Which laser to get?: Side by side comparison of xTool P2 CO2, F1 Galvo, and S1 Diode/IR Lasers

[@SixEightWoodworks]

💵US Store: bit.ly/43cjsP8 🍁CA Store: xtool.pxf.io/jr0qGM 💶DE Store: bit.ly/49KwvKc 💷UK Store: bit.ly/3Tf0QcJ 💶EU Store: bit.ly/48Sh7ua 💶FR Store: bit.ly/4c5upq1

[@fightforpeace4450]

Thabk u so much mate, I was confused between co and s1.

[@alexreid4131]

Thanks brother. Super helpful comparison. Thanks for the transparency about your sponsorship also. Appreciate your content as always and “hullo” from Port Orchard mate 👋

[@SixEightWoodworks]

Thank you! Hey neighbor!

[@cindyjackson4617]

Thanks for the breakdown of each laser/engraver. We recently purchased the S1 with the 40W and we are new to the laser world! We are learning a lot! One of the things we learned is that we cannot use the 40W to engrave certain metals and the limitations with the acrylic. My question is, will the 2W work to fill in the blank spaces on the S1 where the 40W will not work? Can you share the capabilities and show the work of a 2W on the S1? Thank you! Cindy

[@simonak9699]

About 99% of the channels recommending xTool products have received them for free... The P2S with attachements is 9,200$ CAD with taxes... And that's without proper ventilation, consumable supplies, shipping supplies, and other setup accessories. They claim you can make your money back "almost immediately", but the number of small orders you'd need to fulfill just to break even is staggering.

[@chrisroyak4479]

Once again, another honest review and informative video where you share your personal experiences using the tools you're excited talk about! Always a treat to watch and learn!! Great job neighbor!

[@ajvaldez]

Great Video, I have been thinking of buying a co2 Laser, been praying about what one to get, your video is a great help! thanks so much. God Bless!

[@LoansbyCurts]

I have the S1 and love it. Im looking at adding the IR module, or buying the F1 . Does the IR module basically do the same thing as the F1? I think he portablity of the F1 off sets the lower cost of the IR module. Which would you choose?

[@SixEightWoodworks]

Awesome! The IR module will open up more materials to engrave and is pretty awesome; however it would have the same max speed of the S1. The F1 on its own is insanely faster as it’s a galvo laser. Plus, the portability and option of removing the plate to engrave on all kinds of things makes it great. The F1 can still do larger (longer) items if you get the slide extension. My recommendation would definitely be to add the F1.

[@mesaviewshop]

This may be a dumb question, but what are the main differences between a CO2 and diode cutter? If I am not going to be engraving in metal and really only engraving in wood does it matter? I have a cnc machine that I use to cut out thicker pieces of wood so I envision a laser cutter for me would be more like adding engraving or cutting out thin ornaments and key chain type projects.

[@reneschadowski]

Hi...did you test engraving golf balls + golf tees with the xTools you have? Are the xTools able to engrave multiple objects (on a jig) in one go? For example for the pen´s you´ve showed in the video. I do not need high troughput...but I need to to engrave multiple objects (on a jig) in one go for saving time and convenience. Regards

[@apomaria]

Super helpful video, thank you!

[@dennisfreitas7675]

Great job very helpful information thanks just moved back to Oregon and getting back into the craft shows in fact doing one this weekend and next weekend

[@SixEightWoodworks]

Awesome! Good luck!

[@Cronin207]

What makes you like xtool over say omtech? I’m itching to get one or the other and am not such which to get

[@hopeforamerica1714]

Thank you! How do you like the F1 Ultra? I have a tougher question for you... let's say there's this guy and he doesn't know squat about lasers... and he just walked out of a cave he's lived in all his life... but he wants to start something without knowing exactly what to start making... and he can only have one machine... overall, which machine is more versatile with different functions and applications and materials... the P2S... or the F1 Ultra? Thanks!

[@Jeff-gj5vm]

Is there a good place to get the wood products you are using the laser on?

[@TomStone-ml9op]

Love your videos, would like info on where you get file for your sports logos. I am also a Seahawk Mariner Kracken fan from Yakima very new to laser community any help is appreciated

[@caesarblanko1399]

thanks for the grate video, is it possible to engrave on uneven material, for example bark?

[@mustafakhoja1]

xtool has a adeal for combined P2 and F1.. trying to understand if its worth getting f1 as well for engraving since p2 handles most of the volume. Still not clear on the value f1 adds ? definelty looking for reason to purchase and to understand.

[@SixEightWoodworks]

Great question. The P2 is amazing. Can cut all the types of acrylic and thicker wood without limitations. Like you mentioned, it handles the volume. However the F1 is super convenient and fast. While it can cut, it really shines in its ability to engrave almost any material. Because it has both diode and infrared it can engrave more items. Because of its design and smaller footprint, it’s so much faster to engrave items as well. I often cut items on the P2 and then engrave them on the F1. It’s also convenient for multi tasking having both machines. The F1 is also portable. I bring it in the house a bunch and run it with the purifier without any issues while watching TV. It can also travel to craft shows and more. This video shows how convenient the F1 is for engraving: kzbin.info/www/bejne/mKXQd3uJpMmeg6ssi=H0Nm8dIa000YElEA Hope that helps!

[@KevinStefano-s6u]

Another quick question for the user community, can the S1 40W cut clear and semi transparent acrylic if you spray a coating on it or cover it with something like painters tape (either on the top of the bottom)?

[@ValleyForged]

No. I have never seen an actual way to cut clear acrylic with a diode laser. You need a co2

[@fruitloops68]

Does P2 engrave on stainless steel?

[@susyjacobs8248]

Love you Nick

[@BruceBrammer]

Will the S1 cut 1/4" thick pine wood?

[@billynewman5513]

They say the 40 watt will

[@KevinStefano-s6u]

I very much appreciate your amazing content. As a church pastor I also appreciate the idea of a bit of a "woodworking ministry" (aka Holy Side Hustle, lol). I am really struggling with the decision between a P2 and the new S1. I would love to be able to cut wood, glass and a full range of acrylics, but am concerned that the P2 does not do detailed engraving the same way that the S1 does. I don't mind digging into money I have saved, but am interested in making the wisest investment possible to give me the greatest flexibility. Do you have any thoughts about the P2 v S1 debate specifically in terms of level of etching/engraving detail? (by the way, your projects are absolutely incredible). Your additional thoughts are greatly appreciated. Grace & Peace

[@JimHester]

Just a note on the prices listed in the description: The P1 _starts_ at $4999, not $2999.

[@SixEightWoodworks]

Absolutely. That was just the coupon code that kicked in at 2999 that would apply for a P2 purchase. Sorry it was unclear!

[@MrKaebee]

I would really like to have the S1 xtool, the only reason I don't is the price. I am a disabled veteran, and try in increase my revenue with woodworking. I know that I could make income with the S1. I can make payments on the xtool, but cant pay the whole price at one time. If you know anyway the xtool can help me with financing please let me know. I love all your videos, especially ones where you sell your stuff. thank you. I am a retired nurse also.

[@FliegerFliegen44]

They have financing through affirm on their website and you can get as low as 0% for 18 months.

[@MrKaebee]

@@FliegerFliegen44 I tried to get the loan with them, they turned me down, well, the bank they deal with did. Any other way you know. Lmk if you do, thank you

[@BlueRidgeRider]

I powered up my S1 for the first time today!