What If Anakin Skywalker Didn't Take a Seat

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

Animation Clips: What If Anakin and Obi Wan Fought Grievous kzbin.info/www/bejne/hYjLdoeej918eM0

[@TreyisHeavyMetal]

I love that clip

[@brokenbridge6316]

I respect your reasoning behind how you told this story.

[@brokenbridge6316]

"What if" Sabine Wren was Force-Sensitive?

[@AlphaWolf77975]

If you're willing to read this @PentePatrolStarWars What if Plo Koon, Mace Windu, Yoda or a combination of them discovered Anakin's and Padme's relationship because of the council's mistrust and caution about Anakin and Palpatine's friendship?

[@cypressstoner2532]

Even if Anakin was kicked out of the order, i still believe he would find ways to improve himself in the force, plus he could still make himself a new lightsaber as long as he has a crystal & the parts to make it with.

[@davidmauriciogutierrezespi5244]

5:05 I honestly thought that Obi-Wan would try to move Anakin to his seat and whisper "I swear to the Force Anakin if you keep this up I'm calling Padme"

[@kuramakyubii8135]

This made me laugh more than it should have lol

[@jacksonconley5117]

I think Anakin got the most fitting ending here. He faced consequences for his immaturity, but he got his happy ending. I think it makes sense that he’s no longer a Jedi, but as a person being who he is.

[@RyanTheDark]

I love how Anakin ended up. He was impulsive and disrespectful in that scene, but one can understand being from his perspective. I am glad that Sidious was defeated.

[@kenanmeral8891]

Note to self : never read comments while watching what if videos again

[@RyanTheDark]

@@kenanmeral8891 Ouch, I learned that the hard way too lol

[@VME-Brad]

Slightly different approach. What if Anakin didn't take a seat, not by having a continued hissy fit, but "calmly" refusing the "honor" after the council complains about the chancellor exerting his influence over them.

[@RedRam_Menhtrol]

What if Ventress survived the Clone Wars and joined the Rebellion.

[@cacheh1671]

I like your idea

[@RedRam_Menhtrol]

@@cacheh1671 thanks 😊

[@maxtombs361]

Good one

[@voryntheriolu2525]

This!

[@eidoneverchoosen1171]

What if Ventress raised luke?

[@CrazyKungfuGirl]

Palpatine: ah Anakin - oh. Master windu. I thought Anakin was coming... Mace: nope. Palpatine: oh. I see... (Long awkward silence) Palpatine: you wouldn't by any chance like to hear the tragedy of Darth pleigus the wise?

[@zabu14]

Windu: No. If what you just told me is a sith legend, then you have to be a sith. For now, you remain a sith, wait in this seat until i bring reinforcements to kill you off.

[@andrewwilcke9378]

@@zabu14 Palpatine: Alright, sure Windu, may i choose from the best of the best?

[@reckszkingzactivitiesrkat.4134]

I like the fact that Anakin stood up for himself here in the council chambers whether he was ready for the rank or not , there is benefits to being like this in life. Great fan fiction man keep it going bro 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾.

[@FENRIR-20]

What if Anakin refused the position on the council by using the rules of the Jedi as the reason for his refusal.

[@Somethingfs-sx1ft]

Good what if

[@Xylospring]

​@@Somethingfs-sx1ftMaybe he walks in seeming very Confused as a ploy, and hands it to them. His what could come off as confusion that's he's actually being given something at all.

[@matthewdunlap3700]

The “live the life you deserve to live” from obi-wan made me tear up. Great writing my friend, well done.

[@matthewmann8969]

What if Dooku was trained by Plagueis instead of Sidious and instead Sidious was trained by Tenebrous?

[@TreyisHeavyMetal]

I love this idea, Dooku and Plagueis would make a sith army Imo.🤘

[@latvonik2589]

you are tweaking

[@ddm7833]

What the actual fuck am I reading

[@Achuidian179]

Or better yet; What if Doku was never a Jedi!

[@trentw.3566]

What if Dooku killed Sidious and led the Sith to the Light? Would Anakin still have had two kids? Who cares man. You been up too long.

[@reviveTitanfall2.]

nah if i saw a angry mace windu i would piss my pants

[@pirate42069]

Anakin should have just dropped all his shit and walked out the council door then go straight over to Padme's place.

[@npittswarof2]

Thanks for the story. I love how you write your stories. Most people say that anakin would instantly fall to the dark side if so and so went wrong. But I think most writers don’t take into account how the Jedi aren’t stupid and will probably try to help him. Great writing Pente

[@EvilGingerChill]

This one caught me completely off guard, but it was a damn good story, definitely unexpected but I ended up enjoying it a ton.

[@dominicbastian7684]

I really don’t think that Anakin was in the wrong. It’s like if you’ve met a qualification to be promoted at work and they fire your favorite coworker then use that as an excuse to give you the responsibilities of someone who has been promoted but neither the pay nor the title of that position (pay being getting into the archives and title being rank of master). We all know we’d feel the same as Anakin and I honestly would have less respect for someone who got shafted not speaking up for themselves

[@ISawFiveHoursOfSleep]

Disagree. What happened is much more akin to a CEO of a car company using his influence to try and get his favorite professor tenure. It doesn't even matter, at that point, how much promise you show (or not, imo) ... no one who received tenure under those circumstances would ever have the respect of his peers, and I'm sure that's exactly why Palps made that move. If Anakin gets made Master bc of Palp's request, it would forever be tainted. If he doesn't, well, we saw what happened.

[@dominicbastian7684]

@@ISawFiveHoursOfSleep he earned it. He trained a padawan who was offered Jedi Knighthood but turned it down. Training a padawan to knighthood is the requirement for becoming a master, but because Ahsoka left the order after being tried for a crime she didn’t commit, Anakin was not allowed to become a master after having gotten the qualification. Whether Palpatine tried to influence it or not isn’t important, he still did what he had to and was denied the rank of master on a technicality

[@ISawFiveHoursOfSleep]

@@dominicbastian7684 If Anakin was otherwise a calm, balanced Jedi whose padawan turned down knighthood due to circumstances outside his control, that'd be one thing. But given his general behavior, an abundance of caution was more than warranted. I wouldn't have let him on the council at all in their shoes, and told him my reasoning. I think the mere fact they did let him on, hints that they were open to him being a master eventually, but on the *order's* terms. Like after completing an "orphaned" padawan's training postwar, perhaps.

[@leopoldwebster1130]

If the Jedi council trusted Anakin more I think things would have ended up different. Anakin's impatience and the council's lack of trust in Anakin were what lead Anakin to fall to the dark side. To be completely honest... how much patience does one have to have before a love one perishes. How can one remain calm and balanced when the people you love is actively in danger. Both Anakin and the council have their faults and short comings. Anakin should have come clean but to what cause... being kicked out of the council for being married to Padme. He will only have the dark side to turn to from that point on to get the knowledge and power that he seeked. Some on the council were Ignorant and others were arrogant.

[@ISawFiveHoursOfSleep]

@@leopoldwebster1130 "How much patience should one have before a loved one perishes?" I dunno, why don't we ask Obi-Wan, Qui-Gon, or the Skywalker twins? Maybe Ahsoka? Or Padme's opinion? Jyn Erso, perhaps? It's Anakin's fault that no Jedi knew that was part of his mental calculus, or WAY more importantly, how far he was willing to go if he perceived a loved one to be in danger. I'm no jedi myself, but I don't believe loved ones being in perceived danger gives you a blank check to do anything and everything. Nor do I think you need to be a Jedi to see that. The council could have been better with him, for sure. Wiser. They could have done more, but imo, that would have looked like sending him to a therapist, and decreasing his resposibilities until he wasn't breaking under the strain. Let's be blunt, if you put Obi-Wan, Luke Skywalker, Leia Organa, or Ahsoka in Anakin's life, we would have had a different outcome. And that's okay ...really, people don't have to have the kind of moral strength these characters do. But that doesn't make Anakin less responsible for his choices. It means he should have never been given as much responsibility as he was, he should have been a politician's pretty (and slightly himbo) husband, flyboy, and stay-at-home dad, because that's clearly who he was meant to be. And he would have been a lot happier.

[@torik9300]

Thanks for another great one, glad Anakin and Padme got happy ending. It hadn't occurred to me they would probably have another kid since they can live their lives more truthfully.

[@dennismiller534]

I completely disagree with Anakin being in the wrong especially after what the clone wars showed us with Asoka. You have to train someone to knighthood to be a master but after the counsel was tricked about the bombing that could never happen for Anakin and mace didn't care that they made a clear mistake and pushed another person from the order he couldn't even bring himself to apologize. After the masters showed that a kid with attachments was not welcome and once he finally was he was treated like an outsider until he started winning them battles pretty much everything Anakin did up until order 66 makes sense especially being upset about not being a master on the counsel

[@locoarticwolf2181]

Looks like Anakin is about to throw hands(lightsabers). This’ll be interesting to watch and see.

[@dianesinger9729]

Well done I liked how you treated Anakin as being kind of being wrong. Like how Windu handles Anakin not giving into the bratty behavior. Not surprised he was kicked out in the end. Glad he had a happy life with Padme in the end.

[@barcabocalda2583]

Little do they all know Palpatine would RETURN And anakin would need to finish what he needed to do & windu was always a jealous b*tch towards anakin let's be honest And in this fan fic anakin was also right the council themselves were old fools

[@Caxkj0]

Brilliant! Short, simple, love it! Once again, perhaps the only what if guy out there not to fall into the trap of turning Windu into a bad guy, nor making Skywalker escape responsibility from his actions. Keep it up!

[@Jedi_Knigga]

You’re probably one of the few Star Wars fan fic channels that understands the character of Mace Windu, and you write him so well in these “What Ifs.” Windu was not resentful towards Anakin and had immense respect for him. People just hate that Windu wouldn’t stoop down to Anakin’s petulance. Windu was the type of Jedi Master that wouldn’t accept anything other than what he knew Anakin was capable of.

[@babatoure4105]

What does petulance mean in this context?

[@tommyl.dayandtherunaways820]

Not resentful, condescending is the word to describe Mace’s attitude towards Anakin. It might be different in the EU material, but in the movies, Windu is undoubtedly the most adversarial to Anakin out of everyone on the council.

[@Voltar_99]

@@babatoure4105arrogance, mainly.

[@FuntimeByzantium]

what about the whole Ahsoka situation? was Windu right back then?

[@davidalan528]

I agree that Windu is better than other Jedi at holding Anakin accountable. Unfortunately, I also think part of that is indeed about Windu’s arrogance. He doesn’t think Anakin is fit for the Order, and any behavior Anakin exhibits that confirms that perspective makes Windu a little - just a little - smug. He’s a prideful Jedi. I think where people get him wrong is that they think the pride and arrogance is personal, and it’s not. Windu isn’t a *self-centered* Jedi, his pride and arrogance are all about his very idealized image of the Order and its service to the Republic. He believes that being a ‘proper’ Jedi is the only way to show respect for what is to him the highest calling possible. And Anakin represents all that goes against that. Unfortunately, Windu can’t see the flaws in the Order, and therefore can’t see the flaws in himself, that contribute to Anakin’s behavior (not to take any accountability away from Anakin’s own petulance, that’s real too). If he had a less idealized view of the Order, and a less rigid view of what constitutes the ‘right’ way to be a Jedi, then his respect for Anakin as a warrior and fellow Knight would be more evident.

[@Toumahitoedits]

What if Asajj Ventress killed Darth Tyranus(Count Dooku) during the clone wars? What if Barriss Offee was trained by Darth Sidious? What if Anakin on the Invisible Hand after Dooku's defeat, then revealed Palpatine's true identity as the Sith Lord then kills Sidious? What if General Grievous was the Sith Lord? What if Ahsoka turned to the dark side on Malachor, thus joining Vader? What if Pong Krell survived Umbara? What if Mace Windu was the Sith Lord? What if Boba Fett was the Sith Lord? What if Darth Tenebrous(Master of Hego Damask II) killed Darth Plagueis? What if Darth Bane avoided the Rule of 2, thus many sith still exist? What if Darth Vitiate/Tenebrae was the Jedi Grandmaster of the Jedi Order? What if Darth Nihilus killed Meetra Surik, Mandalore/Canderous Ordo, and his former apprentice Visas Marr over Telos IV? What if Darth Traya killed Darth Sion and Darth Nihilus on Malachor V? What if Darth Revan never returned to the lightside? What if Darth Malak killed Revan on the Star Forge? What if Firmus Piett was the Sith Lord?

[@BigSteve9713]

Take a shot everytime he says Padme's Residence

[@tntaclegrape]

"Take a seat, young Skywalker." "What?" "Take a seat." "What?" "A seat." "What?" "Sit down..." "What?" "SAY WHAT AGAIN! SAY WHAT AGAIN I DARE YOU! I DOUBLE DARE YOU MUTHERFUKA!"

[@victorskwrxsti7899]

"Haha I wont promote you to Senior Manager because I fired your best employee before she became Junior Manager, and training your employee to Jr Manager is required to become Sr Manager"

[@ulp2020]

What if the inquisitorious were never dissolved and instead served as generals in the Galactic Civil War?

[@snowfellwolf8280]

What if the blue shadow virus got out into the galaxy during the clone wars? I think it would be an interesting one given how a plague would throw everyone's plans including Palpatines for a major loop

[@Kubinda12345]

I've some ideas for What If: - What if Palpatine wasn't elected the chancellor of the Republic in Phantom Menace? - What if Anakin's bombing run managed to kill Grievous on Malevolence - What if it was Saw and not Steela who died on Onderon? - What if Anakin killed Dooku in their duel during the Rako Hardeen arc? - What if Tarkin died in the Citadel meaning there would be no Tarkin Doctrine for the Empire? - What if Qi'ra joined the Galactic Empire with Han perhaps becoming an ISB agent? - What if Han killed Darth Vader during the battle of Yavin? - What if the Ashmead's Lock's prisoners succeeded in assassinating Mon Mothma meaning that Leia would become chancellor and the New Republic wouldn't demilitarize?

[@brothers_of_nod]

It was a good what if with a good ending, it not only makes sense, but it was happy in the end for Anakin.

[@Martial_Autist]

Tbf anakin wasn't entirely wrong that he should have been granted the rank of master. Ahsoka had been recognized as worthy of the rank of jedi knight, and once a padawan graduates their teacher is granted the rank of jedi master. So he really did meet all the requirements and his promotion was long overdue. She only refused her promotion and instead left the order altogether because the council lost her trust, due to their actions following the temple bombing. And probably more importantly their later refusal to own that error in judgment, instead trying to sweep it under the rug as past events being 'the will of the force'. Maybe the glass was half empty after all. x'D Before watching the clone wars I really didn't think of that scene as anything other than the council following standard procedure and rules, but from anakin's PoV it was probably more akin to pouring salt into an old wound.

[@marikam2998]

Anakin didn't get The Rank Of Master because, he wasn't ready to become one. On top of that, he was too young to get The Rank Of Master. Therefore, it was too early for him to receive it.

[@haydenfowle7576]

​@@marikam2998he is one of the most skilled General in The Clone Wars he fought all his battles in the front and he won The Jedi over half the war

[@marikam2998]

@@haydenfowle7576 That's true, but there could be other Jedi Knights of Anakin's Age who, could deserve no less to get The Rank Of Master. I think The Force like God loves very patient people, which means that when the right time came for this, Anakin would receive The Rank Of Master.

[@haydenfowle7576]

@@marikam2998 I would be frustrated too given if I carried The Jedi/Republic War Effort during The Clone Wars and Led all battles in the front I would of been pissed too

[@marikam2998]

@@haydenfowle7576 Well, Anakin might not be the only Jedi Knight who, carried out the efforts of The Jedi. And Republic. There, each bear their own burden. And play your part. It's just that Anakin could stand out more than other Jedi Knights of his age who, like him, could take part In The Clone Wars. There is a time for everything. If Anakin didn't get The Rank Of Master when he wanted to, then The Force thinks it's too early for him to get it. And that his time to get The Rank Of Master has not yet come.

[@ulp2020]

What if Cin Drallig trained Obi-Wan? It'd be cool bc Obi-Wan is regarded as one of if not the best swordsman in the order, and it would be interesting to see how his skills grow by being trained by the Temple's battle master

[@Emperor_Atlantis]

Since when was obi one the best swordsman in the order?

[@austinestep8461]

@@Emperor_AtlantisObi-Wan was considered the greatest master of form 3 the order had ever seen.

[@Sienna6164]

What if Anakin actually took the seat and dipped?

[@AGenomeSoldier]

I can't lie and say I enjoyed this. I do see the perspective and the decent story building.

[@UberPodfan]

The, hello at the beginning always gets me 😂😂😂

[@socialaccount0000]

"Take a seat" "What?" "..." "I said what? Forgive me Master Windu, but since saving the Chancellor I've been struggling with hearing loss. As it turns out, crashing a ship from orbit without hearing protection is quite detrimental" "I had said to take a seat, but re-considering your recent accomplishments, I rescind my previous decision. You are on this council, and you are a master"

[@benjamingray2071]

"take a seat young skywalker" "no"

[@barcabocalda2583]

Honestly man I have to Disagree SOME things you said in the end about Anakin Yes hes at fault for his behavior but he wasn't wrong about the council either plus the way they've treated him before let's be honest They've done him dirty and like shit before so in a way I don't blame him entirely Mace was always a jealous douche bag towards him In the end .. look at what Happened to them all in the end it was a big I told you so Jedi deserved what they got Side note MAN I was hoping that council member would attack Anakin Skywalker So the chosen one would make him look Stupid with one move Being a master doesn't mean your all powerful I'll bet anakin would give lot of their council members a run for their money Like that one idiot who turned his saber on Anakin

[@matt_canon]

The only is that I feel that Sidious would have attempted to execute Order 66 in order to create a chaotic diversion, and attempt to escape and falsely claim it was a coup/ assassination attempt. Sidious is a very intelligent weasel, and I feel like he would have an emergency plan to quickly activate Order 66 if all odds turned against him.

[@tvfunkyman6269]

What if anakin said thought the councils not to grant him the rank of master was acceptable and fair.

[@eereree]

“I prefer to stand… bi-“

[@haleychambers2]

What if Darth Vader didn't destroy Alderaan after he discovers that Leia is his daughter?

[@Richtofen-gy9cj]

Vader didn't destroy Alderaan, Tarkin did

[@dakotalange2858]

What if Anakin was allowed to marry Padme openly

[@multiplevoice9127]

“I am a master, I am a master, I AM A MASTER!!! Master Windu”

[@Dredlord601]

I saw that you never did a what-if about young Obi-Wan Kenobi training young Anakin Skywalker when the council didn't give them their blessing that would be a really good video

[@zerosen2141]

Anikin never thought about it in a positive light. Sure, only Masters were ever on the Council, but Anikin, even though it was a result of someone else's plot, he was a Knight, and granted a seat on the council, an unparalleled first. the first knight on the council, genuine bragging rights, something his ego would love.

[@tommyl.dayandtherunaways820]

The thing was (and the movie didn’t really explain this at all, but the official novelization did), it wasn’t a pride issue for Anakin. I mean yes, he obviously felt humiliated at being the first non-master on the council, but the main reason he wanted to be a master in the first place wasn’t to stroke his own ego, but to gain access to the restricted Jedi archives to find a way to protect Padme from the visions he was having. In general, the book maps out Anakin’s rationale a lot better than the movie, it shows how it came from a genuine place of love and not just “moar power”.

[@dylanh7600]

You do realise he wanted access to the restricred area for padme he did not really care for the seat

[@MrCadeRay]

Really depends on the who's perspective we have for me. Anakin acting the way he did makes sense. Especially after a mf pulls a weapon on him. The rest of the council being kind of fed up with him also makes sense. However, pulling a weapon on a fellow jedi should be HEAVILY punished especially by a "master". I dont think that was warranted at all, other than that this was great.

[@Sasuke81a]

I'm surprised that none of the Masters had summoned the Sentinels...

[@y.n.tryone4683]

No matter what alternative scene anakin always ends up bring balance to the force so I think with maul being the only sith while in hyperspace he finds a way to escape and kills Tano and brings the ship out of hyperspace , goes into exile gathers up all with sith artefacts and holcrons, and grows tremendously in power on the same level or slightly below his former master , he takes control secretly of the seperatist army by recruiting one of the separatist leaders who managed to escape Kit fisto legion , secretly grow the seperatist army in the unknown regions with mass production of battle droids while taking care of crimson dawn , he would create a plot which would destroy the Jedi , by staging a fake SOS signal which would draw out key individuals from the council and it would blow up killing some council members he would capture kenobi and torture him until anakin felt it in the force , being that maul killed lots of Jedi at this point anakin felt drawn to save his friends , anakin and maul would engage in a fierce ferocious and close duel , however since anakin grew in thr force and grew calmer and more in tuned with the force , he would be like qui gon Jin persona and he would use mauls arrogance against him and he get the final blow ending the galaxy tryanny of the sith

[@JamesDavis-hs3de]

Enough is enough! I have had it! With these motha fuggin sabers! In this motha fuggin chamber! 😂😂😂

[@timmywoo3572]

Damn the Jedi council did be kinda mad

[@williambrown8686]

He got his happy ending.

[@wolffang471]

Love the animation.

[@434444334]

What if jar jar binks was taken seriously

[@ondrejtravnicek8705]

I still want force sensitive Domino squad.

[@wardaddy9142]

Hey PPSW congratulations on hitting 75k! I've been watching you for over a year and the story's are totally cool! Good job man! BTW this is a good what if?

[@dontavious3772]

ngl I thought it was going to be a shitpost but this is honestly better

[@N3O1999]

20:24 the sound effect 😂

[@gwyndolin1536]

I assumed this was just going to be another joke What-if, where Anakin was just stretching his legs or wanted a custom seat like some of the Council Members got.

[@haydenfowle7576]

6:05 Rex and The 501st look up to their General and Clone Force 99 also looked up to Anakin due to his disobedience towards orders

[@ArronRatliff]

Anakin was a spoiled little snot. But at the same time the Jedi Council are a bunch of stuck in their ways elitist hypocrites.

[@Machoke.]

If only Anakin didn't take a seat😂

[@roguecalvinist]

What if the Jedi never found Anakin on Tatooine?

[@TheWise9]

What if Anakin didn't exist until the empire?

[@archonmage2486]

What if kenobi liked blasters

[@haydenfowle7576]

I would be upset too if I carried the Jedi/Republic war effort throughout the entire Clone Wars leading from the front in numerous campaigns winning The Jedi over half the war and still not be made a Master

[@wingding0111]

What if Cal Kestis trained Luke?

[@samk3lly]

Ha hah! The tension was so high you could almost cut it with a lightsaber. 😆 Another highly enjoyable story. Thank you, my friend.

[@balsamic2947]

You know what would be funny when some random Jedi comes to ask anakin if he is willing to give his kids to the Jedi order 😂

[@ravenbob4293]

Man this video made me miss order 66 at the jedi 😊.

[@MS-fh4sz]

I have to say. Either Lucas had a $h1tty military adviser or not one at all. For ROTS after being on the front lines. And being in most of the worst battles of the Clone Wars. Anakin wouldn't have sounded as whiny as he did in the movie. Yes, would be still friendly with Obi Wan like he is until the end of the movie because they were truly brothers until that point. But with Anakin being on the Front Lines for 3 years. With little down time in those 3 years. And with the Jedi having no Shrinks or counselors present ever. By the time ROTS came around he would have been suffering from Extreme combat PTSD issues, and the Superman complex which he had. And he definitely would have Intermittent Explosive Disdorder aka I.E.D. at age 23. Anakin would've been cockier, a more arrogant, non friendly, distant and broodish to most people and, including most Jedi. More no nonsense, less talk talkative. With an attitude of like ''ok can I go now? Since I'm not involved''. Or like ''ok what is my next mission''. And he definitely would have been less whiney sounding in the whole Movie. And if this scene wasn't written by somebody who hasn't seen war. Anakin's response would've been different. He would've been pissed yes, but the outburst would've come out through his emotions in The Force more so than verbal outrage. And he probably would have still popped verbally. But it would've been more like " cold, arrogant and monotoned really'' and not whiney. He also would've been popping facts of why ''should he be on the council? Without having any say so or Authority, and not being promoted to Master. He would've brung up a lot of stuff like killing Doku and other things to try to sway their minds. And if none of that ultimately mattered to the council. Anakin would have pulled the ultimate power card. And told them coldly and sternly ''you know what for 13 years. I've got little to no respect from this council. Ya'll failed me more than I've failed this council. And ya'll failed my former Padawan. And It's obvious ya'll need me more than I need ya'll. Screw being on the council. Ya'll have 24 hours to make me a Jedi Master. Or I quit.'' And he would've just walked out and waited for their final decision. That is more along the lines of how the scene would or should have gone. If Lucas actually had a military adviser.

[@locoarticwolf2181]

What if Ventress Killed Grevious during their duel on Dathomir? What if Ashoka redeemed Vader on Malachor? What if Maul and Kenobi made peace on Tatooine and teamed up? What if Vader won the Darksaber, ruling Mandalore? What if Anakin/Vader was a double agent playing the long game? What if Thrawn joined the Republic? What if Vader survived and lead the Imperial Remnant. What if Padme managed to free Anakin’s Mother? What if Hondo actually traded in a Captive Dooku instead of double crossing? What if Echos of Oblivion didn’t happen in SWTOR and Vitiate/Valkrion returned during the movies akin to your Darth JarJar fic spanning the saga? What if Vader and Thrawn lead a Imperial Rebellion separate from the main one? What if Starkiller survived and trained the Skywalker Twins? What if Lord Starkiller replaced Vader in the Original Trilogy after TFU1 Darkside Ending (not counting DLC) What if Legends New Republic fought the First/Final Order? What if Dooku realized Palpatine lied to him earlier before the war and actually fought to win with the CIS? What if the Empire was Good and the Rebels were Evil?

[@JD_Saltyway]

What if Savage survived after Sidious captured Maul? After all, at this point he knew everything too.

[@Echoes13131]

What if Padme was at the Jedi Temple during Order 66?

[@dakotalange2858]

What if Cin Dralik trained Anakin

[@drigondii]

What if Mandalore the Preserver established a formal alliance between the Mandalorians and the Jedi?

[@0BI-WAN.KENOBI]

I like that i didn't die as always.

[@dylanh7600]

Will there ever be a fic where you criticise windu

[@russellglass2837]

What if kit fisto survived the attempt to arrest the chancellor? I wonder if he would join the rebellion or maybe even help train luke?

[@jamesplunkett8912]

What if Anakin had another son named Qui-Gon Skywalker?

[@Tyrannus10200]

What if Grievous Killed Palpatine during the battle of Coruscant

[@joekauffman9690]

This was a great talk, would had been different, could you do what Anakin quit the Jedi order after Mace told him that he was not given the rank of master

[@kinggoji953]

There’s probably an alternate timeline where Windu said “take a seat, young Skywalker”, then Anakin just proceeds to sit on the floor, then everyone just looks at him sternly and Skywalker saying “What. He said take a seat. And I did.”

[@Blazeyblazeyblaze]

What if plo koon was a secret sith lord? What if shaak ti trained ahsoka instead of anakin? What if padme was a sepratist?

[@krewlsorrow354]

What if the gunship wasn't out of rockets?

[@clasher138]

The council is mad at Anakin for his insolence. That's bullshit because what they did to Ahsoka was worse

[@tomcross3000]

As a punishment to kcaj and tiin for drawing a blade in a council meeting, I think they would be sent to either kashyyyk as you did for tiin, or utapau to fight gg with or without kenobi or kolar(not fisto, he would be most necessary only if grievous was hiding in a watery location where fisto would be at his pinnacle) anakin to stay for his own punishment on temple guard duties. I ultimately think sidious would win the duel even with yoda there, and even in losing, order 66 would still be enacted, a fail safe in place maybe with an agent having access codes, sly Moore or tarkin possibly- hundreds of clone squads killing hundreds of Jedi and forming resistance strongholds and pockets while the droids are mostly shut down as planned. Cinder happens, legions come out of exegol- unknown to the Jedi, sidious secured funding and the set up of a secondary republic armada should order 66 not go according to plan or he dies, which was in the works during the last decade. While not as huge as in rise of skywalker because less time passed, they are more than enough along with clone remnants to pose a real threat to the republic which is illegitimate and treasonous to them, and they want to set up an empire. I think the next step, just to make it interesting, the Jedi leadership meet with the acting chancellor and they offer leniency on prison terms to the separatist leaders, if they start up and reconfigure their droid forces to fight on the republic side.

[@venator-yv1gw]

What if Anakin never built a lightsaber but tinkered with blasters instead

[@joseph20yearsago61]

Good story but if you make anakin the main character , it will be better..

[@onlinegametime]

What is the Jedi council found out about the pregnancy and wanted to take the babies away for themselves?

[@Somethingfs-sx1ft]

They are evil for that

[@onlinegametime]

@@Somethingfs-sx1ft What do you mean evil, like the Jedi like to say. It was the will of the force. They need the kids for their Jedi Order.

[@Somethingfs-sx1ft]

@@onlinegametime they were slaves of the senate after the russan reformation

[@joshadley]

didn't see that ending coming, well done

[@matthewbeddard4157]

This one was really good. I think Anakin being in the jedi order is kind of a waste of his potential.

[@jordanlane870]

Here's one to think about what if the rebel alliance found dark force fleet

[@criticato8916]

What if Valorum was the Sith lord instead of Palpatine?

[@fumkioyuki8457]

nice story but want punch windu's face. anyways an idea simmiler to this was what if anakin requst not to be on the concuil

[@russellcolemaniii4207]

What if qui'gons force ghost trained Luke

[@Tiago-d8h]

What If Ahsoka didnt leave the Jedi

[@kaelobherrmann6884]

What if mother talzin succeeded in the disappeared arc in season 6?

[@AlexSDU]

If Yoda was with Windu fighting Palpatine, then which Jedi was sent to Kashyyyk instead of Yoda??

[@Richtofen-gy9cj]

Saesee Tiin, did you watch the video?

[@AlexSDU]

@@Richtofen-gy9cj I must have missed that part.

[@esiaahjackson4542]

This was a interesting video because wasn't expecting story get so intent in begin of the video because knew Mace Windu would got of annoyed with Anakin and maybe Yoda to but didn't expect one Council Member turned on his lightsaber in the middle of it left alone two and also like everything start revealed itself through the story like was a domino effect especially Ahsoka got pictures so great and interesting video Pente Patrol Star Wars