The Truth About American Colonialism | Guest: Dr. Jeff Fynn-Paul | Ep 910

[@makeitcount179]

" For there is no other Name under heaven given among men whereby we must be saved :;Jesus Christ"

[@michellelangston119]

Love this interview, I like how he’s truthful about history being ‘messy.’ Also, me and my husband loved the movie ‘The Blind’ … I have always appreciated the Robertsons and Phil & Kay’s testimony. ❤️ 🎥

[@jsshay01]

“The Blind” was one of the best movies I’ve ever seen. The end was just so good. We need a sequel. I so admire the Robertson family, they stand for Jesus! And listen to “Unashamed” every night. I’d encourage everyone to see it.

[@MLEeightysix]

When the area I live in in Southeastern Oklahoma was turned back over to Natives on the legal front, a lot of Natives were worried about what might happen. They really didn't want it but because the paperwork was originally written incorrectly, it left a loophole that couldn't be avoided. It's caused some weird legal issues even with inmates and how they serve their time. As far as reparations, I have very little Native blood that I can claim but me and my children get free healthcare and it's honestly pretty good. I'm so grateful for that.

[@CosmicAli_TheObserver]

The land has been gone, where's the Great Melting Pot!?! If you are here in America and a citizen, this is your Country now as well as mine. I am Indigenous, but my fellow Americans are from all walks of life and I take great pride in that. I am more upset with the morally reprehensible behavior that the descendants of the pilgrims have brought here, more than I am my stolen land. (Besides, it is us that belong to the land not the other way around.) America is supposed to be the Great Melting Pot, we offer refuge to people escaping from hunger, abuse, female circumcision, and the dreamers that want to have a better life for their children. We need to be living in a way that encourages and inspires people to have pride in our Country, in themselves. The Indigenous have over 400 Tribes, a better use of time would be spent figuring out what tribe you are speaking of when you say "the Native Americans". Like the different caucasian countries in Europe, we are all different people with very different cultures. My Tribe are the only people that fought the US Government and won, not everyone deserves that respect.

[@anonymous3637]

The Melting Pot is just a 1908 play whose author wasn't even American, not a real thing

[@Loislaneski]

I too am “Native American”, part of the Mikmaq tribe of Elsipogtog New Brunswick Canada 🇨🇦 If I may just suggest; be careful where such pride takes you. Your tribe was the “only one to fight the American government and win”? But what did they really win against the government? The power, the wealth, the land? If the government TRULY sought this “win” over this tribe, don’t you think they had the power, wealth, and resources to accomplish that? And is this tribe now completely independent, free of government funding and services? If the government still funds the tribe, then it doesn’t really sound like the tribe has really “won” whatever it is you think is worthy of such pride.

[@Loislaneski]

If Russia decided to come and take over the lands of your tribe, do you think it would be your tribe who would be the reckoning force they met? Or would it be the American military?

[@perryroberts4353]

@@Loislaneski The Haida as well as other Nations on the North West coast traded and had disagreements with the Russians for hundreds of years before the Europeans showed up an

[@desertrose0601]

I swear this channel has more ads than content. It’s very frustrating when listening to be interrupted so often.

[@saltandlight316]

This is for everyone saying that this is one sided... Two things can be true at the same time. America is NOT stolen land. The Natives were here before, but they didn't have a country set up. They were several hundred years behind Europe, and they were going to war between each other for land. The world was very different than it is today. Until VERY recently when people wanted land they went to war. The people that won the war kept the land. We are not the only ones that did this. Look at ANY country today and they conquered the people living in the land before them. Now, even though we did not steal the land the American government did not treat the Natives very well. I think part of that is that the Americans were afraid of the Natives, so the government had to force them away from the general population. Sometimes fear and ignorance of a people can drive something like this. I can say the same if the Natives. Many Natives were fearful and ignorant of the Americans, and they would also act on those impulses.

[@staceyallen7480]

Well said ❤

[@thatsmynamesowhat2949]

Absolutely

[@theeternalsbeliever1779]

I wouldn't exactly call it "ignorance" when the American Indians(i refuse to use the pc term "natives" because it validates the idea that the land was stolen) were known for engaging in unprovoked attacks against settlers.

[@saltandlight316]

@@theeternalsbeliever1779 I think that there were unprovoked attacks on both sides. No man is without sin. There were good and bad natives and good and bad settlers. I refuse to paint one group as all good or all bad. I also refuse to use indigenous for the same reason. I feel like that is the new PC term. The reason that I use Native verses American Indian is because it can get confusing with Indians that live in India, but to each their own.

[@og666]

why don't you want to say stole? i'm sure if russia conquered us you'd say they stole the land. it's cool if you don't think stealing the land is a bad thing but the word is a fairly accurate description of what happened

[@joykeebler1916]

- the United States, was not an established Country, as so in borders originally ...So even by logic, the land had no area or jurisdiction for which to be called

[@dick_richards]

Great interview, God bless u all.

[@sarw9294]

I live In Bolivia, where the emblem of this particular city is a conquistador. You see it on everything, from official buildings, to lamp posts, to signs to schools. And of course all the many monuments are of conquistadors and other Spaniard warriors. It’s interesting to see a culture from this perspective, in which the people of the country do live as conquered people. I mean, that’s how it looks as one living here: There is a sharp distinction between who is “conquered” and who “isn’t.” The distinction lies in what one wears; the schools one attends; the restaurants one eats at; the entertainment one enjoys. However, whereas in North America, the natives do not allow non-natives to participate in certain ceremonies, here they do. You can dance in the San Roque festival wearing indigenous regalia even if you are not indigenous. The one caveat is that you must be male. When my kids wear indigenous clothing everyone thinks it’s beautiful, and they always compliment them. They’re greatly encouraged to wear it, in fact, which can be verrrrry different than up north. As one who has worked on both Southwestern US and Canadian reservations/reserves and now lives in South America, it’s extremely interesting to note the differences. Here, right or wrong, they’re very, very proud of the conquistador heritage.

[@rebeccabarrand5132]

You mentioned you've worked on reservations. What type of job did you have?

[@Tj-TrustJESUS]

GREAT interview!! This needs to be in every public school in America!! Truth was shared, this generation does not understand the price that was paid for our FREEDOM!!🇺🇸

[@lavadamorrison4569]

It is great to learn about history, but it really doesn't matter today. We are here and we are not going away. It is time for the American Indians to leave the past behind and move forward. I have close ancestors that were Cherakee Indians. I was born in America and I am an American. This has been the freest country in the world. Even when we erred with slavery it was addressed with the Civil War and slavery was done away with.

[@user-cc5od3zk4p]

No different in Canada. Indigenous people want to continue the victim narrative because it’s very lucrative financially.

[@buffalolifesavers]

Love your show, Allie! I listen to every episode. Since you came back from maternity leave, I've experienced audio issues on youtube. I listen on my laptop while I go about my day. I have to practically hold the laptop up to my ear to hear the audio. I don't have this problem with any other show. Thanks!

[@buffalolifesavers]

Actually it appears that your guests' audio is better than yours. It's mostly on your mic.

[@janetotto9321]

Years ago, a friend bought a new car with her "Indian" money, as she called it. Her father actually was instrumental in the forming of the department of Indian Affairs with Robert Kennedy. so they knew their native Indian benefits.

[@AldiAldiFPen]

So, let me get this straight commit genocide. Then claim to have one ounce of Indian blood to fraudulently claim benefits.🙄 The racist owner of the Washington Redskins did the same thing. You can't make this level of depravity up if you spent a lifetime trying.

[@markmcflounder15]

Candace has mentioned in her book: Blackout (2020): that something like 30 native american tribes of the north west owned slaves. Her book is such a good primer to Thomas Sowell.

[@tomhitchcock8195]

The Earth is the Lords

[@nothanksmegan]

My ancestors were pioneers who came here between 1732-1847. Neither side of my family owned slaves (Jews and masons owned 97% of the slaves in the US). My ancestors came here with nothing, not knowing what to expect but being fully aware there was absolutely no infrastructure or social safety nets to keep them afloat. Legally or not, migrants coming here post-industrial revolution are seeking handouts, to benefit from the hard work of others, to instantly have a better and easier life; that was not the mentality of pioneers….They knew a better life was generations down the road and expected nothing from others. To compare my ancestors (who also has little interaction with tribes) to modern migrants is preposterous and stupid. I won’t tolerate the comparison any more. It’s only an attempt to make me think my heritage isn’t honorable or worthy. Also to call dairy farmers and loggers colonizers is laughable.

[@impalaman9707]

Were they German? I also found that most Germans didn't own slaves and in fact were anti-slavery. Its the reason you never see any black people with German last names. They are almost all English last names

[@thorpeaaron1110]

Where's the statistics on the Jews though?

[@impalaman9707]

@@thorpeaaron1110 Good question! The smoking gun is always a black person's surname. I don't see any Jewish surnames that black people have. They are almost always masonic English last names--like Jackson, Washington, Chamberlain, or Jefferson

[@shellone28]

I disagree with preposterous blanket statements such as, "post-industrial revolution migrants seek handouts," or bigotry against any group, just as I disagree with comments that disparage Christians in general, on account of evils such as the history of cults that identified as Christian organizations, like the follower of David Koresh, or Jim Jones. It might surprise you to know that there are migrants who come to the U.S, from all over the globe, with professional backgrounds, and/or advanced degrees, or those whose pride causes them shame when it comes to participation in "entitlement programs," altogether or long-term. Let's not leave out those who come with pennies and surpass others who have been blessed with advantages they take for granted, or fail to take advantage of in pursuit of advancing themselves. While it is possible your ancestors were all that you say they were, such assumptions are tasteless and translate to hubris. For all you know your ancestors could have very well landed after a lengthly exchange of letters that ensured they would have a "safety net," in place, to ensure a means of survival, shelter, or a community. Clearly, the intention is to suggest that your ancestors were superior to the "modern immigrant" because of the attack on the notion that they would even be compared to today's immigrant. "How dare they."

[@naynay9652]

Some are faux last names. Rothschild had a different name originally. I am forgetting off the top of my head. Also, confederate Mason Albert Pike was a Jew. Many were. ​@impalaman9707

[@soniacasanova384]

This was painful

[@robertawinters9366]

God's blessings from Bay City Michigan

[@jambox9919]

Historical figures are complicated just like we are complicated.

[@lmlm_]

We are a nation of pioneers and settlers that conquered wild land to create the greatest country on Earth. 🇺🇸

[@jayrocky9067]

EXACTLY 👍🏽

[@Lacteagalaxia]

Exterminated indigenous and wild land? maybe a genpcide was commited and the indigenous lands were occupied what you say sñunds racists.and a country woth gteat diference of class ; health not for all ; millions of poors lying in streets and a severe drug problems ; many deads for guns per year in a first gdp but no n1 in quality of life is a great country?.

[@lmlm_]

@@Lacteagalaxia Try writing coherently next time 🤡

[@Hismana-oi4yx]

@lmlm_ but were dieing from the plague and slums of Europe prior to being sent to our land as criminals. Right...

[@lmlm_]

@@Hismana-oi4yx Meanwhile the third world is still suffering from the plague and slums today. 😆

[@makeitcount179]

"That if you confess with your mouth Jesus AS Lord and BELIEVE in your heart that God raised Him from the dead, you will be Saved ( from the just penalty of your sins ) (10) for with the heart ( desires center ) a person BELIEVES resulting in Righteousness (imputed by Christ; 2 Cor 5:21) and with the Mouth...confession is made unto Salvation" St. Paul wrote in Romans 10:9,10

[@kurtbradwill]

My high school was the Columbia River Chieftans. They're now the Columbia River Rapids. The Columbia doesn't have rapids 🤦‍♂️

[@marilynbatten5365]

Lol!--and "chieftains" is primarily a Scottish word, used to describe clan leaders. I could not find a single reference where the word "chieftains" was used to describe Native Americans. Even if it was meant to, it seems like it's a positive allusion to the athleticism of the indigenous people. Did anyone ask them if they wanted the name changed?

[@AldiAldiFPen]

@@marilynbatten5365 Firstly, I am assuming you are a female by your name. You clearly have no context of the names of these sports teams and mascots. For example, the founder of the Washington Redskins was a well known racist and they were the last team to integrate. These racists mascots have no business in sports and are nothing more than bigoted backhanded insults.

[@peterjohnson1734]

@@AldiAldiFPen The shallow thoughts of an indoctrinated mindset.

[@Ecos107]

A great read about this topic is "They came for Freedom" by Jay Milbrant. There are so many layers and stories all wrapped up in the events that lead to the first colonies in America (there were many, not just the pilgrims) and many personalities involved and a lot went into how each situation was handled. It even goes into the politics amongst the tribes that were occupying the north east regions and their varied relationships with the many explorers, map makers, tradesmen and settlers. Some of it is amazing, some of it is heartbreaking. As I tell my kids, you can't put a blanket statement over any part of history.

[@alanreinart1548]

We need to give it back to China, India, Egyptians, Nubians.

[@kennethbaker5223]

Who's "we"?

[@impalaman9707]

From what I consider a "Biblical" perspective---there are no "native" peoples in the Americas. There are only those who got here first. How were the first people who wandered across the Bering Strait supposed to know if there were already people here, any more than the Pilgrims who landed on Plymouth Rock thousands of years later? We all ultimately came from Noah's ship and went our separate ways. But we found each other later

[@rstroh2105]

interesting perspective

[@damoab1909]

Of course you wouldn’t want truth. It benefits you!

[@impalaman9707]

@@damoab1909 What do you even mean? The truth for the origin of all life is found in the Word of God

[@dfel549]

Excellent episode!!!!!

[@kjvertruth1026]

Love the content but the number of ads is very annoying 😒

[@jefflincoln700]

Welcome back nice lady!!!!!

[@myahkgatsby7578]

Great interview!

[@shannonwaller1498]

Good conversation

[@markmcflounder15]

Among multiple factors but especially How-ard Z-Inn has be so passionate about refuting this outlandish M-arcs ist corruption. Almost all my posts on him just disappear on this in clusiv & divers environment

[@meshi2535]

This interview is so one sided. My Great Grandmother didn’t tell my mother that she had Cherokee blood until after a dentist asked my mother (age 18) how much “Indian” she had in her, telling her she had “Indian” teeth. When my mother confronted her grandmother and asked her why she never told her, her grandmother said when she was growing up, being “Indian” wasn’t a good thing to be. Her grandmother, my great grandmother, went on to tell her that her family hid out in caves in North Carolina when the government started rounding up the Cherokee to move them west. There was no “farmstead” or cash that was offered to them. Like that would have made up for the fact that the government moved them off of the majority of their territory and split families apart during that “move”. It wasn’t called The Trail of Tears because the government was so generous and kind to them. I don’t know to this day how many of my ancestors died on that trek that happened during the winter, I only know that the name of Cloud, my grandmother’s maiden name, was on the registry. I really like you Allie, but please seek some facts from the people whose ancestors lived it.

[@alex43223]

While I can appreciate your opinion, your evidence is anecdotal as opposed to well-researched. The majority of society now runs on anecdotes and feelings, vs. facts. I appreciate Allie having this interview and providing evidence of unpopular truths in this backwards society we now live in.

[@jayrocky9067]

Stop crying over things that happened 100 years ago. If it wasn’t for the WHITES we wouldn’t have the greatest country in the world. 💯

[@lmlm_]

The Indians put up a good fight for 314 years (1609-1923) but we eventually won. War and conquest is part of human life, especially back then.

[@saltandlight316]

I'm sorry for what your grandmother went through. Two things can be true at the same time. The Americans did win the war and the land. That is how the world opporated for most human civilization. However, once the Americans won they should have treated the Natives better. America has dark stains in our history. However, the ideals of America stated in the Constitution remain true, and as long as we strive towards those ideas and keep Christ first we will continue to improve.

[@sigmanocopyrightmusic8737]

​@@alex43223 are you an American idolator who denies the crimes of America . The founding fathers were free masons. They persecuted Christians who believed in non violence and didn't want to fight in wars.

[@Ottorockz]

Great convo! Very informative!

[@robbchastain3036]

I know not much about the history of the Indian Wars, as they were called, tho" I do have a couple of books about them as I was once stationed at Ft. Leavenworth, Kansas and have begun reading one of them with an interest in U.S. military history and the rights and wrongs of it. And skipping far ahead to these days, I think that while history should be studied and understood, the small kindnesses shown to Native Americans by everyday people nowadays should not be overlooked. And I had such a moment with a hitchhiker decades ago as I was driving east in my mini-truck and picked him up at the side of a road in California, something we did back then. Tuns out he didn't speak English but we somehow communicated the basics with one another and he wasn't at his destination at the end of the day, so I got a motel room for us, we continued the next day, and then, in the middle of nowhere in New Mexico, he indicated that this was his stop. So I pulled over, perplexed by his request, yet sure enough, there was a narrow trail that led up a hill and that's what he took to get back to his people. And I was simply glad I had helped him get there, no fanfare or anything, just a ride and a thanks and goodbye.

[@Hupernike45]

Ally Beth, with all due respect, the word is "lies" not "myths".

[@hglundahl]

28:11 It can be mentioned, the reason why the taking of Tenochtitlan, the Aztek capital roughly equivalent to Mexico City, was so bloody, was, the indigenous people were pretty beyond what Cortez could control. They were vengeful, and understandably.

[@user-cc5od3zk4p]

Thank you, Dr. Fynn-Paul for a factual discourse of history.

[@billjohnsonpgc]

This interview is all COPIUM. I love this channel but this is very one sided lol

[@marilynbatten5365]

Um....most people have only ever heard one side, which did not contain any of this information. When you hear the very biased, one-sided version that the Marxists created, do you call them out for being "one-sided?"

[@rogeralsop3479]

The BBC won't like this post.

[@michaelfalsia6062]

I am a Christian and an Italian American and I celebrate Columbus day without any shame. Nor will I ever allow Christophobic reprobates and leftist low lives ever intimidate me! Definitely NOT as a Christian, and not as an Italian American! God in his providence and Sovereign will decreed that indigenous people so called were overcome because of their sin and pagan ways similar to the reasons for the expulsion of the indigenous peoples in Caanan. In order to establish this land as a gospel stronghold for the propagation of the everlasting gospel which would reach people all around the world to receive the salvation in the Lamb who was slain.from the foundation of the world God so ordered the powers of that age. This includes the natives in this land and many so called indigenous people came to saving faith and were delivered from their sins and wicked hearts by the preaching of the pure gospel. Hence the reason why Dartmouth college came into existence in order to train those God had saved out from among these natives who would now train for the gospel ministry. The first Bible printed in America was translated into the language of the native by John Elliott another proof of the divine hand in the history of this nation. Revelation 5:10. God used Europeans to bring the good news of salvation to this continent. Sovereignty through divine providence. God has predetermined the boundaries of all people and organized His great commission accordingly. It was time for this land to be transformed and move into a more progressive environment in order for the gospel to impact what we call the modern world for the truth as it is in Jesus. Another facet of God's immaculate Sovereignty and providence was to use this land because of the light and truth of the gospel to lay the foundation for good and just government and the freedom necessary for the true Christian faith to blossom and bloom as a force for good for all people. A land where the word of God could freely be proclaimed by the protection of law. Without the European renaissance and Reformation there would be no modern age. Again this was all in the divine decree. The period of unprecedented world wide missions begins in England at just the right time as modern man emerges and the age of reason also begins to dawn. God is right there with His church to counter this and at the same time do a work of evangelization that would sweep the globe for the Lord Jesus and His redeemed, elect saints for a witness that truly reaches the utter most parts of the earth and lost sinners wherever they may be found. Europe and America were chosen and ordained to be the lands where the greatest gospel mission activity in the history of fallen man would begin. You and I friends if we have been truly saved were part of that decree in the eternal councils of the Triune God that reveal His Son in each of us to the praise of the glory of His grace. This is how Jesus would build His church from that time forward when the Westeren European peoples would venture out into this side of the world gospel horizons would be realized in ways they had not previously. And even where imperial intent was the driving force we can say they meant it for evil but God meant it for good. Something also discovered in His Sovereign decrees! Think of Phyllis Wheatly a young child taken from her land in Africa as a slave and brought to America, purchased in a slave market in Boston by the Wheatley family who wanted her to be raised by as Mrs Wheatley's mistress. In that whole unpleasant and unrighteous affair God used this evil institution to deliver her soul from sin and lead her to embrace Jesus as her Lord and Savior in a Congregational church which she became an member of. Although Phylis Wheatley would get attention and notoriety as a poet yet she was a godly woman who loved her Lord and served Him faithfully. Phyllis would go on to tell of her own conversion and how thankful she was that God had brought her out of a land of darkness (her native Africa)in order to save her benighted soul as she would write to hear the truth as it is in Jesus which was effected because of the slave trade. Behind this sinful nefarious practice she saw the hand and purpose of God to receive life in His Son through an institution we all recognize was wicked, inhuman and contrary to the Christian doctrine and spirit. Phyllis would also right a flattering poem about the evangelist George Whitefield who she loved even as she loved her godly and kindly Pastor who she also acknowledged in her poems. What a faith this dear Sister of ours had despite the circumstances under which she came to know the love and grace of God who wrote her name in Lamds book of life. We must likewise see the hand of providence in the eternal council of our Triune God who works in mysterious ways His wonders of grace and salvation to perform in human history. God is going to visit this world to two ways. That is to reveal wrath and judgment Romans 1:16-18; Psalm 2 and 110. And in saving grace when He delivers us from the power and penalty of sin as creatures fallen and defiled in Adam. John 3:16; Romans chapter 5. God's people are to see and understand human history for good or for bad through the lens of His redemptive plan in Jesus Christ our Lord. Acts 17:22-31 vs 26 in particular. Let the unsaved wicked hate us and maliciously speak against us for this as we defend and declare the righteous and Sovereign hand and will of Almighty God over all the affairs of men and nations! If they hated Christ as we are assured so too will the enemies of our Lord hate us. So be it! Let God be true and every man a liar. Romans 3:4. History as it has been said is indeed His Story and we joyfully praise and bless God for all that He is and does! Revelation 5. Here I stand, God help me!

[@Justice55339h]

Amen!!!❤ Hallelujah!!🙌 My spirit lept with your stirring words! We are the city on a hill, giving light tot he whole world, as the very first Christians who came here always envision. God is faithful despite fallen humanity and corrupt histories throughout the world, there was still SO much essential good and so much that is wonderful ESPECIALLY here. Praise and glory to God! We should be so grateful, I am too grateful for words. And the devil WILL NOT WIN this antichrist war against our God-given nation and God's people in Jesus' name!!! The spirit of the accuser will be cast down!!!

[@Pimpbot2oo1]

Great guest but waaay too many ad breaks

[@solochristo65]

Before I even listen...... There was enough land for the settlers and MANY others who came to America to all get along with the Native Americans......But there was a thing called SIN that was in every human being....

[@Justice55339h]

Also vast majority Native Americans were wiped out inadvertantly by disease they didn't have at that time. Sad but it was clearly God's sovereign will, they were pagans..

[@robertmueller2023]

News International/Facebook/Pfizer HQ? Yes, that's what my attorneys/accountants think.

[@calebcooks8497]

Allie clearly don’t know your history Christianity was already in Africa pre trans Atlantic slave trade

[@AldiAldiFPen]

The oldest known Bible is from Ethiopia. Yet, she is saying Africans were practicing "witchcraft".🙄 Little does she know witchcraft originates in Europe. The question is what was Europe practicing while Ethiopians in Africa were reading the oldest Bible in the world. Some folks are so racist it is laughable.

[@calebcooks8497]

@@AldiAldiFPen Allie just ignorant

[@AldiAldiFPen]

@@calebcooks8497 The Holy Land is far closer to Africa than Europe. For goodness sake Israel shares a border with Africa. In fact Israel was considered part of Africa during ancient times. The term Middle East was never used until the British came with their colonizer treachery. The only witchcraft I see is taking a man born in an ancient Israel and portraying him with white skin and blue eyes.

[@timothybuckley7317]

​@@AldiAldiFPenI was a missionary in Africa briefly. They still practice witchcraft there to this day.

[@Justice55339h]

​@@timothybuckley7317that explains a lot smh

[@davidsteffen3860]

No the natives did not have a system of land ownership they were tribal and had territories they fought over with surrounding tribes. And if we conquered them in a war that happened get over it. We are where we are and need to work together going forward.

[@AldiAldiFPen]

Get over it... Would you feel the same if that was said about 9-11? Heck southerners are still fighting the Civil War. Should they get over that?

[@blessedtobealive]

3:28 oh well as long as it was far fewer. Can't wait for your next videos, the truth about slavery and the holocaust.

[@WCove99]

I LOVE Allie, but I don't know why she can't admits how bad some whites have been to non whites.

[@brittanyd3173]

😅

[@Justice55339h]

Nobody said oh well..are you guys trying to create peace or continually accuse us and create severe division and instability in our society. That will hurt you too in the end. It is racist propaganda against us and our mostly good history to be hyperbolic about the negative things that happened. So he was calling that out, and that IS important. And it is wrong for people to being lying and hyperbolic. Every history of all peoples throughout the world has sin and stains.

[@joykeebler1916]

- and this is lawfully why land can't be considered as in stolen within that to previous comment posted

[@robertmueller2023]

What do you think, Jason Greenslate of Fox News on disc 23?

[@L0vejenjen]

this was an interesting interview,i think towards the end he mentioned black people getting the same amount of reparations as indiginious and im confused what he is referring to i love your channel by the way

[@saltandlight316]

Native reservations get a ridiculous amount of money from our government each year. Also, they get a free ride to any college they want. Unfortunately, most Native governments keep the money for themselves, so they don't invest in infrastructure. Also, Natives are very tribal, so they aren't allowed to leave the reservation or they can't come back. That keeps most of them from leaving. And even if they wanted to leave most of them don't have past a 2nd or 3rd grade education, so they couldn't survive off the reservation anyways. Like I said the elders keep the money and don't invest in their community. I know a missionary that works on a Native reservation in Montana. My husband and I have visited a few times. It is really sad. Pray for them.

[@whitneymilgate7975]

​@josietanner3960 same here in Canada. The money doesn't go to the community. The Native leaders keep it all to themselves😔.

[@L0vejenjen]

yes black people dont get money from government unless he referring to people who use government assist services which all of us do not so i was confused about what he was talking about, because thats not reparations thats getting governement assistance aka welfare

[@saltandlight316]

@@whitneymilgate7975 It is really sad.

[@marigold973]

I'll need to listen again, but I heard him say the indigenous received more than Black people. If so, this is consistent as other groups continue to receive cash payout whereas reparations for the Black community is pushed back through commissions and ongoing discussions. Even today, Isr. and Ukr. receive money direct with little issue. I realize some offer religious perspectives in defense; my concern is that partiality continues at all. I'm less confident this interview broadens understanding but again, I'm going to give it a second listen.

[@purpleivory2]

Enough with the ads already. I can understand 1 or 2 but every 10 minutes is way too much.

[@meredithmontz756]

H. E. Marshall’s This Country of Ours.

[@MrNochase]

He has to STOP calling Indigenous people Natives you cant be an immigrant which the word Native means while living on your own continent/country.

[@naynay9652]

No it doesn't. Read a dictionary

[@MrNochase]

@naynay9652 that's your issue. You are reading the dictionary. Now I ask you what year dictionary are you reading? Marinate in that for a second, while I'll be on to the next topic .

[@VIZIONARYxx]

A one sided interview.

[@Justice55339h]

That's an interesting perspective you guys keep pushing in the comments here because ALL we Americans hear nowadays in msm, the schools and Hollywood is a racist one sided view that brutally demonizes the majority of Americans, our ancestors, and America itself. We rarely hear another side and when we do, this is the response? Refute his claims, with facts and arguments, don't just make meaningless blanket statements like this that try to shut people you disagree with down/try to silence us.

[@peterjohnson1734]

Sort of like what goes on in college campuses and MSNBC, CNN, etc.

[@VIZIONARYxx]

@peterjohnson1734 yes and 2 wrongs do not make a right.

[@peterjohnson1734]

@@VIZIONARYxx It wasn't a debate, it was an interview. Every interview doesn't have to be adversarial.

[@VIZIONARYxx]

@peterjohnson1734 oh okay I didn't realize that at all 😀 No matter what it is a one sided view.

[@makeitcount179]

":We have an advocate with God the Father : Jesus Christ the Righteous" 1 John 2:1

[@ggpmf]

Didn't watch but the whole world is living on stolen land.

[@yellahair87]

Wow… very disappointing interview… especially if you’re going to be talking about another race, maybe you should’ve considered having someone of that race included… very limited views considering history is usually written by the victors & most of Native American history was oral… the whole thing about Natives getting so much money & being so protected by the law is so laughable considering most Natives never get that money since it’s tied up in litigation & they live in some of the poorest conditions, there’s people on my reservation that still don’t have electricity or running water to their houses. There’s also a myth that Natives don’t pay taxes & get lots of money from casinos which is totally false. Crimes that happen on Native land hardly get prosecuted because the US govt makes it super complicated for anything to be done. People wanna act like all these bad things happened hundreds of years ago when it was my parents generation that were sent to boarding schools & stripped of their native identity & languages & culture from people who had no love of God in them which is why a lot of Natives of my generation have a resistance against Christianity now. Yes, history is complicated, but it’s not right to try to whitewash it to make it seem like it doesn’t matter when Native peoples are still suffering from the consequences of colonialism to this day.

[@AldiAldiFPen]

You are speaking nothing but the truth. They will sit up there and arrogantly talk about another race, when they can't even speak their language. On top of it Killers of the Flower Moon was just released. I guarantee you neither one of these white people where aware of that atrocity. It is enough to make your blood boil.

[@Gloman-cv2qj]

Some land was stolen & some wasn’t? Then why couldn’t the criminals just stay in the part of the land that “wasn’t stolen?”

[@ruthjackson1343]

I'm sorry your parents had to be forced to go to school. I've been on a Native American reservation before, and it was sad that so many people are living in such depression, and no one had any hope for the future. Even the kids had no aspirations. All they saw was murder and evil, it seemed. A lot of people had kids and then left their kids on the reservation or went to jail. So sad. Every culture and people group needs Jesus, and there's no way around it. Only He can make a way to heal the hurt. Because we can't change history, and being mad at each other won't make things better. We need true, workable solutions. And more hate toward any people group, whites or otherwise, isn't going to help. The best thing we can do is pray for the current circumstances and people involved, that the government would truly take Native Americans needs seriously. Because, from what I saw, it seemed like Native Americans were being compensated and given no hope or reason to actually start their own businesses and create wealth that would bless their people. All I saw were two Casinos and trailers overflowing with stuff people didn't actually need. Take away people's motivation for productive work, and you get a people given to all the things that will destroy them.

[@user-hg6pq3rg9z]

The europeans that came to this country fought the natives and won. The natives lost their land and now they cry and want their land back? It doesn't belong to them its our land not theirs.I am not going to feel sorry for a defeated people group. Its our land. So stop whining and grow up.

[@hglundahl]

36:15 sth I'm especially horrified at this wokeness targetting Karl May, who was in fact one of the pionneers for romanticising Indians as different but not bad to the point of glossing over what sometimes legitimately was bad. A German in 1912, when he died, would associate Apaches with the (Protestant) Christian Winnetou rather than with the pretty cruel Geronimo.

[@BigGodLife]

Truth matters along with facts. We're only privy to a part of that. What causes racism is when we're told or taught the injustices to a portion of a group by certain peoples of another. It doesn't always tell the whole story or even the facts of that period. Racism is propagated by those specific people groups that have been wronged. What believers should remember and remind ourselves is that human nature is corrupt. All of us were born under the same sin. The majority will not want truth and therefore will perish. We can't make reparations for wrongs done to anyone from the past. As Christians we are to make disciples, aka preach the gospel to all nations. This is not our home. There will be a new Heaven and new earth wherein lies righteousness. Our hope is in that and to love one another. I have experienced prejudice, and it's hurtful and painful. I don't want to minimize anyone's pain from just being a different race. As Christians when we can forgive and be changed God does remove the hurt, because we see how injust and corrupt the world really is. That I includes all races. We however will be accountable for our words and deeds. Let's not let the world keep us from Gods plan. He is our vindicator. And believe me, white, black, yellow, red; if you offend or defile any of Gods children, He will pay back. That is the side you don't want to be on. I will say one more thing.. I'm very grateful to be an American. God shed His grace on thee. 🇺🇸

[@L0vejenjen]

amen

[@AldiAldiFPen]

You said, "We can't make reparations for wrongs done to anyone from the past." Oh yes we can. And, I do not have to go back to enslavement to justify it. What kind of depraved country puts Black soldiers on the frontline to risk their lives during World War II and then denies them the G.I. Bill when over 1 million of them return home.... Yet, you can say with a straight face Blacks do not deserve reparations. Trying to hope those World War II veterans die off is not going to work, the bill will simply get higher. If that is not enough for you check into the history of Freedman's Savings Bank. This is not even a drop in the bucket of the foul things this nation has done to Blacks post enslavement. Then you also said this, "Racism is propagated by those specific people groups that have been wronged." 😠 This is the equivalent of you were assaulted because of the short skirt you wore. Blacks endured Transatlantic enslavement. Indians endured the British Raj. The Chinese endured the Opium Wars Propagated racism...... You could not be more wrong. If anything you should be thanking these people for the level of forgiveness they have displayed.

[@brethagan798]

At the end of the day America was founded on Judeo-Christian values and we have certainly been blessed by God. God allows nations and people to rise and fall. Go take it up with Him about who should own this land as it is ultimately His anyway. I will also say that the world would be drastically different today had America never been discovered and settled.

[@thorpeaaron1110]

Judeo-Christian is an oxymoron and America wasn't discovered people were already living here.

[@AldiAldiFPen]

The world would probably be at least 500 years into the future if america was never discovered. America's philosophy is the entire world must suffer so we may benefit.🙄

[@Justice55339h]

Exactly, amen.

[@Justice55339h]

​@@thorpeaaron1110discovered by Christians is what people mean when they say that dear

[@damoab1909]

Hahahhahaha a white man who is some random expert Allie B giving a white perspective from White books and white accounts of what happened 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@Justice55339h]

Racist much?

[@asagehopkins]

What is a “white perspective?”

[@BrennanWayneLuther]

Get that white language out your mouth then

[@petermeents16]

I wish the commenters would read the man's book. It is well-researched and well-documented, and not so one-sided as many of them seem to think. He can hardly cover all aspects of the topic in a thirty minute interview. Read his book, then make your judgement about whether he has handled the subject fairly.

[@Klm242]

Interesting that I have an uncle that married a Cherokee lady.. Beautifulby the way.

[@jan.2780]

a bit hard watching 2 white people talk about how white people aren’t that bad 😅

[@kelriden1991]

You are so pretty and smart Allie.

[@carlafairbanks8983]

😞

[@Ottorockz]

😂 Allie- " History is not binary"...you mean history is trans?🤔😖😆

[@toriferguson5]

So much misinformation smh

[@Justice55339h]

Prove it, go ahead. Enough with your condescending lame controlling terms🙄 It's lazy and insufficient. Prove your claims

[@peterjohnson1734]

Keep shaking your head, maybe you'll purge yourself of years of indoctrination.

[@BrennanWayneLuther]

Maybe if you shake it hard enough you’ll shake the bullshit out of it.

[@allengill8473]

Wow, you are so incorrect...native Americans were not pure as the wind driven snow and as this historian states, the history is complicated.

[@lorrainemagarian2677]

On the first Thanksgiving, didn't the pilgrims lure the Indians to the gathering only to slaughter them?

[@rstroh2105]

no. please read "Of Plymouth Plantation."

[@Justice55339h]

They had an alliance with the local Native American tribe near them because those Native Americans needed protection from another nearby tribe trying to take them out. Some Pilgrims helped their local Native American tribe they had alliance with take out the chief of the enemy tribe. For which he was condemned by his pastor by letter, who was back in England. Even though it was defense. Narive Amwricans were offen warring with each other and enslaving each other, which is why they could never create the strong unified nation we did here that many of them now benefit from. That was not Thanksgiving. Thanksgiving was the happy feast the Pilgrims had with the locam Native American tribe who they had an alliance with them who taught them how to grow corn and how to survive, after half the Pilgrims had died in the first harsh New England winter. It's about gratitude for God saving their lives and blessing our country with bounty, peace and togetherness 💜