Why Are Myanmar Refugees In Malaysia Being Deported, Even At The Risk Of Death? | Insight

It has been two years since the coup in Myanmar returned the military junta to power. Persecution of dissidents and minorities continues in the reclusive country.
There have been reports of deadly force used to supress civilian protests, and the use of explosives and air raids against armed resistance. Over a million people are estimated to have been displaced by the violence.
But those who have fled Myanmar have not been welcomed by its ASEAN neighbours. Why has Malaysia deported thousands of refugees, even as they face persecution by the military junta?
For greater INSIGHT into issues affecting Asia:
• Insight
===============
ABOUT THE SHOW: Insight investigates and analyses topical issues that impact Asia and the rest of the world.
==========================
#CNAInsider #CNAInsiderInvestigates #Myanmar #Refugees
For more, SUBSCRIBE to CNA INSIDER
cna.asia/insideryoutubesub
Follow CNA INSIDER on:
Instagram: / cnainsider
Facebook: / cnainsider
Website: cna.asia/cnainsider

[@cj-fx2kj]

Singapore dont tryna act hero la. Malaysia is not developing country to keep refugee. We're not like europe. If yall singaporeans so concern about them why not taking them?😂. Action speaks louder than words.

[@Dezznut09]

CNA ada sentiment anti Malaysia ¯\_ಠ_ಠ_/¯

[@satyannair4837]

Well, I look at it two ways. Singapore is as small as the UAE and the Gulf states, and, therefore, can't take a proactive stance to welcome millions of refugees. However, it can appeal to the goodness of its bigger neighbors, particularly Malaysia. After all, millions of Muslims are being accepted as refugees in the Christian West. I am sure Muslim Malaysia can reciprocate in kind when a few Christians in the neighborhood seek asylum there.

[@cj-fx2kj]

@@satyannair4837 netherland is smaller than malaysia and still can accept refugees. Dont give excuses la. Yall tiny islnd hypocryte always tryna act hero in media but do nothing😂

[@gilnahnu]

@@hellyeah7403 there are burmese refugees in Australia.

[@carlgrissom225]

@@gilnahnu that person is a bot account. best to just report it. see them all over the place about myanmar spreading misinformation.

[@az-fy3mp]

need to ask ah? msian at singapore work visa expired also got kicked, these immigrants got no id whatsoever but still u need ask why they got deported? really???

[@johanahmad817]

Theyre refugees, read a law book

[@az-fy3mp]

@@johanahmad817 in the eyes of malaysian law they are not refugees. they're illegal immigrants. i've got nothing against them but to ask why they are being deported? that's kind of a s2pid qustion. unless the law changed then that question will always be a s2pid a$$ question to ask.

[@cashewnuttel9054]

They are poor people, give them a break.

[@aizuddinaziz8239]

All rohingya refugees should go to singapore because Singapore is always the champion in human rights.. Instead of just making a documentary singapore should provide a asylum to rohingya and not just talking without doing anything

[@fairuzdin3012]

Singapore dah banyak malaysian bang kat sini tak payah nak tolak balak lagi bang Kat Singapore.

[@aizuddinaziz8239]

@@fairuzdin3012 xkira la byk ker tak.. Yg penting singapore kena ambik pendatang dari rohingya.. Bru betul.. Jgn tau nk complain dgn kritik jer.. Sembang jer lebih tapi habuk pun tada.. Setakat sembang mana2 negara pun boleh buat

[@whatdaheckish]

Agreeeeee🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@whatdaheckish]

@@fairuzdin3012 ye lah ramai Malaysian keje dah korang Sporean busy TikTok, busy worry about 1st world problem, how to goncang goncang kereta for more fuel, getting drunk, getting tattooed and also busy complaining many Mainland Chinese datang keje. 🥱🥱🥱

[@imjuzsayin..5017]

Most Malaysian just working in Singapore legally & staying in Malaysia. If Malaysian is a burden for Singapore, please replace em with these refugees.

[@mohmeegaik6686]

Will Singapore accept huge number of refugees like Malaysia already have - over hundred thousands??? Who is responsible to foot the costs of giving refuge to these needy people???

[@faisalchan7501]

If they see refugees boat in sea they will Push That boat to other way

[@syarizansulaiman6554]

Singapore should receive as they signed Refugee UN deal

[@sufyannufael5224]

Hahahaha..why .you people want to destroy their peace and clean country with your style of living

[@anniemaraj8773]

Islamist and Christianity has no special status in Singapore

[@tompoki]

Haha, they only receive chinese with money, like Jack Ma... Rohingyans? karen? They treat them like dogs, but they potrayed like there are noblest in SEA region

[@louistheroux530]

It is very hypocritical for Singaporean media to cover this topic about other country, when Singapore does not entertain asylum seekers in any way, nor allow UNHCR to operate within its borders....

[@satyannair4837]

Well, I look at it two ways. Singapore is as small as the UAE and the Gulf states, and, therefore, can't take a proactive stance to welcome millions of refugees. However, it can appeal to the goodness of its bigger neighbors, particularly Malaysia. After all, millions of Muslims are being accepted as refugees in the Christian West. I am sure Muslim Malaysia can reciprocate in kind when a few Christians in the neighborhood seek asylum there.

[@louistheroux530]

@@satyannair4837 Malaysia had always been welcoming to refugees. That is why there is a pull factor and it ends up hosting the largest refugee population in ASEAN (despite its size compared to Indonesia and Thailand). That is why it is facing this issue with refugees now. Malaysia is definitely heading towards saturation (if it has not already), and simply do not have the resources nor capability to host these refugees anymore.

[@satyannair4837]

​@@louistheroux530 Malaysia's population density is far less compared to Indonesia and Thailand. For instance, Indonesia is six times bigger than Malaysia, but its population is nine times greater. In fact, as Muslim societies implode worldwide, the onus lies on countries like Turkey, Indonesia and Malaysia to step up on welcoming refugees. One can't expect small nations in Scandinavia to do their bit, when Muslim nations themselves play the I-don't-have-space card.

[@louistheroux530]

@@satyannair4837 "In fact, as Muslim societies implode worldwide, the onus lies on countries like Turkey, Indonesia and Malaysia to step up on welcoming refugees. One can't expect small nations in Scandinavia to do their bit, when Muslim nations themselves play the I-don't-have-space card." Nope. The issue is not the religion of the host or the refugee. Only states which had signed the 1951 Convention should be expected to host refugees. There should not be any expectation for countries which had not signed the 1951 Convention to host refugees, because they have no legal obligation to do so. If they do host, it's a form of charity. But if they change their policy and decide to be like Singapore, they are well within their legal rights to do so.

[@satyannair4837]

@@louistheroux530 Aren't you contradicting yourself, when you claimed earlier that Malaysia has been welcoming a lot of refugees, and it is "saturated" now? And religion is an important card for Malaysia at the least. As Islam takes centerstage and becomes increasingly aggressive in the country, there is an inherent desire building up amongst Malays to make Malaysia a full-blown Muslim nation. Islam has been steadily climbing, and has crossed 60% today. To that effect, it has been encouraging more foreign Muslims to settle in Malaysia, even as the Chinese feel increasingly threatened and are leaving in droves. This is actually good, because it means more Muslim refugees can find a home in Malaysia, if they are willing to open the borders. As for the West signing a pact to take in refugees, did they expect a 2-million-strong Muslim caravan forcing itself into Germany, France, the UK and Scandinavia? The pact involved a formal invitation to refugees, not millions storming into their borders. And since Muslim refugees don't have a good record of mixing with the mainstream, it is causing massive problems for the West, particularly the smaller ones. It's time for the world to identify more Muslim nations for placing Muslim refugees, and, in that regard, Malaysia should be in the Top-3, in my view.

[@euyie8738]

Msia and Msians are known for their charitable nature. They are receptive whether you are Rohingyas, Chins, Karen’s, Bataks, Champas, Chinese or Indians. In my village there are Vietnamese who overstay, Rohingyas with UNHCR cards, Madurese etc but the villagers don’t report them to authorities as they don’t cause trouble. If they try to do that in Singapore I have no doubt that they would be driven off the country’s shores even before they could even draw their combs to comb their hair. To be fair CNA should explore why Singapore is so heartless.

[@tankman20064]

We got caning too. Want some bo ?

[@anonnymouz6826]

Singapore tiny island dumbass

[@aryang4488]

Excuse me??? Why don't you explore it in Singapore. And see where you heading to once your exploration covered.

[@euyie8738]

@@anonnymouz6826 Yay start using deragotaries. Typical babi

[@phoenixofburma2068]

Singapore is founded in bullies' technique on Malaysian, not long time ago. Everybody will experience when work or live them together.

[@th5258]

WHY NOT SINGAPORE START TAKING IN THOSE REFUGEES SO THAT THEY CAN HAVE BETTER LIFE IN SINGAPORE??

[@Dezznut09]

Singapore and other countries only know barking and make propaganda say Malaysia is cruel countries

[@bharathdeva9407]

@@Dezznut09 dude singapore does not have any obligation to take in refugees .

[@truthhurts856]

Burma/Myanmar is an absolutely beautiful nation and the people are honest, friendly and helpful. In my humble opinion, Burma would have been much better off without Anglo British Colonialism. For instance, there's hardly any Muslim, Hindu or Christian there up until Colonialism. I supposed it's fair to say that many of these tragedies that nation facing today, such as racial, ethnic and religious conflicts, started with Colonialism. 😔 Speaking of ethnic and religious tragedies Burma facing today, the fact that the world's longest Civil War which is in Myanmar, mainly between Buddhist Burmese and Christian Karen (while Buddhist Karen are largely at peace) was made it possible, prolonged and supported by Anglo Clans of USA, UK & Australia, etc while they are using next-door neighbor Thailand (which has a defense treaty with them) as a base camp since in the 1950. In my humble opinion, ethnic Karen refugees fleeing the conflict/war in Myanmar are entitled to cross over to Thailand to stay, as well as eligibility to relocate to new places such as USA, Australia. - The fact that the world's longest Civil War which is in Myanmar, mainly between Buddhist Burmese and Christian Karen (while Buddhist Karen are largely at peace) was made it possible, prolonged and supported by Anglo Clans of USA, UK & Australia, etc while they are using next-door neighbor Thailand (which has a defense treaty with them) as a base camp since in the 1950. True, ethnic Karen refugees fleeing the conflict/war in Myanmar are entitled to cross over to Thailand to stay, as well as eligibility to relocate to new places such as USA, Australia. - Anglo Clans of USA, UK & Australia, etc are using next-door neighbor Thailand, which has a defense treaty with them, as a base camp since in the 1950s; from which attack against China/PRC was launched by sending Chinese Nationalist (Taiwanese Kuomintang) forces into nearby Burma's eastern border closed to China in the '50s and '60s. In the '60s and '70s, using Thailand as a base camp, attack against nearby Laos & Cambodia were launched during Indochina war where several millions innocent civilians were killed. - Colonialism & Colonization are evil things done and benefited by evildoers.. Here in Singapore, a tiny island with 6 million souls lives like sardines in a can, where else in nearby vast bountiful Australia which is ten thousand times 10,000 bigger with a mere 27 million inhabitants. Similar situation in tiny and packed Japan, which is running out of space and land. Do you know that their living room and bedroom are the same place, and that most Japanese people sleep in their living room. 😔 - Here's the one solution. Why don't Burma's Muslim, Hindu & Christian population, if they wish, move to place like Anglo Colonized vast bountiful Australia/New Zealand in Asia-Pacific region? After all, these are Asia-Pacific lands looted from Native Asians-Pacific people." 😔 [For the hidden root cause of the Myanmar situation, May I suggest you read the informative multi-pages comments by 'Ms. Gregoria' at, kzbin.info/www/bejne/bWG9n4SQeqeJq7c ., that I learnt so much more truths about Myanmar than I've ever known] ... My prayers go out to Myanmar people! 🙏🙏🙏

[@mrsalwaysright6478]

​@@truthhurts856 I agree, Slavery, Colonialism & Colonization are all evil things done by evildoers. True, Burma/Myanmar would have been much better off without Anglo British Colonialism. By the way thanks for the informative multi-pages comments by 'Ms. Gregoria' at, kzbin.info/www/bejne/bWG9n4SQeqeJq7c

[@ayahpinkofficial2769]

Meanwhile Singapore caned Anyone entering Singapore illegally..💀

[@whatdaheckish]

Singapore should take them...

[@kirie-8524]

Easier said then done, if refugees arent or cant be properly integrated into society meaningfully it would only cause increased crime and civil unrest here. Look at France and Germany for example.

[@fairuzdin3012]

We have taken enough malaysian here in Singapore,those refugees are there to replace the malaysian that we took😂

[@HuiChyr]

@@fairuzdin3012 Oh ... say no more. Pls take these refugees and train them to take over Msians jobs in Singapore. Maybe CNA next documentary would be "Why Singapore Deports Myanmar Refugees?" 🤣🤣🤣

[@Redmi-xu1yo]

Ni no Kuni

[@anonnymouz6826]

Half of Malaysian are living in Singapore !

[@pikachu-rb5pd]

If Malaysia treats these "refugees" so badly, why don't Singapore intervene and let them into Singapore?

[@BitterSweetisMe947]

maybe they have no more available space for them to live in. Singapore is only that big.

[@shukriramlee]

Go to Singapore since 70% percent of the people there was CCP refugee during world war.

[@Dezznut09]

Singapore is rich ,they should accept all of these immigrants lol

[@satyannair4837]

Well, I look at it two ways. Singapore is as small as the UAE and the Gulf states, and, therefore, can't take a proactive stance to welcome millions of refugees. However, it can appeal to the goodness of its bigger neighbors, particularly Malaysia. After all, millions of Muslims are being accepted as refugees in the Christian West. I am sure Muslim Malaysia can reciprocate in kind when a few Christians in the neighborhood seek asylum there.

[@dezjdidjdi]

@@Dezznut09 ask your government

[@Balangair1]

I often wonder WHY these Myanmar communities BYPASS Thailand. Wouldn't they find Thailand culturally closer and more sensitive to their plight? Why travel further down the peninsula towards Malaysia? I'm talking about the Chins Karens and Mons, not so much the Rohingyas.

[@Bluecheese1400]

Because Thailand is right next to Myanmar… guess what? Burmese soldier can just kill them across the border. Thai govern,ent is also junta so they are fine with Burmese killing the refugees so long as it doesn’t disturb the Thai economy or reputation

[@imjuzsayin..5017]

Many refugees/immigrants from Myanmar in Thailand. They're living there & waiting for a green lights from agents to get into Malaysia.

[@nyanyamero]

​@@imjuzsayin..5017also why send them to Malaysia?

[@sokapokvic2514]

@@nyanyamero If you are refugee you have to live in the camp around borders in Thailand and you can't travel out of the areas without document and permission, of course these refugee have nothing such Visa or Refugee documents. Even there are hundreds of thousands of refugee in Thailand who live here for decades and already have Non-nationality card from Thailand provincial for live around and confirm their status but they can't go out of the town or area that they belong to. They cannot go to another provinces or Bangkok and other part of Thailand, So they think Malaysia is better because they can be free.

[@irwanibrahim96]

To be fair, we malaysian have nothing against them. It is only when they bring negative behaviour and influence to nearby community we oppose their asylum. Even last week, a news reported a unchr asylum molested a school girl...

[@d.c.3534]

That reminds me of the sexual assaults that occurred during the 2015-2016 New Year's Eve in multiple cities across Germany and suspects were largely reported to be migrants and refugees. I do not understand how people who make the journey to a safer land would then commit heinous crimes. People who are removed from such environments are very empathetic until they deal with it themselves. Just look at the U.S. and the immigration crisis right now. States who weren't dealing with it before used to be very critical of southern states with how they dealt with illegal migrants until the southern states started bussing them to the other states and now they're screaming for help.

[@lily_m3538]

How biased you sound. Every heard of empathy?

[@c4un544n5]

@@lily_m3538 I dont think he "sound" bias. Maybe a lack of factual evidence but not necessarily bias.

[@thekingminn]

I think you are confusing the Rohingyas and the Burmese.

[@johanahmad817]

Congratulations, you have been deeply misinformed by the irresponsible media, stop reading social media bloggers and read New Straits Times

[@iamgreat1234]

Malaysia never colonize Rakhine state so its not Malaysian responsibilities

[@syarizansulaiman6554]

Malaysia never signed Refugee UN act, so remember our government can do without UNHCR approved

[@Time4Peace]

Interesting to find out who are these resistance fighters and who fund them. It would be great for CNA to investigate that.

[@tankman20064]

Yes, you just see your country lor. Then you knw who fund them lor.

[@dezjdidjdi]

@@tankman20064 hey man they decide to came here for a job

[@dezjdidjdi]

@@tankman20064 lor

[@arcaneisboring7675]

Your mamas pussy is helping this coward resistance fighters fight the war.

[@Time4Peace]

@Muhammad Azim You misunderstood me. I was not blaming the refugees, anymore than those from Syria or Iraq. In fact, they should be accommodated. My question is about the civil war and what lies behind it. Myanmar is undergoing a civil war and a regime change. You can understand better what I mean with this link kzbin.info/www/bejne/hHTJeoqombR6sM0

[@ninjatuna87]

The Title of this documentary is Why Are Myanmar Refugees In Malaysia Being Deported, Even At The Risk Of Death? Malaysia deported them, then Singapore take them in, settle all issues. Action is louder than words(documentary)🤣🤣🤣

[@lolanya00]

if Singapore are so upset about this then they should accept all of those refugees but noooooo SG refused to accept any refugees and then go all "wahh Malaysia badd", typical SG behaviour all talk no action.

[@joe-vl3nd]

A global Problem from Denmark to Italy US to UK 🇬🇧 Australia to Canada Immigration is out of control

[@gennadiyleyfman6920]

Before the most recent military coup, the Myanmar military had been in full control of the country for fifty years - and to what end?! The generals didn’t lift a finger to improve Myanmar’s economy and living standards of the population. What did they do? Nothing!!! What infrastructure Myanmar has, is the result of the British rule.

[@louistheroux530]

These people collecting "community funds" should be audited. There is no accountability at all about what happens to the money after they collect it..

[@yeyyeyyey5104]

Welcome to Singapore...we will care all of you...welcome welcome...will grant you all citizenship and luxury live in Singapore...

[@HuiChyr]

Yes yes ... pls go to Singapore. Spread the words to all refugees too.

[@dezjdidjdi]

Ask your government

[@matjebonklumen147]

I think singapore should take them, seem they are so concern!

[@ahmadin5681]

Hey Spore how about just accept all the refugees

[@satyannair4837]

Well, I look at it two ways. Singapore is as small as the UAE and the Gulf states, and, therefore, can't take a proactive stance to welcome millions of refugees. However, it can appeal to the goodness of its bigger neighbors, particularly Malaysia. After all, millions of Muslims are being accepted as refugees in the Christian West. I am sure Muslim Malaysia can reciprocate in kind when a few Christians in the neighborhood seek asylum there.

[@Laurent1am4U]

@@satyannair4837 what about put them on south Singapore 🕊️

[@ghrbaa6727]

@@satyannair4837 are you dumb, dead and blind?? There are tens of NGOs in Malaysia serving the basic needs of close to 200k refugees here, UNHCR card holder can also access Malaysian public healthcare system. All you need to do is GOOGLE and pop all the information come out. Compared to YOU and SINGAPORE all you do are TALK TALK TALK CRITICIZE WHILE DOING ABSOLUTELY NOTHING AT ALL. You people only know how play the moral high ground while you guys actually have NONE AT ALL. Absolutely nothing.

[@asiaone9609]

@@satyannair4837 nah you guys Singaporean love to play empathy FEELING , we called it FAKE EMPATHY! IF YOU BOTHERED, JUST TAKE ALL MYANMAR REFUGEES TO LIVE IN YOUR COUNTRY! DON'T USE THE "SMALL LAND REASON" LA BHAI!! YOUR COUNTRY HAS LAWS AND MALAYSIA ALSO HAS LAWS! WHY MUST MALAYSIAN ACCEPT THEM?? DO YOU THINK MALAYSIA IS THE PLACE FOR ALL REFUGEES HAAH?? WE NEED TO TAKE CARE OUR OWN PROBLEMS RATHER THAN TAKE CARE OF THEM!! WE ALSO STRUGGLED TO MAKE LIVING IN OUR OWN COUNTRY!

[@mrpeanut6267]

Singaporeans : we do not have enough space for them🤓🤓

[@fatimabubi5703]

Ketika budha membunuh dan membantai sesama manusia, saat itulah karma datang kepadanya

[@sun2020able]

Singapore will never take refugees 🤣🤣

[@tankman20064]

Syria have mah. Land so many .

[@Blck_Stallion]

@@tankman20064 hypocrites sepets. Why don’t you take the Rohingyas then? They ugly? Smelly? Problematic? Got no blue eyes? Dark skin? Not blonde? Hypocrites Singapore just talk so much

[@RoyLimisAw3s0me]

I worked in a refugee school in Klang; they are mostly documented or undocumented; UNHCR has a office in KL where they get protection from the govt of Myanmmar

[@firelord1202]

Why come to malaysia through thailand.. Why dont just stop at thailand.. We malaysia have a lot of immigrant problem.. Immigrant from Myanmar, Bangladesh, Philippines, Indonesia, vietnam, pakistan, india, china.. Please stop coming..

[@lily_m3538]

Try finding some compassion.

[@westwest6309]

@@lily_m3538 no

[@raymondnolasco7453]

What Filipino immigrants are your problems? This is the first I’ve heard of such

[@firelord1202]

​@@raymondnolasco7453have u ever been to sabah? The state have a lot of filipino migrant coming by boat

[@raymondnolasco7453]

@@firelord1202 here bro >>> en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manila_Accord#:~:text=The%20Manila%20Accord%20was%20signed,11%20June%201963%20in%20Manila. >>>>> these are the rights of the Filipinos in Sabah. If they are not accorded those rights; it means Malaysia is not living up to their end of the treaty.

[@Nik-mv5hr]

I would consider the refugees CNA interviewed are the more lucky ones. They have jobs and fairly more comfortable home compared to other refugees. And why charge money for refugees to get a card? They are refugees. It doesn't make sense, the card is granting them to work meaning they shouldn't work before getting the card. If they shouldn't work where the hell would they get the money? It can be a reason to why so many result to work not according to the rule of law or begging in the streets or even become crooks. RM500 is a lot even for Malaysians. I think we didn't hate them at first. We welcomed them. But it all changed when so many Ronghiyas caused problems here. I had 2 encounters. One was when they begged at a sidewalk. They forced me to give some money and keep holding me until I gave them some money. I naturally was pissed, I raised my voice to spook him. I originally wanted to give him RM5 but when he acted like that I got pissed. Second time was at a parking lot. We call them 'Ulat parking'. They forced people parking their cars to pay them. So called, "parking fees", when the parking lots belonged to the city council. It's like there are becoming gangsters. There are so many things that happened and these few bad seeds are painting bad images on Rohingyas as a whole. I think Rohingyas in Malaysia should also condemm these few fellow Rohingyas. If they want peace then live peacefully according to the rule of law. I don't mind they are here. But it needs to be at a controlled amount that Malaysia & UNCHR can afford to pay for their welfare. Provide sufficient education & wellfare so they can assimilate better & don't become a burden that many have became.

[@mohiman5242]

That's how Muslims treat each other🤣but they want western Christian nations to accept them

[@thequietart]

Those refugees in the video are from Chin ethinicity. They’re mostly christian. And anyway, we have received almost 200k refugees here in our country, we simply can’t take more. It has nothing to do with religion. Does Europe accept illegal immigrants even if they’re christian? No right? You have rules

[@Laurent1am4U]

Should send to Singapore la😂😏 wise title media. Singaporean is good people ma / take care ma...& Singapore is open country accept anyone 🤗 welcome all your family to joy future life as 1 class because we are equally 🤗🤗 good luck roghiya Singapore

[@dezjdidjdi]

Ya i agree

[@imjuzsayin..5017]

Malaysia is not a State party to the 1951 Refugee Convention and its 1967 Protocol. It does not have a legal or administrative framework for managing refugees and has not set up mechanisms to process asylum seekers and refugees when they arrive in the territory. Singapore is the best country in SEA. Should be able to take a good care of them.

[@dezjdidjdi]

@@imjuzsayin..5017 ya take them

[@Laurent1am4U]

@@imjuzsayin..5017 🤗 refugee must know the true & the only one country treat equally in SEA is Singapore 🤗Hope someday they bring all family & stay in Singapore 🤗🕊️

[@chaos5104]

Evil people what if it was your family or you

[@johnardygoh6245]

Is Singapore takes this refugees and how many,Singapore is biggest investor and economic gains in Myanmar should lead in takes their refugees

[@jie5128]

Send Myanmar refugee to Cambodia....

[@Amiramirfaris97]

Kesiannya Malaysia.. semua negara berkonflik mesti datang Malaysia untuk dapat perlindungan.. dekat Semenanjung org Myanmar, Arab..Sabah ramai Filipin.. ttp smgt negaraku

[@brentpratt7858]

No country should deny a Myanmar citizen who flees Myanmar to get away from the violence. The peaceful people of Myanmar are in danger and need compassion, No civilized human should ever deny anyone who is in desperate need of help. All countries must keep that in consideration and have compassion 🙏

[@juanpablo-hz3dq]

Everyone is welcome to take all the Myanmar to their countries. The Malaysia has the right to deport all illegal immigrants just like any other nation does. You can’t imagine having a neighbor that can’t fix their problems ever ever ever and continue to go over to the other-side with any any documentation. Can’t happened people. You again welcome to take it to your country and see what happened.

[@matkilau1320]

Singapore welcome them? Then we send 1% rohingya to singapore, after 1 year we want to see what singaporean think. 😂😂😂😂

[@pokokdurian3199]

ASEAN need to resolve this issue.

[@thulomanchay]

That's not how ASEAN work. Myanmar has to ask ASEAN for help to resolve the issue, otherwise each member will not interfere in another member problem. ASEAN is not like NATO or EU, where the US and member countries can put pressure on another member.

[@shahrulamar5358]

Violence in Southern Thailand 🇹🇭 continued to this day. More than 7000 peoples lost their life since 2004. 😟😟

[@harukrentz435]

Feel like Indonesia need to provide an island to host the refugees again like they did in the 70's during the Vietnam War.

[@khairuddinazfar3954]

Ya...just go provide the island.....that will be huge help for them...I really agree with this.....🤭🤭

[@RandomVideos-md5eq]

No, they want go to malaysia not indo and becoming melayu citizen

[@khairuddinazfar3954]

@@RandomVideos-md5eq nah.....they dont even want to speak malay....but indonesia will be different story I guess, thats why I agree if anyone from other country is generous enough to help them..🤭🤭🤭🤭

[@ahmadin5681]

@@khairuddinazfar3954 simply no

[@Dezznut09]

Indonesia or Malaysia ?

[@Time4Peace]

US and its allies are very much involved in the . Myanmar's crisis. But few talk of them want to offer the refugees asylum unlike the Ukrainian refugees. When they sanction Myanmar, aren't they creating more misery and forcing more Myanmar people to flee? Destabilizing Myanmar is really to create a flow of refugees. What's the logic? Is it according to UN laws to impose sanction on Myanmar?

[@satyannair4837]

You're right. Sanctions have done more harm than good. However, the one thing you do realise about sanctions is that it ends up uniting the country against the 'evil' West, so to speak. The refugees in Myanmar are not a product of Western sanctions, but rather a result of Buddhist militancy, through the monks and the Army. Few have spoken against the repression of Buddhist establishments, including Myanmar, Sri Lanka, Bhutan, Thailand, among others.

[@hellyeah7403]

I agree with someone saying that Colonialism/Colonization are evil things done and benefited by evildoers.. Here in Singapore, a tiny island with 6 million souls lives like sardines in a can, where else in nearby vast bountiful Australia which is ten thousand times 10,000 bigger with a mere 27 million inhabitants. Similar situation in tiny and packed Japan, which is running out of space and land. Do you know that their living room and bedroom are the same place, and that most Japanese people sleep in their living room. 😔 - Here's the one solution. Why don't Burma's Muslim, Hindu & Christian population, if they wish, move to place like Anglo Colonized vast bountiful Australia/New Zealand in Asia-Pacific region? After all, these are Asia-Pacific lands looted from Native Asians-Pacific people." 😔 [For the hidden root cause of the Myanmar situation, May I suggest you read the informative multi-pages comments by 'Ms. Gregoria' at, kzbin.info/www/bejne/bWG9n4SQeqeJq7c ]

[@zeik04]

I'm pretty sure it's the Muslims causing trouble not the Buddhist.. just look at every country that has Muslims. They all criminal's

[@satyannair4837]

@@hellyeah7403 What are you talking about? Colonialism was the best thing that happened to India, Africa, and the rest of the world, although people would rather kill themselves than admit it. The Chinese, for instance, has a far more violent and repressive history in driving its own people out of the country. Moreover, its history with the rest of the Mongoloid race (Japanese, Koreans) has been excruciating!!! The same applies to the Africans and others, but it is convenient today to blame the white man for everything. And Japan has no space? What? You must be referring to Tokyo, which is tantamount to saying China is crowded, if Hong Kong is a point of reference. And what do you mean people should inhabit "stolen" lands? These are white societies. People are migrating to these countries, not because of the aboriginal people or the Maoris, but because of the white man. And if the white man decides he doesn't want you, then so be it. Did you even bother to ask what the white man feels when people force themselves into these societies? Given Xi's screwups, we can expect a massive exodus of Chinese to these lands soon.

[@dearsirormadam20]

@@hellyeah7403 Burma would have been much better off without Anglo British Colonialism. For instance, there's hardly any Muslim, Hindu or Christian there up until Colonialism. I supposed it's fair to say that many of these tragedies that nation facing today, such as racial, ethnic and religious conflicts, started with Colonialism. 😔 Speaking of ethnic and religious tragedies Burma facing today, the fact that the world's longest Civil War which is in Myanmar, mainly between Buddhist Burmese and Christian Karen (while Buddhist Karen are largely at peace) was made it possible, prolonged and supported by Anglo Clans of USA, UK & Australia, etc while they are using next-door neighbor Thailand (which has a defense treaty with them) as a base camp since in the 1950. In my humble opinion, ethnic Karen refugees fleeing the conflict/war in Myanmar are entitled to cross over to Thailand to stay, as well as eligibility to relocate to new places such as USA, Australia. - The fact that the world's longest Civil War which is in Myanmar, mainly between Buddhist Burmese and Christian Karen (while Buddhist Karen are largely at peace) was made it possible, prolonged and supported by Anglo Clans of USA, UK & Australia, etc while they are using next-door neighbor Thailand (which has a defense treaty with them) as a base camp since in the 1950. True, ethnic Karen refugees fleeing the conflict/war in Myanmar are entitled to cross over to Thailand to stay, as well as eligibility to relocate to new places such as USA, Australia. - Anglo Clans of USA, UK & Australia, etc are using next-door neighbor Thailand, which has a defense treaty with them, as a base camp since in the 1950s; from which attack against China/PRC was launched by sending Chinese Nationalist (Taiwanese Kuomintang) forces into nearby Burma's eastern border closed to China in the '50s and '60s. In the '60s and '70s, using Thailand as a base camp, attack against nearby Laos & Cambodia were launched during Indochina war where several millions innocent civilians were killed. By the way, many thanks for the informative comments by 'Ms. Gregoria' at, kzbin.info/www/bejne/bWG9n4SQeqeJq7c ., that I learned the hidden truths on Myanmar issue.

[@whatdaheckish]

Aiyaaa this CNA from Spore is like Al Jazeera to Qatar.

[@tainanking]

Unfortunately for Myanmar, they could end up just another one of those countries that just has constant war. For a Buddhist predominant country, that’s very very unfortunate. But I’m sure Laos and Cambodia would be the same if the people stood up against their horribly corrupt basically dictatorship governments. There’s a reason Thailand can prosper while their neighbors sink. Thailand doesn’t have much more resources or land, they just came up with better strategy for their country and people.

[@BM-zd3vs]

Thailand, Laos and Cambodia are largely homogenous countries. Their conflicts are minimal. However due to British colonialism, Myanmar social fabric had been fractured permanently. Anglo colonisers imported ten of thousands Labourers from Bengal during colonial time. Rakhine population had been outnumbered by Bengali population. In 1970s, due to West and East Pakistan(now Bangladesh) civil war, another wave of Bengali refugees arrived Burma. 🇲🇲 Government announced State emergency because they couldn't cope with sheer number of refugees. The world turned the blind eye on 🇲🇲. In 1947 to 61, there were mujahideen movements in Rakhine State where Islamists killed thousands of Rakhine locals. Mujahideens tried to annex part of Rakhine (Mayu peninsula in North Rakhine) to join Bangladesh. In colonial time, every year over a million people immigrated into Burma from India. Because Anglo government made Burma a province of India. In north east and south east of Burma, Anglo-American missionaries carried out cultural invasion of a Buddhist country to continue imperialists' ruling. Those who converted to Christianity fought its own people for their colonial masters. These converted people and Indian and Muslim immigrants became part of ruling class. They discriminated Buddhist population in their own home by setting damaging and ruthless business practices. Burmese people lost their lands, house, business and even their daughters to foreigners. Indians and Muslims capitalists loaned local burmese with unfairly high interest rates. When the farmers couldn't pay back the loan they took the daughters. Buddhists are too soft, they needs to grow backbones if they want their civilisation survive.

[@tainanking]

@@BM-zd3vs Thailand has had a lot of Muslims as well but the difference is Thailand is accepting of difference.

[@BM-zd3vs]

@@tainanking Not as many Muslims as Burma has. Did Muslims in Thailand attack local population? Does Thailand have mujahideens who massacred thousands of Buddhists in 1960s? Does Thailand have Rohingyas Salvation Army that attacked Hindus and Buddhists civilians?

[@tainanking]

@@BM-zd3vs Thailand minorities get along with each other but the problem in Burma is the military. You do realize Thailand also had a coup right ? But doesn’t have these horrible problems. Myanmar maybe need to reinstate a royal family

[@Orgruul]

@@BM-zd3vs You say the Buddhists needs to grow backbones for their civilization in Burma to survive, yet the ruling military regime oppresses their own people while instigating themselves as rulers in a closed market crony monopoly. The notion of "trying to preserve Buddhist culture" as an excuse to take control of power while doing very little for economic development for the general population is outrageous. You mentioned the Indians and Muslims taking Burmese daughters if they couldn't pay back then, now you see widespread poverty from military mismanagement and Burmese workers abroad doing low wage jobs that's not necessarily preserving Burmese self-respect? The Burmese military is in a position to bring wealth and prosperity to its civilization but instead has impoverished it being no different from the British colonizers. For an supposedly "Ultra Nationalist" force they sure oppress and impoverish their own nationals alot.

[@leehyunsong7001]

Very karma, many Myanmar denied Rohinya as the country citizens, now they themselves become the refugees.

[@anonnymouz6826]

True

[@fonsyalfonso8242]

I think it’ll be easier for Rohingya moslems to assimilate in Saudi Arabia, Qatar or any Middle Eastern countries. Hopefully a country from that region welcomes them 🤞🤞🤞

[@mohdnor1198]

Cna shld interview Malaysian instead of all useless interviews here. We msian don't want all refugees. We want zeros refugees..

[@lalaiex2285]

IF Refugees good for economy, why Singapore didnt want to take them?

[@baharm65]

Should have deported to S’pore instead of to Mynmar. S’pore is the richest country in the world, they should be able to help.

[@laifongchan537]

Sorry, Singapore do not want them here.

[@SuperTitser]

come on CNA why not u people urge ur gov't Singapore to accommodate these refugees in your high rise condos if you have a soul to help, instead of just reporting and capturing many views around the world why not make a move to help just saying

[@RoyLimisAw3s0me]

Refugee school in Klang is like an ID to protect deportation....

[@captainmee3469]

AT MINUTE 41:22 is good solution for refugees in all Malaysia... but need make sure do they will have same rule as foreign workers? i mean will they get to apply for penduduk tetap / PR in near future ?? if can.... do they would like to join us as fellow Malaysian as multiculture ?? and do the Malays accept it?? or make new rule that they can only ren thing but cannot own like singapore house??

[@lifeguidance3579]

No they can’t join us!! Enough is enough!! They would probably find easier way to solve their problem in order to survive. For example they probably try to marry local people or Bumiputera to get what they wanted.

[@Dezznut09]

CNA , Stop spread lies and propaganda ಠ﹏ಠ

[@thsmuon5178]

Myanmar variuos PDF(people's defence force) arms groups funded by the people of Myanmar from within and out from the country. We are sick and tire of our military government. China and Ruzzia are part of the problem.They support military regime. We hope USA would directly involve and support the fighting forces in Myanmar.

[@thulomanchay]

USA is involved from the start.

[@fairuzdin3012]

To all malaysian that say all this refugees should be send to singapore,please,singapore have took enough malaysian here already ,those refugees are to replace for the malaysian that seek refuge here in Singapore 😂

[@pirate1367]

Malaysian in Singapore is contributing to the economy, while the refugees here are stealing money from the people who work hard and pay taxes.

[@dezjdidjdi]

Ah so malaysian the black guy

[@slumberotter5411]

Malaysian in Singapore come illegally is it like those refugees?

[@pirate1367]

@@slumberotter5411 Lol, how come illegally? I thought Singapore is the safest country in Asia?

[@slumberotter5411]

@@pirate1367 he/she said in the statement to ask the refugee who are coming illegally to malaysian to come to singapore intead to replace those malaysian who are in Singapore...as if malaysian in Singapore came illegally. I said that as a sarcasm.

[@fahvm4362]

As Malaysian, i believe Myanmar is living like Communist Era in Malaya. Just like the era of Japanese, British occupy. So, for Myanmar government and citizens, they really need to do something either be a communist state like North Korea, China and Russia. Or become Democratic Country. On the same time, either living together as nation with Rohingya or let Rohingya become Independent State in Rakhine. If Singapore can do, why not Rakhine? 🥸✌🏻

[@lazyboy5711]

arakan will never let this happen.They always deny invader criminals rohingyas

[@fear9866]

How can we help them even people in my place also has worst fate

[@davidnelson3026]

Almost the same thing has happened in Iran right now . . . .

[@bangballs]

Sinkaporeans talk so much but do nothing to take all these refugees in...only can make documentary 🤣🤣🤣..typical all talk no action 😂🤡😂🤡

[@Dezznut09]

NATO ( No action Talk Only )

[@satyannair4837]

Well, I look at it two ways. Singapore is as small as the UAE and the Gulf states, and, therefore, can't take a proactive stance to welcome millions of refugees. However, it can appeal to the goodness of its bigger neighbors, particularly Malaysia. After all, millions of Muslims are being accepted as refugees in the Christian West. I am sure Muslim Malaysia can reciprocate in kind when a few Christians in the neighborhood seek asylum there.

[@bangballs]

@@satyannair4837 LMAO...how convenient for sinkaporeans to say that. Then rich sinkapore should just put their money where their mouth is. Give thy neighbors funds to do the BS they can't do. If not, they should keep their stinking holier than art thou BS to themselves.

[@Milanello3270]

Imagine being inferior to Singapore but still talk like this. The audacity of an average Malaysian is unmatched.

[@kirie-8524]

In this day and age almost all talk online is just slactivisim, ppl like them dont see the long term effects only know how to take moral high ground with no action.

[@matjebonklumen147]

Esok, jabatan imegresen hantar 200k puok rohingya ni ke singapore! Baru betoi, cakap kosong boleh la!

[@calvinlo480]

When military in power there people suffer.

[@thequietart]

Singapore and hypocrisy can’t be separated. Telling people what to do, how to live, but never apply any of that rule to yourself. Puih

[@pangeran92]

Singapore should accept them just like CECA. Overall your PAP gov love foreigner. Your gov distrust your local only served NS.

[@ronzac55]

Even Indonesia is much a bigger country doesn't want these Rohingya. Singapore should take them in.

[@aungmyintoo4635]

It is weird that Malaysian muslim people have more animosity towards Rohingya muslim than other non muslim refugees of Myanmar. There is seems no issue with Chin or Karen ethnic refugees in Malaysia but Rohingya is the most hated by majority Malaysians. I wonder if it is due to their dark skin complexion or the behaviours of the Rohingya as the main cause they are not welcomed in Malaysia.

[@phoenixofburma2068]

Moral and attitude make some one good and bad. Good and bad cause welcome and not welcome. Who they are is not major matter in long term.

[@Anverse-14]

​@@phoenixofburma2068 it's a pretty shallow and xenophobic observation, which is common to refugees everywhere. Attitude isn't a something that couldn't change, it only took actual efforts by both sides to agree in changing perspectives.

[@ffle4752]

There are literally hundred sects of Islam....

[@memyself4362]

U r wrong.. we are not accepting all people who illegally cross border our land or overstayed. They're ill mannered, rough and rude. We are also not accepting non muslim Myanmar who are eating cats and dogs.. drunk, prostitute, dirty, more troublesome, they're more worsen than rohigya. The non Muslim Myanmar can't even speak malay or English.. 😒 annoying when they act that they're almighty.. yo go back to ur own country and fight back for your own Right rather then asking people pitying on u. Even Palestine, ughiyur people know their right and fight back.

[@akane8615]

Why should we like and accept them just because of their religion? It has nothing to do with it, rohingnya are just horrible and ungrateful bunch of uncivilized human.

[@samdiv2670]

No no, no way they'll be able to enter SG without proper authorization. Unless they wanna spend time in prison and get deported once their sentence is over.

[@bernadettebrown1852]

I thought the uk said they could come here?

[@gagakputih3136]

Come here, we welcome you in Singapore!

[@AlreadyShort]

meanwhile tricia is pregnant and adding to the problems

[@yummymellon4058]

Malaysia didn't sign that freaking UNHCR agreement. For real countries who does.. Go take the refugees back

[@morrismorris8090]

Can India ignore the report done by the CA being the large Democracy of the world?

[@brendab69]

It's from Sky News Myanmar's Hidden War.. It's graphic and sad however, the people are reporting there live for 30 days on the ground.. They have been asking the world for help but the people who are fighting to stay alive say everyone is focused on Ukraine and won't pay attention to the slaughter they are facing.. Just saying if anyone is interested in wanting more info.. This program will give you plenty

[@limalanbt6019]

how about you Singapore....

[@gaiamagna9156]

Politics for Profit based on Greed by the Greedy....

[@darwinqpenaflorida3797]

Why not to come to the Philippines to these asylum seekers of Myanmar because the Supreme Court of the Philippines allowed fast processing of stateless and asulym seekers to become citizens in three months and reduced quota costs of legal cases The Philippines has long history of refugee haven and asylum seekers since the 1920s from the Jewish refugees in the 1940s to the Vietnamese refugees in the 70s and it was remained open for refugees to this day thanks to International Convention of Refugees when the Philippines ratified in the 50s

[@gotcha900]

Philippines do not want to accept refugees.

[@kalsomsudin1255]

Dah lama juga dihantar balik dan hidup selesa disana sebab pandai jaga diri dan beradab.🤔

[@rivanmeydika6688]

Btw chin sama karen ada malaysia?

[@mrj475]

I dont understand mainland peolle, from mynamr, laos, cambodia, thai and vietnam all flocks to Malaysia? The reason is their political and their gov been control by the Chinese..

[@Smallpp3072]

Who knows right? it's not like people are dying in a war or something 😂

[@zarinahamzah4158]

Rich countries like Singapore & Qatar are talkin too much without making an effort to help them. Stop blabbering if you are doing nothing.

[@endworld615]

Bring all refugee to Singapore...they will get better life in Singapore 😊

[@brentpratt7858]

Malaysia must be an Islamic country

[@kel2700]

I want to take in one of the children

[@jie5128]

You take rohingya

[@itsmesoleh06]

Take them then, we dont want them!

[@gohkahchin2437]

But many of my Myanmar friends work and travel happily in their country...so can we say its safe to send them back with free.

[@StevenWolf275]

Disgusting.

[@oleibylowrencej]

Malaysia taking care of millions of Rohingya's, Singapore? Singapura-pura. Get a better topics CNA

[@nagawahyudi]

thats why u h to fight for freedom

[@azax3813]

Oh god how many you guys accept.

[@wclooh9297]

Free Aung San Suu Kyi and those who stand with her

[@nagaganas7927]

this is rich coming from Singaporean who wouldnt even accept a single refuge, unless if they are white of course 😊

[@banurishmatirtasasmaya3629]

They really less intelektual less attitude and always broken the law.....

[@leponpon6935]

habibi...

[@memyself4362]

CNA🤢🤢.

[@bakalurx]

Semak

[@nyanyamero]

The ASEAN is such a peculiar association. The countries in that region secretly dislike each other (varying degrees) but must play nice because they're financially challenged.

[@raymondnolasco7453]

So… just like the EU and Nato?

[@febrirachmawati6713]

rly? u meant what u said? We ppl do not think like that. Business is business, sometimes we mock each other in social media, but most of the time we don't rly got them too far bc most of us simply inherently social and cooperative (it just simply culture, and we think simply). For this rohingya case, they are bunch of ppl who did not have any respect to locals, to the point they can caused danger It's rather serious. At first we open-handedly welcoming them, simply bc we just love helping ppl and humanity. You will understand once you know our culture, but they do the bad things. It's more like, when u happily welcoming guest in your home, the guest itself stealing your property, mocking you 'poor', not respecting u by just walking away without manner

[@BitterSweetisMe947]

that's just how neighborhood work, no?

[@aryang4488]

USA shall take them all to their land. Would be helpful.

[@phillip244]

As a note of information , there is a purpose built Rohingya refugee camp bulit by the Bangladeshi Govt at Bhashan Char since 2021. This island is just 34km from northern Rakhine. Then why make the longer and perilous journey to Acheh and Malaysia? The NGOs and the UN according aid in this camp is silent on this option. In the meantime, the Govts of Indonesia and Malaysia have to bear the brunt of the social ills caused by them. The primary reason why they were allowed in the first place is because they were Muslim brethren more than for humane reasons. So, reap what you have sowed. Currently the domestic populace in Selayang and Penang are getting rightfully impatient.

[@keangwooichoo6138]

More are coming. They are trouble makers in malaysia.

[@Bluecheese1400]

Lol

[@anonnymouz6826]

Malaysians with their hate comments of Singapore yet half of Singapore are Malaysian happily accepting gov money and assistance...

[@alikhidzam3749]

So true! Let's replace those Malaysians with 2 million Myanmar Refugees in Singapore #MakeSingaporeRohingnyaAgain #SingaporeLoveMyanmarRefugees

[@alikhidzam3749]

Singapore should now replace those Malaysians with Myanmar Refugees because Singapore is so compassionate and loving

[@dezjdidjdi]

​@@alikhidzam3749 make sure they go there legally then

[@armpropulsa9996]

If you really love and sympathize with the Rohingya ethnic group, please stay with your family, you are a friendly and polite person because you don't experience Rohingya morals, there are no manners, please see, they have dared to ask for a residence permit in Indonesia, even though the Rohingya are illegal immigrants.

[@hewas_chewasky]

Except Karen,Mizo & Rohingya All should be deported

[@mohdnor1198]

All shld go.

[@Kraliezec]

This report says that if they were deported to Myanmar, they would be killed. But do you see the flaw in this claim? If they would be killed in Myanmar, how are they alive enough to travel to Malaysia?????