Tired of Apprentices

[@honeystream9499]

The only apprentices I think worked were Firepaw and Jaypaw. Firepaw, cause like you said, we got to learn about the world and people and life around him. Jaypaw because we got to see his journey from a little apprentice who hated everyone around him, to a skilled and strong medicine cat. But that’s basically it for me. Another reason why Gray Wing is great!

[@cozmo1098]

He’s still sarcastic tho :D

[@avocadocat6432]

i totally agree!!

[@Sher1862]

Agreed! But then they ruined Firestar's personality as the books went on.. I wish they didn't make old protagonist's lose all their personality.

[@mangle18423]

twigpaw was also good tho imo she displayed troubles of not knowing where she belonged, which gives the reader a sense of comfort and support for their feelings of doubt

[@Bitchypoetsblog]

Squrrielpaw was rlly good to we started off with a preppy bratty and know it all apprentice to a clever loving kind sassy and loyal cat who cares about thunderclan and her kin more then anything

[@candiiihearts]

Only thing I want: Evil. Protagonist. I don’t mean Mapleshade, I mean a cat who calculates plans, one that looks at other cats and their perspectives on other clans for reference. One that carefully plans out what’s going on without spending all their time on it. Make them have allies and enemies. Make blackmail and manipulation a thing. Edit: dam hi yall didnt expect so many people to agree- anyways if the erins remember that rc decorated their dens with shells I will forever praise them Edit part 2, the electric boo-ga-loo: oh no theres more of you- anyways to anyone who mentioned story ideas, them making stories, etc, your ideas are awesome and i hope you guys are able to finish them! for anyone who talked about characters, ideas, thongs mentioned in the story, etc, thanks for the feedback! :]

[@cozmo1098]

Having an evil protagonist would be good. We could see the way they think and stuff. The novellas for evil characters are kinda boring but having them in an arc would be epic

[@candiiihearts]

@@cozmo1098 I know right- personally, I hated mapleshade because I can’t remember a single time where she, I dunno, planned. She just killed.

[@l0v3struck17]

omg yes

[@umbsol5053]

(next arc spoilers kinda) im hoping flamepaw turns out evil or at least morally gray. then it'd make sense that he's struggling with upholding firestar's legacy when none of his (way more closely related to firestar) relatives have

[@cozmo1098]

@@candiiihearts yeah she was like, “I’m gonna kill everyone!” Without a solid plan.

[@quickslate28]

This just reminded me of a girl that I met at our local library that apparently didn’t read the books in order. I’m pretty sure she’d just randomly pick a book to read and I have no clue how she managed that.

[@kimei170]

That sounds like a terrifying way to read Warriors ;; I can’t imagine skipping from Dawn of the clans to omen of the stars to the original books and back again

[@AD-gb3xd]

My brother only has access to my collection of books. He's read, in random order, Firestar's Quest, Skyclan's Destiny, Brambleclaw's Storm, Sunset, The Broken Code 3 and 5, and A Vision of Shadows 5.

[@quickslate28]

@@AD-gb3xd I’m pretty sure that’s exactly what she would do, she’d just hop back and forth from arc to arc, how do you even know what’s happening???

[@Corviidei]

That sounds horrifying

[@supersketchy3824]

I started from dawn of the clans so when I read into the wild I was like, wtf, where’s sky clan!!!???

[@EmperorAnimates777]

Totally understand where you're coming from. I swear if Flamepaw is just another "OoH I wAnNa bE A wArRiOr" kind of apprentice then I'm going to fucking scream

[@risingphoenix1335]

Flamepaw has been an apprentice for so long that I feel he doesn't even care anymore, he is just tired of it

[@EmperorAnimates777]

@@risingphoenix1335 if we got an apprentice that was just done with everything, like Jayfeather but even more cocky and miserable, then it would be pretty interesting ngl

[@jinx_76]

i want it to be a kind of "purposely failing so i dont have more responsibility"

[@EmperorAnimates777]

@@jinx_76 that would be awesome for a protagonist who could maybe be later developed into a villain!

[@Juicybaddie]

I hope one day we’ll get an apprentice that is scared of being a warrior.

[@izabelwise5646]

When the thumbnail is a solid color with black figures you know Moon kitti is going to explain a warriors problem.

[@evobrand1210]

I knew someone would say it

[@thishuman1621]

It had to be said

[@Krill_Phil]

Accurate.

[@fiddled.]

This is why i loved Tallstar's Revenge. You learn about Windclan culture, why they are unique from the other clans, and you even learn about Tunnelers and Moor Runners, this was an interesting introduction to Windclan, it was great. Especially how Shrewpaw and Barkpaw had actual personality and not just "Oh, I have to check fleas, wow so terrible." You had a different perspective to apprenticeship, and the mistakes Tallpaw had made as an apprentice. Infact, Honeypaw had more personality than Lionpaw did, she was always fangirling over Berrynose, her death was heartbreaking because her personality made me grow attached to her more than I did Lionblaze.

[@highlytrainedprofessional8673]

]⁰⁰⁰0⁰

[@billcipher8645]

@RC Studios I remember it happening and a second later she dies. It's hilarious and terrible at the same time

[@ssprites]

I was going to comment this exact thing lol

[@pillowmoment]

The group of cats in Tallstar’s generation are great. Barkface is caring, smart. And a good character. Shrewclaw is a brat, mean, and literally the bane of my existance. And Tallstar is WONDERFUL. His story and emotions feel real to me. (It was one of the few books/character arcs i’ve cried over!) WindClan was unique. They just aren’t anymore. We hear nothing about their culture. Such as the point about being special because they’re the closest to their ancestors, and closest to the moon stone. Each clan has a reason for feeling the most important. (Besides ThunderClan, ThunderClan just likes ThunderClan) And this reason for WindClan is fantastic! It’s a shame they were reduced to angry border obsessed freaks. Tallpaw’s arc is very personal to me. The book gives us so much detail about clan culture. The way they walk, act. It’s given so much more detail. Tallstar’s revenge is one of the best super editions, in my opinion. It’s character drama is more than just “i want this position!” And “i like this cat that i’m not allowed to date” and “trouble with StarClan!” It’s more about the emotions and struggles Tallstar faces within his own clan. He feels trapped, held down, ignored, unloved. He doesn’t deal with prophecies or secret training or forbidden love. His story is about understanding himself, and the world around him. Tallpaw’s issues with belonging are different from so many other cats. He feels stupid, he feels like he’s letting his family down, he feels like nobody else cares about the things he does. It sucks that newer books shy away from character personality in favor of the plot. If you told me what two modern characters were like that were both protagonists and asked me who they were, i couldn’t tell.

[@oliviapope4080]

@@pillowmoment YES! Tallstar’s Revenge and Crookedstar’s Promise were my absolute favorites when I was younger

[@selznickselznick]

I think the training aspect is why we have so many background characters with absolutely nothing differentiateing them other than name. If they just spent some time getting to know different cats in the clan, maybe just grooming or chatting, then the clan would feel more lively with gossip and distinct personalities.

[@da359]

I agree. I think the other clans should have different type of training too. Maybe windclan revives tunneling and use it during attacks, or Riverclan learns attacks with swimming, maybe Shadowclan learns different techniques to hunting. Very sly and slow

[@ThoseWhoKnowBalkan]

i really want cats to have friend groups. everybody just kinda coexists in a clan, no rivalries, no gossip, no drama lol

[@Goldendoodlegamer11]

Yes!! Cats having friends or better relationships with their families or heck, even just having relationships beyond their token love interest would make the Clans feel so much more fleshed out and interesting to read about

[@emilymonahan5232]

wellll, just one of many reasons

[@pansybunny5748]

Apprentices have gotten SERIOUSLY boring, can we get a book about a young warrior instead? Or just a different type of training? Just... Something new! Training and learning how to hunt has been beaten to death and I wanna see cats learning specific skills! Or hobbies! Please!!

[@haveagoodmourning]

plot idea: a youngish riverclan warrior that WANTS to become a medicine cat and so they start training for that. it's a bit more difficult since they started training later in life than usual, and they find having a mentor embarrassing at this age (20something equivalent), but they deal, although it doesn't make them popular in the clan. they resent how their mentor treats them like an apprentice. the nitty-gritty of healing is used as an avenue to worldbuild healing methods (and tangents on their differences between clans, and what ingredients are native to which territory.) the warrior has no desire to leave their work as a medicine cat, and nothing is trying to stop them from continuing it either. they stay in the medicine den for most of the book (aside from a subplot about collecting ingredients because of a shortage, where the protagonist has to rush on a time limit to get the correct medicines before a critically injured patient dies without them) and learn about the events of the story from the patients that pass through for healing. injuries get progressively more dire. our protagonist begins to question why. their overprotective mentor refuses to tell them, as the mentor sees them like a kid, and wants to shelter them. they're unpopular enough in the clan that none of the warriors want to tell them either. so they try to find out the mystery themself using brief snippets of communication with a group of starclan cats as clues. the starclan cats are outright portrayed as @holes for this, as these particular ones are just toying with our protagonist, who gets into several arguments with them about it haha. eventually thunderclan attacks riverclan (yes thunderclan is the villain this time). the protagonist finds out that, just as they feared, there had been increasingly large skirmishes with thunderclan, and this was the breaking point. riverclan cats, including the protag, and several very young apprentices (sent out by shady mentors), had been intruding on thunderclan territory to steal herbs out of necessity. and thunderclan, although they had no shortage, refused to remember that sharing is caring, and got mad. protagonist and their mentor have to hold back a few particularly ruthless thunderclan warriors as the warriors try to break into the medicine den where injured patients lie.

[@Clooover]

Luckily we're getting a POV from a young ShadowClan warrior in the Starless Clan arc, Sunbeam, though we also have to deal with two apprentice POVs with her.

[@pansybunny5748]

@@haveagoodmourning it would be great to finally get a medicine cats who actually WANTED the job, I'm really sick of the medicine cats just being unfortunate souls who were shoved into the job. It would also be really refreshing to see Thunderclan as the "villain" seeing as none of the clans are really evil, they all just have different agendas and they really don't need to be the hero clan

[@justyourlocalcommenter7492]

We got Brambleclaw as the young warrior POV

[@sugerwillowsmores5345]

Kitty cat gardening and knitting :)

[@Poppyfrost]

YES! And remember in (i think) Tallstar's revenge when they said ThunderClan step high like deer and RiverClan/ShadowClan stomp? I love those little details.

[@stormSeven]

We need more things like friend groups in warriors. Like the main character could be an apprentice but they hang out with the looser apprentice group and their sibling hangs out with the older and cooler group of apprentices. Or just something hinting at “oh these cats hang out a lot and gossip about the other cats in their clan” or SOMETHING like a mentor and apprentice still being friends past the apprentices warrior ceremony.

[@teaartist6455]

They had that in the earlier books, along with at least suggestions of a more fleshed out culture, I guess it's just one of those things that you have to actively keep track of as an author and that thus tends to fall by the wayside. Okay, not full-on cliques, honestly the number of apprentices usually seems to small for that, but the main three definitely had a different relationship with each other than with the other two apprentices, who were fairly close to each other. It was like two small-ish friendgroups that were sort-of friends with each other, but more the kind of friend you'd see in school because you happen to be in the same class than someone you'd actively hand out with.

[@sokaize]

I felt this with the three, why did Lionblaze and Jayfeather seemingly forget Hollyleaf even existed except for the occasional reference of her? They didn't seem all too sad after the one second spent focused on her.

[@dddeeerrrpppvideos1618]

I wanna an arc where background elders are pushed into the prophecy..

[@clawcakes]

give elders love please im begging

[@lettophile]

I’ve good news for you

[@PommieTheYoomie]

Guess what

[@dddeeerrrpppvideos1618]

@@PommieTheYoomie 10/10 way to learn this lol.

[@UnstablePinetree]

*Changing Skys have entered the chat*

[@nogard0497]

Cats forgot to relax when they lost Sunningrocks

[@smileyc1041]

right?!

[@Stormwolf4]

Alderboy was a nice change from most apprentices, even if the books stole his personality throughout them. Lets hope Frostpaw's perspective doesn't just show they're fat cats and they like fish...

[@sidegrabsheriff]

riverclan cats are fat

[@newabbmantics]

@@sidegrabsheriff Kittypets are fatter

[@rayvenrubi]

good news

[@CelestialTabris]

Started with POT and being exposed to the apprentice olympics lore that never came back gang

[@astraldusk3180]

At this point the most exciting thing in the books is them making dirt

[@Jade-zm2tg]

which rarely happens lol

[@astraldusk3180]

@@Jade-zm2tg ikr they need like some fiber 1 bars or something

[@Jade-zm2tg]

@@astraldusk3180 lol ikr

[@audge-audge]

XD I love how they only make dirt when they need to overhear something It's like, "Oh, the big bad guy is doing something sneaky at night? Okay, the main character will have a random and very coincedental urge to make dirt in the middle of the night and we'll never have them do it again."

[@Jade-zm2tg]

@@audge-audge RIGHT?? or sneaking out through the dirtplace tunnel

[@Jay-wr1se]

It would be cool if the book started when they were warriors and worked their way up to elders instead of leader. Even give us a perspective of after they died and how they got into starclan. Even the reactions of their loved ones

[@clawcakes]

honestly a series that goes over a cat's whole life would be so sick, like the Antagonistic force has a strong hold over the clans their whole life. bonus points if they take it down and die in the process as an elder

[@KatSkan]

Absolutely! (Warning: DOTC spoilers ahead). I think that’s why I enjoyed reading about Gray Wing so much. He started out as a fully grown cat and had a few leadership opportunities throughout his lifetime, but never quite made it to true leader status. He was a very loyal and genuine cat and I thought experiencing his POV during his own death was unexpectedly great to read about since we don’t have unique perspectives like that very often in Warrior cats.

[@maplefoxxo]

@@KatSkan I agree! That's why I really like gray wing,,, it also almost made me cry when he died

[@euphxria3404]

i would die for that

[@Sunnyfall]

Ah but a true fan would remember that in the lake territories, Riverclan could no longer find many shells with which to decorate their dens and instead started using bits of shiny twoleg trash, after checking it was safe.

[@quicksilverchaos4122]

love your videos

[@FireNeko3]

that's a joke right?

[@ThoseWhoKnowBalkan]

ah yes

[@eckstheorphanmurderer1038]

@@snekkers9068 i have a cannibal wc oc!! they leave the clans and just eat kittypets tho

[@eckstheorphanmurderer1038]

@@lumeanoastra1252 no the bitch was just like " mm kittypets are weak right?? and slow?? unlike prey which is fast but weak?? alr deal im gonna eat them yum yum 🤤" honestly i fucking hate them even though they're one of my ocs

[@TheRougeFearow]

Ya'know what would be an interesting plot? A mass starving of Thunderclan because there's no way that forest is big enough to support that many alpha predators! On an unrelated note, has anyone here read Bravelands? Because it's really fucking good!

[@trickykitty1838]

Yes! I can't believe it doesn't have more of a fanbase! I've only read up to the second book, but they write Stinger's villian arc perfectly!

[@feedthetwinkie]

You good sir/madam/noble of any upbringing, have piqued my interest and now I must read this series or book. Do tell me more if you wish.

[@KlearlyIMme]

i read the wiki about Goosefeather's book and the Great Hunger just sounded terrifying like they were so hungry and weak they couldnt move the body of a dead cat from the clearing and just walked around/ tripped on them. They should bring that back

[@audge-audge]

Oh, I LOVE Bravelands! And I ship Thorn and Berry HARDCORE!

[@olympus6856]

Bravelands is fucking amazing.

[@cayla84]

I think the thing that most frustrates me about the lack of cultural differences between the clans is that the books set up a ton of tiny things that COULD be interesting cultural distinctions, but then they just don't do anything with it. Like riverclan decorating their nests. Do they give gifts of shiny rocks or pretty flowers to their friends? Do they have favorite shells or feathers? Did some of the cats who made the Great Journey bring their favorite decorations along? Do they pass down decorations, what happens to a cat's nest decorations when they die? Do riverclan apprentices sometimes bring their favorite things to gatherings to show off to the apprentices in other clans, and how do those cats react? And they've had so many opportunities to highlight the differences. We've had several characters have to stay for one or more nights in another clan, cats switch clans, and the Great Journey itself.

[@flamboyantroach]

i also like hearing about the physical differences between the clans but the books always ignore those. riverclan cats are supposed to be very big and round but i feel like we rarely hear them described as such in a way thats not another clan insulting them (side note: why do the cats seem to take 'fat' as an insult? theyre cats.) like we never see the riverclan cats actually BEING rotund theyre just supposedly so. i want round cats. give them to me

[@isaacoconnor9157]

Into the wild had actual cat noises, like re-ee-ow in a battle. I wish that could come back.

[@harpyhelp]

i'd love to see a perspective from an outsider joining the clans like tree, fully grown and already has their mindset pretty much fulfilled. maybe the conflict of their ideologies and clan life could be a thing or they would be put in as a last resort recruit because they have a shortage of a particular rank like med cat or maybe even deputy

[@Silliestguyalive69]

Like if Purdy joined the clans full time

[@lazulidragon9665]

When was the last time Shadowclan cats were called stinky and Riverclan was called fish faces.

[@owlvenus]

you know it's going to be a good video when it has solid color backgrounds and line art cats

[@qbbi]

4:39 really hit home. Like WHY are there so many cats in ThunderClan if they don’t mention them. Like WHY. Did they make up those characters so the protagonist can talk about how little food there is?????

[@errorduck]

Dawn of the Clans made me step back and appreciate the different culture aspects of each clan. Clans were formed according to the natural skill and abilities of each cat, their own personal sense of home and where they fit in best. It made me want more of this being shown. the tunnelers of Windclan and Shadowclan cats training in camp were also great little culture differences that I wish were shown more often. I want a arc that's geared towards drama in the clans themselves, cat politics, culture clashes, a clan cat bouncing between all the clans to try to find where they fit in like Dawn of the Clans. More cat interacting with each other and developing friendships and rivalries. Less outward troubles and more inward and relationship based troubles.

[@legrandliseurtri7495]

Yes, that's exacly what I'm appreciating so much about dawn of the clans right now, as I'm reading it again. No super strict rules, the groups of cats are fluid and keep changing. I especially like the fact that they are cats who already lived there before, and now have to deal with the consequences of the arrival of the tribe, by either joining them, avoiding them or competing with them.

[@inkling457]

If you guys want a playlist with all of Moonkitti's videos where she talks in length about various WC content, but are too lazy to make your own and look through her videos, I made one. I call it "Moonkitti Thinks", and it includes ALL of her videos where she talks about things, as well as a few extras that I felt fit. Feel free to save it and view at your leisure, I hope you enjoy! Edit: I tried to put the videos in order of importance or topic, not in order of date. I hope you enjoy regardless. Feel free to share this in her Discord server. I don't have money, so I can't access it. But it's still convenient, so I think the people there would like it.

[@lilith_projects3918]

Thank you!

[@inkling457]

@@lilith_projects3918 You're very welcome! She doesn't have her own playlist, so I thought it'd be useful for viewers who really like this type of video genre she makes.

[@Sher1862]

Thank you so much! I Personally like listening to analysis/talking videos when I'm writing or drawing, so it really helps!

[@inkling457]

@@Sher1862 You're very welcome! I like to listen to her videos like this while drawing as well! :D

[@inkling457]

@akasukiuii You're welcome! :D

[@linnylinlinlin]

I used to be able to name almost all the cats up to OoTs then I took a break before Vision of Shadows was released, and then when I went back to the series and there were 3 books out and I was like “wait who are these cats now who are all their offspring” 😭 I’m on another break but rip to all these bg cats (it doesn’t help that I suck at remembering names as well)

[@kittykat5915]

The only thing that I've been able to make from memory is the allegiances of Into the wild.

[@commonlesbianw]

PLS YOU COULD WHAAAT 😳

[@Ivypool123]

same

[@apawture]

we need a character thats as willing as us to rip apart the warrior code, examine every little detail of it, and question it. not just "maybe dating outside my clan isnt terrible" but ALL of it. it feels like even clan cats have no understanding of the code, they just learn it and follow it and are just fine with that. also the medicine cat code has never been written down anywhere, as far as we can tell its just dont date and you can wander where you like. it made sense not to know about it before getting medicine cat protags but weve had medicine cat protags since arc 2 whats going on

[@audge-audge]

Hollyleaf was a bit like that

[@romessalatif949]

Nightheart looks like he might do something like that

[@owowhatsthis1121]

I also miss when apprentices as a part of their training went to the moon stone to talk to their ancestors or lost loved ones, I felt that was something really cool to add like when shrewpaw got talk to his mom who died a few moons earlier and he got some closure for it or when crookedpaw went and instead of starclan he talked to mapleshade. I don't know this probably doesn't matter but I just really liked it and thought it wad cool thanks for reading this if you did. edit: spelling error

[@legrandliseurtri7495]

I though it was funny when in Outcast, someone supports the three's desire to go to the mountains by saying the journeys can be good for young cats and that with the loss of the going to the moonstone tradition, they don't have that opportunity anymore. It's so obvious that the Erin had simply forgotten about it until that point.

[@crystalcolors2229]

when its a single color background and doodles made with only black lineart you know its gonna be a hella good video

[@possumqe9751]

A kittypet perspective would be different and interesting, not a kittypet who becomes a warrior (I’m looking at you firestar) but a kittypet that roams around and learns instead of joining, though I’m not sure of how plot-wise this could go it would be a refreshing new concept

[@clawcakes]

this could be so cool?? like, a kittypet has a friend in the clans (e.g. a fellow kittypet that left, or even a clanborn cat that they managed to make friends with), and when some sort of outside force (a group of rogues or twoleg shenanigans) threatens the clans, the kittypet must decide whether to hide and potentially let the clans fall apart or come out of their twoleg den to save their friend. there could even be a cool scene at the end where the leader of the friend's clan is like "DAMN you are a good warrior, join us please?" and the kittypet is like "nah i'm good, seeya later" and goes back home

[@awoum]

Jake )?

[@possumqe9751]

@@awoum Jake is a good kittypet character but I mean a main character, like we see from their perspective, speaking of jake a novella of him or something would be interesting

[@possumqe9751]

@@clawcakes Ooh! I like this!

[@jem718]

Havent read the series in almost 8 years but i feel like there should be more characters like ravenpaw, that break out of the system and become an unbiased true neutral

[@chickennuggetpaw]

Imagine... An elder main character. Who is involved in the plot despite their age. ...and maybe dies in the end to make it spicier- That would be awesome!

[@starfruit545]

This could have been Graystripe’s Vow, but nope, Graystripe needed to be a *leader*

[@legrandliseurtri7495]

*Graywing* enters the chat. I mean, he was an adult at the start of the story and he dies so.

[@starfruit545]

@@legrandliseurtri7495 *Gray* stripe, *Gray* Wing, something's up...

[@tenacious-hubb8781]

I'm the target audience of warriors and I approve of this message

[@risingphoenix1335]

I think Hollytuft or another cat we forgot existed would be a great protagonist.

[@xxfabby_animationsxx7377]

No one: The Erins:Ya'll want sum kiddos? The readers:No- The Erins:Aight here ya go, take a whole package-

[@reesie.pieces]

Right? Sometimes it'd be cool to have a start other than an apprentice. As the series kept going on, the less interesting the apprentices got, up to a point they were hardly interesting enough to even read the books. A little bit of change would be awesome and refreshen the series a bit!

[@TessuDraws]

Oh my god YES! Every time a cat goes hunting, my eyes just gloss over and I speed through the scene. And the clans really have no culture to separate themselves at all. Knowing that WindClan used to tunnel kinda makes it worse because it was present only in Tallstar's Revenge and stopped in the same book. And ShadowClan is just a slightly more rude ThunderClan. I hope they also remember that RiverClan doesn't make just dens based on your rank but smaller dens for couples that float on water. I really liked the idea introduced in Crookedstar's Promise that they sometimes make smaller dens, like a family home! It's cute!

[@terrycanady7602]

Yes Moonkitti, talk at me about war cats

[@coolcatcartoons]

What bothers me is that it’s always the same three cats recently. You have the medicine cat who worries about stuff The generic cat who becomes a good fighter and Hunter And the cat who always gets in forbidden love. Why can’t the authors change it up a bit? Perhaps have two perspective cats, or more of one role (like two medicine cats or something) or even another kitty pet who joins the clans.

[@quicksilverchaos4122]

imagine a book about two apprentices who both want to be the medicine cat apprentice just fighting over it and trying to get more of the Clan on their specific side

[@seineevee]

I’d really like a daylight warrior protagonist for Skyclan

[@risingphoenix1335]

I would like a cat who we forgot existed who gets some character development and has completely different issues than forbidden love. (Thornclaw or Hollytuft?)

[@clawcakes]

@@quicksilverchaos4122 TWO MEDICINE CAT APPRENTICES IN GENERAL YES PLEASE, it always felt weird that there was only one cat who wanted to be a medicine cat apprentice at any given time. it'd honestly be awesome to have like, a duo of medicine cat apprentices being taught by their mentor and the two of them have a sort of rivalry. bonus points if one of them thinks of it as a friendly rivalry, and the other genuinely despises them

[@thishuman1621]

I feel I like the only exception that I can think of (up to now) is Jayfeather. He wasn’t worried about shit other than a split second before his sister died. He was just grumpy and honestly had the most hormonal teenageresque personality ever. He was probably quite relatable, compared to cats who wanted to do stuff willingly and cats who worry about being trained.

[@dogface8844]

I just want some old guy to be the main character like cmon purdy deserved to be the main character of the entire series

[@kuwabarastarr]

@@lumeanoastra1252 I really want to make that lol

[@dewniper]

Idea: an arc where the main protagonists are like, a Queen with apprentice kittens, an elder, a young warrior that isn’t special in any way: no evil parents, no Famous and Perfect parents, not half clan, just a random warrior. Preferably none of these cats are in thunderclan. Two of them could be in the same clan but not having talked too much. Then there’s a prophecy about something, and obviously they think “well I’m not special so I won’t be affected” well they were WRONG! Also have them build strong friendships and have character development and angst and comfort

[@chipsare-yummy8188]

I LOVE APPRENTICE DRAMA! Stuff like, "Good day outside, Applepaw!" "Oh just like you to say that Archpaw" Like, where did that come from!? Or, crushing...or something. IDK. It's look School Drama, it's intense. I want bullies, mean girls, hot girls, kids with anger issues, annoying teachers. ALL OF THAT.

[@misfits9294]

Ok, but I don't think any clan-born cat would have a Rusty type introduction, to be fair. They lived in their respective Clan for 6 months leading up to this, they're likely to already picked up on so much culture and who the cats are around them already, especially given how tight-knit the Clans as a unit are. But that still could be such an interesting starting point; these characters already know a lot, and can info-dump to the readers if needed (preferably with interesting dialogue or a unique scene, not just thinking in a long list from their pov). But it also shines super well when you get to the other Clans or outsiders in general, because they not only have info on Clan life, but preconceived biases passed down to them from older warriors. So they might be a source of information to the reader about the generalities of the world and how it works, but you can still learn new things from their perspective about the other Clans while they tackle with the stereotypes they grew up with being disproven.

[@batkittii]

Yeah the whole going through the motions of apprenticeship and not adding much new to it is getting tiring to me

[@tockalaluz]

I just hope Sunbeam gets plenty of characterization and development

[@jaydenknight5553]

I want a series of an apprentice perspective of feeling out of place in their birth clan and being accepted into another

[@NapaCat]

Twigbranch--kinda?

[@_pyxeled]

Tawnypelt? Also kinda?

[@hayhayluxray]

tawnypaw

[@swampthelizard]

"Ouch oof my aching bones". Moonkitti is truly an inspiration to us all.

[@leilanivaughan-williams3038]

I get that they probably don't wanna explain the whole clan system every new book and kits probably know a lot about it, but I wish at the start of each apprentice protag's book they would get to know the cats in their clan and think to themselves about those cats and their personalities. It'd be nice if background characters weren't so neutral. They don't need to be super in depth or anything, just have basic traits so that the protag can think about them "She never sits still. I wish I was that energetic." or "Why does he always seem to be in a bad mood?"

[@whosthisguyagain3153]

This is perfect. The Erins need to hire you.

[@ThePolkadog]

you HAVE to read solacefruit's warrior fics on AO3. He brings much-needed worldbuilding, texture, nuances, character depth and clan culture into the warriors world with so much elegance and beautiful prose... I think you'll enjoy how he interprets the world. I love the fandom but the source material is so aggravating and painful sometimes, like you've highlighted in this video

[@pricklypear1704]

Honestly kind of upset that the moor runners and tunneler divisions in windclan were phased out. It created a lot of unique conflict and scenery in Tallstar's revenge in my opinion, and it differentiated Windclan's culture from other clans. A tunneler who actually enjoyed their job would be a cool and immersive perspective to take.

[@catss1234]

These types of videos are REALLY helpful for me to avoid these mistakes in my warriors-inspired story im writing! Tysm Moonkitti! I love your channel! Keep up the good work!

[@nightiingale_]

yes,,, another reason to support dawn of the clans as the best arc

[@hyalophora]

I, too, am sick of young children

[@hyalophora]

@@snekkers9068 that is the only case in which young children are useful, yes

[@somangiscute6370]

I started at Omen of the Stars. It was a while ago but the funny thing is the only thing I really remember being confused about was Jayfeather's powers.

[@legrandliseurtri7495]

Reading minds(kind of), invading dreams of other people, time traveling and moving freely in starclan and the dark forest.

[@PanRawr]

You mentioned how full a Warrior Cat's day is, and this is something I think about a lot, but like... Their territories, being mostly completely separate environs from one another, have to be *huge*. And these are cats! No matter how fast a cat *can* run or sprint, that's not something they're capable of maintaining for extended periods! It has to take them *forever* to patrol these territories, let alone multiple times a day!

[@legrandliseurtri7495]

Indeed! Cats&their family can usually patrol their whole territory, but only because they're living alone. To support upwards of 50 cats, you'd need something enormous.

[@yawninglion1677]

One thing I've always really cared about that the books themselves don't care about is seeing a character's experience as a mentor. Firestar's experience in mentoring Cinderpelt, Cloudtail, and Bramblestar was all very interesting to me. It was fun to see him grow and learn and bond with his apprentices, especially when it came to Cinderpelt. I hate how the newer books kind of gloss over it. Like, Lionblaze mentoring Dovewing could've been a cool way to watch him grow and learn, but all of their interactions were about the Dark Forest or Beavers or some other drama.

[@legrandliseurtri7495]

Another bad example: how about Brackenfur mentoring Hollypaw? Half the time I even forget that's the case when I'm reading arc 3. They just don't talk to each other.

[@yawninglion1677]

@@legrandliseurtri7495 That too! Which sucks because Brackenfur is one of my favorite characters, and he's barely involved in Hollypaw's life.

[@kaykinz2549]

8:46 they made a poll on the official website asking people’s favorite things about Riverclan and them decorating their dens with twoleg stuff was on it and it’s in second place so hopefully it means they remember and include it atleast a bit! Lol

[@jamestomato1744]

Ah Fluffypaw of Bloodclan. That cat's gonna see some shit I can just see it.

[@Nyx_404]

do you guys remember the goo ol' days where cleaning ticks off elders was an *actual punishment?*

[@Rabeaumbra]

Omg, Yesssss!! Also I'm 34 and just learned about warrior cats a couple years ago lol!

[@haveagoodmourning]

what about a book from the perspective of an elder? :D that sounds like it would be interesting.

[@alixmalone19]

I once said that and people said it would be boring. It's only as boring as the writer makes it lol

[@smokey6032]

I want a Evil protag Thats atleast a warrior Cause im honestly tired of app's being the Main charicter And stuff Like why can we get a NEW protag one that is related to idk Tigerstar or something And becomes evil and AFTER there evil arc has a redemption arc It would be more interesting In my opinon

[@9nikola]

This is just Brambleclaw in the New Prophecy

[@SkiggsMoDiggs]

I was literally just thinking "The apprentices protagonist thing is getting so numb"

[@9nikola]

I'd like a new series to introduce us to the Warriors universe now that the culture and characters are so fully different from what they were in The Prophecies Begin. Maybe in the series after A Starless Clan, once all the characters we got to know in the 1st series are all dead, there should be a cat so asocial as a kit that when they become an apprentice, they only know 3-5 cats in the clan and barely the most obvious parts of culture. That way we could get to know the cats in the protagonist's clan in a more thorough way without having any of that "this protagonist has known these characters their entire life" excuse. Then they could finally advertise the series as a "perfect place to start for new readers" without _completely_ lying. And we can get to know the characters better since nobody really knows anything about any new characters in the last two series.

[@l0v3struck17]

i started reading the books when i was 9 i feel so old

[@Robin.xxbinn]

I started warriors in omen of stars, and I completely didn’t understand, over reading omen of the stars, I started to understand, but I though was confused on everything that happened. I thought that everything in this arc was UnIQue but over the course of reading the OTHER arcs I began to understand ‘hey, these apprentices are quite similar’. I didn’t really have a problem with it, I still don’t. But in each arc, it bothers me how it always, ALWAYS starts the same way. I know sometimes It doesn’t, but in the more recent arcs, it does. It always starts with a ‘Alright RootKit! Remember NeedleKit? The supportive generic sister character? You and her are becoming apprentices! But your fur is so messy!’ It bothers me when there are so many other possibilities. For example, the Erins could write that’s scene in a way where maybe the kit’s mother doesn’t care about the kit becoming an apprentice at all, making an interesting way of seeing the character’s life, and seeing how the character interacts with other main figures in their life, it would be interesting, or maybe a story can start off where a kit wakes up in a forest with a bunch of cats near them, giving the impression the kit was abandoned. Or maybe a six moon old kit dropped off at camp with a mother begging to make them a warrior. That’s just my ideas though,

[@WarriorsAce]

Moonkitti destroys warrior cats with FACTS and LOGIC! Seriously though I agree warriors is becoming incredibly stale. I don't know why I'm drawn to these badly written books with the same repeating characters that never take any risks. I guess fanfiction can still be good and unique.

[@KK-hd1jw]

Sometimes I listen to these videos without headphones and recently my brother asked “What are you watching? Sounds like a ten year old ranting about some story” and then I have to break it to him that I am listen to a 28-year-old that talks about poorly-written cult cats in the woods.

[@GloryTheBiscuit]

This actually helped me rethink my own original Clans. I had planned on each having completely unique ways of life not just with food and like the way they hunt but like how they operate and live in general. Like how NightClan cats hunt at night and sleep in holes. MountainClan hunt cougars and don’t really have a medicine cat. FishClan are like beavers. StormClan use feathers a lot…. TimberClan make dens in trees and DarkClan is basically a bunch of rouges who just show up sometimes 0w0

[@catnerd3871]

This. This is why my tribe novel has a kit protagonist, a young adult protagonist, *and* a to-be protagonist

[@HavingFunISKEY]

I need to read this. Hate the tribe but this might be interesting :)

[@catnerd3871]

I haven’t written it yet, but I have some notes on it! :D

[@otterbanana1556]

I want an evil medicine cat apprentice that would be interesting

[@coyotix]

I need books where the elders are brought into the forefront WHILE elders- not just super editions showing them in their youth. Shove em into prophecies and journeys! Sandstorm came close to this when traveling to SkyClan with Alderpaw, but she wasn't the main character. And if they do make super editions for elders, show them doing cool things WHILE elders. Old lady Mousefur book Erins PLEASE

[@purplewingedangel3558]

My birthday has been blessed with a new moonkitti video. Life is good.

[@aknifeinthedark6878]

Happy Birthday! 🎂

[@clawcakes]

happy birthday!!!!!!

[@supersketchy3824]

“There’s no good arc to start on” Me with dawn of the clans: 👁👄👁

[@Owenbot3000]

In my opinion, it would be good for this if we started with a new born kit, and they learn about clan life in their apprenticeship and being a kit.

[@da359]

Me, with a story in the clans with the 2nd protagonist being an apprentice: *Oh.* It's fine, they have a mentor to apprentice relationship. And adopted mother to son, oh and small little detail, they committed *murder* together.

[@SavvyKitten666]

Moon is a child at heart and will always be a child in personality.

[@willowshineofriverclan8451]

4:19 I actually did start with the Apprentice's Quest and I was SO CONFUSED why there was a cat named Purdy

[@quietstarsilence7038]

My thought has always been, there's not enough being taught to the apprentices. They don't respect starclan, they aren't taught to be independent or how to lead. I like the ideas coming from fanfictions, shadowclan having a buddy system because they are considered evil. Every warrior has a buddy that they hunt and fight with. More emphasis on thundercats climbing trees. Riverclan was once known for finding pretty stuff and decorating their nests. What happened to that? Windclan should still teach tunnel safety and how to move in them. Skyclan was known for their jumping ability but like... How often is that show now?

[@clawcakes]

all i want for christmas... iiiiiiiiiis... a POV character that has a role that hasn't been covered before... elder POV character when? outsider (loner, kittypet, etc) that doesn't become a clan member POV when? STARCLAN CAT POV WHEN?

[@mysryuza]

I want evil protagonists (main arc), evil med cats, and evil apprentices. These kinds of people exist too (Murderous kids if Junko Furuta’s case taught anyone anything, killer doctors, etc.)! If one can write a creepy groomer into canon, then they can write a murderous med cat with personal gain, or a child who actually had petty reasons to kill someone and doing so gave moral panic to their clan with the “they’re just a kit” arguments.

[@ShadowStray_]

I have an idea for a new arc. Another clan, (from a different forest) has come seeking refuge in Leafbare. All the cats get separated into the different clans and struggle to survive to to a shortage of food. These new cats also have a different religion, and culture, and are not tolerated by the other clans. Soon, outrage sparks a war between the two groups. A lot of cats are killed, and now the clans decide to make peace and reincorporate the other cats into their clans.

[@ShadowStray_]

Also the cats have different naming rules

[@thishuman1621]

“ Moonkitti complains about apprentices but secretly it's just the lack of cat cultures again “

[@copicking173]

I just want a terrible Thunderclan leader. Ivystar. Please give us Ivystar

[@jettash0720]

Another thing would be to stop making at least one new protagonist related to Firestar somehow but I doubt that'll ever happen (looking at the way they said Flamepaw is gonna struggle with this fact and I kinda died inside). But you're absolutely right, the way they deal with apprentices especially as POV characters is some boring repetition at this point

[@Lavenderbutterscotch]

Riverclan don't fail us. River clan as a clan literally differs so much from the others. They can't hunt on border patrols, their kits practice fishing as kits, they're constantly in fear of flooding, and they struggle in the winter. Most or this I've gotten just from Crookedstar's promise. A book that definitely went into developing the clan as gossipy b*tches who don't want to start drama but love sharing intriguing tails.

[@relltwo3120]

Erin Hunter watching this: write that down! write that down!

[@seenoblade7291]

i'd love an arc where it seems like we're starting in wind or shadowclan, but the protagonist's mom moves to riverclan to be with her mate around a moon or two before apprenticeship, so the book is spent with an apprentice learning about their dad's clan and adapting to it and maybe even falling in love with it. potential conflict of mom eventually leaving to go home bc she's so homesick and the protagonist feeling betrayed or torn. in general we need more culture and more good and present dads

[@aaronking2020]

As someone whose never read a Novella or Side Book or whatever they're called, The Apprentice's Quest (OoTS Book 1) was really confusing. Same with TPB B 6

[@amblonyxx]

I like the threes apprenticeships because they actually took their time putting them through it. So they weren't only apprentices for like 5 minutes.

[@vinnnn5561]

basically we need death note version of warriors cat.

[@supersketchy3824]

These are probably my favorite types of moonkitti videos, besides the I spoil

[@boysen8840]

This is such a well articulated opinion. It hits the nail on the head. Also, a very important realization for people who are writing their own warrior cat stories. An apprentice view should tell inform the reader of lore, or there shouldn't be this view at all.

[@TypicalBraizey]

9:03 Ah yes, the 5 clans surrounding the lake. ShadowClan, SkyClan, ThunderClan, WindClan, and my favourite; WaterClan

[@CheCheSlide]

This is my birthday videooo!!

[@RoseProseFroze]

Wait the next series is going to be in Riverclan? Interesting.

[@Spottedstorm27]

I've said it before and I'll say it again. Purdy book! Give it to us Erins! Semi new culture interacting with our clans! Plus, best boi.

[@thishuman1621]

I feel like they clans are just the hogwarts houses: Gryffindor/ThunderClan: -Brave -Protagonists -Always solve everything Slytherin/ShadowClan: -Ambitious -Cunning -Not actually evil/mean but always made out to be Ravenclaw/WindClan: -Literally never mentioned -I can’t even think of characteristics for either except from ‘smart Hufflepuff/RiverClan: -Just kind of stay out of things -Mostly willing to help SkyClan is irrelevant because they’re basically just ThunderClan but smaller. Gryffindor/ThunderClan and Slytherin/ShadowClan are the main two houses/clans, and you can’t say otherwise. Excluding Skyclan, I can only think of one narrator who wasn’t SC or TC, and that’s Feathertail’s brother (I can’t believe I just forgot his name, I swear it’s Stormfur but idk)

[@pixelapocrypha]

I think that a lot of series' run into the problem of wanting to get new people with every installment. Not every new arc needs to be a good jumping off point. I'd love for them to do a series where they just assume we know the things long time fans would know and not waste a ton of time reteaching us those things.

[@ferniecove5653]

Honestly the new characters in the newer books are so irrelevant like yes who the heck is Eaglewing, the new books arent creating memorable new characters. Honestly anyone who sees this video and wants to make a warriors oc story should watch this video. As someone who wants to pursue writing i'd watch this over and over agian for tips.

[@ariartsy9220]

Meanwhile my fanfic with apprentices focuses on the main character's relationships and a murder mystery