Where did Chinese communism come from? | Behind the Book with Professor Tony Saich

The Chinese Communist Party is profoundly influential both inside and outside China's borders. But few know of its early history, and until recently, the most prominent narrative of its origins came from the Party itself. But the recent release of two collections of documents reveals a more nuanced story than the official narrative. On this episode of Behind the Book, we speak with Tony Saich, Daewoo Professor of International Affairs and Director of the Ash Center at Harvard Kennedy School, about his new book, "Finding Allies and Making Revolution: The Early Years of the Chinese Communist Party," which provides an in-depth study of these new documents.
---------------------
About Harvard Kennedy School:
The John F. Kennedy School of Government at Harvard University is a graduate and professional school that brings together students, scholars, and practitioners who combine thought and action to make the world a better place.
Our mission is to improve public policy and public leadership across the United States and around the world so that people can lead safer, freer, and more prosperous lives. Harvard Kennedy School teaches current and future leaders the skills they need to effectively advance the public purpose in the public, nonprofit, and private sectors. Our renowned faculty and trailblazing research centers pioneer bold new ideas. And as the most international school at Harvard, we convene global leaders in the Forum, host visiting experts in the classroom, and attract a diverse community of faculty, students, and staff.

[@changyang1498]

Wtf is this comment section? Either I’m having a stroke or the Chinese government is commenting on this video.

[@brad349miller]

Yup. It's disgusting.

[@bullseye99]

Would love to purchase the book. If anyone has a clean copy ($20 or less) please let me know.

[@mariapiade-rozza6749]

Thank you. I really appreciate your research and interviews.

[@LemurJackson]

No problem bro, I did the animations, research, voice over, and talked to Tony Saich. I also made you. I am your birth father.

[@Sirji2057]

.

[@edwardjing5539]

Henk Sneevliet has another name，Maring, or Ma Lin 马林 这个Hank Sneevliet就是“马林” We usually talk about him in the context of Comintern’s connections with the Chinese Nationalist Party. 我们一般谈到他都是说“共产国际和国民党的关系”如何如何 Not knowing his role in the CCP’s founding. 不知道他在中共历史上的作用

[@hahaha-tu4oh]

一大就是馬林主持的，二大開始陳獨秀才被推舉為委員長

[@riskifadli6113]

He was also being influential for the founding of Indonesian Communist Party.

[@retogamed]

jews, it was jews, just as karl marx was a jew

[@cristiangerardinobilityhou5410]

Time for the "Gök-China" project: joint ventures of those countries within the past Gõkturk empire. Russia, China, Turkey and some middle eastern countries.

[@xiaoxiaowu6449]

Why you use Wang Jingwei's photo at 1:46...

[@jaderhe]

你指望美国人真的能懂什么？

[@mahmudmarsudi4430]

Also in Indonesia, a dutchman, Hank Sneevliet

[@rupeshpatel232297]

As Indian I support India but good to know china's history

[@666tentaxion]

you support fascism if your country do so?

[@666tentaxion]

I'm an Indian and i support china

[@KJ-kn2rz]

Me too

[@jacobfield4848]

The Banks created Communism the Chinese people have no say or control over China.

[@weiner392]

What’s this video got anything to do with that dust ass country bruh

[@teensintimestntx7068]

i studied it on our history book,i am a 14-year-old student in china,it is difficult for us(English is so hard....)

[@factsdontcareaboutyourfeel7747]

English isn’t my first language too and it was hard for me. I improved it by watching hollywood movies, tv series, not skipping the cut scenes in pc games😂 and participating in debates and stuff. It really isn’t that difficult

[@mariespeaks2542]

Boy wonder shut the fuck up. How about you learn Chinese and then tell us it’s not hard? Also, he’s saying “it is difficult for us” in reference to COMMUNISM. Not speaking English.

[@florinabn4669]

@@mariespeaks2542 woa woa chill the f out asshole, would you? Wtf is wrong with you attacking people like that who were only replying nicely, did you even read what they said? They put English is hard between parantheses which means they were referring to the language, not to communism! and nobody was speaking about learning Chinese here, but about English! The other person is not an English native speaker either! You just made yourself a fool

[@factsdontcareaboutyourfeel7747]

Marie Speaks I’m asian too. English is my 3rd language. I was just suggesting him on how to improve his English skills

[@factsdontcareaboutyourfeel7747]

Florina Bn lmfao why is she even triggered?😂 I’m asian too

[@lucyinhnkmm8864]

when i noticed the map don’t have taiwan ,i know this video’s opoin simplely

[@someonewhocares5924]

Thanks for noticing this

[@nosyrosie3716]

Thank you 🙏.

[@salmon9130]

Grigory Zinoviev, Andrey Vyshinsky, Adolf Joffe, Mikhail Borodin, Richard Sorge......

[@prophet_master]

ave ave

[@razzaman9023]

We all know what connects all of these people together

[@luckytiger5551]

Go read "Mao" written by Philip Short, a book written by a professional reporter who lived in China for decades and writes the chronicle of events in ginger details base vast credible documentary references.

[@luckytiger5551]

@Michael Ojeda that's what Mao said to the Red Guards, who are equivalent to (and copied from) Mussolini's "Blackshirts" and Hitler's "Brownshirts". They are masses of thugs who served the tyrants as cult members. Worship has always been a part og the tyrants' schemes.

[@ouyangtimothy9164]

​@@luckytiger5551 Shut your nonsense, that very word was said to the students in University of Moscow when Mao was giving a lecture there at Nov 17th, 1957. Back then the red-guard did not even exist. It just takes a simple google to learn the truth but instead you chose to spread misleading and hateful messages.

[@luckytiger5551]

@@ouyangtimothy9164 You idiot

[@jacklai8933]

E Z I don’t think you get it, but of course since your a Karen I doubt you’d understand with all that American propaganda in your head

[@luckytiger5551]

@@jacklai8933 I recommend you stop your worship of Mao and stop imagine your shared his success or glory, you will not meet him or Jesus anyways, and he will not give you what you did not get from America. Keep a straight mind.

[@tybriggs9880]

Evil is sneaky

[@Antxnio.ForReal]

Sneak 100

[@s1050]

What’s “evil” about China? If anything the US is the most evil country in the world. Disgusting place that bombs and murders innocent people, starts illegal wars, worships evil consumerism and capitalism, full of gun nuts and crime and is one of the most unequal countries in the world despite being the richest...

[@andyfriederichsen]

@@s1050 Okay Winnie.

[@mariapiade-rozza6749]

Why a Dutch person was involved with the Chinese group

[@DmoneyS44]

He was part of the global communist movement at the time and was sent to China to advise Chinese revolutionaries

[@citationduninternaute]

Comment quotation : I’m from Malaysia. China has traded with Malaysia for 2000 years. In those years, they had been the world’s biggest powers many times. Never once they sent troops to take our land. Admiral Zhenghe came to Malacca five times, in gigantic fleets, and a flagship eight times the size of Christopher Columbus’ flagship, Santa Maria. He could have seized Malacca easily, but he did not. In 1511, the Portuguese came. In 1642, the Dutch came. In the 18th century the British came. We were colonised by each, one after another. When China wanted spices from India, they traded with the Indians. When they wanted gems, they traded with the Persian. They didn’t take lands. The only time China expanded beyond their current borders was in Yuan Dynasty, when Genghis and his descendants Ogedei Khan, Guyuk Khan & Kublai Khan concurred China, Mid Asia and Eastern Europe. But Yuan Dynasty, although being based in China, was a part of the Mongolian Empire. Then came the Century of Humiliation. Britain smuggled opium into China to dope the population, a strategy to turn the trade deficit around, after the British could not find enough silver to pay the Qing Dynasty in their tea and porcelain trades. After the opium warehouses were burned down and ports were closed by the Chinese in ordered to curb opium, the British started the Opium War I, which China lost. Hong Kong was forced to be surrendered to the British in a peace talk (Nanjing Treaty). The British owned 90% of the opium market in China, during that time, Queen Victoria was the world’s biggest drug baron. The remaining 10% was owned by American merchants from Boston. Many of Boston’s institutions were built with profit from opium. After 12 years of Nanjing Treaty, the West started getting really really greedy. The British wanted the Qing government: 1. To open the borders of China to allow goods coming in and out freely, and tax free. 2. Make opium legal in China. Insane requests, Qing government said no. The British and French, with supports from the US and Russia from behind, started Opium War II with China, which again, China lost. The Anglo-French military raided the Summer Palace, and threatened to burn down the Imperial Palace, the Qing government was forced to pay with ports, free business zones, 300,000 kilograms of silver and Kowloon was taken. Since then, China’s resources flew out freely through these business zones and ports. In the subsequent amendment to the treaties, Chinese people were sold overseas to serve as labor. In 1900, China suffered attacks by the 8-National Alliance(Japan, Russia, Britain, France, USA, Germany, Italy, Austria-Hungary). Innocent Chinese civilians in Peking (Beijing now) were murdered, buildings were destroyed & women were raped. The Imperial Palace was raided, and treasures ended up in museums like the British Museum in London and the Louvre in Paris. In late 1930s China was occupied by the Japanese in WWII. Millions of Chinese died during the occupancy. 300,000 Chinese died in Nanjing Massacre alone. Mao brought China together again from the shambles. There were peace and unity for some time. But Mao’s later reign saw sufferings and deaths from famine and power struggles. Then came Deng Xiao Ping and his infamous “black-cat and white-cat” story. His preference in pragmatism than ideologies has transformed China. This thinking allowed China to evolve all the time to adapt to the actual needs in the country, instead of rigidly bounded to ideologies. It also signified the death of Communism in actually practice in China. The current Socialism+Meritocracy+Market Economy model fits the Chinese like gloves, and it propels the uprise of China. Singapore has a similar model, and has been arguably more successful than Hong Kong, because Hong Kong being gateway to China, was riding on the economic boom in China, while Singapore had no one to gain from. In just 30 years, the CPC have moved 800 millions of people out from poverty. The rate of growth is unprecedented in human history. They have built the biggest mobile network, by far the biggest high speed rail network in the world, and they have become a behemoth in infrastructure. They made a fishing village called Shenzhen into the world’s second largest technological centre after the Silicon Valley. They are growing into a technological power house. It has the most elaborate e-commerce and cashless payment system in the world. They have launched exploration to Mars. The Chinese are living a good life and China has become one of the safest countries in the world. The level of patriotism in the country has reached an unprecedented height. For all of the achievements, the West has nothing good to say about it. China suffers from intense anti-China propagandas from the West. Western Media used the keyword “Communist” to instil fear and hatred towards China. Everything China does is negatively reported. They claimed China used slave labor in making iPhones. The truth was, Apple was the most profitable company in the world, it took most of the profit, leave some to Foxconn (a Taiwanese company) and little to the labor. They claimed China was inhuman with one-child policy. At the same time, they accused China of polluting the earth with its huge population. The fact is the Chinese consume just 30% of energy per capita compared to the US. They claimed China underwent ethnic cleansing in Xinjiang. The fact is China has a policy which priorities ethnic minorities. For a long time, the ethnic minorities were allowed to have two children and the majority Han only allowed one. The minorities are allowed a lower score for university intakes. There are 39,000 mosque in China, and 2100 in the US. China has about 3 times more mosque per muslim than the US. When terrorist attacks happened in Xinjiang, China had two choices: 1. Re-educate the Uighur extremists before they turned terrorists. 2. Let them be, after they launch attacks and killed innocent people, bomb their homes. China chose 1 to solve problem from the root and not to do killing. How the US solve terrorism? Fire missiles from battleships, drop bombs from the sky. During the pandemic, When China took extreme measures to lockdown the people, they were accused of being inhuman. When China recovered swiftly because of the extreme measures, they were accused of lying about the actual numbers. When China’s cases became so low that they could provide medical support to other countries, they were accused of politically motivated. Western Media always have reasons to bash China. Just like any country, there are irresponsible individuals from China which do bad and dirty things, but the China government overall has done very well. But I hear this comment over and over by people from the West: I like Chinese people, but the CPC is evil. What they really want is the Chinese to change the government, because the current one is too good. Fortunately China is not a multi-party democratic country, otherwise the opposition party in China will be supported by notorious NGOs (Non-Government Organization) of the USA, like the NED (National Endowment for Democracy), to topple the ruling party. The US and the British couldn’t crack Mainland China, so they work on Hong Kong. Of all the ex-British colonial countries, only the Hong Kongers were offered BNOs by the British. Because the UK would like the Hong Kongers to think they are British citizens, not Chinese. A divide-and-conquer strategy, which they often used in Color Revolutions around the world. They resort to low dirty tricks like detaining Huawei’s CFO & banning Huawei. They raised a silly trade war which benefits no one. Trade deficit always exist between a developing and a developed country. USA is like a luxury car seller who ask a farmer: why am I always buying your vegetables and you haven’t bought any of my cars? When the Chinese were making socks for the world 30 years ago, the world let it be. But when Chinese started to make high technology products, like Huawei and DJI, it caused red-alert. Because when Western and Japanese products are equal to Chinese in technologies, they could never match the Chinese in prices. First world countries want China to continue in making socks. Instead of stepping up themselves, they want to pull China down. The recent movement by the US against China has a very important background. When Libya, Iran, and China decided to ditch the US dollar in oil trades, Gaddafi’s was killed by the US, Iran was being sanctioned by the US, and now it’s China’s turn. The US has been printing money out of nothing. The only reason why the US Dollar is still widely accepted, is because it’s the only currency which oil is allowed to be traded with. The US has an agreement with Saudi that oil must be traded in US dollar ONLY. Without the petrol-dollar status, the US dollars will sink, and America will fall. Therefore anyone trying to disobey this order will be eliminated. China will soon use a gold-backed crypto-currency, the alarms in the White House go off like mad. China’s achievement has been by hard work. Not by looting the world. I have deep sympathy for China for all the suffering, but now I feel happy for them. China is not rising, they are going back to where they belong. Good luck China.

[@avilafitness3751]

@@citationduninternaute I see you teacher

[@renatocorreaarrieche]

@@citationduninternaute "The British owned 90% of the opium market in China, during that time, Queen Victoria was the world’s biggest drug baron" Take that, Pablo Escobar!

[@citationduninternaute]

The Covid-19 is neither Chinese nor French, it is American: F O R T D E T R I C K American center for biochemical weapons research. The Covid-19 appeared in the United States in September 2019, the government disguised itself as influenza, hence the unusually high figure of flu deaths in the United States. A scientific publication talked about it: kzbin.info/aero/PLOlB2r4hfY_9uWaubKEpK34sTzxe7Tewz

[@michaelpocci1876]

On July the First, they'll celebrate the 100th Anniversary of the Foundation of the Chinese Communist Party. So expect HUUUGE celebrations and military parades, probably

[@hawkingsonharbous5518]

Harved Kenedey School even makes many sorts of mistakes in Chinese map.It’s just funny and ridiclues when people have seen what happaned.

[@ianlouden7939]

Do you mean the cartographer told to draw 5 dashes on a map left behind by the British, then claim all within these dashes legally belongs to China?

[@everythingisoverparty1809]

Wow I hope we have some hopeful leader that will revult against the communist party

[@everythingisoverparty1809]

@Soldat a/s why

[@everythingisoverparty1809]

@Soldat a/s not the government the communist party

[@everythingisoverparty1809]

@Soldat a/s what I mean is it shouldn't be Communist

[@everythingisoverparty1809]

@Soldat a/s no the Soviet Union set it up to be anti capitalist and communist

[@everythingisoverparty1809]

@Soldat a/s but why do they still claim it's communist

[@j.dunlop8295]

Red Roulette, book !

[@Exodus26.13Pi]

Is this about China or an American teacher?

[@user-nz9gn9xe5r]

@@user-sf3vw3kh3b 给我爬

[@Sodierof4tuneBabi]

united states of china

[@UnionAndroidSRboi]

The same founder of Indonesian Communist Party...Sneevliet

[@danfrancis3581]

No mention of Chen Duxiu?

[@sakura7431]

Such a poor video. Talking about foundation of CPC without mentioning Chen Duxiu and Li Dazhao then implying the CPC was founded by communism international single handed? Seriously? what research is this... and actually none of those points about early period of CPC are secret, anyone who has researched subject knows and have a clear understanding about the origin of the party. I think this kind of low quality cheap "discovery of the truth" kind of research is the main reason why US think tanks can not get China right, not even right one single time in the past 20 years. SAD.

[@jjjjjjjjula]

I agree that this video is very bland and oblivious, it should be complemented with more information. But it helps understanding the influence of the Komintern into China's Comunist Party

[@sakura7431]

@@jjjjjjjjula yes, indeed. and the influence of Komintern in CPC's foundation is not a secret at all. but probably many people are not aware of that, in that aspect, it do help viewers to have a full picture of the history.

[@jhonklan3794]

yet they call america imperialist 🙄

[@Tua867]

1. Chinese labor in ww1 2. Shandong Problem 3. Manifesto Karakhan.

[@ingeniouspotatohead1517]

龚飞

[@brad349miller]

❤❤❤❤

[@karsanopandiarto2165]

Snevliet give effect in indonesia, too. He is embrio of communist party in indonesia.

[@nato7185]

My wish is to make them capitalist or sosialist

[@gonosol]

Gho3t does it create it or take advantage of it?

[@blankblank5409]

Stfu nato

[@blankblank5409]

Gho3t 😘

[@MultiZeek]

You capitalist pig

[@nato7185]

This is a fucking joke

[@huhhuhhuh5029]

Hold a case us for tupac

[@zeekmx1970]

It came from the depths of hell.

[@coronavirusisacommunistchi845]

Revelations 12:3, 12:9. You are right. The Word of God in the Book of Revelations agrees with you. China is Satan.

[@jaderhe]

@@coronavirusisacommunistchi845 这么快就快进到抹黑成恶魔了？当年你们也是这么抹黑德国人的吧？

[@tianlezheng6829]

傻逼神棍

[@retogamed]

from the synagogue of satan

[@user-ke3sg6hy4k]

you are wrong

[@jameszhang5377]

I think it's wrong from the beginning, it should be all started from 1840.

[@Wayne-tb8tk]

It would be advantageous for it to go back to where it came from, with everything else that never evolved into something that works for the people, not the other way round ,!!!

[@beautifulrelaxingmusicsoun9545]

This video is a masterpiece

[@jamesguo4510]

As a Chinese, I want to say something to Americans. The world is big enough for 2 political systems. We never force you to have ours, please don’t force us to have yours.

[@marcioleonardo9859]

👏👏👏 You are right!

[@PeXis]

Zero tolerance for totalitarian control states. We've seen where they lead and the clock is ticking for China.

[@lk7195]

We are not forcing you and no one can force us.

[@dirtydirtyshisno7284]

@@lk7195 The US has always tried to forcibly destroy socialist movements, basic history understanding proves this, it is undeniable, through backing war efforts, their own war efforts to propaganda spread worldwide

[@Mango_Eter]

"We never force you to have ours" Also China: literally has an evil mastermind plan to take over the world by 2049

[@kienphung9084]

CCP came from Russia.

[@YouLoveMrFriendly]

@Michael Ojeda , yes, and I wonder why Hong Kong protests the ccp? I mean, they'd be better off fully joining the PRC, right?

[@ouyangtimothy9164]

​@@YouLoveMrFriendly I wonder why Catalonia protests the Spanish government. I mean, they've already joined Spain, right?

[@YouLoveMrFriendly]

@@ouyangtimothy9164 You're pro CCP? You're a sick man

[@YouLoveMrFriendly]

@ThatOneAsianBroChick I think Hong Kong citizens wish they were in Britain :) Or anywhere communism doesn't reign.

[@user-eb7sy4ch7r]

lol XD

[@phosatieux2772]

this has Vox Vibes

[@TheHollandHS]

CCP today is not communist anymore but a fascist state. Is most sugarcoated said a large francoist Spanish state without a strong cult leadership. If very critical like Xinjiang camps and militaristic expansionist accusations would say a nazi without antisemitism.

[@tigermo538]

Could Tony please research on how to prevent democracy goes to moneycracy?

[@atriciacannon4579]

Bartar & trading added with self sufficiently work's well. The time is now to get out of a monitary dependency.🐦

[@ken01209]

Too late, no democracy...there is only plutocracy

[@abcdaddy2263]

Gong-Fei

[@christophereduardo9903]

It's Communist Party of China CPC, not CCP.

[@user-di5tl3iv8l]

Mikhail Borodin was evacuated on 4.12 anti-communism campaign, en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shanghai_massacre. Also, Mao is known for his 'disobedient' to '100% Bolsheviks', he was criticized not only by pro-commuinter like Wangming (on current Chinese historical textbook it is called 'a correction of leaning to left') but by Stalin himself. It's well-known in China but sadly neglected by this professor.

[@isaacp170]

Map is wrong it

[@Cryptic_Keeper]

It came from hell

[@BeefT-Sq]

" Dictatorship and determinism are reciprocally reinforcing corollaries : if one seeks to enslave men, one has to destroy their reliance on the validity of their own judgments and choices---if one believes that reason and volition are impotent, one has to accept the rule of force. " -Ayn Rand-

[@aben7810]

Nice one! We need communication and compromises apparently to start anything

[@ganboonmeng5370]

For westerners pretending to understand China...with spending...time..in China and knowing chinese history...civilization is a joke😅

[@yo-yoyou6727]

I'm Chinese, and I don't want democracy because I see that your democracy is terrible.

[@kiwonkim94]

Isn’t KZbin illegal in China?

[@andysew100]

@@kiwonkim94 big brain hahaha

[@EzekielDBarrett]

There's plenty of places where democracy is working incredibly well. Unfortunately democracy in the US is failing for a number of reasons that would also lead it to fail (at this moment) in China -- the average person is poorly educated, nationalistic, and economically disadvantaged. China isnt ready for a proper democracy the way the soviets weren't ready for communism and the Chinese weren't ready for a Bolshevik world revolution. Now China just has a lot of the bad characteristics that came out of that period -- discrimination against minorities, centralized decision making by elites, corruption, and expansionary ambition. But these things are all working fine with their shift back to capitalism, and with the modernization of China and the improvements in education and middle class choice, the mindset of the average citizen is cluing in pretty quickly

[@user-pc2my9ej5t]

@@kiwonkim94 Legal or illegal is not matter if the police dont care wether you are visiting youtube.

[@radiokiller9032]

And yet you like live under authoritarian society where everything is limited. Even just a small complaint to a government will send you to a gulag. Say hello to the Uyghur people who suffered in a concentration camp

[@mariapiade-rozza6749]

I will buy this unique book that must circulate at every library around the world.

[@atriciacannon4579]

Don't trust those libraries, they want to control what's available to read.🐦

[@Anomize23]

@@atriciacannon4579 Thats why you buy more than one to compare 😎

[@ylh2475]

wrong map

[@JeffAPierson]

Modern growth by persecution and abuse.

[@workingproleinc.676]

Reading the westoid seething is always hilarius

[@SchuylarColfax]

Gongfei

[@user-mm2ox8en9i]

emm……哈麻批

[@user-eb7sy4ch7r]

资本主义暴徒👿

[@huhhuhhuh5029]

The one in jail will be the ones with 💣 on the to the police department to meet in nyc

[@jb894]

And now they gave us coronavirus

[@britannicustai2232]

Virus divulged from Detrick Fort, US biological arsenal

[@rohayucheri4384]

Yup troblesome country in the world

[@thomaslong6655]

US gave HIV to the world.

[@albertpacaj6871]

You can't eat this bread is clean was but it didn't really do that

[@ingeniouspotatohead1517]

50分

[@jeffkelley2445]

Drain the CCP swamp....

[@bornagain9192]

Wish they would stop buying off people sneakedly can't they do anything above board who can trust such actions

[@blueciffer1653]

you just described the US

[@bornagain9192]

@@blueciffer1653 some factions here that I don't see as ligit ad China joe is destroying our country

[@huhhuhhuh5029]

Sue department in Texas

[@ting_chang]

It’s sad that the open minded spirit is gone. 既得利益者不可能放棄利益。無神論又使得人性敗壞。

[@ting_chang]

@ 可是無神論也是宗教信仰的一種喔！當您批評宗教是給腦殘洗腦的時候，您自己也成為腦殘一員，因為您相信無神論唷！

[@alexwschan185]

@@ting_chang 神與性根本沒關係，你可拜神而又人性敗壞。

[@jameshdr5583]

Hahaha.... it’s better to keep so called god’s proxy from ruining the population !!!!

[@drannoc100]

Nine Commentaries Pt 1: What the Communist Party Is (It has both pdf and documentary series you can search and in both languages.) I heard CCP was search for its author because all Chinese love its accuracy.

[@aidantarget9439]

All hale stalin

[@prophet_master]

m

[@hijrahkuutkakhirat3467]

If it is not stopped, we are all be doomed

[@trjoshi8256]

啦啦队长春了吧？

[@trjoshi8256]

改她的事了解下雨啦

[@huhhuhhuh5029]

Meet at trump tower

[@MatheusEgger-qj4xy]

The left is not even parliamentary because the communist socialists and the left want state intervention in the world, in society, in the economy, in everything. Our world is still under the threat of the red left (of the red sect) and it wants to make the world socialist countries and make them a new communist Venezuela or countries like China where freedom does not exist, where you are watched with a chip in your back to be fined if you crossed the street line. Communism, like the State's interventionist politicians at all, fascists, Nazis, socialists all over the world, all on the left through evidence and facts with many studies, are the enemies of humanity and of God. It happened in July 1917, in the third apparition of Our Lady of Fatima that warned the three little shepherds about the danger of the communist threat that was emerging in Russia and that if the requests of Our Lady of Fatima were not granted, humanity asking forgiveness for your sins, convert, another worse war would happen and Russia would spread its errors throughout the world, promoting wars and persecution of the Church, the good would be martyred, the Holy Father would suffer and several nations would be annihilated. It is necessary for the Catholic Church to consecrate Russia to the Immaculate Heart of Mary in "union with all the bishops of the world" Though the apparitions of Our Lady of Fatima took place almost a hundred years ago, Our Lady's call to prayer and penance for the salvation of souls and peace in the world is as relevant now as when first delivered to three Portuguese peasant children in 1917.At the peak of the First World War, Our Lady warned of another worldwide conflict, the rise and spread of Communism, and a terrible persecution of the Church unless people repented of their sins and returned to God. She also requested devotion to her Immaculate Heart and a special consecration of Russia.. Read the Fatima books sold on Amazon and watch the videos below: ▪www.amazon.com/Our-Lady-Fatima-William-Walsh/dp/0385028695/ref=mp_s_a_1_6?dchild=1&keywords=our+lady+of+fatima&qid=1604940955&sr=8-6 ▪www.amazon.com/Fatima-Today-Urgent-Marian-Message/dp/1586174916/ref=pd_aw_sim_nf_14_5?_encoding=UTF8&pd_rd_i=1586174916&pd_rd_r=9f9041c0-02e3-490e-b188-79c8fb7b34c9&pd_rd_w=7Rbqr&pd_rd_wg=pLJE6&pf_rd_p=ff47f7bf-a434-49d8-a744-7510f6ab8fe6&pf_rd_r=GSYKCY51QA6B11VYCJJZ&psc=1&refRID=ZNZDFED3PB4EZC9F5WE4 ▪kzbin.info/www/bejne/i5monH1qo9SBbJo ▪kzbin.info/www/bejne/o2fFhKaXi7FpnaM ▪kzbin.info/www/bejne/pIaqnH6BdtSaetU ▪kzbin.info/www/bejne/npq5gmusp6x0lZo ▪kzbin.info/www/bejne/gInFg2aldqmql68 ▪kzbin.info/www/bejne/qp2sm4CAd7ihiKc

[@riskifadli6113]

You are talking to much.

[@Mango_Eter]

Good video, but the maps are horrendous. 1. In 1915, the Nationalist government still occupied outer Mongolia, and the ROC has always controlled Formosa (Taiwan/Chinese Taipei). But by then, Tibet had been independent for two years. And the Uyghur Xinjiang would stay independent for another 3 decades or so. 2. The Soviet Union did not have control of Kaliningrad, southern Sakhalin, or Karelia, and it did include Belarus, Ukraine, Kazakhstan, Uzbekistan, Kyrgyzstanz, Turkmenistan, Tajikistan, Georgia, Armenia, and Azerbaijan. 3. The Aral sea was still at its full size around this time, only starting to decline several decades later.

[@woliver1359]

这视频笑死我了，美国人啊……

[@314piyush]

Negative

[@user-ch4fk3ug6t]

Oi

[@joeschmoe435]

The Jews

[@anonamos6086]

Nobody will ever convince me communism is a good thing.

[@telugumirchy5339]

You better get my Indian map correct. You are offending 1.4 Billion people. Get your facts right.

[@Me-ht9yb]

Either way theyd be offending over a billion people.

[@telugumirchy5339]

@Joe Bravo Someone is sad and pissed. Want a lolly?

[@Nate-ud2yt]

Judaism

[@nguyenhoanglong420]

YES COMRADE BOLSHEVIKS = NEW ISRAEL JEWISH OF LAND AND USA SUPPORT IT COMRADE !

[@kshitizsiwakoti6982]

China’s map was different until 1949 to 1951 as Tibet and Xinjiang wasn’t a part of China before that

[@jameshdr5583]

Wrong info.... Tibet and Xinjiang are part of a China way before 1949 !!!!

[@kshitizsiwakoti6982]

@@jameshdr5583 Tibet was a separate country before 1951. They had a different flag and sovereignty. Why do u think the Dalai Lama had to flee who by the way was the monarch of Tibet and talking Xinjiang before 1949 it was the nation of east Turkestan. Xinjiang literally means new territory in Mandarin.

[@jameshdr5583]

@@kshitizsiwakoti6982 Tibet was under ROC and before that Qing dynasty. Tibet never was an independent country.

[@Mango_Eter]

Yeah, and the ROC still controlled outer Mongolia in 1915. Plus, they used modern borders for russia...

[@jiajunxu614]

Tibet and Xinjiang are all controlled by Qing empire and ROC. Dalai was not born in Tibet but Qinghai Province. He was chosen to become Dalai with the certification of ROC government.

[@TTTTTTTTT853]

Wish China could go back to the 'Spring and Autumn period', where it was basically democracy but just 2000 years back

[@TTTTTTTTT853]

@Chen Nan bruh seriously??

[@jiuncho4435]

No, 白左

[@YHT-fn8ib]

You are wrong. Democracy only existed among the nobles at that time, and there were a large number of slaves at that time. And that is not democracy, but a set of aristocratic etiquette.

[@user-cp4we2us8d]

i want your country go back to china,s 战国zhanguo，after springand autumn

[@jameshdr5583]

Hahah, go back to emperors era, and forever wars ???? Hahahaha....

[@drannoc100]

Harvard professors - please don’t put salt on Chinese people’s wounds!!

[@arandomchinese6706]

What the heck..

[@treasure7118]

its literally history bro

[@user-lt6ke9hg8f]

@@arandomchinese6706 这个视频。非常的有偏见。隐藏信息。 西方国家不会有未来。因为你们无视历史。扭曲历史。

[@user-xi3qq1su9c]

可惜赵国修了

[@austinharris5346]

Lmao why are you using the modern borders for artwork depicting the late Qing, warlord period, and civil war era political developments? Hard to even call it an error, just an astounding amount of laziness making for some very misleading details.

[@tingli9408]

汪精卫都有了？

[@karenisak9631]

GOD BLESS AMERICA AND THE AMERICAN PEOPLE.

[@MasontheMarxistDog]

Rothschild and jews

[@VentilatorenBumser]

Jews? Chinese people

[@andykaufman7620]

Communism is not really a 'Working Class' movement. It is really a movement of elitists, who use the working class for their own ends, and the history of communism demonstrates that fact. It is in fact an Oligarchical elitist system that is akin to a tyranny of the Skilled Labor over the Unskilled Labor, and control by those who organize and control Skilled Labor toward ends that primarily benefit the ruling class of Oligarchic elites or in some cases, Autocratic, where the Oligarchy itself is put in check by one 'first among equals' who is obviously more than equal to the other oligarchs and political class.

[@andykaufman7620]

What you see is that Communism is a FORIEGN ideology to China. Think about that. China and the Han are ruled by an ideology Chinese people did not generate, cultivate, and embrace by indigenous origins. China is ruled not by Chinese, but by other interests by proxy, and by substance.

[@andykaufman7620]

@JEWS CONTROL THE MEDIA Noticed the rile over the Robin Hood that any calls against shutting it down or that doing what they did was somehow unethical or should be made illegal was then called 'anti-Semetic' which it was clearly not.

[@jameshdr5583]

@@andykaufman7620 are your on drugs or what !!! Hahahaha

[@vaibhavsajith4267]

Word salad

[@AbdirahmanIdris-ku9xm]

Agreed. I'd also add on that communism is like smelling the honey from a bee hive and then getting attacked by a swarm of angry bees. The inevitable corruption that communist societies always have is why communist societies never fulfill the dreams of those who initially sought a "workers revoltion".

[@rahuljoshi6935]

You are showing the indian map wrong be careful

[@bornagain9192]

Satan

[@Gray-om1bj]

Pfft. Communist bandit.

[@izackhosking1436]

騙局

[@ingeniouspotatohead1517]

武毛

[@sanangelostyle6788]

Taiwan is a country

[@yooo1423]

This vid ain't about Taiwan

[@Ptsxlouuivestouetjourd]

Yeah it's called China

[@arthur1543]

共產 中國人民是光榮的人民。 CCP不光榮。

[@user-eb7sy4ch7r]

Are u idiot?

[@commie5211]

汉奸，滚

[@user-nk4bh6ek2u]

ccp!china!

[@user-td3fy2pt5p]

天安門事件

[@mariespeaks2542]

@Soldat a/s he's LYING about Tiananmen Square?????? Bro read a book...

[@finnegansx4423]

@@mariespeaks2542 not about the event itself, but how it was propagandized as massacre

[@GeorgeFloyd2]

nah.

[@retogamed]

Grigori Voitinsky, Vladimir Neiman-Nikolsky, and Henk Sneevliet all where jews - just like karl marx, real name Moses Mordecai Levy tibetans thank you for this red terror

[@orvos1459]

And Israel Epstein

[@kirateesaila9906]

🇨🇳👍👍

[@johnPxIV]

The CCP is evil!

[@thebennettfamily5739]

I am the only anointed king 🤴 of Jamaica 🇯🇲 and ruler of the world 🌎, I will free all the prisoners of the world 🌎, democracy and Babylon system as falling, Jesus Christ my lord and savior he as chosen me and my wife and have made us ture royalty in his sight, king and queen to rule the world 🌎 in love.

[@allenluis7360]

Where did Chinese communism come from???? come on man, you are so wrong about CCP and wrong about Chinese communism, the basic of communism is along with Chinese history, and the Chinese communism is not all like it around world, they call it Chinese Charactic communism, The Early Years of the Chinese Communist Party is quite different from the Chinese Communist Party during Mao Era,

[@Christopher-ij1tm]

Taiwan is a part of China,so could you please paint Taiwan with the same color of China mainland?

[@CGYT-hq5ce]

Taiwan is not part of china! They have there own government!!

[@Christopher-ij1tm]

@@CGYT-hq5ce Do you exactly know China's history?

[@Christopher-ij1tm]

@@CGYT-hq5ce Taiwan is a part of China,just like California is a part of America.California wants to be independent,so does Taiwan.But can you say that California isn't a part of America because of that?So Taiwan is a part of China,it's a province,but not a country.

[@CGYT-hq5ce]

@@Christopher-ij1tm In old china, taiwan is part of china. After CCP gain into power Taiwan declare independent because they don't like communism!!

[@Christopher-ij1tm]

@@CGYT-hq5ce Although Taiwanese don't like Communism,Taiwanese is also Chinese.You can't forget Hitler because nowadays Germany don't like NAZI.So you can't say Taiwan isn't a part of China because Taiwanese don't like Communism.And HK &MACAU don't like Communism,too.But they now are a part of China.

[@viewsmart2670]

CCP will be 70 years old soon. By far CCP is the most innovative and successful political party in the world. CCP failed many time, and make so many mistakes, but it keeps learning and changing. For last 40 years, CCP has outperformed either Democrat or Republican in many aspects, and way better than both combined. When Sneeliet went to China, that country was almost non-exist, extremely weak and poor. Now China is the second largest economy in the world, soon will be on the top. A billion of Chinese are out of poverty. Sneevliet had no clue what he had done to the world, he should be proud.

[@Talkwithtina808]

Not today

[@DC-jt7ye]

소련의 역사도 70년 입니다.나는 이 이야기를 매우 좋아합니다.