What Happened to the Chronicle Wish Banner In Genshin Impact?

[@ninjakiwigames5418]

100% agree! And yeah it's funny how the two problems are: 1.Make 50/50 carry over 2.ACTUALLY HAVE THE BANNER EXIST

[@huyphamle159]

3.Don't have enough freemos for these banners 4.Weapon banner is still expensive to pull though

[@BadassHatdog]

​​@@huyphamle159 the weapon banner is actually 90 pulls less than the og the chronicled wish already gives you a chance to lose to eula's, tighnari's and dehya's limited-time BiS weapon which is already a bonus the only thing that could make chronicled wish work is if it were to be leaked prior to its release so people could save up.. imagine an inazuman chronicled wish, literally nobody is a standard character the og weapon banner requires 90 x 3 = 270 pulls to guarantee while the chronicled wish weapon banner only requires 180 pulls just like the limited-character banners

[@randyrandom3358]

​@@huyphamle159 It's the better weapon banner though

[@huyphamle159]

@@randyrandom3358 nah I prefer losing 75/25 and carry my pity over

[@randyrandom3358]

@@huyphamle159 You just need to save 160 pulls for it to guarantee and get the specific weapon you want, which is better considering the actual weapon banner needs around 240. Do correct me if I'm wrong, but I thought the actual weapon banner doesn't also save or carry pity over?

[@WarsunGames]

The thing is. I thought the banner was permanent. So when it vanished i was shocked.

[@jahircartagena8106]

I thought that at least would last the entire version

[@dan9563]

This is mihoyo without honkai in its title what do you expect

[@TheConvexDR]

I mean, mihoyo themselves said that it will go away and come back whenever they feel like it lol

[@WarsunGames]

@@TheConvexDR Naw. I think i`m done. I just uninstalled the game. Spent the whole month an about 80 bucks trying to get Segwine and failed. So Yeah i`m done. I have a whole constalation Noelle and even then it keeps giving me Noelles and i just won a 5 star which means rolling back they gave me my first duluke in 1 year. Yeah i think this is a good spot to stop. Over 80 rolls an still no 5 stars from the banner. Not 1. Yeah i think i`m completely done. They need to fix the game. No one has time for that. I could have just bought the character for 10 to 20 bucks. An saved money.

[@TheConvexDR]

@@WarsunGames That's fine, I hope you find a good game for your needs.

[@nottyseel949]

Amazingly, the artifact system is worse than the gacha.

[@VoidEnigma]

Agreed... I made this video about it here 🤣: kzbin.info/www/bejne/pH-qeIKGeLJ1grssi=iUKyqPxDe_0hZp8W

[@seagl4ss]

honestly more forgivable because you can have off set pieces, and it only takes 3 to fodder into 1 new strongbox artifacts compared to hsr requiring 10 for foddering and needing complete pieces on 2 sets

[@yosefsts7977]

​@@seagl4ss until u spend 30 fodder into strongbox and get 5 flower 5 feather when u need goblet, or when u got 10 goblet and none of them has correct elemental main stat, and full set looks better visually for me so im REALLY annoyed on getting 5 set on genshin.

[@Lofarzel31]

@@seagl4ss Don't forget more substats like SPD, Effect RES, etc.

[@zzzzzygaming]

​Yeah!! HSRs 10:1 is disgusting 😂

[@Twag7]

Let's be real they only added it because they didn't want to rerun Klee, Albedo and Eula, and Baizhu only got two reruns despite coming out less than a year prior so they can put him in the Liyue one. This banner only exists so normal banner slots can be kept for characters that sell well, not for the player's benefit. I'm normally not very critical of Hoyo but this is just such an obvious farce.

[@magekazin]

I believe they truly meant to continue this as a way to rotate character reruns faster. But what happened it wasn't perfect and the community does what it always does and goes on their genshin sucks rants, they don't listen to us and so on. And the pulls were probably low and with the hate they got, they scraped it.

[@ChangeOfHearts39]

Wuwa

[@realwermos]

​@magekazin you should know by now that hyv doesn't care about it's Genshin fan base. They'll rerun it again when the cash flow is tight.

[@Twag7]

@@magekazin I like to think that about most things in this game, but the chronicled wish is so obviously not intended to help generate income. It's specifically to rerun characters who rake in less money. Granted, not many Mondstadt 5 stars are especially strong and so far we have only had a Mondstadt chronicled wish, but it's glaringly obvious that they simply didn't want Klee, Eula and Albedo to get reran since it steals a spot away from someone more popular who is more likely to earn them money. Likewise, Baizhu was rerun twice despite being out for a year so they don't have to put Yelan or Hu Tao on the Liyue banner, notice how Yelan is getting a banner in 4.8 when she would have fit the criteria for a Liyue chronicled wish perfectly. Likewise, if it was for the player's benefit, why hasn't there been another since? They are waiting for more worse/less popular 5 stars to be out of rotation for a while to put them in instead of ones who people will be pressured into pulling for.

[@DarkButterflyChikage]

Wuwa nation 🎉

[@Rettilos]

Slight correction: Pity does carry over but not the guarantee

[@voshadxgathic]

It's specifically the fate point that doesn't carry over. Which we already have practice with on the weapon banner. It's a small, but important distinction to say fate point instead of guarantee, because saying guarantee implies it's akin to the limited character banners, which it's not.

[@sakaom]

PITY CARRY OVER??? LETS GOOOOO I HAD 78 PITY ON THAT DAMN MONDSDADT BANNER 😭😭😭

[@TechTalk0069]

Yes. pity carry over​@@sakaom

[@tovarishchfeixiao]

@@voshadxgathic But it's still not a problem. People are just too dramatic. Afterall, you just have to save-up enough pulls to make sure that you get the character even if you happen to lose the 50/50.

[@Blue---Kit-n3i]

Is this a satire comment? By any chance?

[@leeo268]

Shenhe wanter: It been 84 years....

[@Hoyo_Finally_Rerunning_PJC]

Primordial jade cutter wanter: I'm the grand grand son of my grand grand dad and it's been 274 years...

[@sagittaronapricot5839]

I got Shenhe on her recent rerun after waiting for what felt like 100 years, and Albedo on the Chronicled Wish after 1000 years (he even brought the enigmatic Eula, who's known for having a rerun once every Amber Era with him). Don't stop waiting guys, patience will compensate you! We have always had enough time - Abyss Sibling.

[@Hoyo_Finally_Rerunning_PJC]

@@sagittaronapricot5839 waiting until we all die cuz it looks PJC is not gonna get a rerun in our lifetime.

[@enviousdragon9109]

I've been waiting for her rerun and I'm losing hope. Let my queen out of the basement!

[@Hoyo_Finally_Rerunning_PJC]

@@enviousdragon9109 tell her to blink twice if she's being kept a hostage

[@izusmallmight8953]

I wish they added a 3rd regular limited time banner instead of just two.

[@Twag7]

This would make the weapon banner kind of awkward to make. In my opinion, the best thing they could do is occasionally have 3 banner phases per version, like they did in 1.3 where each banner lasted 2 weeks rather than 3.

[@Pingu2010]

@@Twag7 One way I could see 3 concurrent banners working is if they did away with the way the weapon banner work, and just have disctinct weapon banners with a 50:50 for each signature weaopn (well, ideally there'd be no 50:50 like WuWa, but eh).

[@idminister]

@@Twag7 just do like HSR....split the weapon banner; like it always shouldve been

[@r.d.6290]

@@Twag7 Make 3 weapon banners? Get rid of these stupid crutch solution to the "Staff of Homeless Incident" which the epitomized path is, maybe?

[@chickensauna]

Wuwa weapon banner though 👍

[@JustValiant-]

If they added 2 or 3 more Permanent Rotating Banners: Regional Banner (Characters of one same Region appear), Elemental Banner (Characters of one shared element appear), Special Choose your own Banner (Players can pick 5 of their favorite characters to appear on one banner to wish from). They would make insane amounts of money with this move.

[@sundae_yay_ay]

That’s such a good idea

[@browserjunior4707]

The fact that Fire Emblem Heroes does this and no one ever complained is so funny cause like it’s such a simple fix to a long-standing gacha problem of FOMO being more and more strict and time gated. They have weekly banners, banners for events, polls for the top 10 heroes released in the current version as well as the bottom 10 released. And they also jack up the rates for special banners like when they do Legendary or Mythic banners where everyone gets a flat 6% 5* chance. Stuff like that gives whales and F2P more reason to pull cause you can either make your weak characters stronger by borrowing skills from the stronger units or just by having the stronger units be maxed out completely cause of the increased rate drop.

[@kaku7398]

Really sounds like what Guardian Tales did in the "recent" updates, are you perhaps a guardian as well ? :D Because honestly that's such a banger idea

[@SHAdow98V]

Good ideas, the choose your own banner thing i doubt would've worked unless you c9uld only choose the shit characters, cuz if you could make your banner from all characters then everyone would just choose the meta ones like archons and Neuvilette or Arlecchino and such.

[@Axterix13]

They wouldn't make insane amounts of money. Those of us who whale already have the characters we want at the level we want. The dolphins will mostly have the ones they want with the first re-run. Then there are new (non-f2p) players. The newer players have a lot of other, strong characters to catch up on, plus the new hotness. And they want the FOMO, so you'll open your wallet because otherwise you'll have to wait 8 months. And that leaves the F2Ps. These are not a cash cow, for some strange reason, so will not make them insane amounts of money ;) You will see people saying how they've been waiting for X character for Y years in KZbin comments. It, however, won't reflect the reality of the overall demand. These are the select few people commenting on something dear to them, and nobody else bothers to say, "skipping the three year old character". So it can make it seem like there's a demand for a character like Eula or Cyno, but there just isn't. That said, it likely costs Hoyoverse very little to set up a banner, once the system is in place. A player with a character they like is more likely to keep playing/spending. And, well, the reason the chronicled banner was added in the first place is because there are too many characters that the time gaps between them is too long, which means the poor selling ones are going to be even longer still. Added to that, there's a growing four star constellation issue as well. So, they're idiots for not doing something to address all this, as it is harder to get a new customer than it is to keep an old one. But then, being idiots at PR is a bit of a Hoyoverse/Genshin team strong point.

[@dinispedroso8151]

As someone who couldnt pull Shenhe in 3.5 due to other priorities but vowed to do so in her next rerun, its been extremely frustrating having everything prefarmed (artifacts included) only for it to gather dust. The whole 5* and 4* reruns fiasco has been atrocious scummy.

[@ruy7164]

She is probably going to rerun on 5.0

[@dinispedroso8151]

@@ruy7164 shes been "probably reruning next patch" for the past 7 patches. Do not just brushed it off like its a none issue.

[@ChangeOfHearts39]

Wuwa.

[@Wuhaboo]

Nop evey 0.0 is archons then their subordinates so...​@@ruy7164

[@SwieczkaNiweaniewierzeDarek]

​@@ruy7164 Nah, Wriothesley is probably going to rerun instead

[@hazelmaple]

I don’t see why they don’t have the new banner more often, even filler patches. They obviously don’t want to rerun old characters like albedo, Eula, and Klee anymore and this banner gave them an option for, I’m not sure if they don’t do it again because Liyue has some really good characters that fit the criteria like Hu Tao, yelen , ganyu, etc. shenhe ironically doesn’t qualify because she hasn’t had enough reruns. But with the unknown time frame makes me think this is just the Mondstadt banner that they will run once a year just to say the characters got a rerun. It’s really too bad they don’t at least carry over guarentee on that banner since they make you wait who know how’s long for it to come back

[@shironasama0445]

I hate Chronicled Wish for what it could have been. Like they could have rerun it every patch with different characters. Also imagine they let it share pity with the limited banner. Hoyo does this shit so often, they have a good idea and then fuck it over.

[@SwieczkaNiweaniewierzeDarek]

Sharing pity with the Limited banner wouldn't be profitable for them at all, but they should've made it a permanent thing, refreshing once every version with 3 older limited 5 stars.

[@BladeSerph]

Luuuuurking~ Funfacts: -Punishing Gray raven has ALL its A-ranks on a perma selector, same with weapons and Uns and Cubs, so they never need to do rerun banners for those. -Punishing Gray raven also throws ALL units into its standard banner, so you can technically pull for any character with them periodicially doing `selector` re-runs, usually in the latter half of a version which usually has multiple S-ranks you can pick between to be the Rate up choice (though it tends to be a 70% rate up, its still better then Mihoyo`s retarded 50/50 they decided todo for not only Gen-stingie but also Zen-lazy). Gee, its almost like they could easily create a MEANS of archiving older units by simply creating a special `selector` for older units so people can simply choose say a, `enhanced` rate up higher then 50/50 and let people burn pulls (probably specifically standard ones mostly) so they can waste pulls on older units and just leave the special ones like Archons, Fatui harbingers and super popular ones like Kazuha as part of the rerun crowd.~~~ Moral of the story: As the CC put it: Mihoyo is just greedy as fk. Since they just straight up sabotage thar own titles in the sake of wanting to thirst for more profit, without understanding how you actually coax people into spending, by impressing, not terrorizing. Anyway back flip to P:GR Enjoyment.~ Next week we get a FREE S-rank Physical amplifier with a FREE special effects coating, with a NEW weapon harmonization system we can farm for FREE to make many characters alot better WITHOUT, needing to spend much on pulls this patch, unless desperation for the weapon and Pet (CUB) kicks in REALLY hard.~

[@sharktos3218]

Sorry to phrase it that way, but are you stupid? You do realize what you described is just "Add 3-6 more limited 5* banners", right? Just that you could lose to another 5* instead of C5 Qiqi. You really didn't think this through, mate.

[@cybremystica93]

@@SwieczkaNiweaniewierzeDarekyes….please. I would love this

[@firewolflycan]

They also made only Hunter path and beacon be on there

[@cqwiii]

It was pointed out at the time, idk by who, that Hoyo was being intentionally vague about how often the chronicled wish banner would run. - and when Hoyo is intentionally vague about something, its because you wouldnt like the truth. It seems that the truth is probably that they intend to hold back the chronicled wish banner until moments of optimal profit, which they could control and predict for players engaging in multiple Hoyo titles 10/10 for calling out Hoyo for milking Genshin only to fund their other projects. If they reinvested even a fraction of that money back into Genshin, Wuwa would have never had a chance.

[@ChangeOfHearts39]

Wuwa

[@Wuhaboo]

Ikr justice for genshin no more genshin could never it's hoyo fault, the game and the players deserve better

[@numaruldoi3031]

What has wuwa to do with this? And second, you speak as if people dont play more that one game at the time...

[@cqwiii]

How can I speak as if people only play one game at a time when I specifically mentioned Hoyo's ability to maximize banners for profit when players are playing mutiple Hoyo titles? What Wuwa has to do with this is that it is a Genshin clone that was able to sprout and thrive specifically because Hoyo has been so stagnant and lazy with Genshin. If Hoyo had cared to support Genshin beyond the bare minimum required for maximum profit, nobody would have looked twice as Wuwa- just as World of Warcraft murdered nearly every MMO that came up during its prime because nobody in the MMO market wanted another game.

[@Wuhaboo]

@@cqwiii true

[@pronoun171]

The simps who say that they have no choice, they have to make money forget that games do not have a right to exist. If you put out a crap product, and then screw over your players you don’t deserve anything.

[@DiamentowaSzklanka]

Bruh they don't realise how much money hoyo actually makes from genshin alone 💀💀 you could assume the servers cost a lot to run but certainly not like a million dollars a month?

[@AratakiBullPowerSiddo1]

Thats such a dumb take. If games have no right to exist then no form of entertainment media like movies, songs, etc. doesn't either Nobody saying that Mihoyo didn't mess up but condemning the entire gaming media in general's too much.

[@BulletSponge71436]

@@AratakiBullPowerSiddo1 I'm pretty sure you misunderstood OP's comment.

[@merusotajio2222]

​@@AratakiBullPowerSiddo1it means no entertainment no game simple how did you not get it ?

[@EyelessAugust]

@@AratakiBullPowerSiddo1correct. None of those has a right to exist. You seem to get it, what’s the problem

[@kazuu_44]

the chronically would have been PERFECT if the 50/50 guarantee CARRIED OVER. the weapon banner too, just make encounter points carry over. sure players who’ve used the system will be sad they already wished, but even they want it to change. even without compensation everyone just wants it to change.

[@biac327]

it’s so frustrating since i wasn’t able to get shenhe either times, i’ve been waiting for her forever now.

[@thesparklegirl3236]

Same

[@Hoyo_Finally_Rerunning_PJC]

Primordial jade cutter: first time? And no.. PJC is not in standard wish

[@WastedTalent83]

man i was able to get her, and c1 her on the second banner.. i wanted to slowly take her to C6.. guess what? gonna take 15 years at this pace XD

[@LucyMai92]

I remeber in the last survey there was even a question that asks about your salary. How lame!

[@itzcrystalzz]

LMAOOO?? that’s wild. what the hell

[@kaiser8773]

It got eated by the cats

[@Otherface]

Amazing 😀👍

[@Neahmon]

Ragna pfp spotted, based.

[@recentmap7268]

You mean eaten

[@angel_0132]

​@@recentmap7268 no. eated

[@vict632]

The Chronicled banner was a godsent for me. Finally managed to get Wolf's Gravestone and Song of Broken Pines. And if I had more wishes I would've gone for Skyward Blade. A Liyue version would be amazing too but Hoyo works in mysterious ways. 🤷‍♂

[@Hoyo_Finally_Rerunning_PJC]

No, they look at the feedback and do the opposite.

[@whyistheskyyellow8681]

Fr, i finally pulled wolfs gravestone and hunter's path during the chronicled wish, and i was looking forward to the liyue one to get xiao's spear ... 🥲

[@nobody-xh6ii]

I actually got eula's signature while pulling for hunters path and still got hunter after. So freminet ended up with a new shiny toy which was a win for me.~

[@AsifKhan-ot9dv]

@@whyistheskyyellow8681 i got that spear twice from standard 😋

[@whyistheskyyellow8681]

@@AsifKhan-ot9dv AFSHSGHS i want that 😭😭 i keep getting aquila favonias

[@BatDragonLuver]

I want Ganyu, so I felt personally attacked during this example.

[@steffy23456]

If you like her design, personality and like her playstyle, I suggest you do it. She's flexible with supports and even if you don't want to main the left click, she makes for a decent burst dps. She's also fairly easy to build, since her selection of bows is rather large and she has a crit damage ascension stat. I hope you get her. - a Ganyu main

[@ChrisX_212]

Ganyu should've been eligible in Blue Wish, like Keqing and Qiqi. Her weapon is just an Amos Bow. It doesn't make sense why Ganyu is limited, but her weapon isn't. That said, yeah, I played this game at 4.0, hoping for Ganyu and she NEVER APPEARED ever since. Not even in Lantern Rite, when others say it's the best time if I wanted Ganyu (LIARS!). So you can imagine how pissed I am. But unlike a lot of people who pulled their support from Hoyo out of frustration... Sorry, but I have way lot more endurance than those guys. It'd take more than that for me to scorn a company.

[@Skye_4]

I got Ganyu on her last rerun but was never successful to get her bow even on standart banner🥲

[@Hoyo_Finally_Rerunning_PJC]

Hoyoverse: Let's make skins for ganyu and shenhe but let the players wait a year if they didn't get the character.

[@ChrisX_212]

@@Hoyo_Finally_Rerunning_PJC Also Hoyoverse: Let's make skin for Nilou and make her available RIGHT AT THAT MOMENT!

[@unknownkw]

Hoyo shoot themselves on the foot by not rerunning characters on a regular basis forcing new players to buy account in order to play their favorite character. It is a joke. Their low sales in recent banners is well deserved. There is no reason they can't put up more banners to match the character pool so that new players don't have to wait for more than 9 months to pull for x.

[@EvanM-ko8ym]

Whenever someone says they want to play genshin I tell them not to do it, but if they insist, I tell them to buy a genshin account with their favorite character. It is the best way to get the character you want. I got an alternate account with raiden shogun + signature w/ random 5* and 300+ farmed wishes for a measly $20. There's an entire site dedicated to buying accounts and its a godsend.

[@sleeppss]

Low sales? Still being top 3 best selling is far from low sales tho Genshin would need to drop down to atleast 10M a month for hoyo to even care. Yet we barely step down from 30M

[@PCVP4729]

@@EvanM-ko8ymmind naming the website? And how long have you had this account to be sure of its legitimacy?

[@swilleh_]

@@PCVP4729 i got my Diluc for 1$ back then on "5mmo". Also bought R6 Points a few times on their site.

[@swilleh_]

@@EvanM-ko8ym tbh missing the early game would be awful for some people like me because of missed lore. I bought my Diluc after like AR30~ and i think i would've done the same today.

[@vampi314]

the 2 requirements they proposed for a char to be selectable for the chronicle banner also sorta walked the banner into a corner from the get go. not only it was "need to have been run at least 3 times" but also "must not have been rerun recently", and this second requirement is super vague cuz how do u determine what "recently" count as. (n im guiding myself by the livestream wording, since the faq post has no mention of either of these requirements) at the time when chronicle banner happened, klee n eula were on a 5 patches long gap since their last rerun, while it was even longer for albedo. if we then use this info to assume that "recently" = "five patches or longer", at the time the chronicle banner was released, there was very few characters that fulfill BOTH conditions, even if we assume, that 3 out of 6 slots would be filled by standar chars instead of limited ones. now, i dont remember at the top of my head WHICH chars fulfilled these 2 conditions aside of the 3 that were on chronicle banner 1. im fairly certain kokomi was there n ganyu... im not 100% sure about ganyu. anyone curious can go and check. the point is, there was very few chars that could go to the chronicle banner to begin with. if we add to that, the "has to be from the same region" (which, btw, this was never mentioned as a requirement, at least as far as i remember), then that banner was bound to not be a "once every patch" kind of deal. they have just too few chars that fulfill all the conditions. as a foot note, i do think this is the reason why they hurried so much to have baizhu reruns so close to one another (4 patches from one another), healers r usually one of the least grosing banners and next time a chronicle banner happens, the snake doctor can directly be thrown in there.

[@amandaslough125]

A Liyue banner would have Keqing and Qiqi for standard units. Then could be filled up with Hutao, Ganyu, Childe easily. And now Baizhu and Yelan eventually.

[@ThePenguinsKing]

Yelan is in 4.8 as was announced in the livestream. If we go by order of release it means either the chronicle wish banner will release in 5.4 or that yelan wont be in it

[@joycewhoelse]

@@amandaslough125 i dont think childe would be on it since he's not from liyue nor would hu tao be on it bc hu tao is one of their more better selling banners plus i think childe would get a rerun in early natlan times since he usually appears around that time anyways

[@SkyeSoleil]

I was skeptical of the chronicle wish banner when it was announced but thought it might be good for players who really wanted a character or weapon… then it lasted only half a patch. That just screws people over and forces them to spend money because who knows when those characters will be available again

[@maxroy6933]

I'll tell , they won't be available for another fucking years to come 😭

[@KratosAurionPlays]

4:55 Who exactly decided this? We're literally getting Shenhe in the next Chronicled wish lol

[@magdalenas.4]

I met a newer player, who had 4 standard banner 5-star characters, but only one limited one. I asked how is that even possible. She told me she lost on the limited *AND* chronicled wish banner…. The rest is history…. 😅

[@FourDollaRacing]

I literally have no limited characters, after two years of playing... they're all the same to me, so I build guaranteed characters with Paimon's Shop Constellations, and 5* Standard Characters.

[@rosiekira4093]

Well for the first 2 years of playing I never won a 50/50 and even as of today I have only won 3. Genshin just hates some ppl 😭

[@fatuusdottore]

Having the banner be predictable and pity carry over really is the one fix that matters. Hoyoverse just needs to do that tbh.

[@bbysiea]

as a f2p i'm getting scared for the future. genshin is my favorite game, and i've been playing since 2.0 nonstop, even though my account was made in 1.1 and i quit after a bit. primos are getting less and less literally before my eyes, i do my comms, i do story quests, i do hangouts, i explore, and even then i only get roughly 40-60 wishes depending on what was released that version.

[@Lil_Noot]

I think stupidest part about Chronicled is that you have to use Intertwined Fates. Unless you’re skipping or a whale, you will not have enough for a character, their weapon, and then Chronicled on top of that.

[@TheStrongestBaka]

Skipping should be the norm.

[@sleeppss]

Yeah its pretty scummy how we get more and more banners but the pulls are basically the same every year

[@SorarikoMotone]

@@sleeppss i mean, thats how it is with all gacha games. it either banner bloat or more banners. you have to learn to choose what to pull if you're unable to whale, thats how they make one into a whale. there's a reason gacha games are games of resource management for f2p's. its a bigger issue in other games, however, because of powercreep. you will NEVER get everything you want, unless you manage your expectations - thats kind of a point.

[@lolwarrior2181]

@@SorarikoMotone Except not really Other than FGO, Genshin has easily the worst FOMO out there for gacha games. There would be less demand for something like chronicled banner if the amount of FOMO didn't reach this level. In Genshin, 99% of 5* are limited, meaning you cannot get them outside of a specific timeslot. So no more getting spooked or offbanner like other games which lessen the FOMO. If your favorite character is eula or albedo, enjoy waiting for a year or two until you're be able to pull for them. Also this affects 4*, like kaveh Not only that, but the premium resource gain is awfully stingy. You don't even have enough pulls each patch to hit soft pity, let alone the hard 90. Taking account the 50/50 into account, you'll probably need to stockpile 2.5-3 patches just to be able to guaranteed someone that you want as an F2P. And don't even hope getting your hopes up with weapon banner as now you need 3 rotations (albeit with 10 less pity for each rotation totalling to 240 pulls max). That alone is ~4 patches just to guarantee. If you want to guarantee someone + their sig, you pretty much need to save up 3/4 of the entire year of events (6-7 patches or 9-10 months). And there's like what? 8-10 5* chara in a year? Also this doesn't take into account if you want to c6 a non-launch 4* because good luck getting them without pity or buyable in the shop.

[@BulletSponge71436]

@@TheStrongestBaka Generosity should be the norm.

[@nevilex]

I think I'm also fully switching to F2P after the battle pass runs out. My breaking point's Chlorinde's weapon banner. Weapon banner's fkd me over too many times. 180 wishes on characters at least carry over. Weapon banners I lose 2x so many times in the 1yr I've been playing for just a 20% more damage.

[@Hoyo_Finally_Rerunning_PJC]

Don't support hoyoverse they don't listen to the players. I love genshin but ugh i'm fed up...

[@xChaosFlower]

Don't bother with the weapon banners. There are plenty of options for weapons than character's signature weapons

[@lamborghin1rami598]

​​@@Hoyo_Finally_Rerunning_PJC Agree, the biggest problem is that we have demands but we still play the game anyway. And that's the only thing hoyo actually cares. So as long as we are still playing, they aren't gonna hear a word

[@Hoyo_Finally_Rerunning_PJC]

@@lamborghin1rami598 I used to play everyday, now I only log in once a week ever since the bs 4.8 livestream.

[@EarlyGene]

@@xChaosFlower Though there's going to be metaslaving trolls who will try to gaslight others into thinking that certain characters will only work with their signature weapons as well as try to gatekeep them from pulling for those characters if they're not willing to pull for their signatures on the weapon banners.

[@jajathenewking6131]

My most hated part is why not run it for the whole patch, then the pity is an issues but I'm so used to that.

[@lamborghin1rami598]

Ikr, like this has to be another solid proof that genshin is greedy af

[@memmo98]

One thing to point out is that if i remember correctly the pity DOES carry over but there is no 50/50 but we cant even be sure about that since it never appeared again Btw i wanted dehya weapon so bad that i pulled but got wolfs gravestone and i regret it so much so yea i think its just better to think of it as a better weapon banner 💀

[@WastedTalent83]

but.. carry over to what? if they never rerun that banner?XD or do it once a year? ahahahhaha

[@ChimeraAxolotl]

At this point we need a third or even fourth character event wish banner

[@Itskaty._.]

They can adopt the expa foca system from hi3 where banners only run for 3 days separate from the current event banner but shares pity it allows for much faster rotation and if anyone think 3 days isn't enough that banner is for people who were waiting for a whole year for that character they surely have enough pulls

[@maxenite]

I started on second phase of 4.2. I was very interested in Genshin's lore and characters. When I first saw Shenhe I said "damn this is my favorite character design til now. I wonder how is her character and gameplay" and I'm still waiting for her rerun. I'm so tired of saving for her. I skipped so many good characters for her. I always have to think like "I can't spend all I have, I have to save this amount of pulls for Shenhe". Man screw this. Why Yelan gets 2 reruns in 4.0 and 4.8, why Baizhu gets 2 reruns on 4.2 and 4.6 but I have to wait for Shenhe? Yelan sells so much okay but Baizhu don't. That's not an argument. Even if we say it is, do I have to like and play only the characters who has high sale numbers? What's the point of adding so many characters then? I find this sooo st*pid and I believe some higher people on Hoyo are just ignorant of how gaming works.

[@catycandy6613]

Yes bro ++++ жду шень хе 😭😭😭

[@dancerdancer215]

at this moment of time, you should be glad that you didn't invest your primos in her. i've invested a lot in ayaka c2r1 and shenhe c1r1, and guess what?... top freeze team with kokomi and kazuha C2 is not able to clear some abyss chambers in time . i didn't played for a year, and now even did more researches to improve my capabilities with ayaka freeze to make it work (while before it was working anyway), but that didn't help me... the second team usually was raiden c3r1 national... but now was forced to make it work with international ( with a lot of tries because its aoe team while monsters cannot be grouped) and in second team to put a weird team with damage based on raiden with sara. so ayaka c2r1 and shenhe c1r1 are sitting on the bench. for you to now i'm practially f2p , its just the case that i was collecting primos for 6-9 months to invest more in a few specific characters

[@maj0ga.]

Instead of only 3 weeks but not long as the whole patch, just make it on the monthly reset timer when the shop refreshes.

[@sparticus55667]

been playing for years and finally got a lost prayer book.....on my alt!!!!!! just let me get the frigging weapons jerkksss. never even seen a gravestone lol

[@samandrielswings]

people keep parroting that gacha is inherently predatory, but it seems the meaning of that is lost on many. you feel manipulated because you ARE being manipulated. they're literally baiting you and, in cases like the chronicled banner, outright trying to scam you out of your money. i'm not saying this with any judgement, to be clear. i've also spent money on this game, and probably will do it again in the future. even if the idea itself is good, hoyo knew what they were doing by introducing this banner. if they'd announced it as once per year/anniversary banner, they might've avoided some shit they got. but they obviously don't care at all about it to begin with. hoyo doesn't deserve your energy like this. take a break, rethink your expenses. go browse some fanart. 9 out of 10 times you'll find your character being treated better than in game, AND you won't waste money on a greedy company.

[@Hoyo_Finally_Rerunning_PJC]

Just don't spent any more money on this company hoyoverse until they listen... They never listen to the players...

[@SorarikoMotone]

@@Hoyo_Finally_Rerunning_PJC its not always bad that they dont - especially in this case.

[@WastedTalent83]

its true tho XD These are not "games" you buy and done, like it used to be 20 years ago. These are scammy practices that are legal for some reason, and people decide of their own volition to be scammed. Its like "gaming" saloons with only slot machines... you know its a scam, but they go anyway. People WILL absolutely find any excuses and bullshit to not just admit "yea we get scammed and we don't care" , but hey, that's people for you.

[@jex-the-notebook-guy1002]

Wait what about fanart? You know Genshin has a bunch of doujins right?

[@Hoyo_Finally_Rerunning_PJC]

@@SorarikoMotone no chronicled for more then 8+ months? lmao okay cIown

[@stayysilver]

Yeah, the banner was pretty disappointing compared to what it could have been. At the very least, we did get access to Dehya's and Tighnari's weapons. Cinnabar Spindle is still completely unachievable for new accounts (including mine) as well as Robin and Silver wolf's LCs.

[@No-Ink]

You know what Aether Gazer did in their recent China region patch? (China is ahead compared to Global so we'll get this) They made some older limited characters go in the pool for the Standard Banner but now you can choose which 3 characters from that pool you want to be rated up. And pity is 70 pulls. Now the limited banner only gives limited characters if you lose 50/50. No more standard 5 star characters when losing 50/50.

[@LPTheGas]

Most likely, it bombed because of the timing. Two of the three most-wanted characters in the game were rerunning at the same time, the very next banner cycle. Nobody who didn't already have both Kazuha and Neuvillette was spending one thin primo on the CW, and that's without even taking into account the issues pointed out in the video that pissed tons of people off. IMO, a better solution to the "too many event 5-stars, not enough banner slots" problem would be to 1) put a cap on the number of event 5-stars, and whenever a new one is introduced, move the least-demanded at-least-one-year-old one to the standard banner (and thus also to the failed 50/50 list for event banners), and 2) add a 5-star selector to the standard banner like ZZZ and HSR have.

[@Axterix13]

The thing is, the whole point of the banner is for it to take all the characters who will bomb and bundle them up, without impacting the sales of more in demand characters. It's basically a PR move that placates the few people who would actually choose to get those characters over saving for the META/new-hotness characters that are running before, during, or after, while still paying for itself. That it was going to bomb was a given.

[@Moxuko]

Even as i was waiting for the Albedo rerun, i feel sad for everyone still waiting for their favorites caracters coming back,

[@Halcyon554]

Nikke made me drop Genshin. To put into perspective, I've been playing Nikke since May, and while I have put in just two hundred or so into the game, I'm already at 100 Special Recruit tickets and just under 70,000 gems. Only about 1000 or so of those gems are paid, the rest...free. Granted, while the game NEEDS you to have 3 copies of 5 different characters to break the level 160 barrier, it facilitates this by letting you roll A LOT and often. From Social Points alone, which you just get via having friends on your friends list, I'm doing at least a low rate 10 pull every week. It definitely feels a lot more generous, and unless the character is seasonal or a collab, they go right into the standard banner after the initial banner phase. I mean gacha is gacha and it'll always be predatory, but at least Nikke allows a player to have a pulling endorphin rush often and all the time. There's even a Wishlist on the Standard banner where you select 15 different Nikkes...5 from 3 of the Manufacturers, and when you roll an SSR(or 5* for you Genshin players), it'll always be from either the Pilgrim group or one of the 15 from your Wishlist. It boggles my mind to think that Genshin is still so stingy years down the line.

[@arnowisp6244]

The guy in charge of Genshin is the problem but they are a co founder so they can't do anything about him.

[@ankitjadhav6775]

Tldr: u are a pervert who likes big anime didies?

[@ABlandName]

So what you're saying is you dropped garbage for even more garbage

[@Halcyon554]

@@ABlandName all gacha is garbage really. Predatory games really just putting on a shiny coat to make you spend. But at least Nikke ain't raking me over the coals and throws rolls at me like candy.

[@Konayori]

Good idea, bad excecution in a nutshell

[@PioterCygan]

When in the middle of Sumeru ( like 3.4 or 3.5 i dont remember) there were discussions about 3 Character banner. Now, its a must

[@islippedtheslime]

It’s even worse when you remember the banner takes intertwined fates instead of acquaint fates. That means, using your Ganyu example, she could be on the chronicled wish running alongside your favorite character in a limited wish. But, you just have to choose which banner to pull on because it’s not like you can just save up acquaint fates to get Ganyu then use your primos to get that limited character. No, it *had* to be gems.

[@killerwakka1]

The simplest way to solve this problem is to put the old characters in the standard pool like any other gacha game did before them. This also has a side effect of improving the quality of the limited banner since the 50/50 looses are not so bad anymore since you could get a character that was not in the standard banner before

[@buahkelapaliar8829]

Placing old limited char in standard banner will enrage people who pulled them before. The best possible way is releasing it in Chronicle or regional banner.

[@voidcritter4]

​@@buahkelapaliar8829 Why would they still adjust to those who already have them. Good for them for those who have them already... but for those who don't?? This is like the event weapons, players who happened to catch them before they've gone would often say, "Boo-hoo, you should've been there; I hope these event weapons won't reappear."

[@BowsettesFury]

Or they can just do what I suggested in the Hoyo lab app. Allow people to buy the character they want once. Implement a trade system since they treat this game like Pokémon anyways. After purchasing the character once you get the gacha mechanics. C1 super easy, c2 not as easy and so on. They stand the chance to make even more money that way. Also reduce the price of fashion in the game as well. It’s already extremely limited in the amount available and paying $30 for a fake outfit is just plain stupid in the first place.

[@KhaliqueThomas]

I’m glad this video exists. I whaled a hard to get Neuvilette and his weapon, and I also wanted Wriothesley and his weapon as well. I KNEW it would be awhile till I saw Wrio again, and I was fully expecting to see him again around 4.7 or 4.8. NOPE! we’re getting Yelan again, who’s had 2 reruns in Fontaine (4.0, and 4.8)

[@alteredme82673]

Man this hit me like a truck. I joined to pull for Furina and I was considering buying the primogems to get her since her banners ending pretty soon, and I already feel bored of Genshin. My desire to even get her has died which is pretty sad for me. Hoyoverse, why?

[@ChangeOfHearts39]

Wuwa

[@Hoyo_Finally_Rerunning_PJC]

Don't support hoyoverse they don't listen to the players. I love genshin but ugh i'm fed up...

[@SorarikoMotone]

@@Hoyo_Finally_Rerunning_PJC they do listen - just not to the tiny minority of players that think they're the majority.

[@Melotaku]

@@SorarikoMotoneTHIS 🙏

[@BulletSponge71436]

@@SorarikoMotone Absolute cringe and not true. The fact that you're against the things that would *only benefit everyone* is crazy to many. Absolutely crazy.

[@EVenture_XD]

The banner is good in theory and could have been hella good in practice. You made good points like how older characters wouldn't become completely unaccessible. The banner system could be future proof, as it runs 6 characters at a time on one banner, allowing 10 characters to run per patch ( and roughly 80 a year if they do every patch ). The one banner also prevents banner inflation and choice paralysis, while still reducing the time between character rotations. Also, if liyue and further regions get banners, it would defs improve in value, as losing a 50 50 would still yield high value characters like going for kokomi and getting kazuha, and even if not, it's way better than another diluc.... but ya if they had just allowed the player to keep their fate point and/or extend the duration to the entire patch it would be perfect! Long term this is our best bet, the 3rd banner would quickly become inefficient (roughly 48 runs a year, much smaller than the current and growing cast) and throwing old characters on standard would literally make them hell to get But ya ramble isnt perfect, just wanted to yap about it

[@John_II]

I think you nailed it. I was excited for the chronicled wish banner, but it was done in a way to make sure no one would wish on it, unless you (1) happen to have the wishes saved, (2) happen to want Eula, Klee, Diluc, Mona, Albedo, or Jean or their constellations and/or (3) you were willing to whale. It needs to either have (a) pity carry over or (b) come back regularly with some predictability, or (c) just make it permanent. Heck, let's make it so we have regional banners for all the past regions (let's say up to Sumeru). As it stands now, I'm not wishing on it if it comes back with the exact same rules.

[@natsuyuki8415]

Well, they did say it would appear 'from time to time', so not every patch. I did think it would be in 4.8 though. Pity does carry over, the guarantee does not and it really should.

[@WastedTalent83]

"we don't want people to feel Anxious" -Mihoyoverse-

[@OsaZen992]

When they introduced the Chronicled Wish banner my only problem with it was that a guaranteed didn't stay until the next banner. Like why would they ever think using the fate point system would a good idea, the mechanic that makes people call the weapon banner a scam. I thought we would get a new chronicled wish every other version, maybe every third version, probably some sort of Liyue version since the first one was Mondstadt. I looked at the Liyue 5 stars to theorize who would be on a Liyue Chronicled wish. Obviously Qiqi and Keqing would be there, and probably also Xiao, and Ganyu, and after that I really didn't know who could be there. I didn't think they would put archons on it, so I ruled out Zhongli. Childe released in 1.1 and was pretty involved in the Liyue story, so maybe he could be there. Hu Tao could be there, but from my understanding she still sells pretty well so I didn't think she would be on it. Same goes for Yelan, maybe even moreso than Hu Tao. Then I thought Shenhe since even though she still only had 1 rerun, she could get one with Wriothesley in 4.6 and then be on Chronicled wish in 4.8, but that didnt happen. Now its looking like they are just putting Baizhu on banners so they can put him on a Liyue Chronicled wish. So I thought that they would just skip Liyue and go straight to Inazuma. Without Raiden that could have been done with Ayaka, Yoimiya, Ayato, Kokomi, Yae, Itto. But with Baizhu getting his 2nd rerun in 4.6 now I think that they are giving us a Liyue Banner again and are just waiting for it to "have been long enough" for Baizhu to be on a Chronicled wish banner. I honestly wish they could bring back the Chronicled wish and just make it something that happens from time to time, just so we can avoid situations like this, where 3 5-stars have been completely unavailable during all of version 4, and 2 of them even got skins in 4.4. I obviously want them to fix the fate point system, and just let the fate points carry over, because the only reason why they don't is to incentivize spending so you don't lose your fate point and therefore your chance at getting the character you want. I have been playing since 1.0 with some breaks here and there, so I already have several limited 5-stars that I rarely use, so at this point I just want constellations for my favorites. Im a Ganyu main, and it has been more than a year since the last time I had the chance.

[@Axterix13]

The problem with the weapon banner isn't the fate point system, though. It's that it requires two fate points, meaning you'd often have to go to the full 240. Of course, not an ideal system. A better company/team would have solved the issue by having the banner give us a box instead of the featured weapon(s), and we could open it and pick either weapon. This solution would mean no need for fate points, 160 wishes max to get the weapon of your choice, the weapon banner wouldn't be instantly ultra-garbage the moment an overly niche weapon you have no use for is the other featured weapon, and would only be reliant on the normal pity, so would carry over across banners. The reason why they went with the fate point mechanic, though, is simple. It let them re-use existing code that supported having multiple featured things, while having a 50/50 system of sorts in place.

[@OsaZen992]

@@Axterix13 The reason why I say the fate point system is the reason why the weapon banner is a scam is that it doesn't carry over. It would absolutely be better if it was just down to the 75/25 and if you win you get a box to choose between the weapons like you said. But it would be way better than it is now if fate points didn't get removed with every banner or when you switch your target. Right now if you will have any less than 210 pulls, it is really risky to pull on the weapon banner unless you want both 5 stars. If fate points could carry over, then pulling for weapons would immediately be way less risky because you would at least be able to guarantee getting what you want at some point, even if you dont have 210 pulls saved up for one banner. And I 100% agree that they chose to use fate points because it would require less effort to make.

[@iamfilledwithcalculust9579]

DAMN IT I’VE BEEN SAVING FOR SHENHE!!!😭😭😭😭😭

[@thesparklegirl3236]

Same

[@ankitjadhav6775]

They will only release on Ayaka banner

[@marcus2259]

Maybe its time to tell some secret. Just wanna say as someone whos f2p but has a bunch of characters with average 30crit value per artifact piece (54+ max) and also have 3x 50 crit value pieces. The technique is just simply grinding at a specific time (😏) everyday for a week in only one domain. Feels like theres some sort of hidden pity per week per domain and time also matters. Just try every time frame of the day ( morning, afternoon, night or dawn and observe what works for you).

[@komi-samabeliever7319]

Man, I'm glad I got my Eula from that ordeal. On the hindsight now, dodge a massive bullet there, ain't no way I can keep my calm knowing they owe me my pity by keeping the damn banner. That guarantee reset still the most infuriating thing ever. That alone really set in stones what they intended to do with this banner.

[@tsugikuni.michikatsu]

I have problems with the rerun patterns as well. I want to get shenhe, but at this point, I don't have any idea when she'll rerun. worst thing is that, there are other characters that I need to get as well, such as archons. so deciding when to save and pull is hard when it's like this.

[@ribztercabz2222]

I got an idea, they could've just put them all on a standard banner and instead of just getting random 5 and 4 stars they could have us set up our own drop table with older characters then pull from that using standard pulls. tbh there's no reason to gatekeep us from their ever expanding roster, they'd still make money if we'd pull from even the standard banner provided the characters are desirable other gacha games with now huge rosters even would find a way to have you own old characters, sometimes for free even. it sounds dumb really. theyre not gonna pull in new players who have been planning to get the characters from the older regions. I'm so curious with how they're planning all this. they're like those devs with games that depend on their thriving whales, not caring about the new ones, and that's just lazy.

[@sakura_branches]

the thing that sucks is that the chronicled wish would actually be a great system if they implemented in. not a perfect one, i wish guarantees carried over and it lasted the whole patch, but it'd allow players to get older characters and weapons. while the one we had may not have been a very strong lineup, i could see a banner with smth like baizhu, xiao, and hu tao being better. i still wouldnt wish on it very often as a f2p but i could see myself throwing the occassional 10 pull at it if the character lineups look good. the problem is that they for whatever reason they decided to run it once and then never bring it back again. i hope they bring it back in natlan just cuz the rerun situation is getting ridiculous. even though it couldve been better it was still a faster way of running older characters and the fact they just forgot abt it is sad

[@matdan4576]

Wuwa doesn't kill genshin,it was genshin that killed itself

[@Nagataeatscorn]

I love how WUWA players need to mention the game anywhere and everywhere 💀

[@Lilleliliao]

wuwa players stop mention other games every 5 seconds go !!

[@boboverlord1]

​@@Nagataeatscorn All I see is genshin players randomly mentioning WW out of nowhere like this comment section lol. And y'all still have the audacity to tell WW players to stop mentioning other games.

[@ankitjadhav6775]

Nah, Wuwa Forgotten and gone ,Meanwhile Genshin getting ready for another shining moment

[@boboverlord1]

@@ankitjadhav6775 Your brain needs examination

[@frishter]

Seems like a good time to have the chronicle wish with the imaginarium theater mode too. I do feel like hoyo don't respect us though.

[@jacoblineberry1788]

As someone who has been playing since around a week or two after the game's initial release and has only missed maybe two weeks worth of active days for mostly unavoidable exhausting personal reasons in total, you're absolutely right about how bad it feels being a veteran player. As far as veterans are concerned, the chronicle banners as they've set them up are pretty much the least tempting things that could exist. Sure, I might want Albedo cause I lost the few times I decided to go for him and didn't go for him the other times cause I was saving for characters who were gonna release an update or two after him because I love his voice actor and his story and design, but I'm not going to spend the same currency I have to save or use on promo-characters on that banner. With upcoming characters and the tight time-frame I have to get them and others I might want; especially if I decide to go for their weapons, there's just no way I could justify spending so much as a single wish on that sort of banner. Maybe if it used the same wishes as the perma-banner. Maybe if they carried over. Maybe if they lessened the amount of wishes to make up for just how much they're shoving into a single banner that is basically meant to serve as something like a dollar-bin at Walmart. Maybe if they made it so you are literally guaranteed the character you pick every time you go through it. Maybe if they made the wishes cost half as many primos if you spend them on that banner. As it now though, I can't justify it.

[@Lindy-nw9rd]

the greed of cai haoyu knows no bounds 😒 thank you for making this video to resolidify why I never wanna spend money on this company again. also when she he's banner finally releases after 2 years, people are more likely to spend $$$ for her since they won't know when she comes back 😒

[@xeniver1]

I don't think Hoyo will ever win back my admiration and respect for how they handle Genshin, VoidEnigma framed it perfectly everytime i play the game i just feel manipulated, i'll never spend any money on Hoyo games again.

[@Niddy_Gritty]

Why the heck is he so greedy and stingy

[@SorarikoMotone]

please stop spreading misinfo about Cai Haoyu HE IS A TECH GUY he did nothign but work in pre-release of the game. he left the game after release, much like with hi3 (david was in control when that game was stingy, aka since both cn and global releases). this is an open info you can learn if you actually follow interviews with the company. in fact - after genshin's release, he was working on a shooter game within the company.

[@SorarikoMotone]

@@xeniver1 ....welcome to gacha games? lol

[@Niddy_Gritty]

@SorarikoMotone "Uh sure" After he left HI3 things got WAY BETTER and everyone who plays HI3 knows that as a fact

[@heatseeker9573]

"How long would someone have to wait if they joined Genshin Impact for just Shenhe", hey... HE'S TALKING ABOUT ME

[@dancerdancer215]

at this moment of time, you should be glad that you didn't invest your primos in her. i've invested a lot in ayaka c2r1 and shenhe c1r1, and guess what?... top freeze team with kokomi and kazuha C2 is not able to clear some abyss chambers in time . i didn't played for a year, and now even did more researches to improve my capabilities with ayaka freeze to make it work (while before it was working anyway), but that didn't help me... the second team usually was raiden c3r1 national... but now was forced to make it work with international ( with a lot of tries because its aoe team while monsters cannot be grouped) and in second team to put a weird team with damage based on raiden with sara. so ayaka c2r1 and shenhe c1r1 are sitting on the bench. for you to now i'm practially f2p , its just the case that i was collecting primos for 6-9 months to invest more in a few specific characters

[@yuuzelthyc9683]

"The only thing that I think keeps this game alive is the characters" Actually the lore kinda keeps me going

[@piie6603]

Yeah.... the lore of THE CHARACTERS

[@maxroy6933]

​@@piie6603which are hidden behind artifacts and manga 🤣

[@piie6603]

@@maxroy6933 and the 40 hours of boring dialogue

[@Axterix13]

I don't think low sales would be a reason to not do the banner. I mean, it makes the few players who want those characters or weapons happy, and, hey, not like you want to re-run those low interest characters on the regular banners. System is already implemented, so it'd likely turn a profit with the major work already done. I think, instead, they just don't know who to put in the banner. They can't put Shenhe on there because of a dumb rule they made for themselves, so who do they add as a third with the #1 obvious choice not allowed? Hu Tao? There are also only 2 Liyue standard banner five stars... and there will be 0 for Inazuma. The city theme sounded cool for Monstadt, but they didn't think ahead. But really, they're Hoyoverse, and more, specifically, the Genshin team. The Genshin leadership crew, especially in PR, is kind of special. For example, they don't announce through the in game notification system when their live streams are. Just how incompetent do you have to be to overlook that? They don't go for easy wins like giving a few 10 pulls of standard banner wishes for the anniversary stuff. That sort of thing. They're pretty dumb in a lot of ways.

[@StarSeeker1]

I literally got an ad for ZZZ in the middle of this video ☠️

[@moashiyodi4424]

If you are a older player then you know this isn't their first rodeo keeping their word so not a shocker

[@RoseCookiASMR]

i feel the fact that each update gets less content to 100%. i mean, what was that dainsleif archon quest? it felt so rushed and i was done with it within 2 hours without skipping the dialogues. i loved genshin so much but now its just so unsatisfying and im sad that im so unmotivated to play this game. same with hsr sadly. im too unmotivated to even run this game and play the story because im still kinda frustrated about the fact hoyo literally forced me to build imaginary trailblazer in order to kill the grand theatre boss the chronical wish banner was a nice idea for sure i finally got tighnaris bow and albedo but its a shame they dont continue with it. the upcoming characters are pretty boring to me, i was hyped for columbina but since shes gonna be cryo im not even sure if i should waste my primos on her (i whine about it alot but i dont care, i love columbina and i cannot accept her being any other element than anemo) and i would just love to have ganyu, zhongli or hu tao in my collection. but maybe they will do the chronical wish banner every x.5 patch?

[@aintailstweentales7964]

...... You do know you can use the free pre-build imaginary MC for the theatre boss in the story right? You don't actually need to build your harmony mc you just need to unlock it, are players just blind and didn't see it in the characters list?

[@RoseCookiASMR]

@@aintailstweentales7964 i mean to farm the mats. i alrerady beat the story long time ago but its a pain to kill since my none of my imaginary characters use break effect, and the only break effect dps i have is boothill but the boss doesnt have a physical weakness, and the second phase is just pain because of that shieldwhich im too dumb to break quickly enough and urgh its just annoying,. the third phase is pretty cool tho and no none of the people i could get a support character from chose the imaginary trailblazer as a support character

[@binsarm9026]

Hoyoverse realized the BIG boo-boo when they thought what the Inazuma Chronicled Wish would look like - even if Raiden was not on it - the sheer value of getting ANY Inazuma 5* was TOO good for the players - not to mention the weapons too !! (Haran, Mistsplitter and even Redstone - i would happily take any of those !) i predict they will combine BOTH Liyue and Inazuma and then put the least popular ones on it.

[@a-non6238]

Considering Inazuma has no standards they might actually end up doing that. Would help sabo the weapon pool potentially with the shield required Liyue series too. Or I could also see them merging Inazuma with Fontaine which also has no standards but that seems even more far off.

[@binsarm9026]

@@a-non6238 they will probably combine Fontaine with Sumeru - although Sumeru is probably as "bad" as Mondstadt and can get it's own Chronicled banner whereas Fontaine is even MORE stacked than Inazuma !! :D

[@WordsOfTheTeacher]

I’ve been waiting since I STARTED THE GAME OVER A YEAR AGO for Shenhe and Ganyu. I’d also shell out so much fucking money to pull on Keqing directly but despite being money hungry some characters they just won’t sell

[@WordsOfTheTeacher]

Worth noting that not only are they not taking my money for those characters but now that I have hope for chronicled banner with Ganyu and Keqing (and Shenhe MUST get a rerun soon… right?) has me withholding ALL of my money for them and skipping new characters and basically everything, in *all* of their games. Haven’t spent money to pull since… Acheron? Or chiori/Eula? I can’t even remember

[@ddobleg1623]

I would suggest dividing old characters into two categories, those who You are not going to re run ever again, klee, tartaglia, eula and throwing them into the permanente and them using a separate banner that rotates quicker with the other ones, or just thro everything into the permanente and make it so You get a 5 star something in the permanent every 25 wishes or so

[@eclipse5708]

Actually there's one other benefit to Chronicled which was the main reason I wished on it- it allows you to guarantee Standard 5*s. I've been playing since freaking 2.0 and I've never once pulled Keq or Mona in Standard or 50/50 losses, the RNG keeps giving me Jean, Diluc, and weapons over and over and over and over. Chronicled actually let me pick Mona instead of waiting for the RNG to tell me I can have her. Sadly with the first one only focusing on Mondstadt chars I haven't been able to do the same for Keq and I'm stuck waiting for either Chronicled to return or for the RNG to actually have mercy on me.

[@xvgarnet]

I am a Tighnari main but I started playing after he was featured so I didn't have his weapon, so this banner was a godsend to me. I think the idea of this banner is good even if you need to have 180 pulls to secure what you want, but at least in that banner you couldn't lose to qiqi, keqing or any other standard banner character other than the mondstat ones. My guess is this was going to be true for other regions, but I think Hoyo realized that characters from other regions are actually very good and "losing" a pity to Yelan or Hu Tao, for example, is something they can't allow. Hopefully, with wuwa in the picture, they will realize they can no longer do what they want and retain their players.

[@09ULTR4]

What’s crazier is that idk why nobody thought of this but if a character hadn’t had a rerun in a while, why not just put them on the standard banner? Boom, everyone’s happy, no new banner is needed, and spending primos on the standard banner actually has a point now

[@dragondesabysse2258]

They are legally not allowed because they was advertised as limited character and they could get in legal trouble in china if they do it because of that

[@EdgeLie]

Legal issues, china has many laws

[@09ULTR4]

@@EdgeLie oh yeah I forgot about that

[@ProjectLethargic]

I think one of the best things about the chronicle wish banner is that it gives weapons like Tighnari and Dehya's signatures, aswell as stuff like the jade cutter that doesn't have a character attached to run now that double banners are in play

[@Asali-l8x]

I agree with ya video I've been playing a lil over a year and I'am still waiting on Shenhe and Ganyu ☠

[@LMC-xz6qh]

6:43 that's literally what I did, I prioritized Klee (and lost 50-50 and got Albedo, but managed to get Klee on early pity). Thankfully I was able to get Neuvilette too.

[@basilhibiscus6119]

I’m so frustrated too with them taking Genshin payers feedback, and add it to new gacha games instead of adding it to Genshin

[@propooperplays]

HYV: "We got feedback for Genshin. What do we do?" Employee: "Double all of it and give it to Star Rail and ZZZ." HYV: *promotes them to Employee of the Month*

[@slayerking88]

I started playing Genshin last year, after Shenhe was last in the banner. When I encountered her in the storyline, I ended up liking her a lot. I ended up farming for her mats, I also have a R5 fav Lance, and a pretty good set of artifacts for her ready to go. I was able to get all of these items ready after Chronicle Wish Banner was announced. I expected for a Liyue banner to have happened by now and I'm really disappointed.

[@Stormcrosser]

I just want to say that this Chronicle with banner or whatever it is it's coming in hsr and it's the same thing if not even worse because for the light c you have 50/50 but in the game the original light c banner is 75/25

[@chibisamus447]

The background music at the end was sooo fitting!

[@glaq]

The parasyte ost, a man of culture I see🔥

[@RipeFreshOranges]

I have a great idea for Genshin every 1000 wishes you can 5 star choose two characters and you will randomly get along with the two a 50-50 but no matter what since you are going to get a character like you will be happy. I have only gotten one 5 star character and I have been playing for a long

[@VeliaOwO]

The Chronicled Wish banner has some issues, but the biggest issue really is that it isn’t even rerunning TwT Why does it take them so long to run a second one?

[@Hoyo_Finally_Rerunning_PJC]

8 months later still chronicled wish, what a cI0wn company hoyo is...

[@Koulechov]

man i wasted 40 pulls in that shit

[@ThePenguinsKing]

Then you have 40 pity when it comes back

[@sakaom]

wasted 76, lost my 50/50, had like 78 pity and didn't get my damn bow 😭 at least the lost 50/50 was a good weapon

[@maxroy6933]

​@@sakaomthis will make you mad , you know what i lost to???? FUKING EULA'S WEAPON ..... IT'S NOT EVEN GOOD ON ANY ODY EXCEPT EULA AND I DONT HAVE HER ARGHHHH ( BECAUSE I DONT LIKE OR WANT HER )

[@maxroy6933]

​@@sakaomthis will make you mad , you know what i lost to???? FUKING EULA'S WEAPON ..... IT'S NOT EVEN GOOD ON ANY ODY EXCEPT EULA AND I DONT HAVE HER ARGHHHH ( BECAUSE I DONT LIKE OR WANT HER )

[@sakaom]

@@maxroy6933 i feel you haha i started maining freminet because of that damn mondsdadt banner. tried to get amber a weapon FOUR TIMES, failed them all. when i got one of the best claymores in the game i took it as a sign lol

[@xChaosFlower]

I completely forgot this existed. I skipped it since I had the characters already, but was shocked it just vanished. I thought it would last longer

[@neanahidden]

The pity not carrying over is mind bogglingly stupid. It does so in every other banner. Especially when it uses the limited banner pulls. (Also I’m not risking getting Eula even for Albedo cons or the hunters path 😅)

[@mozzy2968]

I was kind of under the impression it was gonna be more of a yearly event thing, but it would make a lot more sense to tie a yearly special wish banner to the anniversary.

[@komgoo4974]

I bought Ganyu skin at 4.4 due to it being on sale and expecting Ganyu to rerun soon since when they released Ayaka skin they made her rerun one patch later. Its 4.8 with a ton of pulls in my bank and just hoping each patch they rerun a character that hasn't gotten a rerun in 380 days as well as her best support cause I am as well saving for Shenhe. Now to screw the few cryo fans I'm pretty sure they will rerun Shenhe and Ganyu in the early patches of Natlan to give the archon and whatever harbringers or dragons there all the spotlight and I will have to chose between getting characters who haven't rerun in over a year or the characters that are influential and important for Natlan rip.

[@a-non6238]

The archon at least should be guaranteed to rerun within 5.x and is a safe skip if need be. I woulda said all characters before 5.6, but considering Wrio was early Fontaine and still doesn’t have a rerun… 😬 As someone waiting for Kaveh cons (who now wants Kinich & will likely need to dodge a 5* again, ironically Ganyu the first time) I feel the pain and REALLY hope your ladies come back soon. Honestly feels like a scam to sell skins of characters with a limited time discount and NOT release the actual characters for like a year+

[@kuro0021]

I think the solution will be a “New permanent standard banner” for each region so that it stays all the time and player at least have chances to try their luck, I know it’s gacha so “selecting a character” inside a standard banner will be impossible to ask from Hoyo.

[@kaminaridenki._.]

You chose a great example, i joined to get ganyu in 1.2 and didnt get her, and only a year later i got her ;-;

[@Hoyo_Finally_Rerunning_PJC]

Meanwhile... I joined for primordial jade cutter in fontaine... it never came... then came back for natlan... it never came... 100 years go by and my son tries to get PJC but it never came... another 100 years go by and my grand daughter tried to get the PJC to commemorate me but failed to do it in her life time( the cycle continued)

[@sffb8295]

As someone who came to Genshin and saw Shenhe for the first time (I initially came for Wanderer because I dig his aesthetic and gameplay), I really wanted her. It's been frustrating to wait for her while also wanting some older units to pull for such as Albedo.

[@claire98]

Yeah they're so shady with those banners. I might even fully quit Genshin because of it.

[@SorarikoMotone]

...welcome to gacha games, they all are, genshin's one of the least tho.

[@vincentwolf1456]

@@SorarikoMotone One of the most* I play multiple gachas, none of them has such an scummy weapon banner. It's downright criminal.

[@ThePenguinsKing]

@@vincentwolf1456 this banner is better than the weapon banner. People also ignore the fact you can lose to a limited banner character. It has weapons that aren’t rerunning which are best in slot for some characters.

[@Melotaku]

Are you only here for the gacha? There’s a huge game there too you know.

[@claire98]

​@@Melotaku You're right. There's so much more wrong with genshin, it's not just the gacha. Tedious world quests you can't skip, puzzles that are making less and less sense with each update (especially in that added Liyue region), world quests with barely any action and a whole lot of talking that wastes your time... I was willing to overlook that since I still liked exploring. However, the way they're running their banners is the last slap in the face I can take from this company that does not care about its playerbase at all.

[@lunaring5340]

Shenhe has been my most wanted character for years. I joined just too late to get her first banner, missed her second, and have been suffering ever since. My disappointment that this golden opportunity vanished into thin air is kind of crushing . . . Using her as an example hit a bit too close to home.

[@zgmf-x20astrikefreedom21]

Just like on HI3, they should at least slowly add the older limited 5* characters on standard banner, that way we have a chance to get them....but yeah, I can't see them doing that at all 💀

[@kurniawandelima]

HI3 has higher powercreep issue. Old characters just won't make it for abyss or MA. That's why they can rerun S rank chars in HI3 easily. But in Genshin, old characters can still perform well, albeit perhaps because of stagnant difficulty of contents but I digress.

[@mura-e1i]

Lately I feel like Arlecchino is the best thing they've released in a year of updates, haha. Let this guy cook, the video is awesome - shocked at the facts!

[@Chockitkat]

Im so glad that you said that this game can be cleared with any characters. The meta hypers make it such that you MUST get Kazuha, Furina, Neuvilette, etc. like as long as your characters deal 1000000 damage, it's genuinely not a problem.

[@sleeppss]

Yeah, somehow in the first few years everyone was happy even with 4* now everyone wants the meta shiny team I do blame hoyo partially cause 4* now arent as good as before

[@SorarikoMotone]

fr tho i play itto mono geo, before that i was a razor main who successfully defeated raiden shogun on rank 45+ with undergeared characters, including that razor. in no way i EVER felt a need to pull for any of these. so i pulled what i liked - itto, cyno, wanderer, childe and lyney. out of these, i only played itto, to the point that he's my first and only c6r5 5*. fully f2p, after 3 years of slowly pulling on his banners. so what if geo is not the best element? its the best element for me!

[@Chockitkat]

@@sleeppss honestly to me, you just need to get Venti, who is able to group everyone, and everything else becomes so much easier. One Venti can be run with 3 different 4*s, and all you need is a healer for him to be sustained. I do hope Genshin releases better 4*s in the future though, especially for hydro

[@Chockitkat]

@@SorarikoMotone oh my goodness you're a goat... You actually make me wanna start playing Itto even for funsies, and I'm so glad to see someone else who agrees that META isn't the only way to go in this game. Dedication is what you need in this game, and players like you make me remember why I'm still playing Genshin impact. And I feel you so much, it's like I love playing characters that people say are shit, back then people were like Kokomi is better you should pull for Raiden and Kazuha, but I skipped both of them because I knew she was exactly who I needed to run with Keqing, and back then she was such a lifesaver for me. And later on I got other characters like Ayato, Ayaka, Kazuha, Hutao, Shenhe, Itto, Klee, Albedo, Xiao, and honestly while they may suffer in some teams I do think the fun of Genshin is exploration and experimentation in team comps to make them work. I am really glad you're having fun with Itto, and clearing Raiden with an underleveled Razor at AR45 is absolutely amazing 😍 thanks for sharing your story to me too, I'm just so glad I'm not alone

[@xvgarnet]

The meta is not to beat the game, but to get 36 stars in the abyss which is the only hard content in the game. You can get 36 stars in the abyss with 4 star characters only but it can be really really hard, especially since 4.7 abyss which really went up on difficulty compared to previous ones. Casual players who only want to do the story and don't care about the abyss can beat the game with the hydro traveler.

[@MarcSy]

I agree with you. I was also wondering what happened to the CWB. Genshin doesn't care about us, their customers. That is why I I'm now F2P and easing my way to quitting. I refuse to play anything else from Mihoyo, I hope a lot follow suit too. Natlan will be a turning point to a lot of us. I even lost interest on what keeps me playing Genshin, the story. My artifact RNG is terrible that its been up to years since I'm able to upgrade anything.