TOP 7 Homekit Products to Add & some to Avoid in your Smart Home

[@diegoestabridis2478]

like the features, setup was difficult for some of my devices (August Door lock, kzbin.infoUgkxhB5YOMNj04GuoAosExygP4cH-dKeb4aB Bose speaker)... but all switches and outlets (5), thermostat, tankless water heater. Unfortunately all I can do is turn on/off Bose. It doesn't support volume or changing channels, but I believe that is due to the particular speaker I have.... Worth getting if you already have other devices to use it with... I don't sit around and ask Alexa questions much so that doesn't really matter to me....

[@qubit7112]

Just installed 8 Wemo dimmers and second gen light switch with no problems in the last month. They are fast and look better to me than any others sold. Nanoleaf light strips seem to be the best for me esp having thread.

[@mossimac]

2nd Wemo switches are great!

[@TheBradLloyd]

Thank you for sharing! Glad to know the Wemo switches work well for some! Agree with the Nanoleaf Light Strip!

[@robertbolton9154]

I use a lot of Wemo switches and plugs. They aren’t as user friendly to connect, but once installed I have found them very reliable. I will say that my biggest mistake was the Ring doorbell. I should have found one that was already HomeKit compatible.

[@qubit7112]

@@robertbolton9154 yep! I purchased August door bell and lock which work beautiful together.

[@GoFastGator]

We NEED a thread enabled light switch that has a “smart bulb” mode. The smart mode would ensure the bulb has power all the time but still provide physical controls. Being mains powered, it would make an awesome Thread network in any home where it’s used in multiple rooms. All with NO HUB.

[@TheBradLloyd]

100% agree Brian!

[@morells09]

It's not Thread enabled but LIFX makes a pretty good smart switch that is similar to what you're asking for. It only works with LIFX bulbs but it's just not feasible to create smart bulb compatibility with every brand. Just ask Brilliant.

[@davidlittle6876]

Completely agree with the Lutron switches! One of the HomeKit accessories that I’ve have ZERO issues with

[@TheBradLloyd]

They are great! Thanks for watching David!

[@eduardosandoval8303]

Regarding the VOCOlinc light strip, I have one in my living room behind the tv and it has worked for me pretty well I don’t have any complains.

[@sigjudge]

Absolutely knocked it out of the park with this video. About to reinvest in some HomeKit applicants and this really helped cover a wide-range of products I was already looking at.

[@TheBradLloyd]

Thanks Sigmund! I really appreciate that and so glad this is helpful as you consider expanding your Smart Home!

[@nicodlttr5261]

Thanks for the nice video! I live in Europe, so the products sometimes differ. I myself use the Nuki (no-key😉) door lock. Received 1 notification from Nuki in 3 years: “you are leaving the house, do you want to lock the front door?” Shouldn't actually be allowed, but still nice to get a notification. So be happy with it! I also use the Tado thermostat and thermostatic valves. Handy to heat each room separately! Because I also have sensors on the windows, the heating switches off when the windows are open and back on when they are closed. Oh yes, I have an Aqara water sensor on my terrace. If the attic window is open and it rains, I get a notification. This way my parquet floor will not be damaged! Greetings from Belgium, looking forward to your next video!

[@TheBradLloyd]

Hi Nico, product availability can be a challenge, even in Canada with many products. Sounds like you have a pretty good setup! Thanks for watching.

[@ktkyletaylor8212]

Love seeing this list and the fact that I recently bought the doorbell … and also got the Ecobee Thermostat and Sensors, Lutron Casetta Starter kit, 6 Aurora Dimmer Switches, and a bunch of new Aqara Sensors and Switches on Prime Day!

[@TheBradLloyd]

So awesome Kyle! Love that our set up is pretty aligned. Enjoy the new Aqara products from prime day! Thanks for watching!

[@schneideris]

On the Weiser lock, I would say that mine (I also have 2) have been pretty solid, more so now that I put a HomePod Mini in the garage by the one that was being a little in-responsive. The keypad always works so even without connectivity I know I am getting in. My biggest issue is with the door jam and the movement that happens with cold weather that causes more resistance on the edge of the deadbolt (reports a jab, even when it actually does close). A big per peeve of mine though is the screw on the bottom of the unit that needs to be taken out to change the batteries (try accessing it with a door knob below the deadbolt).

[@TheBradLloyd]

I couldn’t agree more with your feedback. Thanks for sharing! Also, this is a great point about improved performance by adding a HomePod mini. I actually put a HomePod mini at my front entrance and I think, now that you say that, it’s exactly why I’ve not had the same issues! Good call!

[@schneideris]

@@TheBradLloyd The HomePod Mini had the same effect on my MyQ garage door opener. The issue that I now appear to be having is slow response times from a variety of devices, including HomePods. With 3 Apple TV 4K’s, 1 big HomePod, and now 6 HomePod Mini’s in the configuration, I am starting to wonder if the master hub is either getting confused, or if it is being asked to control far to many devices (add 6 Meross switches, Lutron Casetta, Hunter Douglas blinds, the locks, TV’s, couple of Nanoleaf bulbs, a HomeBridge for my Denon receiver, and likely some others that I have forgotten). Today, I ordered the Aquara hub along with a switch and door sensor to try out. Did so prior to catching this video but happy to hear about your side recommendation. My interest is in seeing if the ZigBee devices can work nicely for the sensors.

[@poloby76]

I have 10 of the Wemo light switches. No issues with them at all. None are in bedrooms due to the light on the switch. They work with my scenes without any problems as well. I did have problems with plug. I have the August Smart lock and love it. Simple to use and the install was easy. For my doorbell I have Eufy. But it doesn’t work with HomeKit so will definitely check out the Logitech.

[@TheBradLloyd]

Thanks for commenting! I'm glad your Wemo switches work well for you! I really wish there was a way to disable that LED light though...

[@SusanMiddleton1]

You should have asked me Brad before you bought Wemo! Haha. Wemo plugs were the second smart home product I bought after a thermostat so that could be 8 or more years ago. Way before Homekit and Hue. They always dropped off and I was constantly resetting them. So they have not improved over the years - too bad. More recently I had a Wemo switch for my porch light which also had connectivity problems and did not fit easily into the 3 gang box. Next was an Eve switch which fit but was not responsive most of the time. Guess what - I ended up with Caseta switch which works perfectly.

[@TheBradLloyd]

It seems we are not alone with the Wemo issues...... Interesting feedback on the Eve switch. I have one that I'm hoping to test out soon. It would also be nice if Eve adds Thread to their switches in the future. Can't argue with Caseta though - they just work! Thanks for watching!

[@SusanMiddleton1]

@@TheBradLloyd I forgot to mention that one of the Eve switches was in my garage. Never worked. It was just to far from my home hub I guess which at that time was my Apple TV. No excuse for the one in my front hall. They might work better with HomePod.

[@mratzelster]

I have had the same inconsistent performance from Wemo. I threw mine away because they were so frustrating.

[@TheBradLloyd]

@@mratzelster It's unfortunate, but seems to be pretty a pretty common experience for most (but not all).

[@kellymjones41]

Here's my adventure with a wemo plug. I had some difficulty setting up the Wemo smart plug with my iPhone even though I followed the instructions exactly. Despite resetting the smart plug to factory defaults, making sure I was 2.4Ghz wifi on all devices, and using both the Wemo app and the Home app separately, neither the Wemo app nor the Home app could find the new device. Here's the workaround I found somewhere on the internet, I should have taken better notes: 1. Reset the Wemo Mini (by pressing and holding the power button and plugging it in - release the power button in about 10 seconds, when the LED starts to blink White - it blinks White after it blinks orange). 2. Note the Setup Code from the label. 3. Open Home App, tap on the '+' sign on the top right, and when it opens the camera to scan your setup label/QR Code, select 'Don't have a code or can't scan' and enter the code manually and retry Setup/Pairing. That worked for me, but I will avoid Wemo in the future.

[@liamgriffith]

Well done for naming and shaming some of the crud products out there, as well as highlighting the good ones. Would definitely add the Meross LED Light Strip to the Avoid category and the Nanoleaf LED Strip to the Buy category. I also wanted to share the 3 basic principles I now abide by after similar experiences 1. Must have native HomeKit integration, 2. Can be manually controlled, 3. Must use Thread or Zigbee for low-powered devices and Ethernet or Wifi (limiting were possible) for powered devices. Would be great to hear your and the community's thoughts on this too. Keep up the good work!

[@TheBradLloyd]

Hi Liam, I agree with the Nanoleaf LED strip, good call! Thanks for sharing your feedback! Your 3 basic principles are solid especially #1 - Homekit! Thread or zigbee is ideal & fast! Sometimes it’s unavoidable to connect with bluetooth or wifi but do carefully consider the connnection technology, especially with low powered/battery operated devices. You’ve got the foundation for a solid smart home!

[@polystormstudio]

I'm curious to know why you think the Meross LED Strip should be avoided. All my smart bulbs are Meross and I just got the light strip. They do what I need them to do, turn on and off on command and by programming them. My only complaint for all of these is they're a pain to set up and forget about controlling the colours with the Homekit app. However the Meross app sets up the colour and brightness fine.

[@liamgriffith]

@@polystormstudio Aside from the two points you mentioned, up until the most recent firmware update, I would get a frequent “No response” status in HomeKit and the strip would inadvertently turn itself off and on. The last two issues have lessened, but I still stand firm with my recommendation not to buy for the points you mentioned, plus the poor colour and low brightness, compared with Nanoleaf, Eve and Hue strips. It’s ok for an inexpensive HK accent light, but not recommend for task or ambient lighting which have increased lumen and/or colour accuracy requirements.

[@thetruthhurtsu]

Sir you nailed it!! I had the wemo plug and I would not stay connected and one day it just stop working. I wasn’t mad at all because I had planned on replacing that plug anyways. Next up is my Vocolinc diffuser. Once (sometimes twice) a month I have to reset it because it won’t stay WiFi connected. Not sure which one is worse, the wemo or Vocolinc, either way I will never spend money on either product ever again.

[@TheBradLloyd]

Totally agree with Wemo, and many others (though not all) seem to agree as well. I haven't had too many issues with the Vocolinc diffuser, though their led strip has been awful.

[@simonpowell]

Great video. I’d agree with everything you said, except I’ve had no issues with the VOCOlinc LS2 Lightstrip

[@TheBradLloyd]

Ok, good to know VOCOlinc light strips are working for you. Thanks for sharing and watching, Simon!

[@Lvmykidos2]

Just started my journey of a smart home. Fortunately, I bought 4 of the Meross SmartPlugs. 2 of them set up easily, had some trouble with the other 2. After some googling, I had to make sure my phone wasn’t connected to the 5 ghz WiFi. After that, they set up. Glad to see these were a good choice in your video even if they are a bit finicky. At first I set up my HomeKit using a much-older iPad as the hub, but yesterday, I bought my first HomePod mini. Needless to say, it will not be the last 1 I buy. 😂 Thank you for your very informative videos. I subscribed.

[@TheBradLloyd]

Hi Michelle! I'm so excited to hear you've started your HomeKit journey! It sounds like you are off to a great start with the HomePod mini and the Meross Smart Plugs. I haven't had the same issue connecting the Meross smart plugs (when your phone is connected to the 5GHz band), but I've heard others that have. Luckily setup is usually just a one-time thing. Now that you have your HP mini, you can also take advantage of some Thread accessories! Creating a smart home is a lot of fun, so enjoy the process!

[@dangreenberg1096]

I LOVE this list! Big thanks to The Brad Lloyd!! 🎉

[@ahgflyguy]

VOCOlinc put out a beta for their L3 bulbs that included adaptive lighting, but that was almost 6 months ago. I’d like that software, since I have several of those bulbs.

[@TheBradLloyd]

For sure, Adaptive lighting is a nice feature. I haven’t tried the VOCOlinc bulbs yet, just the lightstrip. Thanks for sharing!

[@martinpharand2760]

Great list, agree and have most. My favs are Ecobee and Nanoleaf products, the office is an essentials & under bed are two lightrips. I cheat and also use Hoobs. One area of the home that I found lacking was the garage door opener, mine has MyQ but I’ve been playing with the Refoss Smart WiFi Garage door opener AK version that you can pick up for 45-60 depending on Amazon’s mood of the day in Canada in US you get the Meross…The key is to use the Meross app, not the suggested one. It’s simple in its operation and has been solid in my HomeKit setup for 2 months, I’ve also installed a few for friends and neighbours. Who doesn’t want to control their garage door with CarPlay😀

[@TheBradLloyd]

🐝 Ecobee and 🍃Nanoleaf are great choices! I haven’t tried Hoobs out yet but I have been tempted to bring some products (like holiday lights) into Homekit. Maybe this year! Agree, it would be great to see more #Homekit options for the garage door. We also use MyQ and haven’t had any issues. Shane just did an awesome video on the Meross garage door opener if you haven’t checked it out… kzbin.info/www/bejne/e3O7dKmppMhkjpo

[@TheUnofficialMaker]

can Hoobs bring in some hard wired door contacts?

[@martinpharand2760]

@@TheUnofficialMaker Can you “communicate” with those sensors with your phone via an app? If so, it’s possible that the hub that controls those wired sensors could talk to hoobs. Tough to say without more details.

[@TheUnofficialMaker]

@@martinpharand2760 was wondering if the pi hoobs runs on might expose the i/o to HK

[@TheUnofficialMaker]

@@martinpharand2760 i think Homebridge RPi might do the trick!

[@patrick4003]

Good video, I love TP-Link Kasa with Homebridge. Low cost and very good. Inside plugg and Outdoor

[@tomwaid]

I have had pretty much zero issues with my Wemo smart plugs. Have never had to reinstall on HomeKit. I have 5. Once in a great while I have to reset them (normally due to a random power outage). Aqara products have been both good and ok - depending on the device. The alarm/door sensors have worked great. The motion sensors - hit and miss. 2 work perfect, my third one I gave up on after multiple attempts to get it to stay connected. Ugh very frustrating. Great video!

[@TheBradLloyd]

Hi Thomas - Thanks for the comment! Glad to see you have had better luck with Wemo than I have! Aqara has worked well for me. If you are having issues my suggestion would just be making sure your motion sensor isn't too far away from the Hub. I was having some issues that improved once I relocated the Hub.

[@Nick19837]

Hi Brad - I was wondering if you have heard of the Brilliant Smart Home Control Panel? Supposedly it’s compatible with HomeKit. Would love to see a video review if you get the chance.

[@TheBradLloyd]

Thanks for the suggestion Nick. Great idea, I'll see what I can do!

[@marcus3jankowski]

Really like the videos. Could you maybe do a video on dos and don’ts with smart lighting and smart switches. I’m new to all this and am going to start making my house smart. Thanks!

[@neilmackinder2267]

Hey Brad, excellent video! The only issue I’ve got, and not because I found it bad, is with the Logitech doorbell. If only I could purchase one in Canada! I own more than thirty Lutron Caseta light switches and they are definitely the base of my SmartHome system. I have also had Wemo switches and smart plugs and have found them poor as well. I wouldn’t buy anymore of them. Take care and keep putting out great videos!

[@TheBradLloyd]

Hey Neil, I hear you on the Logitech Doorbell. I tried getting information for Logitech on a future release date to Canada but not surprisingly, I didn't get any answers. I'm sure it's only a matter of time because they come to the Canadian market, or we start to see more competition with Matter coming soon. Looks like we have had similar experiences with Wemo and Lutron! Thanks for watching!

[@BryanEsler]

Great list! Been looking at Caseta for some time now and trying to just lay it all out between keeping traditional switches and integrating the Caseta alongside it. That and I've got so many 3-pole switches ... kind of annoying.

[@TheBradLloyd]

You won't be disappointed with Caseta. The Pico remotes are a convenient and cost effective solution for 3-way switches.

[@BryanEsler]

@@TheBradLloyd Thanks Brad. What do you recommend in terms of plates? Most of mine will have either one or two standard flip switches next to them, and I'm not finding any Caseta branded plates that offer that.

[@TheBradLloyd]

@@BryanEsler Hi Bryan - Most of the plates I use are "builder grade", with visible screws. It's on my list to eventually replace them with something more sleek. The Lutron plates are usually only single gang.

[@taylorlightfoot]

@@TheBradLloyd The Lutron switches work very well, I just really wish they'd updater them to use White LED lights instead of green; the green is a little dated and less elegant.

[@swiftaudi]

You know what I hate about the lutron dimmers. No quick flip off the switch without looking. What I love is hey Siri turn on whatever light.

[@myHomeKithome]

Great list Brad! I just got my first Eve Energy with Thread installed and it is FAST! I also use a Meross Outdoor Smart Plug and it has been pretty solid for me controlling my mini pool pump and some outdoor rope lights.

[@TheBradLloyd]

Totally agree! I love that the Eve Energy is full thread as well! I haven't used the Meross Outdoor Smart plug, but may be worth checking out!

[@thebstinger]

I have a few of the Meross double plugs and they always work for me. Very reliable!

[@myHomeKithome]

@@thebstinger i’ve been trying to get rid of nonessential Wi-Fi devices, but yes they are reliable in my experience

[@BrianRouse]

I’d avoid the Insignia garage door opener. The performance is spotty at best, doesn’t stay connected, and sometimes returns an open status when it’s actually closed. Not something you want to see when you’re four hours away from your house.

[@TheBradLloyd]

Such a great point! That would be unsettling if you were away from home and getting the dreaded no response error! Thanks for sharing and watching Brian!

[@thomaslogonran2403]

will the Eve door and window sensor work with the Ecobee thermostat?

[@TheBradLloyd]

For sure.... you could setup an automation to say "when door/window opens, turn the AC off".

Can you, please tell us any recommended led strips for Homekit which could be maybe water-resistant or something like that? As I want some in my bathroom.

[@djl61]

When will you review the available Homekit garage door openers?

[@TheBradLloyd]

Maybe 1 day! I use the MyQ bridge to bring my LiftMaster garage door opener into HomeKit and works great.

[@Jhovan33]

Lutron only works on 110v. Does not work at 220v wired homes.

[@jamessharpe7407]

Great Video! I can vouch for the Level Lock. I had the 1st gen August but it kept losing connection in Homekit and eventually just crapped out. The newer versions may be better but I decided to make the switch to Level and haven't had an issue yet.

[@TheBradLloyd]

Thanks for sharing James! I've heard great feedback with level!

[@Dr_Cole]

I’m having the opposite experience with Level. I use the Bolt and, at first, it was used in my front door. However, my wife did not like replacing her high-end locks and we had to switch it back. That meant my Bolt was relegated to my side gate. I have the new Apple 4K TV within 18 feet of it and a HomePod above it by about 15 feet. Neither work to obtain a connection- AT ALL. I have had to buy a separate HomePod that sits in the corner of my garage immediately on the other side of the gate. What’s worse is that this only permits a 50/50 likely of connection. I am about ready to call it quits with my Bolt. As I’ve heard somewhere, even 98% is not good enough for certain household products.

[@32543219]

I have several two switch light switch panels that incorporate traditional toggle light switches and traditional rotary dimmers. I want to control the traditional toggle light switch ( exterior lights) , and I do not want to replace the functioning dimmers. Any idea where I can find a HomeKit toggle switch similar to the ones available for Google and Alexis home automation?

[@dannybroddy]

Good video, however, I do disagree about the Belkin reliability I haven’t had an issue. I have 3 switches and 10 smart plugs and two outdoor smart plugs. I wonder if you have tried using their hub with it maybe that’s why I am so lucky! I agree with everything else thought great video Brad!

[@TheBradLloyd]

Thanks Danny! Totally respect that and glad to hear that Belkin Wemo products are working well for you! I haven’t used the products with their hub so maybe that would help. Glad you enjoyed the video and I welcome varied opinions and experience. It helps us build an awesome Homekit community to help each other out!

[@dannybroddy]

@@TheBradLloyd don’t get me wrong though, if I had the ability of fore sight, I think I would have way more Caseta switches in my house than I do now. I’ve never had an issue with them! Hue had been very good too. When I first got them in 2016 I was having issues which they have since fixed!

[@SMX815]

Another impeccable video & I like your honest advice on the many HomeKit accessories 🙏😊

[@TheBradLloyd]

I appreciate that! Thanks Simon!

[@MelissaAtwell]

Thanks for sharing this useful list! I totally agree about Belkin Wemo, especially the electrical plug. While I’ve had good Belkin products in the past, their Wemo line of “smart” home products are pretty dumb. Nothing but trouble.

[@TheBradLloyd]

I agree Melissa - I don't like being negative, but many others (not all) have commented that they've had similar experiences, so it's good for people to be aware. Eve Energy is #1 in my experience!

[@crazy55rider7]

I have a ? I would like to install a light dimmer control in an RV it has 120volt AC .But the light control works on DC 12v? What do you think

[@Maged0407]

My Hunter Ceiling Fan stopped working under HomeKit and their own Hunter App. Not sure if it has to do with the software update from Apple. What do you recommend for smart Homekit Ceiling Light/Fan? It here is any Smart Switch for Fan/Light combo?

[@joffs123]

Superb. Thank you.

[@jamalwright7337]

If the nano leave polls have built-in thread do you still need to have a new HomePod mini or a new Apple TV to use the thread?

[@TheBradLloyd]

The Nanoleaf panels are supposed to be a Thread border router (with a future firmware update I believe) so this may be possible, but I think it will need to be tested to be 100% sure!

[@Bigglare]

"Thread HUB" Great video.

[@TheBradLloyd]

Thanks Lawrence!

[@MartinBellamyMBDrums]

This was a great video and also cool because it has Canadian prices! Any recommendations on strip lights??

[@TheBradLloyd]

Thank you! It depends on what you are looking for. If you have a thread border router (like a HP mini), then Nanoleaf Essentials is great, and not too expensive. If you don't have a budget then you can't go wrong with Philips Hue. I have a video on the Onvis light strip which is addressable, though you have to get it from Amazon.com which means USD and duty/import fees. I'm starting to test the Meross light strip now which is reasonably priced so after I've had some time I'll do a video review for that as well.

[@MartinBellamyMBDrums]

@@TheBradLloyd okay that’s awesome, thank you for the info!! Can’t wait for that video. I’m super new to the entire home kit, so I’m still learning :P Cheers from Toronto! I’ll be staying tuned for more videos :)

[@AM2PMReviews]

I love my VOCOlinc lights they work well

[@TheBradLloyd]

Thanks for letting us know. I’m glad to hear they’re working well for you! Appreciate you watching!

[@Rob87]

Biggest difference between Ecobee lite and the regular version is that the full price version can operate your humidifier on your furnace, which is worth the extra price. I am 100% on the same thought as you for door locks, I am holding out for a newer Thread version with apple keys

[@TheBradLloyd]

Yes - good point. The Ecobee Lite also can't control an HRV, but in some cases additional wiring is still required to make that feature work. Hopefully we see some new locks with Thread & Apple Keys before the end of the year!

[@Rapidfire556]

I have a lot of Wemo and like you I had the switch leave homekit and had to re-add it. All the plugs have been phased out for Meross and I'm not having much better luck there either. All that being said, maybe it's the mesh network? Devices on the 2.4ghz on node A while phone is on 5 ghz on node B? No idea.

[@TheBradLloyd]

Hi Craig, it's possible it's a wifi issue, but it shouldn't be an issue with your phone being on 5ghz. Going with something like Hue or Aqara (Zigbee), or Eve (Thread) should help a lot!

[@Rapidfire556]

@@TheBradLloyd thanks, I’ll definitely keep in mind if not give that a try!

[@Adventure.AS.25]

Great video. I followed your link for the Lutron Aurora. I am interested in using this to control Nanoleaf bulbs, however the description and comments on the Amazon Canada page indicates it only works with Hue bulbs. Can you confirm that this will work through the Caseta hub to control the Nanoleaf bulbs?

[@TheBradLloyd]

Hi Ray - Sadly the Aurora only works with Hue. Hoping we get something similar for Nanoleaf soon!

[@eduardosandoval8303]

My experience with Wemo is really bad. My VOCOlinc lightbulbs were not working well until I added a mesh wifi now they work fine including the light strip (I was demanding to much on my router).

[@TheBradLloyd]

Yes, thanks for sharing. I think routers/wifi can often be the issue. And the more Wi-Fi devices we add the more strain on the network.

[@davidbucklin3986]

Thanks… I enjoy your analysis Your doing a great job…. Thanks

[@TheBradLloyd]

Thanks so much David, I appreciate the feedback!

[@mavirek]

Have you done a comparison of Eve and VOCOlinc contact sensors? From a newbies POV it appears Eve is the high end and VOCOlinc is the budget option. My experience with VOCOlinc contact sensors so far is they go "offline" because they rely on Bluetooth, which is problematic. (I have to stand in front of my door for it to even show up as "online" on my iPhone.) So I was worried I'd have to switch over to Eve for better performance--but they are expensive. (It's also confusing because while you included So first, I ordered a HomePod Mini--arriving some time today--in hopes that it would cure the "offline" trouble; and I'd get all those other perks with the Mini that you have explained in your videos.

[@TheBradLloyd]

Hi Mavirek, The newest Eve contact sensors work so well because they use Thread. The HP mini is a Thread border router. The Vocolinc sensors use BLE so you won't get the benefits of Thread unfortunately. If you need something reliable, Eve is worth the money. A budget option would be Aqara, but you will need a Hub. Hope that helps.

[@jprichardson8050]

Brad. Any suggestions for outdoor porch, outdoor garage and outdoor light post smart color bulbs? I am in Rochester, NY so like you I need to consider the cold winter months and if the bulbs will be able to take the freezing temps.

[@TheBradLloyd]

Hi JP - Unfortunately I don't have much advice to offer. Philips hue has a line of outdoor rated lights, but I don't specifically see temperature ratings They are pricey but probably your best bet. I'm hoping to test some basic bulbs this winter. I'm in Southern Ontario so similar weather.

[@jprichardson8050]

@@TheBradLloyd yeah. Those Phillips are more fixtures. Not looking to replace fixtures. Just bulbs. LOL. Thanks.

[@MrWetrek]

What lights do you use for your TV?

[@roycelabor4339]

Great review Sir! You've definitely improved my smart home to buy list!

[@TheBradLloyd]

Thanks Royce! Great to hear it helped.

[@roycelabor4339]

@@TheBradLloyd My pleasure! Now I have to figure out how to get my wife's iPhone to sync! LOL

[@mratzelster]

Do you think it's better to spend the $$$ for the doorbell you reviewed or to get a Ring Pro for much cheaper and have to figure out how to get it to connect into Homekit?

[@TheBradLloyd]

Just my opinion, but I think native to HomeKit is always better when possible. With Matter, we should see more competition and more supported products in general, so I expect less expensive options will come.

[@walleyeye]

Totally agree about belkin wemo products. I use wemo light switches and they just disappear when they want and are a BIG pain to reinstall!!! COME ON BELKIN WEMO!!!

[@TheBradLloyd]

I hear you Thor - I have the same issues with Wemo.

[@garyschoolcraft4797]

Now that Eve door and window has thread. I can put one in my mailbox and set up “YOU’VE GOT MAIL” when the mailman drops off the mail. Awesome.

[@TheBradLloyd]

That's awesome Gary! I would love to see that!

[@mikerulon]

Voco link is a mess with their power strips also and my Kwikset lock is unreliable also please let me know when you find a lock you like

[@TheBradLloyd]

Thanks for sharing and yes - I will! Hoping for a Thread lock soon!

[@ModMINI]

I just got a couple Premis (like two days before watching this video - one was unreliable but works better with a hub nearby (homepod, iPad or Apple TV 4th gen)

[@TheBradLloyd]

@@ModMINI Glad it's working better with a Hub close by. Mine are ok.... just not as reliable as needed for a lock. Also heavy on batteries. They will do until I come across a Thread enabled door lock.

[@MLSpr]

I thought Aurora wasn’t actually exposed to Homekit and only worked in the Hue app. I also wish I could use these or something like it with Nanoleaf Essentials.

[@TheBradLloyd]

Hey Matthew, thanks for watching. You’re right the Aurora isn’t exposed to Homekit but because hue is, it works great. The main benefit is that the light switch remains in the ON position allowing you to control your hue smart lights with Siri or the physical dimmer on the wall. I couldn’t agree more that a product like this that is compatible with Nanoleaf essentials would be great!

[@derrickrudolph4819]

Great video Brad! I think this may be my favorite to date. I have either already invested in or have all of your top 7 on my HomeKit Wishlist. I’ve wanted the Logitech Circle View doorbell for quite sometime. However, as you mentioned, it is not available in Canada. I do plan to purchase one in Orlando when we visit Disney World in May. I did however pickup the Logitech Circle View Security Camera yesterday and can’t wait to get it setup! Thanks for another great video! I’m looking forward to the Motion Sensor comparison video you’re working on. Keep up the great work!

[@TheBradLloyd]

Thanks Derrick, glad you enjoyed it. I've heard good reviews on the Logitech camera, so I think it should work well for you. It would be great if the doorbell would come to Canada before May, but at least you have that to fall back on. Should be a fun trip though. It must feel great to have travel plans again!

[@derrickrudolph4819]

@@TheBradLloyd - Absolutely! We originally booked our Disney trip for April of 2020. Of course the parks were closed as the pandemic hit in March that year. Just a few weeks before we were scheduled to leave. So my family and I have been waiting for quite a while to visit Disney World. We’re so excited!

[@JamesJohnson-em9pc]

What do you think about the Leviton WiFi switch

[@TheBradLloyd]

I’ve heard mixed reviews, but never tried them personally.

[@kristinotto102]

Ugh yes the WeMo mini plugs are the bane of my existence. I really need to replace them at some point, they go unresponsive at least once a week.

[@TheBradLloyd]

Boy do I ever know what you mean. It’s really unfortunate. Hopefully you can replace them soon!

[@ModMINI]

I have a few older plugs that require the Wemo Homekit bridge. Even that goes unresponsive. It's gotten so bad that I use a non Wemo smart plug to reboot it once a week!

[@johndwhite1972]

This was very useful information. I subscribed!

[@TheBradLloyd]

Thank you John!

[@eduardosandoval8303]

My whole house is HomeKit and the Wemo switches that I had I completely replaced them because they were really bad.

[@Nogi-aka-DJNugz]

Great video - would you need the nano leaf bulbs with the caseta switches?

[@TheBradLloyd]

No need for a smart switch. Often smart switches cause issues with smart bulbs so best to leave it alone. You could always add a smart button like flic or an Aqara mini switch if you wanted to.

[@nicolelalondebourgeois4394]

thank you for this. I am not high tech and thought it was I who just could not get the memo. It is worthless. Most frustrating.

[@TheBradLloyd]

Totally agree Nicole - definitely not just you 😊

[@anthonycraig274]

Can you connect Eve weather with ecobee.

[@ArasPundys]

I think I'll wait on locks until the Key feature is actually implemented. Don't want to buy a new lock just because.

[@TheBradLloyd]

That totally makes sense Aras!

[@Us_and_themm]

Do you know any door/ window sensor for outside 🙏🏼

[@TheBradLloyd]

No, I don’t…But you are right - why not?!? I could think of some great uses for outdoor sensors!

[@Us_and_themm]

@@TheBradLloyd yeah me too. Especially on shed doors and garden gates 🤷‍♀️

[@islandsnow]

Oh the ecobee3 lite doesn’t work with room sensors?

[@TheBradLloyd]

Yes - they just don't come with the thermostat so would need to be purchased separately.

[@islandsnow]

@@TheBradLloyd wait so they do work just need to purchase separately? That’s fine. I thought they didn’t work at all with the 3 lite

[@TheBradLloyd]

@@islandsnow Exactly. The room sensors just aren't included.

[@ojasray1]

What is the best way to configure homekit, for a family? So when someone says, "turn my room lights off" it knows which room lights to turn off...

[@TheBradLloyd]

If you want to say "turn off my lights" and have Siri know where you are, then you would want a HomePod in that room. The HP (mini) is assigned a room, so when you ask it to turn the lights off, it will know the room you are referring to. Creating zones in HomeKit is also a helpful way of naming areas you want your lights off. Hope that helps!

[@anthonycraig274]

This is such a great help.

[@NaffyD92]

Gotta disagree with the opinion on Wemo. I feel they're actually better than Meros. Their 3 way light switch is fantastic and I used their single light switches in our bedroom and they're fantastic. There is an occasional hick up but it's easily fixable with a simple resetting of the wifi. I'm curious if your wifi signal just isn't the best and is causing your issues? Used to have some issues with Netgear as our router and switch to a much better TP Link router to improve overall signal for our home. Suggesting a switch that costs double the wemo just because it's 2% more reliable seems pretty ridiculous. Typically you'd only want a smart switch in a few locations at most: main living space, Kitchen, and master bedroom. All other areas could be easily addressed by using another product you mentioned: The Nanoleaf essentials lightbulb. I use these for our outdoor lighting (Garage, entrance, and back porch) and they can be easily paired in homekit to function based off of a homekit enables security device (like eufy security cameras). Strongly recommend people give the Amazon starter kit from Wemo a chance. You get a lightswitch and a smart plug for just $40. If you go with Casada switches you're gonna end up spending $60 on the switch alone. If you have prime, give Wemo a shot....this is bad press IMO and I'd hate for people to waste money.

[@mystiquemetal]

I've had Wemo smart plugs for years and they always work. One thing I've done is set static IP in my wifi antenna for these plugs so they always get the same IP address assigned. otherwise, no complaints. Maybe this is how to make these things work all the time. however, I did struggle until this became my go-to practice with wifi devices. Hopefully, this helps anybody

[@TheBradLloyd]

Great suggestion - worth a try!

[@fatpigleung]

Sorry to ask, I lost confidence of these automation devices. I successfully set up a switch and a few Honeywell thermostats with HomeKit, they worked well for a few months, then they become offline and I have to set up from beginning again. I have a Amazon plug, it also worked for one month or two, then become offline. I tried to forgot the device and set up again, it just died. I have some plugs of other brands that work with alexia, also worked for a month or two, then I need to set up again. I just got annoyed, I am busy dealing with smart devices failed. The more I used, the more trouble. Do you guys have these problems? I am using fiber network and all computer devices had no problem with internet.

[@TheBradLloyd]

Wow, I can see why you would feel discouraged. I can't speak to Amazon devices, but in general, that should not happen. You said you have Fiber, so your internet is strong, but make sure you have a solid WiFi router as well. You may also want to try some non-wifi devices like Zigbee and Thread and see how well that works. Good luck!

[@Famousjack]

Sad to say I bught all Wemo light and plugs in each room my house and a good portion do not work at time and require firmware updates. And do not work with HomeKit.

[@TheBradLloyd]

Ouch..... I feel your pain. Their new Thread switch is supposed to be much better I hear.

[@RyDawg96]

I also have the VOcolinc flowerbud and the RGB lighting is shockingly inaccurate.

[@TheBradLloyd]

I wouldn't disagree with that. For what I use it for (some fun light in my daughters room, and oil diffuser), it's no big deal - but 100% agree about the colour accuracy.

[@mattgoepper1800]

What WiFi router do you recommend for HomeKit?

[@TheBradLloyd]

Hi Matt - many good options - but will refer you to a great video Shane Whatley did on this topic. Hope it helps. kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z6jXdKSBopKohrc

[@schneideris]

I have a very automated home and was using the Netgear Orbi wifi mesh, but with mixed success and major frustrations. Recently I moved to a Asus AIMesh setup that supports Wifi6 (not WiFi6e) and the results are significantly better. The router is so important as you add more and more devices.

[@TheNameOfJesus]

The Eve Weather device has an operating range that goes down to only -18C (0 Fahrenheit), which means it's not viable for most places in Canada. It might even get permanently damaged below -18C. The same thing is probably true for most smart doorbells.

[@TheBradLloyd]

I’ll be putting that to the test this winter for sure. There typically aren’t many days where it gets that low, but enough to test it out.

[@TheNameOfJesus]

@@TheBradLloyd That's nice of you, thanks. The value of -18C is probably the point where they stop warrantying its functions. It will probably work fine at some lower temperatures. I wonder if it records the minimum temperature internally so they can know that the user voided its warranty. :-)

[@patrickincalgaryv1502]

I've had my ring doorbell for about 5 years here in Calgary and its seen -30c every year and -35c several times. its powered thru the doorbell wiring, but for some reason the battery needs charging at least twice each winter. but I still wouldn't get another one due to its really slow response time and multiple false alarms daily, even after adjusting the range and pattern.

[@robsfungaming9722]

Nice video but I’m surprised that you have issues with the light strip with VOCOlinc. I have one behind my book shelf and so far I never had issues with it. I’ve have it for almost a year and was my first HomeKit accessory.

[@TheBradLloyd]

Hi Robert, funny how that happens. Many have had issues like me, but for some it works totally fine. Glad it’s working well for you, I hope it continues to hold up!

[@trumankong7053]

Wemo are bad, I bought 4 of them and from time to time, they lost connection with wifi and became unresponsive. Which is very annoying

[@robertpozderec]

Great list. I’ve been into HomeKit for years and this is very accurate.

[@TheBradLloyd]

Thanks Robert!

[@elmedia1532]

I want to put a lot of emphasis on WiFi. I lived in an older house for many years with Hue and all Wifi switches working 98% of the time. Moved to a new neighborhood with over 48 neighboring signals and 97% used 2.4Ghz band! Nothing worked or responded half the time. I removed over 24 Wifi devices to Lutron or other based hubs like Aqara, now I am 100% working 100% of the time. I run every end device now like laptops, gaming consoles, TV, etc. that I can on 5Ghz wifi 4-6. Only have 3 2.4Ghz Wifi homekit devices.

[@Pincapybara]

Well colored homepod minis are here

[@TheBradLloyd]

So true! Doing a giveaway here: kzbin.info/www/bejne/f2GanZt7hLprndk

[@coletc]

Lutron Caseta is a bad recommendation for switches because they are outrageously expensive. I think they even require hubs. I’ll take your word for it on reliability, having not owned them. I’ve been adding Meross switches throughout my house. They work every single time, fast, and roughly $20/each. A basic Lutron switch is $60. Why pay that? I get it if you had a good experience with them but man that’s a rough recommendation. Chuh-Ching!

[@TroyForbesvideo]

Avoid the Rachio lawn watering system . They have had problems maintaining homekit connection. Tech-support says they have been working on it. They have promised the solution is right around the corner for years.

[@TheBradLloyd]

Thanks for sharing this Troy! Good to know!

[@samuelgomez974]

Wait what? Nanoleaf essentials being Calle bright with vibrant colors? I love their panels but their bulbs are one of the worst if not the worst out there for brightness and color saturation

[@TheBradLloyd]

Thanks for sharing! I find them the colours to be great, for my use at least. Not at the level of Hue, but for the price I think they do well!

[@tommygraham1990]

Wemo was the only reliable smart plug I could find.

[@TheBradLloyd]

Interesting... I'm glad to hear it works for you. I've heard that some have had success. Thanks for watching!

[@stevengeorges9046]

I am disappointed at the number of devices that don’t have Thread! There should be a warning label on any device that claims to be HomeKit compatible but didn’t bother to include Thread.

[@philmeers5824]

Really disappointed in my Nanoleaf. They are just too much trouble. It’s in a place I can’t reach easily. Bad call

[@swiftaudi]

I can’t get the august Wi-Fi lock to work with home kit. It works perfectly in the august app but if I can’t tell Siri to unlock my door who cares.

[@TheBradLloyd]

Not sure Thomas. All I can suggest is a factory reset and try again. If that doesn't work, try contacting August for support.

[@swiftaudi]

@@TheBradLloyd I reset it, turned off Wi-Fi and connected it using the home app instead of the august app. It took three Tries.

[@TheBradLloyd]

@@swiftaudi glad you got it to work. I’ve had trouble adding devices to HomeKit but usually once added you’re good to go.

[@El_Guap]

So you got 7 of the 10 Homekit accessories made?

[@TheBradLloyd]

Haha yes. And many in between!

[@jet1708]

LIFX is awesome for HomeKit.

[@ClashofTitans001]

Sorry but Nanoleaf Essential bulbs are total crap. I have used three A19 Bulbs; they drop connection after sometime. You have to reset the Nanoleaf bulbs and add them to HomeKit all over again. After sometime it becomes frustrating. By the way, i have a HomePod Mini and Apple TV on Thread nearby. Long story short, I have ditched Nanoleaf products and moved over to Philips Hue with hub. Abit pricey but they work beautifully. Over the last 6 months, I have zero connection issues with Philips Hue bulbs.

[@kevtechs]

I did not expect this man to talk like this I’m weak af 😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@karthiktulasi7474]

I bought a couple of Nanoleaf lights and a lightstrip …disappointed is the best i could say

[@TheBradLloyd]

Thanks for leaving your feedback Karthik. Mine have been good. Can you expand on your disappointment? Curious if others have noticed the same.

[@karthiktulasi7474]

@@TheBradLloyd as I said I bought 2 lightbulbs for Living room. They started fine but never connected correctly with Homekit and would always get the ‘not responding error’. I had to go to Nanoleaf app to reset the connection and it would work okay for a while and then start issues again until a point where they just stopped working completely. The light strip was bad from the start…I had trouble connecting the lightstrip apater to the Led strip …and when I got it it would just come loose every once in a while even when glued together with a cellotape. Never reliable. I got rid of all three of them and just are sitting in my storage now 🙁

[@EduardoRamos-lx2eq]

Wemo switches are awesome. Must be your WiFi

[@TheBradLloyd]

My dissatisfaction with WeMo seems to be shared by many others, but it’s good to know they work well for some others!

[@gusmoser8974]

Logitech Circle video doorbell not recommended in cities with constant high temps over 98 degrees Living in Las Vegas the camera shuts down , showing it needs to cool down, happens all the time. Our temp were nearing 100 & will reach 115 degrees in the shade, night temp will stay above 98 degrees making the camera use less. Logitech has agreed and is refunding the cost, as I got the camera in December and worked fine till it became hot. It took lots of strong arming them until they cried uncle Please note it does not work in the heat, other times it’s great. Just got the ARLO video doorbell works fine ,so do my Eufy cameras in direct Sun exposure But ARLO doorbell does not support HomeKit unless you buy the ARLO hub $100 plus add cost, but still will not record and save to apple. Good marketing as all of this is not mentioned in their site. So not truly HomeKit compatible Buyers beware

[@GHinWI]

Trying to wrap my head around the absurdity of using a smartphone to turn on the sprinkler!

[@TheBradLloyd]

It can be really useful! Using HomeKit in general, not just a smart phone.

[@anthonycraig274]

The only Eve product I wouldn’t recommend is their proximity sensor. It’s big and ugly and very expensive.

[@garypleasant3116]

Yep, don’t invest in Wemo. All of my light switches and many of my outlets are fitted with Wemo products. Constantly devices missing and I often have to disable Wemo skill and reenable on Alexa.

[@TheBradLloyd]

Yes, sadly I agree. Hopefully they can improve their products in the future.

[@Filipe_2004]

Philips hie should be on avoid because of the price 😂😂😂 and aqara should be in the good because of the price too 😂😂😂 but cool review

[@TheBradLloyd]

Hi Filipe - I still like Philips Hue but agree it's over-priced and the competition has really caught up. I'm getting more into Aqara and pretty happy what you get for the price. Thanks for sharing!

[@Filipe_2004]

@@TheBradLloyd yes :) i’m really happy with aqara and their reliability :) i even have an aqara door lock and all of their products are cool cheap easy and work all of the time :p

[@nicholas790]

You missed Philips Hue….I hate them! No response randomly, slow to respond and way overpriced! I’ve switched to the Nanoleaf brand. No bridge and zero issues plus they load quickly and use thread.

[@TheBradLloyd]

I like Nanoleaf as well, but my only issue with Hue is they are expensive. My Hue reliability has been 2nd to none so surprised to hear that.