We ALL Feel Sorry for Rose | Downton Abbey

The Crawley family visits Lady Rose MacClare and her parents for a summer break at Duneagle Castle in The Highlands of Scotland. What they didn't expect was to find out an unhappily married couple and a very uncomfortable stay for all of them.
The Crawley family feels sorry for Rose... IS there anything that they can do for her?
From season 3 episode 9: The Crawleys go to Duneagle Castle to celebrate Christmas with the MacClares. Everyone is delighted as they fish, hunt, and dine. Unfortunately, when the Crawleys return, tragedy strikes. Will things ever be the same again?
This is the official KZbin channel for Downton Abbey. Immerse yourself in the much-loved British historical drama, relive some of your favourite moments and tragedies, and keep up-to-date with the latest news.
Subscribe for more here: / @downtonabbey
Watch Downton Abbey on iTunes: bit.ly/Downton...
Twitter: / downtonabbey
Facebook: / downtonabbey
Instagram: / downtonabbey_official
#DowntonAbbey #DowntonAbbeyFilm #LilyJames

[@traceyreed9167]

I sympathize with Rose because I understood her character so well. When you come from a home that criticizes your every move, you end up making foolish mistakes when you get a moment of freedom. They did a great job of portraying this.

[@miriamhavard7621]

💁

[@barbarat5729]

It also makes it hard to shake the belief that everyone is criticizing you.

[@phaerion9142]

@@barbarat5729 yes, I have been for ages shedding the "everyone is criticizing and demeaning me" been raised by a critices-everything-but-preaches-criticizing-is-wrong-when-you-do-it-and-it-is-never-them family.

[@Kelaiah01]

@@phaerion9142 That sounds horrible. :( I hope you get better, and that you have nothing to do with that family anymore.

[@masuganut2082]

@@Kelaiah01 agreed!

[@Izzybaggins]

The look in Cora’s eyes when she suddenly remembers Sibyl is extremely accurate, I see the same look in my mother’s eyes when she remembers that my sister is gone.

[@patriciajrs46]

I am sorry. Loss is always felt. A grieving period does not exist.

[@gumnaamaadmi007]

I am sorry for your and your family's loss.

[@melaniekendall4903]

It's only a TV programme 😂

[@thangvuong9196]

Rose's mother is one of the most detestable characters in the whole series

[@nina1522]

Green is the character I hate most, but Rose's mother is tied with Bates' ex-wife Vera for the Number Two position.

[@Xerxes2005]

She is detestable, but I like that every character has a good side. The scene between Cora and her, as two mothers talking about their children, was really good and showed us that she really cared about Rose (too much) and that she was very conscious of her downfalls as a mother and wife.

[@lindakayeholmes3841]

That’s good acting 😂😂😂

[@thangvuong9196]

@@lindakayeholmes3841 yes!

[@D_Marrenalv]

Agreed.

[@GoldenRose116]

Rose was such a sweet girl, even to the servants she didn't know she was kind and polite. Her mother is so toxic, its sad.

[@HeatherHotcakes]

Golden Rose She was really good with the servants especially when they were willing to lie on her behalf and help her pull off some scheme.

[@ingriddubbel8468]

Against the servants?

[@GoldenRose116]

@@HeatherHotcakes even outside of that, the servants knew thst they could easily go to Rose if they needed something. And she genuinly liked them, when she returned for Ediths wedding one of the first things she did was downstairs and greet/talk to them.

[@paintedwithlove]

She really was the sweet heart of the show after Sybil. Like in the last Christmas special when she comes back to Downton says hello to her family and then rushes downstairs to say hello to the staff and show them the photos of her little baby 💖

[@josephodell4830]

Her sister was toxic. Not really her mom

[@Hallows4]

This scene really shows how insightful Violet is: While she rarely has qualms about voicing her disapproval, she understands that constant petty criticism is not the way to effect real change.

[@pattyamato8758]

Not only that, she understand's Cora's grief over losing her daughter. It doesn't go away after a set time, one will always miss their child who has died, or any close loved one. The Brits and people back then were more "stiff upper lip/Carry on", but Violet understands human nature so well.

[@shaniatreyu9303]

@@pattyamato8758 Violet knows how to weave around the stiffness of British etiquette and still say progressive things while sounding dignified at the same time. It's a very clever tactic when you're in a titled role that gives you little leeway to emote properly.

[@miriamhavard7621]

Rose was an angel. Sometimes misguided, but a beautiful soul.

[@HeatherHotcakes]

Miriam Havard Did you miss her constant, consistent lying. Cause she was a great deceiver of all.

[@maragathm]

@@HeatherHotcakes Did you miss the fact that her mother was from hell, the fact she survived all that emotional abuse, and had a kind heart free from prejudices of her time, was a good human made a good marriage is shocking. Whatever her faults it was because of her horrid mother once free she flourished.

[@miriamhavard7621]

@@HeatherHotcakes she was immature. Who of us is without sin? And she blossomed. Who on that show didn't lie? So many characters displayed faults, including Rose. Why single HER out?

[@evacope1718]

It's a shame Sybil wasn't alive when rose came in, they were similar in ways

[@jpaxonreyes]

@Christiaan Baron - No, because she kept lying and running off to go dancing. It turned out to be mostly harmless, but giving everyone the slip could have been dangerous.

[@nicolebragg1171]

I like that Cora & Robert basically adopt Rose & take her into their care. With her family so strained & tense, the loving family of Downton really helped her grow & see how a family life can be happy.

[@marinazagrai1623]

I would add one thing…she knew she had the support of her dad, but Susan would lose her eventually and that treatment just pushes Rose away from her as fast as possible.

[@LucyLovettLestrange]

Perhaps it was kind of like having Sybil around

[@whitneydavis7443]

Shrimpie wanted her to have the experience of a loving family. And although I detest Susan, I do think she loved Rose. She was just so unhappy in her own life that it spilled out onto everyone else. And misery loves company.

[@carolstewart4088]

Rose in turn called her daughter Victoria Rachel Cora, Rachel for her mother-in-law. Notice Rose did not add a Susan in there.

[@whitneydavis7443]

@@carolstewart4088 Mrs. Patmore even questioned her about that in the final episode.

[@shannonfick7170]

Love that little moment between Cora and Violet. They didn’t talk about their feelings much in those days, but the pain is always just under the surface for a mother who loses a child

[@romulusthemainecoon3047]

I love that moment too!!

[@robertmoore6149]

Mr Gregson was one of the more tragic characters in the show. He tried so hard to impress yet be be honest and sincere. He died for his principles fighting the Nazis before the rest of the world knew they were a threat. Wish we could have seen more of him.

[@rahaa.sh_307]

I agree. Also the broken ship between Edith & him will always haunt me.

[@safespacebear]

"my whole childhood would seem impossible to you, but I survived, and so will you"...Bates is so good at relating to folks for a stern tough man, he's got a real pronounced sense of empathy. A lot of the nobility come to rely on his strength and he always provides it without ever overstepping the mark. It's only natural the Anna and John would want to protect Rose and as others said, she was a hot mess for the first part of her character's development.

[@robinlillian9471]

And no wonder with her cruel Mother.

[@KoiYakultGreenTea]

Safe Space Bear he could’ve easily have said rose had it better than he did by miles but he knows pain is pain and everyone feels it

[@nina1522]

I really believe Bates has a heart of gold. He does have a dark side, but I think he had to develop that because he had a difficult life. He is a good friend to the other servants, he is fiercely loyal to Robert, and he adores Anna. It makes me wonder how he'd be if he had had an easier life.

[@jeremymiller9582]

Yes, and I love that he in one sentence reminded her of how lucky she is to be who and where she is while also managing to sympathize that despite her luck, her emotions are equally as valid.

[@TheLadySilverMoon]

Rose's parents had fallen out of love for each other, and they had lost all their money and was about to sell their family home. This made Rose's mom Susan miserable, so she made everyone else around her miserable too. Like Mary showed us in later season, when you're unhappy you can't stand to see someone else happy.

[@nina1522]

I had a little sympathy for Susan for a while, but those stunts she pulled with Rose's wedding, first with those pictures of Atticus and the stripper, then getting up and blabbing about her and Shrimpie's divorce at the ceremony, ended that. She ended up alone, miserable and bitter, and she brought every bit of it on herself.

[@MandieTerrier]

The Dowager said she was *always* nasty. Even when she was a girl playing with her dolls.

[@angelabby2379]

@@MandieTerrier got it from the mom 🤣🥺

[@dylangarcia3898]

Why were the Maclares so broke to begin with , it's seems odd that a noble family would go completely broke .

[@glen7318]

@@dylangarcia3898 Didn't manage their estates well, Hugh spent a lot of his time representing the crown rather than attending to his own financial interests.....

[@romulusthemainecoon3047]

The Dowager could be snarky and didn't always see eye to eye with Cora, but her empathetic, quiet "We all miss her. Every single day" was absolutely the right thing to say at the right time.

[@sheilaburns8977]

My eyes burn every time I watch that scene. ... PEACE.

[@rahaa.sh_307]

And it was true as well. Just like a mother shouldn't lose a child, a grandmother shouldn't lose a grandchild either.

[@leirelarrakoetxea5747]

One thing I like of this series is that they don't forget those who have passed away in most series somebody dies, there is while of grieving but then everybody kinds of forgets. In Downtown the dead are always missed in one way or another and that make us miss them to and never forget them and brings realism

[@yevgeniyaleshchenko849]

@@leirelarrakoetxea5747 True but to be fair, it was only 4 or so episodes after Sybil died (I know it's more in the terms of time passage for the characters within the show but still); I don't think they brought her up that often after season 4

[@12classics39]

Mr. and Mrs. Bates’ kindness toward Rose is a great indicator that they will be wonderful parents someday.

[@mattpaul173]

Sybil is someone you can look up to and aspire to be. Rose is someone you can relate to and sympathize with.

[@thewimp9630]

And Mary is the one you have to be from time to time.

[@ryujin8842]

You have absolutely no idea how much I miss the Downton Abbey theme song! It is bloody brilliantly and magnificent!!!

[@markmh835]

I second that! 👍

[@ryujin8842]

White Fairy How did you make it your ringtone??? I’ve been trying

[@ryujin8842]

White Fairy does this work on iPhone?

[@mistydelahay9255]

If you type in Diwnton Abbey ambience you get an hour of the theme song.

[@bisharobashir4548]

I wholeheartedly agree!

[@joyl7842]

I just love how Bates helps wherever he can and knows exactly what to tell Lady Rose to make her feel better. How such a damaged person can be so great. That is one of the world's true miracles.

[@echo.echo08]

I like Rose. She's ok. She's fun and nice to the common folk but she's not Sybil. Sybil is revolutionary--truly ahead of her time and a better role model, i think.

[@nina1522]

Alas, souls like Sybil's are few and far between, even more so these days.

[@Roberta_Trevino]

Yeah but it's unfair to compare Rose to Sybil. Sybil is on another level of human kindness and tbh it would be unfair to hold any character up tothe standards of Sybil's strong morals.

[@liv97497]

But she's not meant to be - I think that's the beauty of the show, that you're not supposed to idolize these characters. They're generally good people, but there's always moments in the show or lines here and there that show they're flawed. In Rose, you see her be a little bit entitled sometimes, and even a little self centered, but that's okay, because there's other aspects of her personality that are loveable and relatable. But I did love Sybil, too, and I so wish we could've seen more of her.

[@b.3049]

Sybil was also too perfect and therefore dull.

[@mugiikari1641]

@@b.3049 Sybil wasn’t perfect. She was a bit too trusting and a bit too reckless. She did things without thinking them through. Sybil was way better than Rose tbh but I find Lily James to be a bad actress and that probably forms my opinion more than the actual character.

[@__seeker__]

How the hell is Bates always so cool? Anna hit the jackpot.

[@lolabrini3758]

i cant stand him mister always goody too shoes no one like that exists come on🙄live a little lie a little

[@thefrenchislander]

@@lolabrini3758 Yeah me too, I never really liked his character

[@CSGray-nf2hx]

@@lolabrini3758 So you never saw the episodes he lowkey revealed he knew how to forge writing?

[@12classics39]

@@CSGray-nf2hxhe learned that while stuck in prison for something he didn’t do.

[@sealdude5581]

​@@lolabrini3758People like Bates absolutely exist, but they're very rare

[@DaisyOh]

Remember when O'Brien ditched Cora for Rose's mom? I wonder how that all worked out...

[@juliana22]

I always wondered about that because Rose's mom comes back for her wedding and she see all the Crawleys. It was never really addressed only that she couldn't afford those privileges anymore like having a Ladysmaid. But still, it would have been interesting to see Cora mention O'Brien.

[@beccahermann5948]

If you watch the UK version, it was addressed only once. It was said that O’Brien stayed behind to work for the new governor’s wife.

[@juliana22]

@@beccahermann5948 really? I have watched all the episodes multiple times, i don't know how i missed it on the dvds. Thank you.

[@DaisyOh]

@@beccahermann5948 Thank you, that's fantastic to know! I really adore O'Brien and hope she made out well in the end. Such a great character.

[@FeBa-fq6cj]

Daisy Ohdaisy Her Ladyship’s soap

[@k.p.paveine3764]

It's so sad that I can totally relate to her. Being raised in a family where your every step is criticised and being made to feel foolish just for existing.

[@patriciajrs46]

I often felt that Edith and Rose had a lot in common.

[@lolabigcups7121]

In the end it all turned out well for Rose. I think she might've had the happiest ending of all.

[@fanni24]

She was incredibly lucky that her fiancé and his mother stuck up to her when her mother spilled the truth about her failing marriage and the divorce. If Atticus' mother hadn't stand up for Rose against her own husband, she couldn't have married Atticus in my opinion.

[@lolabigcups7121]

@@fanni24 Naw, I think it was Lord Sinderberrys mistress showing up and him being faced with his own hypocrisy that truly changed his mind.

[@fanni24]

@@lolabigcups7121 Well, he wasn't a good man in my opinion. He only felt remorse when he was about to be publicly humiliated by his mistress and illegitiamte child in front of their friends and family. He would've easily continued to have an affair if the woman and his son didn't turn up in their house.

[@orlandobloom2883]

Matthew showing up in the first scene made me cry...

[@DaisyOh]

Same. Poor, sexy Matthew...

[@isabelsoliman1271]

I think we ALL feel sorry for Rose

[@ladyfoxwf1075]

Victoria Justice ain't havin none - a that XD

[@brianinge8174]

Lol I'm crying

[@lilredpandagirl9681]

It's okay, Rose. My mom is exactly the same way. Bitter, unpleasant, conceited and hateful. I go days and weeks without talking to her because I don't like being criticized by someone who doesn't know me and never bothered to get to know me.

[@LadyTeePrinceLover]

Gosh Claudia! You sound just like me! 💜

[@gisawslonim9716]

It's because the mothers always expect their daughters to be exacty like them and that is usually not the case...disappointment sets in, the mother tries to coerce the daughter, the daughter rejects it and tries to be her own person...well, one sees what happens. If only the two of them could accept the other just as they are everything would work out beautifully.

[@rahaa.sh_307]

@@gisawslonim9716 Rose had no trouble accepting her mother if she just let her daughter be!

[@judycroteau482]

But you survived. Good for you. ❤️

[@BloodInTheStrawberries]

Go no to low contact, you'll be so much better- Don't waste yourself on someone who doesn't value, love, or respect you as a person. Even if it is your Mother-

[@libbyshooter9680]

Even baby sybbie was suspicious of Edna 😂🙄

[@overcomerbtboj]

Lol 😂

[@fantasticbeck3938]

“Stay away from my dad!” 😂

[@maviskoon1509]

Edna is scum

[@emmabenuska699]

It seems in her world every thing was a party,but then she taught Anna to dance,I remember the young man from the tea dance,then working with the displaced Russians.In another comment somewhere it was said that Rose fillled the gap that Sybil left,I agree.

[@andresuston7692]

Why not treat the world as a party while you can, instead of regretting it later when you can't?

[@Winson844]

Robert: "It puzzles me why you choose to employ amateurs like my daughter" Mary: *Turns to Matthew* "I agree"

[@vilwarin5635]

she couldn´t give it a rest right?

[@bigrivtodagled8210]

Such a bitch.

[@lizd.8655]

I really don't get why Mary is a liked character. I'm not a middle child but I deeply related to Edith.

[@abcdefg7679]

Lucy Van Pelt i hate mary. She is so arrogant, selfish and treats edith horribly. She has nice moments of course especially when helping anna but generally i don’t like her

[@Ana-xt6ze]

@@lizd.8655 I kinda liked her when she was with Matthew, I feel like she was more careful about the negative aspects of her personality and tried to be better than that, but she just went back to being a bully after he died, which was very disappointing

[@rubensnobre3281]

Violet: "We all miss her, every single day" 💔🥺 ohhhh God 😭😭😭

[@clarkclarke]

Rose was misguided...had no love it affection firm her mother ... I think she reacted the way most young people would ... she was acting out .... Rose just need to be of value (?) and she genuinely liked people ..

[@halloween42]

Mary's accent is soooo exquisite

[@jpaxonreyes]

It's sooooo posh. I _loved_ to hate it.

[@pattyamato8758]

Heard that naturally she had more of a Cockney accent and had to work to sound so posh

[@lilypond5158]

Lily James is such a good actress

[@ece8011]

Ikr she is amazing

[@pattyamato8758]

I know - I thought she was wonderful in "Manc", and other roles

[@m.layfette6249]

Lady Rose McClaire is the youngest daughter of Lord and Lady Flintshire. She's a quintessential Daddy's Girl, thereby Loves her father immensely. 💗 She's Proud of her Father and the work/position he does/holds at Court. Her Mother is absolutely Horrid. She resents her husband's attention toward Lady Rose. She desires to be the "Center of Attention". Her desire to be as attractive as Lady Grantham (Cora) when it comes to hairstyles and fashion. Lady Flintshire is her own Worse enemy and I Do Not Blame Lady Rose one-1 bit for marrying Attitcus and naming her daughter after Cora. #TeamRose

[@MandyJMaddison]

Correction- Flintshire (Scottish placename)

[@m.layfette6249]

@@MandyJMaddison Thanks. Blame auto correct. 😊

[@theenforcer9965]

just started to watch d,a im 50 and mom is 82 we are enjoying it on the sat we binge watch a series wwith a takeaway and a pint

[@vickistine9388]

The Enforcer...Good for you & your Mom!! It’s a wonderful series!

[@emmabenuska699]

Cheers!🍻

[@marylinramos4300]

sounds divine!

[@kerry3710]

You know those books you wish they'd make into a movie? Well I'd love to read the Downton Abbey saga!

[@patriciajrs46]

Is it in print? I hope Mr. Fellows wrote a book of it. Perhaps it would explain some things that movies like to leave out.

[@naomichadwick4223]

Remember Ella, Have Courage & Be Kind☺️

[@mariapilarme]

I love these Brits they call each other names in the most polite manner. The power of words! When someone call me something I would said” I’ll take that as a compliment “ Haha 😆

[@themermaidstale5008]

Mary’s 💚 so jealous 💚 that Edith’s being recognized for her talent!

[@tt8807]

I was so bummed she wasn’t in either movie. Rose was such a sweet character.

[@barb2435]

im glad to say in real life ,, rose went on to make great movies,,i found a good one on netflix,,thank you ,,;)

[@emmabenuska699]

She is a wonderful Cinderella

[@pattyamato8758]

Yes, "Mank", right?

[@songbird377]

I visited Duneagle (Inverary Castle) a couple months ago! My profile pic is me standing as close as you could get to those archways, sadly they blocked it off so you can’t walk under there😕

[@amylynnsgraphics]

During that scene I wish I was one of the ladies at the party so I could go find her and give her a big sisterly hug. I just felt so sad for her, she's such a delightful sweet person, who's just trying to find her own way. Yes in the beginning she got into all sorts of mischief, but with a mother like that, I can relate. My parents are great but were super sheltering and over protective and drove me to rebel at times.

[@bonniebester606]

Thank you for understanding...

[@Soulful_Chaos]

1:46 That baby was so talented! 😂😂😂😂 iykyk

[@rachelnguyen5079]

Anyhow, Rose has lovely relative and staff who all around her 💖💐

[@escdarkside]

I got an ad for the movie before AND after this

[@naturazpolski9213]

I find it scary how related I feel to Edith and Rose. Rose's mother is always critising her for every single thing she does, whether it's good or bad, whether she did someting well or if she fucked up, she's still and still critised, starting from petty stupid things, going to serious one. On the other hand there is Edith who has ALWAYS been overlooked by her family, no matter what she achieved and did, it wasn't nothing worth for her family to pay attention, everybody was always looking at her older sister, even if she needed their attention more at some point. Dudes, if I could choose to hang out with some fictional characters, I would definately do with these two! We could have the most stereotypical ,,lady's day'', go to some great place with jazz to dance and then later in the night get drunk at home, talking gossips and dramas about our families unfair treatment!

[@Richardsonprincess00]

True, composure is the answer without giving up nor crying and it's only society. Thinking Rose is the next Sybil...

[@luisbriceno4414]

i read the title in victoria justice’s voice

[@user-ww5hm8lu1w]

Luis Briceno i think we ALL feel sorry for rose?

[@dyhia1311]

I think we ALL read it in victoria's voice

[@elleross9023]

I feel like Rose and Sybil would be very close, they seem to have a similar personality.

[@glen7318]

not at all. ROse is silly and frivolous

[@LucyLovettLestrange]

Cora and violet might not have seen eye to eye with each other (at times) but it was nice to see violet comfort Cora over Sybil

[@chiccachannel]

With a mother like that who needs enemies...

[@connellwalker7873]

So rich in emotional content, unexpected highs and painful lows.

[@R.rojas102]

Well she got married and able to run away from that horrendous mother

[@AndriaBieberDesigns]

They loved each other so much

[@CJ-im2uu]

Rose is my favorite of the upstairs. I found Mary pretentious. Dockers played her role well.

[@anacardoso9090]

For some reason I do not know why, I never really liked Rose... Ok, her Mother was almost her enemy (a completely bitter person) but she always seems a bit rebelious with no cause... She was up to her time, but just as a party girl. For me, Sibyl was revolutionary in every aspect: shining, vibrant and responsible for her decisions.

[@miriamhavard7621]

So what she liked to party? Can you just imagine how gloomy it must have been living with that old cow of a mother of hers? She DESERVED happiness and joy and to feel loved and to be able to love. 💕

[@TuomariMuller]

I agree. A bit boring character.

[@seithdaniel9013]

And so she was a party girl. She's young, full of life and bright ideas, a stark contrast against her impertinent mother and their decaying castle. Considering the time in which she lived, yes, she might seem rebellious without a cause. A Lady smoking? Going to secret parties? Partaking in prohibited affairs? Marrying a Jew? Yes, she looked like she was rebellious, but when you strip the Edwardian biases from her life, you'll find her to be a relatively normal teenage girl trying to live a relatively normal life. She is rebellious, and she is a party girl, and that's what makes Rose, Rose. As viewers, I think we have the obligation to look beyond what is shown to see what is hidden. At least, this is how I watch Downton Abbey.

[@celinee.9562]

@@antoniabanoczi-gg8te yes she learns ! She first has to break free and break a few rules before she can understand why rules are helpful in life. She grew up with so many rules, it would have maybe suited to another personnality but she is a free spirit and a young soul. She may not have the same kind of intelligence as Mary but she is bright in her own way i think. By that i do not mean smart, but brilliant ! Distinctive. She brings a spark of life where she goes. She's the polar opposite of her mother !

[@vickistine9388]

Miriam Havard “that old cow” Hysterical!

[@cyrilmauras4247]

The Drawing Room shown as in the fictional "Dun Eagle" is in the house (Wrotham Park) where Robert Altman filmed "Gosford Park". Maggie Smith was in that film.

[@mgpattison]

is the title the victorious meme......... askdjslsjajs love that

[@micca903]

I hope The Gilded Age on HBO will be just as good. I'm sort of worried because the deeper into the past you go the harder it becomes to depict a realistic picture of the period. But I'm happy it's on HBO. They seem to have a good group of people there.

[@thanib7796]

Whoever is typing the titles to these videos are really into memes, aren't they? LOL.

[@Mkaela90]

I like the part when her mom asked Cora to talk something nice about her to rose .

[@romulusthemainecoon3047]

One of the few times I liked her mom!

[@andreafabianbouchard3574]

Everyone's commenting about Lady Flintshire, yes, I understand it's due to the title, but if you're naming the worst of all of the show, I'm just quite perplexed Green, Bates' ex wife and for heaven's sakes, that slimy serpent just right there, tainting Anna's reputation and constantly manipulating Tom till Blessed Mrs. Hughs came to the rescue; are all unmentioned! Lord Merton's sons and daughter in law were nasty, as well, with all that scheme almost killing/murdering their own Father for Money and Inheritance Keeping Isobel Away, too, leading to heartbreak in his deathbed hadn't Dear cousin Violet intervened! Personally, it'll always be the likes of Green for me. That was traumatizing. Anna did not deserve it not an ounce bit. And such vile beasts and vermins exists even to this day and I want nothing but justice be taken to hand.

[@evelynbyrd4961]

Rose's mother hasn't changed Abit. When, Shrimpy, married Susan, she was slightly cooky then. The World had changed, not Susan.

[@dawnemyers8873]

Mary can really be mean especially to Edith! Mary is so self intitled and feels she is so beautiful and smart. I think things that happen to Mary are brought on by her bad behavior.

[@rahaa.sh_307]

Robert literally said the same thing, why aren't you blaming him?

[@rossrreyes]

No Lady Rose in the Movie!!!!??!!!!

[@Richardsonprincess00]

Sorry

[@gutsfinky]

No, she was married and living in New York at the time the movie took place.

[@veerseth4911]

0:27 he only adressed cora and not the countess

[@aperson22222]

This smoking was a one off thing for her, thankfully.

[@AdityaPradiptaMeneer]

0:27, is it the custom to greet the most senior company present?

[@vanessamimi5976]

which ep is this

[@glen7318]

Lily James was brought in after Sybil's death, to replace her.. but she seems to have left and only returned at the very end. Anyone know why? It seems that both ALlen Leech and Lily James were both added to the show and then left and only came back towards the end...

[@flyboy152]

>> The Crawley family visits Lady Rose MacClare and her parents for a summer break at Duneagle >> From season 3 episode 9: The Crawleys go to Duneagle Castle to celebrate Christmas Make up your minds. Summer or Christmas? As I remember the episode, it's summer, or at least not the middle of winter. They're hunting in the Highlands, and having outdoor picnics.

[@jehannethompson1432]

It’s September bc Mary had George in September 1921. I don’t think the Christmas episodes are necessarily around Christmas time. The only time it was actually Christmas time was when Matthew proposed to Mary

[@staciecarrel4492]

In this clip Bates also mentioned how “it never seems to get completely dark, unlike down south”. The only time of year where that would be true is Summer.

[@theoriginalpublicnewsense]

I never felt sorry for Rose. She was annoying, as teenage girls often are. I know. I used to be one. But one of my favorite scenes--or two--of her were when she was hinting to Robert about getting a wireless. Robert's reaction before she could even get it out was , "NooOO"....NoooOOO" Well played. 😄

[@leahsundvall5894]

Rose had the same spirit as sybil.

[@kofoolanrewaju1639]

The nerve of that maid

[@AlexdrinaArmstrong94]

0:47 Mary Is definitely her Father's Daughter

[@Diamondelle84]

2:47 It's either that, or a bottle of whiskey 😆

[@rafiyahaque5411]

which season?

[@iloveyourunclebob]

The ens of season 3

[@deedragongirl]

Cinderella and Prince Adam!

[@kayleeidk982]

I think we ALL know the meme behind the title.

[@sunshinesmile94]

Wait. I am so out of touch with this series but... Is that Matthew?!? How is he still alive?!?

[@MarinaKaFai]

It's set shortly before Mary gives birth and he dies after George is born.

[@matthewreierson6910]

The Dowager Countess would have to well and truly be made of stone not to mourn the loss of her own granddaughter. And if even the Dowager Countess thinks you're too hard on someone...

[@hansolofholmberg2071]

Her father is the actor who played Oscar Wilde.

[@taroman7100]

Mary who's nearly due looks about five months max.

[@andrew_4747]

And again we have Mary, being nasty towards Edith for finding some happiness.

[@RCurtis049]

Anyone else think that this was from the new film and freak out that Gregson was back

[@margaretgaby2356]

Haha slouching like a field hand.

[@GevEdgar]

¡A cute child!

[@johnnyM809]

Rose was great. One of the best characters in DA.

[@waverlyphillips2849]

Lady Flintshire was insufferable.

[@jerryadams2191]

My rose, 😎📺✌✌💎

[@patriciajrs46]

I love Maggie, the dowager Lady Grantham. Smith, I believe.

[@davidweihe6052]

Dame Maggie Smith or Violet Crawley, Dowager Lady Grantham, but not mixed up.

[@Trogdor1365]

I don't think there's anyone who doesn't love Dame Maggie Smith. She has played so many iconic characters. I don't get sad when celebrities pass (I sympathize with their families of course, and feel badly if it was a young person, like with any stranger) but I dread the day I read Maggie Smith has passed.

[@JenaRaschka]

Anybody else notice the odd green screen?

[@loisdora3919]

Jena Chapman - Yes, I noticed the green screen also!

[@ABirdOnTheMoon]

Couldn't Robert and Mary shut up .. and just support Edith for once!? Why did he never say a word about how immature and stupid Mary was with all her shenanigans .. now that Edith writes a column and he disapprove of it .. he says something. She is being independent and free .. and because she is not hiding it or doing something tabboo .. she is to be criticized and discouraged!? eh .. I always wondered how could Edith hold it with them leaving such cruel comments to her face.

[@rahaa.sh_307]

Mary saw everything through class, & she didn't consider Michael classy enough for their family & believed he was just using Edith to get aristocratic & wealthy. I'm not saying any of these thoughts were good, no, they were absolutely problematic but it also indicates that in this specific scene, Mary was just protecting her sister & family, though in an extremely unpleasant way. And Robert! Omfg! His reaction to Edith writing from the very beginning annoyed the hell out of me. Wanted to punch him for that, & not just once🤬

[@ABirdOnTheMoon]

@@rahaa.sh_307Mary was never about protecting Edith. Fast forward to when he dies and Mary tells Anna that she found him decent but she never understood what he saw/loved about Edith. She actually looks down on her sister a lot. Mary never saved a chance to humiliate her sister or to be in the spotlight.

[@rahaa.sh_307]

@@ABirdOnTheMoon Your point about death reaction proves mine Yes, Mary did look down on Edith but they were still sisters, Edith wasn't good with Mary either but she did show support at times, same can be said about Mary's reaction here.

[@taroman7100]

Poor little rich girl ran away from the mansion. It's the same old story.

[@sheismymom]

Rose shouldn't be smoking

[@rocketmom60]

She only smoked in that one scene and never again in the series. Don't forget, women were making their way during the 20s and no one knew at the time how dangerous smoking was.

[@miriamhavard7621]

Well, no one should be smoking......💁

[@gisawslonim9716]

For goodness' sake, EVERYONE smoked at that time; NOBODY knew it caused cancer and smoking continued among the "smart" set well into the 1970s.

[@lisacox4984]

"Unusually impossible"? For some people it's all too usual.

[@iloveyourunclebob]

Lol this episode is on right now

[@AlbertoGarcia-wd7sc]

Ah, Celebrimbor has arrived

[@sarahjuarez1433]

Curious on why her mother was horrible to her own daughter. Why have kids if your going to horrible??? Can tell she never wanted any.

[@glen7318]

She would not have had any option but to have them....

[@DaveDexterMusic]

Good god, Rose was a tiresome character. I'd rather have the space left by Sybil untouched, but drama gotta drama.