Trying the FAMOUS STEAK PIE at GUY FAWKES birthplace in YORK!

I'm in York! I finally managed to get there after plenty of deliberating and I start my journey at the Guy Fawkes Inn which I've been recommended by so many of you who either live in York or have given it a go.
Please don't forget to like and subscribe to the channel!
/ @garyeats

[@philipmckeon8944]

I’m delighted you took the price into consideration even though the meal was delicious. Some people who don’t know what it’s like to have to live on a budget simply don’t understand. That’s ok. You can’t keep everyone happy but you sure try and do a great job. Thanks for this one. 👍

[@GaryEats]

Most of the time, I like to keep the price into consideration as it's part of the meal. Thanks Philip, really kind and appreciative of you.

[@garyblack2389]

Many people are on a budget now, a lot are even eating £1 iceland basic ready made meals sadly. Really they need to learn how to cook and make several meals for the freezer.

[@lindsayjohnston7465]

Everyone deserves to treat themselves once in a while

[@tonyphotiou1742]

The star rating you are supposed to give when reviewing needs to take into consideration all aspects of the meal. Price being one of them, product itself, service, value for money etc. Sometimes when I see 1 star reviews, that annoys me because that assumes everything was bad. Generally, those reviewers have had a bad opinion on service for example, and gave an overall rating of 1. The meal may have been good, price OK, but because for whatever reason they got bad service, they trashed the whole score. So yes, price needs to be taken into consideration as far as the overall review

[@RichieW]

My new favourite channel!

[@GaryEats]

You're my new favourite person, lol.

[@mrn13]

I can say that when I visit England/UK this is exactly what I want to eat! Regarding the price, if its all made from scratch and served in a "historical" place below 20£ is quite acceptable. If it was priced under 15, I would expect prefabricated ingredients...

[@GaryEats]

That's fair enough. It's hard to judge but I would say for the price, it was a little bit much but the ingredients were excellent!

[@sneer0101]

Not sure if you're going off American prices or something, but between 10-15 quid you'd still expect decent quality

[@johnavast5939]

@mrn13 great response! I love your comment about "prefab ingredients" I am going to use that now :) lol It is so true- I don't mind paying for real food and food made right then with real ingredients- not frozen or bagged, etc. Good call :)

[@manoo422]

If you think you can cook a pie like this from scratch in less than 30 min you are dreaming. Of course they are 'prefabricated', probably part cooked and finished to order.

[@mrn13]

@@manoo422 😆Off course not- from scratch means all the elements made "in-house". If I order a 4 hour beef stew made from scratch, I dont expect to wait 4 hours for it man!

[@jamesdobson5022]

Remember you are not just paying for the food !!! You would be happy to pay that for a steak !!! And there is a lot more skill and effort into making that pie than simply cooking a steak !!! Great video as always !!!

[@robertleach9120]

Oh my word Gary that pie looked amazingly good ! Granted there wasn't a lot of mash & the price was a little high for what I would pay but as you said, it's a tourist haven and the uniqueness of it being Guy Fawkes' birth place does "allow" them to price accordingly. My wife & love York and have been there numerous times on our 2018 & 2023 UK holidays. So much history and glorious architecture to view ! Enjoy your time away from London in "God's Country" & I look forward to your next video. Take care !

[@GaryEats]

Hi Robert. Yes, the pie looked brilliant. Probably one of the nicest looking meals I've had in a long time! Appreciate that, have a good one my frined!

[@rationalbacon5872]

All those costs arising from government regulations in trade make the price at the guy fawkes inn truly ironic.

[@martindunstan8043]

Evening Gary 👍that was one hell of a pie. The amount of mash probably wouldn't be an issue if it had come with a bit of veg. Looked super tasty and yes maybe £15 is nearer the mark. Nice one✌️🍻

[@GaryEats]

Absolutely agree with you Martin. Hope you’re having a good evening!

[@martindunstan8043]

@@GaryEats thanks👍

[@juliemcgarty4764]

Thanks for the video Gary pie looked really nice I love watching your videos

[@GaryEats]

Glad you enjoyed it and thank you Julie. Means a lot.

[@paulg0170]

Glad this Chanel is growing. Great review and camera work.

[@GaryEats]

Much appreciated! I will pass on your nice comments to the cameraman!

[@TelThePower]

Wow, What a Pie! However unfortunately they were tight for the price... Some green beans, couple of pieces of broccoli and Cauliflower, oh & another scoop of mash! Then I'd say it would have been a 10 all day long... I thought your score & price analysis of £15 was spot on Gary for what you got mate... Great review, looking forward to more! Oh & i watched the Imperial arms Sunday roast vlog you done, that was definitely a 10 👍

[@GaryEats]

Yes, it was excellent! I pretty much agree with what you said. Ah yes, the Imperial Arms has an excellent Sunday Roast - one to go to if you're nearby!

[@andrewbowley6869]

Totally agree 👍

[@andrewbowley6869]

Sorry, I agree about the veg but £20 for a freshly baked stunning pie at an historical pub in York?? Day out, magical day because York is that. Pay it, keep the pub and York going

[@richardd1329]

Whenever we are over in the UK on vacation from Canada, we always spend a day in York, and this is our place to go to for lunch. My wife and I always have the fish butty and have never been disappointed. After seeing this review if I am back there again, it will be the steak pie for me. I love everything about this pub, the atmosphere, the beer and the food. Also considering its location I don't think the prices are too bad.

[@GaryEats]

York is a lovely city so I don't blame you for going there. Please do try the pie, you will love it!

[@jrobinsdna]

That pie as a treat and it looked a treat I'd say a 9 out of 10 as you were completely blown away after all

[@GaryEats]

It was excellent

[@peterkops6431]

Can’t beat a good pie Gary! 👍🏻🇦🇺👍🏻

[@GaryEats]

I agree completely Peter 👍🇦🇺👍

[@andrewburton9643]

Pie looked amazing, pastry looked class and choka full of meat but slightly stingy on the mash. Love your diversity in choice of meals, always trying something different and lots of different locations. Excellent, interesting videos, keep up the outstanding work. As always after watching one of your vids... hungry again now 😂👍

[@GaryEats]

Thank you Andrew! I do try to do a few different places and not always the same as it gives a bit of variety doesn’t it? Makes it more interesting for you to watch. On the meal, yes I completely agree with you!

[@mattmorris6740]

I must say, that pie looked incredible, definitely need some veg along with it especially for that price. York is bloody expensive though.

[@GaryEats]

It was both good and expensive. Thanks for watching!

[@Jan-iq5sm]

Needs veg included . Veg is still inexpensive. . I think it’s a bit pricey . It’s not a difficult dish to cook .

[@nickycotton6137]

Aye, Peas or Mushy 1's would've sufficed.

[@martinhodgson2303]

Inspired by your video Gary so my wife and I went to the Guy Fawkes when we were in York last week. She had the steak pie and I had the vegan one and they were both superb - loved them! What a meal. As you say, outrageously good, the flavour was so good! And good beer too! Thanks for the review!

[@GaryEats]

That’s so good to hear Martin 👌

[@BusinessButlers]

As a York resident and also a former B&B landlady, I would never have recommended that place to any of my guests despite your comments. There is only one place to really appreciate good food in York, and I know you like steaks - so if you come back to York, try out The Whippet Inn on North Street. However, their steaks match their prices - highish and not budget. I do not think they do lunchtimes though, so it would have to be an evening. Hahaha - you need to learn to love mushrooms, Gary. You do not know what you are missing. And York folk don't like extra service charges even tho that bar is only frequented by tourists, not residents. Keep up the good work, I enjoy your reviews. * And no I am not a bot, I am a genuine human being living in Huntington a part of York.

[@GaryEats]

Thank you very much. I’ve tried to love mushrooms but I can’t. Unfortunately, the Whippet was very busy when we went in so couldn’t do a review unfortunately!

[@glenn5328]

That’s a really good review. The pie looks first class. I personally like mushrooms. It’s an acceptable price for the location. If Tom Kerridge or Gordon Ramsay or another TV chef baked that you would be paying £40 plus.

[@GaryEats]

You’re spot on Glenn 🤣

[@user-zx1pc9eq8w]

My adoptive father is from York. He eats steak pie regularly, made at least weekly by his cook. The steak pie in this video looks just like it.

[@GaryEats]

Ah lovely, the best kind of pies!

[@lisabudd5979]

Heritage and themed menu .this place is fantastic. And The out side street is stunning ,like a story book. Food is wonderful ,the home made meals are wonderful. 10 🇦🇺😊

[@GaryEats]

So nice in there Lisa. Lovely place to go!

[@kettethomas4603]

You know it's good when you start to nod your head involuntarily.

[@GaryEats]

It's superb!!

[@stephaniewhite9526]

The pie seemed amazing. I could probably even overcome my own mushroom phobia with this too. But I completely agree with the price aspect. No pie is worth £20 in a pub and the portion of mash was really small. My grading (from look alone) would be a massive 10 for the pie but overall 7-8. I so enjoyed the review and its the only time I have seen a menu where all the food is Guy Fawkes which was a You Tube first. Thank you once again Gary for another amazing review.

[@GaryEats]

Hi Stephanie. Completely agree with you - I really enjoyed the theme behind the inn as well. Lovely little place and thank you so much.

[@Bebe777333]

It looks fantastic!

[@GaryEats]

It was!

[@siobhanblake9150]

I don't eat meat, but I would absolutely go to this place based on the review. I'm sure they're bound to have some great veggie options too. Thanks as always Gary!

[@richjjames7462]

Gary according to my calculations 30k views on a video will net you about 70 dollars. You have travel expenses such as petrol and the meal to pay for. This is to say nothing of your fabulous sound engineer and camera man. Or, overnight stays. Gary you are a legend let's see you hitting 60k in 2024. Much love and merry Christmas

[@GaryEats]

Have a wonderful Christmas!

[@spizzenergi2292]

These days I wish Mr. Fawkes had been successful.

[@michaelcrowhurst3722]

That must be one of the finest looking pies I have ever seen!

[@GaryEats]

Spot on Michael. Pictures alone it looked incredible!

[@46joe]

This pie could easily be created at home at a fraction of the cost......Its basically a slow cooked stew wrapped in pastry.......try it...!

[@fogartym77]

But then Gary wouldn't give us these reviews! Some of us do like to eat out now and again 👍

[@navidbutt-inflammationwiza1983]

10:17 Gary, I do like your reviews. And, I'm glad you're rethinking your scoring system. Which to me is slightly out - a little too generous. Me thinks paying customers like you and I often deserve better..

[@GaryEats]

Thank you. I’ve changed it a little bit reflect VFM a bit more - it needed a bit of a rework. Thanks for noticing!

[@ginasmith9489]

Pie looked delicious but expensive…. Great video again thank you Gary 💕

[@GaryEats]

Thank you for watching!

[@nigelpowton9509]

Wow, that pie was to die for! As I've said before I don't have a big appetite and I would have found the pie a little too large for me. Personally I would have preferred a smaller pie and more mash to create a more balanced plate of food, (with a price reduction to align with this). Regarding price, I've always found central York to be on the high side as it is a prime tourist area and vendors know they can squeeze out that little bit more from people's wallets. Another great review though!

[@GaryEats]

Indeed Nigel. Thank you!

[@sonyavincent7450]

When there's that much filling in a pie, the whole experience almost becomes a casserole. Needed a green vegetable but nearly perfect. ❤

[@GaryEats]

Very true!

[@roger_melly5025]

Great channel Gary - I love how you take everything into account - presentation, flavour, value for money, ambience etc. That pie looks amazing 😋😋😋

[@GaryEats]

Thank you kindly Roger.

[@rolffigueiredo3786]

Evening Gary , what a delicious looking pie . Two things, you mentioned the Royal Standard in Beaconsfield . The sausages which you had were probably made from organic pork , the mash might have been made from freshly baked potatoes, and the onions probably gently cooked in the butter for around 50-60 minutes to properly bring out their flavour. Right so today you’re in York in the aptly named Guy Fawkes public house trying out their steak pie. My guess , to get meat cooked very tender it takes a very long time. Taking into account where the Chef is putting his skill , sourcing, adding, tasting is in itself a true accolade .. In both places of very similar quality and surroundings . I would easily have paid the money and a Mr. Andrew Baker has pipped me to the real point. Love your show. Good luck and God bless. ❤

[@GaryEats]

Hello there. Yep, completely understand your point and I have no complaints about the pie. It was excellent! Thank you and you too!

[@seank2359]

Love the shirt very sharp 😸

[@aurora9426]

It really brings out the blue in his eyes 😻

[@GaryEats]

Thank you Sean! Makes a change from the disasters that are my outfits. Haha.

[@GaryEats]

Hahaha thank you Aurora.

[@stevebriggs2645]

Good video Gary again 👍.Pie looked delicious but l would have expected more mash and some veggies to accompany it,also a bit pricey for a pie in my opinion.

[@GaryEats]

Thanks 👍 Completely agree with you Steve.

[@markbull7757]

Without vegetables that does not qualify as a good plate of food. Great channel, many thanks to you.

[@GaryEats]

Many many thanks and fair enough Mark

[@jefffrancis6920]

Omg. That pastry. What a pie of legends.

[@GaryEats]

It was an excellent pie and cooked to order so perfect 👌

[@pkyid]

Guy Fawkes had the right idea looking at all politicians these days! Superb video again. £19.95 for that isnt bad the pie was chock full of meat

[@chrisbutcher3280]

We need a new guy fawkes

[@kiranpatel6521]

He was a terrorist you clown! Like the IRA! Fenian sympathiser!

[@GaryEats]

Thank you my friend, I really appreciate it!

[@AllanNeaves-qn3zr]

Evening Gary,another pub/ restaurant crammed with history and character. That pie looked amazingly tasty 😊 Very small portion of mashed potatoes 😢I found the " garnish " a very strange mixture 😮. A vegetable would have been nice😊.I'm not a political person,and the fact they(?) failed to blow up Parliament, as my teachers said " must try harder "Before the price, another son of York Dick Turpin ( a real highwayman)by the way hung as a horse thief,and not as a highwayman, using his mums maiden name😢I digress. For a pie 🥧 however good,still top heavy 😢 A good first stop on our journey. Again CTP should have been out & about on the Knavesmire getting the local flavours, well he can't get it on expenses 😢To the gallows, and the next stop 🛑 😊❤Allan&Family

[@GaryEats]

Thanks Allan. Hope you're doing well, glad you liked the Pie. If you say it's good, it's definitely good!

[@steved7961]

Dick Turpin ended his days in York but was born and raised in Essex.

[@AllanNeaves-qn3zr]

@@steved7961 I bow to your greater knowledge. But I think his horse was local??

[@steved7961]

@@AllanNeaves-qn3zrThanks. Unlike Dick, I was actually born in York and wish I were still there.

[@AllanNeaves-qn3zr]

@@steved7961 Always have a goal in life. A small lottery win could help.Or become a Highwayman! Stay safe and dream Allan&Family

[@iamatwinnie]

LOOKED AMAZING. iM STAYING THERE IN 3 WEEKS..AND HAVE STAYED A FEW TIMES BUT NEVER HAD THE PIE. tHINK i WILL DEFINATELY TRY IT THIS TIME XX

[@jonathanmarkbotterell1926]

.......that pie looked incredible. The price reflected the venue in this case. I'm a sucker for historical pubs. 😎🌟

[@GaryEats]

Me too 👍🏼👍🏼

[@DrFrankLondon]

Never been, but after seeing this, I have to try it, mate! But I think I will have to ask for extra mash and have a stronger beer. Fantastic to see you up in York and looking forward to more reviews from Yorkshire! Fabulous review as always, Gary and enjoy the stay in Yorkshire. 😀 BTW I would expect to pay that in York and Whitby, but not in Leeds for instance..

[@GaryEats]

I had a feeling you'd like this mate, did think of you during the video! Really appreciate it, hope you're doing well. Still have Leeds on the list - Whitby will be some point next year! Cheers again :)

[@sheilam4525]

Looked like there was a lot of eating in that pie and beautifully presented too👍

[@GaryEats]

Was an excellent pie, Sheila. Thanks for watching!

[@thereyougo4931]

Totally agree Gary. The mark should reflect not just the taste but price and value for money. Not harsh at all.

[@GaryEats]

Thanks mate 👍🏼

[@shirleyadamscorbett5724]

This was a joy. The Steak pie was amazing and so filling. It was huge. We wished we hadn't had a starter as we couldn't finish the pie itself. We would definitely go again. We would give it a 10.

[@GaryEats]

That’s absolutely fantastic to hear Shirley lovely x

[@norriaty]

I remember staggering out of York District Hospital in a daze after my wife had given birth to my son and straight into this pub for a pint and a whisky! Always a fondness for the place but it’s a bit of a tourist trap so generally avoid it unfortunately. Can’t deny pie looked great though!

[@GaryEats]

The pie and location was truly excellent. Glad to hear you've also been (albeit in much more celebratory circumstances)!

[@simonjones7766]

The pie looked amazing gary,i think you are spot on with your score,if it had a more hearty serving of mash and maybe some green beans it would have made for a really decent meal

[@GaryEats]

Thanks Simon. Agreed!

[@geordiejones2]

Hi Gary, Firstly welcome to Yorkshire, a great clip as always to which you hit the nail right on the head re prices, York is a VERY popular tourist area and the businesses know that, thus they charge accordingly, on saying that and in there defence the rates in York for businesses are very expensive. The pie itself was amazing and the fact it was cooked to order even more so, i must admit given its size, the potato amount i would of been happy with. Re your score, i think 8.5, but you were there i was not. Chris.

[@GaryEats]

Hi Chris. Thanks mate. I was deliberating between 8 and 8.5 but I think the lack of mash made go towards an 8 more but it’s very close. Thanks as always for watching mate!

[@Jan-iq5sm]

You pricing is spot on . 1595 . Perfect ! You, that eat all over the place, knows how to compare and analyse. You are discerning about value and cooking skills . Most people might eat out once a month and dont compare the apples to the pears . We trust your judgement implicitly. You are fair and sometimes very overly generous , as the restaurants are struggling to make a living . Survival of the fittest . I ,like many others , honed my cooking skills , and prefer my own food now .

[@GaryEats]

Very kind. Thank you and I don't blame you.

[@uglenddalejones2]

What a brilliant find not forgetting what a beautiful looking Pie 👌👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻 Got to factor in- location,style of restaurant,ingredients used and the time taken to create a quality,homemade dish as well as skill level. It was a pie not lacking,portioned perfectly- I would imagine if you had more on the plate you would be unable to move,so the chef has shown skill experience and mindfulness in his plate.

[@GaryEats]

Glad you enjoyed it and thank you! I really agree with your assessment as well!

[@user-wv8cs4si4n]

Looked delicious, the pastry almost looked like a hot water crust like you’d get on a pork pie, once again I’d maybe like a side of veg, but that pie was certainly packed with ingredients. Enjoy York and look forward to more of your epicurean foodie adventures

[@GaryEats]

Thank you Karen. More uploads coming over the next few days!

[@fogartym77]

Love a good pie and that looks top tier. The gravy and the steak look lovely, rich and tender. I know you normally have a coke but good to see you sample the local beers (I myself am a cider drinker) but to each his own. Another great review - "Cheers!"

[@GaryEats]

Thanks my friend. Have to agree, it was brilliant!

[@johnbluett6079]

What a great venue full of history and to top it off a simple steak pie and mash. Love good pies. And yes lots of establishments scrimp on a few extra chips , mash and potatoes.. I know times are tight but the cost of a bit more mash is only pennies

[@GaryEats]

I really like venues that have a bit of history behind them and this is one of them. I agree with you!

[@johnoconnor7536]

The pie looks spot and it didn't come with chips but mash. Mash could have been a larger portion and a bit creamier but still preferable in my opinion to chips. Don't think cost was all that bad when you consider it's in a tourist City and you weren't forced to stump up a predetermined service charge. I think £20 for such a quality pie this acceptable considering what I've just said. Score 9.5/10.

[@GaryEats]

That’s fair enough John. A brilliant pie, no service charge but I will say the lack of mash moved it down a little. Cheers for watching!

[@andrewbaker7548]

£19.50 for a "fresh home made" pie & mash, isn't expensive if you enjoyed it. Who pays the staff, the rates, the electricity, gas and water bills, the decorations. Pubs don't make any money on beer and drinks because nobody can afford it, they have to make money on the food. If you want a cheap pie go to Gregg's eat their rubbish.

[@GaryEats]

I don’t have many complaints with the price but when doing a review, I have to factor price in. Pie excellent, mash a little small and no veg. Thanks for watching!

[@tommyhassan3545]

I agree with you 100%

[@melanielattin4591]

I agree expensive

[@RobbieB2024]

It’s extortion what they charge these days I know only too we’ll living and working in Dublin City ,same problems “it’s taking the piss!, it’s a rear treat for family’s now , and just not an option for some at all these days .saying that the food did look quality , maybe a bit skimpy on the veg though

[@Pots57]

Good value no rubbish there don't need no more potato or veg it's the pie your after

[@markjones327]

Looked a great pie Gary certainly made with love , not sure I’d pay £19 Tho bit steep , great vid mate 👍

[@GaryEats]

Thanks Mark 👍

[@glennandrews7411]

That pie looked lovely and I loved the cure in the background!

[@GaryEats]

Agreed Glenn!

[@nickycotton6137]

LoL. Let alone 'The Fine Young Cannibals' 😊

[@paulmccarville8623]

That plate of food looked absolutely amazing! and what's not to love about being in York!! one of my favorite UK cities!

[@GaryEats]

It was superb and yes, York is stunning

[@RobertBuckley-tj3px]

At that price i think i would have expected some vegetables on the plate. I do love a pie and would ddefinitely try it if i go to York. Thanks for another great review.

[@GaryEats]

A very good point Robert but the pie was excellent 👌

[@stevekirkby6570]

Epic Pie! Well described!

[@GaryEats]

Thank you kindly!

[@claudiaweidman1004]

The pie and mash looks delicious 😊

[@GaryEats]

So good!

[@andysmith819]

Now that's a pie! Looked delicious.

[@GaryEats]

Thank you 😋

[@JSC131]

Looks absolutely amazing fair play Gary great content and subscribed.

[@GaryEats]

Much appreciated Jeff. Glad you're liking it!

[@leemayell7570]

Hey Gary, great vlog once again. Totally understand your marking -1 for mash paltry portion and -1 for no veg accompaniment. Pie looked lovely but the rest a little disapointing, keep up the good work, really enjoyable to watch and always consistent unlike so many others on you tube 👍

[@GaryEats]

Thank you Lee. Appreciate that mate!

[@GaryYork-tk2ow]

I've passed by the Guy Fawkes but have never gone in to eat. The pie looked great, although I would have liked a bigger helping of mash, as well as peas. Just a short walk from there is the Royal Oak. They also do a great steak pie, along with mash and peas. Great video. 👍

[@GaryEats]

Thanks Gary. I love York, I think it's a beautiful city. Glad you enjoyed the video!

[@davidhughes4489]

That Pie has just concluded my deciding of the next place for a short weekend break very soon. All the best to you.

[@GaryEats]

Thanks, you too!

[@duncanboyf4175]

£19.95 knocks the sox off that £37 + service charge for a fried fish at Harrords. Quality, quality pie. Keep up the great posts.

[@GaryEats]

Spot on. Thank you Duncan!

[@user-ju6ud4go6b]

Pie looked great and the meat looked tender and the gravy in and around it looked real tasty. Nicely presented Yorkshire do fabulous pies this was one of those. I would have liked one more serving of mash to soak up that lovely gravy. Price wise - well it is York and near the cathedral so tourist land really so hence the price. I think i would give it 9 really because the pie crust was really good and filled to the brim with meat. Good one Gary -Yorkshire’s finest -you are in for treats there.👍

[@GaryEats]

Absolutely love the city. Beautiful place!

[@mohammedkamalhussain3694]

Gary your "B roles" are getting better and better 👏

[@GaryEats]

Thanks Mohammed

[@Danny_Dennis]

That’s a fantastic looking pie !

[@GaryEats]

It was superb. Lovely and homemade!

[@edd4875]

That pie looked epic! Could have had an extra portion of mash. Just discovered your channel. Keep it up! Good work 👍

[@GaryEats]

Spot on. Thank you very much my friend!

[@jshaers96]

I don't think you need to worry whether you're being 'fair', it's your honest opinion and you are entitled to say what you like. That odd plate they gave you (more a shallow bowl, really) means they can give you short measures without it looking too obvious. Too many pubs seem to think they're fancy restaurants when they're not, and an ice cream scoopful of mash is really taking the mickey. Personally, I prefer it when you are prepared to mark these places down a bit. If they want to charge high prices then you're entitled to hold them to high standards.

[@GaryEats]

That's fair enough. I try to be fair with VFM and what I'm getting in return. I agree with what you've commented. Thanks for watching!

[@MikePaton-Williams-yv9qo]

Genuine pie with filling encased in pastry👍

[@GaryEats]

It was a great pie Mike definitely

[@Staggercfc]

For the preparation of the pie I would happily pay the 20 sovs. I was pleased to see it didn't fall apart all over the place when the knife was taken to it, so well prepared and cooked was the pastry. I'm sure the meal would have filled most people up so the just enough helping of mashed potato wasn't for me an issue. A really nice meal, that... and reasonably priced ale too. Well done.

[@GaryEats]

Thank you Stagger. I'm glad you enjoyed the video, maybe another to add to your list after Bombay Delight? Cheers mate!

[@Staggercfc]

@@GaryEats Well, if ever I'm in York I will hunt down that pie, Gary, even if I get lost trying! Thanks again!

[@GaryEats]

No problem. Hope you're well.

[@Ziggylyle]

Thomsons fish and chips, onion rings, bits. The best in the world. Malton road, Hazelbush, York. YO3TW Great show tonight

[@GaryEats]

Ah, I'm gutted that I must have missed that. I saw Drake's but decided to do something else but didn't see Thomsons. The good news is that I'm going back soon so can do then!

[@sharonkellybeattie1900]

That's a good looking pie and yet again Gary another honest review love your videos

[@GaryEats]

Glad you like them!

[@johnkeir4139]

Great looking pie Gary. I am so hungry. Margaret

[@darrenroberts-pp9nn]

Glad you took up my recommendation to try it

[@GaryEats]

I was going to put your comment on the screen but I couldn't find it. Thanks Darren, really appreciate it mate.

[@iancrawley4009]

I don't mind paying within reason and to be fair that looked worth the money. Another perfectly presented and timed review.

[@GaryEats]

Thanks Ian. Appreciate it!

[@andrewroberts4736]

That bitter looked nice. I like weak beer and then drink more of it.😁 I would have liked some nice lightly buttered cabbage with it. Crusty bread and butter for the gravy. The pie looked absolutely superb. Packed with steak. And an excellent crust. I think £20 is over the top for the pie. I agree with your estimate . Due to the price I am taking off 1 point and 1 for the small portion of mash. Brilliant review as always.

[@martindunstan8043]

Absolutely 👍a bit of greenage to go with that but I don't think I'd be man enough to eat crusty bread with the gravy after eating that pie🤣

[@GaryEats]

Can't have too many of those weak beers Andrew otherwise it becomes a problem, lol. Spot on with your assessment (I would say that as I said the same haha). Thank you mate!

[@susandavis4821]

Afternoon Gary another great vlog, love your vlogs. Pie looked nice but too much gravy for my liking. and it looks hot too. I make a mean meat pie and enjoy a pie. Bit pricey for a pie! however in tourist area bound to be pricey. Thank you Gary.

[@chrisjannahthomas3877]

Best looking pie I've ever seen, great video bro 🤛🏻

[@GaryEats]

Thanks Chris.

[@RegNarnoc21]

Hi Gary,I’m putting on weight since I started watching you eat all those lovely meals.🤗

[@GaryEats]

Haha, I'm sorry my friend!

[@liberty_and_justice67]

Looked delicious, particularly with the bitter👍

[@GaryEats]

So good. The pie was one of the best. Thanks for watching!

[@paulwilliams5174]

Given the size of the pie, the mash would have suited me fine.York is an expensive town and a lovely place to visit.In the north we don't expect to pay a service charge, unlike the south where it is expected.Your meal was about right for the city and normal value for the part of in which you were dining.Thank you for the review,I will certainly visit there.

[@GaryEats]

Good to know! I hope you have a great time 😊

[@TheSecondof5]

Well Gary, seeing as how you've come up to my neck of the woods, God's own county, I thought it would be a good time to say how much I am enjoying your culinary adventures. Not far off London prices though. Too rich for my gravy. Yorkshireman born and bred, strong in arm and thick in head. Ha ha ha! keep up the good work.

[@GaryEats]

Lol. Great to that you're liking the content mate. You'll be delighted to know, I'm back in Yorkshire tomorrow!

[@CheshireCat6639]

Cant beat pie n mash, looked yummy,the pie was huge,i think for a treat i would pay that for the quality plus a good portion too🎉 ty for staring 🎉

[@GaryEats]

So good. You are welcome!

[@CheshireCat6639]

@@GaryEats I found you today and I love watching rate the food/place/price streams..no 🐃💩 reviews with down to earth honesty without being too harsh....Its a thumbs up and new subscriber..ty Julie 🎉

[@GaryEats]

Thank you!! Very kind of you Julie :)

[@leesmith4028]

Wow my mouth is watering will av to go there cheers pal ❤

[@GaryEats]

Hope you enjoy it Lee. Have a good time!

[@frankyw8803]

That pie looks amazing .

[@GaryEats]

It was superb.

[@colinraine8245]

Glad you enjoyed it . I love that pub but there are also many more in York that are fantastic with lots of history . Everytime l go to York l head straight to Kalpakavadi at Fossgate my favourite genuine indian restaurant in the UK... and fish and chips at Drakes.

[@GaryEats]

I may give that Indian restaurant a go when I’m back there. Thanks Colin!

[@colinraine8245]

@@GaryEats You'll not regret it Gary l love their crispy dosa and sambal starter .. its Indian owned and food from the south of India... they've a website if you look onnit you'll be there for sure 🙂😋

[@leemacgregor]

Gary that looks awesome !! top review

[@GaryEats]

Thanks Lee. Hope you’re well mate!

[@31secondsorthereabouts86]

That looks delicious. I'm getting indigestion looking at it, but still. It looks delicious 🤤🤤🤤🤤

[@GaryEats]

Lol. Absolutely how I felt!

[@paulc7535]

Pie Fawkes. Love the reviews.

[@GaryEats]

I'm annoyed with myself I didn't say that haha. Really appreciate that my friend!

[@jeffrhorer1811]

That's amazing! My Dad was wounded in Africa and brought to England on a hospital ship and was taken in by an English family until he was healed enough to go back. He raved about the steak and kidney pie they served at some point. Now I can see what he means.

[@GaryEats]

This was excellent Jeff, I should have scored it more in hindsight 👍

[@beltxabeltxa]

Wish I had one of them now, love it

[@GaryEats]

It was delicious!

[@beltxabeltxa]

Thanks

[@palace1439]

Gary now that looked an absolute banger 🔥.

[@GaryEats]

Was a fantastic pie, Palace!

[@scotty6346]

York is a brilliant city, I went there last April for a long weekend and loved it.

[@GaryEats]

It's a wonderful place.

[@Slartie24]

Looks bloody delicious

[@GaryEats]

It was bloody delicious!

[@iamtheeggman1986]

Mouthwatering pie 🤤 I need a trip to York

[@GaryEats]

A brilliant place!

[@brianjonas4654]

Your reviews are excellent. I also rated it all an 8, based on your review. Blessings from Texas,USA. 👍😊❤🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@GaryEats]

Thank you Brian it was an excellent pie and homemade so that was perfect 👌🇺🇸🇺🇸

[@grumpyoldman8661]

Scrumptious!

[@GaryEats]

Oh yes!!

[@Redsaxophone11]

Gary, I agree with your comments, that was one big pie and tasty with it, but the price was a bit over the top and the portion of mash was quite small. As others have mentioned below a better balance could be achieved between the two. York is an expensive area to eat in having been there myself and it's good to see that no service charge was added. As for your marking, I felt it was slightly harsh and I would have given an 8.5 out of 10. The overall price including the beer was quite decent though. Having a lager with that meal instead of a beer in London could have easily added anywhere between £7 to £10 just for the lager alone to the bill. Great review though and I wasn't aware of this place until I saw your review, great work and keep them coming.