Western Historical Critical Method || Muslim Historians Toolkit || Dr Jonathan Brown

Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @karimafoundation
Karima Foundation
www.karima.org.uk/info

[@sabriya7647]

Excellent Informative talk

[@alib7489]

Jazakallah Khair

[@tomimn2233]

I woulda loved to see that intro tho.

[@abbasr.7422]

Can we now still safely say (some) hadith are 100% reliably traceable back to the prophet or not (especially hadith that deals with laws or advice that will take a huge courage to follow and goes against common sense but since the prophet said it, we must follow)? How do we know as a laymen? Since scholars can quote this hadith and the audience has no say in the matter.

[@fab03102]

Very often "common sense" is actually cultural norm deep down. Cultures get things badly wrong, and modern western culture is certainly no exception. Muslim/Bukhari hahiths are probably something like 98 or 99% reliable.