ULTIMATE 16" CREATOR Laptop Comparison 👉 ASUS ProArt P16 vs Dell XPS 16

[@felicytatomaszewska]

I believe the P16 is the clear winner for me for three main reasons: Performance: The P16 offers superior performance, which is crucial for my needs. Price: The price difference of $500 or more is significant and cannot be ignored. Weight: Even a small difference in weight makes a big impact when I'm traveling. This is why I currently use a 14-inch MacBook Pro instead of the 16-inch model. Whether I'm traveling by train, ferry, or airplane, I always manage to find a power outlet near my seat, so I don't have to rely on the battery. Additionally, I prefer physical buttons and a trackpad with clear edges, which the P16 provides. This makes it a no-brainer for me if I decide to use a Windows laptop. However, this is a big 'if,' especially considering that Microsoft tracks even keystrokes. I don't have a compelling reason to use Windows in my environment, whether for personal or office use.

[@ElevatedARFitness]

Great video! The company that I work for has always supplied dell XPS as part of their offering. However, the biggest flaw I've found on this PC is the "aluminum” / overheating issue. All works well (like any other PC) once out of the box. After a few weeks of heavy use, then the heating issue arise. It seems to be a common issue on this model.

[@MrPerrisC]

I get the Asus for price but I have always been an AMD fanboy. By the way, having more abundance in ram helps even if ram doesn't bottleneck. The operating system both proactively and passively caches data into RAM, on longer compute sessions, and if you stand by, ram going unused winds up populated with most likely data you typically use. Typically, on my 32 GB box, 12 gigs are in use, 19 gigs shows in resource monitor as cache data, this happens overtime computing, but gets reset on a restart, does not get reset on standby. In essence excess ram acts as a ram disc, there's no performance hit using excess ram as data cache. I'm on my phone so I can't check, if memory serves, the Intel soldered ram is probably faster than the Asus? I personally go for more RAM over fast ram. Another also, I believe AMD is providing software that allows users to change power drawer percentages, not positive about that, v I think I saw that on another creator's tube

[@atlantikbummler]

Exactly the review and comparsion I was looking for. Thank You! I'm looking for a 16" OLED touch. Leaning for the DELL XPS with Intel and 90Hz Display. Regarding Keyboard and Ports I am not sure if I will like the new Dell. Would take Asus if it would offer Intel configuration but with AMD I am a little shy because I have some old SW where I don't know if they might cause problems with AMD. Other than that, I really like the new ProArt P16. I am upgrading from a Surface book 2 15" which I had for 7 years and still love it. But beattey is end of life and changing nearly impossible or super expensive with risk of damage. That all the new notebooks now have easy acces to for battery exchange is a hughe step forward.

[@DanielRodriguez-fg5ll]

finally! thanks. will watch this right away.

[@louloup4246]

Thank for your test . Effectively the real configuration is 4070 2+2 to ssd 64 go ram . I don t understand why it s difficult to have real test in context . Maybe with amateur and pro on davinci resolve because it s the editing software. Also ableton protools cubase . To see his power and fluidity in real context . The step 2 is also to compare with macbookm3 pro m3 max and the best pc with same same graphic card because 4090 hit the 4070 . For creators it is the ultimate test . Also to see what is happen just on battery . What we could do and how many long time . Because there is theory and real project and workflow . Thanks for your work

[@implode_]

Thanks for this comparison. I need a computer and have narrowed it down to these two. I would choose the ProArt over the XPS for these 2024 models. I'm wondering what will come out in 2025. I'm going to wait and see. Either better machines, or get the 2024 models a little cheaper.

[@growseryt1839]

You have read my mind, 2 days ago I searched for a vid exactly about this and damn there it is

[@theTechNotice]

:)

[@murraywebster1228]

My (older) XPS 15 came with a funny little dongle which stopped working after first software update, still worked for a while with other laptops but crapped out completely after about two months, according to seller dongle was not included in warranty as it was „a free gift“, nice after spending @ €3000……..

[@TikTok-to8qq]

at that price it should be built like tank like iPhone 16 on which cyber truck ran over

[@piwypd0]

also you forgot battery, if asus is slower while unplugged it should be more efficient and more battery lasting right?

[@implode_]

In your review on the previous version of the ProArt P16 ( the one with the Intel ) you stated when powered off and charging it would get very very hot, and of course the fans would kick on immediately when powered up. Did you notice that on this 2024 model? Thanks for your reviews btw.

[@theTechNotice]

Nope, don't Notice that on the new

[@KelGhu]

It's funny how the word "Trackpad" has taken over "Touchpad". The original word is "Touchpad" and covers all "pads". "Trackpad" is originally the brand name of Apple's product/tech.

[@cheekster777]

Thank you my friend.

[@amigatommy7]

One of each would be nice...

[@chrysanthcrest]

I'm really considering the P16 at the moment, could you tell me how wobbly the screen is when using the pen? Since the main purpose is digital painting, it's one of the more important factor for me as well. I also considered the PX13, but I need the extra SSD slot to run Linux (I want complete separation and no dual boot). Thanks in advance!

[@Promikes]

You can use VMware for Linux, no need in different ssd. And by the way wobbling is horrible even without pen. But I am considering p16 too...

[@chrysanthcrest]

@@Promikes Yea I know. I tried both VM and WSL and just didn't like splitting resources for both host and the VM (I know, Ubuntu doesn't require much), but it is indeed the better option than conventional dual boot. I still prefer having separate SSD in cases like complete OS reinstall, etc. I was thinking about 3D printing a fitted dock or something just to keep the screen from wobbling if I did get the P16.

[@Promikes]

@@chrysanthcrest my friend, I was thinking about same thing))) you are not alone... also I am confused about its PWM screen, modulation is harsh on this one.

[@David-px5lr]

@@Promikes is wobbling horrible even when you have it resting on your lap as you type?

[@HarpreetSingh-br2ix]

I am using Asus p16. Its a great machine well built. Worth every penny

[@taupangnang1245]

For Dell XPS 16, I think the extra weight is not caused by the metal, but the glass, I mean, the clean "track pad" part are all glass 😂

[@amigatommy7]

Bought a P16 recently. Ran into a display problem where the desktop is dim if a window is open. No fix yet.

[@Incrediblysimplestudios]

Lenovo yoga pro 9i deserves a shout out

[@lastofthevandals]

Excuse me, but what the hell does 13:43 mean? How can ASUS don't run benchmark which is basically a render scene? But you've claimed that the software works... So the render wasn't working? F12 did nothing? Or render has stopped? Or WTF was going on with ASUS there? I am really confused 😵‍💫 I mean missed render option is kinda huge problem for 3D software

[@BenjaminMoorebeer]

Why not compare to MBP 16"? I bet that would fair well, especially with video encoding.

[@DanielRodriguez-fg5ll]

Oh no, I was expecting the StudioBook 16 also in the comparisons. I have the 13980hx, ADA 3000. Any chance you have an opinion how much faster or slower is the Studio book than the P16?

[@theTechNotice]

coming out soon P16 vs old Studiobook :)

[@DanielRodriguez-fg5ll]

@@theTechNotice thanks. the suspense is killing me.

[@drpp5448]

This is exactly the comparison that i wanted to see. somehow nobody is recommending XPSs anymore

[@DaneReidVoiceOver]

The Dell was released early this year with Intel's first core ultra processor. It's not running Arrowlake. It would've been better to compare whenever the AL Dell is released. There was never any doubt the Asus would win.

[@manuelthalmann2826]

Also p16 does support thunderbolt

[@TheIberrie]

The Asus is a clear winner for me. I need to buy a new heavy spec laptop for work but I read online about the Asus screen randomly going black for a second. Anyone knows if this really is an issue or just a few people with the issue? I Don't feel like spending around 3K on a laptop and having to deal with problems like that from day one. If it is a common problem I would stick to a Dell even though it is slower

[@ronervine]

Not sure if you have made your purchase yet or not, but thought I would chime in after owning the P16 for a few months and always having Dell XPS models beforehand (3 different models) Yes the P16 will do weird things with the screen, when you open it from standby it will go dull and takes a few moments to sort itself out so to speak. It will also turn off randomly from time to time. Very frustrating. As I type this on my previous generation XPS the P16 is currently being fixed for a second time after only 3 months of ownership. To be fair this time its due to bit locker not letting me in so its software related. The first instance it wouldn't turn on or charge., just died on my completely. I was given a full refund but STILL wanted the P16 as it is an AMAZING laptop when working. So they shipped another after repurchasing it again... I now worry constantly if it will just decide to die on me again (especially worried when it falls out of its warranty period) I am based in New Zealand and fortunately we have great consumer protection laws. In saying that if I get the call that the P16 can not be fix for a second time I will be taking the refund and purchasing the new XPS full spec which works out being 6.6K NZD compared to the P16's 5.2k NZD . Getting a third P16 in as many months is just plain madness. I will say I have NEVER had an issue with the XPS line its just this time round I thought I would try the P16. Its a real shame because the P16 is INCREDIBLE I have just found it to be very unreliable. I hope this may provide you some help :) Sing out if I can answer any questions you may have and I will try my best to answer them.

[@TheIberrie]

@@ronervine Thanks for the reply! I also had/have 3 XPS's . But with the last 2 of them I've had my share of problems. With one the battery inflated due to heat, which also destroyed my keyboard. Had that one replaced since I had 3 year on site insurance, so that got fixed smoothly. But what made me kind off mad is the one I'm using now, the screen randomly freezes on a daily basis (for years now, nothing they can do about it). So you have to turn the screen off and it is fixed. Very annoying if you do a lot of Team calls and your screen freezes. It also regularly overheats and shuts down. With the current XPS offered, being even more expensive and they limit the power provided to the NVIDIA card a lot (WTF??) you pay way too much in my opinion. So I was looking for something else, ended up with P16. I understand you now have a new P16 without issues? Maybe the first one was a "Monday morning laptop"? How long do you have the new P16 now? I appriciate you feedback a lot, tx!!

[@ronervine]

@@TheIberrie Hey, apologies for the late reply. Sorry to hear you had so many issues with the XPS line. The few issues I had could be sorted locally by their repair team even though one was well out of its warranty window. I could not fault Dells aftercare service. Moving onto the P16 which is what I currently own, the first unit was a complete write off and was replaced. I just got it back for a second time however it was a "boot logo issue" where it just kept the start up screen on the ProArt logo without actually starting up if that makes sense? I got it back yesterday from the Asus repair team and they just reset the bios. Its working perfectly now. So it was just a software issue I guess. Both times Asus where incredibly quick to resolve the issues (within 3 days) which in NZ is unheard of .. Everything takes forever to get done, we are kind of lazy in the respect but Asus has been honestly amazing. Fingers crossed no more issues as its the perfect laptop for me ! Stay well friend :)

[@akarna69]

Dell has a better track pad, ProArt is better in every single other aspect and is $500 cheaper. Big W for Asus, massive L for Dell, or two massive L's.

[@IDontKnow-bb6mt]

Amazes me people buy Dell, especially these horribly designed xps laptops. And to make it worse they are a ripoff

[@kendout]

Are there any tech youtubers capable of making content about build quality? Talk in detail about hardware quality. Because with more than 13 years of experience using technology devices. Specifications for me are not a prerequisite anymore (manufacturers often use parameters to attract customers), the quality of the product is what I care about. I'm willing to spend more money to buy a lenovo t14s or x1 than spend less money to buy a product from asus - I'm considering the aspect that I can afford it and I want the product to be worth the money, I don't want to be guided by the manufacturer's marketing nonsense.

[@liltee92407]

I must add.. I have the dell and only had it for a month before the ports started disconnecting and reconnecting on its own. Smh it's so sad that they want so much and it's not worth your money. ..

[@sentientai3739]

Well its a no brainer for creators just get the Asus P16 it actually has physical function keys. Can't believe Dell looked at the Touchbar macbooks and decided to make it worse.

[@ContraVsGigi]

Don't buy any of them. Wait for Arrow Lake, it will be much faster and more efficient that the last year's generation CPU. I think the launch is next week.

[@varadillath4508]

That’s desktop not for laptop. The new generation high performance intel chips for laptops will be released during CES in January 2025

[@PKperformanceEU]

Apple already stomps arrow lake with m3max, just wait for the new m4 pro and max will demolish arrow lake even more than m3 already does: )

[@ContraVsGigi]

@@PKperformanceEU Thanks, but no thanks. If they open their platform to install my chosen OS, I might consider it.

[@PKperformanceEU]

@@ContraVsGigi you can. You can run vm’s with max cpu cores allowed to the vm, i wish we had bootcamp option but still parallels is not that bad anymore. Pretty solid performance

[@ContraVsGigi]

@@PKperformanceEU I mean running it on hardware.

[@MrAzyyh]

Would you recommend these over a MacBook

[@seanedits10]

When are lunar lake benchmarks coming 🥲

[@theTechNotice]

So much new stuff coming out in the next couple of weeks, stay tuned! :)

[@seanedits10]

@theTechNotice Awesome thanks

[@Masteraaa-cb5uj]

Nice

[@blackshadow4156]

Note that if the xps 16 get 64 gb of ram it will be better to buy a gaming laptop with 4090

[@williamblake7386]

Meteor Lake is the Ryzen 7(8)X4X(Zen 4 cores) competitor, nobody in the right mind would buy it for the full price. Outdated furnace. Btw, no noise tests/demo, no good laptop review.

[@puwanatth]

at this moment get P16 with 64 RAM for sure !

[@KreativeDevices]

🔥

[@rsher_digital-art]

Please build a system specifically for Blender.

[@nosuchthing8]

Asus has 6 speakers sir...

[@sativagirl1885]

Which Silicon Valley firms are hiring talented creators in October 2024?

[@louloup4246]

You compare a pc with a piece of art . It s not cool for Asus ! Only mac could be compared ! The same for twice the price . The important question ! I m not sur about. The maximum of ssd is 8 to like the Last or 4 . For a creator it is a crucial question . Cause external ssd are slow 2go s.

[@samv2777]

Expense be computer doesn’t make you creator

[@aleksandrmikhailov3255]

Any reason to buy this instead of the M4 macbook pro?

[@theTechNotice]

3D workflow

[@aleksandrmikhailov3255]

@theTechNotice yeah, and for the other 95% of people? 😄 Serious 3D work is done on a powerful PC anyway, not a laptop, right?

[@TheWxcvbn2011]

It's not running MacOS, which is a relief.

[@vampritt]

no point comparing them. new intel ultra 200 version is coming out to make both of these obselete.

[@theTechNotice]

well... Lunar lake only supports 32GB of RAM which puts it out of question for a lot of creators....

[@Tyrellco7]

Sorry I am windows user from 25 years but today never I buy a windows laptop of 3000 or 4000 E. The high temperature, noise same as plane, always wired to MAximum performance... Etc... No thanks for its better and safe M4 macbook pro or MAX.

[@Tigerex966]

That was a long time ago and macs Intel did the same even the m3 pro and Max when pushed can be loud.

[@PKperformanceEU]

Hell yeah macbook pro 16 literally kills the competition, i mean M4pro and max will demolish intel and AMD more than they already did with M3. Windows sheeps listen carefully: M4 uses arm v9 and that alone is a massive jump not to mention N3+ litography. Take my word m4 kills the competition and there s nothing u can do about it: ) I could go into greater technical detail but why for average joe s who see this comment.

[@Promikes]

You can't understand one thing - macos is not a windows... that's all, I am saying this as mbp m1 max ​user for last 3 years, and whole life on windows previously, macis is for women and casuals, that's all I want to say@@PKperformanceEU

[@kosteztelnice]

​@@PKperformanceEU huh, zen 5 is too made on 3nm lithography, not to mention Intel new CPUs do use tsmc 3nm tech too...

[@PKperformanceEU]

@@kosteztelnice yeah so? I told you M4 will stomps the rest. It did and does. M4 vanilla is almost if not max TDP HX370 lvl. Depending on benchmark and. If i compile synthetic algorithms with -Ofast, -loopunroll -Accelerate(or armPL) -pthread. The same good stuff on x86 so: Ofast intelMKL, mavx2/512, loopunroll, amx M4vanilla is neck a neck or faster than 70-80w HX370. Mac👑👑👑👑

[@isl0w3]

60 Hz is really a downside, no matter how much better the overall performance is. it's 2025 nearby

[@Tigerex966]

For most things that don't include 📜 ng and games it's bare if at all noticeable definitely not videophit editing music production etc.

[@eygs493]

the most useless review out there

[@theTechNotice]

Thanks for the feedback!

[@eddieoconnor4466]

The only thing that I don't like with the new Dell 16-inch?...is that "invisible" track-pad.....some folks aren't gifted with mnemonic memory..and can't figure out the "edges" etc I need the physical track-pad to be there..and to function normally...this is why I had to switch to the Lenovo X1 Carbon and the ThinkPad T-490.....I don't need fancy gimmicks and silly fads...I need a laptop that's always "at the ready" to get some programming and development done. You know how hard it is to code when you're "fishing" for the edge of a trackpad?...(for those of us that prefer edge scrolling as opposed to two or three finger!) Nah...I'll have to pass for now...but I love Dell as a company...been with them since the early 90's.....hopefully?...Dell will return to the "XPS" format that put them on the map..and will get back to making LAPTOPS that put FORM and FUNCTIONALITY back to the top of the list..and leave the gimmick-y stuff for their other lines / series!