we watched the Mamma Mia movies WITH A LIVE AUDIENCE (w/ Matt Bennett)

[@booktales1687]

The audience cheering for the cameos like they’re the Avengers is the reason I love this channel

[@miserablemarie]

well Sky is the young Howard Stark. I was hoping some Iron Man joke would appear at some point lol

[@RyanBohringer]

I got to be there live with my brother it was so much fun 😂

[@Evanz111]

It reminds me of that viral video of the cinema crowd erupting with cheers when Einstein appeared in Oppenheimer, like he was Tony Stark or something 😂

[@gilliancooper2720]

The reveal of Meryl Streep being dead at the beginning of the second movie is truly hilarious.

[@milo-ru3hc]

I literally GASPED in the theatre I was so upset lmao 🤣

[@COSun25]

That was the worst thing the writers could've done.

[@tdsm99]

@@COSun25 she doesnt do sequels remember

[@namecomingsoon9517]

@@tdsm99 i mean she is still in the movie

[@infinitylord1524]

700th like

[@rebs_bebs]

What's hilarious is that meryl streep has said she wants to come back for Mamma Mia 3 and I hope they just act like she never died

[@turnipcrazy]

I guess she could try to play Donna raising Sophie or we could get a secret twin to show up. Considering in the first movie they insinuated that Donna's mom was dead and then the sequel Cher plays her mom, it's not out of the ballpark of possibilities.

[@rivershaley]

that would be so funny and a retcon i’d fully support

[@hxrleydxrling9662]

i mean they forgot about donna’s mother being dead and had cher come in so.

[@rebs_bebs]

@hxrleydxrling9662 to be fair it was a throwaway line for cher in the first one, not a huge plot point that is the catalyst to the entire movie for Meryl. That being said no one would care and theyd love it 😂

[@beckmannm]

I'm hoping for "Mamma Mia III: Thank You For The Music" where it is revealed the god Apollo is actually Sophie's father, and so she journeys to the underworld to bring her mother back!!!

[@bragonitos]

"IT'S CHER" hits like the Falcon saying "on your left"

[@urfriendhannah]

Hate to be that guy but… Cher*

[@taylor1983]

"stop stop stop they're playing waterloo!!" is officially registered in my lexicon

[@benstin]

I love the sequel for what it is, but it's funny as hell to me that they made one of the best songs from the original -- which was a curtain call song -- the worst song in the sequel

[@asantepauwels]

Me at the bar with any ABBA song

[@cryptidferrets]

Stellan Skarsgard has like FIVE whole sons that are also actors the fact they couldn't get any of them to play his younger self in Mamma Mia 2 is /wild/ to me.

[@verazetrazz8677]

One of them is literally named Bill too

[@sybilpv638]

None of them really sing though. I can't picture Pennywise belting out to ABBA's greatest hits😂

[@brynniefresh9746]

with peace and love none of them are as attractive as the guy who played young bill…also none of his kids are singers, i’m pretty sure, so that’s probably a big reason

[@Quzga]

Alexander and Stellan are so cute together, they're so similar in personality lol

[@asantepauwels]

​@@sybilpv638 I'm so dumb some times ,reading your comment made me realize that he's Bill skarsgard is his son. Mind blown

[@EthalaRide]

I feel like the dad division is pretty good. Bill is the one Sophie relates to the most and is probably her biological father, Sam is the one Donna wants to be with, and Harry is the one who is the most fulfilled actually BEING a father spiritually.

[@aliciabergman1252]

That’s beautifully put😊

[@QuinnPixel]

i agree plus she’s like set for life sophie is never gonna have to worry about money again lol

[@chi_pucca_chi]

Having Matt Bennett scream at the the top of his lungs “ITS CHER” is the highlight of my life

[@alexeifiore8573]

my favorite part of the second movie is how cher’s character gave absolutely no fucks that her daughter was dead. she showed up to that funeral for a hookup 💀

[@Courtesyflush52]

Also the fact that Cher is only three years older than Meryl Streep

[@j24030]

also the fact that its said donna's mother is dead in the first movie

[@kyleeren]

​@@j24030WHEN

[@kyleeren]

​@@j24030WHEN

[@gilliancooper2720]

Meryl Streep being on the poster of Mamma Mia! 2 and her not even being in the movie is wild.

[@MissMillsonxx]

She is in it for the last song and then she participates in the after credits song so TECHNICALLY it's not a lie lol.

[@toitsuii]

meryl streep CLICKBAIT

[@Tannerj50]

@@toitsuii Meryl Streepbait

[@brynniefresh9746]

she is in the movie she’s just only in it for like three minutes coz it’s for one song

[@DPadGamer]

The sad-twerk-along for Rent was so much fun, great to see Matt Bennett back again :D

[@milo-ru3hc]

“stop, stop, STOP!! THEY’RE PLAYING WATERLOO”

[@LacTheWatcher]

The Cher reveal to this crowd and the trio was a truly amazing moment

[@shubbuby39]

can we talk about how in the first Mamma Mia Donna says her mom is dead and in the second movie they decided to ignore that and cast a very alive Cher

[@wehaveadarkside]

i dont think anyone loves mamma mia for being "a good movie" we just want to have fun singing abba with meryl, colin, stellan and pierce and have no thoughts for two hours and thats why is one of my favorite movies since i was a kid

[@cranberryrosebud]

I will say this until the end, there is above-decent musical directing in this movie. Multiple numbers either have cool choreography or move the characters around the set, there’s a constant flow, and that’s what you give an ABBA musical - I don’t see the need for much more; although, as a bonus, the cast has great chemistry imo

[@stephaniefrost4910]

100%! It’s summertime vibes in a movie and such a fun movie musical

[@katierasburn9571]

@@cranberryrosebud its all just fun and the way th songs are acted reflects that, lots of movement and colour and silliness, its great. it understood its assignment perfectly

[@erintingley2403]

ARE YOU KIDDING MAMA MIA?! The way all the actors were literally drunk the whole filming. Iconic.

[@klaraf.b.9820]

the second movie really didn't need to be made but that doesn't mean it's not one of the most incredible cinematic experiences of this century

[@fatoumatacisse3796]

I enjoyed the second movie just as much as the first movie I liked getting to know more of donna’s background and meeting the three dads in the second movie

[@katierasburn9571]

@@fatoumatacisse3796 and the actors thy chose for young donna and the dads were so good and had great chemistry too, just like the ogs in the first!

[@EthalaRide]

Everyone going feral for Cher's helicopter entrance knowing the boys wouldn't see it coming

[@booktales1687]

The cut from Meryl Streep showing up and Matt Bennett walking away is the funniest editing I’ve ever seen 😭

[@ToastKnight_]

"Mama mia! I how can I RESISTANCE!!!" Eric Strifler....some year

[@rivershaley]

that quote is so embedded into my mind that every time i hear that song i only think of “how can i RESISTANCE”

[@archiermanilo23]

thought i was the only one

[@lucynosbisch]

Okay say what you will about Mamma Mia two, but the “my love my life” scene made me cry my eyes out

[@Chitownreader]

I literally started crying as soon as the scene was shown in this video 😂

[@bubleous]

i adore the parallel of how alone donna was during sophie's christening was vs how all full of friends and family sophie's child's was

[@alluraaltea]

the first time i watched mamma mia 2 i had a full breakdown, sobbing and all when meryl’s ghost showed up in the baptism basin

[@kores5324]

SAME

[@pastajade]

SAME

[@gilliancooper2720]

"Does anyone else think that the credits should have rolled 20 minutes ago?" Miles is saying what we're all thinking.

[@jerryfromtheblock6463]

2:42 Mamma Mia being set in greece despite how easy it would be to just do the same on some italian island is something i never thought about and will now forever associate with the movie . not making it in sweden makes absolute sense but come on if you go Mediterranean why greece and not italy?

[@mfitzburger5137]

Because Greece is the place that was a trendy honeymoon spot in the 2010s, while Italy had lost most of it's sparkle through the Jersey Shore era.

[@jerryfromtheblock6463]

@@mfitzburger5137 damn that actually makes stupid capitalist sense

[@katierasburn9571]

@@mfitzburger5137 also greece has a reputation for being cheap, hnce donna's ability to run away, buy a run-down hotel and barely manage to pay for it, whereas italy by contrast has a reputation for luxury and being expensive, just my thought

[@jerryfromtheblock6463]

This movie is great and all but my favorite piece of media with a full abba soundtrack will forever be that community halloween episode where everybody turns to zombies while the deans ipod is playing his abba playlist on repeat over the loudspeakers

[@kores5324]

I've never had any interest in watching Community..... until now, I will watch it just to get to that episode

[@BlackParade727]

I watched all of community years ago and loved it but every so often I'll hear an episode description and be like "...what?" Absolutely zero recollection of that 😂

[@the.realjimboslice]

was searching the comments for this!

[@fabra1122]

​@@BlackParade727 same 😅 I watched it like three times but am always flabbergasted when someone mentiond a plot line haha

[@SakuraTheShadow]

The Stellan to Stellar transition was immaculate

[@nicholasdeporto5257]

“It’s a twerk along” *audience cheers I love this channel

[@brynniefresh9746]

i wish that they actually made harry a little more metal looking in the sequel coz it would’ve been cute if he was like this rocker who’s got the same sweet demeanor

[@kodarpy]

My favorite thing is all three of them not being aware that Meryl Streep doesn’t do sequels

[@Jlboynes]

Well apparently she's doing The devil wears Prada 2 😆

[@archerdork7116]

This movie is truly horrendous in terms of plot, execution and character development, but by god I always ugly cry the whole way through My Love, My Life. Best moment in the whole franchise, I bow to thee.

[@indigo8632]

crying laughing at “THAT’S MERYL! THAT’S MAMMA!”

[@rowanfraser7177]

Mamma Mia 2 made everyone including me sob at the cinema. I’d never sobbed with 40 year old plus ladies before but I recommend it

[@swamprat6666]

Original creators confirmed Bill (Stellan!) is Sophie’s bio dad! 😊

[@tofanpurnomowaisaka503]

Makes sense, I think if the brown haired & eyed men was her dad she'll inherit their hair & eye color.

[@Harrison_Furman]

Matt Bennett!? The crossover I never knew I needed

[@toadt0ad]

there’s a twerk along for rent with him too :p

[@Reecef266]

He's been on before. Great to have him back!

[@Treyman-yi7ei]

He did a commentary about Rent with them before too

[@Harrison_Furman]

@@Reecef266 I had no idea until now! I’ve been watching PMI for like 10 years now so I’ll go through spurts of not watching them as much. Makes perfect sense why him and would get along well

[@mothumn]

“It was stellar” needs more appreciation

[@marianalopes9526]

the mamma mia movies exist on a different plane of existence none of us can ever hope to touch, and yet... the joyous whimsy and wondrous glee surround me each time i watch these movies

[@JetsFittedUp]

I feel like I manifested this with the sheer amount of ABBA I've been listening to.

[@mariahjmcsweeney]

i’ve been excited to see the helicopter reveal in a highlight vid since being at the show two years ago that was so funny live lmao!!!! so glad this one got the youtube treatment so i can rewatch it 1000000 times now 💝

[@dillonbarrett5108]

gave my mom acid and can confirm she said it was nothing like mama Mia

[@-laetiqueta-8474]

The first time I saw the second movie, I thought Meryl Streep had actually died, and they made the movie as a tribute for her or something and her appearance was old footage...

[@PrettyMuchIt]

LOL

[@KSmith-kp5jz]

Matt Bennett and Mamma Mia feels right. Clicked immediately.

[@teleytubby]

That scream for "IT'S CHER!!!!" sent me to the moon

[@sunlightlotus]

"She's like Ash Ketchum" Miles singlehandedly decimated me with that line LMFAO

[@StevieMcKenna10]

So happy to see Matt again, the Rent twerk along was such a vibe, and now so is the break dancing

[@megscribner]

I love that I enjoyed each of these guys in their separate endeavors (PMI, TryGuys, and DJing) and they happen to be friends who are so funny together

[@PokhrajRoy.]

The title is EVERYTHING 😂 Amanda Seyfried created a specific niche in ‘Looking for people in Europe’ with this and ‘Letters to Juliet’.

[@Thephantom95]

OMG, i remember being at the New York show for Mamma Mia 2 and just like the NY show for SAW, it was just fucking fantastic, Eric. The additions of Miles and Matt FUCKING Bennett waa legendary to say the least. Also, that Meryl Streep and Cher reactions in the second one was literally the equivalent of the portal scene from Avengers Endgame, even down to us cheering and losing our shit. LMAO

[@kerobop]

As someone who watched these live recordings on the Patreon last year, I'm ecstatic that more people get to see your guys's reactions to this Kafkaesque double feature of jukebox musical jumpscares guest starring Cher.

[@Ignore-this2121]

This felt like some sort of cult gathering in the best way

[@Sjp977]

This movie is really just about Meryl’s hot girl summer she had in the 70s

[@chlorinesoda]

One of my mom’s favorite movie was Mama Mia , it’s safe to say I cried like a baby during the second one. This will forever be her movie , and now one of my favorites. Edit : I’m at the end of the video and I am once again in tears

[@MissMillsonxx]

The last scene with Donna watching her granddaughter being baptised while singing that her daughter was her love and her life is so beautiful. Every time I watch that movie I am a wreck by the end.

[@krystle4585]

Stop a live watch party of this is so fun 😭 love mamma mia

[@yemidotcom]

Lmaoo I remember seeing you guys do this live. Hilarious!!!

[@PrettyMuchIt]

thanks for comin out to the show!

[@gilliancooper2720]

The amount of videos that Pretty Much It has been churning out lately is my favorite thing. :)

[@namecomingsoon9517]

7:06 PEOPLE DON’T THINK HE’S GOOD?! THIS WAS ONE OF MY FAVORITE SONGS IN THE MOVIE I LOVE HIS VOICE SINGING IT

[@PrettyMuchIt]

PREACH!!!!!

[@liyahlondon582]

YES MINE TOO I WAS SO CONFUSED?!?!🚴

[@benstin]

The boys might have decided the second movie should not have been made, but it's a beautiful trip and experience that could never otherwise be replicated

[@Quzga]

As a Swede this movie is religious to us. My mom references it weekly lmao

[@PrettyMuchIt]

🙏🏼

[@piperjohnson1412]

Calling her mama the entire second movie literally has me on the floor. Don’t slut shame mama 😭😭😭😂😂😂😂

[@jackalexande]

"I'd like to see you get in her way" WAS SO GOOD LMAO

[@Avocado11]

Went to the LA show, was an incredible amount of fun. Strange that "Lay All Your Love On Me" which was the best part of the entire show didn't get a clip in this.

[@annar.70]

As someone who loves Mamma Mia so much she's played Rosie, Donna, and Sophie (x3) on stage I'm so sad I wasn't here for this omg

[@DanyelleDarko]

17:22 I thought Eric and Miles were bowing to Cher but they were folding over in laughter 😂

[@namecomingsoon9517]

One of my favorite musicals maybe my favorite. I was so happy when i saw the sequel in theaters. It made me so emotional. Seeing older Donna in the chapel and singing in the crowd was just breaking me

[@rikissik]

for a second, I was like "OH MY GOD I WAS AT THIS SHOW" then I realized i was at your NY show and watched mamma mia 2 with you guys! hahah but the commentary track for this one was so fun!

[@PrettyMuchIt]

that’s the second half of the vid!

[@rikissik]

@@PrettyMuchIt alright i just finished the video, god damn, talk about reliving that trip of a movie from a different pov! thank you for coming to ny!

[@scorpioson564]

i've been waiting for this one!!!!! some of my favourite commentary tracks - i once woke up my mom at 2am because i was laughing and singing along too hard to these lmao

[@ginabell694]

I went to see it with my mom and her mom. They fangirled over Pierce Brosnan the whole time. Lol

[@christophermcdonnell8809]

Ever since you uploaded the short of Matt dancing through the crowd I’ve been waiting for this highlight! What a video! What energy! I hope one day you do a London show.

[@godai6203]

MATT IS BACK BABY!

[@Man310Reaper]

I was so happy to be in the audience for this show. So mad the LA saw show sold out before I could get a ticket

[@enbytoon]

Oh my gosh I’ve been WAITING for this highlight reel, I remember the Mamma Mia so well, can’t wait to see yall again in August!

[@OurEnbyOfTheUnderground69]

HELP IM GETTING FLASH BACKS OF BEING FORCED TO DO MAMMA MIA IN MY CATHOLIC SCHOOL

[@Blackkey034]

Omg how traumatic damnnnn

[@booktales1687]

That’s so wild considering bedding before marriage 😭

[@bubleous]

my school did it too but they had them change harry's character from being gay to being a priest 😭

[@loganchitty]

14:55 “IS THAT EARTH???” Oh I WISH this was like that Goosebumps episode where it’s revealed all the characters are aliens about to head to earth

[@vickylandry51]

You and Miles are always absolutely freaking hilarious together 😂 Matt is lots of fun too

[@stephaniefrost4910]

2:44 I mean…Matt has a point 😂 this is one of my favorite movies to rewatch in the summer and I never thought about that!

[@ericaj1699]

I NEED more twerk alongs! Grease, Into the Woods, Phantom of The Opera. I need it all!

[@Catawampus105]

No one reacting to Matt Bennett saying Qu'est-ce que c'est was so sad when he did such a good reference

[@chillysmeg]

i’ve been waiting for this for YEARS

[@thingusbingus8181]

I hereby petition that there should be an annual Matt Bennett twerk-a-long.

[@michaelbateman2563]

Eric, miles and Matt Bennett is literally a perfect lineup

[@hbk15111]

One of the funnest videos I’ve ever seen!

[@PrettyMuchIt]

so glad you enjoyed!

[@MartialKaiju98]

I literally watched this movie for the first time with a friend a few days ago! What a timely upload for me!

[@toriecarter2711]

One of my favorite movie theater experiences was seeing Mamma Mia! It was the midnight showing, when those were a real thing, and we walked past the massive line for The Dark Knight to enter our theater packed with mostly women & a few guys. And it was amazing~~~ We all confirmed ahead of time, as we chatted before trailers rolled, that we were all okay with singing and dancing, and we just unapologetically all enjoyed ourselves^.^ Funny enough, the most similar experience I had was seeing Burlesque in theaters!~

[@needyverse]

17:35 The following 10 seconds are some of the greatest I have ever seen

[@sblol]

holy shit this video is made for me. the rent commentary is my fav video and MATT IS BACK FOR MAMMA MIA!!!

[@linneaconnery3828]

AHHH ive been waiting for the commentary track to happen for YEARS

[@Intrusivemov]

Dream to one day see a live show from yall, love this video!!

[@PrettyMuchIt]

glad you enjoyed the vid, hope to see ya at a show someday!

[@LeenaAbdelghani]

I literally thought the same all the way from Africa. still hoping tho!!

[@louvelvet]

so happy to see miles back on the channel !!!! he always has me in tears lmao

[@caleblim6890]

“Mamma Mia is ACID for MOMS” is one of the weirdest and most accurate things I’ve ever heard

[@katelinhanke3636]

Me and my bestie were there and it was such a blast! The guys not knowing Cher was coming and then her avengers level appearance was legendary!!

[@antoniacosta6221]

IVE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS VIDEO FOR YEARS THANK YOU ERIC

[@alfredopasta218]

I mean.... I only accept the lore that Donna died because she didn't know how to swim -help, i saw both of these IN THE THEATER-

[@benstin]

5:53 "I wanna see this live now" Can confirm seeing Mamma Mia live is a fucking blast

[@Maddogdevon]

Was thinking literally this morning “I wonder if I’ll ever be blessed with a Mamma Mia highlight video”, clearly Eric heard my wish thank you king

[@ashleyluna6683]

It’s not a musical reaction if there isn’t a twerk along 😂 love this channel so much

[@terroglacier981]

I WAS AT THE LA SHOW! It was so fun, and I’m so glad it’s now forever for viewing pleasure

[@lucygarrett9785]

I have been binging your videos all day and now you've posted, this is fantastic

[@connerolmedo888]

IVE BEEN WAITING FOR MANY YEARS FOR THIS

[@chanelchannel8318]

I went to see this show and it was AMAZING. I had so much fun, can't wait to see y'all in LA again in August!

[@PrettyMuchIt]

WOOOOO see ya there!!

[@mariaharrington8101]

I love watching this commentary’s on Patreon! I love this highlight vid too!!

[@emmacook5658]

5:45 wasn’t this movie based off ABBA songs? So that might be why it’s low key insane lmao