The Ultimate Whiskey Wish List - According to Drew P

[@kindlee3468]

Mine would be MIC DROP the absolute 1st bottle... 💕

[@davidlittle6621]

WLW, Michter 20, Pappy 15, Old Carter

[@SouthernSon100]

Just subscribed. Keep it neat!!! Love the list

[@Theplaymaker1271]

1. AH Hirsch 1974 16 year 2. Willet Family Estate 14 year bourbon (or any Willet Family Estate bottles 8+ years) 3. JD Sinatra Century

[@scottjorgensen6743]

Nice work w all these videos. Watched tonight w New Riff. Congrats! Dr. J

[@DrewPWhiskey]

👊

[@toshibake]

Solid list and a lot of great bottles! Would love a 12 year Very Very Old Fitz Gold Vein. I have one bottle from your list - 2016 Michters 20. Bought it in December, I plan to drink it but haven’t had a life event that warrants popping that bottle yet. Heard amazing things about it so excited to try it when I eventually open it!

[@DrewPWhiskey]

That’s amazing! Good for you. I hope it lives up to the hype.

[@toshibake]

@@DrewPWhiskey thanks man!🤞Cheers and hope you can find some of those bottles on your list! Hadn't heard of it before your video, that dusty Eagle Rare sounds amazing!

[@joshcastonguay8899]

I was lucky enough to have a sample pour of the Chessman, keep searching it is definitely worth it.

[@fredfebbriello023]

I’m in the exact same boat as Tom Lynch. I think I’m just too inexperienced to offer much deep insight. My one that I continue to look for (to no avail) is Stagg Jr. I just started this whiskey journey late last summer and participated in a bourbon tasting with a friend for charity. The last sample was Stagg Jr. It was like fireworks went off in my mouth. Where my tasting abilities are today are light years from just then. But yet that whiskey still escapes me...lol. Fantastic perspective as always, Drew. Thanks so much!!

[@ryanfinney5054]

What a great list! Thanks for sharing

[@randys5202]

Great video and awesome list! Right now my number 1 want is Four Roses LE. Have really been liking Four Roses lately

[@arbeckWA]

1) William Heaven Hill 12 year. I had the 11 year bottled in bond and at the time it was the best thing I've ever tasted. 2) Four Roses Al Young. I've never had this, or any other Four Roses LE. When I come across a Four Roses Single Barrel Cask Strength, they are usually things I love so I imagine this would follow suit. 3) A Stitzel-Weller Pappy Van Winkle 15 year. I was able to try it once at a restaurant and loved it. I've tasted the modern 15, 20 and Lot B and think the 15 is the best. 4) A 15 year age stated Noah's Mill. I tried this at a weird whiskey festival I happened to run into at a hotel I was staying at once. I was fairly early in my Bourbon journey and this was by far the best thing I'd ever had. Was it really that good? I don't know. How does it compare to the Noah's Mill that is out now that is just ok? Again I don't know. But I'd love to find out. 5) Kentucky Owl Batch 1 Rye. I have the batch 2 and the batch 3 and they are probably both in my top 5 of favorite bottles I own. I've never seen the batch 1 in person and don't expect I ever will. I'd probably pull the trigger on anything less than $300. 6) A National Distillers Old Grand Dad 114. This was my daily for a long time. Old Grand Dad 86 was the first bourbon I bought and enjoyed. I would love to taste what it was like from National Distillers. 7) King of Kentucky. Brown-Forman is probably my current favorite profile. If I'm drink a cheap bottle, it's likely Early Times BiB or Old Forester 100. Old Forester 1920 is probably my current favorite pour when you factor in price/availability/quality. If I'm at a shitty bar, I know I can almost always get a Woodford. Everyone who's ever had this goes nuts for it. The idea of a barrel proof with the Early Times Mashbill is intriguing. I also know I'll never get one.

[@ejbsee6081]

Of you have not had the chance yet, try one or three of Middleton's Irish whiskey - Very Rare, Barry Crockett, or Dair Gahleic. Best I have enjoyed is the Middleton's Very Rare 2016

[@mojo88bassandbourbon72]

Old Stagg from 60s my unicorn

[@andrewlowe1265]

Love the Vice Golf hat! Yeah, this is definitely a dreamer’s list. Still early in my Bourbon journey and feel like I learn something new with each of your videos.

[@robertslocum2555]

Also, just realized you remind me of Jon Lajolie

[@TJMcDVM]

Enjoyed the video as always but think it confirmed that I’m still not a collector. I don’t have any specific bottles I want yet just whiskeys I want to try. I’m still at the point where I just a want a 4RSBLE, a Parker’s Heritage, a GTS, a M10 Rye. Any year really.

[@usmcteck2918]

Just bought a sealed wild turkey 101 decanter from 1982. I’m dying to open it is proving to be somewhat difficult. Always wanted a dusty turkey!

[@spencermaddox8230]

Dawg if you see a michters 20 at retail there is no chance you wouldn’t buy it, you’d take out a loan if you had to.

[@nates5880]

I live in Bryan Texas I think that was my Eagle bottle lol

[@kodycecil4854]

Yep, run that! Had to set the reminder 😆

[@rtpqei1]

Awesome list. We got some overlaps. Four roses four ever

[@mikecoleman3433]

I’d get Double Eagle, Very Rare; and Al Young if I could justify spending the money they’d cost!

[@richflinchbaugh1271]

Key question: Which of the bottles you want to own would you actually open and drink?

[@DrewPWhiskey]

I mention that at the end of my vid...

[@richflinchbaugh1271]

@@DrewPWhiskey Yes, you do. You said you would open all of them except the last one.

[@rustymanrustola]

Audio is a little off

[@Schwanda.1]

That Augusta National bottle is incredible. That’s definitely a unicorn of unicorn bottles. If I could pick any bottle to have on the shelf, I’d probably pick 2012 George T Stagg (Bourbon of the Year in the year that I got married). If I could have any bottle to drink, it’d be a Stitzel-Weller Pappy 20.

[@erikevenson4303]

Drew; have you had Balcones yet?

[@DrewPWhiskey]

I’ve only tried their corn whiskey. It was solid.

[@jrhodes109]

Great video Drew! Man I'm a sucker for that Al Young bottle!😍

[@robertslocum2555]

I found a 4 roses small batch 2020 barrel strength release but they're asking $299. Worth it???

[@tfldad]

Great video, Drew! Im still new enough to bourbon & whiskey that I don’t really have any Ultimates. I need to learn more about what I like, try more stuff, and learn about the random unicorns like your list has. Love your list though... interesting blend of baller quality and personal connection.

[@andrewt248]

One thumbs down? Well, I guess not everyone’s into name it and claim it.

[@mikesnook6210]

Didn’t even know that last one was thing! Wow that’s the gold standard... great list. I only have 1 on your list... thankfully my top was Bookers Rye and I spent about 20 months tracking one down. Cheers 🥃

[@joshuamire2721]

I was able to try Michter's Celebration this weekend and it definitely impressed. I'll never be able to buy a bottle but it would definitely be on my unicorn list.

[@scifisoldier]

My pops has been holding down a bottle of orvw10 for about 15 years, he paid $30 for it and said it was the best whiskey he ever drank, same bottle obviously different label, wish i could post a pic of it

[@johnnycampbell3422]

@drew just so you know, the delay between video and audio is problematic to your channel; you might want to look into that. Best Regards

[@mohnjayer]

Being an HH fanboy like yourself, I want to find some of the old pirate bottles of ECBP that were hazmat. I didn’t think that much about them at the time but have since become an absolute sucker for ECBP.

[@TheNemaddux]

Drew, there is a couple Old Crow Chess Piece bourbons for sale near me. Contact me if you would be interested. They are sealed . I thought of you when I saw them. Thanks!

[@mojo88bassandbourbon72]

Ashton Kutcher of whiskey

[@Zkiesel]

Damn fine list!

[@micahmistretta1448]

Do you have a FB group?

[@DrewPWhiskey]

I do not. I’ve thought about it - there’s just so many groups out there already.

[@kodycecil4854]

@@DrewPWhiskey If you build it, they will come. 😂

[@peterwhite507]

Tough list. I still have 1/2 a bottle of FR 125th and an unopened bottle. They were $85 Cad in Ontario when they showed up on the shelf. My favorite Bourbon on any given day. No A.H. Hirsh 16, 19 or Willett single barrels Bourbon/Rye from the early 2000's? A head to head with Booker's Rye vs Red Hook Rye would be a very cool Rye showdown.