Do Window Brands Actually Matter?

[@Toni-rr2qz]

Andersen quoted me $106k to replace 27 windows. But if I act today, I could get them for the discounted price of $76k. My response "get out"

[@americanwindowconcepts]

Lol! That is what I am talking about. The idea is to create a "fear of missing out" for the customer if they do not take the highly discounted price, but where does all that discount come from?

[@timrobertson2511]

Anderson windows are junk.

[@nfn7121]

Sounds like my floor guy $26k. Then I said but I have a quote from your competitor for 7k. No problem we will match it. Wish my floor guy was by bank. I got $5 in my bank account but your competitor has $100k in my bank account. No problem we will match it.

[@CarolineH363]

I replaced all my 27 windows from my home in France for 40K€ with the german Schuco brand windows (tilt and turn).

[@grizzlyinvesting]

Was it Anderson by Renewal that gave you that quote or was it an actual rep from the Anderson Window Company? Big difference and what type of product did they quote you on E-Series or 400 Series ?

[@jolynn5668]

I just recently had my windows replaced by Renewal by Andersen. The window quality may be good (time will tell) but as with all products, it's the quality of the installation and the attention to detail of the installers that can make the outcome great or just so-so. I got a so-so. The crew was 5 Spanish speaking men which was a concern as they obviously ran into a problem with installation of the bow window but, since I don't understand Spanish, no clue what the issue is. The 5 double-hung windows were installed in 5 hours the previous day but the bow took 4 hours the next day. With full frame installation, very few of the mitered corners of the casings were without gaps and the nail pinner left additional dings in the wood that rules out staining as I'll now have to fill, sand, and paint the casings. The bow extends further out from the brick than the original and nothing covers/seals the bare wood underneath and there is foam insulation squeeze out between the brick and the bottom of the bow. Again, it's not all about the quality of the product.

[@leeannes.2257]

Which brand is best for cold climate? I live in Maryland.

[@RetrieverTrainingAlone]

I was surprised at Renewal By Andersen Warranty only covers installation for 2-years and does not cover "performance of the low-maintenance exterior glass coating on products with HighPerformance Low-E4® glass"

[@ERICLnj]

Im looking to replace original windows and sliding patio door in my 1980s condo since they have been failed for 15 years. the windows are double hung aprx. 60x40 and 60x20 inch. The door is big at 110x80 iish 3 pane on third floor condo. Was qouted 8000 for anderson door and silver line windows. Was also qouted 6200 for Okna brand door and windows from a diffirent contractor. Im 43 and have no intention of moving anytime soon, but want a successful stress free outcome that will give me no drama. Both places have great install reviews. I never heard of Okna and the reviews are terrible and excellent but I can say the same about Anderson and Silver line

[@americanwindowconcepts]

I have yet to hear of Okna Windows myself. You are correct though, you may see both great and bad reviews for both manufacturers...but if you can visit a showroom to see the windows and doors, and if the company to install them for you have great reviews, than I would feel much better about hiring them for my project. Take your time as well, try not to rush something until you feel all of your concerns have been alleviated.

[@andyk4688]

They do, but when you have salesman and installers out there under measuring for fit then a proper fitting window is more important. Always have the installer measure for tightest fit.

[@llamacebu216]

Almost every window runs a standard size especially on new construction

[@CHDean]

Wow. This is great, inclusive information. TY!!!

[@americanwindowconcepts]

You are very welcome!

[@ScottyLo]

My house was built in 1971 with 27 windows. 24 of which are double hung the other 3 are very large windows that do not open. I can’t imagine the quotes I would get to replace them. I live in NJ.

[@americanwindowconcepts]

All depends on what brand and style of window you get quoted for. Vinyl will come in around 1000 dollars an opening installed. Fiberglass will be more like 1500-1800 average each, and wood windows would come in at the highest at 2000-2500 per opening. Also, all about the type of glass and warranty received with these windows, and obviously who is installing the windows for you.

[@cameraz99]

I just got a quote to replace a 92" x 55" bow window in my house from Renewal by Anderson. They want $15,000 for a dual-pane, composite-frame window.. Window World wants $9,330 for a triple-pane (vinyl) window. Guess which one I'm going with?

[@dannmcnaughton9506]

If your window is still in good shape you can get it repair cheaper then new.

[@ryan74701]

I have plygem windows in my house and they are only 4-5 years old, low E, and they radiate cold in the winter, I picked up a NT Windows brand window off fb marketplace for my shop and the quality compared to my actual house windows is night and day, NT Windows are made in Ft. Worth Texas .

[@freshyoungguner]

Anlin still better than

[@dannmcnaughton9506]

I have a Mobile Window and Screen repair business I will go to your house and repair or repair or manufacturer a new Screen in your driveway with 40 years of experience, 90% of replacement windows do no need to be replaced just replace the old or broken parts , and maintenance them and that window still will last for another 30 years . I live outside of London , Ontario hopping to train more people to repair Windows.

[@zackwalters3062]

As of 2024 Anlin was bought out by Miter brands which is the same company that owns Milgard. Current employee here

[@Hectekk]

Need help. Live in SoCal and trying to decide between Pella 250 vs Milgard Tuscany for 20 windows at my house. What would you choose? Thanks.

[@szargos]

What about in smaller basement type hopper windows? I'm looking to replace these myself and trying to get a decent window. There are some available at the big box stores, but they don't really seem super high quality. Will window dealers be able to provide a quality small basement window by like Pella/Andersen, etc.? Or does it not matter so much with these smaller windows.

[@mikezisk5009]

Yes, I went to my local hardware store that sells windows and I purchased a great replacement , cost $220 but we’ll worth it.

[@johnnycashh7148]

Wish you would have actually named the brands.

[@donaldperrotta8514]

I paid $ 10,000 for Harvey Classic double hung windows for my 1951 built cape style house : 21 windows total including 3 basement windows and 2 windows in the garage.

[@nitroDubbs]

They're going to need to be replaced in 5 years. Any money you saved buying a cheap window will be lost through your HVAC system running 24/7 do to poor insulation.

[@stevesanzari7294]

@@nitroDubbs Tell me about it !

[@Jimmyb612]

Trying to decide between pro-series jeld-wen, American craftsman, and simonton. Any recommendations?

[@maciejfassa4394]

Video is pretty helpful. On personal note, I like Dako company.

[@seanyahn7158]

Second vote for Dako Windows. I’ll be looking into that company.

[@patrickgavin2012]

Hi Dako salesperson!

[@maciejfassa4394]

@@patrickgavin2012 Its not like I said they are best or anything ;).

[@jescar101010]

Anyone have any feedback on Pella Windows installed by Power Home Remodeling?

[@DjAmp126]

best bang for buck company for home remodeling. I used them for everything on my house. they offer higher quality Pella windows for half the regular price including installs. less than a third of the price of renewal by Andersen for similar material

[@chuckmurray1825]

I'm looking at GenTek Signature Elite Windows but I'm concerned that there does not seem to be a lot of data out there and I found a few really bad complaints. On paper, they look like great windows.

[@americanwindowconcepts]

Hi Chuck, on paper they will look like great windows, that the job of marketing. Now, the real world complaints and concerns of actual purchasers are what you want to look at in this case. That will usually be a huge deciding factor on what windows you are optioning for your home.

[@stevesanzari7294]

I bought Pella and I hate them ! Does that help ! Too expensive and Don’t do the Job ! Now I’ve said too much !

[@Greatday68]

@@stevesanzari7294 Pella makes a wide range of windows. From builders grade to high end wood /vinyl or wood / aluminum., Most people purchase based off the name and buy the cheaper builders grade and at that point you're just paying for the name and the reputation of their higher end windows just like other well known window companies. Now I have Pella and they work great, Best windows I've seen or worked on. The quality of the materials are top notch, They used stainless steel rollers on their sliders, quality spacers between the pians of glass with desiccant inside of the spacers. the crank mechanism work flawlessly and made of quality parts. But I did pay the higher price, Not as high as an ordinary person because I'm well known in the window industry in my area, I've worked in the window industry for multiple manufactures, from actually building windows, instillation, and warranty, And no I've never worked for Pella, not that they didn't try to higher me, Now I've had my Pella's for over 15 years and they still work like the day I installed them. Here's a little tip All your windows don't need low-e, only those that get direct sunlight The windows on your north facing side will be fine with argon filled gas. And your comment does not help, because you didn't explain what issues you are having with the windows, Any brand window can have issues, And most come down to not being installed properly, they must be perfectly square . not even a 1/32 on an inch off, This issue alone will cause the window to not seal tight or make them not operate as they designed to.

[@chuckmurray1825]

@@stevesanzari7294 I ended up buying Andersen 400s and they have been great so far. No more drafts or moisture and by utility bills have dropped as well. So far, so good!

[@elenasinclair3005]

Of course they do, always. For example I invest in Dako Windows USA products and I always know that I get high quality at a relatively low price.

[@seanyahn7158]

Nice! I will look up Dako Windows and see what they are about.

[@llamacebu216]

So when is the best time to buy windows at the cheapest price? It seems the cost is constantly going up

[@Grande79]

Best time would have been 5 years ago and 5 years from now the best time will be today

[@shantor100]

renewal by Andersen is the biggest rip off ever. thousands of thousands for a few windows. I've seen quotes for $38,000 for 12 windows and higher

[@americanwindowconcepts]

I can understand where you are coming from, but also think of their wood window lines that are not part of the "Renewal" line, they are priced in such a way that makes sense for the materials, glass and hardware used. I always hear when we compete against their quote, that we are a third of their price in most cases. They have to pay for their marketing somehow I suppose. Good products though.

[@shantor100]

@@americanwindowconcepts marketing and huge commissions and lots of levels. Their salesman can make over $200k

[@dancowan559]

Craziest Andersen quote I’ve ever seen was $20k for 3 double pane vinyl windows, they were fairly big but I was able to give the same client 4 triple pane windows for $12k. I’ve only been in the window sales field for a brief time but I can’t understand how Andersen is making ANY sales with quotes like that. The 20k figure was a discounted price too!

[@steveswoodworking2504]

Years ago I got a 12 ft wide double slider wooden Anderson glass doors. I thought that was by far the best window in the house. The outside is covered by a plastic coating of some sort. Well, they use pine wood. They could have used balsa wood, but in an upgrade, went with pine. It rains 2 miles from here, the pine rots. The outside where the plastic coating is cracked, water gets in and rots it. On the inside, condensation from the window drips off the glass down to the pine and rots it. Worst window ever.

[@777irishgirl]

Was just quoted today on Anderson for 40,000, 7 windows and 1 slider,, I’m like not now

[@susanorth1290]

Phoenix Az. area for you’re company?

[@MrTeff999]

Only buy windows from an established brand with a stellar reputation who will be there to service them decades later. My twelve year-old vinyl windows with a lifetime warrantee were made by a company that was bought by another company who no longer makes parts for it.

[@americanwindowconcepts]

Oh my, I am sorry to hear that. I agree, there are some window manufacturers that get started, but then close their doors after a decade or so, leaving the customers hanging.

[@shantor100]

happens all the time and not just windows , roofing and supply houses are constantly being bought and sold for billions of dollars. sometimes they retain the old name for recognition but you'd be surprised

[@MrRerod]

Makes sense but you make it sound easy. How many manufactures produce cars? No where near as many as the number of window manufactures and all their different lines or series.. Why? Because there's allot of money that's on the table from folks that don't have the time to compare and end up with a subpar product.

[@StompOutSobriety]

By WindowMart windows in Royal, AR.

[@NYslice331]

A salesman from a local installer came to my house and quoted me $9300 for 7 Duralast sliding Windows. I think Sunrise Windows makes them. Any experience with Duralast windows? Thanks

[@americanwindowconcepts]

Not yet, I would have to see if there are any dealers of those windows in this area. Are the windows quoted vinyl? Also, is it for a full tear out, or retro replacement?

[@NYslice331]

@@americanwindowconcepts The windows are quoted Vinyl and are replacement windows.

[@TheSeriesofTubes]

Sounds like some cheesedick brand x vinyl window. Don’t buy a plastic window if you’re worried about quality.

[@michaelsix9684]

remember sales people are under a commission system, they will pressure you and quote you high numbers, shop around all you can

[@cumulus1234]

What about Marvin Essentials

[@dougui20]

90k for 20 windows from Anderson, I am good

[@americanwindowconcepts]

They can come in a bit expensive, but it all depends on your project and window type required, or simply wanted.

[@3Antimasonicparty3]

“137 things window companies won’t tell you about vinyl” great article to read. What is vinyl? PVC What is the poison plastic? PVC Do your research

[@Grande79]

#138, Fibrex is 60% PVC

[@baramuth71]

The USA is still a long way from European window technology with the tilt and side opening function. Only through European companies that are now also expanding in the U.S. for the American market is the U.S. learning.

[@tulio3571]

Today i was quoted $3600 for one western 4x5 aluminum windows , i need 4 , and about $16000 for a 12x 8 folding aluminum door , la cantina. Any thoughts?

[@MrTeff999]

This is confusing. Can you clarify your question?

[@americanwindowconcepts]

Both Western Windows and La Cantina are beautiful windows, and very strong. It is not unheard of to have those types of windows costing a couple thousand dollars each, also depending on size, thickness of glass, and obviously the inherent need for "tempered" glass with the size most of those windows are. I would get a couple other quotes to see how they line up with the original quote provided.

[@brandybrandenburg9525]

Have you heard of White oak construction? They have a patten on their window. Virgin vinyl and thicker glass. I would love to know what you think.

[@seanyahn7158]

Hi Brandy, White Oak Construction sounds like the builder or installers of windows. What is the brand of the windows, or is it truly White Oak Windows? Virgin Vinyl and at least 1/8” standard glass (double strength) is great! 3/16” (triple strength) is always a great option as an upgrade as well if available.

[@TheSeriesofTubes]

If you’re concerned about quality don’t buy a plastic window, Jesus Christ.

[@Lyubovstrauss]

excellent

[@americanwindowconcepts]

Thanks!

[@kaseyhodges7977]

Ply Gem windows hands down!!!! By far the best!!!!

[@Zach-hm6ky]

I'm working on a quote for $30,000 from with Alside windows. Do you like these?

[@v8powa466]

Did you go with alside? I'm working with them now

[@blueboat9581]

Of course brands matter

[@ericswain4177]

Do Window Brands Actually Matter ? Your kidding right ? As a tradesman I say do your homework, don't skimp but just the same because they cost more does not make them better ither.

[@Dave-zl2ky]

Most of the brands are just generic windows made to last 12 to 20 years.

[@ghostmost2614]

Anderson asked enough questions to come up with my homes value then based the price of my windows from that number. Stupid me, apparently it’s common knowledge that windows should cost what 20% of your homes value is. Not 20% over the cost to produce and installation which is a good and fair profit margin. Literally snake oil BS

[@mrazik131]

yes best warranties ....10 years and then company went out of business !

[@citticat2]

Yep, I got burnt with a "Lifetime Warranty".

[@stevesanzari7294]

This is All BS ! The windows are only as good as the installer ! Most windows are made the same ! Unless you spend a Fortune Everyday Vinland windows don’t Last !

[@clearnewview]

Milgard really sucks...! Very non-intuitive locking and unlocking mechanisms, very low quality manufacturing standards and abismal customer service.😡

[@americanwindowconcepts]

They are a huge window manufacturer, and steadfast to their warranty as it is spelled out. They have several grades of windows, and phased out their "Classic Line" vinyl window. The newer Trinsic and the Tuscany seem to be pretty nice, and newer window warranties tend to cover more. As competition adds benefits to their warranty, others tend to follow suit....not helpful to your situation I'm sure, but just throwing that out there.

[@larry5039]

MILGARD Tuscany is very nice.

[@stevesanzari7294]

No , because they both suck and are very Expensive !