We Test The Hottest Electric SUVs On The Market! Model Y vs ID.4 vs Mach-E vs Polestar 2

The Out of Spec team puts some of the most talked about electric cars head to head in this review to figure out which is the one you should buy! We cover topics such as design, pricing, charging performance, driving performance, and even finish up with a real-world efficiency run! We hope you enjoy this video.
We would really appreciate it if you subscribe to our channel! The more subscribers we have, the more awesome opportunities we will be able to bring to you!
A huge thank you to the amazing Out of Spec Studios team and also to @MachE_VLOG for bringing their car to join in the comparison!
Kyle on Twitter: @itskyleconner
Kyle on Instagram: @Virtualkyle
For more behind the scenes content:
Twitter: @Out_of_Spec
Facebook: / outofspecreviews
Instagram: @OutofSpecReviews
Inquiries: [e-mail]
0:00 - Hello & Welcome!
1:57 - Price / Purchase Experience
10:33 - Range
16:29 - Battery / Charging
30:01 - Charging Infrastructure
36:32 - Exterior Design
47:55 - ID.4 Performance Drive
53:25 - Mach-E Performance Drive
1:00:44 - Model Y Performance Drive
1:06:50 - Polestar 2 Performance Drive
1:15:35 - Interior / Cargo Polestar
1:22:52 - Interior / Cargo ID.4
1:29:41 - Interior / Cargo Mach-E
1:35:44 - Interior / Cargo Model Y
1:42:08 - Efficiency Test
1:49:22 - ADAS
1:53:59 - Final Thoughts / Champion
#ModelY #MachE #ID4
If you liked this video, we recommend checking out some of our other channels!
Out of Spec Motoring: / outofspecmotoring
Out of Spec Reviews: / outofspecreviews
InsideEVs US: / insideevsus

[@monstercameron]

Kyle, you talked for 30 mins straight with what feels like no speaking errors, stutters or a teleprompter, kudos one take man

[@Kopchronicles]

I personally think Kyle is the best Car enthusiast in the world he gives you the most info, at the end of every video you feel you have learnt so much. Also not to be overlooked is he and the team are so hardworking.

[@robadr13]

I noticed that too. He's taken a big leap forward in the last little while in terms of on screen presence - so much information at his fingertips. I think the intensity of the month in Europe really turbo-charged him.

[@doobeone]

@@Kopchronicles i know state of charge because of him

[@danlovaj]

Yes. He’s the best cause his passion and knowledge of all things EV truly shows.

[@NighteeeeeY]

absolutely 100% agree.

[@dannyusanovic2937]

So just to comment on Polestar2 charging curve.I got my 2021 standard AWD in October. Used EA only couple of times (before 1.7 ota updete),and it charged at 150kw steady up to 50% state of charge.Then it slowly tappers of up to 80%. It still pulls 90kw at 80% So in my opinion,charging curve is very good

[@normt430]

And Edmund's testing has the latest version withing about 10% of M3 perf too!

[@brandenflasch]

A feature length film comparing EVs!

[@Megaphonix]

Oh man. 2 hours of EV content? I am so ready!

[@lespaulranger]

i wish tesla would stop marketing their inflated range figures

[@MachE_VLOG]

It was fun to get to see this being made and to have our Mach-E in the video! Great work!

[@KyleConner]

Thanks for all the help! Great to hang out

[@DouginaBoxster]

Tell the truth...were you cringing at the tire squealing?!?!?

[@MachE_VLOG]

@@DouginaBoxster Just a bit!

[@anthonyc8499]

@@KyleConner I've test driven all of them and it's between the base GT and Gradient ID4 all wheel drive for me. 3.8s 0-60 of bouncy fun or German practicality with a roof rack? I need the car that will bring me joy and stay relevant for years. Halp!!!

[@brandenflasch]

@@anthonyc8499 ID.4 AWD

[@kentgabriel3572]

this is probably one of my favorite videos of yours.....very informative...relatively non biased ....and all around fun. Looks like everyone had a great time. 👍🏼

[@Kopchronicles]

I just love this Channel it's the go to for me. I love Kyle's knowledge ,enthusiasm, passion, the dedication to letting us know everything about these cars and the attention to Detail fantastic.

[@Viper989]

Literally the exact 4 vehicles I'm currently cross shopping! Love it

[@Cooper323]

Got myself the Mach E and have not been dissapointed. Best of luck in your search!

[@duze1]

Which one did you end up choosing?

[@evolv.e]

I really love the diversity and seeing more models to choose from with their own flavor and features. Given there’s all have similar range, an equally important consideration is how long do each of these take to charge. The VW, Polestar, and Ford can take up to twice as long compared to the Model Y to add the same amount of energy depending on SOC. Add that the more efficient Tesla goes further on the same amount of energy and it all amounts to less time charging/waiting to charge and a very noticeable difference when traveling away from home. Our family has purchased five EV’s over the last 8 years, and no other brand is as easy or fast to recharge as Tesla’s Supercharging network. I’m not against any non-Tesla, but also know how important it is to be aware of this major difference in charging, before making a major EV purchase. Happy shopping!

[@darkhorse2036]

Mach e GT 100% test that you will love it.

[@dearbulls]

Wow, 2 hours of video? You guys are making a movie. Thumbs up before watching just for the effort you put into it, Kyle. Good job. One addition: I think it's worth mentioning about each of their real-world ground clearance since they all call themselves "SUVs". Thanks to your dad that just measured the ID4 AWD which has 8.2", I believe it is the most suitable "SUV" out of the batch, about 2" taller than its competitors here. And a taller ride also contributes to more consumption (worse mile per kw). But it is probably the only one that I could dare to take to go onto the beach or onto the dirt roads.

[@Igoriann]

Liked it before watching it too!

[@Levonuz]

Dude, because of you and your channel (and your dad of course) I have finally ordered a few weeks ago ID.4 ProS. Great job! Thank you!

[@joemcdonough7509]

Thank you Kyle for this terrific review! I've got a 5 hour flight tomorrow and plan to watch this whole thing! Out of Spec and InsideEV's are easily the best youtube destinations for EV news, reviews and road trips.

[@suvari225]

This video is one of the best videos in this channel. Thanks for the effort to all. It was really fun to watch.

[@klantic2]

This was a great video. Long, but worth hearing about all of these models. Thanks for taking all of your time and effort in making this.

[@ryanplitt7102]

I’ve been waiting for a long time for this video! This will be a big hit! Thank you so much!

[@NorthernL1fe]

Amazing video, with great cars! I've ordered the Polestar, and living in Norway one of the main reasons for me was its winter driving ability. The fact that it is all wheel drive at all times makes it a much safer driving machine in the snow in my opinion :)

[@AtlasAir767CA]

Wow thanks for doing this can't wait to watch the whole video!

[@jps99jps99utube]

This is simply awesome. Very well done. Thanks!

[@Chris-dc7ye]

As a new owner I’m happy to see the polestar getting some votes amongst these crossover it’s definitely more of a sedan than any other vehicle in this comparison.

[@TypeErrorDubs]

Yep, test drove it and the back seats are as small as any sedan I’ve ever been in. Fun car tho!

[@rmflyer1258]

Yea Keep supporting the CCP to build a bigger army to take over you

[@LiberalLoser]

@@rmflyer1258 Yep. Buy American built cars made in USA and eh.......... Mexico and eh .................CHINA!

[@normt430]

There has been update(s) for the Polestar 2 AWD that it now gets similar efficiency as the lower output, FWD P2, according to Edmund's EV range testing.

[@ChristianCantrell]

Thanks for putting so much work into this video. I'm going to look at ID.4s this weekend!

[@conrado800]

ID4 AWD = dream car

[@rzu7120]

Great comparison and feedback from everyone who worked on the video. We appreciate the hard work.

[@claudium1441]

What! It has been 2 hours?! Amazing video! Keep it going!👍

[@PedroBrandaodrums]

Excellent video I got the ID.4 Pro S but in my opinion they all great the more options the better.

[@priddle3392]

Kyle your enthusiasm and dedication to EV knowledge and sharing that with your viewers is awesome. And your Dad did a great job on his personal ID4 comparisons.

[@jalh9080]

Really helpful video. Great to see immediate reactions from car to car.

[@DefStr8up]

Awesome video. Do it again as more models come online! Rivian, Hummer, Lightning, Cybertruck!

[@BrianK04]

With Kyle, the longer the video the better.

[@DougThompson]

@Kyle Conner I believe the Polestar has an efficiency mode, Its called "Range Optimizer". Reason I say this is, I have a Volvo XC40 and it runs on the same 1.7 OTA that was just delivered. It would have been neat if your driver had a moment to find this in the infotainment system (which is very easy to find it) and test using that. It is supposed to make the car a bit more efficient. Not sure if it changes the charging curve, either You or Tom M can test this. Great video as usual!!

[@CraigMatsuura]

Great video review, would love to be able to test drive all of them. Only have driven 2wd versions of the Id.4 and mach-e. Looking for AWD for Utah weather in the winter. AWD is very popular here in the Intermountain West.

[@officialyasir]

Thanks Kyle and team !!! This was great!!

[@jasonblair4057]

Great video and awesome effort on the teams part. 👍👍

[@jeffmelodia2077]

Oh. I forgot to mention how much I appreciate your videos. Thank you and your amazing team.

[@NighteeeeeY]

i havent even heard of you until recently when i saw you on TST podcast and i was blown away by the quality of your content. insane that i have never ever heard of you or seen you before on youtube. and i watch TONS of car content on youtube. very very strange youtube algorithm there. i have watched like 100h of your content over all the different channels over the past few weeks....i absolutely love your in depth content, very very very informed videos, absolutely based opinions on everything, top notch presentation and like...speech...absolutely blown away. 11/10 content. one of the best channels on youtube if youre into electric cars. or just even cars. so happy i found your channels. keep it strong! love you guys. big shoutout to anna and alyssa too. what a bunch! love from germany

[@Bumblerazz]

Love this video! I've been trying to keep track of details between cars through bits and pieces of other vlogers, and this is by far by the best. Incorporates all the important details in one place. Love it. Do more when more cars are released. Want to see comparisons between these and the new Korean offerings.

[@sebrofseven]

hands down the best thorough ev comparison I have ever watched, thank you. I test drove the polestar this morning with the plus and pilot package, wowowow.

[@mshohman]

Thorough, that was really epic, love the passion. Hey, for next vid, how about a real world performance driving comparison of the Y Perf, the GTPE, and the Polestar w/Perf? Take them on some twisties and a hill climb, etc., and see how they stack up, esp over some time, say a morning in the mountains. I think there's a lot of people in the 'entry-level' performance category that would really find it helpful. Cheers!

[@isaacmanagil3195]

YOU ARE one of the best. Without any doubt. You are amazing. Much better than many journalists. ... My future car...? I'm thinking...probably ID4. The confort, space and rolling silence is amazing.

[@culturedfrog7999]

I find it so funny that he mentioned all of the cars door handles EXCEPT for the mustangs, which objectively has the strangest system!

[@kqschwarz]

I don't like the tire squealing stuff on public roads, but besides that this is the best comparison test out there. Plus, Kyle is clearly one of the most knowledgable people on KZbin (he has become the American version of TeslaBjorn). Thank you for a great video.

[@peteradebi9548]

Thank you for putting all of this great content in one video. You could have made half a dozen videos from this!

[@officialyasir]

Just started watching and noticed the video is 2 hours long. Hell yeah!!!

[@agh8459]

Well, I'm still watching the video so I might make some more comments, but as a new owner of a Polestar 2 as of last Thursday I will say that the purchase experience and availability were both excellent. I ordered mine online on 9/20 and picked up 11/4. 2022 Model Year, everything but Performance Package and leather. The whole process was painless and seamless and the only part that felt traditional to your point was going into the dealer to sign the usual paperwork, which was a non-issue as a good chunk of that was government mandated (title, plate application and so on). Beyond that I did get the dealership upsell of wheel, tire and windshield protection which I took as it only slightly increased my monthly payment and with US roads crumbling as badly as they are I figured it wouldn't hurt. All in all, an excellent and simple buying experience that I'd recommend to anyone.

[@leaflover3497]

Did you go to a Volvo dealer or are there actual Polestar dealerships?

[@paulwinter9672]

Great show, thanks.🙂

[@srinyacharya]

This is by far the most thorough and very technical review of EVs ever ! well done and kudos to you for putting all the time and effort. You've got a new subscriber !

[@rabidsquirrel22ben]

Loved the video. Another one these at a slightly higher price point would be awesome! Maybe Mach-E GT, Model Y Performance, E-Tron, and i-Pace?? Idk if I missed any other EV SUVs in the $60-100k range.

[@beautyofgrace3915]

I'm test driving VW.Id4 tomorrow, and hopefully the hyundai ioniq5 soon. Great video!

[@teslafudge1585]

"until you see it next to an *actual* mustang" 😅lol. Awesome breakdown of each. Would add how often Tesla remote updates change vehcile features. None of the others come close, from range to alerts to games to remote sentry mode - none of the others manufacterers come anywhere near close of OTA updates and software improvements.

[@Darclover82]

My car M3LR AWD is a year old. And it’s not the same car it was when I purchased it.

[@doobeone]

stayed for the whole video. nice work guys.

[@kellyblake7250]

Great video! Kyle’s videos are a large reason I considered the ID.4. The test drive was the reason I bought one, even though the nearest Electrify America charger is almost 50 miles from me. I have had my ID.4 3 months and could not be happier!

[@Beanz192]

Test drive a Tesla, you won’t be disappointed.

[@tk6729]

@@Beanz192 I test drove a Tesla. I don't ever want to sit in another one again in any capacity. Not to mention the dated 2016 looks it still has in 2022. You do you.

[@jonbush8950]

My first vid of yours was your LA Auto Show walk through (2021) and now this: I really appreciate the depth and detail! Subscribed!

[@OutofSpecReviews]

Thanks for watching!

[@mho0]

@@OutofSpecReviews I have to say that I claim you guys are a bit responsible that I had to order BST ... greeting from Finland

[@gust9464]

Great video Kyle. So true about some dealerships have no clue about electric cars. I would say Porsche dealers as well. Some have no clue 🤦🏻‍♂️

[@goulash1971]

Great & exhaustive review !!! We’ll done!!

[@backcountryFLcyclist]

Wow! Just a complete video of all four vehicles!

[@volvo_kristian]

Awesome test and video 😎

[@FthePump]

Great reviews and glad we got to see you in Sonoma!

[@JonathanEzor]

I made this decision, and chose the Mach-E (and have ordered a GT). I don't like Tesla interior layout, style or service options, did not want to deal with the Polestar service experience and smaller storage capacity, and the id.4 is not the driver's car I wanted. I have a great local Ford dealer, the Mach-E had my favorite interior layout and functioning, and even the GT (non-Performance Edition, which is what I chose) gets 270 miles of range with a sub-4 second 0-60. Regardless, though, I'm thrilled U.S. buyers finally have *choice* (with more to come) of EVs in this segment!

[@MrOktsx]

I was seriously considering the Model Y. But after a year of price increases, a Bill that might make it a "wash" and a ridiculous wait for a Tesla, Kyle has me swayed toward the VW.

[@jimji2774]

Yes they have now made available a power upgrade download for the Polestar giving it over 500 hp. I look forward to seeing a test of it soon. I need to drive a couple trim levels of this vehicle to see how I like it. Really like the regen adjustability of the Kia EV6 with the paddle shifters though and wish other vehicles had them.

[@nolebucnaround8350]

Love the Polestar 2. I think it’s the best blend of all of the things I look for in an EV. Performance, tech, range, build quality and style.

[@Telhmaaa]

Only thing it needs is dealerships that can help when i breaks down, and good customer support.

[@normt430]

@@Telhmaaa that's what Volvo dealerships are for. The Polestar Space is just for ordering and delivery.

[@Telhmaaa]

@@normt430 I know, but i had a polestar that had some trouble, was 16 times in the Volvo dealership. And they just can't do a thing. Everything need to be comunicated with the Polestar headquarters, and if you have a problem, they say. you need to talk with Polestar. we are just a service center. we can not help. it is annoying as f. good when everything is fine. but not good when you have troubles. I sold my Polestar just because of that. lost sadly enough 10,000€ on that sale :(

[@fmartin59]

@@Telhmaaa sad too hear. No dealership near you? Where you at?

[@BovDrives]

I’m saving this video for everyone. Really good to see the differences and show that tesla isn’t the only dog in the game, but also for doubters of EVs. Tesla fan myself but I can appreciate its advantages of nitpicking disadvantages

[@evolv.e]

16:50 “it’s all about the charging” - agreed 💯

[@MisterNatel]

Excellent video… congratulations.. personally I love the Mach e

[@stangmatt66]

1:51:48 Sorry Patrick is wrong. All non-GT Mustang Mach-Es come standard with CoPilot 360 Assist 2.0 which has hands-on adaptive cruise control with lane centering, Ford’s version of Autopilot. Hands-free BlueCruise requires an optional prep package on Select trim that is standard on CA-1, Premium, and First Edition trims

[@MachE_VLOG]

Sorry about that. Thanks for the update.

[@markfitzpatrick6692]

Kyle your parents are smart. Dave and Kathy have been doing great with the videos. He has had a lot of id4’s I bet Dave has charging under control. I’m 57 and have no problems. I don’t need a Tesla I can use the others fine for 6.5 years.

[@ScottLeapman]

At the end of the day, there are now many great choices for an EV based on what you prioritize. I chose the Polestar 2 and couldn't be happier, but go with any of these EVs (or the many others that are coming out soon) and you'll probably not regret it.

[@odisy64]

@De A teslas have the most durable motors and batteries, ill take that over a car with perfect panel gaps.

[@vjhicks8533]

Nice. I’m planning to test drive a Polestar 2 next week. What configuration did you go with?

[@ScottLeapman]

@@vjhicks8533 I drive a Moon 2021 Launch Edition (dual motor long range with Pilot and Plus packs) with the Barley leather, standard wheels and no Performance Pack. No regrets, although I do wish I could have the gold seatbelts ;-)

[@seanplace8192]

I'm mostly looking between the ID.4 and MY. The latter really depends on if the price drops next year, or if I can find a good deal on a used one. The ID.4 is such a good value. My only gripe with it is the lack of a front-trunk. It's the perfect spot to place things like toolkits and the portable EVSE. That way your cargo isn't in the way if you need to grab those things.

[@daved217]

Good video, good work.

[@Runtythestar]

Quite possibly the best EV video ever by anyone. You excitingly touched upon all of the things that many of us want to know.

[@3811eric]

And Ioniq comes out top!!!

[@777Outrigger]

Kris Rifa just got 144 kw charging to 40% in his Polestar 2 after the P1.7 OTA update.The temp was 3 degrees C, or 36 degrees F. He said the preheating prior-to-charging upgrade gave him a better speed than his Tesla Model 3 in the same temp. Things are changing fast.

[@ShermanMR2]

Very nice aerial footage. What drone are you guys using?

[@DH-xp5bg]

I just cross shopped the same 4 vehicles and ended up with the Polestar 2. Earliest delivery and much better lease rates than the Model Y or Mach-E.

[@Chris-dc7ye]

Me too… did you get the 2021?

[@brandenflasch]

Interesting to hear the Polestar leases well

[@DH-xp5bg]

@@Chris-dc7ye Yep

[@prolibra72]

Loved this vlog! I'm a rideshare driver that's thinking about buying my first ev car for work and I'm leaning towards VW's ID 4!

[@doThatGWalk]

I think for rideshare, ID 4 would be a pretty good deal because I've heard someone that got a really good deal with the dealer as well as tax credits + the free Electric Gas from electricity America. That would make your cost go down a lot since it's 3 years free.

[@randy2558]

Will be awesome when the Q4, Ioniq 5, EV6, and Ariya are included too. Looking forward to the 4 hour review next year! 🤣

[@Darclover82]

Why do I feel that the Ariya will not hold its own when released. It’s like Nissan is always holding itself back. Like swimming with bricks tied to its feet.

[@randy2558]

The other issue is the Ariya was shown WAY before the Hyundai/Kia ev's were even previewed. Now those vehicles are already on the streets and Ariya is still vaporware. By the time it's actually sold Nissan will be way behind and playing catch-up. Hell, bz4x and solterra might be out before Ariya at this rate.

[@Darclover82]

@@randy2558 agreed. How are they the first to market with a full BEV but have not come to market with any follow up models. And barely revised the leaf second gen. It’s just a pain to watch. And let’s not get started on Toyota. The Prius line has been on the market for 22 years in America and they are still playing catch-up.

[@theyoutubegeek7493]

Charging curve after 1.7 update is almost better than Tesla now!

[@davidmortensen4905]

Great review

[@alanhold2468]

Very cool. And looks like you all had a great time. Wish I could have been there in my Zoe gt line. 🇬🇧🙏👊

[@danmason7]

Any full review of the BMW i4 and comparison versus the Polestar 2 coming guys? Loving your reviews!

[@nathanlinares5503]

can't wait for kyle and the team to get their hands on ioniq 5 and ev6!

[@johnreeves7261]

Thank you for such a thorough review of these electric cars.

[@zerozzZzz]

Love our vw awd id4. Looks nice at night as well. Would be nice to see bmw ix or Audi e-tron.

[@mikesablarry]

I ordered the VW ID4, mainly because it's the cheapest, and the charging is still amazing on that car! And I just love the look of the car.

[@ll2k89]

Quality video! Suscribed

[@silentjohn80]

Thank you for an awesome video! I've actually newly ordered the Polestar 2, but not the dual motor - I went for the standard range single motor. I almost never need to fastcharge, so I felt I'd rather save some money (the standard range charges slower than long range, which might be important if you often need to use DC charging - it's not very important to me). I ordered both the Plus and Pilot packs, though.

[@thomaseriksson3182]

Thanks for this👍 like the Polestar 2 best😎✌️

[@bignamek]

Where was this filmed? When you're talking in the beginning it feels like around Morrison (mt falcon?), and when driving seems like it might be around/through Deer Creek Canyon. Driving me nuts! Lol Also very good reviews!

[@zachnilsson4682]

I'm loving my Polestar 2!

[@adamrfletcher]

Just a heads up Kyle - Ford has a new subscription thing they are rolling out for EA that will charge you $2 more a year than just subscribing to EA but it is 12 months pre-paid and works with Ford Plug and Charge. So $2 penalty to just have Plug and Charge but good I guess if someone wants to pay for that convenience. PS: Thanks for these great videos. Best EV dude on YT.

[@Strength_CoachHQ]

Polestar 2 👌

[@billnipp2309]

My 2018 Model 3, I was backing out of a parking spot and was flanked by tall pick-up trucks. As im backing up a car was speeding thru the lot. The model 3 not only beeped but it jammed on the brakes and went into park. It flashed a message on the screen but diasspeared before I could read it. ty

[@jagopr]

That’s a great video. Next year a comparo with Ionioq5 and Kia EV6

[@toddmonahan3369]

Great video

[@dimitarhadjiev8666]

NICE REVIEW,

[@rod2625]

Looking for next vehicle to replace 2013 X3. Being retired not looking for high performance. Really liking the ID4 but will wait for them to adapt LFP batteries and increase their charging rate.

[@raydoherty5419]

Wonderful video! I truly believe anyone shopping for any of these cars as a first time EV buyer should spend a few days watching Kyle’s review videos and especially hid road trips videos, you will learn so much about the ownership experience. Hope your channels keep doing amazing!!!

[@michaelkelleyjr.2605]

Feb. 12th 2022 Thank you for your informative input about the New Electric cars and SUVs Although Nobody has given US price Quote about how much it CO$T too, charge your Electric car and SUV That is most important & goes along with a person’s overall budget if they have ONE! Electric car or SUV…

[@leaflover3497]

I’m just glad that all four of these EVs are now available for sale in the US. Seems like it’s been a long time coming. A neighbor just bought the Mustang and loves it. We bought a Model Y and have never regretted our decision.

[@kenstreet1769]

Great review, If I may make a suggestion? if you make a script card! The Dollar store has 3 feet x 2 feet card write out script with a sharpie. Then you can stay on track easier vs adding in "Oh by the Way" and "Oh ya, We'll go back to that later in this video" all the time.

[@zonemaster23]

What a great video to wake up too.

[@JookySeaCpt]

I dislike that Tesla keeps raising the price on the Model Y without notice. They've done it several times over the past month.

[@bboiikid23]

High demand, needed to slow down. They know people are buying them