What If Yoda Killed Palpatine Part 2 - Star Wars Explained

[@tayetrotman]

I disagree. I personally think that one-Luke would join the other Jedi in the attack, and two, I don't think Vader would bring guards. That's not in his nature, so I reckon together both Yoda and Obi wan would kill Vader, but I don't believe either would die. You see, they could compliment each other. Obi wan used Soresu, and so was slow and didn't have much offensive power, while Yoda used the highly agressive, offensive form of Ataru. Also, Yoda would hit with a barrage of quick and powerful attacks that would tire him at his age, but Obi wan could counter this, using his near unbreakable guard(as he was considered the master of Soresu) to prevent tgem becoming vulnerable when Yoda slowed so he could gain his energy back. Plus, while Obi wan keeps Vader on his toes on the ground, Yoda would pound him from above so Vader would be overwhelmed.

[@a-drewg1716]

i think Luke was still young (like a child young) but i am not certain.

[@beardedbjorn5520]

Luke was only 10 in this timeline. But everything else I think is spot on

[@bobwilson679]

Luke is only like, 10 years old.

[@chiefhardy6312]

Luke is too young. Also, remember that this is a Vader with a much better suit. His powers probably came very close to or even equaled Yoda’s. With the guards, I’m not sure what he would do. He was both fixated with rage, and very competent and smart in battle.

[@oracle372]

@Jason Rasmussen And Palpatine and the clones, so he would have been saved

[@frachris87]

SUGGESTIONS: - What if Yoda was killed in Order 66/The Jedi Purge? - What if Anakin convinced Padme to leave with him on Mustafar? - What if Anakin/Vader was unable to wipe out the entire CIS Leadership at Mustafar? - What if Anakin spared Count Dooku onboard the Invisible Hand? - What if Count Dooku killed Anakin and Obi-Wan during their duel on board the Invisible Hand? - What if Anakin killed Palpatine immediately upon learning that he was Darth Sidious? - What if the whole CIS Leadership (Nemoidians, Dooku, Jango Fett, etc) was killed at the Battle of Geonosis?

[@silverrain530]

frachris87 Yes to all

[@thedanklordofthesith210]

DEW IT

[@grandmasteryoda6687]

I can suggest 2 more videos: What if Obi Wan faced Darth Sidious in Revenge of the sith? What if Yoda faced Anakin on Mustafar?

[@user-pu1rv5ck5b]

Last one

[@Slechy_Lesh]

If Anakin killed Sidious, he would be commended, and be given the seat on the Jedi council he so desired. However, Palpatine had filled a gap in him. His suspicion and even his frustration with them would continue. If I'm not mistaken, Palpatine was implanting the visions of Padme's death, so these would end, leaving him calmer. Yet she would still die in childbirth, something he would now be completely unprepared for. His duties would be cast aside, and the old cracks between him and the Jedi would widen. Without Sidious' corruption, though, I don't see conflict. Rather I see him becoming a wandering, tortured exile. Forever searching for salvation for his perceived failures to save his loved ones, he would even fail his children. He would be looking for a replacement for the guidance of Sidious also, and in the Star Wars galaxy, who knows what someone of his force of will would uncover in his need.

[@BasedWorld690]

What if Mace Windu was allowed to say Motherfucker?

[@DuckingAround]

Ryan Spies lmao i like this one

[@Adam-yumyum]

All Red Gamer "honey where is my super suit? I said where is my motherf****** super suit?"

[@theratking013]

He would be shot by racist space police.

[@milfdominator]

All Red Gamer lol

[@mofstar8683]

Palpating would be able to say, "It's swearing then."

[@tombarnes6923]

I think Vader would've held the Empire completely different. Vader had faith in the force and greatly doubted their tactics. I believe Vader's Empire would not have a Death Star but fleets of Super Star Destroyer and maybe even more. Vader would also create his own order of dark side users, I'm gonna call them the Knights of Ren, basically replacing the Inquisitors because he's not as fearful of force users as the Emperor was. Overall, Vader's Empire would be far more powerful than the old Emperor could imagine.

[@gabrielcarrasco8414]

Not to mention the Death Star while powerful was one big weakness. While well defended would leave the Emperor and Vader vulnerable if the Death Star was destroyed with no means of escape.

[@manatarakona9593]

Plus I'm pretty sure Vader wouldn't be able to be killed by Obi in this scenario.

[@bronsonlukes8190]

Tom Barnes the deathstar was being built before Vader was Vader, so no matter what it's still going to be around

[@tombarnes6923]

Vader would have stopped its construction and put the resources into something more practical, like a fleet of super star destroyers like I said before.

[@manatarakona9593]

Another thing people forget is that Vader never wanted to rule alone. When he had Palps, he was fine with being the enforcer of the Empire. Once he discovered that Luke was his son, he wanted to put forth his plan to continue the Rule of 2. However, he was still conflicted between his loyalty to the man who was like a father to him and his son who be barely knew, which is why he defended the Emperor when Luke retrieved his lightsaber. Bottom line, he didn't care about totalitarian power as much as having someone to rule the galaxy with, so a Death Star is out of the question.

[@EVeljko]

Is there going to be a continuation of this? Something like "What if Luke inherited the Empire"?

[@kaydeholden5552]

Ha so naive *cries in 3 years later*

[@--------352]

@@kaydeholden5552 he is secretly gabe newl

[@omararifpasalic7314]

"They thought that he was General Griveous and that he kiled palpatine and took over."That sounds like a good story

[@achillesjohnson7941]

This video is phenomenal. Please Please please make a part 3!

[@campinatorxbox1610]

Achilles Johnson you took the words right out of my mouth.

[@IEatBears4Breakfast]

Thomas Reagan to right m8

[@thegamingdinosaur7464]

diamond sky9 9 xX

[@fabbyy7253]

There can be no part 3...lol Vader as last embodyment of the darkside is dead, so is yoda. In the end Luke knows the enitre trouth and is most likely willing to become a Jedi, but technically there is no big thread left for the Jedi to fight at that point. As Luke grows up he will turn to his sister Leia. Leia is kinda in love with the idea of democracy and fancys having a senat control the old "empire". Together they will not control what is left of it, but rebuild the structure back to what it was before everything was fucked up. Obi and Luke would later train a group of young Jedi. Eventually Kylo ren would not see the dark side and stay a jedi bla bla comon get creative u can figure it out yourself :D

[@hansyolo8277]

There are other threats than the Sith, though.

[@billiejoebassstudios8511]

what if order 66 was discovered by the jedi in the clone wars.

[@Fernandes.Ferdinando]

billie joe bass studios they already knew about it.... look it up, it's interesting

[@DeepRuffian]

billie joe bass studios what if order 67 was initiated

[@silasguzman6803]

Pewpewboomshot or what if order 69 was XD

[@starfyre59]

What is order 67?

[@DexBunny]

Execution of Palpatine.

[@thecreatorlair]

A classic "What If" scenario. I'd love to see more.

[@mixedmf52]

Yeah they’re my favorite kind of video

[@sverre7676]

Impressive, most impressive!

[@TheStupendousWave]

Thanks!

[@zacharyjones7930]

Sverre Beijer shut it sike nah 😂😂

[@darthslade2802]

The Stupendous Wave what if you were to join the dark side and become my apprentice

[@zacharyjones7930]

Darth Slade no the dark should only be balanced with the light I am an Gray Jedi

[@darthslade2802]

Zachary Jones your arrogance blinds you Grey Jedi

[@Unknown-qv7le]

What if Han Solo didn't agree to take obi-wan and Luke to aldeeran?

[@oobservador4364]

Then the Rebel Alliance would be f*cked, because Luke and Obi-Wan wouldn't have the chance to save Leia.

[@cloroxbleach2961]

Unknown they would find another ship

[@jeffreynewman9801]

Unknown then leia would either give up the information and the rebel alliance would be destroyed or leia would be dead and obi wan would be alive

[@jeffreynewman9801]

Unknown well obi wan would have been alive either way.

[@jon....]

Unknown Jedi mindtrick xD

[@user-vk5vh4mq8k]

Ok Continuing This Storyline What If Vader Killed Yoda And Obi-wan

[@stevenlewis7017]

The Undertale Mashuper he would have won the war

[@aiwowisjdjxjxjxnnana5353]

The end

[@ObservingChristian]

Then Star Wars. Would suck

[@mixedmf52]

66th like

[@sananesananeoglu5055]

Vader cant kill yoda thought

[@rednas3271]

You have some insane writing skills! The description of the lightsabers are masterfull!

[@TheStupendousWave]

Thanks so much!

[@rednas3271]

The Stupendous Wave No problem! I'm an aspiring writer myself, and your stuff is very inspirational!

[@brentkirkland3597]

The Stupendous Wave what if the clones never existed?

[@zacharyjones7930]

RangerElite34 already seen a vid on that

[@shadowninja958]

Rednas yes he is quite skilled

[@DontpushtheBbutton]

What if R2D2 was shot and destroyed as well in The Phantom Menace?

[@PetraRocks100]

Several of our heroes would be screwed I think. Some people might underestimate how important R2D2 has been, but he's seriously saved the day multiple times throughout all the movies. Not even kidding lol, could be an interesting topic actually

[@DontpushtheBbutton]

Randomstuff Exactly my point. And I also think R2 can not be replaced by any other droid. I mean, they have personalities in the Star Wars universe. You can't replace personality (can you? D: ).

[@Jessie_Helms]

Don't push the B button actually that could be good- he wasn't the average R2 unit, he had modification

[@PetraRocks100]

I could be wrong about this, but I think in star wars the way it supposedly works is that if a droid goes for a longer period of time without having it memory wiped they can develop character and personality traits. As far as I know R2 never had his memory wiped once during all those years from episode I to VI, so not only does he remember everything that has happened and potentially learned from those experiences, but as we can clearly see he develops quite the personality over the years.

[@randomizer8757]

That's actually a really good idea.

[@zachfinlayson1457]

it would be interesting to see a part three on this, going over Luke's reaction to not only the new of his master's death, but the news that his father was emperor Vader and he the heir.

[@steveyaged4462]

What if Obi Wan and Anakin switched fates, Obi Wan as a cyborg etc. with Padme living

[@ashc4167]

Steve Yaged That would be bad sadly. It would be a weaker version of Dooku.

[@Phoenixesper1]

What if Shmi was a brothel madem and had 30 john children? What if Anakin was born with only 1 pinky? What if Qui Gon Gin was bald? What if yoda had spent his long life jerking off swamp squirrels in his hut? These and many more questions remain unanswered!

[@fusiontoa18]

wtf..

[@pixel7020]

You know, I thought of that a while after you made this comment. So, shit I look like a copier now lol

[@rhuttner12]

What if Anakin killed Obi Wan while Obi-Wan was under disguise as Rako Hardeen?

[@gabrgarc7428]

rhuttner12 This is a good one

[@shaygarden9831]

rhuttner12 Rako Hardeen?

[@gabrgarc7428]

shannon garvey He's a character that came out in the Clone Wars cartoon show

[@RevCuck]

+shannon garvey clone wars show, season 4

[@zacharyjones7930]

rhuttner12 😂😂😂😂

[@lakenash7947]

If yoda killed palpatine then he would have never found Vader and Vader would have never been given his cybernetics. He would have died on mustafar because of his injuries.

[@alieninthevideo441]

KZbin Hero, His anger would keep him alive and he would also be called Darth Nubz.

[@rashmipatel5471]

Mad Ammeda would find him

[@SonGoku-bn5di]

Jason Rasmussen THE EMPEROR TOLD THE GUARDS

[@rafterscott]

Hey man, just wanted to say thanks for the time & effort you put in on these. I love the what if stories you've been doing and hope they don't stop anytime soon. Thanks for all the great work!

[@TheStupendousWave]

Thanks so much for your comment and for watching in the first place!

[@DemiosGaming]

+The Stupendous Wave do what if darth plaugise survived

[@lordblackheart6270]

The Stupendous Wave hey man, just wanna give my thanks on the video's you upload on these Star Wars stuff is so cool & so radical of being a smart guy on it's history of how it all started & how the character's lives started off, you're a smart guy & I love watching your videos on each one you make & upload is so cool 👍😏😁😄😃👌

[@BigMac8000]

I really like this but I think there's one issue. Vader is always prophesized to be the one to bring balance to the force. That's his role. By dying and killing yoda, he leaves only Obi Wan, Luke and Leia. The weight's shifted towards the light. I think if Vader had put all his resources towards finding Luke and Leia, he would have likely found one of them. Most likely Leia - having done so, I think he would have taken her under his wing as a Sith even at such a young age, training her in the dark, though she'd play no part in the final duel and would most likely be hidden away from Obi Wan and Yoda completely. The fight size-up was great, but I think the soldiers would eventually have destroyed Obi-wan on the Death Star. Their assassination attempt would succeed, but it'd be a suicide mission. Regardless if Vader was alive or dead, the entire death star's force would be there trying to kill the jedi, and aged they can only do so much. In the normal continuity they escape using stealth - but once that cover is blown, they would eventually succumb. I also think Obi-wan might be the one chosen to duel Vader, having beaten him before. Yoda, while more powerful, would recognize his age to be the major deterrent - and yoda's more capable of fighting groups and assisting while Obi-wan's impeccable defense would cause Vader to tire, his cybernetics only sustaining his onslaught for so long. It makes more sense to me that Yoda would defend against the onslaught of soldiers and then using his immense force powers rather than duel, having possibly gained more mastery in it to offset his saber forms loss. I can imagine Yoda crushing entire hallways to deter reinforcements. Meanwhile, the campaign against vader would've soaked much of yoda's and obi-wan's time, and while they might be aware of force-ghosts, they would have turned their back against it for the sake of the galaxy. In the original continuity they had no hope of taking out Vader / Palpatine together, so they instead turned to the force. In this continuity they would've most certainly been forced to neglected this, leaving only Luke, and Leia, without guidance and with only the basic principles of both orders - with one caveat. Qui-gon Jinn would still be there as a force ghost, and his guidance would extend to both students equally. Qui-gon, having witnessed what happened with the Chosen one, would try to teach them both in the ways of the living force, hoping that they could find a way to co-exist - though I suspect again, he would fail as much as he succeeds. Luke and Leia, light and dark, and both heirs to the empire, with a morally dubious Jedi left to coerce them. Leia may resume control of the empire, seizing sith texts and holocrons, two emperor's notes and machinations, and luke would be left with the ghost of Qui-gon Jinn, just a disembodied voice. I do love this size-up though, don't mistake the long text as disagreement. I think there's a lot of gold here. Especially with Vader having top-notch cybernetics and his new combined use of force abilities.

[@XTeam49]

BigMac8000 but thats the thing, the jedi werent really sure if anakin was the chosen one. But then Luke came, he broughr back anakin and killed vader (mentally) who then killed sidious so Luke have always been the chosen one.

[@DatMentalGamer]

@@XTeam49 i think both are imo

[@amotz561]

@@XTeam49 Nope, Anakin is and always has been the chosen one (excluding the dumb sequels)

[@johnpauldriskill8737]

But George always said bringing balance to the force was the light side. I know it’s an old comment but I wanted to say that.

[@Ka0sNinja117]

With events changing where they did in your story, I had hoped you would include Mace Windu's vaapad against Vader. THAT would be an amazing duel! Nonetheless, good stuff!

[@thau8316]

Wouldn't vader find out about Padme's death considering it was very public

[@raw6668]

What if Ahoska or the other Jedi from Rebels was around to train Luke when he joined the Rebellion? Would his skills set change? Would Vader be more concerned about Luke, especially if it was his former apprentice was training him? If it was Ahoska, would she tell Luke the truth about his father? Would Luke be just as skilled as he was when he faced Vader in the Second Death Star when he faced him in Bespin? Would he be stronger and more powerful when he face Emperor for the first time? Would Leia also be trained, assuming the Jedi could feel the link between the two twins?

[@NinjaTyler]

raw666 I'd imagine he'd be much stronger in both the force and especially saber combat, he received almost no formal training with his blade outside of texts and only had little training with Yoda in using the force, with proper guidance he'd be easily a real match and threat to Vader. luke is the most powerful Jedi ever after all.

[@zacharyjones7930]

raw666 Luke would be bad completely unstoppable

[@darthtroller]

more like what if Bail Organs revealed the existence of the twins to Ahsoka, then he would see the woman he recruited training his adopted daughter Leia, but Owen Lars would not agree to let Obi Wan train Luke, so Leia would be sent to fight off Vader, the Lars would survive, Luke would remain on Tatooine with Obi Wan secretly protecting him during his exile, Vader would be no match to both Ahsoka and Leia, and Yoda would be like hmmm, easy it was for us, me the Grand Master, they did not need, so Yoda calls Ahsoka and Leia through the Force, they come and see him on Dagobah where they together train to fight Emperor Palpatine who ran out of apprentices, so he promotes Mara Jade to apprentice as he ran out of Inquisitors, and as I forgot to mention, Vader would be recruited not killed, so Anakin, his daughter and his old apprentice go fight the Emperor and Darth Jade, Ahsoka would defeat Mara and the Skywalkers outmatch the Emperor, then Ahsoka tells the Rebels not to destroy Death Star 2, Vader himself tells the Empire the Emperor has been assassinated by the Jedi, so Vader goes and gets all Imperial plans, he discovers Sidious' cloning process, destroys the Palpatine clones and instead puts himself to become a fully body recovered Anakin as the Rebels would execute him if he were the robotic monster they previously encountered, then he goes and introduces himself to Luke telling him he survived, being held captive by Vader, and he also tells the Lars he thanks them for raising Luke, but Luke stays with them, he would also meet Obi Wan again and thanking him for protecting his son, Anakin still won't reveal his identity, he would start the new Jedi order, with Leia and Ahsoka on the Jedi Council, Ahsoka also being master of the order, she takes the role of Windu, Kanan would be part of the Jedi, with Leia on Malachor, Maul would be killed and this would cause Ezra not to fall to the dark side, Luke however isn't a Jedi, Leia doesn't meet Han Solo cuz Obi Wan and Luke didn't go to join the Rebels so there's no Ben Solo / Kylo Ren, Snoke would remain with the Knights of Ren and him being their master, he would tell them Vader betrayed them and was indeed Anakin, and they would try to bring this rumor everywhere, I don't think Benicio Del Toro's character Von would be Snoke's apprentice, Anakin would be a great match for Snoke, Snoke would himself find Rey and make of her his greatest apprentice, I believe Rey is a test experiment to create a female Palpatine by Snoke, so this would mean Rey won't be that powerful since Anakin destroyed the Palpatine clone project, so Rey would be something else, less powerful, now moving on, we know Yoda died, Obi Wan, Kanan, Leia, Ahsoka, Ezra, they are all in the Jedi council, Grans Master Anakin Skywalker is leading, Snoke would go to Tatooine, kill the Lars and capture Luke, torture him and make of him his apprentice, then we have Luke having to deal with his father and sister, with the help of Rey and Snoke, the Knights of Ren, but unfortunately for Snoke, the Jedi would remain victorious with sadly Luke being killed

[@vaderknight3217]

OMG, this should be a video by itself. I really enjoyed it. Thanks for sharing your idea :D

[@raw6668]

To Robo_Destroyer, That is assuming that Bail would allow Leia to be a Jedi. I assume in fact he got attached and not had her train in fear the Empire would kill her if she trained like a Jedi, otherwise she would have been trained earlier that their be two Jedi instead of one in Return of the Jedi, or Jedis in that case.

[@indylover3]

What if Jar Jar Binks was a member of the sith the entire time

[@Elyseon]

What do you mean "if"?

[@vice166]

He was

[@SonGoku-bn5di]

Elyseon Exactly

[@SonGoku-bn5di]

Jar Jar was the one who created the dark side.

[@--------352]

He was suppost to

[@fernandozubillagasuarez7749]

Do a part 3 like for the stupendous wave to see it

[@teamsteamgamers7274]

yessss

[@Jake-li4te]

I want part 3 too

[@DeathWatch-jh3yx]

Please do what if order 66 was discovered by the Jedi in the clone wars and What if Jango Fett survived the battle of Geonosis!

[@troyc2390]

Emanuel Montalvo like someone said earlier in the comments order 66 was somewhat discovered but I like the jango

[@DeathWatch-jh3yx]

Troy C Thanks But it was not completely discovered. It was almost discovered several times but it didn't happen.

[@troyc2390]

True

[@mwaryan1998]

Order 66 was an order already known and made just in case something bazar happened. In fact order 67 is one for the clones to kill pallpatine

[@ihatetobethatguybut7175]

Order 65*

[@XTeam49]

The fight you narrated in the first part was just amazing, real movie material!

[@jonsmith1149]

This is the best Star Wars explained I've seen yet! Nice job!

[@TheStupendousWave]

Thanks so much!

[@logandonajkowski155]

The Stupendous Wave I like how real this could be

[@writers_journal9615]

The Stupendous Wave do a part 3 pls

[@therishimazefanatic1439]

What if "The rule of two never existed"

[@fireguy3217]

Carlton Watkins Then the sith empire would still exist.

[@MrRoyerp]

In the expanded universe series with Abeloth, there is an entire planet of Sith. They call themselves the "lost tribe." they had been stranded on that planet for thousands of years and they do not adhere to the rule of two. It's pretty cool stuff you should check itout

[@guyknightley3499]

I don't know about that they were always at war with one another even when they were fighting the Jedi

[@MrRoyerp]

Matthew Sowers Totally! they were expected to betray each other; even kill their own family and masters for advancement. Its the way of the Sith.

[@62cky4powerthirst]

Depends, the whole reason why the rule of 2 existed was because of how too many sith was causing weakness. Why bother to train to become as strong as my master when you can team up with me, we both kill him, I get promoted to master, then we do the same to yours? I think there would be more sith: but a millenia of infighting would weaken them drastically.

[@connor4435]

I love how Yoda was just like “a bitch you are” “caught you sword I have

[@peacemaker2019]

"I've been looking forward to this"

[@HANSE658]

What if the rebellion didn't destroy the death star

[@Phoenixesper1]

umm i believe the answer would have been.... "Pew.... BOOM!" End of the rebellion.... Roll credits.

[@Deathlygunn]

Yavin IV would have been destroyed, Han and Chewie would go back to being smugglers in the hopes of paying off Jabba, while Luke would begin to give into his hate for Vader, the man Luke would see as responsible for killing Kenobi, Leia, Biggs, Threepio, Artoo, etc...

[@nicelytroublefield9426]

HANSE658 the rebellion would vastly weaker. But they still have Mon Calamari as a ship producing planet

[@dallas1303]

there is already a video about that at Mr. Sunday Movie's channel, well he's talking about the comic in which the death Star didn't blow up

[@daylondog]

I love listening to your stories because it's like listening to an E-book about a well written star wars novel. I don't agree with some things when I listen but you have a real talent.

[@285wilson]

I disagree in all but one aspect. Galen Marick. Vader wouldn't have continued on alone upon his master's defeat he would have taken up an apprentice to help him maintain control over the Empire and to keep the rule of two alive the only two things keeping him connected to his former master. in turn Yoda and Obi-Wan would never have attacked so soon instead mustering up the combined force of Kanan Jarrus, Ahsoka Tano, Ezra Bridger, Luke and Leia Skywalker and Quinlan Voz for an overwhelming victory for the Jedi.

[@lightingwarr02]

285wilson starkiller ain't canon

[@tickleisweeb]

⚠️Spoilers!⚠️ Ahsoka Tano and Kanan Jarrus (Caleb Dume) die in Star Wars Rebels.

[@theoneeyedking6801]

I have some ideas : 1 - What if Darth Maul died during his fight with Obi-Wan? 2 - What if light whips were more common in the Jedi? 3 - What if Savage Opress Didn't die?

[@mastamizclix42]

1 - nothing much 2 - a whip is a fairly agressive weapon, it doesn't match their ideology 3 - sauvage was all about using force-empowered strikes, but had no real finesse, or real skil; he would've been killed by some other character eventually. He might've killed some more jedi though, as only really experienced fighters knew how to deal with his massive brute strength (eg dooku and sidious very easily beat him).

[@theoneeyedking6801]

Masta MizClix Fair Point

[@theoneeyedking6801]

Swaggy Mc.Daddy Actually he didn't die, watch the clone wars

[@chase6790]

Wasn't just in TCW. He survived in the comics as well. If he died, then much of Sidious' plans would have changed. I think if lightwips were more common, the Jedi would have then focused more on weaponry than they did the Force thus making them more militaristic which, in theory, could change a lot of things... imo. Thirdly, I think if Savage hadn't died then Maul would have made more of a comeback.. it would increase Maul's influence and Mother Talzin and the Nightsister's as well. That'd make them a more powerful force and that also would change a lot of things. Good questions. :) These answers are all my opinions so there's no way to say for sure but I feel pretty confident it would follow these templates.

[@chase6790]

I would normally have said pretty much what @MastaMizClix said since Star Wars never really left room for these options to be realistically considered but your questions were "what-ifs." Hope this helped.

[@Will-uv7nm]

These were some of the best what ifs yet. Good job

[@galarianmike283]

Brilliant video once again!

[@TheStupendousWave]

Thanks!

[@deltahunter4810]

do what if ashoke stayed in the order and was in the temple when order 66 went down and she and vader fought each other, or at least the first two parts of my suggestion please. P.S huge fan btw :)

[@pout6038]

where are all the other "part 2"s ?

[@nasirfrancillon4440]

Deltahunter he did

[@BenjaVOM]

Amazing video! Here are my suggestions for a what if: What if Obi-Wan was killed in his duel with Anakin on Mustafar What if Plo Koon, Ki-Adi Mundi and Aayla Secura survived Order 66

[@randomnoob9630]

Ben the Pugmaster he already made a vid on the first one0

[@BenjaVOM]

oooooh..... haven't seen that one yet, thanks for telling me

[@dcmasterrob5347]

The yoda intro with the stick tapping gave me chills

[@locomotivefaox]

He forgot that Vader' armour was light saver resistant and with the best materials available it'd be nearly impossible to cut through it so any explanation?

[@chocolaterain5097]

datguyscout obi wan hit him right in the neck, severing his head. The plating would not be think enough in the neck area.

[@StormWalden]

I thought the same thing - if Hypothetical-Vader's armor would be made of the best materials, that would include a high-level of lightsaber resistance designed into it, since the only real threats to his person (Jedi & other Sith) tend to use lightsabers as their preferred primary weapons. Both Phrik (see starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Phrik) and Cortosis (see starwars.wikia.com/wiki/Cortosis) were not overly rare, and would have been available for this purpose in sufficient quantities for a single suit of armor. As such, IMO, Hypothetical-Vader's improved armor would have included a full-coverage Prhik-infused lamé-like underlayer (that is, a cloth layer with strands of Phrik woven into it), Cortosis- and Phrik-infused lamé-like mid-layers, and Cortosis-infused/coated outer layers (both lamé-like cloth and power-coated plating) to maximize lightsaber resistance (with the Cortosis also having the added bonus of negating the effects of blaster fire, as with Denetrius Vidian's Cortosis mesh). Thoughts?

[@realjoobkoob]

There was only 1 material in the galaxy that could resist lightsabers, which is Zillo beast hide.

[@StormWalden]

Phrik, Cortosis, and Mandalorian Iron (aka Beskar) are all stated to be resistant to lightsaber attacks.

[@fusiontoa18]

agreed and galen marek once force pushed vader trougth walls too and his cybernetics where fine. not to mention that bullshit ending, vader would have noticed obiwan

[@sentiuntreus]

What if General Gracious killed Obi-Wan during their final battle

[@sentiuntreus]

*Grevious

[@mastamizclix42]

general gracious rofl xD

[@sentiuntreus]

Masta MizClix Why I love auto correct xd

[@sentiuntreus]

Masta MizClix *XD

[@mastamizclix42]

Derp Person it's grievous btw :)

[@SneeringBull905]

This is cool. Could you do a video request?What if in Star Wars the Sith were actually nice? If the Sith didn't go out of their way to treat people badly in their conquests while they built up the Empire, what would it look like? How would the Sith be percieved? What would the Star Wars universe look like if the roles of the Jedi and Sith were reversed? Where the Jedi were the bad guys and the Sith were the good guys? How would the messages in the franchise about the Jedi, Sith, and the Force be different? That I'd think would be interesting to speculate on.

[@itsnotamankey]

Why don't force users just use the force more than a lighsaber in a fight?

[@tehKap0w]

flashy laser swords look cooler. Seriously, that's about it.

[@pokefan3967]

jedi and sith use lightsabers just incase the oponent is carring a lightsaber or a laser connon as the force cant block energy or plasma and basicly everyone as blasters in this time peried

[@WhitzWolf92]

Actually the Force *can* block those things, like Vader did in Empire Strikes Back, but probably not as easily as a lightsaber.

[@dariomatas788]

Little E oh i didnt relise u write using force more at first somehow i thought u writ use force onlyi well most of my coment still make some sens so i leave it 😎😅

[@StevePalpy]

Most force users create a force barrier around them so other force powers cannot really touch them during a saber fight

[@Gamer1990100]

What if Luke never joined the Rebels?

[@mikebagaglia405]

John Smith story over no Star Wars

[@lukemorosini4]

Well their would still a story but the Rebels would likely lose and the Empires rule would likely continue. It definately wouldn't be the type of story most people like where good always wins over evil though anymore in my opinion.

[@philthephilosopher9235]

What if the Empire was ruled by a Jedi?

[@joshtrimmer3121]

it would be really awesome if these what if stories were turned into comics

[@joshtrimmer3121]

love the stories

[@Josh_Suarez]

do what if the rebels lost the battle of endor

[@Phoenixesper1]

What if the ewoks were bald? What if the death star were orange? What if emperor palpatine could only shot force lightning through his anus? What if han solo shot himself first? These and many questions are left unanswered!

[@javiercordova6158]

Phoenixesper1 This is the best comment I have seen today 😂

[@angelinawang4866]

Picture This Entertainment qa

[@thedarklordreturns990]

orange death star is really interesting topic though

[@matthewgoodson9275]

I appreciate your creativity in making these.

[@ganeshapartners]

What if padme had survived child labor?

[@andrewgeorge4304]

What if the Executor successfully captured the Millenium Falcon with the tractor beam in ESB, assuming the Falcon's hyperdrive wasn't fixed in time?

[@jrozzzify]

Recently came across your channel. Love your vids. Iv'e always wondered what would have happened if Anakin left the order & trained as a Grey Jedi. I really empathize with his turn to the dark as the council completely failed him. Constantly giving him horrible advice and putting way too much pressure on him.

[@davidg4612]

What if Padme survived the birth? Great video!

[@mastamizclix42]

actually, she did survive, she died because she "lost the will to live". died of a broken heart and all that nonsense :p

[@davidg4612]

Masta MizClix True, I meant the practical way though

[@mastamizclix42]

Lazarus Project I think it's likely vader would've found her eventually, which would be exactly why she wouldn't have been able to keep her children

[@charleslee8313]

I thought it was because the Emperor used the Force to siphon her energy into Vader

[@jakepasseri5137]

Lazarus Project there's a video about this topic by another KZbinr

[@LegacyMMXXIV]

501st comment

[@diggs5142]

Star Wars Legacy i really like ur mod

[@dagame1231]

Star Wars Legacy nice reference if you didn't mean it lel

[@panafricanmarxist7632]

Star Wars Legacy the 501 legion to all those who don't know

[@jeffytvideos8565]

Star Wars Legacy wow.

[@doughboyalex]

These "what if's" are amazing dude. Keep up the awesome work 👍

[@seanbhoycfc4834]

What if Luke Joined Vader in ESB and Yoda sought out Leia as their last hope

[@SnorkyO]

I think it's been done

[@ColinsScienceProject]

What if Order 66 was largely unsuccessful? I imagine a different timeline where the shift in the force would alert the jedi of the coming betrayal, allowing many to defend themselves against the clone troopers. Vader and the 501st would still storm the jedi temple, but this time most of the entire Grand Council is there, prepared to face the fallen friend

[@thepotato2030]

He has done this...

[@revan6614]

Damn I always wanted a fight between Yoda and Anakin and I wasn't disappointed.

[@szymonsikorski5682]

what if Leia went with obi wan and Luke went with Bale organa

[@KingExituS]

Then TFA would have been the exact copy of A new hope!

[@szymonsikorski5682]

Ur right 👍

[@Xile257]

Brilliant, simply brilliant! I loved this ending to our newest What If video, and honestly I was begging for more. You should really join the Star Wars writing team, haha. Anyways, amazing work; if I could subscribe more than once I really would.

[@TheStupendousWave]

Thank you so much!

[@mazareen]

Another captivating tale, you are doing a great job with these.

[@CitizenDuarte]

What if Luke and Leia were never born?

[@Stellarionas]

What if Anakin used condoms?

[@jamainegardner4193]

CouchPotato Assajj was dead before episode 3. Palatine would've killed Padme and the galaxy is screwed

[@aikenumholtz3539]

Superb video, stupendous even. Loved it

[@BTC_DNA]

Great job, SW. Both creative and consistent w/ the characters.

[@tariffictypist7372]

Question: Wouldn't Luke be only Ten years old at this time.

[@orcho141]

what about if the ship "invisible hand" was destroyed, containing; palpatine, dooku, grievous, obi-wan, anakin and r2

[@nicolastittel2522]

leo orchard but it was destroyed...

[@Cybermat47]

Nicolas Tittel he means if it was destroyed and killed Anakin, Obi-Wan, Palpatine, and R2 on board.

[@orcho141]

I don't know how that isn't clear when it clearly states "containing" :')

[@oobservador4364]

Well, then I guess nothing related to the Sith would happen, since Darth Sidious and his "students" would have died, and Luke and Leia would have a normal childhood with Padmé.

[@IsaacStevensHOA]

THAT WOULD BE AWESOME. PLEASE do a video on that.

[@michaelblomenkamp9761]

You had me on the edge of my seat! One of my favorite channels I have subscribed to in the past year :)

[@jorgerivera9532]

This was an awsome story I would like to have seen the rest, ending it with Luke facing his father but it was great

[@markhomer6903]

Super Vader vs the Emperor? Comments decide.

[@markhomer6903]

*Palpatine*

[@supermegawaffle]

Cory from Cory in the House

[@martintooswoovy573]

mark homer Palpy

[@drelff3414]

Super Vader. The Emperor makes a comment towards Yoda in Episode three that Darth Vader was indeed more powerful than himself and even Yoda. The only thing that held him back was that his physical and mental state were trashed after losing to Obi-Wan on Mustafar. But if in this reality Vader had a suit that not only made him physically stronger but granted him cybernetic abilities as well, I don't see the Emperor beating him.

[@joeydavis1702]

mark homer super Vader would win

[@thebiggerboat3236]

Fantastic vid. I was JUST thinking about this one not too long ago, as well. How funny that it just so happens that this comes along right then.

[@bonniebunny8262]

WHAT IF OBI WAN JOINED COUNT DOOKU PART2 PLZ

[@ajmoras6914]

“He could hear the sound of a light tap” this was brilliant the fact that Vader could fear anyone.

[@ThePodfish]

Really enjoyed this story my friends was really well made and the commentary was on form .

[@sammymartinez9842]

What if General Grievous killed Obi-wan in episode 3

[@Phoenixesper1]

meh... too late to save us from the prequels.

[@rickjames5998]

IRONBat 103 so you mean, what if gen grievous had the high ground

[@benspencer8557]

Do what if darth maul wasn't cut in half

[@True_Comrade]

Then he would be alive

[@theread3480]

Red Blade09 he is still alive watch rebels and the clone wars

[@benspencer8557]

Ok I said what if he was cut in half

[@benspencer8557]

I mean wasn't

[@theread3480]

Vincent Tolisano well he survived obi wans battle but probably not alive in the force awakens

[@srami004]

Great job. Listened to part 1 months ago. Just discovered the conclusion.

[@kyrak7565]

What if starkiller killed Vader and the emperor (dark side starkiller)

[@DatMentalGamer]

@Jason Rasmussen The ultimate Sith Lord of them all.

[@russian3783]

PLEASE Do What if Anakin spared Dooku?

[@yesthatenzo]

Goosebumps, great job, man!

[@zGgriim]

Do a part 3 of this

[@Doc4Strang3]

What happened to Asajj Ventress after and during Order 66

[@paxcon78]

Dead.

[@gengarzilla1685]

She died before the order was sent.

[@NinjaTyler]

Dr. Strange killed of via bullshit

[@jstar1196]

Thnx for covering the palpy keeping vader alive topic!

[@TheStatBoarder]

What if qui-Gon had survived and joined the darkside with count dooku

[@youknowwho8001]

What if Mickey Mouse joined the emperor instead of Anakin Skywalker?

[@Biffaroni211]

You're truly a gifted storyteller

[@wesleytabak1190]

What if order 66 failed due to clone malfunction?

[@yoda5523]

The clones would still execute the order but more clones would refuse and more Jedi would survive

[@TwoGuy]

What if padme survived

[@kiandaigle2340]

Plasmonium he already did that on if you pay attention

[@dcd10able]

Epic description of the battle between the 3

[@meijimarts111]

I'm amazed that Darth Vader didn't took any apprentice

[@jeffreynewman9801]

Meiji Marts he had an apprentice called star killer but turned to the jedi side

[@meijimarts111]

Jeffrey Newman The video didn't mention it and it totally slipped in my mind

[@jeffreynewman9801]

i knowit didntsay it in thevide george lukas said it

[@apock2474]

would he? He took starkiller to assist in killing sidious.

[@chef_boi3583]

Apock 247 star killer is N O T C A N N O N

[@michaellabonte6390]

aw....I was hoping Vader would win

[@tazmanian5802]

Mr.Linguine nah man, Obi beast. Every time he walks into a room American Bad Ass plays

[@ElijahW2003]

Mr.Linguine Spoiler.

[@tickleisweeb]

Obi-Wan for the win, mate!

[@Huaka8907]

Me too

[@IsaacStevensHOA]

why?

[@13dirtyd13]

Thank you for this. That was simply awesome homeboy. Keep up the amazing work. I truly enjoyed both videos immeasurably.

[@zelenilum290]

What if Padme cheated on Anakin with Obi-Wan?

[@peezysmith5245]

Zelen Ilum WW3

[@thedanklordofthesith210]

I HATE YOUUUU

[@tickleisweeb]

Obi-Wan Kenobi liked Duchess Satine.

[@lordofpain3476]

She did , didn't you know that OWK was the Master playa ? Big and tall , short or small OWK had them all . He called his junk " the force " that is why he was always saying " may the force be in you . "

[@Lycan_Jedi]

Padme dies sooner and Vader turns faster.

[@willlackman4223]

What if the droid army surrendered joined the republic

[@maribelcowan930]

Will Lackman

[@yoda5523]

sheev

[@gavinaverbeck9334]

Will Lackman ... The droid army is programmed to fight and kill clones and jedi...

[@nicholasdirosa5134]

very impressive how u brought to light that palpatine reinforced how vader survived on the volcanic shore by channeling the dark side.

[@averagealien346]

What if Anakin had the high ground in Revenge of the Sith?

[@rizzardbro]

Average Alien I HAVE THE HIGH GROUND

[@santiagozuniga8555]

what if Jar Jar binks was a sith lord?

[@Jigsawmyers]

I've really liked what you have done with this what if Comparing and using stuff from irl and in the movies

[@towa21]

what if the empire found Yoda on dagobah before Luke went there

[@dariomatas788]

What if maul and savage opress kill palpatine? (i think it would be wery interesanting cuz than in my opinion clone war would be much longer. and it would between 3 sides republic,seperatis and mauls forces mainly mandalorians.)I dont want creat any more of my scenario cuz it would be shit im sure so plzz u make it 😃

[@dariomatas788]

come one people lets make this.

[@dariomatas788]

to explain how maul defeat palpatine may be u can make savage sacrifice himself somehow so maul could win.

[@NinjaTyler]

Dario Matas or dathomir magic plot armor enabling them to over power him

[@dariomatas788]

NinjaTyler yep thats strong plot armor buth the best armor in star wars is yar yar plot armor he is too stupid to be killed. And blody stong age monkey bears that destoying most advancef civilization in galaxy theey hawe shit top plot armo. Blody ewoks i realy hate them.

[@darthtroller]

Maul would team up with Savage and make a deal with Ventress to more easily kill Dooku, Talzin would survive and help them, Obi Wan would be more important, and also in episode 3, Palpatine isn't captured, Maul and Opress now more powerful go and kill Grievous, then conquer separatists, but now, Ventress is in Maul's side cuz she is under Mother Talzin and she won't betray Talzin's children once more, now there's four opponents who will join forces with Sole Dathomirian male Snoke (in my theory) and we have Obi Wan, Anakin, Ahsoka, Yoda and Windu on the great level to destroy the opponents, first of all Obi Wan needs a spare lightsaber (Qui Gon's) and he will kick both of Maul's and Savage's asses, he also would be assisted by Ahsoka, Anakin would easily defeat Ventress, Mother Talzin would be rekt by Windu himself, Snoke then has to be killed by all of Anakin, Obi Wan, Ahsoka, Yoda and Windu, he fails, MEIN FAILÜRE fails

[@darthnihilus511]

Your theories are very specific, more like a story of their own. That is what is so great about star wars, the world it has created inspires a drama and emotion that engages the imagination. I fantasize scenarios and involvement in a way that I haven't done since I was young, before life constrained me to reality. I am so glad I discovered this universe before I forgot how to do this! It keeps me young, optimistic and open minded. Plus it's just fun! At the same time the analogs to today's life are real and relevant.

[@joakimorpana9890]

what if hansolo would hawed died in the freezing chamber