What Happened to The X-Men Explained! (The Westchester Incident) - LOGAN

[@BobaTalks]

Thank you for all the support on this video!

[@bwyandotoomuch4507]

BobaTalks i

[@lps_bazarsparks2179]

BobaTalks Np!

[@tony46126]

Bryan Alvarez Someone said old man logan was to tie with deadpool kill the marvel universe knowing the hulk, spiderman ( Miles Morales) are the only survivors.

[@urdad3611]

BobaTalks I

[@khalidalsallal4942]

Thank you very much for the explanation.... Just one more question what happened to him that made him heal slow?

[@linkjourney422]

What’s more devastating is that this film takes place in the new X-men timeline that was created in Days of Future Past. That means that no matter what happened the outcome would still see the extinction of the X Men

[@magixgworl]

Oh damn that’s depressing

[@nickgarcia3319]

but if professor x dies in logan how is he ind DOFP?

[@ennardidk1987]

@@nickgarcia3319 DOFP: 2023 Logan: 2029

[@georgeridden1705]

Oh........

[@ennardidk1987]

@TJ In the opening of the movie in a podcast they say "It's 2029, nobody cares about mutants"

[@dtcoas]

The Westchester event would be awesome as a deleted scene on the DVD.

[@chrisr03]

Wait, they shot the westchester incident?

[@mor_xn_o768]

skkansndiduwbbw jfkwjwirankskwkqkks no. It was mentioned but they never shot a scene

[@chrisr03]

Lisa i was being sarcastic

[@rafakeitaro]

Making it it’s own solo movie could be a great idea

[@zoxyy.1x]

@@rafakeitaro bro that’d be pretty dumb

[@Lukeupx]

Am I the only one that was waiting for a rock to move when Laura changed the cross to an X.. 😭

[@thefreeencyclopedia7244]

Just Like Batman V Superman

[@princevegeta1647]

I was waiting for a hand coming out of the grave with adamantium claws. :'(

[@serenityisablessing8386]

WalkerSlayer there is an alternative scene with his claws poking through the rocks.

[@roigipot8120]

WalkerSlayer No.

[@roigipot8120]

Shawn Kirkland It was a fan made scene genius.

[@ayemaiself5985]

Westchester incident would be a post credits scene worth waiting for.

[@J.L.The-runt]

Now it's really sad if you think of it, how Xavier saddens day after day with what he has done with the mutants, accidentally too

[@BobaTalks]

Definitely!

[@Jordan-mq4wj]

J.L. Sprinkles it was more sad and heartbreaking watching how broken down and tired Charles and logan were than there actual deaths.

[@breakdancerQ]

I think leaving out the Westchester incident was brilliant, because it would've revealed way too much. Leaving it out definitely makes the watcher interested and try to piece together what the world is like now. The movie also does a great job at gradually giving away clues to piece together what happened to get a raw picture of what happened as the movie progresses. It's unfortunate that we'll never see on screen what exactly happened but I also think not seeing that event on screen makes gives it even more tragic. It's for everyone to speculate now how that event went down.

[@Vasun05]

So spoiler Anyways I always think that Charles wanted to meet the children that escaped so he could see young mutants one more time and teach them how to control their powers like he was a teacher again because that was probably where he was happiest

[@billmcreary1092]

Vasun05 Yeah when you see Charles meet the little girl for the first time you can see it bring life back into him again😢

[@Vasun05]

Now now don't cry here have some onions cut them for me please :)

[@Vasun05]

That was such a dramatic shift but I also think that is why Logan accepted the job initially along with the money. Charles Xavier was the happiest he has ever been so Logan thought okay I'll take the job. Then when he discovered the coordinates were from the comic I think one of the main reasons he was so angry was not only because it was a waste of time but also because it would destroy Charles worse than anything else. My question is were the coordinates just one to follow or did someone specifically place the coordinates there

[@ThatGuy76985]

The nurse and children got the coordinates to Eden from an X-Men comic book. Logan stated that most of the stuff written in those comic books were bullshit and never happened, and Eden was one of them. So yeah, it's most likely those coordinates were just put there for entertainment purposes by the comic book writers. BUT, there still is the possibility that there is something there at those coordinates.

[@Puppy_Puppington]

@@Vasun05what do you means? Didn’t the film itself have the nurse & children pretty much use something they all were into and knew ? Coincidence or fate that it happened to be coordinates they were feasible lol. That is up to one’s beliefs about our universe. Or I guess maybe the fictional one lol

[@phillipcarbin7394]

the real question is what effect does these anti-mutant toxins food do to humans. and what about magneto since he has his helmet wouldn't that protect him from Charles Xavier's seizures?

[@jamiebraswell5520]

You assume that Magneto is even alive in the 2023 timeline. He is not shown, nor is Mystique. We do not know their fates when the timeline is reset.

[@jntravels23]

Phillip Carbin wait what about Deadpool??

[@jntravels23]

Phillip Carbin i kno he wasnt part of the X-Men but has anything happened to him??

[@phillipcarbin7394]

Deadpool was not in the movie. So who knows what exactly happen to him. My guess is we will see what happens in Deadpool 2.

[@jntravels23]

Phillip Carbin yeah wait what about Colossus?? And N.T.W in the Deadpool film? They was part of the XMen weren't they??

[@Culturefocusededutainment]

The westchester incident could be a whole movie by itself. Using elements of Mysterios mind tricks and Xaviers tremors killing everyone as a prequel to logan.

[@BobaTalks]

That would be cool!

[@Luison40]

rgoddess69 twenty century fox doesn't have the rights to use Mysterious character or even mention it, so forget about him ever being in a marvel movie

[@danatay5508]

@@Luison40 lol have you seen the spiderman trailer?

[@DCMarvel2009]

Personally, sounds more to me like something that the Shadow King would do because he just hates Xavier that much.

[@HangingTurkey]

That's been done already, kinda. X2 was about Charles being captured and almost killing all mutants

[@N3m0_o...]

the incident of westchester is not many years a go....one year a go in the events of logan

[@chimofcb92]

Andres Calderon Ikr? Every video I've watched about this topic says "many years".

[@N3m0_o...]

chimofcb92 You said it, in all the videos, but in the movie they say it by radio just after the incident in the hotel...one year...not many

[@skyediver]

Yeah, I'm with you. Very clearly in the movie it says on the radio that the Westchester Event was one year ago, not "many years ago". Kept throwing me off when this otherwise interesting video kept saying that clear mistake.

[@bratton79]

Definitely happened one year prior to the events in Logan. I also remember that the mutants had been poisoned, so their powers were already waning when Prof X had his epic seizure that killed them all. The poison damaged Logan's rapid healing abilities explaining why Logan can now age and why his adamantium is now slowly killing him. He needs alcohol to dull the pain that he is constantly in. This was really a wonderful film, a true masterpiece.

[@freddypedraza2066]

Andres Calderon I hope you are right, I don't see how Jean Grey could die from that, she's stronger than him, and Jean Grey was killing people by accident in the comics first

[@JJ.McCorley]

I love the way they did this. It means that initially we don't know what's happening. When Charles doesn't remember he utter's the line, something along the lines of, "Logan, What did you do?", for people who know the Old Man Logan comic you initially assume that this all happened somewhat the way it did in that comic, but then we later get a payoff with the twist that it was actually Charles - really works well. I'm glad that they didn't include the scene, even later as a flashback as I think it would have been too distracting from the Laura story

[@TejanoBarrera]

So we got Jean and Cyclops back again at the end of Days of Future Past, and now they're dead again. Disappointing 😫

[@octaviancaesarhibernicus4447]

Edward Barrera Cyclops is a wanker and the Phoenix storyline is one of the worst in X-Men.

[@altirius]

@@octaviancaesarhibernicus4447 yes i hate cyclops

[@Dr.HooWho]

@@octaviancaesarhibernicus4447 nah

[@himayamata]

Somewhere in the afterlife, Apocalypse is laughing at Professor X.

[@Vethsoddities]

as he should 😌💅

[@burningheart2909]

This movie should've had flashbacks while Prof. X was having seizures, with all neighboring X-Men dead beside him. I mean, it's cool and all to hint and tease about the plot, but it helps with the flow of the story, even for those who've read the comics. Besides that, Logan was badass for all the scenes with his claws out, ammiright??

[@briankelly9052]

There will be more x men movies set after apocalypse, if they explained everything those movies will be ruined.

[@flukerjoy]

Exactly

[@rogueproductions9011]

@@briankelly9052still waiting on those lol

[@Andrew.Grabowski]

During this video, i theorized that cerebro (the machine professor x uses to find mutants) is somehow involved in the westchester incident. Think about it. It makes more sense if cerebro overpowered Charles head during his seizure (maybe his first seizure?) Forcing his powers to be spread so far throughout all of westchester and killing those that may have been trying to stop it or those that were closest to him (physically, i mean). Thoughts on this theory are always appreciated!

[@ProperlyGaming]

Once i realized what happened while watching this movie i felt heartbroken. Charles xavier the one who looked at these people as his students, his children, his team only for him to be unwillingly responsible for their deaths all due to him having some sort of degenerative brain disease. Logan trying his best to keep this heartbreaking information from him, to protect his father/mentor. Truly a heartbreaking story, but also a story with a hopeful ending with potiential mutants who can take up the mantle of the x-men again and be the heroes the world will inevitably need in the future.

[@264amdx]

I think the fact that they didn't include a flashback scene just added more suspense to my experience. It was a sort of mystery to me and several different clues indicated that it was Charles' seizure that killed all the X-Men. I think if they added a flashback it would have taken the mystery of that underlying story and it would not have given the movie viewers their own imagination of how it all happened.

[@Dr.JohnCampbell_]

Thanks for the feedback contact me for your new year reward ...✍️✍️✍️I have something special for you🏆 Congratulations 🎉🎉

[@iswaterwet1897]

wait in days of future past when hank says that they might not be able to change the future caise of the river always flowing in the same direction does this mean that charles killing the x men is a result of wolverine stopping the sentinels as the x men still need to die for the river to carry on flowing

[@hikimaq8623]

That’s what i first thought of, but now i think it’s just the people, Magneto was right, there was never a chance for mutants to live among humans, no matter how much Charles tried, the future always gonna be bad because of the hatred and fear in ordinary people

[@Balder-gb4eq]

spoilers you've been warned they could have included a short version of the westchester incident just before Charles remembers and x-24 puts his claws in him

[@Dr.JohnCampbell_]

Thanks for the feedback contact me for your new year reward ...✍️✍️✍️I have something special for you🏆 Congratulations 🎉🎉

[@ncv4183]

I just dont understand how jean would've died seen as her mind is op asfuck

[@Dr.JohnCampbell_]

Thanks for the feedback contact me for your new year reward ...✍️✍️✍️I have something special for you🏆 Congratulations 🎉🎉.

[@negahertzzz9079]

you deserve more than 100,000 subscribers

[@BobaTalks]

+Nega Hertzzz Thank you!!

[@augustodelima3854]

I really liked what they did with this movie. Letting us the audience figure out what happened and focusing on the main story, otherwise it will be all about the incident and not about these amazing characters and their relationships and how they dealed with what happened in the past.

[@Dr.JohnCampbell_]

Thanks for the feedback contact me for your new year reward ...✍️✍️✍️I have something special for you🏆 Congratulations 🎉🎉

[@hazod3156]

The director did it perfectly

[@BobaTalks]

+Jason Dewitt agreed!

[@lilopasha8762]

my big question is, where was magneto when the seizure happened?

[@KiritoSA00]

Lilo Pasha Died, i guess.

[@zigsterabs7439]

Lilo Pasha my guess is he dies of old age. If he was murdered, it would have been mentioned in the movie. If he was alive, he would have been mentioned

[@pdwAF]

Lilo Pasha dead man. He was a good bit older than Charles & Charles is old as dirt

[@guitarheroaddict12]

Lilo Pasha maybe at one point somehow magneto died plus with dealing with old age caused Xavier to breakdown overtime

[@kingoliver3743]

I wanted to see Charles power kill the xmen not to sound bad I just wanted to see that play out

[@thefreeencyclopedia7244]

King Kenneth, lol. im laughing now for some reason. power kill. 😂

[@Dr.JohnCampbell_]

Thanks for the feedback contact me for your new year reward ...✍️✍️✍️I have something special for you🏆 Congratulations 🎉🎉.

[@Justmyhandle]

*Here's two big questions I'm still pondering after having seen Logan, feedback and speculations are welcome:* *1)* Did Charles develop this degenerative brain disease naturally, was it always going to happen and he just didn't realize until it was too late? Or did Xander Rice's plan with the anti-mutant toxins in food first cause its early stages to start? *2)* If Charles could access and track the minds of every mutant in the world through Cerebro (or every human, as Stryker's son Jason demonstrated in *X2* ), how did he never once get information from anyone's mind about Rice's plan?

[@terryforsdyke306]

1) an interesting point, which I never concidered, I had assumed naturalybut the anti mutant toxin is not impossible and based on the timeframe that could also be why Logan's healing factor had reduced to the level it had. 2) Charles could track/read minds anywhere using Cerebro but he only used it to try to find mutants to train. Charles would not have got information for several reasons; he avoided deliberately reading minds Rice's plan to elimanate mutants was probably known by less than a hunderd people and at most a few thousand, out of 7+ billion, at most one in a million people (and probably far fewer) would have had knowledge of that plan, so Charles could have specificly went looking for knowledge of the plan while in cerebro and not found it. The chances of stumbeling onto it accidently are literaly millions to 1 against.

[@Justmyhandle]

*+Terry Forsdyke* Great point regarding Cerebro, it makes sense that he wouldn't investigate the growing lack of mutant births by deliberately searching through and reading everyone's minds against their will. It's also possible that his condition was ironically a result of gradual mental deterioration from all the times he used it over decades. And Mystique poisoned him with it once before. That accumulative neurological strain is bound to have long-term effects even on a brain as powerful as his, which further justifies why he didn't use it every time it could've easily solved a conflict. Cerebro was always a rather dangerous creation that Charles knew carried heavy potential risks.

[@mr.clippy7815]

Keith this is my theory,Remember that moment in first class where magneto uses a coin to peneatrate shawn skull while charles is controlling is brain?well,I think that was the cause of his is disease because in the movie you can see charles in pain because hes feeling what shawn was feeling and propaly cause some sort of disease in his brain.

[@Dr.JohnCampbell_]

Thanks for the feedback contact me for your new year reward ...✍️✍️✍️I have something special for you🏆 Congratulations 🎉🎉

[@MCharlerySmith]

They should've showed the Westchester incident; it would've added some much needed context and colour to the film. It was quite depressing and felt empty without any other core characters making an appearance. As much as Wolverine is the X-Men's centerpiece the movies have shown he's not strong enough by himself and he works better as part of a team of super powered characters.

[@Dr.JohnCampbell_]

Thanks for the feedback contact me for your new year reward ...✍️✍️✍️I have something special for you🏆 Congratulations 🎉🎉

[@officialtreyway6405]

My question is Even tho Logan healing factor is slow And when he got stabbed into that tree at the end Wouldn't he eventually heal?Slow but hell heal?

[@zigsterabs7439]

Justin Bieber he was physically harmed to the extent that his healing factor couldn't heal him anymore. He also overdosed on the green drug (forgot what the name was)

[@UnderEmir]

He was impaled from his belly

[@craigstafford7851]

Justin Bieber like all things with time, bodily functions subside with age. In this case, his powers subsided. Nothing lasts forever. Mutants will die one day. Logan was getting older and his powers were declining. In addition, he was told not to overdose on the medication he was given, but he did. The affects of it gave him a vey limited quick rush, but as it too would subside with time, his body couldn't continue to function at that rate anymore and it accelerated his mortality.

[@fraezma]

Justin Bieber He can't heal if he's dead

[@LibeliumDragonfly]

He'll eventually crawl out of dirt if somehow they convince Hugh Jackman to reprise the role again.

[@redhotmixes9386]

Thanks for the explanation man

[@BobaTalks]

Thanks for watching!

[@mcribs1280]

also if they showed the incident we would literally have to see every xman die or be left wondering if beast made it out

[@mcribs1280]

or why didn't Jean grey come back to life

[@michalpiskorski9731]

Logan has the most dramatic and sad life ever. In the other hand I think his attitude is inspirational

[@Grizzlybear0908]

I think the best way to have put that in was through a anniversary. As logan comes home, the radio is playing a broadcast remembering those that died suddenly on that tragic day...

[@nico74321]

I hope they make a prequel right before the incident happen. it'd be cool to see professor x busted all brains out of x men and become a fugitive

[@Dr.JohnCampbell_]

Thanks for the feedback contact me for your new year reward ...✍️✍️✍️I have something special for you🏆 Congratulations 🎉🎉

[@mattgilbert7347]

The radio report we hear in the film is cut off at a crucial point "..people were killed, including several members of the.." Cut. The next phrase would have most likely been "X-men" or "Xavier school".

[@Dr.JohnCampbell_]

Thanks for the feedback contact me for your new year reward ...✍️✍️✍️I have something special for you🏆 Congratulations 🎉🎉.

[@overheatedeskim054]

i bet the reason they didn't do the scene is because they didn't want to pay for all the actors to come back of a small scene

[@CephlonMayngrum]

They did in deadpool

[@BMW9661]

@@CephlonMayngrum No, he meant the original Xmen trilogy actors, not the prequel actors. This takes place in 2029, after the original X-men DOFP ending, it would have featured Halle Berry, Anna Pacquin, James Marsden, etc.

[@Dr.JohnCampbell_]

Thanks for the feedback contact me for your new year reward ...✍️✍️✍️I have something special for you🏆 Congratulations 🎉🎉

[@Beastmode-jb8hv]

I appreciate you making this video to help me make more sense of what happened. It really kind of breaks my heart that someone couldn’t write a better ending than this. We are talking legends amongst so many generations of people. I watched X-Men cartoons as a kid and to find out now I’m middle-aged and they all just kinda died because one of them had a seizure..? That’s a tough pill to swallow. Poor writing in my opinion. I wish they would’ve hired someone better to do the job.

[@Tej132]

btw where's Deadpool in all this mess

[@cakeistasty-yy38]

tejas tayade across the border in Canada... he is Canadian....

[@daoyang6055]

He's probably somewhere else at this point.

[@sungod9797]

Immortal.

[@Royalstl]

This comment is golden knowing we get the movie soon😅

[@ribaalhijazi9139]

The movie as it is, is perfect 👌

[@Dr.JohnCampbell_]

Thanks for the feedback contact me for your new year reward ...✍️✍️✍️I have something special for you🏆 Congratulations 🎉🎉

[@dragontamerjosh8501]

There should have been a short 10 minute scene at the start of the movie showcasing the events that happened before the main storyline.

[@Dr.JohnCampbell_]

Thanks for the feedback contact me for your new year reward ...✍️✍️✍️I have something special for you🏆 Congratulations 🎉🎉

[@rikilethbridge632]

The fact that Logan woke up in 2023 at the end of days of future past where everyone is alive, but then only had 5/6 years before everyone else gets killed by Xavier is sad

[@Dr.JohnCampbell_]

Thanks for the feedback contact me for your new year reward ...✍️✍️✍️I have something special for you🏆 Congratulations 🎉🎉.

[@1091494alvin]

Thank you for making this movie mean a lot more to me! Subbed and liked!

[@Dr.JohnCampbell_]

Thanks for the feedback contact me for your new year reward ...✍️✍️✍️I have something special for you🏆 Congratulations 🎉🎉

[@lovexcruz]

The part that confused me as well was Jean Grey was at the end of DOFP when logN woke up but she died in the dark pheonix which took place after the days of future past… can anyone explain this part to me as well?

[@nlikos180]

She didn't die. She flying as flame at sky.

[@thedarkbeforethefallout8357]

People clicked 👎 just bc he asked, saying it would HELP his channel. I gave it a like bro. Good points. Nice presentation. I'm glad we have guys like you, willing to give folks a reason why, or how and the fine print in movies that have confusing twists etc. Thanks again. -Tdbfa

[@Dr.JohnCampbell_]

Thanks for the feedback contact me for your new year reward ...✍️✍️✍️I have something special for you🏆 Congratulations 🎉🎉

[@kmustapha6455]

maybe magneto is taking a bath when xavier having a siezure, who wear a helmet when taking a bath right?

[@Dr.JohnCampbell_]

Thanks for the feedback contact me for your new year reward ...✍️✍️✍️I have something special for you🏆 Congratulations 🎉🎉...

[@khylerbane4523]

I like to think Magneto was wearing the helmet but Charles was so powerful that the helmet did nothing.

[@drummerstar1190]

the xmen died due to an ilussion of mysterios and made wolverine wipe out the xmen then when he found out what he had done it scared him.and thats why he is how he his in this film

[@Dr.JohnCampbell_]

Thanks for the feedback contact me for your new year reward ...✍️✍️✍️I have something special for you🏆 Congratulations 🎉🎉.

[@yourordinarystranger366]

The thing is, we know in general how many died. But we don't know who all is still here. We know scott and the beast etc are still alive from deadpool. But we don't know who's all alive. It's so weird for them to do all these movies and days of future past just for everyone to be dead

[@Luison40]

I don't like having to guess or think of theories while watching a movie, I want things straightforward, so yeah, I would have very much appreciated to see the westchester incident either at the beginning of the movie or as flashbacks during it , I had to start watching videos like this one after watching the movie in order to fully understand what te hell happened in this film , it was very good but tragic as well and I didn't like the fact that they didn't show this incident at all

[@Domasiukas]

Luis Perez I had a completely different reaction. I came to the cinema expecting Logan to have killed the X-Men (like it happened in the comics). In the beginning he does not tell Charles what happened, so I thought that Logan is keeping it secret to protect his butt. But we saw the hotel scene mid-movie. AND THEN I saw the TV report and realised just how wrong I was. It hit me even harder than major deaths.

[@91friedegg]

Maybe they'll flush it out with sequels.

[@agrumbler2872]

You might like things straightforward but most people prefer subtlety

[@kinggeo3165]

I would of likes to have seen it aswell if this is the last xmen movie it should be explained not so we get hints at what happend

[@rainbowcloudss_]

the report on the radio stated that the westchester incident happened over a year ago, it caused 600 injuries and killed 7 mutants.

[@cuevagrafica]

And the Deadpool came and bring bye bye bye back in 2024!

[@isthatmarri1221]

This is the prime reason I hated this movie. Days of Future past was the perfect ending but then here comes this. The xmen were taken out by a damn seizing Charles. Like really? After all they been through to survive jus for them to go out like that

[@ImWhyMortalsCry]

Man it was so sad after the casino insident how Charles was like "I'm sorry, I'm so sorry"

[@matthewhummel1572]

Cool video, I also agree with the director, but I would like an option on the blu ray to have it in an extended version.

[@FrankyFango]

I wish that part was not cut out of the movie, that would've been a big epic-dramatic opening of a super hero movie ever!! and i wish it's in the deleted scene on the DVD or Blu-ray!

[@Dr.JohnCampbell_]

Thanks for the feedback contact me for your new year reward ...✍️✍️✍️I have something special for you🏆 Congratulations 🎉🎉.

[@henrynunez6691]

I just have to say when will we get some more X-men movies coming up soon.

[@MrSnapy1]

Great film! The continuity of the whole Xmen timeline has been torn to shreds over the years.Like I said great standalone film just each movie has its own timeline universe it seems.Which is really hard to build upon when you redo timelines every single film.

[@Dr.JohnCampbell_]

Thanks for the feedback contact me for your new year reward ...✍️✍️✍️I have something special for you🏆 Congratulations 🎉🎉

[@bryanwilmarth1435]

First of all, THANKS Boba for a job well done!!! Your explanation was a pleasure to listen to! I'm a subscriber, now. Secondly, I like the way the movie opened. Showing the actual Westchester event at the beginning would have made the rest of the movie kind of bland. I would, however, like to have seen some flashbacks of the event...maybe 1 or 2 of the X-men or students dying as Prof. X has a seizure. I pieced together what had taken place leading up to Logan but I somehow missed any reference to some sort of anti-mutant agent put in the food supply by the government. I'll have to watch it again. That was a big downer for me, not knowing why mutants weren't being born any longer. Thanks for the insight. So, yeah, flashbacks of the Westchester incident would have really been cool. One thing I didn't like is the Prof. using the word F***. It shocked me and it just seemed out of place I guess you could say. Again, job well done!!!

[@Dr.JohnCampbell_]

Thanks for the feedback contact me for your new year reward ...✍️✍️✍️I have something special for you🏆 Congratulations 🎉🎉

[@YOLO-ft4jt]

how come that jean cannot stop professor?

[@freddypedraza2066]

Germel John Marata poor fox writing

[@chenvang9926]

X Men apocalypse erases that timeline where Jean died in the last stand

[@marianburge2210]

yes, I would have loved to have that included if not in the beginning maybe with Charles recalling a memory maybe with X23

[@Dr.JohnCampbell_]

Thanks for the feedback contact me for your new year reward ...✍️✍️✍️I have something special for you🏆 Congratulations 🎉🎉.

[@willpaulson8417]

I would love to see the incident in an extended blue ray release with the older actors involved.

[@blazestar2914]

Will Paulson yeah me too

[@Dr.JohnCampbell_]

Thanks for the feedback contact me for your new year reward ...✍️✍️✍️I have something special for you🏆 Congratulations 🎉🎉

[@johnjordan8722]

Long story short charles had a seizure like he did in logan but in this case he killed most or all the x-men

[@jameskobegonzalez5228]

John Jordan but the radio said a year ago like in 2028

[@johnjordan8722]

so what?

[@spencergadoury]

thank you for this video! I really loved this movie very very much.

[@BobaTalks]

+Spencer Gadoury Thanks & me too!

[@spencergadoury]

BobaTalks it was sort of confusing in the film but when you brought up the incedent I forgot they even mentioned it in the movie.

[@ststes]

Spoilers It was said the film through a news / radio broadcast after Prof X's second in film seizure that the same thing (Prof X accidentally hurting people because of his seizure) happened year ago resulting in many injuries and deaths including the X men. It was Logan that want to buy the boat and get Charles away so he couldn't accidentally hurt anyone. Logan kept Prof X kind of drugged up both the suppress his powers and seizures and so he wouldn't remember that he was the one who killed the X men. At the start of the movie Prof X didn't remember what he had done.

[@Dr.JohnCampbell_]

Thanks for the feedback contact me for your new year reward ...✍️✍️✍️I have something special for you🏆 Congratulations 🎉🎉.

[@galaxybreadgameplay1470]

Great explanation i understand and you got another sub

[@BobaTalks]

Thank you!

[@altirius]

So basicaly charles killed jean,scott,storm,hank,ice man,collosus and kitty pride?since raven was killed in dark phoenix and charles,caliban and logan are dead in Logan(2017) the x men are all dead?😢

[@Dr.JohnCampbell_]

Thanks for the feedback contact me for your new year reward ...✍️✍️✍️I have something special for you🏆 Congratulations 🎉🎉..

[@hollyroxy25]

I agree that it shouldn't have opened with the Westchester incident, but it still would've been nice to see a flashback to it when Charles was remembering what happened.

[@Dr.JohnCampbell_]

Thanks for the feedback contact me for your new year reward ...✍️✍️✍️I have something special for you🏆 Congratulations 🎉🎉

[@Cam-cv4ok]

enjoyed the vid keep it up

[@Dr.JohnCampbell_]

Thanks for the feedback contact me for your new year reward ...✍️✍️✍️I have something special for you🏆 Congratulations 🎉🎉..

[@madnesscombat6973]

What I really wanted to know was when did the X men figure out when the anti mutant toxic thing stopped mutants.

[@TB-wj2ve]

Should have opened with the incident. The characters of old man Logan and x23 are big enough not to have suffered. Meaning it wouldn't take away from their storylines. Now you have people stuck with unanswered questions. Don't know about anyone else, but I like to know everything mentioned.

[@Dr.JohnCampbell_]

Thanks for the feedback contact me for your new year reward ...✍️✍️✍️I have something special for you🏆 Congratulations 🎉🎉.

[@A-myth]

Yeah would have like to see it somewhere in the middle of the film. Wolverine was the fav character, but others were also loved, and just removing them without any warning does not give closure to fans.

[@Dr.JohnCampbell_]

Thanks for the feedback contact me for your new year reward ...✍️✍️✍️I have something special for you🏆 Congratulations 🎉🎉.

[@Suhailee91]

i would of preferred them to explain the incident in the opening scene

[@Dr.JohnCampbell_]

Thanks for the feedback contact me for your new year reward ...✍️✍️✍️I have something special for you🏆 Congratulations 🎉🎉..

[@timothymoore2197]

I just watched Logan for the third time, and after watching, I think it would have been better if the movie explained the incident a little more

[@frankthebutcher6679]

people really don't understand the movie? fuck....the timeline isn't even as confusing as they make it out to be either....pay attention to the movies it's all there......this movie was the best one in my opinion btw...just the perfect end to an epic franchise

[@parkb5320]

The Westchester Event couldn’t have been that long ago as the movie Days of Future Past takes place in 2023. And I believe at the end of the movie Logan changed history and the X-Men were still alive and Professor X seemed ok. Logan takes place in 2029. That means that the Westchester Event had to happen during those short 6 years in between. Seeing as how it all seems like ancient history, I’d say it would have had to have happened very soon after Days of Future Past. Logan went through all that trouble to save his friends only to see Charles kill them all a few months/years later.

[@alexandercisneros5679]

If you guys hear very closely that it took the lives of seven mutants right? But when logan turns off the radio IF you listen closely the person on th radio said including several of the X. That means some of the X men are alive in, i guess that those X men are at Eden

[@TheGamePlaySociety]

THANK YOU! some people just don't understand the words these writers so carefully use. 7 MUTANTS died INCLUDING several X-Men. Now, this is up for interpretation. It could be 4 regular mutants and 3 X-Men..? 3 regular mutants and 4 X-Men?

[@amreenzinia7938]

No, It’s not because of their healing factor it’s the adamantium skull because Mageneto’s helmet is made of adamantium and that is why Professor X cannot get through to Magneto because the helmet blocks it because it is made of adamantium and so is Wolverine and the girl so that is why. 2:31 to 2:32

[@Dr.JohnCampbell_]

Thanks for the feedback contact me for your new year reward ...✍️✍️✍️I have something special for you🏆 Congratulations 🎉🎉..

[@NAYNAYREAY]

I think we should of seen the westchester incident in a flashback around half way through the movie 👌

[@mathieuduval7544]

i have a question for you and maybe its a dumb question, but why is logan dying not healing is he "infected" by the adamandium or something like that????

[@thegreatducktektive7860]

he is too old

[@primal8724]

the adamantium fused to his bones has started poisoning him and impeding his healing factor.

[@th3alley]

Maybe i missed it but what about why Charles blaming Logan for the death of the Xmen??

[@yurrmace]

Had Eric been the soul leader of the mutants, he would’ve had change the fate of the mutants.

[@ehawkins1971]

Movie states it only happened one year ago, and many people including 6 or 7 X-men...click, Logan turns the radio off

[@thesprintmaster]

i think it would have been cool if there had been a flash back of the event either right at the end of the movie, or as a post credit scene; that would have been different but still cool to actually see it.

[@Dr.JohnCampbell_]

Thanks for the feedback contact me for your new year reward ...✍️✍️✍️I have something special for you🏆 Congratulations 🎉🎉

[@TheShapeshifter]

I really wished they showed this

[@Dr.JohnCampbell_]

Thanks for the feedback contact me for your new year reward ...✍️✍️✍️I have something special for you🏆 Congratulations 🎉🎉...

[@BadKid95US]

Im pissed they didnt put it in the movie, in this movie The Good People die people that fought their entire lives for justice. This movie would have been so good if we saw how Xavier took out the only hope left so sad but cool & just insane.

[@Dr.JohnCampbell_]

Thanks for the feedback contact me for your new year reward ...✍️✍️✍️I have something special for you🏆 Congratulations 🎉🎉.

[@thebatman7347]

I wouldve loved to see a powerless Magneto with Logan and Charles, imagine, the only one who could cure Logan powerless and deppresed and the beacon of hope for mutants turned a dangerous double edge sword

[@mcribs1280]

good idea to focus on the characters not the timeline of events a lot of comic movies should take note

[@Dr.JohnCampbell_]

Thanks for the feedback contact me for your new year reward ...✍️✍️✍️I have something special for you🏆 Congratulations 🎉🎉.

[@m4xecution151]

I would have loved to see the Westchester scene at least in an extended version of the movie :p

[@Dr.JohnCampbell_]

Thanks for the feedback contact me for your new year reward ...✍️✍️✍️I have something special for you🏆 Congratulations 🎉🎉.

[@Koldeman]

In a deleted scene, Charles says that Logan killed Jean Grey. Perhaps some of the Mysterio storyline could have happened but it was Charles who messed with Logan's mind during seizure.

[@Dr.JohnCampbell_]

Thanks for the feedback contact me for your new year reward ...✍️✍️✍️I have something special for you🏆 Congratulations 🎉🎉

[@angquangnguyenthac2833]

It was the original trilogy continuation, in which Logan did kill Jean (now dark Phoenix).

[@dankcentral8334]

This movie was really disappointing due to the lack of actual information and it forcing us to be confused the whole 2 hours of watching the movie

[@decayingSineWave]

He had the seizure whilst hooked on that machine

[@Complication84]

It was better that it didn't show it. It kept it grounded in Logan's story and the setting of the current world.

[@Dr.JohnCampbell_]

Thanks for the feedback contact me for your new year reward ...✍️✍️✍️I have something special for you🏆 Congratulations 🎉🎉..

[@MedalionDS9]

Awww it's Baby Boba

[@scarletolsen3644]

2020 So in X-Men Dark Phoenix Magneto has an island maybe that is Eden in Logan

[@Dr.JohnCampbell_]

Thanks for the feedback contact me for your new year reward ...✍️✍️✍️I have something special for you🏆 Congratulations 🎉🎉...

[@angelzhell02]

Quicksilver should survive this cause he has healing abilities too

[@Dr.JohnCampbell_]

Thanks for the feedback contact me for your new year reward ...✍️✍️✍️I have something special for you🏆 Congratulations 🎉🎉..

[@orionxavier9169]

I'm glad he didn't shoot and add that scene into the movie. Not knowing exactly what happened added an extra depth to the film

[@BobaTalks]

+Orion Xavier916 Yeah I like the fact it leaves it up to the imagination of the audience

[@mr.nobody7760]

Does logan know that charles killed all the mutants and how did he survive but phoenix not

[@madbagger75]

charles should have had a nightmare flashback in vegas of westchester that set off his current. episode tieing it together...

[@Dr.JohnCampbell_]

Thanks for the feedback contact me for your new year reward ...✍️✍️✍️I have something special for you🏆 Congratulations 🎉🎉..

[@omightyyoda]

I liked the decision, certainly as a movie opener it would've been "too big", but some quick flashbacks would've been great. Either way, Logan is by far my favorite super hero movie of all time

[@Dr.JohnCampbell_]

Thanks for the feedback contact me for your new year reward ...✍️✍️✍️I have something special for you🏆 Congratulations 🎉🎉

[@marclennon6957]

Hi boba need to make this quick don't wanna get spoiled don't wanna watch any Logan related vids cause haven't seen it hope you understand and I can tell they're awesome talk soon!🤝

[@BobaTalks]

That's ok thanks for stopping by and hope you enjoy the film buddy!

[@ethanspataro5994]

They should add the scene into another x-men film

[@Dr.JohnCampbell_]

Thanks for the feedback contact me for your new year reward ...✍️✍️✍️I have something special for you🏆 Congratulations 🎉🎉..