Villager Trading Hall Tutorial with Zombie Discounts | Minecraft 1.14/1.15 (Java Edition)

[@impulseSV]

Great design! I may have to upgrade my trading hall ;)

[@sloppie1000]

yes this is very good design

[@eirikengevik9826]

Do you know if this design works on PS4?

[@entity-hp3xw]

Hi impulse

[@eirikengevik9826]

@sleepy evee It does? I'll try it then

[@volted_blitz8230]

iTrade will be hella good Impulse

[@HaruGamingCh]

IMPORTANT NOTE: Turning Villagers into Zombie Villagers depends on the difficulty of the game. 0% chance in Easy. 50% chance in Normal. 100% chance in Hard.

[@ÄY5KÄRI]

So does that mean that I dont need to name my villagers if I am playing on hard mode?

[@HaruGamingCh]

@@ÄY5KÄRI You don't need to if you are going to stay in range of the zombie villager. If you go away it might despawn.

[@ÄY5KÄRI]

@@HaruGamingCh So if i heal it straight away then naming it is useless?

[@ÄY5KÄRI]

@@HaruGamingCh Also can I replace those prismarine lamps with glowstones?

[@wilde8984]

Iiro Pitkänen yes and yes

[@sirrismendozasunlessrealms5775]

This guy takes the word "Tutorial" to a next level. He explains details, gives us advice and really cares about little problems we may find and how to solve them. The effort doesn´t not go unnoticed, and as simple as it can be: That is the reason for my subscription. Great video, mate.

[@Eric_The_Cleric]

Just want to say I like your name lol.

[@alunarnova]

can you confirm if this design is still working fine in 1.15.2?

[@Eric_The_Cleric]

@@alunarnova it is. I just finished my trading hall a few days ago. 6 working villager slots so far, everything is perfect.

[@maheshkhatuka7205]

Can u tell what's the prob lem in mine game because whenever I converted the villager into zombie and then cure it never gives discoint

[@alunarnova]

@@maheshkhatuka7205 java or bedrock?

[@crazystikbot1062]

There isn’t one tutorial on this channel that isn’t clear. You explain technical aspects of these farms perfectly, and make them extremely understandable. The farms themselves and the designs are fantastic and super efficient. You explain things in a crystal clear way. Also, I love the fact that you make sure that we understand how the farm works, as many tutorials just tell you how to do the thing. Subscribing is the least you deserve! Good luck with future projects. Brilliant channel. Thanks! P.S, I vote for you as the next Hermitcraft edition! :-)

[@charlesbing6753]

11:38 nonchalantly talks about designs while casting baby villages into the dark abysmal void. Very good video

[@2911oscar]

3 book cases for an emerald and an emerald for a book, that won't be exploited at all...

[@xavierc12343]

Stonks

[@xavierc12343]

Lol I got that too, and I got a mending book. Problem is, he runs out of stock and I have to wait for him to restock, but by the time he does the price goes up

[@mattlewandowski73]

most youtubers I have seen that are building a trade hall have made one such villager. I have heard it is a rare trader, but it seems easy to manipulate til you get one.

[@2911oscar]

@@mattlewandowski73 it's not rare at all, and even if it was, you can just use 2 villagers

[@nastynigel76]

Also if you get a naturally spawning Zombie Villager and cure it, its trade never lock.

[@kazooking2910]

Materials for ONE Trading Module: 1 Redstone Lamp 1 Redstone Block 3 Sticky Pistons 2 Observers 9 Redstone Dust 1 Activator Rail 1 Trapdoor 1 Lever 2 Strings 1 Workstation Average Amounts: Some solid Blocks Some Glass Blocks Some Slabs 1 Lever per Booster Rail Some Light Sources This Material List only includes the Materials for one Villager Trading Module. This does not include the Materials for any of the other Parts of the Trading Hall

[@kw6280]

Thanks!

[@idsevanbenthum2769]

I was looking for this comment. Thanks!!

[@kazooking2910]

Idse van Benthum You‘re welcome. I was looking for something like this coment as well so I counted the resources because I needed them and posted it to help others.

[@qwest500]

Thank you !!!

[@hbaabes]

+ 1 carpet

[@DimSunX5]

Anyone else here from Mumbo Jumbo? ;) I'm already loving this guy! :D

[@nataliecatalano1416]

DemiSideS same already subscribed :)

[@superhot23yearoldfemale15]

I was just about to say that!!!

[@baileyalexander8147]

yeh man

[@samiam5708]

Yeah

[@completelyrandomyoutubeenjoyer]

yeah lol

[@chrissheetmetal275]

11:36 That casual moment where you realize he's set up his system to drop off babies into oblivion.

[@brxiii6048]

😵

[@clauderoy1539]

I'm having a problem where the Zombie will not attack the villager when I drop the lever down. I don't understand why, the villager can't escape and the Zombie clearly wants to attack him but he can't quite get to him. I've checked multiple times and I can't see what I did wrong. Anyone has an idea? Thanks a lot! Edit: Solution: Get away from the station while you do this. Even though the Zombie seems to try to attack the villager, he was focused on me since I was in front. I ran like 15 blocks away and now the Zombie focused the villager and it worked. I've seen many people having the same problem, upvote this so people will see :)

[@antxionrhykel2699]

I had this issue too, except I was in creative, i had another row, 5 blocks away opposite the first row, and the zombies were agro on the villagers on the opposite side, have to make it nice and wide so they cant do that

[@illagevidiot8254]

If you haven't figured it out yet, it's cause the zombie is tracking you and not the villager. Go around a corner and the villager will get turned

[@tumamma8875]

Tysm i have the same problem, i spent like 20 min figuring out wth was going on 😂

[@kanatokazuya1637]

THANKS!!

[@ahmedelgharib546]

if u have ur world set on easy the villager wont turn into zombie if its on normal there is 50% chance he will turn into a zombie if its on hard its 100%

[@icelk]

This is the material list for a single segment of the villager storage: 2 levers (3 for single segment) 1 workstation 1 carpet 1 redstone block 1 powered rail (2 for single segment) 1 activator rail 1 trapdoor 2 observers 2 glowstone/sealantern 3 sticky pistons 9 redstone dust 16 glass 8 slabs 13 solid blocks 2 string

[@PussyGaming67]

Thank you so much ❤️ Also can you confirm if the trading hall works in 1.16.2?

[@dankozy126]

It does work in 1.16.2

[@PussyGaming67]

@@dankozy126 thank you 😁

[@galact1c]

for some reason i started laughing my ass off when the villager just fell into the void at 11:36

[@man-tv7hf]

GalaxyGaming lmao me too

[@casertanick]

Me too I rewinded it a couple times

[@monochromeart7311]

Ray Works: that's the naughty sorter

[@JToaster]

GalaxyGaming same lol

[@kingchris-xt9lf]

same thats why im in the comments rn

[@olivermayman6630]

Item list for the trading hall per module; 2 Carpet 9 Redstone 10 Glass 7 Building Blocks 1 Redstone Block 1 Redstone Lamp 2 Light Source Blocks (eg. Sea Lantern) 2 Observers 3 Sticky Pistons 2 Levers 1 Dispenser 1 Button 1 Powered Rail 1 Activator Rail 2 String 8 Slabs 1 Trapdoor 1 Villager Workstation (eg. Lecturn) Potentially need extra building blocks, potions, golden apples etc.

[@limitedinfinity5095]

thank you so much

[@bigboom2438]

Thanks for this!

[@hotheis2982]

also... does that include the materials you need to kill the villager?

[@repel5801]

God bless u

[@olivermayman6630]

ivace yeah it does

[@effectivelyuseless]

Incomplete Timestamp List 9:25 Sorting and transporting baby and adult villagers 10:40 Transporting baby villagers over a longer distance 12:23 Minecart system 15:31 Extended minecart system 16:00 Pressure plate system to remove pathfinding (making sure villager only takes trade given) 18:02 Villager schedules to determine when they'll change trades 19:50 Ejecting villagers to their workstation area 20:51 Workstation area

[@Sithoid]

Tested this in 1.15 and it seems like one simple improvement can be made to a trading hall cell: place a slab on top of the job block. This doesn't prevent the villager from working on it, but prevents him from pathfinding to other villagers' blocks (which could mess up restocking). This must be done before placing the villager in their cell.

[@BerrysLive]

omg thanks

[@timk.817]

Thanks! I'm glad I read the comments before putting these morons in their cells!

[@johnkan11]

@@timk.817 lmaooo

[@fashnek]

Correct, ALWAYS make sure that a trapped villager never has two blocks of air. And DO NOT USE TRAPDOORS -- those count as air. Keep them properly trapped or else you will get more CPU time wasted on pathfinding, which will cause extra lag and all sorts of unexpected behavior on the villagers AND other mobs in the area.

[@Xd_Dones]

That helped me out so much you are the best, cheers!

[@elyncross4486]

This is very well worded and easy to follow. I'm usually clueless when it comes to redstone contraptions but I was able to follow along perfectly. I even designed a prototype to use in my survival world with some slight changes. Thank you so much for the guide!

[@StevieRZ]

it's probably worth knowing that there's a bug that zombie villagers who were named before conversion CAN despawn. so make sure you have a curing kit ready or a fresh nametag before infecting your favourite villager!

[@prumchhangsreng979]

No. Just stay within 6blocks. Nametag are expensive. If u are 128blocks aways, it will despawn. If u are within 32blocks there is 2.5% chance of despawn. But to be safe, stay within 6blocks. Afk a bit. Idk will it prevent the 2.5% chance of despawn or not but it never despawn when i do this. Oh also rmb to add a roof so zombie villager wont burn when it turn day during the curing process

[@StevieRZ]

@@prumchhangsreng979 yeah but u need to not leave your weakness potion and grapple 128 blocks away or u'll be stuck not able to cure them without leaving them to despawn

[@prumchhangsreng979]

Oh i didnt see u said "have curing kit ready". I thought u want us to use nametag during the curing process. 😂

[@StevieRZ]

@@prumchhangsreng979 ah lol, yeah curing immediately is better but name tag is an alternative, they can get cheap if you've cured some villagers already, plus I like to keep some in my enderchest anyway so could use it if out of gapples for example.

[@ethanaw9272]

If I name the villager will it still convert to a zombie even if i play on easy

[@tylerv1221]

this is one of the best tutorials ive ever seen, you accept and understand that it's never a one size fits all and instead of showing us YOUR perfect version you come up with a bunch of extra scenarios and teach us what things do instead of saying that when it's done it will work. great video, +1

[@BoWSkittlez]

11:36 is my favorite part. Baby villager just casually falls to his death haha

[@ElectricGun100]

Get a fletcher, zombify him then cure him. He'll give you emeralds for a few sticks lol

[@DrDevon23]

Combo this with a witch farm for infinite emeralds!

[@stigrunarsolli1062]

@@DrDevon23 Or zerotick bamboo farm

[@fabremymonke]

or trees

[@hotheis2982]

evan danendra do you need to use glass?

[@SoraNeku]

@@stigrunarsolli1062 or quantum tick farm

[@HaruGamingCh]

Wow! Great timing. I was about to make my librarians to zombie villagers to get my discounts, and then you uploaded this! What awesome simple design and easy to understand. Keep the videos coming, it really helps a lot of new players.

[@shakedapter5745]

Mumbo has used your design in the hermitcraft server!

[@XenoKnightAlpha]

What really sold me into subscribing to you was your explanation of how the Redstone works (especially at the end). I can't ignore a good teacher!

[@mynamequis4325]

They really need to add LogicalGeekBoy to Hermitcraft.

[@curtisniebergall4767]

Honestly yeah

[@illegalcqt3856]

E

[@blurk1722]

Legacy

[@jtsp84]

@11:39 love the baby villager casually faling into the abyss like nothing is wrong. also, this thing works great! just be sure your difficulty is set to hard when converting a villager to a zombie villager or he will have a 50-100% chance of dying. learned that the hard way a couple of times before i googled it. (also, working for me on 1.15 pre4 snapshot)

[@bilegsukhtserenjav1350]

You got a shout-out from Mumbo Jumbo!

[@midnightCirc]

11:32 And off he goes, just like that! *baby falls into the abyss*

[@AnimilesYT]

Sadly entity cramming is a thing, and this causes the villagers to drop down to 1 hp which is quite a risk if you have a good villager. Mumbo experienced this as well as seen in his video. I've modified the holding cell by placing a heavy weighted pleasure plate in there. When the signal hits 3 (21 villagers on the plate) it will send out a minecart. The rails also get changed in direction for a bit and the villager is sent into lava with the same sort of system you used in your video. The minecart is also collected and put back into the system.

[@Lohkey]

Edit, to the people asking if this works in 1.18, it works in 1.19.1, so yes, it works in 1.18. Nothing changed about zombies or villagers in any update recently, so all mechanics from 1.14/1.15 still directly apply. Please ignore the paragraph below unless you're having problems with your zombies. In which case read the paragraph, and my replied comment. :) Hey Logical, I know this is a really old video, and doubt you'll see this, but it's been my go-to trader hall ever since you released it. Haven't played since release of 1.16, and upon building the first part of this on a new server, am encountering an issue I don't remember from before. It appears the zombie I've trapped next to the villagers is doing some really weird pathfinding, and often not caring about a villager that's actively within his reach. I understand that zombies can track villagers through blocks, but I would think their pathfinding would at least allow them to realize there's something within their attacking range that they *actually can path to.* I end up with a zombie at the far end of its hallway trying to go around a corner and attack the villagers there, ignoring the villagers that are lowered and in line with it...

[@Lohkey]

Am an idiot, but leaving the comment in case another needs it. If you get the attention of the zombie yourself (they will always prioritize player over vill) and then run away from the zombie (preferably in line with the guy you want infected) the zombie will lose aggro on you and pathfind to the closest thing it can, the vill you dropped. Feel super smart. Spent all day figuring this out lmfao

[@justinnelson6794]

Just so everyone knows, this trading hall still works like a dream in 1.17.1. Thank you so much for showing us how to build this!

[@oscarq9195]

Lmao when the baby villager just fell into the void at 11:40 😂 Great video tho

[@onetickpulse4398]

Very cool design Logic. Especially the first part where you choose if you sent the villager to the trading hall or not is a good idea. I do have some concerns though: first of all when the villager hits the second tripwire it doesn't have a block above his head anymore. With my testing this will always eventually lead to him jumping. This will cause him to jump into the second tripwire, messing the circuit up. I've done some long testing and came to this stable design: kzbin.info/www/bejne/nXO9oGSgj56bnck which also has a zombie converter build in. It has the perks that the villagers can't jump up. In my testing I've also found that activator rails are not 100% reliable and are still buggy. Therefor I use water streams in my design. Another point of thought is the baby villager sorter. This design isn't 100% reliable. In my testing the villagers would sometimes jump and you'd end up with baby villagers swimming up. Therefor I made this design: kzbin.info/www/bejne/l2rKdGB5icp_qZY which is 100% reliable. Still love the how you took a very different approach to this, with things I didn't even think of some of the things.

[@TheBrewingMiner]

Coincidental, I came here to see the differences between the two to see which was more reliable/efficient, thanks for the list 😊

[@onetickpulse4398]

Happy to help. Huge thanks to Logic for the pro/cons of this trading hall. Really helped me to design mine.

[@gohoosiers8824]

OneTickPulse I tried using the activator rail but my villager wouldn’t go where he was supposed to go, so do you have an example on how to use water?

[@Rainxiety]

@@ubersuperboss7761 I'd say this advertising is fine because its helpful. He/she is sharing ideas.

[@online_cat]

I disagree. Can villagers even jump 2 blocks high?

[@laggybum3218]

Party on dude! I can't wait to build this on my server!

[@roostern33b]

One thing about this design that I overlooked for my base. If you place stalls adjacent to eachother on corners, this creates two problems; 1: The piston lever will lower both villagers on the corner to the zombie, infecting them both. 2: If you decide to go with the extra lamp, the redstone block on each side will power the corner lamp. Make sure two corner stalls don't share the same corner block to avoid this. I haven't completed it yet, but so far, this looks incredible. Well done.

[@JamielAlmeida]

Efficient, thorough, and funny. Definitely the type of content I like to keep up with, so allow me to put my subscriber cape on, one sec...

[@capixkw2560]

You did great job! I love how you explain mechanics behinde your contraptions so everyone can learn how they work and maybe do something on their own instead of blindly following the tutorial.

[@S3lix]

Love the design, but make sure, if you do build this in survival, extend the piston that activates the activator rail in each module to the side of the rail instead of on the top like shown here. The villager can suffocate and even die in the block. Watched mumbo's episode and saw this, he lost a villager with a trade he worked like 20 minutes to get.

[@hotheis2982]

what side? And won't that mess up the circuit?

[@AK-sw5rv]

I really love how he broke the trading hall tutorial into many part! some of them,I used to modify my transport system! Thank you good sir. I'll give my thanks to their creators too

[@FellowRabbit]

Thanks so much for this design. Ever since learning about it, it's basically been the only thing I use for my villager trading halls. I actually worked out a small improvement to it to make it more compact as well! You can move the piston to where the sea lantern is and put a piece of glass with redstone on it behind the top observer to make it shorter and take fewer materials per module. Currently building a new hall in my most recent world and that's the design that has saved me in a cramped building situation.

[@whateverguy9204]

Incredible tutorial. I love it. As a tip, if you don't have Name Tags, you can not name the Villagers and wait for them to heal before leaving so they don't despawn. For the zombie, you can, while finding zombies, drop some item at them, Zombies have a 50/50 chance of being able to pick up stuff, and if they have your stuff, they won't despawn

[@josephwright8752]

I've been testing this system since upload. On my server, unfortunately the difficulty is not on hard, so dropping down villagers for infection is not viable(the villager can outright die). To remedy this, I've moved the zombie in a one block behind the minecart in the job selection room. The zombie sits in a space separated by a trapdoor, which means that you can choose their trades after they've been cured. Great tutorial for an automated system of getting these broken villager trades!

[@thepeachyviking]

Could you expound on this or maybe send me a picture of what you are talking about. We are getting the same issue.

[@xits_]

i got the exact same issue. Can you please send a picture

[@onghungphung7668]

Missy: sire, pls stop it. I will give you discount as much as you want.

[@tyrannus00]

This is like vr torture from altered carbon

[@Daethbane]

Loving this design! I made a 40 slot version and it's amazing having it auto reset if "unfortunate" things happen 😉. Also, you can put the Despensor between four villagers and it will hit them all at once with one potion. Cool stuff!

[@Nub00005]

hey man great video, lots of information about villagers it was tough to find elsewhere. like how gossip affects prices, the pathfinding mechanic for jobs. and i friggin love how you show everything as an application not as an object!! because we are not out here with a bunch of copied builds in our base lmao. he gets it.

[@shaneconnor1006]

Loved the fact the you didn't do a block by block tutorial and did it in segments. Made it great to adjust the design to suit the space I had for the trading hall. 10/10 will trade again.

[@henrygniel7278]

When you see the baby drop into the void.

[@MARS-fi6wq]

This is so clear now, probably cause you did such a good job ! Thx. l liked the vid and subscribed.

[@yogeshanchu]

Always love the enthusiasm of this guy. much appreciated bringing this all together, good tut.

[@TheJameswade123]

Great tutorial, got the breeder and trade selector sorted so far, will be watching this several times to sort my hall

[@froxx93]

Thank you sooo very much. I tried to work out a concept of a trading hall by my own, but I had a few issues with it all the time. Your model is just flawless and also really easy to expand. Amazing job!

[@amywilliams5580]

An additional note: if the redstone block isn't being pulled up by the piston, make sure that you have a full solid block on top of the top piece of redstone (the one that he put a carpet on top of). If you decide like I did to just place a slab there, it won't get pulled up. Took me way too long to realize what was wrong when I did this, so I hope that my comment helps someone! :)

[@Mihai.george.gabriel]

I have wood planks above the redstone but still doesnt work, any sugestions ?

[@TheGamingChannel100]

Great design, but I would't reccomend zombifying the villagers in the way you showed on the video. The holding chamber to try and get good trades is practically pointless, as the holding chambers in the trading hall already server this purpose; you should send villagers directly into the trading hall and zombify them regardless of their trades, after they're cured they'll still randomly change their trade as long as you havent traded with them; then you lock it in by trading with them. This prevents you from potentially losing valuable villagers during the zombification process.

[@you_just]

If you’re on hard mode, you’ll never lose villagers.

[@shok24199]

​@Dubble Likes Bubbles Naming them is just a safeguard in case you want to walk away while they are a zombie. If you don't have any name tags, you can just wait next to them while they are being cured so they don't despawn. Once they are human again, the name tags aren't necessary.

[@kaas0kruimel]

For all of you having problems with the villager not falling in the hole. try riding the cart yourself until you fall in the hole, or temporarily remove the redstone block above the activator rail, jump into the hole yourself, after that replace the redstone block and try riding the cart again, this should fix alot of issues.

[@blackjjj57]

to everyone who has the "villager don't fall into the hole" problem, replace the lever with a full block , and also change the half slab below the powered rail into full block too so that you can put a lever beside the block p/s: I tried your method but it didn't work for me

[@hazel313]

@@blackjjj57 I've tried your method over and over again and no matter how many blocks I put around the redstone block the villager gets out no where near the place I want him to be and he just suffocates

[@idonthavecreativity6204]

@@blackjjj57 it worked, thx

[@ultikillerrrr]

I love your tutorial! Not only I learned to make a trading hall. I understood how it worked too!

[@flauer1464]

Such a well-made tutorial! I really like your way of showcasing the structure of the build and how you break it down into it's components!

[@picklejuice1264]

This still works for 1.16 -> If people put the villagers inside the Villager Hall and they won't restock, place a half slab on-top then break the workplace block and then replace it. They should immediately restock... I hope this helps!

[@mia-xv8hi]

THANK YOU SO MUCH!!

[@brunocbart2421]

wait how? The villager glitches throught the trapdoor in 1.16.1

[@roostern33b]

Finally got around to building this on my server, along with Impulse/Logical/Work's villager breeder Some little tips and tricks that I ran into across the way; BREEDER TIPS 1: If you are looking for a particular style of villager, you must build your breeder in that biome. Occasionally, villagers from different biomes in a new biome will produce villagers of their starting biome, but most of the time, it's villagers in the biome that they are currently residing in. 2: MAKE SURE THE PILLOWS OF YOUR BEDS ARE IN THE CORNERS OF THE BREEDING AREA. TRADING HALL TIPS 1: If you can't afford to make a drop in your build before the job selector due to space constraints, a piston with a rail ontop of it works just as well. However, the rail must be directly ontop of the piston, otherwise, it will break. If you build it properly, you can power your piston and your powered rail with one button. 2: BE SURE TO REMEMBER THAT YOUR VILLAGER ON THE ACTIVATOR RAIL WILL ALWAYS BE EJECTED FROM THE RIGHT SIDE. 3: Patch any holes between your job selector and your trading hall. I had the longest bit of trouble where the villagers in my job selector were taking jobs from my trading hall and I couldn't figure out why. Eventually I came to the conclusion that it was a hole in my rail system that led to my trading hall. 4: Only keep one cart in circulation throughout your entire system. That way, if you do multiple button presses on accident, you aren't spammed with multiple villagers. 5: Build a mail room next to your trading hall that carries goods from all your farms throughout your compound/base to your trading hall. This will save you a ton of time carrying stacks of items from your farms to your trading hall.

[@MatuHUN]

So I have an issue in 1.15.1, with villagers being ejected one block ahead of the activator rail. Also, he would take damage from the redstone block

[@jeremymartin1463]

same here

[@mtfreitasf]

Same issue here

[@thisisnotapigeon3934]

it does work but the thing needs to be at the right hand side

[@mtfreitasf]

@@thisisnotapigeon3934 Mine is from right to left - the same orientation as in the video. I also tested in a creative world and it worked (1.15.1). I don't know what is happening in my survival world

[@jeremymartin1463]

Fixed it put topslab on the 3 faces of each redstone block that are not the direction you want him to go. I think its a server thing. Not needed in solo imo. Also sometime the redstone block come back in place. Maybe its due to server lagg. Fixed it with a repeater instead of one of the restons dust powered by the upper observer. Still break from time to time but its much better since then.

[@nickkyriakidis1661]

In the room where you decide on a profession, you can place a slab or a trapdoor right above where you'd place the profession block in order to cycle through a villager's trades. Villagers have long heads and can't pass through a two tall space when so much as a trapdoor is placed on the top side of the second block

[@TheHoinoel]

Now this is how you do a tutorial. Very well explained, to the point and great farm design to boot! Kudos :)

[@Tom_M_Riddle]

Also you need to name the zombie, so he doesn’t de-spawn, I don’t know if he mentioned that.

[@darthvader4899]

no you can give him any item and he won't de-spawn

[@quandaledingle2052]

I like the Bill & Ted’s excellent adventure reference 🤣

[@illagevidiot8254]

For anyone who's having trouble with villagers dying before dropping in front of the lectern, put the redstone block directly infront of the activator rail, and the piston one block forward and one block lower to match with a block ontop and a repeater going into it. I've been pulling my hair out all day trying to figure out why it stopped working and it kept killing the villagers I sent through the system. Turns out it was the redstone block suffocating the villagers before they get kicked out. Probably has something to do with my villager loader system injuring them from time to time, but there is no way in hell I'm going to change that. All I need to do is change 3 blocks this way, and the loader system has been beautified and would require probably a day of work to fix. Also, the workstation bug a-la-mumbo and iskall's videos seem to be solved as well.

[@foolishmacaroni3320]

Thank you!

[@stefaniftimie526]

Thank you, random stranger

[@lolliepop5141]

The reason they are dying is most likely due to entity cramming taking place wherever you are storing your villagers before sending them to their holding cells. Just make sure you don't have too many villagers crowding together in the same spot at any given time, and you will not have to change the design.

[@illagevidiot8254]

@@lolliepop5141 Nah, for me its the drop from the villager breeding area. It hurts them once in a while when the fall down to the rail below.

[@timeforvintagepancakes9751]

This thing is awesome, but in particular, I love the villager-dispenser module. I use one at the end of every breeder I build and when it comes time to populate my iron farm it saves me a lot of time and frustration that would otherwise be spent trying to force the Hurr Hurrs into water columns.

[@aholm8318]

You are the first person that explained redstone so that i understod it, thanks man!

[@bigmancrisp4508]

You, are fudging amazing! This might be one of the best tutorials EVER made!

[@francescagonzalez6598]

Might have just watched the best redstone teacher out there.

[@bautik9301]

16:10 i think you can use rails to block path finding

[@leminos6119]

Didn't work

[@zssdfounder4607]

If it doesn't prevent the villagers from moving through to it then it won't stop pathfinding.

[@Kata_Rin]

Bartek Gorlikowski it works for me. whenever my villagers stand on one side of a rail and i place a workstation on the other side, they will not walk over to the workstation and don’t claim it

[@bassPindaHouse]

Hi dude! I'm very thankful for the tutorial. It's very very useful to have all the parts involved explained! I was building it it my survival and noticed that there's an easier way to give a job to the villager, being also easy to get it on its spot. Let me explain: if you place a trapdoor in front of them before they are sent to their spot, they can't reach any block outside of that 1x1 so their pathfinding doesn't work. The other workstations are invisible to him... so it's not necessary anymore to have another separate chamber to choose their work there, do the sticky piston stuff, etc. Also, you can remove and place the workstation as many time you want because they won't move anyway, even without a workstation, since their hitbox touches the trapdoor. Once the job and the trades are OK, you can remove the trapdoor, because they will be trapped with their own workstation, and without the trapdoor you can see their head better

[@AlishaShatogi]

Really great tutorial! Thank you for both explaining the mechanics and showing how the design is flexible.

[@samiam5708]

11:38 Baby falls out the world and he continues talking 😂😂

[@deanna3873]

14:21 when the tutorial starts

[@Ometen]

This must have been the best minecraft tutorial i have ever seen.

[@rinsw8872]

I love how you explain things in simple way, thx!

[@noname-codm4590]

Nice talking speed! Not to slow but also not too fast that you can still process the ideas!😀😀

[@charlespeyton8046]

My villagers keep getting pushed out went sent to the chamber Any ideas on how to fix this?

[@benjamin.t---]

When my villager gets ejected from his mine cart he lands on the track.

[@cjuice9039]

Yes I have the same problem but I can't figure out the solution

[@PiCarg97]

Same

[@coldsaad]

It is on the wrong side of it

[@davidknavs9418]

i had that problem too but i figured i out... i had my slabs not directly under the upper string but 1 block further and it made villagers not be able to land on the right but rather on the track.

[@albertgeokgeuzian1210]

@@davidknavs9418 what do you mean by 1 block further? because i downloaded the world download and it didnt work in the world download either

[@Layarion]

2:20 how do you control which villager picks up the profession? Mine keeps locking to one still inside the adult separator.

[@what-259]

11:31 Me: Aww.. Also me: *suprised pikachu face*

[@OlivierMassut]

Fantastic !!! It's exactly what i needed and how I needed. Everything is krystal clear and well explained. Thanks you very much for that video.

[@kingchris-xt9lf]

building this inside a cleared out ocean monument

[@bigred4279]

Hey, I am running a realm and I built this design, but it keeps kicking me out one block behind the activator rail, can someone help?

[@pleaseinsertcoin4679]

Big Red, same for me

[@ImNotQualifiedToSayThisBut]

Are you playing on bedrock?

[@sorenschultz1144]

Im having the same problem

[@ImNotQualifiedToSayThisBut]

@@sorenschultz1144 Read my comment..

[@pablos6481]

My villager ends up between the two red blocks in the rails, nut sure why.

[@em1t562]

Hello guys! For those on normal difficulty I have a nice tip. First send the villagers into your system, cure them and then set their trades. This way you won't get excited for mending books and kill your villager in a zombie accident.

[@eliaswagner1312]

Or just turn to hard Mode, cure the villager and set it back to normal

[@diahero4754]

This is exactly what I needed :D

[@PikaMates]

Great guide! Im definitely not regret subscribing you!

[@INeatFreak]

next time can you please make a list of all essential item's required

[@PepicWalrus]

spoon gang give this dude some love

[@mattrussell8479]

For other people having the issue where your villager or you are getting ejected from the minecart on the powered rail and not where the observer or string are, I have a solution. Some people have mentioned changing out levers for redstone blocks and changing out half slabs for full. None of that worked for me. What did work was using the debug stick to change the orientation of the string to the right of the activator rail to west. You need to be in creative mode to do that and use the command ( /give @s minecraft:debug_stick ) then hit the string till it "changes orientation". Visually some of the string change to reflect that and some did not. This worked for me 100% of the time without changing anything else from this build. I know you need creative mode for this fix but i think its worth noting that the string orientation seems to be part of the issue. I'll let other smarter Minecraft players use that information how they will.

[@dokueki4246]

all i did to fix it was just make another railway across from it and the villagers would go in from the otherside of where youre trying to get them in and it worked without changing anything from the build

[@pineapplewafers]

Great tut, I will be building this eventually, but instead of the pressure plate and the piston, couldn't you just use a bottom half slab on the floor, and a top half slab two blocks up? This would leave a 2 block tall gap for the player to get in and out, but the villager (and other mobs) would see it as only a one block space and not be able to pathfind out to other stations... and you wouldn't be stuck standing on one space to keep the door shut.

[@KevinSolagnier]

I built a second module and the villager doesnt fall into the hole. Did I forget something?

[@blackjjj57]

to everyone who has the "villager don't fall into the hole" problem, replace the lever with a full block , and also change the half slab below the powered rail into full block too so that you can put a lever beside the block

[@deanna3873]

thanks

[@brockmcdaniel2725]

@@blackjjj57 whenever I do it, the minecraft and villager take damage and he doesn't fall into the hole. I tried what you said, but it didn't work. Ideas?

[@Liza.Wharton]

@@blackjjj57 still won't work

[@Funkoh]

Imagine someone accidentally punching you then after that executing you

[@seanclayton8181]

i have built this in 1.15.2 and it all seems to be built correctly but the villager hops out on top of the track in front of its aligned red stone block. Any Suggestions.

[@gatsot]

sean playdoy same

[@myxion2671]

ATTENTION: To everyone whose villagers eject onto the tracks, I just figured out the problem. The platform inside the holding cell gets stuck in the "in" position if you let the villager escape once they are captured. Reset this by breaking the slab underneath the string and replacing it so that it is in the "out" position. The villager will not eject into the cell if there is not a platform for it to eject onto. Just tested it, this works for 1.16. - Will beeson

[@myxion2671]

@@gatsot you aren't adding anything by saying "same"

[@gatsot]

FireSniper k

[@haveallama]

@@myxion2671 You sir have saved me hours of headache, thank you so much for posting this comment.

[@nancyblackett4167]

I have adapted parts of this for my system. Quite useful. Thank you for the video and design.

[@Liloulalalala]

Impressed by the quality of this video, really good deconstruction and explanation

[@hoodzey9743]

To anyone coming down here wondering how to fix the villager popping out on the rail in between the redstone blocks It could be that the block the villager has to land on is out of wack, and you have to replace it. Check the box the villager has to eject into and make sure they have a block to land on. Your cell should look like this with the piston not connected to the slab : imgur.com/YtQC1M2

[@Zugirf]

Still villager pops next to the redsrone block

[@sqhare]

Try putting glass in between the Redstone blocks. That should fix it

[@jaenka6840]

Genius, literally a genius

[@ryanvoytas4631]

I'm having a problem were when the villagers get ejected out of the mine craft, they land on the rail. how do you fix that Version: 1.15.2

[@demerzel3798]

Activator rails only eject entities to the right. If there isn't a block to the right of the activator rail, it'll eject them onto the rail. You can actually remedy this by putting glass blocks above the rails.

[@tygmaster8146]

Jackson above te rails is redstone, where do i put the glass then

[@wgs5030]

@@tygmaster8146 he meant above the powered rails. This model does not work on the current snapshot however.

[@cindybonduelle2907]

William G Skalleberg but there is a lever

[@wgs5030]

@@cindybonduelle2907 Place the lever literally anywhere else. It's for powering the rail so it doesn't need to be on the wall above it.

[@LLLadySSS]

Omg this is so good! Best one yet

[@sambattistone5342]

This video was most excellent. Party on dude!

[@kyleb1174]

I am playing on a Realm and the villager gets stuck between the Redstone blocks on the rails whenever I send it. It then just walks off the rails. Is there a way to fix this?

[@arranholmes4683]

is the trading block definitely on the right hand side of the villager ?

[@idiotmcgee4870]

@@arranholmes4683 I have the same problem. I think it just has to do with lag, and I'm not sure of a cure

[@shaack]

the villager only ejects the minecart on its right hand side, make sure the minecart direction allow it to eject from that side

[@blackjjj57]

to everyone who has the "villager don't fall into the hole" problem, replace the lever with a full block , and also change the half slab below the powered rail into full block too so that you can put a lever beside the block

[@GifCoDigital]

@@blackjjj57 you keep making this same comment. What the FUCK does replace the lever with a full block mean? The redstone block already knocks you out early and you want to add another block in front of that?