U.S. Education vs.China & India - ABC 10 TV Sacramento, CA

[@theoakatsuki]

I am Indian. Our maths difficulty rises from early classes. But I adore the Japanese education system. Up until class 2 they dont have exams but give huge importance to development of morals. Students clean their own toilets. Now thats discipline

[@humoursabji4045]

Point

[@nupursharma9146]

exaclty...

[@arunabha003]

@Pafnuty Chebyshev how is that cringe?

[@arunabha003]

@Pafnuty Chebyshev yup... Like one shouldn't comment without knowing the exact meaning of Cringe...

[@Shikhar_]

@Pafnuty Chebyshev Cringe? Geez you are a moron

[@tusarkoirala5955]

I am a foreign student in the US. I was shocked in my first semester in the US when I saw students learning simple algebra in college. We studied calculus in high school and trigonometry in 8th standard (very advanced). I took calculus in my first semester in my US college and got A by only going to class during exam time.

[@norcaloutdoor5462]

Depend what major you study.

[@kishorekumar624]

Did you do ICSE syllabus in ur high school years?

[@aasishs2270]

@@kishorekumar624 well I am doing it

[@MichiganUSASingaporeSEAsia]

Tusar Koirala what state? California?

[@moniqueuu8777]

Because you studied it earlier means what? You dexided to stay and continue to study in a country that is behind in studies in your country?

[@kirtigupta9753]

"We owe the Indians a great deal here in US. They have made a lot of people wealthy" Correct statement and very apt one.

[@AaronZhang1202]

Exactly just like how now the ceo of google is an Indian entrepreneur

[@princejafri786]

Ryt

[@aniruddh449]

When he said we are the no. 1 and after some time I felt his feeling 🤣

[@HammadKhan-tl6bb]

You said this because chinese cant give you likes, since there is no youtube there.

[@sumedhparalikar5236]

Us Indians or come to casino Indians

[@iluvkochikame]

I'm Indian and I had calculus when I was 13. The math is strong in this country, especially in South India.

[@Sam-dh1wh]

You forgot about Bihar.

[@believeme8341]

Hit The Assassin jio he bihar ke lala

[@aigeanthokchom3797]

manipur board sidi yadraba board ne. mark ta likpagiwane... kemta yadre

[@vaibhavsingh9990]

Bitch ever heard of JEE

[@RollsRoyceFanatics]

I am from Australia, and self taught myself Trigonometry and Differential Calculus at 14. The education system wasn't there to help, but loving parents had to buy me the books. Unfortunately they were poor, and books were prohibitively expensive. Things are better now, if you are driven to learn, then the internet provides infinite access for all!

[@snebis]

In India for the poor and deprived, their mantra for success is MATHEMATICS because it needs only two things, brain and hard work, which a poor child has in ample.

[@ollovlogs]

Truely agree

[@soumyadipbiswas6835]

@legendary/Gaming Legendaries !! stop always bringing race, ethnicity in a simple matter. Intellectualism has its place, it's not the place or the time.

[@uddangwaldangwal1586]

India is not a poor country bro .It is in fact the sixth richest country in the world with a nominal GDP of $8 trillion.But still we have the largest no of poor people in the world but that is only because of overpopulation.We also have many rich people.There is a large unequal economy divide.

[@akashanand6908]

@@uddangwaldangwal1586 well gdp dosent really explains what is the average standard of living of the individual in the country....And it's been stated many times that the massive gdp is only because of the massive population....But times are changing and we should hope for the best

[@uddangwaldangwal1586]

@@akashanand6908 This massive population is also the reason for unequal economy distribution In India and also our low per capita income.

[@liamkim7202]

Asian math is not a joke man, I’m asian almost every asian students take calculus class including me!

[@pavim9131]

Ya but but for me they deleted calculus coz it's hard😢😢 And I am currently learning this in 12 th

[@Aminshuvlog]

I first study calculus at 7 th standard

[@Aminshuvlog]

@@pavim9131 it is because of pandemic enforcement ....but I taught my all students full syllabus.....and situation is not willing for all students

[@aryanbharadiya9206]

I've just finished my calculus homework lol

[@dtxvines6269]

@@Aminshuvlog what the hell which textbook u find calculas in 7 lol dont try to act smart

[@KushalJainDO]

Well, the grass is always greener on the neighbor's side :)

[@randomcurrypuff6237]

Very true. No education system is perfect. That is why Asian people still go to universities in the US. My thought is the US should apply a more "Chinese" way and Asian education system should become less competitive.

[@shaileshgokhale1185]

I agree with your over-arching statement. Please read the comment I have posted above and comment on what you think. TIA

[@arunthakur1661]

Haha u r funny

[@faiz8840]

@@randomcurrypuff6237 I'm from India, and I can tell you you're goddamn right

[@CriticalThinker0890]

This is actually true, they see good on us and we see the good on them, basically I always support kids to be given ample amount of childhood rather than sending to KG at age 2

[@Ryan-ud1mt]

I think Indians are the best minds in world be it in field of IT sector or in mathematics .No one can match Indians potential .And also a important lesson never mess with Indians. By the way I am from USA.

[@humoursabji4045]

Ever heard of Japanese?

[@Ryan-ud1mt]

@@humoursabji4045 yeah but they aren't CEO's of big IT company neither gave any zeros ,decimal system , binary no. , Navigation etc . to world🌎🌎.

[@bhagathyennemajalu]

They are helping other countries not India. 60% of Engineering graduates from my batch left india for opportunity at US, Europe and Gulf countries.

[@satyamsoni1004]

@@bhagathyennemajalu hope this change soon because nowadays India is really doing good in start-ups and we have some 70+ startups became Unicorn

[@sohansen3575]

Chinese are better

[@jega1102]

In India and China,discipline starts with parents, passed down to their kids. Our culture is respect for elders and good sense of direction in life. Parents instill the value of hard work, confidence, self respect and pious, and that creates a man and his community.

[@Arzay15.9.01]

But they forget to teach equality in my opinion.

[@straydwag]

@@Arzay15.9.01 Can't say about China, but India never ignored gender equality. Now you must be thinking of Caste Discrimination in India right? That was not in our culture from the source, our culture went thorough many rough situations (last time brits destroyed us for 200 yrs) so in this times people made there unions to oppose the rulers. Which then converted into an caste system. Now things are very much loose. It doesn't matter who you are. Of course there's Muslim Hindu controversy, which I say is a healthy controversy (Not physical) cause we are a victim of terrorism.

[@Arzay15.9.01]

@@straydwag how do they teach it parenting or curriculum?

[@straydwag]

@@Arzay15.9.01 Cast system is mentioned in books as A Dark Reality. Educational system here is made to reform the future youth acc. to how they should behave in an open democracy. On ground also the changes can be seen, BUT! There is some sort of discrimination still exists. Law have strick actions against this kind of discrimination. (Just for example : If you mock a road sweeper and if he files a FIR [case] against you. You will be in trouble now). So now the the discrimination exists but is declining every day. The young age is open minded, skilled, have values. The problem is that the picture west media portray to there audience of us is still decay old. You would know that India have slums but you probably don't know that the Biggest statue in the world is in India (Statue of Unity). You know that theres racism in India, but you won't know that Gandhi's first encounter was against racism. You may know India is one of the biggest Unemployed country but you may not know we also have the most skilled youth. India have it's own silicon valley. Reliance Jio is the only telecom company in the world without any single Chinese equipment. Manglyaan mission (India's mission to mars) was ₹6 per kilometres and average cost of an kilometr in Uber is ₹10. There are many positive aspects of us but not as famous as the negative ones.

[@Arzay15.9.01]

@@straydwag my opinion is that it is hard to deny one's ancestry but not every one can change unless something that can shake the foundation of one's culture, or history will repeat itself. That is why the first lessons youve ever know is one of the most important things that can guess what you can become.

[@abbylee5916]

I agree. I live in Silicon Valley, the place he talked about and 80% of us are Asian. We are helping the US economy grow. My family worked for Apple. All around us are asians who work for google, yahoo, youtube, Facebook, Cisco, hp, etc. all these high tech us companies that help the economy.

[@VicmundLim]

Which asian is more chinese or indian

[@MichiganUSASingaporeSEAsia]

Abby Lee no USA is helping Asia nations and communities grow. So are you Indian too? California sucks by the way and have one of the worse school systems in America

[@tanishqkabir5461]

@@MichiganUSASingaporeSEAsia you can't run the US without Indians

[@MichiganUSASingaporeSEAsia]

Tanishq Kabir how can you say that when Asian Indians can not even governor themselves? Some say Gayish culture too. The men love to have boys and will abort in some cases if a girl. Sickening and unethical. Man out number women the most on the world in India...I read one comment from Singapore-no wonder men walk down the street hold hands with each other.

[@earthpatel5196]

@@MichiganUSASingaporeSEAsia dumbfuck only few asian thinks that girls are bad in asia rn

[@abirmajumder6746]

In India Education is too rigorous. No time for sports or any other activities if you want to excel in education as you might fear losing out by as less as 1 mark. There is entrance exam on every level even for 1st standard. If you do MBBS, then you need post graduation entrance for MD and this is extremely tough if you are from unreserved category. This system does not provide enough scope on free thinking as students are under constant pressure.

[@anirudhnair8689]

Abir Majumder India doesn't have any religious perspective in India.. In India there's no Tax over Education like Pakistan

[@Subvishy]

Well said sir.

[@cataclysmal5315]

Abe China pe bhi nehi he.

[@RajeshKumar-gd5gl]

Education is the most powerful weapon which you can use to change the world.

[@leansnscenes7806]

@@RajeshKumar-gd5gl cant change the world if your dead like the thousands of kids who kill themselves everyday because of the pressure of the education system

[@shekharverma2163]

We Indian actually have no other choice...... 😭😭

[@nannuuuuu]

The truth 😂😂😂

[@pranavrajendran2548]

Right

[@Debarshi_Das]

Absolutely true

[@aniketsharma1705]

@unbox the best book DUTTA to isme hasne ki kya baat hai ....chutiye

[@jajaja7394]

U are lucky to get education.Thr are ppl who want it but couldn't get it! Be thankful!

[@piyushsumera9076]

Unfortunately all the Indian brilliant students are going to foreign countries.. For example,I am Doctor and some of my friends who literally can revolutionize the health sector of India chose USMLE for their postgraduation and they will no more contribute to our health sector..Same can be said about all these IIT toppers,hardly anyone stays in India.

[@ravekieran319]

Ground fact sir reservations for PG seat & no security at hospitals in India is whats making many choose USMLE , PLAB etc

[@randomdude9135]

@@ravekieran319 Yup, caste based reservations should be eradicated

[@ravekieran319]

@@dipayanroy3481 Maybe India should follow Cuban rule for doctors studying in government universities for that. search it

[@vaibhavsalve891]

In India mob lynching ,casteism = (higher caste people hate lower caste {thinking they get special treatment} by quotas and reservation in school , scholarships and jobs } Some Using fake atrocity cases against them Lower caste -hating {higher class for they were treated untouchables by higher caste for 5000 years and still are in some remote areas ,were not allowed to enter temples, not allowed in schools (Dr ambedkar was the first untouchable to passout school and attend college ,universities he wasn't allowed to sit with higher caste people or drink water from their pots and utensils he had to wait for a peon( if the peon didn't come he had to stay thristy) he whould not touch him and would drop water in his mouth from a distance of 5 -6 m , Some still killed in name of honor killings (if they try to marry someone from a higher caste, still looked down as something disgusting at some places , and (you should also see the movie article 15 (two girls brutally raped by people of higher caste and hanged on trees {to keep the lower caste people in check} {just because they were asking 2 ,3 more rupees in there daily income) etc.😥 For example, according to the People's Union for Civil Liberties (PUCL), the majority of those assaulted in 2007 were poor women from remote areas and Dalits. SR Darapuri of the PUCL alleged, "I analysed the rape figures for 2007 and I found that 90% of victims were Dalits and 85% of Dalit rape victims were underage girls."Darapuri allegations do not match with the data compiled by National Crime Records Bureau of India, which found 6.7% of rape and sexual assault victims were Dalits in 2007, where nearly 16% of Indian population is classified as Dalit.[ Rape cases are increasing In 2016, India recorded 106 rapes per day, highlighting the mammoth rate of crime rate against women , The NCRB data reveals that 2,60,304 cases of crimes against women were sent for trial in courts in 2016. The conviction was secured in 23,094 cases. Also, reported in 2016 were 206 cases of acid attack on women, while 7,236 women were stalked.In 2016, the horrifying gangrape of a 23-year-old physiotherapy student on a moving bus in New Delhi, which came to be known Nirbhaya Case, She was with a male friend who was severely beaten with an iron rod during the incident. This same rod was used to penetrate her so severely that the victim's intestines had to be surgically removed, before her death thirteen days after the attackprompted thousands to protest on streets on India’s archaic rape laws and handling of sexual assault cases.😭🤐😓 And the increasing fake rape cases against males, In 2014, as per a report submitted by Delhi Commission for women 53% of reported rapes in 2012-13 were found to be 'false'. This report considered the cases that were dropped before going to trial as false, and failed to differentiate between the cases dropped due to coercion and cases where it was clear that women were lying so much hatred is spreading everywhere in India Muslims are lynchied if they are seen with any meat {if misunderstood for carrying beef (mobs don't care to ask if it's cow's , goat , or chicken meat)😓 So many protest have happened And still no strict rules for lynching crimes.

[@vaibhavsalve891]

I love my country INDIA🇮🇳🇮🇳 BUT not some of the people living here 😓

[@Vikas_Bhartiya]

indian students r really hard working and innovative.....but not getting enough opportunity to enhance.. especially in government schools...

[@kingkongthemonster8061]

Vikas Bhartiya+indian and chinese all hard working peoples and we are smart too , let working together make this world great again !

[@MichiganUSASingaporeSEAsia]

Vikas Bhartiya good at cheating too

[@jagadeeshabs7677]

Actuly its problem for reservation, political rules..., companies... Attitute, personal growth.. Etc

[@pradipchaterjee9576]

@@kingkongthemonster8061 Yes

[@gangmusic7187]

Indian student have practical problem

[@zhizheng3795]

The indian and chinese student are both work hard in school ...coz ww are have diffferents stations between US

[@DeepakKumar-ym1hd]

India and China never were and never will be enemies.we should beware if western policies to divide these 2 great nations.

[@dharmang]

@@DeepakKumar-ym1hd never were is wrong, first learn some facts from the past

[@ColtraneTaylor]

@@dharmang You're both right.

[@amangola1103]

@@DeepakKumar-ym1hd shut up be practical bro use mind for thinking not emoticon

[@kunal.sharma]

@@DeepakKumar-ym1hd forget it China is biggest mf

[@CA-AkshayDhake]

I am an American citizen studing in India, I just want to say Indians and Chinese are generations ahead when it comes to overall discipline and performance. The reason America is still afloat is because a few crown jewels of America do it. Please centralise education on national basis. Make the position of teachers more competitive.

[@cambo-indiafriendship]

where Akshay?...

[@pradeepsapkota5797]

I think American school are good but the student don't put that extra hard work and gives the student too much freedom

[@brucesekliar5824]

Totally

[@apolitical1161]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/ZpvNn3SAhLeGY5Y 👆👆👆 In most Schools in India, There are *No Teachers* & Those *Limited Teachers* who are operating in schools are _More or less_ *Incompetent and Inefficient* and many times *without* any proper *Teaching Degrees* which results in destroying the *Future of India* & This is Absolutely *Shocking*... _Most _*_Students_*_ from the _*_8th Std_*_ can't even *READ A 2nd Std TEXTBOOK*._ In many *Indian States*, *_Teaching Posts_* (for *Teachers* to be *filled in large Numbers*) are still *Vacant.* *_Teachers, Students_* and their *_Parents_* must watch the *_Above Video_* & *$hare it,too !* 📗🖊👨🏻‍🏫👩🏼‍🏫👩‍🎓👨‍🎓

[@Shivam-ps6cx]

That's why they are good in every job

[@alexim158]

@@apolitical1161 Pakistan is begging you know ? Ur Prime minister is on another trip to beg some money. Go and get lost from here , no one is discussing about Pakistan.

[@apolitical1161]

@@alexim158 , No one is even discussing about you or care about your opinion. & No one is even asking your opinion on it, Darling ...... You are better being Quite!

[@KeithBallardEdu]

Samantha - you should be proud. India has come a long way in the past 50 years and will be the 2nd largest economy in the world in the next 40 years

[@ed4all33]

I am indian , I studied in india . My kids were born and brought up in the west as we had moved. The one thing i told my kids repeatedly was “ respect your teachers , i do not want to hear you being disrespectful to them or being unruly in school , because our teachers ( most of them atleast) give us the gift of education and knowledge , and they do it not because of the money ( all educators unfortunately all over the glibe are sadly underpaid), but because of the passion of giving u knowledgable , which will help u to became a better human being.

[@Analysing802]

Teachers teach bull shit in government schools except some

[@snehakuku]

I am a Lecturer and when I moved to UK and started teaching here, I was nothing but utter shocked comprehending the level of knowledge, fundamentals taught, reasoning ability and aptitude were too low to match the bachelors even I was teaching in so good university back in India. Here, they have all tools, support systems, facilities and yet they do not want to learn for the sake of knowledge. They just want to get away with it for the sake of doing it. Barely I interacted 1 or 2 students who shared interest to gain knowledge understand how I can benefit from this in life and career. But the rest were like lost hopes in Education especially higher education. The predominate students are from China, India, Pakistan, Bangladesh, Singapore, Japan and Oh! Boy these young minds were so on fire with lots of skills, knowledge, reasonings, sincerity - they blew my mind. The difficulty level reaches so late here that by that time Asian students have already grabbed the CGPA and scores in their batch and got placed or hired by MNCs already.

[@redage9759]

What u teach?

[@satyadeepborah1143]

I passed my 10th with History major. Took commerce and Accounting and Finance Hons during grads. We all had mathematics. Mathematics is a part and parcel of Indian and Chinese people.

[@NSriRamSai]

Untill highschool and college , the education system in india is very good. But at university level its not that good

[@anweshabhattacharya4651]

Only exceptions are IITs. The private engineering college culture that is spreading like mushrooms in India is rooting the higher education system.People study engineering just to grab a job from campus placements in one of the software MNCs. really depressing situation

[@coolblizzard1993]

+sri ram sai Even public primary schools are terrible.

[@nehashrivastav7552]

Why go to private institute with crap load of fees, work hard... Medical college are good not everyone make it to aiims

[@DjRocky]

Speak for yourself, i studied in BITS Pilani and IIT Madras. Plus there are other good private institute like Manipal, Vellore, SRM etc.[ I have engg background that is why specifying about that field]

[@sivakrishnat8225]

Spot on. College education is very bad in India. In USA it is too good.

[@sadenb]

Indian schooling is of high standard . Our mathematics curriculum is very strong . We have quite advanced level Calculus in XI-XII standard that acts as a solid base to any of the engineering subjects. Indian mathematicians are really good. A normal boy who is getting educated in a very less developed government school is far interior of states aspire to do well in maths and he had so much interest that I was amazed. There was this guy who wants to be a big mathematician . He loved numbers and did calculations so quickly and he was just 7 years old . Generally boys are more attracted towards the technical side while girls are more attracted towards life science and medical science. Indian doctors are of high quality . Sure we face problems of high population but you know when the educated people rises , the population is going to decline which results in high quality students

[@sadenb]

Say whatever you want . Doesn't really matter. Keep your jobs safe .

[@sadenb]

We do have a reading culture. I live in West Bengal , India and Kolkata is known as the art capital of India. We have produced great authors like Rabindranath(Nobel Prize winner for literature ) , Satyendranath , Bankim Chandra ,etc. We do have plenty of bookstores. College Street is a whole avenue of bookstores for a mile. We organize International Book Fair anually which is the largest book fair in whole of Asia . In a fair over 600 stalls are setup. Millions visit it every year. We have over 8 universities in our city itself out of which 6 are of National importance and are recognized internationally including IIEST , IIT , ISI , University of Cal , Jadavpur Uni. Except that we have plenty of other colleges. We have separate colleges for Arts , Law . My brother is an IIT passout in Marine Engineering and he worked. Regarding Academics influence , we have a huge amount . The hurdle is the politics and corruption which is reducing a lot over the couple of years. Infact do you know that internet users in the country have increased from 90,000 to 350000 in one year ? I myself have completed Masters in Computer Science as aspiring to do PHD and I am from a simple middle class family.My sister also is doing Post Doctorate in HIV AIDS research from University of Rochester , NY. Academics are highly inculcated in middle class families because of the lack of choice in other fields like Sports or musician even though there are plenty of people in the field of sports and music. Some of the people of distant villages in the state of West Bengal alone are MIT passouts working in ISRO , NASA , We also have extremely rich medical universities, rich in terms of knowledge. It's just because of our economy being not that great that India is the cheapest medical tourism place in the world. Now that the economy is rising heavily it will cross barriers. I am telling you the reason INDIA IS slower than CHINA in GDP is because of democracy. We grew 7.3% this year and projected 8% next year. China was 6.9% this year . We have a young population . That's another story. The biggest library in the world was Nalanda Library which was raided by the Arabs historically. Nevertheless we have huge public libraries here. The Kolkata public library is one of the biggest in Asia. I have been to America this summer and stayed their for few months . I am honestly saying Americans have very less knowledge of the rest of the world .Consider movies even , I know about Star wars culture , AFI , Citizen Kane , importance of B/W films even though I ma in the field of science. I am also a musician by hobby. American students have think of Indian films as Bollywood which is utterly not true . Because of linguistic diversity we have over 20+ film industries. Satyajit Ray (Oscar winner) who was one of the influences of Martin Scorcese ,Spielberg , Lucas , never made a single Bollywood film . The highest grossing India movie is not from bollywood. In the past 10 years we had 2 nobel laureates in Economics and people are trying to come back to India now because they understand what it is . We are promoting primary education for all . It will take some time but it will happen . Compared to the US , we are just a 65 year old country . We got our independence in 1947 and our neighbours try to hinder our progress. But we still kept developing Our Previous president was a scientist , one of the leading scientist in the field of space research and aviation

[@sadenb]

Come see the real India and don't base your opinions on the media or the indian community in the US.

[@mynameisjeff3182]

+Robbert Lee hey buddy i do agree some stuff that you have stated but if you wanna see cons of a country/thing then you will see only the bad side. It depends on the perspective you see. So yeah each and every country does have bad and good in it.

[@budatx09]

+Robbert Lee Mr. Lee. Now let me start of by saying; this entire debate was about how smart you and I ( I grew up in Texas, pretty much the toilet of America, well one of em) are in comparison to countries who even though they have all their problems of a third world country would have (govt corruption, gaps amongst their citizens on riches, infrastructure not updated) they still would still, could still , take any test that can be thrown to them from any college professor from any ivy league school and still pass it with out even trying. Now please look back on your post and think about how you try to defend your country with the choice words you used to counterattack Mr. sanch Sanchayan when all he said was he was taught things at an early age than you. Stop trying to describe other peoples mistakes and their weaknesses when you should take a hard look in a mirror bud. You sound stupid as fuck when you spout bullshit about our government being the best it is when we could be doing the same thing as india. in terms of how much we spend on the precious education for all the children of "mericuh fuck yeah". The way you write this post tells me a lot about you. you sound like a fucking little kid who assumes he's a big boy who can read, write, and count money. WOW, you must be so proud of your achievement my good sir. Count your fucking blessings, and realize you live in a country where you don't have to see all the corruption that works behind the shadow. where you can live your life till you die eating three meals a day , and sleeping in a comfy bed. in your house that you bought till you retire and you become the bitch of the government who now lives off social security checks every month. GOD BLESS AMERICA

[@dhanaty6744]

True. When I came to Australia for PG. I was shocked we had very simple Website building using software and normal coding which I already learnt in 10th standard 😅.. so it was very simple to get HD here in all my semesters 👌🏼...

[@ollovlogs]

The main reason why Indian and Chinese are ahead in education is just simply because they are taught manners and discipline first, and after that learning comes. It's true that most of the people said that, the people of India and Chinese are hardworking and do so become innovative in someway or the other. And I am proud to be indian JAI_HIND_JAI_BHARAT(India)

[@imamfmirrorball]

students aren't taught "manners" in Indian schools

[@ollovlogs]

@@imamfmirrorball yes i do agree but they are taught before they start going to schools.

[@imamfmirrorball]

@@ollovlogs it's just what families teach you.. the way they tell you to behave, they make you learn etiquettes.. but this happens in every country

[@apurvkumar5961]

I agree with this guy. He is correct in assessing that one of the key needs for developing a good education system is to inculcate discipline among the students . China, India, Japan etc have got that right by teaching everyone at a young age to respect their elders and have mutual respect for everyone in general. Our defence and other technological achievements are directly linked to advancement in education. I hope the Indian govt realises this soon and pushes the research facilities of its higher education institutions.

[@tukaramjagtap150]

The current education system in India is ok n do good.... Imagine if the real educational system of Gurukul and ashrams is followed what result indian kids will do......

[@ZOMBiEbuTTmE]

I really hope that that day would come. Atleast in my lifetime XD But gonna get jealous a lot because I couldn't get that type of education. Lmao

[@Hostile2430]

You would be braindead zombies like some Madrassa educated mullahs from Pakistan

[@vishuk9391]

@@Hostile2430 man are you serious!!!! i mean you are comparing gurukuls to madarsas 🤣🤣😂dude do some research!!

[@Roy-mk9zl]

They will be ruined.

[@elonmusk352]

@@Hostile2430 lol nice joke

[@pfiko]

Year 10 India .. I studied how a nuclear reactor works ... legit ... can cross check C.B.S.E syllabus

[@fisheeptiger]

Every time I looked at my son's test sheet and home works (8th grader), my heart aches. It's just so basic. And when I asked him math questions , he's often so confused about many concepts and don't even know how to write a clear proof step by step (he told me his teacher never taught how to). And the more ironic thing is, he has been straight A student since 1st grade and is currently in DOUBLE HONOR math class (learning 10th grade Geometry) and was accepted to a very selective STEM academy!

[@kailina5644]

I came across this video.. I am Indian.. And yes.. Even before school education our main education starts at our family level where we are taught to respect our elders and teachers. Ground level is key in formation of our future. School with uniforms, 6-7hrs of daily classes, homework, projects and at 10th and 12th grade we have to give board exams.

[@TreeTop4]

I have studied in the USA. I liked several things about the education system in the USA. First, none of the teachers force you to study (unlike India sometimes). If you are in college, you should be smart enough to set your priorities straight. Second, there is no pressure of scoring a particular number in tests because you are graded and as long as you are scoring more than 90 to 92% you get an A. Also, the Americans know how to use the technology which I found very intriguing. I attended a community college when I first came here. Then went on to complete my Bachelors and Masters which were 100% online which allowed me to keep working and studying at the same time. You can't do this in India. On the other hand, as an Indian, I can say that the Indians give a lot of importance to education no matter what part of the country you are from. I guess both THE COUNTRIES CAN LEARN SOMETHING FROM EACH OTHER.

[@hash_caul976]

what are you talking about man, indians who serves in millions in USA industries today without india they are nothing, in ome day economy collapse

[@JohnDoe-ps5hi]

@@hash_caul976 stop being a dumbass. That goes for any race.

[@Damian_HENRY]

WTF are you smoking hook me up need a dealer like yours

[@NM-tk4kc]

I scored 99/100 in my 10th, 149/150 in my 12th mathematics. Now I'm consultant for largest Telecom company in Australia

[@ShubhamShubhra]

You missed the perfect score both times. If you are from Asia Your parents are probably still giving you trouble for that. 😂

[@Veer_Pratap7]

I am Indian and I know the control of teachers on their students.

[@VJ96K]

In india school day starts with a prayer "Guru Brahma, guru Vishnu" which means our teachers are the Devtas/gods... n i love this prayer

[@aninred760]

Fake, In hindu schools in India. My school? I prayed 3 times everyday to Jesus, I’m a hindu

[@VJ96K]

@@aninred760 toh tum chutiye ho jo apni school ko bole nai ki jesus chutiya tha.... Shivmoga mein marne wala sach mein bewakuf hai jo tum jese Hindu o k liye jaan diya.... tu bhi baptism ya sunni karwa le....

[@sauravbarman4252]

Not in my school. Our anthem was about our love towards our motherland.

[@whoooshme8898]

@@aninred760 should've gone to a Hindu school then

[@aninred760]

@@whoooshme8898 Christian schools were far better in my city. (Hyderabad)

[@jaz3ee]

Kerala , Tamil Nadu and some other Southern States of India have a very good Education system and the students are pretty much Intelligent over there !!

[@daretodream7204]

Kerala??? 😂😂😂😂

[@pavim9131]

Ohh yeah in Kerala students is but they hardly get admission in college even someone who get ≤85 %

[@viswanathr2756]

The whole country still follows the Victorian era education system so education system in Kerala is as shitty as every other state in the country. It's just that both UDF and LDF gave importance about the literacy and education of the people and compared to the other states we became more economically powerful since the people started going to the gulf and so the people knows the value of education.

[@shashanksrivastavasri9641]

@@viswanathr2756 it's all about beginner advantage and geography.. I mean at the time of independence Kerala litecrcy was almost 55% Where as fir UP it was 12% .. So even if we compare today It's not the government who are to get credit. Neither the government of both states nor the central government.

[@ghosthunter8664]

@@daretodream7204 99.9 %litracy rate bro..plz check India's best education state

[@shaswatsahay9326]

But now PUBG is spoiling us..😫

[@ashwinkumar7402]

And Blue Whale killed some too😁

[@Hello-wc3ny]

#bangamesinindia

[@dharmang]

lmao gujarat is in banned state for pubg

[@arunthakur1661]

Haha funny

[@tanishqkabir5461]

Pubg isn't spoiling you son you're spoiling yourself

[@unicorn5360]

I'm from India and every day in my school we took pledge for respecting every thing like food, people, books etc everything you have

[@prashantsingh9637]

He is a man whose taking with absolute CLARITY and Ground Realities. Only such people DESERVE to be at leadership positions so that they can take right decisions

[@enjoylife7214]

I am 16 and i understood whole calculus in school at 11th and 12th class .... integration, derivation and algebra was totally Taught when I was in 7and 8th class...in those class we have mathematics book and one algebra book with it ..I know basics to standard whole algebra....I think 70%of maths in india get completed in school...

[@abc1def120]

I am Indian and I believe that some of the educational techniques in America are pretty good. Problem in America is too much freedom. Freedom is wedded to discipline. Discipline and many things are missing in America.

[@N5cool]

Information isn't the big deal in today's age of Internet...practical skills, application and thinking are more important than studying whole loads of theory...why the hell do you think Chinese and Indians go to the United States for tertiary education?

[@harip.ap.a3302]

They arent looking for better education .they are looking for jobs,bcz of lack of oppertunities in india.i have many freind studying accros america and china and singaporenall of them failed in indian entrance and wanted an degree that is cheap and with label of foreign

[@kannankr1884]

Family plays the main role... "Respect" is something which is not taught in families but seen in families.... and that makes a lot of difference... Let me correct something in this video, budget allocated for education is not the best in India (atleast). In a budget, you should allocate lion's share for education... You have to shape tomorrow from today itself....

[@happyvirk1]

I was learning trigonometry in 6 standard,, when I came here I was shocked to see that it’s so easy here in college

[@Harbingersknight21]

I was learning basic algerbra like Progressions, Quadratic equations etc in class 5 In class 6 little bit calculus , basics of mensuration and trigo 😎 Now in class 11 am studying for jee 🥲

[@varietiesofvideos1653]

The indian system is really great and we have all classes from nursery to 12th all in same school under one roof and in the US middle school,elementary,high school are all different

[@KeithBallardEdu]

You are 100% correct. America has really lost its way!

[@jose000]

.

[@niggy.]

Ye Ye

[@solomonsajj7726]

I still remember my college final semester, studying 24separate books fully, it wacked me but made me grow in knowledge and confident, To write 5, detail questions, 1200 words each, mind boggling

[@rajjal100]

I might be biased..but this teacher got some stuff .. :). Well done and may you be the start of the change Mr.Keith Ballard.

[@sangitakarad7218]

In our past times in gurukul and ashramas... They literally memories hundreds of books World by world ( which world is on which page, etc) And very creative... These people found the distance between Earth to sun 7000 years ago... It was written in HANUMAN CHALISA (it's poem you can listen it on KZbin also)

[@oksowhat]

4:18 this is what Indians need to realize, going to the US may increase their living standards but living here they can compromise on that but will increase living standards of thousands.

[@anushkalols]

This is pure organic, wholesome stuff. Only facts. Bravo👏

[@diyakasaragod1152]

He spoke so well. Proud of him 😊

[@shaileshgokhale1185]

Let me tell you this to my American friends, being an Indian (born, brought up, educated), and having spent substantial amount of time in the USA; do not model your anything based on other countries. I found Americans to be more 'fully rounded' than people in other countries. I think the key to American culture is self determination. Keep it that way. Do not look at the 'control' as you see it in India or China; the near absence of discipline issues in Indian schools come from the familial culture not from 'control'. I was not aware that the auto and shop classes were taken out of US education system. It is understandable (lack of funds) but very sad. India used to have vocational education, as I am told, when my dad was in middle and high school. I have seen what difference it makes to ones personality and character having such type of education. Yes, education gets higher priority in India and China but most of the 'well-educated' people you find coming from India are from private schools. Early education gets priority more in the Indian and Chinese cultures, not necessarily when drafting national policies on education. The government spends better on education when it comes to universities which has led to top world class universities coming up in India. But the high emphasis on education in Indian culture is more or less balanced off by the lack of enterprise and entrepreneurial attitude. That is why you may find more CEO's, MD's and top execs of Indian origin in multi-national companies than companies owned by people of Indian origin. So, no, you don't have to model your education system on any other country's. You have to model your education system based on your core values, while taking good points from other countries.

[@harshitabhuyan8892]

I think it's about the fact that while India is an ancient civilization, the country has received independence just about 75 years ago. We had to pick our country up from the ruins, learn to live together, find balance, govern ourselves, set up an education system and start industrialization all in these 75 years while undoing the damages done during 200 years of colonial exploitation. Ofcourse it took us time to catch up with other countries. For the longest time Indians were focused on getting a good education and job security and nobody wanted to take risks with startups but now things have changed. India is literally in the middle of an entrepreneurial revolution, there are startups coming out left and right and we are churning out lots of unicorns(companies valued at a billion dollars or more). So don't worry we are getting there, it wasn't a problem with the education system but rather our country was building a foundation and a level playing ground. Indians do own lots of companies today and this revolution is only going to explode in the coming years.

[@hemlata5738]

Why, just tell me why?. You all are so biased. Showing a good school in China and America but, when it comes to India, you just showed mid day meal rural government school. At least the competition should be on equal basis.

[@dramakun4931]

We r not poor Every time they show these poor schools

[@isNamanSharma]

@Shreya Singh yo what's wrong with u guys, most of the Indian population is studying in schools like that, they were showing public schools , and can you please tell me how many of the public schools have advanced infrastructure, I dunno why u guys are butthurt every time western people show the rural side of india, first of all why are you even bothered by what they think about us , and even if you are , then you should know majority india is rural, there are only about 20% or less somewhat developed cities in india, I dunno why you want everyone to think India is a well developed country when in reality it's no way near that, just accept the fact and be positive one day we will be the best

[@isNamanSharma]

@@dramakun4931 'YOU' are not poor, yeah that means no one is poor.......about 70% of Indian population is living under poverty dude, what do u mean

[@isNamanSharma]

@Hemlata Singh Why would they be biased, why do u all act like the whole world collectively is doing some sort of "saazish" against India

[@dramakun4931]

@@isNamanSharma for your kind information Our country is fastest growing And india is colony of Britain So we are poor But korea is not colony So u r not poor So first study history

[@naveensagar2408]

That sir on the right is telling the hidden truth of US (H1B ) visa . Thank u sir recognising my 🇮🇳 People talent.. 🙏🙏

[@RakeshKumar-sx7ob]

He is the most realist person I have ever seen 👌✌️

[@KeithBallardEdu]

Mr. Singh Thank you for your comment

[@KeithBallardEdu]

Everything in the world is a comparison. Education is no exception!

[@KeithBallardEdu]

Lisa Jing, thanks for yiur comment. I agree with you 100%.

[@KeithBallardEdu]

Not sure that anything has changed. I will be doing a TED Talk next year regarding visiting public schools in the 15 highest performing PISA countries. The following year, my book will come out and I will be doing more than 100 TV interviews across the USA.

[@Haru-iu8bm]

keith ballard Thank you , Sir 🙏🙏

[@Gnani7]

The mantras are from the Taittiriya Upanishad, Shikshavalli I.11.2, which says: matrudevo bhava, pitrudevo bhava, acharyadevo bhava, atithidevo bhava. It literally means "be one for whom the Mother is God, be one for whom the Father is God, be one for whom the Teacher is God, be one for whom the guest is God".

[@KeithBallardEdu]

I agree!!!

[@mattdamon2084]

81% scientist in nasa is bhartiya (Indian) ,it's outstanding and also not supposed too at same time

[@avinashasitis]

I think he is being a bit too harsh on USA education system. Yes India and China are doing well but still it's western countries which are at the forefront of innovation. About less disciplined USA kids: Well, a little bit of rebellious attitude is good for being a non-conformist and being creative and choosing ones own path or following ones own heart. I don't think anyone will hear any story such as that of Bill Gates, Zuckenberg or Steve Jobs where a kid drops out of college to start something of his own any soon from India and China in near future. Still long way to go. The good thing is irrespective of where the talent is coming from we are all collaborating to make this world a better place with technology.

[@wolverineiscool7161]

you're pathetic

[@piyushsingha8701]

Jack ma from china

[@neelsolanki9288]

Many IITian's have sold their Million dollar companies, before even getting their Bachelor Degree. In which world are you living?? Many IITians like me are not going leave India. Not all work for money, We work for Nation!!!!

[@angelinatan9441]

Isn’t that it?? If the people who dropped out of school like the people you mentioned were successful. Doesn’t that meant that the US education sucks?

[@098stan]

ma da dash .... have u heard email... that's India ... ditch... cause u gots the greens don't mean u gots the beens!!!

[@nightwolf4036]

I'm indian and i made an ios app at the age of 11. Programming is easy but i don't know why foreigners find difficulty in that. It's so easy to make an app.

[@sophiedavalos5730]

Can we all agree that rigurous education programs are not the only factor in success, or at the very least that they don't have to be idolized? Hard work and respect are extremely important qualities, however, having been a "perfect" student all of my life I can tell you that the pressure, stress and neglect of basic physical and emotional needs is no joke. I don't think it's the way to go at all.

[@adityatripathi3968]

i bet u keith it will be a eye opening experience for you..!! just come and visit INDIA again .....just see the change.!!

[@MohammadUmairAnsari]

The major reason is US offers excellent career opportunities with great financial benefits in multiple fields hence education is one of the ways to earn a living. In India, education is the pillar of life and other fields are not focused on that much.

[@karishmaagrawal331]

Most Americans are broke

[@amit6844]

I've also heard that in new zealand the maths ques they ask in exam for jobs, are same as the ques we solve class 9th & 10th in india.

[@coolblizzard1993]

I would like to tell you that the educational system in the public schools of India is terrible. Hardly any portion of the budget is spent on education in the states except a few states in the south. None of the Indian universities are amongst top 50 universities of the world. Focus is on quantity rather than quality.Even the private schools and colleges are terrible. The reason behind so many top class engineers and doctors we produce are the coaching/tutorial classes that almost every middle class kid attends in the evening after school with the aim of being able to get admission in the top government technical institutes. Otherwise except a few private and public schools, the situation is terrible.

[@harshtiwari7503]

+Your Daddy Saitama coaching classes and tutorials are one of the worst things that could have ever happened . i know that it was helpful once but it has become buisness for most of the the institutes to fool the children to get money and let them dream of helping them to get admiission in a good college.

[@shirishchinchanikar8199]

Public schooling is bad i agree but hence students prefer coaching classes which are quite good like in kota

[@daddydeadpool9871]

All I hear is complaining

[@Saurabh-255]

In India the most famous sentence about teacher is "Guru Govind Dono khade kake lagu paye balhari guru Apne Govind diyo bataye". In English Teacher and God is standing together I don't know who is more respected I'm blessed teacher that you introduce and tell me about God.

[@ykd0011]

In bharat ( also known as India) there is sanskrut saying which says मातृ देवो भवः। पितृ देवो भवः। आचार्य देवो भवः। Which means Mother is god. Father is god. Teacher is god. And it is like 5 thousand year old saying but USA is very young country and it takes time. So in future it may go well.

[@chintuvallabhapuram2392]

The first lesson we were thought as an asian (indian) "your education starts with ur respect for ur teachers" and when it comes to discpline we were also thought that jo matter however we are infront of no onewill atleast pretend when some one comes

[@harisrasheed3997]

IIT : I'm here Aiims: can I join you

[@shreyass672]

Sir keith I suggest u even look into Indian engineering and other institutions like IIT they may not be known around the world but most of the Indian people working in sillicon valley are IIT graduate students

[@abhira3159]

Are u kidding me we just don't fund our education and education system is based solely on memorizing. American education system is much better it's just that students are not as hard working over there as in India.

[@AmitSingh-sw8qb]

there education system is good but their students only loves party chill n other stuffs they got so much facilities than us if we could get those facilities then we can do much things 😞 but of total US population Indiana only 1% is there but each year almost 13% Indian students get graduate from whole US and it's huge no if our are only 1% there

[@hemanthreddyvennapusa18]

Our education system is not solely based on memorizing.There are so many schools here which focus on learning through practice and research.If you dont know just shut up and instead try to change the process not generalizing it to whole india.

[@truthisall]

abhishek rai

[@rameshkosana7461]

Hello, abhishek raj just feel proud to here that words from american, we are the Indians just killing ourselves by comparing with others

[@javitritiwari9538]

+abhishek rai You are a victim of leftist policy on self loathing

[@KeithBallardEdu]

M K - thanks for the info!!

[@shreyakorgaonkar7276]

Dont know why I was recommended this video..it was uploaded 9 years ago..today top management will hv Indian no matter which company..thr r few Americans who contribute alot to economy with thr intelligence n hard work but very large population is left behind n dnt prioritize education..In india I can say ..Government wants every kid in school no matter wht ..thy do everything to make kids learn basics..n basics in India sometimes is high school or college level concepts in other countries.🤔🤔🙂🙂👍👍🙏🙏

[@KeithBallardEdu]

Suryash Malviya - thanks for the recommendation. Unfortunately, I do not speak Hindi.

[@abbylee5916]

The best education system is to combine china/korea's system with US. Schools in the US should be more serious. Teachers in the US need to be better prepared and passionate for teaching. The students attitudes must change. Students need to have the passion for learning.There should be a national curriculum that every student should try to meet.

[@MichiganUSASingaporeSEAsia]

Abby Lee North Korea? Right.. seriously?

[@earthpatel5196]

They should combine india's system with us, as the richest people in USA are indians ;)

[@Analysing802]

@@earthpatel5196 oh??so who are Jeff bezos,bill gates,warren buffet then?

[@rebeledits5196]

I am a student of the Indian education system. Yeah, we are taught to obey our teachers, In India, rote learning is our priority most schools don't have many extracurricular activities. Maximum focus is put on the stem subjects. So our education system does not train a student for the real world. We are just taught to mug up answers, obey the teachers, suppress our opinion.

[@enriqueheredia5794]

India will soon become a superpower. I don't why Indians are leaving this beautiful country. Indian Parents are right, doctors and engineers have huge scope. Other streams like commerce and arts have no scope. Love from Spain 🇪🇸

[@gren4837]

the idea of prioritizing education over war and military is what every world leader needs to acknowledge.

[@KeithBallardEdu]

Only some cities in China have participated in PISA but Chines education system is very strong and it is get stronger. Japan and South Korea are not small countries - depends on how you define small. It is not about how big or small a country is but more about the quality of its education system. Chinas system is veryyyyyyyyyyyy impressive - perhaps you need to go there and find out for yourself!!!

[@i_Konark]

Indian CEO of some of the leading tech firms in USA Google, Alphabet Ceo - Sundar Pichai (Indian) Microsoft CEO - Satya Nadela (Indian) Twitter CEO - Parag Aggarwal (Indian) IBM CEO - Arvind Krishna (Indian) Adobe CEO - Shantanu Narayen (Indian) Palo Alto Network CEO - Nikesh Arora (Indian) Mastercard CEO - Ajaypal Singh Banga (Indian) Only Fans CEO - Amrapali Gan (Indian) And many more....

[@kirtigupta9753]

Maths and sciences are the strongest among Indian students. There's a lot of History of education in India. The world's first University was Takshshila established 2100 years ago and the second University of Nalanda was established 1400 years ago. So you see, education has always been in our genes.

[@nature6717]

IAM a physiotherapist and I observed that in our Indian students postural and musculoskeletal problems are raising day by day due to lack of physical activities and exercises and grounds in schooling.

[@KeithBallardEdu]

Ashish- the question should be - how many students will be happy in the USA when many of their futures bosses will be Chinese? The world is not fair and things will change dramatically within the next 20 years.

[@virtualatall]

My relatives emigrated to UK in early 2000s and they put their kids in public school..guess wat there is no exam till class 5...after 3 months they put their kids in private school.. Now my cousin is passing out her medical degree from Oxford

[@KeithBallardEdu]

yes, I am very familuar with the PISA test and am currently traveling to the 15 highest performing PISA countries in the world as well as the 4 BRIC countries. It is part of a book that I am working on. to date, I have traveled to 11 countries - 9 to go!

[@rainukm]

Hello Keith! First of all I really appreciate your sincerity in this domain. If you wish to do something for the society, you should seriously study about the works of John Taylor Gatto. Also have a look at the best resulting models like Sudbury - which is in your own country, Summer Hills, etc...

[@Glen.Danielsen]

Keith Ballard is a voice with a clear steer. We really need a cultural revolution in America. We have some things going for us, otherwise the foreign brain power wouldn’t keep coming here. But we need overarching change. 💛🙏🏼

[@AnkitKumar-pi6ey]

Keith sir thank you very much for this survey. I request to please suggest any idea to India for improving its education and come out from education crises with limited resources. Thank you sir again.

[@fisheeptiger]

Keith, I would thank you so much for your passion about this issue. I am a Chinese american parent who has kids in American middle school and elementary school. I personally complete my college education in China and post graduation in USA. I have first hand experience about the differences between the two countries. To be honest, I am so worried about American secondary education system now. I think it's definitely the time for American people to wake up and exam our education system.

[@KeithBallardEdu]

I agree - the U.S. K-12 Ed system is far superior to the system in India. India has some great private schools but the public school system for the most part is pretty bad!!!Just look at the PISA scores for India - I believe they were dead last in the world.On the other hand, China has a very good K-12 Ed system and it is constantly improving.

[@krantikoganti8608]

I agree with u. I dint go China hence don't know much about it uncle won't comment on that part. What is different is education is a high priority culturally speaking and the zeal to succeed is lot more in India and China than the US. With that zeal we overcome the challenges.... :)

[@anubhav111196]

Americans can't locate so many countries on globe maybe you should know what you are saying

[@madhuslazycooking4951]

you should visit kfi education ,that is completely different philosophy than any other school in the world,it is sotuated in pune,varanasi and hydarabad.you can google on Krishnamoorty foundation,they dont advertise their school but its philosophy is completely different.I kids are studng there.

[@jega1102]

keith ballard Most Americans don't know half the world, so pls do yr homework before you talk.

[@AnilSharma-ud9bh]

i am from small village of india,my father is a driver.but my government give many of things to me as well as lots of them which are like me.Now i am in DAV school which gives many of private services to student.i dont think that china has good school than indian. In our school, teacher taught us how to behave with elders not to make toys. they tell us about nature and truth..so that's why we called as indian.

[@deepz513]

So proud to be Indian. But we always complaint about everything.. people really have to look at the silver lining here..that's why I want my kid to have basic education here..be disciplined and knowledgeable ..later get higher education abroad..that's what we middle class people aspire to do

[@saiavinash7432]

India may have bad buildings and low quality of life in general but the quality of education is high standard af.

[@juhii456]

I really respect this man coz he is trying to make his country better by learning how the things are in different countries , there is nothing to feel superior or inferior irrespective of country which we belong as no one is perfect.

[@starship3812]

Don't worry america you are not going to be beaten in super power race by china becz we indians are here to support America. indians are learning just to serve USA we learning to make America great. Although we indians live in poverty.

[@greensquirrel4019]

I've been a part of private owned catholic school in Kolkata, India.. The discipline is a big thing here... I'd say it's even more important than grades..

[@tharunkumar6879]

the social system in India is such that the kid ought to become either a doctor or an engineer. he ought to work for the family and forget his own interests, passions, creativity and talents. that's the case in most families I've seem till date.

[@MichiganUSASingaporeSEAsia]

Tharun Kumar agree

[@KeithBallardEdu]

Matthew - thanks. Yes, I am writing a book. It will be out next summee. I will be doing more than 100 TV interviews talking about it.