Tubing Mascara vs Waterproof Macara | Which Is BETTER?

[@tara7261]

To be honest, I really don't like mascara like that. To me when the lashes are so desperate you could count them, it's clumpy. I have to have voluminous fluttery lashes.

[@kadinsmomma07]

Tara Taillon I agree! I thought the lashes did get clumpy, they formed groups of thick lashes. I like fanned out lashes. BUT the cleanup was nice, afterwards it looked much cleaner than the other mascara.

[@kadinsmomma07]

Tara Taillon I agree! I thought the lashes did get clumpy, they formed groups of thick lashes. I like fanned out lashes. BUT the cleanup was nice, afterwards it looked much cleaner than the other mascara.

[@CoolWhip-E]

Tara Taillon I agree on the clumpyness, but that cleanup tho..... WOW. IM IN LOVE. I hate when my eyes are left black and gross and it's impossible to get it all off. This seemed easy and clean. Buuuut like you said they we're clumpy and a little to much together. but maybe you could apply it different and it would work. Maybe run a spooly through them to separate more. idk

[@jessicabender5867]

totally agree! i want people to be asking me if im wearing falsies lmao and the blinc does NOT give that look

[@prairiejenn494]

Tubing mascara is the only kind that stays on my eyes! I like Blinc but I go thru so much mascara that I also love the L'Oréal double extend beauty tubes (the red and white 2 in 1 package) from the drugstore. My ride or die even though in Canada at the drugstore it is still anywhere from 12-18 bucks depending on place.

[@ren6451]

L'oreal has the same exact tubing mascara. It's called Double Extend 2 in 1. I've been using it every single day for years! It's great, I love it and so easy to wash off.

[@nellienell13]

Rana Abusaid yep I use it too ....u can actually layer it which is awesome ....start with the white side ...use ur fav mascara next and finish with the black (red) side and it will still come off in a tube ...as long as I make sure u use the white first ..I use it every single day ..bit I'm able to switch up my mascara look by using diff these in between the two formulas ...it's awesome

[@faithtoler3952]

nellienell13 great tip

[@joycampbell6157]

Absolutely hands down my favorite!!!!! A tip for anyone trying it out the easiest way I've found to remove it is w just warm/hot water and a rag!!!! I've been using this for about 2 yrs and I've tried a few diff ways including makeup remover and the water and rag have worked the best for me :)

[@GoodReadsAndDPs]

Anyone else think shae is like the prettiest girl they've ever seen?!?!😁

[@ThatGirlShaeXo]

😱you are too kind!! thank you love!💖

[@GoodReadsAndDPs]

you're welcome, I can't believe you replied

[@AleshaNicole]

Shae why are you slaying us so hard in this video?!😍

[@downwith_thethicccness]

its so weird shae is only at 289,000 subs when I feel like her, Vintageortacky, and xsparkage are the best, most creative, and dedicated you tubers on here. I love that Shae has always been honest and her true self and she deserves millions of subs.

[@justStardust940]

no she doesn't. this video is sponsored.

[@nunpho]

hi shae, there's a super easy way to remove the mascara. just get some warm water onto your washcloth then sandwich your lashes for 20 secs and the tubes should just slide right off with no rubbing. for anyone looking for good tubing mascara in the UK, no7 make a good one!

[@janebarnette6548]

what is the no7 one called? I'd love to try it! +frozensky86

[@nunpho]

Jane Barnette I'm sure it's called stay perfect :)

[@poisonivy8057]

frozensky86 really?we have no7 here in Canada and will definitely try it very soon

[@sailormoonwannabe]

I think I see No7 at Ulta all the time now, I was wondering what it was..because I had never heard of it before. (in the states)

[@janebarnette6548]

+frozensky86 I just wanted to THANK YOU for recommending the stay perfect no7 gold tube tubing mascara! it's AMAZING, at a fraction of the cost of the Trish McEvoy one I've been using for years. I *love* it. thank you!!!!

[@maquillamelily212]

Zero clumping? Separating? Ok

[@naomi_4916]

compared to the waterproof there was very little clumping i assume that it what she meant?

[@ThatGirlShaeXo]

+Megan Donovin maybe try less product than I used. I know I can have a heavy hand :)

[@maquillamelily212]

ThatGirlShaeXo I'll do that, very interesting product

[@madison5743]

I just tried the Blinc mascara a couple of days ago and I'm in love! I only have to apply one light coat and I feel like that's the best way to make it not look too clumpy but yet it still gives me more length and volume than any other mascara and I've tried a lot of them

[@lillivewire87]

I love my Blinc...I can totally wear it overnight. I do a lot of overnight hiking where lots of pictures get taken and if I don't wear mascara it looks like I don't have lashes because they are so light. I can wear this through a sweaty hike, sleep with it on, and there is zero flaking the next day when we hike out. SUPER easy to remove as well...just warm water!

[@amymitchell9985]

I totally want to try this out!! I usually wear waterproof everyday because it's the only kind that keeps my lashes curled but I'm now interested in tubing mascara!!

[@kris232010]

I love the blinc mascara by itself if I use the blinc black primer it starts to flake during the day. I love how easily it comes off with water!!

[@johannamckenzie7302]

Blinc's liquid eyeliner has the same idea it balls up and comes off in one piece... I love all of their products 😍😍

[@brittfaced4699]

I got a tube of Blinc mascara one month in a Boxycharm box and absolutely loved it. It's a great formula and brand!!

[@mariabrooks8065]

This was great review. That sleep test was perfect! The blinc side looks exactly the same from when you applied it until you woke up! I should have given it more of a chance when I got it in an old subscription box!

[@AshleyWheeler2.0]

I'm glad that you did this because I got that mascara in the Sephora PLAY box and I would have totally been using it wrong. Thank you for doing this.

[@neworleans1979]

Tried the link and it's not working...thank you Shae for doing this review....as always you look beautiful!

[@Veganbri]

What lipstick were you wearing?

[@tinal8398]

I am sold!! That was really cool looking... I use only Waterproof mascara and I can't stand when my lashes come off with removing it!! I have to try it 💜

[@destinyrobertson4197]

I love your eye makeup!!!! Your my favorite beauty blogger!!!

[@crkvlogs6819]

You're so pretty without makeup shae. I got a blink mascara in a boxycharm but it was a primer and I really liked it and used it as a mascara

[@ahoyjesss]

Your make up actually looks so pretty in the beginning without any mascara!

[@DonorFan]

Blinc is the best and the only mascara I ever use. It's perfect for middle age women. No smudging or flaking ever!

[@robinhenderson5558]

Your skin looks so beautiful!!!

[@sarahblue7446]

obsessed with your channel. Thank you Shae!

[@lindseeey69]

Your skin! Omfg I'm shook! It looks so clear and bright and beautiful omg 😍😍😍😍

[@jacquelinperez9590]

Your bareskin is looking so flawless!! love it!!

[@anapinheiro1033]

Even though the BLINC Mascara looks better I still don't like the finish of it.. My favourite is the Bourjois Volume Glamour Max Mascara! It volumizes and lengthens my lashes sooo Good😊 Love You ❤

[@anapinheiro1033]

Preferences 😊 #snapchatfam

[@SamanthaMarchxo]

I have the mascara - it's great!

[@sabrinamartinez8708]

wow! thank you so much for sharing this! i have always hate putting mascara on my eyelashes and recently just gave up on doing anything to them at all because i feel like when i take off mascara my EYELASHES COME OFF! Just way to harsh for me, but this product could be my answer. I'm definitely considering this!😃💘👏

[@janebarnette6548]

+ThatGirlShaeXo the Trish McEvoy lash curling and volumizing mascara both are tubing mascaras!! I have used Blinc but much prefer the TM lash curling one. Tubing mascaras FTW!!!!

[@bodybalancer]

So glad Blinc is getting more play. It revolutionized my lash game 😜✨

[@heygabbymae]

YAS SHAE. I love this mascara there's truly nothing like it. I'm a lazy makeup girl and it's my ride or die.

[@ThatGirlShaeXo]

I can't believe I have gone this long without it Gabby!! Thank you for watching!💖

[@bethrogan424]

wow that's amazing. I have just ordered this mascara and I can not wait

[@shesheeshena]

I'm not into mascara all like that. I'm such a false lash brat lmao. obviously I came to watch this video to support my girl Shae and to tell you I watched your snaps don't ever apologize to someone for being here if they don't like it they don't have to watch love you girl

[@suncrestco316]

Girl yes! Shut up and take my money! I'm a mascara junkie but I absolutely haaaate taking it off. This looks so awesome!!

[@ThatGirlShaeXo]

KATIEE YESS YOU ARE MEE. you'll love it!!

[@beckypratt432]

Shae there is a drugstore mascara that is very much like Blic, I'm not even kidding. I have used it for years and it's so amazing. it's from L'Oréal and it's got a primer then the tube mascara it's package together the mascara is in a redish tube. try it, you will love it. I don't have any at the moment , but I'm telling you it's the same. I am always so shocked how easy it comes off when washing g my face and how there is no harsh rubbing or tugging needed, just glides right off. Thought I would share that with ya if you didn't know about the drugstore version. 😉

[@beckypratt432]

oops, miss spell blinc!

[@beckypratt432]

I am not sure. I will go look on line and see and then let ya know.😉

[@beckypratt432]

I just looked it up, I was wrong on there being to mascara bottles, it's been so long. anyways it's double ended. it's call Double Extended Beauty Tube (tubes) try it out. honestly thry are amazing and I wouldn't recommend them if I was 100% happy with them. 😉

[@kerriromo9951]

Becky Pratt I've been using the Loreal one for years. It's awesome. I work 13 hr days and it's the only mascara that isn't completely under my eyes at the end of the day

[@maggieparmley9350]

Wow. I wish I woke up as gorgeous as Miss Shae❤😊

[@noniefuss]

You're braver than me sleeping in all of that mascara. I know you said you didn't intend it as "Hey, everyone! Go sleep in your make up!" but if I even think of sleeping in eye make up I wake up with the worst headache of life. No joke. I've always wanted to try a tubing mascara. Maybe I'll grab one during the Sephora VIB sale. :) Thanks for the vid!

[@hannahkayee831]

Gorgeous as always! Need this in my life ASAP!!

[@ThatGirlShaeXo]

Thank you Hannah!!💖

[@SaucerJess]

I love this mascara, but you have to make sure to do only one coat and it removes way easier with warm water :)

[@meredithsiss292]

This is so awesome! Thank you for doing this- you should do more videos like this- love you!

[@ThatGirlShelbyy]

That's so cool 😍😍😍 I honestly was really doubtful about it but that's actually awesome hahaha

[@elianaselzer5785]

So… You’re an expert on a mascara you have never tried? Trish McEvoy also makes a great tubing mascara. Completely falls off your eyes in the shower. Does not give enough “wow“ factor. But works really well underneath something that does.

[@Nancy-sk3bi]

Finally I'm on time love Shae seeing you made my head feel better got a headache

[@ThatGirlShaeXo]

AW NOO feel better soon Nancy!

[@Nancy-sk3bi]

ThatGirlShaeXo thanks

[@misstoasted2525]

I love tubing mascara! cheaper dupes at Target you can find the Boots n7 stay perfect long lasting mascara (gold tube) and cover girl remarkable mascara in purple tube. but I have found my lashes have totally grown out longer and fuller bc I'm not losing them from rubbing my eyes when I used to take off my mascara at night. I'm totally going to get Blinc in the VIB sale

[@janebarnette6548]

thanks for the tips about the no7 one --- on the high end, my favorite tubing mascara is Trish McEvoy. I get them during Nordstroms' mascara sale!

[@misstoasted2525]

Jane Barnette Ive got to try the trish one. I know its hard to get volume from a tubing mascara, but would you say the Trish or Blinc gives you more volume?

[@janebarnette6548]

+Meghan Melby the Trish one definitely gives me more volume, and with fewer clumps. I personally prefer the lash curling one (even for volume) to the TM volumizing mascara, though, because the wand is bigger. :)

[@chrissylyons9311]

I have been a fan for a while now, and your videos are So hilarious! Loved it! 😀

[@RaphaelaLaurean]

This was a great tutorial.

[@Mrslolalynn]

I've waited for this!!! 🙌🏻

[@ThatGirlShaeXo]

AWW Thank you so much Laura😍💖

[@cassieguadagno5382]

why cant you use makeup remover with blinc?

[@candace152001]

your amazing! always enjoy your videos!

[@rubynasir3895]

I was waiting for this video since you talked about it on snapchat 😊 P.S. You look gorgeous as always and I LOVE this lip color on you

[@srmay1014]

Maëlle has mascara that is a tubing mascara! It's called Above & Beyond Mascara! You should try it and let me know what ya think!!

[@MelissaKaylaXIII]

I use the L'Oreal Double Extend primer/mascara and it comes right off in tubes too! I've been using it for ages, I love it, I can't use anything else now. The staying power is great, too. You should try it out! :D

[@Beautyaddixion]

That blinc mascara came in my Sephora Play! box. I love it! It works best for me over another mascara. :) Oh and I also slept in it the first day lol. It stayed! The way it comes off freaked me out the first time fo sho. But I just wet my fingers and they slid off.

[@beckypratt432]

Kerri, That's awesome. now that Shae has done this video makes me want to run out and buy it. lol!

[@camry8334]

I love watching your videos and feeling like I'm listening to my best friend. Love you so much!

[@mamene3819]

Love your Lipstick. Great color. Looks beautiful on you. What is it?

[@emilyshuler16]

that mascara looked great on u! I tried it, but its not a good combo for my watery eyes because i rub them all the time

[@melindafenves]

That thumbnail though! 👍😍

[@bluemickey23]

Is that the same mascara Makeupbyleina use to talk about all the time??

[@theNightGoesOnx4]

I'm so impressed by your ability to apply mascara with both hands 😂❤ lmaoo

[@dawnrhinehardt601]

What Eyeshadows are you wearing?

[@lisamichele6738]

omg girl I need this so bad! I have such a hard time with mascaras. where do I buy this! also it's cruelty free which is want is want!

[@ThatGirlShaeXo]

YESS it's a must girl! You can find it at the link i put in the bottom or sephora!

[@lisamichele6738]

ThatGirlShaeXo yays thanks for replying! definitely going to buy this or put this on my Christmas list.

[@noelreese5430]

the waterproof definitely clumps more but it seems that blinc does too just a tad. don't know that I'm a fan

[@hannahlafave9916]

Yeah Shae you're looking so beautiful. Love you!

[@juelslee3686]

anyone else having trouble with the link 2 blinc?

[@dianaaguilar8099]

Love this review thank you holy grail!! 😍😍😊

[@ThatGirlShaeXo]

Thank you so much Diana😍

[@dianaaguilar8099]

ThatGirlShaeXo your welcome beautiful

[@laurafranks6061]

Shae sorry love yah but there is nothing special about the way the Blinc tubing mascara looks on my lashes "/

[@halsievlogs]

"I'm using a shot glass for things other than my bad decisions" LMAOOO I LOVE YOU

[@ThatGirlShaeXo]

😂😂Thanks Haley! I subbed to your channel not that it means anything lmao. Your banner is so freakin cute!

[@halsievlogs]

ThatGirlShaeXo omg did you actually?! Thank you so much that means a lot! And ahhh thank you! I'm still making some changes to it but thank you! 💖💖💖

[@raleoa4131]

I believe Blinc also has an eyeliner; can you review that? I have a love/hate relationship with eyeliner.

[@BeautyKhaleesi]

they have pencil and felt tip liner, lash primer, awesome brow mousse, eye shadow, and eyelash and bdow growth enhancer. and they were developed with an eye institute. we sell at my spa and I did a training with blinc

[@jakildixon]

NnoooO Ladies!!!! BEST Mascara Evere!! Tubing mascara!!! LOreal Double Extend. Maroon package!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!'!!!!!!

[@beberoro1]

You look amazing when you first wake up!

[@jaclyndertson3091]

Loved this!

[@stayclassy93]

Great video girl!!!

[@chloechan1]

you sound exactly like mila kunis!

[@Rakhali6767]

Loreal has a two step tube mascara!

[@SydneyLovesToCreate]

Loved the video as always! :)

[@theeluannesantos]

I love how easy it came off. #Snapchatfam #EVERYWHEREfam #ShaeButter Love you so much

[@NorseGirlReadings]

Got to say I'm not a big fan of the blinc ! I love my better than sex waterproof! Great video though hunny xxx

[@yolipadilla2810]

that was a very cool mascara

[@justStardust940]

this video is sponsored . you didn't make it sound like that in the beginning. you made it sound like they sent it to you to try and then MAYBE you would make a video if you liked it for free.

[@divacirce2845]

Definitely not the only tubing mascara. I think Trish McEvoy is a way better tubing mascara and has been around for over a decade!! I get the sponsored videos but you shouldn’t provide incorrect info to promote products. Definitely causes me to question your credibility as a new viewer...

[@mistypham2499]

no ones gonna say anything about her sleeping with mascara on?????

[@ThatGirlShaeXo]

Hey girl. This video is YEARS old. I’m still living - so I survived lol. Yay!

[@עדןק-ת9ב]

you're amazing

[@ThatGirlShaeXo]

😍you're amazing!

[@agalarza19]

Blinc is my jam. Ur my girl Shae. #snapchatfam

[@ThatGirlShaeXo]

I am so happy I finally tried it girl idk what took me so long lol. Thank you fam!

[@oliviad5474]

I’m so confused as you why the heck yo slept in then, that’s the stupidest thing.

[@ThatGirlShaeXo]

This video is years old. Get a life lmao

[@dineyram2939]

very cool👌

[@MeganMichelle__]

Those are both pretty dang clumpy

[@annieyon2645]

ilysm😘😘

[@Harpysylph]

I don’t like the way you apply these

[@mileycyrus2370]

❤❤

[@ThatGirlShaeXo]

💖

[@Respectfully.Stephh]

I love your videos and make up always always on point forever an subsssc