Why I Love Manga 📖❤️ - MIAMAFV 2 Day 17

[@crawlingcastle4844]

"You know how barks go 'woof woof'."

[@w.o.jackson8432]

It do be like that sometimes

[@Nightfurygaming247]

the cutting word "supa" was cut in half? nice.

[@LaserFace23]

I would say the スパ thing is actually more than what you describe here. I'm sure he wanted to be ambiguous too, but more importantly, think of the way the onomatopoeia works: the ス is the sound of the blade moving through something, while the パ is the sound of the blade stopping against something. By having just the ス, the implication is that the blades are sliding back into his hand, keeping the mystery of what his powers are while also having a sound effect that makes sense.

[@VizzinitheSicilian]

What a weeb

[@isaacgr7314]

@@VizzinitheSicilian he could just speak Japanese

[@VizzinitheSicilian]

Sir Psycho Sexy I guarantee that that man is indeed the weeaboo. I. Would. Bet. Money.

[@mattheww9763]

George I don’t know any japanese and I could have told you that just based off of the cutting board example that BGE gave in the video. The Su is the cutting sound and the Pa is the sound of it hitting the cutting board. Pretty self explanatory ;p

[@VizzinitheSicilian]

Matthew W god I wish I operated at such a high IQ level like you ;p

[@zoulzopan]

I personally like manga due to the fact that it's has both elements of a novel and that of a visual medium into one package. A good author can make use of both worlds in a manga/comic medium.

[@kokorov3]

"In Japanese culture, beauty lies in the things left *half* unsaid,"

[@mattheww9763]

11:05 In the anime he actually had the Rattle-Rattle Fruit. He was a Rattlesnake man.

[@fifthofascalante7311]

Matthew W holy shit! A power to match Whitemoustache’s.

[@chipskylark5500]

Lmfaooo

[@PurpleDrink1]

This is pretty much the thesis of why you should watch stuff in the original language, instead of subs or translations. It's a little extra work but it's worth it

[@samuraibeluga3749]

little extra work?? you are suggesting learning an entire new language XD

[@leafshade3643]

As a chef, when I first heard the sound effect used in the anime my first and immediate thought was that it sounded like someone dicing food very quickly in an echo-y (dramatic) room. I'd say it worked too.

[@fifthofascalante7311]

11:24 is to celebrate... actual, proper, thoughtful, imaginative, visceral, striking sound design that is so unique to anime.

[@NikoGardens]

This is outstanding dude, I had no idea about this. Thank you for putting in the work, very good find

[@night1952]

That's just because they didn't use the sound effect they should have, they could have used the sound of a blade being unsheathed or some kind of metalic sound. While i do love manga, the sound effects they use are a crutch due to lack of sound, that's one of the strong points of anime, it has sound, this is just an example of bad sound design not a problem intrinsic to anime (it should be the other way around, it should be easier to convey sound with actual sound than onomatopeya)

[@CreativityCurve]

Read Kingdom already, my whole body quivers at the mere thought of a video about it

[@brandonadrien3476]

Yeah, I thought it'd interest him after the "Art of War" video.

[@CreativityCurve]

@John Ford Yes, the first arc (around 50 chapters or so) is very different from everything that comes after. The art obviously gets way way better as it goes along as with most long running series, but so does just about everything else as well, especially in regards to plot and character development. It might sound like a lot of work just to figure out if you like something, but I'd say 120 chapters (out of the current 600 so it's really not that much) is where you actually get an idea of what it's gonna be like. I'm mostly recommending it because the Kingdom subreddit gets a lot of bleedover from the OP one, seems like there's a fair bit of crossover appeal between the series.

[@ckangaroo15k]

Kingdom is a manga that totally makes the most of the medium of manga. So many dynamic and impressive panels. You can really feel the emotion coming off of some of the pages.

[@nelsonwang2753]

SoulReaper 85 Hell yeah it is, in fact, the manga is better than every anime

[@the_snakelicious]

@SoulReaper 85 the kingdom anime is terrible, stay away

[@blakedavis2447]

4:45 he just referred to dogs as barks

[@Pimpgamer101]

I’d have to watch the scene again, but I feel like with the right amount of subtlety by the sound team they could’ve translated the nuance. Definately not the hand sound, but definately the crash through the hole.

[@SoShiBias]

Well I thought if the original bubble would be revealed as blank, then we'll have a 4th wall breaking result. As in the sound has been "cut out" from production.

[@XxXVideoVeiwerXxX]

TLDR BGE has a nerdgasm for sound effects written down. Implying actual sound effects are inferior. Then uses an example where the audio is garbage. If they knew the power, they should have simply had the sound of a sheathing blade.

[@motherlove8366]

Videos where Best Guy praises things are infinitely better than videos where he bashes things, he's just much better at it.

[@pajamapantsjack5874]

Oh god no *the yaoi hands*

[@SGBlack]

This is one of my favorite videos of yours. I like when you break down one thing and go in depth. It's nice.

[@dragon67849]

subtly addressing the Zoro early haki video in this video, I like it

[@BigA207]

Jojo is much better at anime sound effects that One Piece. Golden Experience, Giorno’s stand, for instance, makes the sound of gold coins when it punches objects.

[@RadioKnive]

This is about Manga though.

[@Flugmorph]

fuck yeah i love manga

[@W0lfguard1997]

Literally just finished rereading the Impeldown and Marineford arc. Perfect timing

[@KHMaster56]

In case anyone else was curious i checked the Viz translation and they use "SH" which i think matches up pretty closely to the original intent since cutting something on a cutting board would make something like a "shunk" sound in my opinion

[@KnightElSneed]

Viz absolutely BTFO-s the scanlators when it comes to One Piece. One Piece canlations oftenly insert swear words that weren't there in the first place too. They translate stuff like kisama as fuckhead when bastard or scum fits better narratively and tonally.m

[@thinBillyBoy]

THANK YOU SO MUCH NATE!

[@oddskymikha8185]

Fun fact, in French the sound effect was also translated as "swup". Btw yeah that Mr1 one fight was so fucking cool holy sheeeeeeeeeeet

[@marlom7882]

The man of culture has returned

[@littlebigcommentary]

Oda likes to use onomatopoeia in creative ways all the time! In one scene between zoro and sanji sanji says he's gonna put razorblades in zoro's food. Then later on zoro is eating his box and the other characters have onomatopoeia that is like "munch munch" where zoro has one that is more like "Crunch crunch" the sound of razor blades getting crunched, but he keeps eating on, with nary a care in the world. I believe this happens in chapter 653

[@PirateSometimes]

the pacing alone makes it superior

[@brandonk2112]

You should do a video on how protagonists meeting their parents affects their development specifically at the teen/kid age. The one I was thinking of specifically was how goku meeting or finding out about his parents at the end of db would be similar or dissimilar to naruto meeting his and how it made him stronger.

[@stripes-2250]

I know you don’t really care for BNHA but the manga has tons of this as well. Love hearing the defense for manga once in a while, not enough of it.

[@RadioKnive]

this current arc in bnha leaves me confused every week. do you have any idea what is happening?

[@stripes-2250]

Renato Valdivia This arc has a lot of parts going off at once and lots of branches from earlier on in the story like Giran and the Doctor only coming back up after 100-200 chapters. As much as I like reading weekly I’d say wait until the climax of Shigiraki and Destro happens because it’s so much information being brought up in intervals that I would wait for a reread. There’s also good catch up threads on Reddit too with all the small details.

[@RadioKnive]

Stripes - Ok good cuz i have not been feeling this series since the Gentle arc ended

[@TheBasedGreeg]

Please make a video on Kaiji! It's one of my favorites, and it's such a hidden gem! My friends won't watch it because of the artstyle...

[@doxiedomian]

Us kaiji fans walk a lonely path. We can call out to each other but never reach out and touch

[@TheBasedGreeg]

@@doxiedomian ‘Tis unfortunate

[@unseen370]

I literally read that chapter just a few weeks ago and that exact panel caught my eye

[@maxmustermann9058]

Luffy vs Kakakuri and Luffy vs Usopp are both better than Zoro vs Mr. 1

[@KillerStar565]

OVERTHINKING SOUND EFFECTS OMEGALUL

[@Vashkey]

Did you call kneecaps up?

[@j3lanzone]

These are some real deep cuts -- I love it

[@shayoko6]

There is a reason manga readers say manga is better despite the usual color,audio and animation difference.

[@OneEyedKing]

Such good one piece analysis

[@AnvilPro100]

I prefer the Best Guy Ever manga, AKA The Bible

[@Godzilla-se8in]

5:34 BGE flosses with an invisible towel.

[@someguy4405]

Pikachu’s name is actually Twinklesqeak. Interesting.

[@theEvangalists]

Awesome video

[@WheresTheSauce]

See I thought pika-chu was named after the actual animal a pika (rock rabbit) it looks SUPER similar to what a pikachu would look like in real life. (Edit) or did the guys doing the design make a mouse thing called a pikachu based on the Japanese and mould the design around an actual pika? Because that'd be fucking awesome.

[@tygamike]

I stopped reading OP in the middle of Alabaster. Guess I have to pick it back up now.

[@RadioKnive]

You dont have to if you dont like it

[@tygamike]

@@RadioKnive Spoilers: I didn't pick it back up.

[@everb1ue]

and here I was wondering what happened to today's MIAMAFV

[@aboredburrito5010]

Are we finally off the boat?

[@LeoSkyro]

Pretty interesting shit Nate. I really wish it were easier to get my hands on RAW scans so I could check out stuff like this, but apparently Japanese people dont pirate mango... ? I mean, there is the occasional site with scans, but no centralized resource like we have for mangadex or kissmanga. Maybe manga is so dirt cheap over there that they dotn even bother. Or maybe manga companies go full on copyright nazi on anybody attempting to scan their shit Funnily enough, I just got done with a chapter in my JP textbook dealing with Onomatopoeias, and Osamu Tedzuka who first used them in Manga.

[@calebhightower7485]

The official Viz Media translation says "SH..."

[@S.A.O.D.A]

So if Pikachu was made by english speakers, he'd be called Zapsqueak. Not a bad mascot name honestly.

[@donovanriley798]

Damnit, I love this series

[@chirstinasilver7274]

He _cut_ the cut sound.

[@BUDGETBALLER]

just keep pumping out One Piece vids BGE, this is my favorite circlejerk

[@SuiteLifeofDioBrando]

I usually pick up a manga if I liked the anime, and if the anime is incomplete.

[@motherlove8366]

That's kinda the point of anime a lot of the time tbh, manga/light novel adds.

[@davidtourt]

PoDCast 4ever

[@Panchita114]

When you are going to talk about Made in Abyss mangaa!

[@Joshua-zo9yq]

Truly the patrician choice.

[@Faulheit]

they "cut" the onomatopoeia in half get it

[@kuasocto3528]

Just read 22nd volume of Berserk and 94th chapter of One Piece. Luffy rising from destroyed Arlong Park was pretty cool, even if not something exclusive to manga format. Guts' battle with Zodd was a fucking mess, but in a way that felt actually not so bad. Both those hunks of meat were moving so fast to that smith boy, that we could say this messiness is just his perspective. And this mess, this particular type of mess is something that could only happen in a comic. I'm pretty sure the real reason for why it can be so confusing is just Miura forgetting that what makes sense in his head doesn't have to make sense on the actual page, but author is dead, yada yada, end result can be pretty interesting to think about.

[@mrbro6882]

Well, now I have to write the Pikachu meaning 50 times now

[@SamTheGumMan117]

I've been reading manga a lot more rather then watching anime and enjoying it a lot been reading Promised Neverland and Black Clover

[@iamdivan7368]

9:03 This video aged well

[@HeroofMightandmagic1]

Incidentally, in Swedish the word "subba" means slut, and the way slut is spelled in English is how the word "end" is spelled in Swedish. Hence all the funny pictures of movies ending with calling you a slut out of nowhere floating around the internet.

[@KalleVilenius]

How many layers is Oda on right now?

[@Kaixero]

If you're not a source material Chad, then by my reckoning, you are not a sentient being with rights. Just what's fair.

[@RikhanaKasumi]

So, when are you going to do a series where you just tell me what manga to read and why? Cause you're probably the only person I'd listen to,

[@greenbowers8330]

One Piece Lecture when

[@DrRyan82994]

Speaking of reading manga online and in japanese... Those shitty blurry scans sure make reading the furigana and complex kanji fucking impossible and it pisses me off. Even when you go and buy manga on honto.jp it's still kind of blurry

[@porporacaska6838]

Last one for me im off to boot camp bye

[@dannypavlov913]

Do a vid on dr stone again

[@1337w334b00]

You know what else is great about manga? I can go to the library and read it for free. No walled gardens of various streaming services or issues like the Eva DVD set going for $150 fucking USD. Accessing manga is so much easier than anime and it is wonderful

[@williancruz9657]

Kissanime exists you know

[@1337w334b00]

@@williancruz9657 kissanime has hit or miss video quality and is missing certain series that you'd expect them to have.

[@eduardomestanza8821]

Bulbasaur isnt the original name!? My life is a lie.

[@SuperXrayDoc]

DID SOMEBODY SAY TELL EVERYONE TO READ BERSERK

[@DESERTEAGLE142]

I love manga

[@bAd12cheZ]

*Daz Bones is a Supa Man*

[@stressouth]

Ah shit, here we go again

[@Gyonoo]

do you still read dr stone?

[@nelsonwang2753]

DAILY

[@Faulheit]

manga is objectively better than anime because theres much more variety of fetishes in doujins than in h anime i mean what

[@zoulzopan]

Comparing one artistic medium to another purely based on their porn potential, spoken like a truly cultured man.

[@wowhowbizarre8176]

Kneecaps would strongly disagree with you 😂

[@RetroGamerKevin]

0:05 POW!!! Right in da kisser!!!

[@tyronechillifoot5573]

Daz nutz

[@supervoltekka593]

How long until Odacchi gives us the "Kupa Kupa no Mi"; the "Spread Spread Fruit"? Some serious pussy play going on! The power of U N B I R T H I N G ! ! ! ! !

[@turza7769]

I rarely get into manga and not being bored af... I just get fcking bored from reading and feeling like the story is dead... I wouldn't say I lack imagination tho... help me I am weird

[@blakedavis2447]

Why don’t you own the manga ?

[@SttudDioPierrot]

Zac Rittner disliked this video

[@argnator]

Supa is Tenko, and it's not Tenko.

[@yeetpresident8313]

That one dislike is Zac Ritner

[@BinaryDood]

yet Bestie will never pick one of those l33t european comics that first inspired modern manga

[@lay-lowandsmash1519]

That was fun

[@LifeAura123]

Missed chance to say "su vs su-less"

[@Jonathan-fn5dq]

One Piece is a fucking masterpiece.

[@laytondickerson3194]

Day 17!!

[@gravethestampede3454]

Autism can be fun

[@synkadus]

Sensei

[@LaserFace23]

BGE specifically chooses Kaiji's 「ざわざわ」 rather than the more obvious JoJo's 「ゴゴゴ」, showing true patrician Chad taste 😎

[@AlexAndriy1995]

manga is good, but I'm anime boi. And it's clear for me, I finished 562 stuff from anime and only 23 manga.

[@wekashipo7507]

This is more of a testament to how amazing One Piece's manga is than how amazing manga in general is.

[@Hersi310]

Really struggling to pronounce the word onomatopoeia there, huh.

[@tomhanks1798]

Gnarly