it Akai. It's just there are too many psycho Mike fans roving the comments section who will make posts (and "Like" posts) like PotatoMan's simply because they can't handle a joke seemingly made at Mike's expense. The world is a weird place... and KZbin is even weirder.

[@TomBrady-ce9md]

This old man is a G. He knew the assignment he knew his time was short. He helped his wife out. Respect

[@JDogth3Wise]

Such a weird combination having a comedic narrator for gruesome stories, but damn it works surprisingly well.

[@thathandtoolguy]

Is it just me or does Nancy Pfister's daughter look like a less strung out Courtney Love?

[@UncleRicosCamper]

Yes!!!

[@ReBecca-rl4bi]

Totally thought that, or Francis Bean

[@addie_is_me]

Less strung out? As strung out.

[@thathandtoolguy]

@@addie_is_me Hard to be as strung out without being dead. Courtney is a walking zombie.

[@aceykrew5207]

Courtney Love looks like a strung out Courtney Love. Lol

[@Cochise6666]

"Gonna Meet Nancy, Pfister, THEN take her to dinner...what? Was it something I said?" You're priceless to delve into that whole line of comedy. You fiend.

[@Scorch428]

Pfister? I barely know her.

[@IbanezFan550]

Pfister? Damn near killed her!

[@gidget3467]

I thought he said, "Nancy, Phister 'HEY, gotta buy her dinner first, right?' ". Either way, when he made the joke I laughed so hard 😂🤣😂😂 Ahhh Mike, your humor and quick wit NEVER disappoint

[@jimmym3352]

I totally missed that.

[@gidget3467]

@@jimmym3352 understandable. Mike’s a sly devil 😈

[@reactormeltdown]

Interrogator: So how many strands would you say that you saw? Answer: Well, I personally counted them with a pair of tweezers at the scene and then spread them out, before taking some macro photography pictures to independently verify the fact that I saw exactly 234 strands of hair. Interrogator: How much blood would you say that you saw? Answer: Due to the differential absorption and evaporation patterns, it's difficult to tell. But I asked some CSI's I know and, after looking at the video evidence I took, they surmised that it was around 250ml. Interrogator: It's been a long night and I've been called in from my dads retirement party. I'm trolling you!

[@zinga9328]

'someone who was born into such' privalaaage' 😂😂😂😭😭😭