What If Old Obi Wan Killed Darth Vader on the Death Star

Ben Kenobi fought with Darth Vader on the first Death Star before his heroic sacrifice. What If Ben Kenobi defeated Darth Vader on the Death Star? Would Ben continue on to train Luke and Leia? Would he feel a sense of completion or regret over finally killing Vader? How would the Emperor react to yet another failure by his student?
Support the Channel: / ppsw
PODCAST: open.spotify.com/show/4T2dHne...
Twitch Account: / pentepatrol
Community Discord: / discord
THUMBNAIL BY: RenderDriver: renderdriver?ig...
Support My Other Channels!
Support This Video's Musicians!
The Way of Water - • 🎥 Epic & Trailer (Free...
In Search of Solitude - • 🌳 Classical & Cinemati...
Permafrost - • 💭 Meditation (Free Mus...
Fire & Thunder - • ⚡ Free Epic Music (No ...
Unexplored Moon - • 🌙 Copyright Free Orche...
Eight Mountains - • Eight Mountains by Savfk
The Epic Hero - • 💪 Orchestral Trailer P...
Dunes - • ⏳ Soundtrack (Free Mus...
Refusing the Ultimatum - • 😟 Tense & Orchestral (...
Passage of Time - • ⏱️ Cinematic & Backgro...
Love - • ❤️‍🔥 Romantic & Piano ...
What Happens When We Die - • Sad Soundtrack (Free M...
The Preparation - • 🔭 Soundtrack (Free Mus...
Eglair - • 🚤 Epic & Cinematic (Fr...
Instructions for Living Life - • 🎹 Piano Instrumental (...
Terminus - • 🎖️ Free Epic Heroic Mu...
Still A Long Way To Go - • 📽️ Free Film Orchestra...
Magic - • 🍬 Free Classical Fanta...
Long Way to Go - • ⛓️ Sad & Beautiful Orc...
Age of Wonder - • 🌁 Cinematic & Epic (Fr...
#StarWars #starwarswhatif #obiwankenobi #anakinskywalker #clonewars #ppsw #skywalker #ahsoka

[@PentePatrolStarWars]

Go to MiniFigs with this link for *10% off!* All you need to do is use the link & *10% will automatically be applied!* Special Thanks to MiniFigs for Sponsoring today's video! minifigs.me/?ref=pentepatrol 💜💜

[@magpiekritik3123]

What If on Halo 3's final mission the portal on the Ark sends the Forward unto Dawn (intact or split) carrying Master Chief, Cortana and Arbiter (all together, two or one depending if the ship splits or not) A long time ago in a galaxy far, far away . . . . Star wars (or to be more specific at the start or little before the Phantom Menace or New Hope) let the debate begin !?! Warning this is a work in progress! but feel free to take, edit and use in your final draft if you wish, just a small mention/credit of what I may have contributed will be fine with me :) Option 1, Arbiter solo: The front half of the Forward unto Dawn carrying Arbiter teleports into the Star Wars galaxy at speed, passes the CIS blockade, who are left wondering WTF was that, but of course turn their attention to another approaching ship ( Qui Gon Jinn / Obi Wan kenobi journey stays the same for now ... ) Arbiter crashes into the ocean or large lake on the planet of Naboo, after salvaging what he can and escaping the sinking wreck Arbiter sets off in search of civilization ... only at first to find Jar Jar Binks !?! ... After setting up camp for the night and having something to eat ( either human ration packs salvaged from the F.U.D | or some form of creature that Arbiter would be able to cook/eat ) lured by the smell of food Jar Jar " Attempts " to sneak up! ... Only to get caught (detected via Arbiters hunter/warrior senses ... that or his motion tracker) after a lot of begging/bargaining Arbiter takes pity on him and offers Jar Jar a deal, guide him to the " Human " capital of Naboo in exchange for food/protection (Jar Jar of course would accept this offer, what with being banished from going home for being clumsy) along the way perhaps they'll find a crashed but still operational warthog (which is worse, trusting Jar Jar to drive or shoot !) after some driving they come under attack from scouts of the droid invasion followed by the JEDI who come to their aid and ... could also appreciate a ride ... ( JJ will likely call Arbiter " Arby " for short throughout the story ) Option 2, Chief / Cortana: The back half of the Forward unto Dawn carrying Chief / Cortana teleports into from their perspective a unknown region of space! Cortana of course will start running scans of the area and drop a beacon for potential rescue (for about 4 years, 7 months, 10 days she won't be suffering from rampancy yet) ... oh would you look at that its the ship that Qui Gon Jinn/ Obi Wan kenobi are traveling on, after some basic introductions / explanations the JEDI will ask if MC/C would like to accompany them to the planet of Naboo or wait for another ship to give them a tow 1a) if they stay some time later the JEDI will send a message saying the CIS have just attempted to kill them, rather than being sitting ducks, Cortana uses what control they have over the F.U.D to steer it to Naboo for a controlled crash landing then using a escape pod. 1b) if they leave with the JEDI, the F.U.D will be left behind for now, will it stay adrift in space, get caught in Naboo's gravitational pull and crash there!) When arriving at the CIS blockade MC/C will have another two choices 2a) Stay in ship until what should be " short negotiations " are over! ... outcome: ship gets blown up with MC/C just about escaping the blast or rises from the wreckage like a Demon to the bewilderment of the battle droids 2b) Join the JEDI in the meeting to introduce themselves to this new galaxy or pretend to be acting security! ... outcome: oh boy, if the CIS were spooked about JEDI showing up in the original story, what are going to think Chief is ... Mandalorian perhaps ( they won't know anything about Cortana yet ) When Lord Sidious gives the order " kill them immediately " so the CIS blows up the horse they rode in on and " try " to gas the JEDI / Chief ... pfffft ha ha ha ha HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA cue the song ( Unyielding Soul ) | whichever scenario plays they link up and fight their way to the bridge (next question is can Cortana interface/hack the doors for the bridge e.g. is there a control panel they can hack? ... also don't forget the blast doors) still even after all that the droidika's with their shields may still be problematic leading to the group needing to sneakoff the ship. Option's 1/2 combined: When combining these perspectives most details stay the same, with the exception of Chief / Cortana telling the JEDI that Arbiter is about to crash-land on the planet of Naboo (or already has) they'll also be able to keep in contact with Arbiter via COM's until the CIS blocks communications

[@racism.gaming]

@@magpiekritik3123 hi

[@brokenbridge6316]

I love your story-telling PP

[@robertnickerson8463]

I was hoping for like your comment, wasn't expecting a gift..

[@jeppthegamer4972]

Damn, He pulled that AD off amazingly, Better than the Raid Shadow Legend

[@LordMayorOfDairyBell]

What if Anakin quit being a Jedi after learning that Padme was pregnant? He realizes he can't keep up the facade forever and that he has a choice to either remain a Jedi and lose Padme and the Kids or quit and be with his wife and kids.

[@ORIGINALFBI]

He'd probably just join Palpatine

[@alduintheanti-dragonborn]

He'd probably go to Palpatine for help since the nightmares would probably haunt him still.

[@brokenbridge6316]

Interesting story idea

[@indoraptergen4231]

I’m pretty sure that’s already been done

[@Acoolnamme]

I miss read Padme as Palpatine and did the most dramatic double take in my life

[@theyuca-clan4239]

You know what was the funny thing he could’ve actually pulled this off if he genuinely just tried to do so.

[@andrewweber9930]

Yep

[@indoraptergen4231]

But then Luke wouldn’t have the inspiration to further become a Jedi with him seeking out ReVeNgE aGaInSt VaDeR ,and because Lucas wanted him dead ,but if Kenobi didn’t die we wouldn’t have Yoda! That character that you probably wouldn’t remember if Luke didn’t spend most of his time with him.

[@thehindenburg3402]

Disney destroyed the concept of what Darth Vader was supposed to be. Now in the community he's just able to be killed by anyone. Whats the point of Vader then?

[@detroitmade6]

​@@thehindenburg3402Disney didnt do anything there are plenty of Legends And EU material where Vader was having trouble with his opponents

[@thehindenburg3402]

@@detroitmade6 Legends didn't make people this way. When Disney released the Obi Wan show is when everyone became like this.

[@slothreacts34]

For some reason, Palps being paralyzed because of his own actions is hilarious. Every time it talked about how he wasn’t able to do simple things was hilarious.

[@greengeek562]

Does he use the Force to wipe his own ass or does one of his royal guards have to do it?

[@adamb89]

Straight up turned into Emperor Palpitation.

[@matthewmann8969]

What if Anakin still stayed in the cockpit like Qui Gon said but did not fly off or do anything on that cruiser instead what if he just took a nap?

[@PokeHokage]

Alternatively what if he tried to help them fight Darth maul? Maybe he finds a blaster and tries to help from a distance.

I think so he sayed it because only one who had chance was Anakin because without him so anyone could not destroy generaton

[@JAN2MARS]

Even though this reads a little like a joke topic, I think it’d be interesting. We could probably assume that at the very least, the space battle would’ve gone badly which would’ve led to the Gungans losing the ground battle and a subsequent chain reaction.

[@patrickd2853]

What if as Mace fell he pulled Sidious or Anakin down with him, not both as he could only use Vaapad temporarily to transfer the lightning into enough energy to use the force a final time before he died.

[@indoraptergen4231]

Died? Where’s the body then?😂

[@TheGuardianofAzarath]

@@indoraptergen4231 well, considering how high up Palpy's office was, I think Windu would have been a Pollock floor painting after he hit the ground. :P

[@miloradowicz]

​@@TheGuardianofAzarath bodies don't evaporate, nor do they pulverize to a pulp whatever the height they fall off.

[@TheGuardianofAzarath]

@@miloradowicz no, they go splat, especially if they're falling from several hundred floors up (minimum)

[@Automaton237]

​@@TheGuardianofAzarathremember that mission in Call of Duty were the main villain gets sniped and should have died but didn't. You can make that same point with Mace Windu as he is strong in the forest you could assume he either died from old age or the empire killed hem with the inquisitors which isn't likely as he's very skilled so he probably just survived the fall and could be still alive but very old or died from old age.

[@patrickd2853]

What if the force retreated after ROTS no one expect Luke, Leia and Vader beings able to use it.

[@user-sj5wz7tt9u]

What about Obi Wan, Yoda and Qui-Gon's ghost?

[@reckszkingzactivitiesrkat.4134]

6:03 “The old fool made a mockery of his teachings enough times‼️🎙” That line made me crack soooo hard 😂👏🏾 , story goes hard bro keep em up.

[@spideysg1163]

What if Vader didn’t turn to the light side but Luke somehow captured Vader and Palpatine and brought them to Endor

[@mariophreak]

Isn't it great when a scenario needs to have the word "somehow" in it?

[@thedivineoblivion9452]

​@@mariophreakSomehow, Palpatine has returned. :)

[@magnawaves]

"You expected me to come quietly upon capture, isn't that right, young Skywalker? You didn't expect me to have incontinence and chose today to abduct me? Oh, I'm afraid my bowels will be quite operational, when your friends arrive..." It writes itself, no somehows or nothing

[@lelouchvibritannia4028]

"God, that stinks!"@@magnawaves

[@edgehead2695]

​@@lelouchvibritannia4028"And I thought he smelled bad...on the outside..."

[@themysteriousspeeddemon]

1:43 Lol 18:50 Looks like The World Between Worlds Threw off The Emperor's Groove, for real. and it also looks like his Empire is in deep Dooku now.

[@saddiqbey9592]

what if ahsoka joined count dooku after leaving the jedi order

[@user-sj5wz7tt9u]

Why would she? Ah yes, Lux...

[@alexrator7674]

Missed opportunity to make Obi Wan throw sand at Vader

[@keeprunningforest4875]

Lightsaber through the chest? Vader would be ok and ready to go after one day off

[@jaczylijaaleniepowiemkto3243]

I love how the way you're decribing the initial fight sounds exactly like the fan remake of the original Death Star duel scene!

[@Fracture_.]

Day 10: What if Darth Zannah was a Jedi? Either she refrains from killing the Jedi who originally comes for her, or another Jedi takes her instead soon after, assuming Bane doesn't find her or a twin of some kind exists. She undergoes training until she becomes a Jedi Knight or perhaps even a Jedi Master. Then, she receives one of two visions. The first vision portrays Anakin or Luke as the chosen one. She believes in the prophecy and enters stasis, intending to train them to confront Palpatine during the Clone Wars or the time of the Empire. The second vision involves Palpatine himself, maybe as the Emperor. Believing that she is the chosen one due to this, she enters stasis until the Clone Wars, awakened by the Force or some other catalyst. To fight him herself. To maintain her characterization as the Zannah we know and love, she excels as a master of Form Three and is proficient in Jedi Alchemy or sorcery, perhaps even both. I think the second vision would make for a better story, as training Anakin/Luke videos are already abundant on your channel.

[@Dseagles14]

What if Owen allowed Obi-Wan to train Luke from a young age

[@fumkioyuki8457]

What if anakin was with padme when order 66 happen Or What if Luke and leai were born in the beginning of revenge of the Sith

[@jclozanoc]

What if Anakin split from vader as a force ghost during mustafar and helped training his kids

[@simonschmidt5888]

What if Qui-Gon didn't ask Obi-Wan to train Anakin, after he was slain by maul? What if Anakin was trained by a Force User outside the Jedi order and without having to follow any code?

[@dannylopez5976]

First one is interesting. Whether or not the order would train Anakin, or who they would choose.

[@nfinity1421]

Thank you for another wonderful story with a path that was surprising, yet made perfect sense. Also, YES! I too wanted that hug on-screen. Thank you for breaking the 4th wall to let me know I was not alone with that.

[@spartakill0922]

Top tier channel man can’t get over it

[@chasetauscher9544]

What if Maul was the Chosen One and he was raised as Mother Talzin’s successor? What if Kina Ha fought in the Separatist Invasion of Kamino? What if Namek and Planet Vegeta were in the Star Wars galaxy?

[@zfilms4858]

"What if... Planet Vegeta were in the Star Wars galaxy?" Are you *NUTS?!* That planet makes the sith look like the jedi!

[@deadmemes1824]

This has quickly become my second favorite Star wars channel 👏

[@saddiqbey9592]

what if savage stayed as dooku's apprentice

[@Theover4000]

These are always amazing. How do you do these so quickly? They can’t be AI Generated, they’re too cohesive! (Big compliment, that’s what I’m trying to say! I love these and I’ve been binging them all week!)

[@Achuidian179]

Day 8. What if; Anakin never gave into his feelings for Padme, Aayla Secura was the chosen one and became Darth Talon, Shme Skywalker was adopted by the Tusken Raiders, Boba Fett saved his Tusken family, Count Dooku was a regular count for the CIS, Jabba the Hutt supported the Jedi at the Start of the Clone Wars, and finally, what if Sabine and Ezra fell in love?

[@brokenbridge6316]

"What if" Sabine Wren discovered that she was Force-Sensitive at the same time Ezra did in the SW: Rebels series.

[@hatthomas555]

Very well done! Not that it means anything, but that's from someone who used to write professionally, so theres that. Love hiw you navigated through the movies and series too.

[@imember7375]

what if general grievous was made of beskar

[@saddiqbey9592]

he would probably be capable of killing dooku or even sidious

[@cartoonzentertainment]

What if Ventress was Qui Gon’s padawan instead of Obi-Wan?

[@brenersilva7361]

He did something like that in the "what if assaj ventress trained anakin"

[@brokenbridge6316]

We should've gotten Luke n Leia both training as Jedi together. Because this made it look like a very natural thing.

[@youngmoneyclutch]

I’m digging the short hair bro. Been watching you since before 20k subs

[@saddiqbey9592]

what if Sidious killed maul and let savage live instead

[@boydchris28]

Another great story!

[@ovni2295]

Working the ad into the story like Cervesa Cristal

[@achasonc]

Excellent storytelling.

[@saddiqbey9592]

what if the jedi order from the high republic and the jedi of the prequals swapped places

[@wargamesmaster]

What if Dooku had a family on Earth and his grandson was the "chosen one"? Hell, what if his secret wife was an historical figure like Anastasia Romanov, Cleopatra or even Joan of Arc?

[@zenphir9051]

If you ever do another crossover episode, might I recommend this: What if the IMC appeared during the Clone Wars? I’ve always seen people compare SW factions to other sci-fi franchises like Halo, WarHammer, Mass Effect, etc. but I have never seen anyone talk about a Titanfall faction vs a Star Wars faction before.

[@CaptainRex332]

What if only the newest clones reacted to order 66 during rots potentially due to the Kaminoin’s not realizing their mistake up until rots

[@erikakerblom2900]

Noice as always Pente! Day: 38: What if Mother Talzin raised Maul?

[@Aero137]

interesting XD you're describing the fight between them exactly the way it went in "SC 38 Reimaginend" (A short fan film that just updated the coreography)

[@yinyang777]

What if yoda was captured by darth sidous and was forced gave into the darkside through torture and other stuff... or what if yoda gave into the darkside when he saw all the jedi bodys in th temple and before he completely turned told obi wan to run and find somone strong enough to defeat him and obi wan through dumb luck got away from the dark yoda to find a being or something to defeat the new sith yoda

[@zackcross7190]

What’s ironic thing about this is the fake line used when filming Empire was “Obi-Wan killed your father.”

[@saddiqbey9592]

what if ahsoka found cal kestis after order 66 and trained him

[@anvos658]

Honestly would be a more interesting story take if as a result of Vader being dead, Tarkin was happy enough he decided to actually launch the tie fighter garrison to crush the Rebels, especially when he can now take all the credit.

[@Bwillis2099]

What if Anakin Skywalker, Ahsoka Tano and Obi Wan Kenobi were stranded in a parallel universe? What if palpatine had a secret “daughter”? What if Luke Skywalker Married emperor palpatine’s daughter? What if the Kaminoans joined the rebellion? What if Qui Gon Jinn and Dooku left the Jedi and started their own Force group/order? What if Luke Skywalker was trained by the Bendu? What if all characters in Star Wars had their genders swapped? What if Grugu Djinn founded his own group of force sensitive Mandalorians? What if Krypton was a part of the Star Wars universe?

[@Wuerstchenmann]

Bro is suggesting a story about incest.

[@Bwillis2099]

@@Wuerstchenmann which what if are talking about?🤔

[@Wuerstchenmann]

@@Bwillis2099 what if Like skywalker married Palpatines daughter.

[@ale-xsantos1078]

Suggested before but Ima suggest it again for the algorithm: *What if Anakin was the model for the Clone Army?*

[@johnpittsii7524]

What if Anakin was trained by Bastillia Shan or Pong Krell. Also what if Anakin was sent to kayshaxx instead of Yoda. Also what if Anakin was an Jedi bounty hunter

[@Parmesean_Cheese_Enjoyer]

What if modern earth was in Star Wars attempt 3 Possible branching routes: Modern earth joins CIS Modern earth joins republic Modern earth joins the empire Modern earth joins the new republic. I’d love to see Thrawns views on our culture and weaponry.

[@brokenbridge6316]

"What if" The Jedi discovered that the Sith Temple under their own on Coruscant was corrupting them?

[@brothers_of_nod]

Before Obi Wan had the high ground, here he did a low blow using a man’s children against him

[@TheLittleWolf2309]

What if Mother Talzin and the Night Sisters killed Dooku during the Clone Wars ?

[@isaiahhenio4556]

Old Obi Wan: I'm Sorry Anakin

[@EmilfilmEW]

Rip Darth Vader😢

[@nopeace3689]

What if They use anakin skywalker's arm that count dooku Cut off, They somehow save the arm and used it to heal vader after mustafar.

[@cameronclophus7998]

Did you make a what if about Obi-Wan and anakin going to the past and meeting Qui-Gon and young Obi-Wan?

[@Acoolnamme]

Palpatine: *enters the world between worlds* The wbw: nah

[@saddiqbey9592]

what if cal kestis tried to restart the jedi order

[@JStryker47]

"Obi Wan hadn't used his weapon in so long" Oh really? And just how much time passed, after he used it against those thugs at the cantina who attacked Luke?

[@ocularzombie6679]

bro did a sponsorship and a face reveal IN UNIVERSE! Nice!

[@Person-ry7iq]

Do you know what happened to a channel called Casey Star Wars

[@ondrejtravnicek8705]

What if the jedi legends came back to life?(sith clone wars but with the jedi.)

[@saddiqbey9592]

what if the clone troopers were all given the super serum

[@GeneralObeseus]

What if the Younglings had visions of order 66 and saw their deaths? Attempt #13

[@jonbonda1917]

There's a lot of Jedi&Force Sensitives that survived. If you go by the Legends, Kam Solusar&Kyle Katarn are very strong Force sensitives also there's Galen Marek clone, Kal Cestis&Merrin around and Sabine Wren too. Rahm Kota could had taken over the training even though he's blind. Also Huyang could be a Living Force Crystal Jedi, his group's been using droids as their shell to move around the galaxy for thousands of years. Similar to a holocron&lightsaber crystal having an imprint of its user but stronger, the live crystals contain a life essence that's force sensitive. In legends novel, Luke found some of them and they joined his new jedi order but continued to use droids as their bodies but most of the time they hide amongst the droid population.

[@rignatetris4435]

sabine isnt force sensitive, but i like the rest

[@jonbonda1917]

@@rignatetris4435 You're right, she's now officially a padawan of Ahsoka.

[@rignatetris4435]

@jonbonda1917 no as on she isnt a force sensitive at all. Just a normal mandolorian trained in the use of a lightsaber thats all.

[@haydenfowle7576]

Obi Wan has to tell Rex what happend to his General and Ahsoka too if he finds her

[@plaguedoctor2986]

What if shaak ti survived order 66 What if aayla secura survived order 66 What if mace windu trained luke skywalker What if ahsoka tano trained luke Skywalker What if darth revan return in the clone wars

[@brokenbridge6316]

"What if" the love of Qui-Gon's life didn't die?

[@analerma3837]

What if Anakin had a zygerrian or what if he was one

[@joesturgess5906]

I think a good one would be what if obi wan killed vader when luke and leia were still young then lightside anakin skywalker reappeared near the lars farm

[@vodkalord6941]

what if Cody was the homeless veteran obi wan encountered? what if Bo Katan was the one who fell in love with Obi Wan as opposed to Satine? what if Obi Wan was trained by Plo Koon ?

[@krismikewill]

They missed the opportunity in the series for the clone, Cody if you will, to say, "Thank you, General."

[@purple_memer]

remember the spin

[@JeffHowell]

Nice subtle nod to FixItInPost's reimaging of this battle...

[@Odinfang]

I still say you need to do what if Palpatine made mother Talzin his apprentice. I think it has the potential to be great with how you do your vids.

[@patrickd2853]

What if the clone program was restarted after New Hope?

[@brokenbridge6316]

"What if" Obi-Wan tried to bring Dooku back to the light instead of Yoda?

[@ORIGINALFBI]

Day 4: What if Anakin was born female and Padme was born male but still King of Naboo? (There have been Kings of Naboo, thry just usually vote in females to be their "monarch".)

[@brokenbridge6316]

"What if" Metra Surik didn't go to find Revan after defeating the Sith triumvirate?

[@adventwolfbane]

What if instead of going to Coruscant for help during Episode 1. Padme decided she needed actual military strength after seeing that the Republic doesn’t enforce its laws in the outer parts of the galaxy when she is on Tatooine. So she decides to go to Eriadu and the Tarkins. She goes to them both because they have a developed industrial base that rivals the core and because they hate the Trade Federation. So instead of wasting time in the senate she gets the Outland Regions Security Force to help her retake Naboo. The TF didn’t know where she was until she publicly showed up at the Senate so they would still dismiss most of the blockade for cost and redundancy.

[@BrandleyR]

What if Dutchess Satine had her mandalorians fill the role that the Jedi should have filled, based on their dogma, during the clone wars? It would be funny from a certain point of view. Mandolorians fulfilling the dutty the Jedi did before the war, bringing peace and bridging between opposing sides for the neutral worlds and those that wish to join.

[@JediMasterZim]

What if ALL of the clones had the inhibitor chips malfunction like Tup did, and Order 66 accidentally activated way too early for Palpatine's plans, like a year into the war?

[@HeartDigger9]

This is actually a really interesting idea

[@goodsonicfan5016]

Then all hope would be lost because he’s STILL the Chosen One!

[@SamCaiman14]

1) In Marvel What if, Ultron and Watcher briefly broke into Mustafar overseeing Vader's castle. What if Vader senses a great disturbance was coming and prepared himself being in that brief moment and while Ultron is fully focused fighting Watcher, Vader pulls out with the Force the Infinity Stones from Ultron, so fast that neither Watcher or Ultron can react and they continue breaking into another dimension, leaving Vader with the Infinity Stones on his hands? 2) What if Darth Tenebrous didnt panicked and succeeded in his goal of taking over the Chosen One by transfering his maxichlorians into Anakin? This possession is unique, more subtle and different than Transfer Essence, so I assume it would take time for Tenebrous to take over. Maybe even requiring Anakin to open himself to the darkside. 3) What if rather than destroying the portal, Vader used it to regain his ROTS Anakin body just like Momim used it to revive himself? 4) What if the Anakin we see in Ahsoka, seeing the mess that is the sequel trilogy with Palpatine even alive, decides he needs to take another approach, as keeper of the World Between Worlds he understands Order 66 and the Empire were needed for a restart of both the galaxy and Jedi, but not to do so much damage to the point the Republic wasnt even properly reestablished (the New Republic had to coexist with the First Order and never had the legitimacy and control of the Republic) and Palpatine could survive. Deciding he must not intervene directly, he appears to Ahsoka at the end of the Clone Wars and decides he will bring balance through her, he trains her in both Light and Dark, eventually even directing her to bathe in the Pool of Knowledge and drink from the Font of power, but with him overseeing the process and Ahsoka having the Daughter's lifeforce she wont become twisted like Abeloth, but instead a being of balance. Ready to lead an early rebellion and lay the smackdown on Sidious in the earlier years of the Empire.

[@danielharman572]

What if obi-wan kanobi requested to be assigned to mandalore as a jedi watchman and he took anakin skywalker to train him as a jedi and the jedi Council allowed it. Kind regards from Daniel Harman.

[@brianvernon249]

What if the Jedi Temple had a course named “Ezra Bridger” The entire class content is to go to Lothal, find outside-the-order-Master Bridger & learn his lessons, which are: Don’t shoehorn yourself into a group Darkness can show you the light Self sacrifice is OK if la Resistance lives on. Other Hanharr wisdom nuggets.

[@Kubinda12345]

I've some ideas for What If: - What if Qui-Gon managed to cut through the door before the Droidekas arrived? - What if Palpatine wasn't elected the chancellor of the Republic in Phantom Menace? - What if Anakin became friends with Iskat Akaris? - What if Mill Aliberth (the Youngling from the Brotherhood book) became Anakin's Padawan? - What if Anakin's bombing run managed to kill Grievous on Malevolence - What if it was Saw and not Steela who died on Onderon? - What if Anakin killed Dooku in their duel during the Rako Hardeen arc? - What if Tarkin died in the Citadel meaning there would be no Tarkin Doctrine for the Empire? - What if Qi'ra joined the Galactic Empire with Han perhaps becoming an ISB agent? - What if Han killed Darth Vader during the battle of Yavin? - What if the Ashmead's Lock's prisoners succeeded in assassinating Mon Mothma meaning that Leia would become chancellor and the New Republic wouldn't demilitarize?

[@legotimefuntime5438]

Please do more stories with EU material. So much potential can not be wasted.

[@brokenbridge6316]

"What if" Sidious, Vader, and Luke all died on the Second Death Star?

[@daltonsmith4823]

Good crossover would be the clone army used Master Chief's dna instead of jango fett

[@brokenbridge6316]

"What if" Hera was Force-Sensitive?

[@alduintheanti-dragonborn]

What if Sidious successfully pulled out Ezra (and maybe even Ahsoka) from the World Between Worlds?

[@brokenbridge6316]

"What if" Padme was a Jedi?

[@Fireprotruther98]

What if Obi-Wan turn to the dark side right after Darth maul kills Qui gon Jin

[@magnuslindal4044]

what if gregor made the exfil with D-squad

[@yoboitboy2009]

What if Bail Organa survived Alderaan

[@Kilgorio]

Cool

[@mattstorm360]

Distraction! Excellent idea Obi-Wan. What if Steela Gerrera survived? What if Tarkin Destroyed Lothal instead of Alderaan? What if Hondo discovered Ezra before the ghost crew? (Pirate Jedi!) What if Ezra's parents, or at least his father, was sent to the Narkina 5 Imperial Prison Complex? What if Anakin helped Obi Wan save Satine? What if General Kalani joined the rebels? What if Palpatine lost his connection to the force? (When trying to turn Yoda, the force would push back.) What if Ezra joined the empire? (Like the what if Luke joined the empire.) What if Palpatine really did love democracy? What if Dooku owned a tusken rifle for home defense? (Three ruffians break into his home.) What if Pente Patrol Star Wars was the Jedi's PR manager? What if Star Wars was in Earth? What if Cham Syndulla was made Senator? (Instead of trying to get rid of Cham Syndulla, the empire gets rid of Orn Free Taa and makes Syndulla the senate leader. Using his popularity with his people to control the population and the semi unspoken threat that his daughter could be considered an accomplice to Gobi Glie's vile act of murdering Orn Free Taa if he didn't.) What if Imperial Bio-weapons project I71A was run by dr Nuvo Vindi on Lothal? What if Sabine Wren stayed with the Empire? What if Haji fired on the escape pod? (First off, Bolvan would have to do some paper work and then be told later it wasn't necessary anymore as the imperial senate was no longer a factor.) What if Obi-Wan used force heal on Padme? What if Captian Tarkin died at the citadel? What if Asajj Ventress and the Nightsisters successfully assassinated Dooku? What if Anakin was born a women? Kendall Skywalker. What if Anakin died to torture? (I don't know what you mean. -Dooku) What if that super Tactical droid that threw hands with Anakin, killed him? (Smashed his helmet and he suffocated.)

[@randomiser2267]

What if the Rebel Alliance Base on Hoth was infiltrated by The Thing?

[@adamb89]

I like to consider what the new order would use for weapons. Lightsabers were destructive tools, but neither the Jedi nor the Sith used them in combat because they were terribly effective weapons. The Jedi used them specifically *because* they were difficult to use and as a symbol, and the Sith only used them to mock the Jedi ("anything you can do I can do better"). What if some ex-Jedi force user looked at his lightsaber in disgust one day and went "Y'know...this thing is actually a piece of crap...." and started using something else. What kind of force powers might be unlocked if they specialized in blasters? Shooting blaster shots out of the air with your own blaster shots. Using the Force to literally fire around corners. Firing shots into the air that hover in place until you're ready to release them all at once as a single powerful penetrative blast. Strafe a target with homing rapid-fire shots from multiple angles, overwhelming defenses. Lightsabers are great melee weapons for sure, they're really only effective for dudes right up in your face. What if you really wanna wreck that dude *waaaay over there*, a blaster really is the way to go.