WHAT IF? SONIC AND TAILS NEVER MET? PART 1 | What if Sonic

Welcome to What If Sonic! In this series we explore different scenarios in the Sonic Universe. Join me as we explore the scenario of Sonic and Tails never meeting! For now...
All copyrighted things are owned by their respective owners.
Music Used-
Hunter x Hunter 99 - Ka Cheisu
Sonic 2 HD - Emerald Hill
Sonic 2 Hedgehog Haven Album - Wing Fortress
Dragon Soul Orchestral Version
#sonic #sonicthehedgehog #sonicfrontiers

[@tntsonic7482]

Part 2 is now up! kzbin.info/www/bejne/p2KbpH-nnJqBmbs

[@wyattm6782]

Cool

[@DaCrazyPurpleBiscuit]

There is a comic about this "called where was my hero" a pretty sad but great comic

[@yourguysnow2783]

And now we have sonic prime

[@axelh20]

@@yourguysnow2783 There is also an episode of Sonic Boom that deals with what would happen to the other characters if Sonic did not exist, obviously the tone is much lighter than Prime, but it is still interesting that SPOILER: Tails is Eggman's Sidekick/Assistant, who rules the town where they live with an iron fist, so Tails is technically a villain.

[@user-eh2vi6lk7n]

Don't forget it's discontinued prequel kzbin.info/www/bejne/p3mafKppr6yoprMsi=Borl4V9QLSRF80aa

[@kawaiiskittle3512]

Yesss I know that comic and yes, it is very sad 😢

[@comicfan1324]

I’m interested to see what Miles gets up to this timeline.

[@PlushPoweer]

Hey comic

[@CaliburnEditz]

sussy pfp

[@hi_tobby3771]

Yeah!

[@wyattm6782]

Its here!

[@M3lonplush]

He will become nine from Sonic prime

[@katelynthewhitewerewolf6376]

It's funny because in The newest Sonic TV Series Sonic Prime we actually get something like this it's where Tails becomes Nine Tails because he didn't have anyone to help him when he was bullied and he got bullied so bad he grew up bitter from all the bullying he got for his two tails and isolated himself from everyone thinking everything and everyone was nothing but cold and heartless and he had no friends. I do like his Nine Tails design though it's so cool.

[@axelh20]

And in Sonic Boom there is an episode in a dimension where Sonic doesn't exist, in this one Eggman rules with an iron fist and Tails is his loyal sidekick/assistant, so he is technically a villain.

[@user-eh2vi6lk7n]

"Where Was My Hero...?" came earlier than Prime, what a coincidence that is.

[@katelynthewhitewerewolf6376]

@@axelh20 Yeah I remember that episode

[@sosku1070]

There is also a Prequel to that story.@@user-eh2vi6lk7n

[@aliciabrown8132]

sonic is one of the reasons tails accepted his abnormality of his double-tails, and without tails, sonic would probably be dead on several occasions because of his recklessness so-

[@VictoryOnYouTube]

It just shows no matter what, if Sonic does not meet Tails. Tails would never be a good person in the future because of his terrible past of bullying that kept clouding him. Sonic kept Tails active as a character no matter how rude he may be in some titles. Without Sonic being sonic, in Sonic Forces my dude just crashed. He couldn’t be what he was in the past. A brave young sidekick who defeated every enemy with Knuckles and Sonic. It’s insane that if they don’t meet Tails just becomes evil and most likely sets the village on fire.

[@sosku1070]

this dude watched "where was my hero...?" there is also a prequel. Which shows that as I heard from some words before. "No matter in which dimension they are. They are still fated to meet each other."

[@thesmilingman7576]

I just realized something according to the Japanese Sonic 3 manual the reason Sonic and Tails went to Angek Island is because they detected strong chao energy readings and decided to investigate if Tails isn't with Sonic why did he go Angel Island

[@boblesponge]

No? It's because it's where the death egg fell

[@daggerfly0087]

@@boblesponge but he didn't know that, so why did he go to angle island

[@Reginald_Ritmo]

​@@daggerfly0087maybe Sonic heard a rumor that Eggman was at Angel Island to build a spacecraft

[@ASHE_ATTACC]

"the ship starts to crumble under the pressure" You mean...Lack of pressure? Space is a vacuum, it'd be *pulling* rather than *compressing.*

[@Preston-T.-Fox]

There is already a version of this it's called "where was my hero" he tripped over a damn rock and missed his opportunity

[@user-eh2vi6lk7n]

Yes, and there was an prequel about it. kzbin.info/www/bejne/p3mafKppr6yoprMsi=Borl4V9QLSRF80aa

[@jettlucashayes8508]

the main question is, can miles get a love life that doesn't get undone?

[@thesmilingman7576]

1:20 I don't think Robotnik stole them as you can go super on the Wing Fortress

[@My_hands_are_sticky]

Man I really like the what if's that you make, now I wonder what will happend to "miles" without metting sonic, mostly likely he will be an edge lord just like shadow and don't believing in friends or anything, but great vid like always!

[@Sonicmid]

Shadows not a edge of lord but I get what you're saying.

[@My_hands_are_sticky]

@@Sonicmid lol I know it just my way to say it

[@My_hands_are_sticky]

@IsaacInfernape2000 (Raman) (18+) oof sorry, thanks for pointing that out I will change it

[@My_hands_are_sticky]

Babe wake up new TntSonic theory video!

[@Sonicmid]

Pretty good the editing was really nice I do have some problems mostly concerning timeline . Since tails Sky Patrol is technically Canon what will happen with wichcart . I'm pretty sure Sonic meets Ray and mighty after chaotix. Sega Sonic I think now is after chaotix so that's why.

[@My_hands_are_sticky]

Wait what? I didn't knew sky patrol was Canon, but if that's the case then it's going to be interesting to see what wichcart does in this timeline, and I always thought that sega sonic happend after or before sonic 1, but did sega said that sega sonic is now after chaotix?

[@Sonicmid]

@@My_hands_are_sticky it got confirmed that Sonic Labyrinth was Canon and saw in the Japanese manual Labyrinth is connected Sky Patrol. Sega Sonic actually takes place after Sonic R this was confirmed by Ian Flynn. What I think they're trying to do is to make a reason why Ray was not in knuckles chaotix. That reason being he didn't meet Mighty yet as Sega Sonic takes place after that

[@My_hands_are_sticky]

@@Sonicmid Man I didn't knew any of that, huge thanks! I would of preffered sega sonic to not be way to far of the classic games somewhere in between idk sonic cd or something like that, but it's alright

[@Sonicmid]

@@My_hands_are_sticky it probably was originally before Sonic 1 but because Knuckles chaotix became Cannon they needed a reason for why Ray was not in the game so they set it way after that game. Some more proof: in mania's manual it mentions that mighty's last adventure was on Eggman Island and that game makes it really clear that Mighty knows knuckles. That means that chaotix is before Sega Sonic the Hedgehog

[@heftyrumble]

@@Sonicmid In my timeline, I have Chaotix after Mania Adventures on the timeline. I chose Mania Adventures as canon and not Mania+ because it's just the same as Mania with a few differences, and in IDW (it's the closest to game canon as possible), Eggman tells Starline that he doesn't like yo do the same thing twice. That isn't his character. Anyway, on why it's relevant to Knuckles Chaotix, is because in Mania Adventures, Ray shows Knuckles a missing poster for Mighty, and Knuckles shrugs in not having seen him

[@gabrielmachado1247]

Yeah we all know this really is them meeting later,maybe wayyy later,i won't know,but for know the timeline is fully secure even if Sonic had to go through 2,3 & knuckles alone xd

[@criesinvariable2493]

there are two aus i can think of: where was my hero and the dystopian future in sonic prime one of these aus include murder

[@thesmilingman7576]

2:37 perhaps this is the competition only zone called Endless Mine

[@user-eh2vi6lk7n]

As I heard from some words before. "No matter in which dimension they are. They are still fated to meet each other."

[@skeletonlover3214]

Sonic is a pretty competent hero

[@thegreattoaster]

Interesting what if

[@theultimatememelord5494]

When's what if Silver went too far back part 3?

[@tntsonic7482]

After I finish part 2 of this I'll be working on part 3 of silver!

[@thesmilingman7576]

2:10 Mecha Sonic MK1

[@kartezbrown9460]

2:39 endless mine?

[@garbage5222]

The rise of Omelet Boy ❤❤❤

[@thesmilingman7576]

3:35 doesn't Sega Sonoc happen after Sonic R (according to Ian Flynn)

[@theultimatememelord5494]

Isn't this just Nine's backstory?

[@Nafi_yft2202]

So it like nine But tails was not bron in eggman worlds

[@LuciansAnimations]

well thats sad

[@nadx268]

That answer was in Sonic Prime where if Sonic never meet him i would turn into Miles "Nine" Prower.

[@tntsonic7482]

I made this before Sonic prime

[@nadx268]

@@tntsonic7482 I know but i think the clip with the backstory of Nine was already out.

[@tntsonic7482]

@nadx268 Even then prime is a different scenario. Nine grows up in a world where Sonic doesn't exist and Eggman takes over. This what if just has him not meet sonic. It's a key difference

[@nadx268]

@@tntsonic7482 Yeah, I am just saying that the stroy is similair

[@rolandcabral5295]

If you think about it, Tails Nine from Sonic Prime is likely what your theory, what Tails is if he never met Sonic.

[@sosku1070]

and "where was my hero...?" Don't forget that.

[@-WarriorCatsGamer]

2:03 what comic is that?

[@tntsonic7482]

Sonic Genesis from Archie.

[@EnclaveStormXL]

Wait Wouldn’t Sonic die at the end of sonic 2 there’s no tails to catch him with the torpedoe and he can’t become super sonic because there’s zero rings in death egg zone so would he have just fallen to his death?

[@tntsonic7482]

In the good ending of Sonic 2 he flys out of the Death Egg as Super Sonic.

[@scottdreemurrthegodofcreation]

Tails would become a villain duh

[@sosku1070]

And a competent one in fact.

[@silveramyknux241]

Tails Nine ;)

[@user-eh2vi6lk7n]

no no. "Where Was My Hero...?" It came earlier than prime.

[@silveramyknux241]

@@user-eh2vi6lk7n That’s why I have the emoticon. I was just joking.

[@user-eh2vi6lk7n]

aaaaah sneaky remark. By the way I think someone reuploaded prequel to that comic.@@silveramyknux241

[@shinovazyle3020]

But what if sonic never mets anyone

[@garbage5222]

The rise of Omelet Boy ❤❤❤

[@tntsonic7482]

🤡🤡🤡

[@garbage5222]

@@tntsonic7482 how dare you

[@garbage5222]

@@tntsonic7482 omelet boy will not tolerate this

[@garbage5222]

@@tntsonic7482 omelet boy will not tolerate this