Vinyl Window Reviews - Home Depot Vs. Lowes

[@donaldperrotta8514]

My contractor installed all Pella 150 series replacement windows in my summer home .. so far , so good ! I’m very happy with them .

[@QualityRecord]

Replacing 10 windows, already done 6 using the Pella 150's. Can't complain. Replaced 40 year old wood windows, some haven't opened in 30 years and the seal broke (on the 40 yr wood) and got all sorts of interesting mold patterns in between the glass. I'm at the point I can do 2 from start to finish in a day. Air nailer is a must. Biggest issue is no off the shelf fits the 40 year old openings, so I have to make the opening smaller. Will have some drywall work on the tops. I went with a wider top trim on the outside to cover the shorter window. Cost is about $550 per window, 54" x 36" including triming. Using PVC trim on the outside. Was quoted $1,600 per window. But in fairness that would be a custom window to fit perfectly. Using off the shelf I'm losing about 1" of glass height and width. But for $1,000 per window savings, I'm ok with that. The inside trim framing (box) I'm doing in one piece and painting on a really flat bench, then installing, even doing the inside trim at this time as well. Let's me do a perfect window trim frame and it's easier to work on the bench. Like I said, an air nailer is a must. Using the sealing tape, lots of it, I do like the Pella window seal tape. Expensive but worth it. A good power miter saw is also a must, make sure it's cutting square. Nice thing about saving all this money, my wife is happy to buy me the tools I say I need to do the job. I set up a work area outside, because cutting all the PVC (cross and ripping) is a MESS! Make sure the windows slides up and down and the panes tilt out before you trim it out. Vinyl windows will bend and wrap and cause binding if you get overly aggressive screwing it into the studs. If I was to complain it would be about the screens, I've had to put the 2nd floor screens in using a ladder outside. Sometimes the screens need a little "persuasion" to fit into the tracks. Window sealing tape and caulking are your friends, use plenty. I went with the "Pella" name because we are selling and moving south in 2 years and the "Pella' brand has a good name, rather then a no name. Lowes vs Home Depot, we are falling out with HD, even though it's 20 minutes closer. Finding the HD is not fully stocked and the Orange Aprons aren't helpful. Lowes aprons are helpful. Oh and we are noticing a difference in the winter breeze next to the windows. The rooms with the new windows are warmer and you don't get chilled sitting next to them.

[@kuzenny]

I'm having home depot doing my windows I have 7 windows and a sliding door they keep saying for my area it costs more is this true? I'm in the 906 area code. They quote 14k am I getting robbed?

[@mikepayne1851]

Can you please throw one of your as a none bias comparison

[@returntothailand]

Replacing Installing second floor windows, charging out aluminum for vinyl

[@jbborg]

Very nice video. Good job. I am new to channel and was wondering if you might have done a comparision on a mid-range Pella and Anderson. Thanks again.

[@mrsduddlycross]

The only windows in stock at Home Depot in my area are new construction Plygem. Anything else is special order.

[@Hectekk]

Need help. Live in SoCal and trying to decide between Pella 250 vs Milgard Tuscany for 20 windows at my house. What would you choose? Thanks.

[@curiosity2314]

That was a great overview.

[@Mom-tk9rz]

Is Simonton casements good or bad? I am being pushed to buy these. I am advised best for the price. I need something affordable. The windows will be under an overhang. Not staying in this house forever. Jeld Wen any good? Don't want to spring for more Andersons.

[@brennickjack]

i just got a Lowes Reliabilt single hung window, with a haf screen . does the screen come out of the window? the screen has a pink label that says do not remove

[@PottersWork]

Jack, if it's like the American Craftsman, you have to lean the bottom window in by unlocking the cleaning tabs to remove the screen.

[@brennickjack]

@@PottersWork thank you sir; The window had no screen instructions, saying to look on line for additional info. I guess you're the on line info I was destined to find. Thank you Jack Brennick Rochester NY

[@PottersWork]

@@brennickjack, no problem! If it makes you feel any better, it took me a bit to figure it out as well. My previous windows were double hung and the screen came off from the outside.

[@realestateness]

Thank you for this video - very informative. A golf ball just went through the cheap "builder" window in my sons bedroom that's why I ran into your video. Don't know much about windows but I know they cost a lot for full house replacement. Economy at this time is not helping. So, I'm gonna have to replace it myself. Don't you think Pella and Andersen comparison would have been a fair one than the American Craftsman?

[@jimh2061]

How do these windows compare to Simonton?

[@debmozumder]

Noisy!!!! I purchased my Pella windows after watching this video. I bought five pairs of double hung Pella windows from Lowe’s, and I am very disappointed even though this video demonstrate, these windows are sturdy compared to the other brands. However these windows brings in a lot of outside noise, especially if you are closer to a road. The second issue is the locking system. The locking systems are very weak. It’s annoying that you have to properly align the window in order to be able to lock it easily. Otherwise the windows get disoriented if it is not be in the right place for locking. Also 150 series does not come with any robber/isolation padding hence it attracts a lot of road noise.

[@hashimhalstead]

For a split second I thought you guys were in the valley because of her sweatshirt! Woulda loved for you guys to take care of our windows 😭

[@THOMASGPII]

No Menards? How about Windows 11, version 21H2?

[@sergeyhay]

Great video, thank you! Any replacement window installer recommendations for Baltimore, MD?

[@Taylorraeconstruction]

Hi. I do not have any installers that I can personally recommend in Maryland unfortunately.

[@janiceearle809]

How about the paint

[@GreenAppelPie]

Shoulda checked them for leaks, I knew a contractor who tested them before installation and found a 40% leak rate.

[@Mncrr]

Windows are not the place to go cheap. Many other places like using your own labor to repair things are better

[@freewilly5073]

I'm actually interested in your opinion regarding home depot and potentially Lowes window installation service. Plan on getting a new living room window but it's very big and I rather have someone do it right than for me to mess up a huge window in my house.

[@Taylorraeconstruction]

I would be careful using either big box store. I think you should be able to find a reputable local contractor to do the job correctly.

[@freewilly5073]

@@Taylorraeconstruction do you happen to know any the Boston area? I've been looking around Google maps and yelp for reviews on quality companies but I've only found maybe 1 or 2.

[@Taylorraeconstruction]

@@freewilly5073 yes I would recommend A & A services. They are in Salem Mass. So I don't know how close that is to you but they are great. A-aservices.com

[@freewilly5073]

@@Taylorraeconstruction thanks, I'll give them a call and see if they are willing to come out to the Randolph area. A bit further south, hopefully they will.

[@Taylorraeconstruction]

@@freewilly5073 good luck. I know the owner Chris personally and he is a great guy.

[@e.b.6488]

I am happy with 2 pro 70 windows I installed from Home Depot. Don't use the 50 series they are noticeably inferior. They are easy to install.

[@janiceearle809]

What to know on installing a wood window and removing wood windows

[@johnthomas8969]

All you need to know is.... dont. HAHAHA. Wood windows are trash. Vinyl isnt much better.

[@UnnamedHandyman]

Just bought a pella 150 for 414 pre tax… lol. Price jump is unreal in a year..

[@pelle8632]

Great video, very interesting I’m looking to diy my own windows on a very small house here in central nj. where would you recommend I purchase from, I don’t want to spend the time and hard work putting in something that won’t last. Is there a window supplier that sells to homeowners other than home depot or Lowe’s.

[@lastplace22]

when is the last time a window was dropped from a forklift?

[@QualityRecord]

Agreed. Not the most scientific test.

[@janiceearle809]

Yes love see Anderson windows

[@DaBuDaSak]

How about the higher ply gem 510 series. They got argon gas. $200 at home Depot

[@Taylorraeconstruction]

Don't think they are in my market.

[@couchpotatoe3204]

You killed that big beautiful and expensive miter saw blade.

[@Kashype101]

My house was built in the 50s same old windows from back then at this point any brand from lowes or homedepot is better then the ones i have now lmao

[@Rider-nb5ts]

Facts!!!

[@PaintHerWhite]

I always go to Lowe's. Not because they are closer, Home Depot is a lot closer. It's because Home Depot has so much crap in their aisles, it's hard to maneuver.

[@johnward9146]

Never see a Pella on the shelf at Lowes, it's Reliabuilt now, Pella is special order and $450 each for a 36x54 replacement unit at NC stores.

[@desmorider747]

Have you ever test Okna windows? Model 500 or model 800?

[@davidkettell6236]

Thanks a great video looks like i am going the extra 15 miles to lowes.

[@debmozumder]

Thank you

[@ElPescadoMan]

So what windows would you recommend? Not the cheapest but also not the most expensive something that would last 10+years

[@Taylorraeconstruction]

You really want to look for a window that uses block and tackle balance systems and preferably us uses Cardinal Glass since the glass is what fails most often in the smaller manufacturers who try to make their own glass most often will eventually fail

[@Taylorraeconstruction]

It's better to look for those features than to say a brand because there are over a thousand Brands all over the country

[@Ashdad99]

I wish he would of gotten the American craftsman 70 series 62 by 36. We install these in new construction all the time and they are the worst product ever. Theres silicone all over the place, they're warped in multiple directions and the balance a thin string attached to a spring that shoots up when you tilt out the sash to take it out. If you dont have the little plastic stops in because they fell out or was never put in it breaks through the vinyl in the top corner. They are so hard to get to operate smoothly no matter how perfect you install the window. We get call backs all the time because the windows are so bad.

[@johnnychaos3]

are you saying the 70 series are bad or 50?

[@superman19572857]

This is not how you determine quality of windows. Who is this guy? When investing in replacement windows for your home, that will perform well and easy to use, and last at least 20 years. Run from this guy. These are the kind of windows you put in a garage or 3 season room or back porch unheated. Complete waste of time watching this guy.

[@Taylorraeconstruction]

Why would you run from me? I am not recommending either window just hoping to provide some useful information and comparison for homeowners and diy'rs who are on a budget.

[@davidr9876]

Yes, these windows are made to be inexpensive, not high quality. But this review is very good and a ton of people buy this level of window. FYI, I sell windows for a living.

[@noelcabadas4674]

Which are high quality windows?​@@davidr9876

[@shoalsbeverage1705]

Coffee break and momentary interaction with the younger generation: Critical!!!!!!

[@johnberry1107]

I gets what I pay for?

[@jwayne777]

Nice video. Love it. Throw it off the roof.😂

[@CrystalV919]

Hello, I'm looking to replace 10 windows in my home and wanted to know which brand you suggest before receiving an estimate. With Home Depot (American Craftsman-$194 each window) and Lowes (Relia-$243 per window) ... Is the brand of the windows important, and what should I look for while buying them?

[@Taylorraeconstruction]

The way the window is made and it's components are very important for longevity. You should look for a minimum threshold in quality if you want the windows to last. It will cost you a lot more upfront but getting a quality, highly rated, local window dealer to do the job is the way to go.

[@CrystalV919]

@@Taylorraeconstruction thank you so much! How about the series, I just read that series of windows are important...i.really appreciate it your assistance

[@Taylorraeconstruction]

@@CrystalV919 That's very true. For instance the pella 150 series is not as good as the 250 series (not sold at loewes) Some things to look for are Block and Tackle balances, low air infiltration numbers and Cardinal Glass if possible.

[@CrystalV919]

@@Taylorraeconstruction thank you so much!!!! I truly appreciate it 🙏

[@Taylorraeconstruction]

@@CrystalV919 my pleasure. Good luck.

[@janiceearle809]

Do you install Windsor windows

[@Taylorraeconstruction]

Hi, no I don't.

[@gloriamurphy4129]

I didn't learn anything here, I am very confused, seems like all the windows are junks.

[@Taylorraeconstruction]

It's a comparison for people who are on a tight budget. So quality isn't going to be comparable to the more expensive windows.

[@GY6SCOOTERCHAT]

Sounds like you got an exhaust leak on your car

[@brandonyoung7760]

Any of these are much better than the 1974 craked single pane windows i have in my home. Next time just throw them off a building into my address 😂

[@annodyesrod8671]

Roof compare

[@danielstevenson1250]

Window World all the way.

[@Tattooclownfish71]

Hello buddy great video I have 10 mobile home windows to replace anyone please help me out I need the put in from outside don’t know the correct term sorry lol am what would be the cheapest that will last more then 10 years lol I can’t afford 400 dollar windows maybe 150 175 please help I bought it as is 14 grand cash some am ripping the walls out putting drywall which my brother is doing for free thank god every small company thinks everyone is rich these days wtf I got water damage cuz previous owner didn’t fix shit that means to me really cheap come on u gotta fix a few things lol should I go to Home Depot or lowes a windows expert is gonna charge a shit load I already know please help thank you god bless I love the video brother 🤘👍🤘😜

[@GreenAppelPie]

Lol, American craftsman, undoubtedly made in China. I’d never use anything less fancy than aluminum clad. I’m good with Pella all day.

[@Taylorraeconstruction]

Although Pella is the clear winner in this comparison, I have had many problems with their aluminum clad windows rotting out.

[@bigmacattk]

@@Taylorraeconstruction To be fair, Andersen windows have rotted out too. Seen my fair share of both, though the vinyl cladding on the sash (interior)of the casement Andersen is superior because they hide the sash rot lol 😂

[@gregcorwin8316]

American Craftsman is a rebranding of SIlverline made in North Brunswick NJ total junk

[@edwardluth7740]

@@Taylorraeconstruction Pella casement wood rot. I am in on that lawsuit working locally now with Pella. And Andersen beat Pella today. Andersen had a window rot problem in the 80s but they corrected their problems. Pella kept making them in the 90s and onward until enough people started this lawsuit. I have no use for Pella today.

[@sdk2265]

@@gregcorwin8316 hum, I see Anderson. weird.

[@carlosbriceno9138]

Horrible Installation

[@ABCDEFGHIJKLMNOPQRSTUVWX-du8vz]

And now those Pella windows are double that price 🤦🏼‍♂️