Vocal Coach reacts to Eluveitie - The Call of the Mountains (Fabienne Erni Live)

[@bslsk.o]

A bit unfair to judge Fabienne with Anna Murphy's song really. The song is a bit low for Fabienne range.

[@johnscottyward4588]

👍

[@Eluarelon]

On the other hand, it just shows that she can do it even with songs not written with her in mind. I adore Anna, but Fabienne is equally good, and with the songs from Ategnatos, she's absolutely slaying it.

In my opinion, she is giving her touch to the music, not only trying to mimic Anna Murphy, who is used to hear Anna's version like me will prefer her version for sure.

[@ProtoLolZz]

@@Eluarelon in my humble opinion she tries too hard to imitate Anna and it really makes the song feel odd, Fabienne has an awesome voice, its just not displayed in this performance.

[@brandonk6479]

@@ProtoLolZz agreed. This song wasn't done with her abilities in mind. It was done with Anna's in mind. And it feels so foreign and wrong to hear this version. They need new music for this vocalist to really let her vocals shine through

[@Tommy-5684]

i realy kind of prefer the older Eluvate when they sang in the retraced old Gaulish dialect on Epona for example

[@terencechan405]

I literally watch these reaction videos to find artists I haven't heard of before. The amount of excellent artists and music I've discovered is unimaginable, thanks Beth!

[@finnmiller-new6383]

For more screaming/growling stuff look to King, Thousandfold or Inis Mona. Love Eluveitie

[@wyntersypher7657]

Might I also suggest Deathwalker

[@rec-reservaespiritualdecor3945]

Havoc is savage too! And for a more balanced combination, Ategnatos and Rebirth.

[@morganlee2802]

I always forget that Inis Mona exists for some reason

[@finnmiller-new6383]

@@morganlee2802 it's so good, one of my favourite really

[@finnmiller-new6383]

@@wyntersypher7657 damn, good one too I just listen to older stuff when going for the growl stuff. Love new and old though

[@caligo7918]

I miss their Hurdy Gurdy, the Violin alone lacks something...

[@luisnunes2010]

It comes in the other songs...

[@Themonist]

Anna is still rocking it in Cellar Darling, just saying ;)

[@Yuri7Fleischhauer]

Listen to deathwalker from their last album. That hurdy gurdy is insane

[@P-lo_ol-9]

more Gurdy, less Hurdy?

[@caligo7918]

@@luisnunes2010 i know, but this song could use some, too ;)

[@LaughingMan44]

Rebirth would have a mix of her singing and his growls

[@Bow-owl]

Rebirth from eluveitie is very interesting, we can listen the 2 singers and beautiful non vocal instruments.

[@juanm.q5121]

She is amazing, but no one sings this song as Anna Murphy, her voice range on the original version of this song slays.

[@alberich3099]

I'm not sure if your taste is tainted due to your emotional attachment to Anna. While I agree that Anna's version touches me more, I'm not sure wether Anna did a better technical job on this song.

[@swissystan]

Totally agree. This is Anna’s song....

[@xSOILBORNx]

Fabi > Anna in every aspect.

[@Samuel-dm1tb]

It is "vocal range" not voice, but other than that, totally agree.....

[@IvcoGT]

that´s true

[@RodesLaw]

Anna Murphy was the best singer this band EVER had. Losing her killed them. This lady is good but not even close to Anna.

[@AntonSobyanin]

Absolute bullshit. Fabienne is much more powerfull.

[@fritsyt2090]

Go listen to Cellar Darling there is Anna since a year or three. Go listen them instead of comparing both great singers. But for me Fabienne is the best for this band and Eluveitie is harsher and better than ever before!!

[@darkomaric3000]

@rodeslav both singers are so damn good. Some songs suits better to Anna like this songs. But this singer actually did amazing job with new songs

[@dubsfehr9574]

I love Fabienne so much.

[@BethRoars]

📖 Get your signed copy of my album Fable here: www.bethroars.com/shop ☀ Pre-save my first single "Power Of The Wolf" on Spotifu (it really helps me out!): distrokid.com/hyperfollow/bethroars/power-of-the-wolf 🥁 Become a Patreon Supporter: www.patreon.com/bethroars

[@novaasher1185]

❤

[@gerritgreveling]

Check out the earlier Eluveitie. During their FEAR DARK YEARS. Raw but briljant. These days they have the support of a mayor label. Too bad. Nowadays they sound to solid

[@gerritgreveling]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/gpSqqIycp9mfhq8

[@ChrisPage68]

@@gerritgreveling They sound fantastic.

[@ChrisPage68]

Beth - I don't do Apple products. Have you listened to Fabi and Jonas's side-project Illumishade? I recommend their debut album.

[@Immortall1408]

If you want to hear previous Eluveitie´s singer Anna Murphy in her current band called Cellar Darling, I would recommend listening to "Death" from KZbin Space London (Official Live) - kzbin.info/www/bejne/mmKZqmWdbNumeJY And there is one singer that you only heard, basically, only as a backing vocalist in reactions to "Valley of Queens" by Ayreon and "The Storm" by The Gentle Storm whose name is Marcela Bovio and here she is singing "Tides of Time" from Epica (piano cover) - kzbin.info/www/bejne/n33CgWmMd699fpY or if you want a metal song, there is "Delirio" by Stream of Passion - kzbin.info/www/bejne/Z2jPZKuLes2Ve68

[@sergiumarian6681]

You should react to Anna Murphy's preformance too on Call of the Mountains. Btw great video, love it!

[@Fallen_Hours]

While I love this singer, I prefer the original with Anna. Do check out their official music video with her and also enjoy the beautiful background scenery!

[@pieisnice9]

Now we get this and Cellar Darling so I can't say I mind too much.

[@Arinahaset]

I FUCKING LOVE ELUVEITIE! So rare to have anyone react to them.

[@TheRodolfoVideos]

I love this song and the fact that they have a different version for each language spoken in Switzerland makes it even more special!

[@ronitganguly3318]

Mr Beast taught them

[@wesleyzimmerman3145]

They also got a Russian vocalist to do a Russian version for them more recently

[@everett880]

Aye Beth, Fabienne is a bonnie lass. Actually, I just realised no bagpipes here...I remember seeing them in the MV.

[@deathsicon]

Didn't see a harp on stage either, but I know Fabienne plays it live

[@MrIranpaez]

u really need to reach Anna Murphy sing this music... like Basilisko said, A bit unfair to judge Fabienne with Anna Murphy's song really.

[@dontworryaboutit5989]

I'm sorry but Anna's version will always be my favorite. She did it in the beginning and was replaced along with others. The new vocalist has a great voice, but I still think Anna did this one better!

[@jimmybondy9450]

well, you know, it sounds different, no doubt. but fabi does NOT want to be a clone of anna.

[@ClaraBeack]

I agree, Anna's version sounds better but it's also because the song was written for her vocal range. Fabienne's is lightly different, they don't shine in the same range of notes, that's why.

[@xGOKOPx]

Nothing to be sorry about

[@theyonlycomeoutwhenitsquiet]

I think it’s a pity that she will be forever compared less than favourably to Anna. She’s doing well. But good quality after situational excellence feels like a let down. Anna was so very good, that even though Fabienne songs this quite well, it feels like the song has been taken down a peg. I also miss the hurdygurdy

[@xGOKOPx]

@@theyonlycomeoutwhenitsquiet They have a hurdy gurdy player tho, and this particular song has never had any hurdy gurdy in it

[@wookieenicolson2499]

I would love to see a reaction to the greatest Scottish band ever, Alestorm. Just for the fun of them, especially post-2012

[@Ghillie__Dhu]

Wookiee Nicolson Fannybaws

[@sf5823]

The violin, it's cool! Wow she's really consistent! I love watching your reactions! 😊

[@oscararzate7956]

Veo que te emociona este ritmo tiene. sonido. Cómo sí fueran unas gaitas de tu cultura pequitas bien 👏👏🍀🍀

[@jonathandeutsch5479]

Should do a reaction to the original song with Anna Murphy before she left the band. 100x better

[@cypherredux2771]

Damn it I was so excited that's what this was...

[@dancsgeo]

Fabienne is a great singer. She has a project named Illumishade, very good too.

[@beyerdr]

Great band great song. Was listening to "Quote The Raven" just a little bit ago

[@odin_yikesvater]

Hmm, special thanks to you, now i am addicted to Eluveitie again :D This band is so very nice ^^ I love it :D Keeo it up! Love it too ^^

[@AlexAmstaff91]

One of my fav band, they are incredible and her voice is amazing

[@jaded9234]

Eluveitie - "Lvgvs" from their most recent acoustic release.

[@rec-reservaespiritualdecor3945]

These guys are one of my favourite bands. Like, they sound way too "them" (this comes from a Folk Metal enthusiast). I love your analysis too!

[@welfiblablabla]

Is that from Wacken 2019? If so, I was there and aas really bummed when the concert was interrupted and finally cancelled because of a thunderstorm 😕

[@PaddyLaPoint]

Looks like a million people have already said it but without disrespect to the line up the song will never sound as good as it does with Anna Murphy. If you can find a video of Rose for Epona with Anna that would be terrific. Every time I listen to it I feel like I'm emotionally melting a bit, something about Anna's voice during that chorus sends chills down my spine and leaves me weak at the knees. Thank you so much for doing a reaction to Eluveitie though, such a wonderful band and it' brings tremendous joy to see them receive credit they so righteously deserve. Please do Silver Bride by Amorphis some time. Keep up the great work Beth!

[@richletram539]

Fabienne is a Great singer BUT, Anna Murphy sings this song WAY better! You have to react to the original version of this song! I've seen them live twice. Once with the old line up and once with the new line up. Both were amazing but Anna just sings certain songs way better. You should react to newer songs that were written for Fabienne's vocal style.😁

[@manuelecheverria8995]

Beth you have to react to Saurom-Náufrago live. Spanish folk metal band, you are gonna love it.

[@daemon119]

She can’t hold a candle to Anna. This version is a travesty.

[@johnmarkjansouzian7428]

Agreed, Fabienne may be a better technical singer, but Anna just suited the band's music much better.

[@deathsicon]

It does seem to have been an off day for her based on this video, she was much better when I saw them live last year

[@ferzmr5706]

The original versión is most wonderful with the Anne Morphy in the voice *_*

[@PaulRuben_]

I would love an episode with Anna Murphy

[@tatjanaherrmann8941]

I have no problems with this version( and i like fabienne too),because eluveitie is in my heart between the first gigs in the zurich area , 20 years again,when Eluveitie was without anna murphy... But i still miss anna murphy sorely!!!!! ...and especially in this huge song , i miss the magic of annas voice!! Sorry for my " swiss mountain english!"... I am eluveitie ;-) ( i am from helvetia, switzerland...)

[@nz540im3]

Please do the Anna Murphy version

[@KentuckyPatriot1776]

Check out Fabienne’s most current project Illumishade...

[@pasza_dem]

I really hope that you check Myrkur someday:)

[@zynius]

Check out her solo stuff on the Illuminate channel =)

[@VotograV]

Thanks for doing Eluveitie. Saw them live already in 2008. Time flies, my goodness. Since you are into Folk (celtic and nordic) a lot could you try this live version in a church by Kalandra - Brave New World? She also sings like an Elf if you ask me: kzbin.info/www/bejne/eWS8dGR8fLGri9k

[@erindaniel2310]

please do. william it was really nothing by the smiths

[@quetsalkoatl]

Yayy. Eluveitie is one of my favorite bands. I've seen them live a couple of times (with Anna and Fabienne), I love that haunting and nature-y feeling of a lot of their songs.

[@art_em_ill4319]

Since you have alread been deep in prog, i'd like to suggest Riverside - Dance with the shadow or Riverside - Volte-Face

[@johanbothma8031]

More European metal!! Blind Guardian, Helloween, Gamma Ray, Rhapsody of Fire!!

[@raducora7159]

This song was written to fit Anna like a glove. Yet Fabienne just nails it. For me, she's only second to Floor Jansen when it comes to singing a song entirely written for someone else's voice.

[@Sadion666]

Beth you should reeaally do Lost Horizon-Highlander (the one) Daniel Heiman's voice is phenomenal!! Also Eluveitie-Epona is really cool

[@Buick_GSX]

I’ve been waiting so long for vocal coaches to discover Eluveitie, they were my favorite band during middle school. This is so amazing, and I haven’t even watched the video yet. Bravo

[@keysielcarnero473]

No wonder it feels like "home", the Helveti are celts like the caledonians or the gauls.

[@carysgwenllian]

Hii Beth, Little Mix is releasing a new single called "Holiday" next Friday (24th) and we would love to see your reaction. Thank you!♡

[@Lusor_Elges]

After another try, pls react to equilibrium blut im auge or amon amarth guardians of Åsgaard live

[@andrew1575]

Kinda makes me wanna fire up Witcher 3

[@nvRfear1911]

Beth, will you be bringing on Oliver Rae Alleron on the podcast?

[@skylard2883]

If possible i would love to see your reaction to Adam gontier singing in three days grace or saint asonia you do a brilliant job and your descriptions are on point

[@malwindreyer3233]

Please react to phil bozeman from whitechapel doing unanswered or hickory creek

[@SirFooplesTheThird]

Eluveitie is one of those bands that really should listen to more but don't know where to start

[@yesman8682]

React to Hua Chenyu! I'd suggest starting with his live performances on Singer - first Bullfighting, followed by Child and then Fake Monk 🥰 Links below: Bullfighting kzbin.info/www/bejne/fKuloqergN6nqqM Child kzbin.info/www/bejne/qWKXiJ-np7SHfJo Fake Monk kzbin.info/www/bejne/bH-lmJaArdV8b68 🥺

[@nz540im3]

The new singer does amazingly. But please look up the Anna Murphy version.

[@nz540im3]

I was stupidly surprised about how awesome this live version of the song is. But Anna is missing :(

[@jimmybondy9450]

@@nz540im3 honestly, after all fabienne is the better singer. still anna was cool too.

[@melvinaustin1478]

Might I suggest BAND MAID. All female rock band. I recommend Freedom or Domination.

[@marianrolnik3168]

Day 76 asking Beth to react to Hentai Corporation - Trash Island kzbin.info/www/bejne/iHm0aJWaeNegl6M

[@brandonk6479]

I'm sorry. This song will always be Anna's. They need new songs for this lady to sing. Otherwise comparisons and fan division will occur. Beth, please do the version with Anna. This song wasn't written with this singer's vocal abilities in mind. It honestly sounds alien, and not in a good way. Not to me. People can disagree but please check the version with Anna and decide for yourself which you prefer.

[@guacicurbelo3964]

Hi! Can you to react to Entra en mi vida by Sin Bandera,please? Thanks

[@bfvader]

Definitely need to check out Eluveitie - Rebirth, though I've come across a few live performances with some pretty bad sound issues. The mix at Rockpalast 2019 was pretty bad, I don't think the Hurdy Gurdy was even mic'd. Anyone have a link to a performance with good sound?

[@ClaraBeack]

You should check a newer song, this one was not written for Fabienne but for the previewst singer. Fabienne goes higher, in my opinion this song is to low key for her.

[@roopa1824]

Hi Beth! Please react to Oasis - Champagne Supernova @ Earls Court 1995.

[@Nero5071]

This song... Belongs to Anna Murphy, It's great this new version, but, Anna can give u more feelings

[@valdito_2123]

I just come here to hear beth hahaha accent is sooo cool and she is a beauty ❤️

[@rileyen4608]

I don’t like the new singer..... the original singer for this song was 100 times better... although, the new singer is sexier and her own songs a great....

[@swngwyrdd3552]

Spent more time watching the violinist. Thanks TwoSet hah....

[@jamesnix078]

Original version with Anna Murphy es ALL, end.

[@rafaelwrencher8478]

Beth should check "É isso aí" from Ana Carolina feat. Seu Jorge.

[@forrest705]

Also loved Ana Carolina performance with "Clouds" on the song The Wind Carried Your Soul. She is a great singer. I look forward to her future work

[@XtremeKillah101]

I seriously thought you were reacting to yourself from the thumbnail because the singer looks exactly like you in that picture

[@joshy_bish]

Please react to her side band Illumishade! World's End by them is a bop :)

[@753nada1]

You should really react to a Breaking Benjamin song.

[@FrowningIke]

Try John Fogerty. One of the greatest singers of all time. kzbin.info/www/bejne/rpa7oqewqth8i5I

[@chadeklund9835]

Wow this is a terrible version of this song. Listen any version with Anna Murphy.

[@SymptomOfDepravity]

Not knocking her abilities but the original with Anna singing is just better. Anna was an incredible force in eluvetie.

[@ovekindvall4702]

I wanted to hurl insults at Beth for reacting to this song with "the wrong singer" but when she melted and gave in to the sounds of "her"people, I really dont have a leg to stand on.

[@riomochaccino2108]

Yes to the yesth power to the folks recommending Rebirth.

[@ProtoLolZz]

fabienne is a great singer, but she fell for the biggest fault for every singer, trying to sing other singers stuff like shes her, she tries to imitate Anna instead of singing it with her own style, and it seems like its difficult for her (understandably).

[@mrs.nesbitt2789]

Right before the concert was broken up because of a storm. I was so sad about it but the gig was great until that...

[@flakedwheelie]

This version of the song lacks so much. The original version is so much better in my opinion.

[@richarddelosreyes1340]

Hello Beth pls react Morissette gravity cover thanks.

[@unreconstructed]

This is the worst version of this song. Please listen to Anna Murphy sing it. She's a goddess

[@elgatosoft]

react to "Mentira" form La ley: kzbin.info/www/bejne/mmLHlIudfLaHaK8

[@themightyrisone9910]

you should really react to the anna murphy versions of eluveitie songs

[@simonlove446]

Please, make a video with your reaction on John Frusciante music 😉

[@michaelmills2020]

One of the old members who was a singer for the band left to and started a band called Cellar Darling ,The Spell is definitely worth a listen

[@chrisumana7644]

Rebirth and Rose for Epona will be a good choice if you want to see contrast between the 2 different singers

[@shawnrodgers2180]

Anna Murphy was so much better for this song .

[@DantezMaritu]

I miss Anna. Sorry to be that guy, but I do.

[@YasWitch7]

GAL YOU SHOULD TRY WITH THE ORIGINAL SINGER OF THIS SONG

[@revolverparker8246]

Beth roars should react to beth roars.

[@maisanmaisan1485]

Hi beth roar please react to faouzia tears of gold (stripped)

[@buccanero]

Now do the one with Anna Murphy!

[@mazaggie]

It's a crime to hear this version before Anna's.

[@MrIza69]

You’re wearing fabiennes look 😂

[@johngalt9989]

The current lineup is excellent, but I miss Anna.

[@jhovo2008]

React to Andrea Bocelli and Martha Sanchez singing "Vivo por ella" beautiful piece about the music

[@Jeff_1985]

React to there music video of this song its amazing