Badflower - She Knows (Lyric Video)

[@111babybean]

Yes, it's supposed to end like that for artistic purpose. It follows the storyline of the song and ends abruptly and unfinished just like the relationship and as predicted throughout. She knows and she out....he knew too! 🖤

[@odddevil9535]

it ends abruptly and the next song on the album starts with "calm down"

[@111babybean]

@@odddevil9535 Exactly like the relationship after she finds out he cheated and lied about it. He knew she would leave too which is what he was afraid of throughout the song. The next song, Only Love, is what he’s going through after she left. It all makes sense including the abrupt unfinished ending of She Knows.

[@EmilPiano]

Is that your assumption or was it confirmed by the band? I really wish it faded out when the song abruptly ends

[@111babybean]

@@EmilPiano As far as I know it hasn’t been actually confirmed but it does make logical sense considering the lyrics of the song and the song that follows, Only Love, in which she has left him. I did see an interview where Josh said they left some imperfections on the album but even if this was one of them it had to be purposely left because it works with the theme. They are no longer some garage band making their first demo on their own, there is no way a mistake like that ending winds up on all streaming platforms, KZbin, the cd, etc., unless they wanted it there. They could’ve easily redone it if they wanted.

[@odddevil9535]

@@EmilPiano oh just my assumption

[@riaingalligan8461]

Why is no one talking about Joeys solo? It’s so good

[@jadefreeburg445]

All of Badflower's songs are so relatable and deep

[@ghostlyrobert]

Yeah especially stalker! 💀

[@michaelchristy506]

badflower has so many relatable songs.... but if this song is relatable to you i think you need to learn how to not cheat my guy

[@beezybeez6285]

This is so good but you must hear “Winding Road” or “Live Not Survive” by SLT 🤘🐺

[@PascalNeem]

@@michaelchristy506josh confirmed himself that this song is actually about a simple breakup. I still think it’s about cheating, especially when you take a lyric like “I’m faithful I swear” into consideration. But perhaps it could mean that he’s lying about still loving her rather than cheating. I’m not sure! I think the song can have multiple meanings.

[@Llamania13]

Listening to it in the dark and the whole atmosphere changes, suddenly getting chills in a good way. The melody is perfectly balanced with the vocals (which are a haunting in a melancholy way) This whole album is making me cry but mostly this song right here 💙

[@robertlidy1059]

The " I caved" and the " Now she knows" hits so hard wtf

[@kelb7350]

This song gives me such late 90's, early 2000's vibes. Also feels like a song that would play in a movie, either at the sad part or as we go into the credits.

[@aubriehanson3264]

The easy read is that this is about cheating, but there are subtle hints that it might be something else…unless saying he’s been faithful is also a lie. The song is hauntingly beautiful and unnerving in its mystery, especially with the abrupt end.

[@mikesullivan7911]

Drugs. Does she know that he's still using heroin.

[@SyairaziSunarto]

@@mikesullivan7911 Correct. I could relate 100% of his lyrics, and women's instinct it's always.... it's hard to explain.. but my wife recently told me that she knows everything.. she knows the truth.. she knows all my lies.. yet she kept it deep in her heart.. now, guess how I react as a person who's actually paranoid and afraid that she'll leave me.. I told her more lies.. there goes the confusion, after that last lie I told her.. She smiled.. She said, she's about to teach me a lesson.. It was 5 months ago after she kicked me out of the house.. Last week she texted, I'm going to have a second son this december.. She said that I might never change... so she knows, that I can't change.. Drugs..

[@savannahsorensen2184]

I think its more about how he doesn't really love her but he doesn't want to be the one to leave out of guilt. She figures it out and is upset and he ends up feeling guilty anyway. I could be wrong but that's what i get from it.

[@savannahsorensen2184]

Wait i just read the comments 🤦‍♀️ that sounds more accurate

[@jackalack5799]

Agreed! I think it would have been even better at the end of the record though. The silence that follows when I listen to it on here (Auto-play is off) makes it all the more haunting. Side note: I did think something was wrong with my album so that's how I came to be here haha

[@StarlingCraftyghoul]

God his voice is so freakin' beautiful and emotional

[@dennisevega2307]

I still have a screen recording from December 2019 of Josh teasing this song because I fell in love with the like 8 seconds that I heard of it and it’s finally out!

[@baddiekaori1305]

Omg

[@talonslipper4182]

I wonder how likely they would be to dmca you if you posted it....

[@EmilPiano]

This album is so damn pure in everything. Badflower you are the literal best. I wish to meet you one day

[@baddiekaori1305]

Theyre on tour

[@baddiekaori1305]

@Cassandra Lavalley awwww/; yeah i hsf to legit beg my mom and ask her help with the moneh ti pay it but maybe next time youll get to dang he lives in tenesse tho nashville craaaaazy tho

[@GuyPaddock]

They are great on tour! Just saw them in New Haven

[@mariobrenes4264]

The feeling I get from these reminds me of MCR

[@baddiekaori1305]

Oh true ty for thus

[@SS-rr7by]

Not at all

[@darrenXparker]

If this isn’t a hit, I don’t know what a “hit” is anymore. 🤷🏼‍♂️

[@jadedecay9592]

The rawness makes my skin crawl... The pure emotion is amazingly bittersweet..

[@Adi-StraightFromLaughtale]

IDK What to say... all the songs are so good.. and they all wanna make me hug someone!!!

[@SquixHD]

4:26 the lead guitar here gives me I don't love you - MCR vibes

[@auri2969]

Why does the song end so abruptly tho. That confuses me immensely. I came here cuz I thought Spotify made a mistake but it appears that it ends that way on purpose. Still an amazing song tho🥲❤️

[@anavybluemystery3486]

yeah it confused me too

[@its.savannahhhh]

My thoughts exactly!

[@lu8440]

SAME i thought the app had shut down or something bc it does that to me a lot

[@sobefreckles]

Glad I’m not the only one. I almost reported it to Spotify 😂

[@111babybean]

Apparently it's on the cd too therefore even if it was originally a mistake it was definitely kept for artistic purpose. It follows the storyline of the relationship and ends abruptly and unfinished as predicted in the song. She knows and she out....he knew too! 🖤

[@laribiamani5431]

{LYRICS} She's crying I feel the tension's rising Inside I'm scheming Anything to stop her leaving Does she know my secret? Did someone leak it? Sometimes I get scared But I'm faithful, I swear I've made mistakes But I know I can change Still I lay awake 'Cause I lied to her face Does she know? Does she know? We made up She still put on her makeup And we go out dancing She doesn't smile or call me handsome She gives me silence Her energy like violence She loves me truly But she looks right through me I've made mistakes But I know I can change Still I lay awake 'Cause I lied to her face Does she know? Does she know? And I wonder How long I'll keep this from her I hate these secrets But as long as she believes it We'll stay happy and together I can't lie forever I've made mistakes And she knows I can't change All the truths I've faked When she cried I caved Now she knows Now she knows Now she knows Now she knows She knows, oh Now she knows Now she knows Now she knows Now she knows Now she knows Source: Musixmatch

[@ChosenoneEDP44]

Do i even have to say it:((( Mother mary on spotify pls🙏

[@thanosfromfortnite9186]

PLEAAAAASE

[@haylspallett4046]

Made me giggle! Love mother Mary!

[@bryndows]

Josh your voice is angelic but you can switch that in a heartbeat it's amazing. This album is amazing you guys are all incredible

[@BadflowerUruguay]

i just listened to the whole album on spotify, and this one is so beautiful, the song that i most played for the moment (3 times hahah, and im going for more)

[@floatingFran]

Good to know I'm not the only uruguayan. Un abrazo ^^

[@BadflowerUruguay]

@@floatingFran I hope we have more badflower fans in Uruguay, we have a mission to do hahaha buena noche hermano 😊

[@luisrios6687]

I have this song on repeat!!! This is honestly an instant classic on my library ! Thank you for this gem .

[@cassidyupton6710]

I’ve been listening to them since I heard ghost on octane radio waited for their new album and did the exact same thing I did last night stay up and listen to the whole thing they never disappoint. This song especially I can’t say how much I needed this album right now this song I’m so in love with this band and how they keep touching my heart

[@Skyler-ow3ep]

Hello fellow octane listener 😁 but same

[@showybobcat1498]

Same my family sucks and I cried the first time I heard family

[@justjody7415]

She knows. She’ll always know. Great song!

[@lukegold4089]

You guys make me feel alive. Dont stop. Your on the right track. Grettings from Argentina. Me and my best friend(ex girlfriend) love you so much.

[@leahblackwell3585]

4:16 gets me every time. It’s so beautiful! That note. Them cords. 😫👌

[@beezybeez6285]

This is so good but you must hear “Winding Road” or “Live Not Survive” by SLT 🤘🎸🎧

[@cheetah5063]

These guys are awesome. I'm glad I found them yesterday. I've been missing out all along.

[@Kim_Muzzs]

3:34 the guitar solo is so good, kinda reminds me of my chem :)

[@beezybeez6285]

This is so good but you must hear “Winding Road” or “Live Not Survive” by SLT 🤘🎸🎧

[@Douglas_I]

It's refreshing to hear a more traditional guitar and a guitar solo in modern music. It seems music is moving away from guitars lately and more towards synths and electronic sounds.

[@LauraRuiz-ue6nr]

Esta canción se ganó mi corazón completico.

[@uponthisautumn]

I'm not crying you're crying

[@noelsamuel159]

Loving this group. Never fails to impress

[@beezybeez6285]

This is so good but you must hear “Winding Road” or “Live Not Survive” by SLT 🤘🎸🎧

[@Alien_Interface]

This is so perfect, just the vocals and the instrumentals it's very yes, I love it!

[@stacey7637]

Seeing this was the best part of my shitty day. Thanks for posting.

[@Ariel_thenotsolittlemermaid]

I hope tomorrow would be better❤

[@deathquota1]

the way it ends...:) "unsatisfyingly" satisfying

[@beezybeez6285]

This is so good but you must hear “Winding Road” or “Live Not Survive” by SLT 🤘🎸

[@lowbudgethowlpendragon]

this comment is gonna be so long but i really love this song and the lyrics and the morbid beauty of it all cw// mentions of relapse and suicide the more i listen to this, the more i think it's about relapse into some sort of addiction rather than cheating. the "i'm faithful i swear" line supports this in my opinion. i think it's from the perspective of someone who had been clean for a while and perhaps had promised their partner that they'd keep it that way but things get bad. they relapse but don't tell her. slowly more and more people find out. but they still don't tell her because they don't want to see her hurt. they need to see her happy. they need her to stay. without her they feel worthless. things are so far gone that they feel it'd be worse to tell her now because it'd only hurt more, knowing they'd kept it from her for so long as someone who's been in both positions multiple times i know how much it hurts for both, every time. the pressure of making promises when you don't know you can't keep them. the guilt when things start to go wrong. the pain of knowing the truth but not wanting to face up to it because then it'd be really true the way it builds up before it all gets loud when josh sings "when she cried, i caved" hits so damn hard and i think really shows the emotional torment for both characters and the toll it's taken on them both, probably without them realising with the abrupt ending, i think it's possible that that could be the moment where the speaker ends their life because it's all too much and they can't cope with it and they're realising just what they've done. i haven't got as much evidence to support that but i feel like it's a reasonable explanation, other than the band just wanting it like that the song is the speaker realising and breaking down, the repetitiveness of the chorus is like them crying out. the way the guitar builds and builds and then lets loose in the solo could be like their tears. the wail during the solo would be literally the speaker screaming in despair this is all just my theories but i think i'm probably not far off. i love how straight up the song is whilst simultaneously leaving it up for interpretation. badflower are a phenomenal band with such raw and moving songs, the likes of which i've never heard before, easily one of the best bands on the scene right now. i cannot wait to see them support palaye royale next year :) if you've read this far then thank you for reading my mini essay and i hope you're doing ok

[@muhammadsabah6527]

This is the golden comment

[@EverythingxBeautiful]

Indeed

[@hollywould0021]

YES!

[@KrumpOcake]

I appreciate your perspective so much, this is something that hits close to home and yet I would have never have had this thought on my own. This is the kind of authenticity that brings back my faith in humanity

[@catherinestarling8715]

The ending of this song is so Andy Kaufman! I don't even know what to do every time it suddenly stops: should I laugh or should I cry, or both?

[@rachael8647]

" She believes in you still!" I need to have this kind of energy for myself.

[@beezybeez6285]

This is so good but you must hear “Winding Road” or “Live Not Survive” by SLT 🤘🐺

[@pocket-clown]

Listening to this more, I don't think it's about cheating. Such a beautiful and sad song

[@BlazingLines73]

My take is it could be about relapse

[@pocket-clown]

@@BlazingLines73 YES EXACTLY

[@mattkeen12]

loving all the new songs

[@its.savannahhhh]

Is the end supposed to cut off like that? It's like that on Spotify too!

[@filnin]

Same question. Sounds not like something conceptual, but a total mess up. Hope will fix it or it's really weird to make it on purpose

[@___97]

I’m pretty sure it’s a mistake. (I really hope it is)

[@ghostlyrobert]

Yeah it's so weird. It threw off my vibe 😂

[@stevenusinger]

I hope this is not the case on the CD. Unfortunately, this is also the case with Spotify.

[@samantha9018]

I was thinking the same thing I kept replaying the end to make sure it wasn’t just me

[@scarecrow1310]

I’ve been with someone 11 years. I lost her today. This song hits so hard

[@deathquota1]

💔

[@beezybeez6285]

This is so good but you must hear “Winding Road” or “Live Not Survive” by SLT 🤘🐺

[@Smuckular]

If you want to know a song more relatable to you listen to promise me (also badflower)

[@maeganbeach4814]

a lot of their songs have this lil undercurrent of knowing you've done something wrong (Johnny wants to fight, mother mary)

[@clararose1795]

I hear in an interview that “OK, I’m Sick” was about the victim, and “This Is How The World Ends” is about the villain. Obviously doesn’t apply to every song but yea, that was intentional.

[@michaeldean2575]

I'm addicted to this damn song!!!!

[@marsharobeson6160]

Lyrical and artistic genius

[@Sir_I.I_William]

Listening on 1.25 speed is pretty awesome.

[@odddevil9535]

wait this actually gives it a panicky vibe

[@tessmarie2933]

Omg I love this

[@korynnef7392]

This hurts my soul and I LOVE IT

[@alyssaorrick8819]

This song breaks my heart

[@Demmylo0]

His voice is slap 😩

[@SveKra]

Best Love-Song Of The World.

[@beezybeez6285]

This is so good but you must hear “Winding Road” or “Live Not Survive” by SLT 🤘🎸🎧

[@emotionalsnowman8254]

I love this.. After this year, holy shit I love it. Hits me in the feels as much as move me does

[@isaiahstoltenburg2834]

Don't get me wrong this song is great, but I can't stop imagining it as a bit of a harder metal song!

[@beezybeez6285]

This is so good but you must hear “Winding Road” or “Live Not Survive” by SLT 🤘🐺

[@thibaultimhoof8740]

i don’t understand is the brutal stop at the end on purpose ?

[@SolarStarseed]

I believe it's to symbolize how abrupty she cuts off the relationship after finding out the truth (his drug use).

[@thibaultimhoof8740]

@@SolarStarseed oh yeah well thought!

[@fedecamusso]

WOW... Exquisite song. 🔥🔥🔥.

[@marsharobeson6160]

Underrated gem. 🫶

[@baddiekaori1305]

Dude the most ebaiguflsong ive ever hesrd k almost cried wow josh youre an amgrl

[@beezybeez6285]

This is so good but you must hear “Winding Road” or “Live Not Survive” by SLT 🤘🎸🎧

[@marissamerrell3035]

I can't get enough of Josh katz 🥺🖤🥺🖤

[@carriesuiter5608]

Same his voice is so amazing.

[@marissamerrell3035]

@@carriesuiter5608 been I love with him since he first started 🖤

[@madilynn_rocky2644]

this one is so sad :((( I'm waiting to listen to my funeral last because ik that's gonna be sad.

[@anomalygal]

does anyone have a tab for the solo? (3:35-4:00) i've found chords but have yet to find a tab or sheet music for the it. i think i'll just wind up transcribing it myself so if you see this and want the tab when it's finished just reply to this comment!

[@joegestalt2092]

That's awesome

[@beezybeez6285]

This is so good but you must hear “Winding Road” or “Live Not Survive” by SLT 🤘🎸

[@PascalNeem]

Hey dude can I have the tab for the song? I’ve been wanting to learn this for ages. Please reply as soon as you can. Much thanks

[@SamAm77]

Dude if you have to tabs for this song that would be SO COOL!!! I’ve been searching for it everywhere but none of them are 100% correct, it’s insane

[@sarahlane8214]

Why does it just cut off at the end? Is that supposed to be like, poetic, like she abruptly cuts him off or something?

[@dannywhitt6656]

Straight from the sopranos.... and yes it’s a poetic ending

[@mr.boxh3ad931]

@@dannywhitt6656 Spoilers god dammit!

[@oleksober]

You guys are awesome🤩

[@beezybeez6285]

This is so good but you must hear “Winding Road” or “Live Not Survive” by SLT 🤘🐺

[@crystalmichelle4766]

If she left come to me please love your voice omg

[@Wolfsings1]

Great lyrics!

[@aaronmirandaneri1522]

Wow what song!!! It's awsome. I like it.

[@angelweed574]

Love this song

[@ricardomele1004]

Amazing song

[@catsrcool2412]

DOES ANYONE HAVE THE CHORDS FOR THIS? FOR GUITAR OR PIANO?

[@itsliyaalias]

i feel like this could be the story before "don't hate me"

[@Smokeythebear_22]

Great fucking song cant play it infront of my girl otherwise shell be hella thinking shit 😂😭😭

[@BrendaHernandez-gj9zp]

love this ♥

[@nathery1181]

I'm crying again!

[@floatingFran]

Thank you for this song

[@Joseph24LOVEAmanda28]

Badflower🏆🖤🤘

[@tiffanyweelborg5170]

I did what I did wrong to my man . And no matter what it is . I'll never be forgiven.. yet he still holds on to me . But I suffer the pain everyday

[@jessicaoppegaard2244]

Wow one more song to love and repeat

[@beckyramsey2611]

She always knew.

[@beezybeez6285]

This is so good but you must hear “Winding Road” or “Live Not Survive” by SLT 🤘🎸

[@carriesuiter5608]

Amazing just pure out amazing!!!!

[@adamnogell7663]

I came here just because I thought there's something wrong with the way this song got uploaded on Spotify haha

[@playiosclasher2921]

why did it just cut out like that at the end lol

[@aaronzNJD]

Caught me so off guard

[@joshiewoshie5937]

Loving the song but is that cut off at the end on purpose? Or was it a glitch?

[@davidxci]

judging by how the video ends i think it is intentional, which kinda sucks because i love the entire song besides that part. hopefully they release an extended version of it some time (or even just edit it to fade out) because it sorta feels unfinished like this

[@Ivycakes29]

@@davidxci I don't think it was intentional, they would never cut of a song like that. I feel it was an editing error

[@クリス-u2g]

@@Ivycakes29 It's the same on spotify lol

[@Ivycakes29]

@@クリス-u2g well it could be they edited it wrong and just put the song out universally like that. It just doesn't seem like something they would do on purpose

[@namaste5523]

It is the same on their CD, it may symbolize the abrupt way the relationship ends bc she knows. Josh knows what he’s doing. He is very intentional he always says.

[@razose1]

Who TF are these malcontents who come here just to down vote a track? Why? Is you life that much worse after playing this track, or is your personal opinion of this song so profound you have to share it with the world?

[@aleska25]

I love it

[@charlieescobar9177]

It’s like the series finale of The Sopranos.

[@beezybeez6285]

This is so good but you must hear “Winding Road” or “Live Not Survive” by SLT 🤘🐺

[@richlles8652]

Now she knows all my secret’s. now she’s gone

[@ThatWasGreatLive]

I get that the song is suppose to end abruptly, but is anyone else twitching a little?

[@aidanangalia8868]

My narcissistic abusive ex cheated on me while I was in jail for defending myself from him and when I got out I found out and they wanted to stay together. He told everyone I was the abusive one and convinced them all. That was till I showed people videos and pictures of what he had done.....then he threw me down in FRONT OF AN OFFICER, then resisted arrest while on the phone with their mom and screaming it was all my fault. He screamed for help from me when he was tackled ........I ran away I couldnt take it , my heart was gonna explode. My friend was there to protect me but I felt so alone in thoes moments. I'm fucked up and broken and now I must heal

[@Awstenkemonito]

LOS AMO

[@zoealessaagsalud135]

no dislikes as it should

[@parisjaye4159]

Why is it ending that way! I feel entirely robbed of melodic closure! Great song ..but this ending is unacceptable

[@Neighborhood_spdrman]

Exactly the point. He didn’t get closure nor does the listener.

[@aidanangalia8868]

I listen to this everytime i think about my boyfriend cheating on me 😢

[@kennethknecht9179]

Brilliant

[@jleo8656]

Everyone complaining about the unexpected ending, but once I figured out it wasn't a glitch, I thought it was brilliant. My solution to it was to put it on repeat. A truly timeless song! I always joke that I wouldn't know which Badflower to commit suicide to, as they have so many good choices to choose from, and I'm glad that, even though this song is melancholy, it's not one I'd say fuck it all to.

[@claudineangeloni3973]

💙 🎵

[@umitsever1692]

I like it

[@micheleweiler-fair831]

We always know…..

[@beezybeez6285]

This is so good but you must hear “Winding Road” or “Live Not Survive” by SLT 🤘🎸🎧

[@emersonphelipe8396]

Que solo é esse! Musica boaaaa do c$+#$-- BadFlower é foda dmais!

[@beezybeez6285]

This is so good but you must hear “Winding Road” or “Live Not Survive” by SLT 🤘🎸

[@the_real_max_level]

Badflowers version of RHCP's "I Could've Lied"

[@Badflowermad]

Does it cut off at the end on purpose?

[@RiseAgainSteve]

I FUCKING LOVE BADFLOWER!!!!!!!

[@breannnolannn]

I am their literal number fan if you disagree plz reply to this comment

[@bossolono3917]

Hes so fine ..u can cheat on whoever with me anytime boy..damn it..

[@beezybeez6285]

This is so good but you must hear “Winding Road” or “Live Not Survive” by SLT 🤘🎸🎧