What Happened with the Christians of North Africa and Levant?

What Happened with the Christians of North Africa and Levant?
♦Consider to Support the Channel of Patreon and gain cool stuff:
/ knowledgia
♦Please consider to SUBSCRIBE : goo.gl/YJNqek
♦Music Used :
Kevin MacLeod - Send for the Horses
Kevin MacLeod - Cambodian Odyssey
Kevin MacLeod - East of Tunisia
Kevin MacLeod - Drums of the Deep
Kevin MacLeod - Impact Allegretto
♦Sources :
www.alhewar.com/Saliba_Christi...
www.internationalbulletin.org/...
www.britannica.com/topic/Rash...
www.britannica.com/topic/Abba...
www.encyclopedia.com/environm...
#History #NorthAfrica

[@Knowledgia]

Hello there guys, we know we normally don't ask this, but our narrator : Royal Carter, has a very close friend who has been diagnosed with a terrible disease. He asked us to put a link to a support page, to be visible for you. Here is the page : www.supportful.com/2423cf3e-97ea-492c-9ab2-b23fe8847957 We are sure that any small support from you would help. Thanks guys!

[@abdulazizawil4954]

Knowledgia Now I wan to see a video of “ what happened to muslims who were a majority in Spain , Portugal , Brazil , Philippines , Crimea ? “ or this channel is biased.

[@realityismerelyanill]

@@abdulazizawil4954 brazil?? Hahaha

[@velos8899]

@@abdulazizawil4954 Brazil??????? Philippines????

[@bluestar4324]

Dude, this video's comment section is unbelievable. I got countless insults without a reason.

[@velos8899]

@@berkinturkylmaz3643 Muslims in Brazil....Tell me the facts Einstein...

[@sewarhorani]

title: "what happened with the Christians of North Africa and Levant?" me *confused*: "I'm right here"

[@Prototyp810]

You aren't north African only muslims are in my opinion 🇩🇿🇲🇦🇱🇾🇹🇳

[@sewarhorani]

@@Prototyp810 im middle eastern

[@kaijixpapa178]

@@Prototyp810 well north africans where of many religions before islam :)

[@kaijixpapa178]

@@Prototyp810 the golden age of north africa was pagan times

[@ziyadpepe6291]

@@sewarhorani Good ... say only middle east next time.

[@alfredthepatientxcvi]

I am a Christian from and living in the Levant! And proud to be one! 💒❤❤💒

[@efthymiosanagnostos7427]

Assyrian?

[@alialahmad4329]

@@efthymiosanagnostos7427 dude they could be arabas greek arman assyririan and many other

[@jordanianchristian8387]

Efthymios Anagnostos yeah I’m Arab and Orthodox Christian.

[@ilham5221]

Are You a Greek. Not Middle East people.

[@jordanianchristian8387]

Media Ilham I don’t know if your talking about me, but my dad is 100% Arab and my mom is 99.96% Arab and 0.04% Italian. So no I’m not Greek but I am Middle Eastern.

[@George-le4jl]

Greetings from an egyptian christian ✝️☦❤

[@teyanuputorti7927]

hi

[@luanasari5161]

hu

[@reefmohammed3553]

Kiss my feet fucking coptic christianism

[@JESUSCHRIST-nk4cl]

We have Christian's in Egypt

[@user-yq3vt5sk6n]

??

[@laser679]

No one: Knowledgia: A-rab

[@johane4764]

I thought I was the only one getting a little ticked-off by it.

[@frendselgiel7675]

George dubya's pronunciation

[@oran9519]

Ayy rab

[@rodneyLee336rlb]

such bias seeps from his voice. A- Rab not Ah rab? exclusion of Ethiopia that has a longer Christain history the Europe. just full of micro aggression.

[@ianmoone705]

Thats how youre supposed to pronounce it, pleb

[@babylonking6104]

Greetings from a Syriac Orthodox Christian

[@ziyadpepe6291]

طز

[@charbelyb9917]

God bless you syriac brother

[@Amar90]

Greetings my brother from Iraq 🇮🇶

[@Bigbustarhymes]

Greeting from a Syrian muslim Arab

[@Bigbustarhymes]

@@ziyadpepe6291 why u say that

[@kxrys9254]

Greetings to all christians in Middle East from Croatia

[@stantorren4400]

H G why? One’s a simple country that exists today while the other was the sick man of europe

[@draki9722]

Catholicism < Orthodoxcism

[@alvaro6587]

@@draki9722 its pretty much the same thing

[@Charlotte-td8qq]

@@draki9722 Catholicism > Orthodoxism

[@darkoracic9694]

@@draki9722 🚜🚜🚜🚜🚜🚜🚜🚜🚜🚜🚜🚜🚜🚜🚜🚜🚜🚜🚜🚜🚜🚜🚜🚜🚜🚜🚜🚜🚜🚜🚜 on your tractor, Turkish son!

[@samyrandome425]

"It is believed that Izlam originated in Arabia" nah some sources say it might've originated in imperial Japan

[@BSKX17]

@Yusuf Isa sarcasm cuz the video said 'it is believed', like there are other possibilities

[@charlesandrews2360]

There is absolutely zero contemporary documentation regarding the beginnings of Islam. What should the narrator have said? Everyone knows Islam started in Arabia? And there's very strong circumstantial evidence that Mecca was not the holy city. A hundred million people believe that Mecca is the holy city. How about you? Osaka? Kobe?

[@charlesandrews2360]

@Hus23iq okay 1700 million

[@rendiar.mp4]

Nah it's From Ulm

[@samyrandome425]

@tarnagueda djata lol what

[@manetho5134]

4:25 the rashidun were not a dynasty, they were elected in Medina, rashidun means rightly guided

[@eifelitorn]

Yeah, he seems to correct himself at 5:28. Weird he kept that part in.

[@gaigairka6811]

It was a republic, until it was usurped by a hereditary monarchy

[@gaigairka6811]

@Somali Kid because it was seized and taken over

[@Omegaeon1]

Somali Kid tribal society was still in place in arabia, republic is not suited for a tribal society ( aka libya ) you need to have a king or a dictator to keep thing stable, also rachidunes were people who are highly regarded in islam, it’s hard to be compared to them unless you’re like...Umar ll the Umayyad caliph

[@Omegaeon1]

Somali Kid the thing with republics, with rachidune or rome, is that it leads sometimes parties to fight each other and corruption grows , a monarch like Muawyia was fit for the job.

[@ebramemad7199]

Iam a christian from egypt 💒💒💒and proud to be one

[@blackhacker2810]

Me Too !!!

[@AdamIbrahimX]

I'm a Muslim from Egypt and you are my brothers and sisters guys ❤❤

[@ebramemad7199]

@@AdamIbrahimX thank you🥰🥰❤❤

[@AdamIbrahimX]

@@ebramemad7199 You don't have to thank me you just like me we are Egyptians regardless of your or my religion, when i followed my family history i found that i came from Christian Family 900 years ago so we all related brother ❤

[@blackhacker2810]

@@AdamIbrahimX ❤️❤️❤️

[@danyawaraji6536]

Thanks for this video I'm from Lebanon an I'm Christian Orthodox. Middle east isn't just for Islam's!

[@Kinghassz]

Dany Awaraji muslims*

[@bidorbidor8035]

en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assyrian_Church_of_the_East

[@velos8899]

Respect orthodox brother.

[@bluestar4324]

Lands doesn't have religion, people have.

[@kutkinderen]

@@bluestar4324 people like the Armenians that you genocided?

[@egyptianboi305]

They still exist btw Alot of my friends are Coptic Christians In Egypt

[@budahbaba7856]

How are the Coptic people doing? I have been hearing about a lot of persecution ever since Egypt destabilized a decade or so ago. Any word?

[@egyptianboi305]

@@budahbaba7856 nope no prosecution just a few extremists here and there from both sides some Muslim Egyptians hate the Christian Egyptians and vice versa as for persecution No there is no persecution whatsoever unfortunately tho both the Christians and the Muslims in egypt can't stand the Jews So that's bad.

[@youssefhany546]

@@egyptianboi305 not when Israel is the enemy of the arab people most people who know there are non-Zionist Jews will say they dint have issues with Jews...

[@egyptianboi305]

@@youssefhany546 I'm talking about the majority of Egyptians,and unfortunately the majority of Egyptians hate Arabs from the gulf countries and the jews.

[@youssefhany546]

@@egyptianboi305 we don't hate all gulf Arabs, and we don't hate all jews... Egyptians hate AL yahood.. Wich is a term we use to refer to Israel, regardless of its actual meaning... We dislike the gulf because they are racist and classist there and they think that they are superior....

[@iraqimapper8625]

Some correction 1-Christian were majority in Levant and Egypt until the Abbasid decline the first time they became a minority was under the Tuluni Emirate, they faced restrictions and sometimes persecution under the Seljuk/Zengi/Ayyubi/Mamluk states that made their numbers decline 2-Christians of Maghrab were few and just represented a part of the population, but the reason why there are almost no Christians in Maghrab is because Almohdons forced the remaining Christians to convert to Islam as a respond to the Norman Crusader Invasion of North Libya and North Tunisia

[@gaigairka6811]

Original Muslims were tolerant and considerate. Mongol invasion ended the Muslim golden age, and Muslims haven't been the same since

[@micahistory]

yeah

[@ba2138]

@@gaigairka6811 The Ottomans were quite tolerant too when it came to religion.

[@MrTristanryan]

Burrelinho - we clearly have a different definition of tolerant

[@ba2138]

@@MrTristanryan Yeah I know that you think about the last decades of the Ottoman's 6 century long history. But you should know that it was the secular ultranationalist young Turks who ruled at those times. The sultan had no power. He was just a puppet. The founder of Turkey, Atatürk, was a member of that ultranationalist party. So I would consider the Armenian genocide done by the Republic of Turkey, not the Ottoman Empire. Just my opinion.

[@adamthaeer217]

A lot of people they did not know Till now 70% Christian in Cyprus 🇨🇾 40% Christian in Lebanon 🇱🇧 10% to 15% Christian in Egypt 🇪🇬 10% Christian in Syria 🇸🇾 7% Christian in Jordan 🇯🇴 5% Christian in Iraq 🇮🇶 3% to 5% Christian in Palestine 🇵🇸 and Israel 🇮🇱 2% in Iran 🇮🇷 1% in Turkey 🇹🇷 More then 95% in Armenia 🇦🇲 ,Georgia 🇬🇪 and 9% in Azerbaijan And there are Foreigner Christian Living in the Gulf countries 20% Christian in Kuwait 🇰🇼 10% Christian in Saudi Arabia 🇸🇦 15% Christian in Qatar 🇶🇦 13% Christian in UAE 🇦🇪 15% Christian in Bahrain 🇧🇭 10% Christian in Oman 🇴🇲

[@adamthaeer217]

Dash 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣 1-Cyprus its part of Middle East 2- I didn’t say Cyprus is a Muslim country 3- I didn’t mention the north Cyprus I side Cyprus 🇨🇾 and there is one island had this name (Cyprus) and it’s part of Middle East Geographically Historically and Culturally and if you said they are Christian there’s 15 million Christian in Egypt more then Greece and Cyprus Population together. So doesn’t matter and there’s Muslim in Albania and Bosnia more then Cyprus people

[@hanialturk5981]

@Dash that’s not the point , Islam during its expansion years didn’t try to Force conversions on Christians at the time

[@bebostrong1]

I think Armenia is 100% christian.🤔🤔

[@basileus6743]

@@hanialturk5981 Haha funny but they forced the jizya

[@basileus6743]

@@hanialturk5981 Haha funny but they forced the jizya

[@yusufal-muqtadir2494]

I'm a muslim from the united states but i went to college in Egypt. And i meet many christians in North Egypt

[@ineptsolaris]

How could you be a Muslim?

[@elmiroble4608]

@@ineptsolaris alhamdulilah proud to be Muslim

[@elmiroble4608]

@محمد شندي they know everything but they don't like us

[@thecpt6265]

@@ineptsolaris How could he? the fuck? Are you serious? You don't find anything wrong with asking someone why he's so and so in such a disrespectful manner? I'm English born and bred, and I'm a Muslim. And I'm damn proud of it.

[@jaroslawk2010]

@@thecpt6265 So how could you be a Muslim? I do not see an answer.

[@rohanchoudhury8043]

Long live Christianity in Maghreb & Middle East ...Long live Jesus in our hearts .Stay blessed all my fellow Christian bros & sis from the earliest Christian settlements & kingdoms ...Love from India 💞💞

[@antarakmit4114]

The amount of likes shows how much they love indian catholic christians

[@Guttenberg.]

@@antarakmit4114 😆😂🤣👍

[@harrypotter12558]

Change ur fkin' name first!

[@malikaabizar8318]

I am Algerian north African I am Christian and proud of my byzantine greek heritage in north africa Mediterranean

[@zakback9937]

@@malikaabizar8318 Urbanite aghyoul

[@AnibalDMasso]

here we are. In my case, my family emigrated from Palestine to Mexico, they were orthodox and catholic christians

[@suleimanhussien1559]

i am from palestine too , and we have many christians which a lot also my friends :)

[@juanohara9025]

¿Osea que tú eres palestino-mexicano? ¿O algo así por el estilo?

[@martinkent333]

Fuck God Almighty.

[@martinkent333]

Fuck Jesus Christ.

[@martinkent333]

Fuck the Holy Spirit.

[@micahistory]

Seems sort of disorganised, I was kind of lost

[@__prometheus__]

Fat Earther yea it is

[@ZiedHF]

There are some wrong ideas as well. Like : Taxes were less for Christians than Muslims.

[@protruth5133]

Basically the piso family created the New Testament

[@lets_wrapitup]

Zied Hf exactly, and they didn’t persecute someone of another faith, as destroying a place of worship is haram

[@micahistory]

@@Alpine1996 yes

[@kaanaslan3003]

Turkey had a large Christian population - about 20% in 1914 prior to WWI. This was reduced to %5 as of 1927 mainly due to ethnic violence, massacres and the world's first formal population exchange between Greece and Turkey. Now Christians constitute less than 0.5% while Muslims around 89% (including non-denominational muslims and secularists).

[@juniorjames7076]

Today lots of Christian Africans (especially from Nigeria) living in Istanbul today. When I lived and worked in Istanbul from 2013 to 2018, on Sundays I attended Church ceremonies, packed with people (not just Africans, also Greeks, Russians, Turks, Iranians, Chinese) in Esenyurt, Sisli, Harbiye, Perpa, Beylikduzu and of course St. Joseph's Church in Taxim. But there's even more evangelical type congregations in other areas. Istanbul is a fascinating city with many secrets.

[@thenamewhowillknockksidown7333]

Notice how he didn't say that Romans killed Christians for years before Romans converted or how romans conquered Egypt

[@3aZM]

Gaps: 1) North Africa at the time of Muslim invasion was alternating between Byzantium and Vandal control, both following two fighting factions of Christianity, this had a negative effect on Christianity in the area. 2) Arabs were not unified under one religion before Islam, so you got Christian Arabs, Jewish Arabs, Zoroastrian Arabs, Atheist Arabs and other.

[@3aZM]

@@siempresonrie5924 Yes after Islam became a thing people were prosecuted for faith but before Islam, Arabs were very progressive and their was a skeptical movement called (الدهرية), we find many poets of that time mentioning their atheist views on life with no fear of prosecution.

[@3aZM]

@@siempresonrie5924 It depends how you measure advance.

[@3aZM]

@@siempresonrie5924 Islam is not Muslims and all the scientist and philosophers that worked on such advances in knowledge were fought by the Islamic society and the Islamic church, and sometimes those scientists and freethinkers were killed.

[@Spellmeister2027]

I thought Zoroastrianism was only for Iranians

[@Spellmeister2027]

Isn’t Zoroastrianism an ethnic religion

[@Boug0014]

Thanks for the video. I’m Moroccan Berber and never understood why Judaism survived in Morocco and not Christianity. I never thought about them leaving but It does make sense given the distance to European Christendom is close. But what’s still baffling is there is no trace to their churches or tombs.

[@elspongebobhh]

ايدتزريتن ارتعيارن امسلمن اوراتيحشامن

[@abdullaevo2745]

لانهم اسلموا ولم يكونوا مشركين قبلها بالصلبان، اما اليهود فقد هربوا مع المسلمين من الاندلس

[@elspongebobhh]

@le le as amazigh in north africa before they were worshiping like false gods until islam came and we accepted islam

[@elspongebobhh]

@le le but there's no christianity in amazigh i know that

[@elspongebobhh]

@le le ok but in tamazight we don't have a words for christianity or jesus we have just islamic words idk but i respect ur opinion

[@bassamtrefi5479]

After the war Syria lost 35% of its population including Christians.

[@-Faris-]

A lot of them fled to Lebanon and Turkey

[@martinkent333]

Tourist love the calm and almonds. Tourists are ALWAYS zombies - immune to reality. They struggle to understand the consequences of wealth disparity, when they visit a trashed country. So they get stabbed, mugged, robbed, raped and murdered and "wonder" about the crime. Zombies devoid of a braincell. Reminds me of the song, "I left my leg, in San Francisco." Their famous cable car has a reputation for SUDDEN stops and being without seatbelts, a number of tourists have lost a limb. Zombies who should check out the dangers online, but are too busy looking pretty.

[@antoinefarag5393]

I’m Christian Egyptian

[@ahmedkadim1851]

HIIIIII😊😊

[@TobinPT]

Be strong!

[@ajzeytoun849]

I am a Christian catholic from Syria 🇸🇾 I want to thank you for this video and want to tell that there are over 2 Millions Christians in Syria 🙂

[@Letthemhate123]

Greatings brother

[@ajzeytoun849]

@@Letthemhate123 greeting back😘

[@celticlad5866]

Mad respect from a Christian Catholic from Ireland. Glad that you are sticking with the very religion that was founded by our Lord

[@Meanthes]

Crusades aftermath :

[@southamptonfan3460]

just a question do you speak aramaic or arabic ? i know syria has 2 languages so its interesting to see whar people think

[@naveenraj2008eee]

Hi sir.... Nice video and very interesting... Your history videos are always nice tp watch.. Thank you....🙏👍

[@DeepSingh-yg7ic]

A lot of Syrian Christian migrated to Malabar Coast in South India , Some of them can still speak a dialect of Aramaic ( language spoken by Jesus )

[@Gal_Flumin]

He spoke judeo-aramaic a dialect of aramaic which spoken by most of the jews

[@DeepSingh-yg7ic]

Like modern day Jews ? I thought they spoke Hebrew

[@Gal_Flumin]

@@DeepSingh-yg7ic no the jews 2000 years ago today the jews speak hebrew and Yiddish

[@DeepSingh-yg7ic]

You are Jew I think . Where are you from Israel or US ?

[@Gal_Flumin]

@@DeepSingh-yg7ic israel and yes im a jew

[@emie6117]

Nice that this is being covered, don't think there is much on this.

[@planets9102]

@@zteaxon7787 someone's a neo-nazi

[@user-cx7pq2pc1z]

This is what God does not love and Unforgivable kzbin.info/www/bejne/mX6Uooeanrygi7s

[@RsahulGameSlayer]

they are still op kzbin.info/www/bejne/rWbWiKCwaJ2pick

[@salmansingh66]

@@user-cx7pq2pc1z shrek? Seriously

[@KHK001]

Great video!

[@ChevyChase301]

No mention of Armenia and it being the first christian state?

[@TormentedToast13]

Armenia isnt in North Africa or the Levant

[@cyrusthegreat1893]

Winston Churchill Armenia is located right in between Iran and Turkey. So, how isn’t it in Middle East?

[@vahekrikorian3581]

Joey Kevorkian , I was thinking the same. Armenia was the first Christian kingdom in the Middle East. The Most interesting part is of this video it never shows the Armenian plateau as being Christian but it show it turning Muslim.

[@vahekrikorian3581]

Winston Churchill , of course it is Middle Eastern. Armenians are from the Southern Caucasus to Northern Mesopotamia to the Mediterranean Cilicia. This is Middle East too.

[@vinifalleroliveira]

@Winston Churchill 1. Did you ever looked at Ancient Armenia map? 2. Cyrus the Great's comment.

[@MinecraftSons]

I need to correct something.Rashidun period not a dynasty.There was 4 Rashidun Caliph (Ebu Bekir,Ömer,Osman and Ali) and they came to power trough some sort of election(we can say council apporoval).All 4 of them came from separete families.

[@sameerhasan8101]

Wow! Bro! The Turkish names of Abu Bakr,Umar and Uthman(peace be upon them all) sound really interesting!

[@MinecraftSons]

@@sameerhasan8101 yeah we cant spell "ع"sound so we usually convert it to"ğ,ö,o,a,e".I m a history student and we take Ottoman Turkish lessons,this "ع" is a pain in the ass 😂.May god make their places haven.The true caliphs.

[@sameerhasan8101]

@@MinecraftSons Yeah. I can understand you!😁

[@neemapaxima6116]

Rashidun "Caliphate"

[@user-ej2gw8vb4u]

mustafa turan Kaval Do you think it was right for Atatürk to Latinize the Turkish alphabet? Is Latin alphabet really more suitable to Turkish than Arabic/Farsi alphabet?

[@alexabihabib8215]

Levantine Christian here 🇱🇧✝️ We are still almost half the population of Lebanon

[@svetlinivanov9550]

Nice

[@anna-maria585]

🥰 love from Greece 🇬🇷🇬🇷🇬🇷

[@torinjones3221]

@@epotato8867 yes but 1/3 are sunni and 1/3 are shia and they basically hate each other

[@arolemaprarath3248]

@Richard Joniec Sadly, Lebanon is re-Islamising amist crises since Maronites are fleeings. This gives the rise of Muslims in Lebanon especially from the Syrian refugees. It's hopeless. Lebanon is an Islamic country......

[@arolemaprarath3248]

@Mathew Also Syrian muslims are flocking in Lebanon making Islam 60% of the population now. Christian is now 20% due to migration.

[@samjquillen]

Every time he says Arab or like any other word I feel like he’s trolling us

[@Georgious]

Captain A-rab

[@haitamc5611]

who the hell isnt trolling us nowadays.

[@MistThief]

Ayrab

[@elswae]

There are 3 ways of pronouncing a in English and ā (ei) is very common in the southern US. It’s just his accent.

[@zs3671]

Let him. It’s why he and his videos lose credibility every time he does that. He thinks he’s smart by doing so - but clearly he reveals himself as a hateful dumbass who clearly knows nothing about world history.

[@gregwright2059]

I absolutely LOVE these videos. Some of the pronunciation is borderline brutal though. Sorty! This is still one of my new favorite channels.

[@revengines8666]

Im a free Tunisian Christian and proud ✝️❤

[@devarim6239]

I am a Moroccan Christian

[@jamesbond2944]

And I am France muslim 😛😛

[@jamesbond2944]

@@devarim6239 I am from Christian country

[@abc_cba]

tell us more about your culture and history

[@revengines8666]

@@abc_cba Well we are a democtratic country, thats on paper supposed to be a muslim one, but many of us are skeptic about it. We dont consider ourselves as Arabs since we live in Africa and not in the middle east(fortunately we dont) so we see ourselves as berbers who are the original citizens of the north African countries (Morocco-Algeria-Tunisia). Some found the way to Jesus and some are still reading and nourishing their minds&spirits, seeking the truth. In our history, we lived for a long time with jews, we consider them as our brothers and neighbours, we also support Israel and we think Jerusalem is the promised land.(If you notice anything thats opposed to that, its actually coming from an Arab country that wants to force another reality to us)

[@galegocossia5506]

Our brothers in Crhist are still there.

[@thatonetroll1059]

@@yaziri7 yea

[@DOJAKtKt]

No one killed them there

[@alqods80]

The big conversion of christians in Egypt came first after 800 years of muslim rule, first after the crusaders, they choose to convert, unlike the conquest-a in Spain where muslim and jews where tutored to covert the jews followed the muslims in north africa away from christians.

[@WildSpartan3000]

They weren't tortured, simply spanish or vanish xD

[@egyptianboi305]

They didn't get tortured Covert to Christianity Or leave Very few were killed

[@egyptianboi305]

@@mohalahs_ XD

[@Unnamed7964]

@@WildSpartan3000 No being spanish wasn't enough, moricos eventually got ethnically cleansed too. You could be persecuted just for having muslim ancestors. The last persecution against moriscos happened as recently as 1727, where the last mass exterminatation took place, several villages werem raided and sacked, many if not the most escaped in north africa. From this point of time no more was left from the islamic influence apart from the genetic impact and some remnants of the islamic religion. There are some inhabitants of small towns in Murcia and Andalusia , which preserved traditions of the Muslim religion (praying toward Mecca , practice fasting during the day in Easter, etc. ) but although it is clear that these people are descendants of cryptomuslims , currently these customs are practiced only by family tradition and people who do it are not aware of being Muslims.

[@winestrauzz1221]

When Marrakesh was captured, according to one source, the Christian church there was destroyed and a great number of Jews and Christian militia were killed. When ‘Abd al-Mu’min conquered Ifriqiya (Tunisia) in 1151, he gave the Jews and Christians there the option of conversion to Islam or death.

[@mantis2048]

Love your videos. Make sure to look up pronunciations on some words, it helps you sound more professional. There were only a few that sounded off to me, maybe you just pronounce them differently

[@RoyalLeoC]

Appreciate the feedback man, ill work harder at it in the future.

[@mantis2048]

Can’t wait for the next video!

[@Matherian2]

Everytime he said "Ay-rab" 😣

[@warriorsrule9350]

Everyone knows ISIL. The Islamic State in Iraq and the Levant. Unless you were hiding in a cave from 2014-2016, you would at least know how to pronounce the word "Levant". But if it's a mental handicap, then I apologize.

[@elsaint7657]

Awesome video well put together good job

[@rashedbash1354]

Started right and ended right , love your work 👍

[@ShadoZP]

Thanks for making a video on this topic. Culture isnt covered much on yt

[@kureganitimurids-mughals7726]

Muslim non Arab also had to pay both zakat ( must pay to the poor) and non Arab tax when umayyads ruled....thats why they revolt and Abbasids take the title

[@JC-fj5qy]

Zakat is not the same as Jiziya lol

[@laithalzoubi54]

@@JC-fj5qy zakat cost more than jizya

[@laithalzoubi54]

@Fuzail Ahmed I think u meant to reply to someone else.

[@popefrancis8153]

@Victor Faouzi No wonder why Jizya was kept

[@theballroom98yearsago51]

@Fuzail Ahmed how is jizya an oppression ? Muslims paid zakat which costs 2.5 % of your money annually,while jizya where a non Muslim can pay whatever they want from a penny to infinity

[@lukeschultz6886]

always wondered about this. thank you

[@romanianrasta4309]

Nice video

[@gipsydanger7379]

Could you cover the rise of Imperial Japan?

[@Knowledgia]

Noted!

[@user-go1zt9ib4p]

Could you cover why Indian still Hinduism

[@alexandervolkov5205]

Knowledgia and the fall in the same vid lol

[@doforget399]

@@user-go1zt9ib4p because of Indian was not controlled by one empire but It devided into thousands of small state and their language was not same. They are fighting for their own value and if they came back go to home without fighting they also killed by their family members and in war area they gone for won or death ( for value of their caste ).

[@warriorsrule9350]

Why? So he can call it Jay-paan.

[@isaacadkins2344]

Greetings from the birthplace of saint Augustine

[@arolemaprarath3248]

Hippo? That is great! Are you a Christian as well?

[@isaacadkins2344]

@@arolemaprarath3248 No i'm actually not! But i have roots from Hippo Regius😁 ( Annaba today)

[@zachfox7771]

did you actually say "a" "rab" when refering to arab, jeez thats bad, lol

[@aaronlandau5575]

"Caw-cass-suss" I love the content, but the attempts at pronunciations in these videos is weak at best

[@Omar_ayach]

I can't see how he said ay-rad it doesn't make sense

[@hashimthaci4590]

I hate everytime when he said ay - rab

[@Cadriul]

He also pronounce the word piety as “Pee-adee” He pronounce some words I thought he’d get wrong fine and then Some I thought he would get fine wrong.

[@kukifitte7357]

@@FreedomFox1 "channel is bad because a non-english speaker narrates" peak american

[@user-go1zt9ib4p]

I Love these channel

[@user-dg5vx8li8f]

انت عربي أيش قال لايكون يكذب ويشوه التاريخ العربي الاسلامي

[@hustlefaith]

Where is our North African and Levantine Christian brothers and sister? 🙌🏽

[@hustlefaith]

Nope but I know they are getting persecuted all throughout North Africa.

[@anis8879]

@@hustlefaith Usually not anything physical. A couple of Chruches closed here and there but they eventaully re-open. As long as you're on your own property the state can't tell you what to do

[@efthymiosanagnostos7427]

Hustle Faith well I’m part Armenian Christian if that counts and Greek. Where are you from?

[@hustlefaith]

Efthymios Anagnostos Philippines but North Africa is like my second home. When I went to Algeria I feel like I was the only Christian walking around. My Algerian family even told me not to visit the Notre dam d’Afrique as I visited ramadan if I don’t want to have problems with people seeing me going to church on ramadan. People has persuaded me so many times if I wanna convert. I kept saying no.

[@efthymiosanagnostos7427]

Hustle Faith oh well both Africans don’t rlly like Christians but don’t convert keep the North African Christianity alive and hope for the best

[@TEverettReynolds]

I am disappointed you did not mention some specific hold outs of the Christian religion during the period, such as Saint Catherine's Monastery on the Sinai Peninsula, where one of the oldest surviving Bibles, the 4th century Codex Sinaiticus was found in the 1850s. Against all odds, this area managed to resist and survive the Islamic conquests.

[@misosoup9616]

Ain't that because of the agreement The Prophet made with them?

[@maddogbasil]

Surprising to see how much ofbthe oldest historical artifacts, practices and even buildingsin Christianity somehow managed to survive in Muslim land Yet we rarely see muslim people, religion or even mosques survive in Christian land

[@monarchblue4280]

@@maddogbasil There are many reasons for that. One reason is because what we call muslim land today already had a long lasting Christian presence. Muslims never really had a long lasting presence in most European countries, but even in some anti-muslim kingdoms like in Spain, Muslim architecture and treasures were protected. When Christian's re-took Sicily under the Norman's, Muslims and all minorities were treated well and kindly. Many arabic maps and scientific treasures from Muslim Sicily were preserved as well. So paint all Christian's under the same brush.

[@dindin8753]

@@monarchblue4280 True christians and muslims do take care of each other even the prophet Muhammad order his followers to go to christian Ethiopia to seek refuge from the idol worshippers in mecca. And the Abbasid caliph send gifts to the holy Roman emperor Charlemagne. And all Muslims conquest is not religious at all until the crusade happen.

[@moukbu4235]

ان كنتم تحبون الله فاتبعوني يحببكم الله ويغفر لكم ذنوبكم

[@Skeptical2424]

Mo Ukbu “فاتبعوني"

[@moukbu4235]

@Ionuț Răducan no death or dumb ppl here mate take your sign language elsewhere pea brain

[@mikeylejan8849]

God bless my christian brothers and sisters in the middle east.

[@malekaltayari3936]

Good bless my Muslim brothers and sisters in Europe 🌹☪️🌹

[@DefenderOfChrist_]

@@malekaltayari3936 that is just wrong

[@iceychilli557]

Love And Support for my Catholic Brothers And Sisters 🇪🇸 🇵🇹 🇫🇷 🇧🇪 🇱🇹 🇩🇪 🇭🇷 🇮🇪 🇭🇺 🇮🇹 🇵🇱 ❤ ✌

[@mortens.7490]

@doc jouj I know some Lebanese people who are all Muslims, none of them is Christian.

[@hassanbassim4007]

doc jouj Western Christians consider middle eastern Christians Heretics .

[@herodotus945]

@@hassanbassim4007 Oh really ? Even if they belong to the Catholic church like the Maronites, dumb ass ?

[@cxarhomell5867]

@@mortens.7490 some of them are christian you dumbass

[@ilham5221]

I thought albanians are just a Islam and Orthodox.

[@Suite_annamite]

As far as I'm aware, *North Africa even produced 3 Roman emperors* (Gordian I, Aemilianus, Septimius Severus) *and 3 popes* (Gelasius I, Miltiades, and Victor I).

[@nziom]

That doesn't make Christianity is rooted in North Africa there were many ethnicitys who ruled the Roman Empire

[@Suite_annamite]

@@nziom No one said anything about "origins": and even if someone maintains that, in the realm of political or religious systems, that nothing came from Africa - be it North or Sub-saharan , well, they should also be careful not to over-exaggerate things that came from the Middle East. *A lot of things are falsely attributed to the Middle East, but came from India.*

[@nziom]

@@Suite_annamite don't change the subject Christianity doesn't belong in North Africa

[@Suite_annamite]

@@nziom *Neither does Islam* , but Christianity did historically make it there first.

[@nziom]

@@Suite_annamite exept in Christianity North Africa was under the Roman Empire rule only even North African Christians couldn't rule there unlike in Islam where North African Muslim's build there Own empire and expand it to an extent never reached before unlike the Roman Empire were North Africans were slave's in Islam they were masters and for the first time in history all of North Africa was united under a single nation Almohad kingdom was a Muslim kingdom but it wasn't under the rule of Middle Eastern Muslim's it was under the rule of North Africans also the ziri kingdom and many other Islamic North African kingdoms were under the rule of amazigh blood line's unlike in Christianity and the Roman Empire Indigenous North Africans never accepted Christianity even after centurys of Roman invasion Christianity never was and never will be a part of North Africa.

[@Viktir123]

His pronunciations have me laughing like it's a comedy video but I'm glad he made the video so we can learn about this.

[@malekaltayari3936]

as a tunisian i like to tell you that the pope of vatican 🇻🇦 back in the old days they were 3 frop north africa two from tunisia and one from Morocco Tunisa:Pope Victor I Tunisia:Pope Gelasius I Morocco:Pope Miltiades

[@anna-maria585]

♥️ Love from Greece 🇬🇷 Be blessed!

[@malikaabizar8318]

I love you Greece north africa I am from algeria north africa and I speak berber your Christian Mediterranean sister long live Christian ✝️ 💙

[@user-oi7sv8vg8e]

Im greek orthdox we are greeks ☦️🇬🇷 greek coumnity in the levant about 2 milon people proud to greek orthdox ☦️🇬🇷

[@davidgil6485]

I was expecting some kind of Turkey-Greece discussion in this video, it's still pretty civilized though

[@michaelkouklakis838]

Oh, I can change that, if you want. :)

[@dr.apollo4226]

David Mankarios Wait, why do Greeks hate Turks? I mean I know a lot of countries dislike Turkey, but why?

[@dr.apollo4226]

David Mankarios Sorry I assumed you’re Greek, your last name kind of sounds like it. Do the Turks still do that or was that a long time ago?

[@dr.apollo4226]

David Mankarios Good to know. Thank you.

[@user-uj2jx5jn2e]

@David Mankarios no in islam if you are poor then don't pay zakat same with non muslims

[@aryachris1908]

Just subscribed

[@efthymiosanagnostos7427]

Many Christians still live there. But let’s talk about Anatolia where 60% were either forced to convert or genocides such as Greeks, Pontics, Armenians, and Assyrians and Georgians

[@hasankidar4646]

There was no forced to convert to Islam. There were many Christians in Anatolia, but after the defeat of the Ottoman Empire, Ataturk made an agreement with Greece to rescue the Muslims in Greece. by replaced Greek Muslims with Anatolian Christians .

[@AsiaMinor12]

Those genocides only happened when the Turks adopted European ideas of ethno nationalism that the Greeks love priding themselves in.

[@alireact1827]

We dont force islam to people. we have no authority of that. but the lands must be govern with sharia of allah

[@sscxcc8053]

Regarding the maghreb : there were many religions not just Christianity : polytheists ( Phoenicians/libus ) , arians , jews... however, a seizable part of tunisia used to speak latin and pay taxes until 13/14th centuries

[@terryplew3333]

Ssc Xcc didn't know that the Tunisians were Latin speakers.

[@nizzam1]

No Tunisia was where Charatage was until Rome invaded and sacked it

[@VALDIGNE]

the oldest Christian churches are in Tunisia.

[@yuvalammar4164]

Latin was the administrative AKA state language it wasn't spoken day to day by local inidigenous in Tunisia back at that time.

[@sscxcc8053]

Yuval Ammar actually tunisia and the maghreb had their own version of latin . Its called african latin and some historians claim it was almost a seperate language (africa here being tunisia’s roman name which much later became the continent’s name)

[@esisteshaan3839]

Heartfelt respect and love to all the persecuted Christians from 🇮🇳

[@2headedtasman200]

This comment section will be stressful.

[@AsiaMinor12]

Not really, even the neo Christians have to admit that their narrative of super evil Islam is not that accurate.

[@abc_cba]

3:25 *You completely ignored the Arab Christian history* You should do some research on Arab Christian tribes and how they developed the Arabic alphabet from Aramean language. Please, do some study and don't turn a blind eye again !

[@ruinnaimperii4686]

Even forgot to mention Arab Jews

[@DK19998]

Actually most arabs were jews and christians (not counting yemenites)

[@mich722]

Muhamed combined Judaism, Christianity and local Arab culture and traditions to create Islam.

[@mich722]

@عبد القيوم بن جريج دانلوب الحنبلي Muhamed combined Judaism, Christianity and local Arab culture and traditions to create Islam.

[@abc_cba]

@عبد القيوم بن جريج دانلوب الحنبلي Well, Negus was from Ethiopia and was not Arab. Whereas, epitaph for Imru' al-Qays, dated around AD 328 had Arabic alphabets for the first time on any document. There are many places where Christians lived including founding Beth Qatarye (today called Qatar) and Baharna (today called Bahrain) and Zaidiyah (in Yemen) as well as Sir Bani Al Yas (in UAE). The city of Al-Hirah (in Southern Iraq) has Arabic foundations of the alphabet devised by Lakhmid Christian tribes and even the famous Hatim Al Tayy was from the famous Qahtanite tribes as well the Royal Rashid clan who ruled Arabia until Sauds took over were descendants of the once Christian Shammar tribe.

[@malekaltayari3936]

Muslim from Tunisia and proud 🌹 🇹🇳🌹 Respect to others

[@InGrindWeCrust2010]

Great username!

[@user-sq1ms5sw5z]

مسلم كيوت

[@IamSome1]

BTW , The title says what happened to the Christians of North Africa, Not the History of Islam

[@critzilla9722]

Your . videos are amazing, ^^ but it will be good if you display some years on the video when you talk . about difire events and periods ^^

[@chrisian-ararat7373]

where is Armenia?- The first Christian country

[@NihilSineRex1881]

When do you do the History of Romania video?

[@endzmeetmusic9053]

Lol. Couldnt get enough gypsies to film in one area

[@NihilSineRex1881]

@@endzmeetmusic9053 are you racist or something?

[@cristiankorcsek]

Knowledgia is romanian search Lumea lui Dedo is his channel

[@dari1510]

@@endzmeetmusic9053 we are not gypsies, learn history asshole

[@efthymiosanagnostos7427]

Endz Meet Music better than being an Analbanian gypsy or a Turkish gypsy

[@redsamson5185]

Christians of the Levant are still there. Mayan ppls also endure even though they abandoned their giant stone cities.

[@oussamakhorbi4476]

Love from Tunisia 💜

[@narimanenaris178]

Alhamdulillah I'm Muslim and I respect all religions in the world 🇩🇿♥️🕋

[@chebalolita1493]

ALHAMDULILAH FOR CHRISTIANITY AND JEWDISM

[@AhmedHassan-ed6il]

@@chebalolita1493 alhamdulilah for Islam

[@glendathegoodwitch6987]

Maybe you do, but your Islamic ancestors, following in Mohammad's footsteps, did not. This is not your fault at all, of course, but it did not make Islam peaceful then nor peaceful now.

[@jccjjccj3305]

Do you have a child bride?

[@samirelmouden4606]

​@@glendathegoodwitch6987What are your arguments?

[@triggerthemall4837]

Spain and portugal were colonised by the berber moroccan(moor) empires such as:Almoravid empire+Almohad empire. Moorish(Moroccan berber) cities and castles are still today in spain and portugal

[@bosbanon3452]

That is true

[@The00adam00]

Lol what? if the Arabs didnt Arabise you, you wouldnt have colonised anything.. You were led by Arabs...Your language was Arabic...berber moroccan lmfao

[@The00adam00]

@hassan messaoudi thats fine. Arabs dont care what you wanna be. But dont take credit where you were just simply taking orders from your Arab leaders. It was an Arab Muslim invasion, led by Arabs, with an army of Moors (Arabised North Africans). Since you people dont wanna be Arab you cant claim what they did. I have no idea why you North Africans are so hateful. Arabs think of you as brothers...

[@YahyaBenyahi]

Mozarabic people: .

[@amazigh8776]

@@The00adam00 i dont even know arabic lik 85% of the moroccans

[@kstreet7438]

Are anyone’s recommend videos all different now? I see so many Channels I’m my subbed to

[@freecitizen2760]

About half the comments are about his pronunciation of “Arab”.

[@lesbiangeese3737]

These things are what are important to those morons. That pronunciation is common in many types of American English. American and British English pronounce many words differently, for example "aluminium " which just sounds strange when heard in the other camp. Not worth getting upset about though.

[@freecitizen2760]

Lesbian Geese : I was watching some physicist speaking about time and space, and the theory of relativity ... about half the comments were about his hair, his teeth, his sweater, and his resemblance to Steven Tyler of Aerosmith. I think it’s a coping mechanism. Complicated subject matter? Comment on something more pedestrian.

[@lesbiangeese3737]

@@freecitizen2760 often the wisest thing is to say nothing, hence the comments which you give examples of.

[@weka301]

@@lesbiangeese3737 Cool down Lebanon Greece

[@lesbiangeese3737]

@@weka301 ok

[@minanabeh6135]

Coptic orthodox christian here❤️✌️

[@averongodoffire7344]

I love seeing the names change the way they do. The way the people conquering them read them and thought how they sounded or should sound.

[@micahistory]

Very interesting idea but tbh, this wasn't one of your best videos

[@anzl16]

not only this video covered the topic for the dwindling of the christian population of north africa but also explained the spread of islam short and concisely. so good

[@sotonyechukwu7786]

Many North Africans would not believe if you told them many of their ancestors practiced Christianity and Judaism before Islam. Like many of other continents, we have so much to learn about our continents history.! Who are the Black Bare-Barr and how do they relate to the Santana of the Lemtuna tribes and what is their connection with modern Senegal and some of the modern day Amazigh/Berber tribes?

[@miknes12345]

It is really a tragedy how Christianity was pushed out by Islam in North Africa. All of these countries in North Africa would have been so much richer and developed, and the inhabitants would have faced less racism today, if this region would have maintained Christianity as its main religion. Religion is without a doubt a very bad thing, but when you have a religion as backward and oppressive as Islam, the negative effects of religion becomes so much stronger.

[@pcgamingonyt5798]

Oh man you are just islamophobic and nothing else

[@miknes12345]

@@pcgamingonyt5798 I am not. It is a fact. There is not a single Muslim country, perhaps aside from Dubai, that have an economy as developed as any economy with Christian origins. The only rich Muslim countries have economies based on oil. Muslim countries are characterized by authoritarian governments, internal strife, widespread poverty and horrible gender inequality. I am sorry, but these societies are not as developed as the Christian ones. Just imagine what Portugal and Spain would look like now, if there had not been a reconquest by Christians. Spain would be like Morroco or Egypt. There is one explanation, which is Islam. Because Islam teaches women to be kept on a chain and the followers to follow ancient rigid rules like how to go to the toilet and how to dress. These societies are stuck in backwardness and don't develop, because everything in these countries are just focused about following Islam, rather on than on learning and adapting to modern times. But, don't get me wrong. I am not an islamophobe - I am against religion of any kind. Christianity is also bad, but at least it is not as bad as Islam, which is the religion that has had the most negative effect on the world, keeping its followers in poverty, opresssion and general backwardness.

[@user-kg7zr3yl3n]

islam and christianity share the same values, exept that europeans today have completely abandonned theirs, and christian states were much more backwards than muslim ones up untill the french revolution, you're nothing but a misinformed racist

[@user-kg7zr3yl3n]

north africa wouldnt have been any richer or more developped than ethiopia, or armenia, or belarus, or whatever christian countries that you chose to ignore, you only compare it to western european states that went around the world looting everything and amassing capital to build what they have today

[@miknes12345]

To be critical of Islam is not being racist. Islam is a religion, not a race. Europeans have evolved by not letting religion being at the center of life - the French revolution is a good example. It championed enlightment, individualism, science, democracy - whilst Islam is still stuck in medieval times. Those values you state Europeans left, are not values worth keeping, if you think that opression of women, homosexuals and making religion at the center of everything are values worth keeping. Europe has developed and abandoned old stupid superstitions - Religion is ancient superstition. We have evolved since the time of Abraham - religion should have no place in a modern society. Instead, because of the fanatical worship of Islam, we see movements like ISIS and Al Qaeda, and fanatical young men who think they will go to heaven and be rewarded with virgins, by blowing themselves up on a subway train.

[@Theziz8]

Mount Lebanon, the last bastion of Christianity in the Middle East. Long may the Maronites live!

[@sarahlaila6694]

Lebanon is situated in Asia not Africa

[@Theziz8]

@@sarahlaila6694 Yeah..who said otherwise?

[@OttomanLebanon]

Heeeeeeeeeeeeeeee Maronites!! Get outta my lannddsss. You guys or sect originated from Syria not Lebanon. Lebanon will forever be for Islam.

[@Theziz8]

@@OttomanLebanon How dumb are you man😳

[@Theziz8]

@Golden Crown Palestinian Christians are majority Orthodox. Maronites (who are Catholics) are a majority in Lebanon (Christians). Saint Maron was a Syriac, after his deathin 410 his disciples founded a monastery/school called Beth Moroun. Two of Saint Maron's disciples came to Lebanon and converted the LOCAL INHABITANTS.

[@user-sm8tx1hr8v]

Just to correct you there 7:40 Muslims had to pay more taxes then the non muslims The non Muslims paid jizyah and the Muslims paid zakat, and jiyah was to ensure the protection of non Muslims and allow them safe haven in the caliphate.

[@user-sm8tx1hr8v]

@Ezio Auditore Well perhaps I can explain, When and when only the Non-Muslims used the services provided by the Muslims, they had to pay. Muslims paid for this by Zakat, which helped the community, and plus Muslims couldn't force Zakat on Non-Muslims because it is something religious, so the jizya was given. Now if you believe that Jizya was a humiliation than you are humiliated every day. You have to pay taxes, but in America if your a Catholic and donate money to the poor you get a tax exempt ID allowing you not to be tax, so if every Catololic does that than is tax a non-Catholic tax. As for second Class citizens, well these Second Class citizens became scholars and government officials. Unlike in Medieval Chirstians states where Muslims rarely rose to power.

[@herodotus945]

@@user-sm8tx1hr8v Armenian genocide.

[@gog_magpie]

Taqiya is strong with you 7_7

[@user-sm8tx1hr8v]

@@gog_magpie Taqiya can only be used in 3 cases, When someone is about to kill you and asks you to renounce your faith, When you are in War, or when the lie will make Peace about two people or not cause harm between them. And by the way the only one mentioned in the Quarn is when you are in a death situation, and by the way the patriarch of Jerusalem writes in his book the call of the minarets, you can lie to convert anyone to Chirstianity. If any Muslims lies, then he has committed a major sin. So yeah I am pretty sure I am not doing any Taqiya.

[@user-sm8tx1hr8v]

@@herodotus945 What about the chirstians Who killed all the Muslims of Bosnia, and What about Jerusalem. The European COLONIZATION. Hitler and Stalin.

[@PJDubbing]

My ancestors where traders in Egypt. They were forced to convert to convert to islam or leave. That is when alot of them moved to australia and malta.

[@salgarcia8021]

I believe in the one thing most ppl don't. Infact ppl of "faith" have don't even acknowledge..I believe in ppl. Like you guys😄. You guys keep up the good work.

[@samibnhassan9239]

This comment section is perfect to write your own history

[@gerry8653]

Just an observation: It seems that the narrator is pronouncing a number of words that are not generally accepted by scholars or those they describe. "A-rab" rather than Arab. " Califa" rather than caliphate. "Levan"(?) rather than levant, for example.

[@ds7788]

If an online distributed query with anonymity is implemented...the result may be shocking. Not many dare to confirm face to face.

[@hatukai]

I am from Jordan and I love my Christian neighbors

[@user-sq1ms5sw5z]

مسلم كيوت

[@hatukai]

@@user-sq1ms5sw5z في عندك مشكلة بالتعايش يعني؟

[@user-os7dw3tr6v]

Hallelujah!

[@aleksandarvil5718]

Could you cover Rise of Swedish Baltic Empire??

[@gwho]

The pronunciation of many names of places familiar to English speakers is funny =]

[@Palios33]

First Christians were the Cypriots though and then the Syrians. Saint Lazaros brought Christianity to Cyprus before christ resurrection

[@Palios33]

@Fady Al qaisy you are completely out of time and topic my friend. Christians didn't had emperors for a long time..

[@PhillFlyer420]

I am a Jordanian Orthodox Christian :) 🇯🇴🇯🇴🇯🇴

[@mufalmewww]

The new videos include more information on this topic

[@rolfsannes8246]

good video but please turn of music or get subtitles

[@ermdzakir4334]

If we dug history What happen with Spanish and Portugal Muslims.

[@adamnesico]

The same what happened with magrebi, saharan and sahelian jews and christians. Can you blame chistians for copy muslims?

[@adamnesico]

محمد شندي I speak of muslims, not Islam.

[@justsomeotherguywithamusta6810]

@@adamnesico actually no, to this day the Jewish population is still present in many Moroccan cities, they mostly lived in sections we call الملاح which is just a name we call the place where they lived, they lived in pretty much the same places even better, most of them we're actually pretty rich. Sooo...

[@adamnesico]

@@justsomeotherguywithamusta6810 Ali El-farsy Soooo that doesnt change that jews were forcefully converted by almohads and talibans in the cited places and catolic kings just imitated almohads. And almost all those magrebi jews went to France or Israel, so they didnt were very satisfied.

[@hasbialhadi7929]

@@adamnesico is Taliban are in Morocco?

[@zaine8476]

Ay-rab and Muzlim, as spoken by the narrator, are total credibility killers for me. Because this is an interesting and important topic in Middle Eastern studies I managed to make it to 4:14 before I just couldn't go on any further. For a video that appears and sounds like it involved a bit of research you missed some pretty standard stuff!

[@otherwize12]

Oh well, I rarely meet Arabs that have a proper understanding and pronunciation of English words. Yet I do meet a lot of Arabs that would criticize others for not being able to properly speak Arabic.

[@emerald_kiwi4046]

What's the song plz?

[@TheAlanFFM]

Not to be a stickler, but you highlighted Phoenicia (Or Lebanon) in blue when you were talking about Judea. Judea was to the south.