Why Ibn Taymiyyah was in jail? | Mufti Abu Layth

Mufti Abu Layth tlks about why Ibn Taymiyyah was in prison.

[@JewelAhmed3]

Is it me or to do some of the pseudo Salafi najdi movement prefer to love and admire Muhammad Ibn Abdul Wahhab & House of Saud more than the prophet of Allah saws.

[@hammadsiddiqui8421]

I second that

[@ydw8405]

So wrong.. your opinion came out of ignorance..

[@FaisalSheikh82]

It's def just you, and those that agree with you. Unfortunately.

[@hammadsiddiqui8421]

@@FaisalSheikh82 shutup

[@FaisalSheikh82]

@@hammadsiddiqui8421 Why? Just because I made a comment that you didn't like, and you only have the mental capacity to respond with "Shut Up"? Perhaps my boy, it is you that needs to "shut up".

[@kaalufshinni3576]

Shaykh Ibn Taymiyya was a brilliant but demented Hanbali scholar who has inspired today's Salafis. He was jailed mainly for the same beliefs you now hear among the Salafis such as anthropomorphism, takfirism and other extremist ideas which went against the pale of Sunni Islam. The famous Moroccan scholar and traveller Ibn Batuta met him in damascus in 1326 and described him as being majnun (insane). His own student ad dhahabi, though he admired his teacher's intellect, described him as frequently tactless , harsh, prone to insults and argumentative( now you know where our modern day Salafis get their habits from). While Salafis cherry pick and take the most devient views of ibn Taymiyya and propagate it, they are silent on the fact that Ibn Taymiyya belonged to the Qadiriyyah order of Sufis. His critique on sufism was mainly on the innovations that had crept into the orders that were unislamic. When he died he was buried in the sufi graveyard near his brother. While a controversial, brilliant and somewhat unhinged scholars, his breadth of thought has been confined by the Najdiyya Salafis who have picked up and run with his most devient ideas, ideas for which the Muslim authorities, both secular and religious, ensured that he remained incarcerated and away from the Muslim public of his time. His obscure works would have remained in the dustbins of history were it not for the Najdiyya Salafi who, flush with oil money, revived them and printed them in the millions and helped to promote his devient ideas. Unfortunately, these ideas have plagued Muslims and have given birth to extremism and the birth of all devient jihadi groups from Isis to Shabab to boko haram, who follow this brand of extremist Islam, and have caused the death and suffering of untold number of Muslims.

[@HiTekNomaschenko]

"demented" Allahu Musta'an

[@AbdullahMikalRodriguez]

Well said.

[@jackrossley8832]

mufti how do you cut your hair during lockdown?

[@asathelogiclaman637]

People now almost behave as if there was only one scholar thats ibn taimiya😂🤣😂...lol

[@JewelAhmed3]

Ahh it make sense now why the Salafi hate the concept ziara (visiting the graves of the Prophet saws).

[@icysaracen3054]

From a geopolitical perspective, I can see why Saudi are keen to allow Israel to take over Jerusalem if you think about it. It makes it hard for all Muslims to visit Qubbat as sakhra/dome of the rock. win/win

[@unnanointedonesufi]

@@icysaracen3054 they dont care about that

[@icysaracen3054]

@@rhuiden4086 yeah sorry vocabulary went out of whack there

[@Abuhan47]

@@icysaracen3054 Saudia are lenient on isreal bc they rely on the US to protect their airspace from Iran. It has nothing to do with any religious thing.

[@HeadshotKillaa]

You were locked up for far more serious matters than Ibn Taymiyyah. Please refrain from speaking about the scholar. We know what you did b0y 🧐

[@Tinolg7]

What did he do?

[@aqilshamil9633]

@@Tinolg7 he work undercover to uncover ISIS rats hiding in Britain , brainwashing the muslim youths , to protect his cover UK police had to arrest him , I guess IDK .

[@Tinolg7]

@@aqilshamil9633 ohhhh

[@KlangelihleMalinga-pb7ds]

He should really shut up. He does know who was Sheikhul Islaam. Imaam Muqbil(r.a) used to say the barking if dogs doesn't harm the sky.

[@icysaracen3054]

Ibn Taymiyyah was the Oliver Cromwell of the Muslim world.

[@mohammedabudu7331]

Ibn tamiyyah and imam abdulwahab should be in the same whatsapp group

[@jivaji2028]

😂

[@Adrian-yf1zg]

Nah, the difference between their statuses is night and day... Have you seen the simpleton booklets and pamphlets of mohammed abdul wahab and then have you seen the depth and scope of the works of ibn taymiyyah.... He was a true shaykh ul islam.... The other was an extremist who murdered many and teachings lead to exteemism

[@Adrian-yf1zg]

@@alifbat1562 could be... But my point is he was million times better than mohammed abdul wahab who slaughtered whole muslim towns and is the grand daddy for isis

[@Adrian-yf1zg]

@@alifbat1562 i suppose the mongols were idily sitting in their homes waiting for ibn taymiyyah to invade them

[@slaveofallah_3820]

Hhahaha

[@Johneladjmi76]

At 0:55 beautiful explaination, always love the psychological aspect of this videos.

[@slaveofallah_3820]

We have four dislikes oh noooooooo we are all so saaad Please people who dislike accidentally I dislike Sike No really though pro who have disliked who cares you are haters we shall always give him thousands of likes and your dislikes never shall exceed 7 you seven Indian cow loving mushriks should just relax and oh you ones who accidentally dislike undislike ahahaha I’m so finished rn Please people good comments only listen too our beloved sheikh with an open heart I swear by Allah he is the best scholar in this time JazakAllahu khayr

[@slaveofallah_3820]

Beautiful ya sheikh al Kareem JazakAllahu khayr

[@hassanabdaladl]

Mufti I'm a bit confused brother, and you know I love you, but ibn Taymiyyah was jailed primarily due to his tajsim, not this ibn al-Qayyim story? Or at least not based on what I've heard. Can you clarify for me?

[@farzana6676]

Ibn Taymiyyah was jailed on atleast three occasions for different issues. Amongst them was tajseem, traveling to visit the grave of the prophet, and also he gave a fatwa that issuing three talaaq's at one time only counts as one talaaq.

[@hassanabdaladl]

@@farzana6676 ty Farzana that sounds more accurate

[@yassiral31]

A tactful analysis, well approached and well explained

[@sayedmosesshah2023]

Mufti you get hated on because u discuss the issues others shy away from being open on your view is a bold move nothing but ratings

[@unnanointedonesufi]

41 ibn taymiyah worshipers disliked this

[@glenbrito2624]

But we know at least 12 to 14 companions were involved in an assassination attempt against the prophet when he was traveling back from the land of tabuk when he was traveling through Aqaba Hudafah and ammar ibn Yasser both confirmed the story and some years later Hudafah was asked by Omar ibn khattab if he saw the faces of the people who tried to kill the prophet and Hudafah said he did and then Omar asked him was I one of them this is from authentic Hadith from Bukhari . As the Prophet passed through the Aqaba, 12 men from the army conspired to kill him. Masked, they decided to climb the top of the Aqaba and throw rocks at the convoy till it slips and falls off the mountain. The sources concur that the Prophet was warned of the conspiracy by Gabriel.

[@ydw8405]

to whom did ibn Tayyimiyah did the takfiri to ?

[@reshailraza514]

ابن العربی

[@GuruShiya11]

@@reshailraza514 he is not only one baby

[@Xaviergonzalez85]

@@GuruShiya11 ahmad sirhindi also disparaged ibn arabi. There's so much written about it.

[@GuruShiya11]

@@Xaviergonzalez85 Thanks

[@serialkiller928]

@@reshailraza514 Hafiz ibn Hajar, ibn Kathir , Hafiz Dhahabi and Mula Ali Qari Hanafi also made his takfeer

[@Gog3453]

Not only did he call people kafr. He also called for the execution of those he deemed kafr

[@fushiigso7145]

🥺🙌🏼💕💕

[@fushiigso7145]

@Siraj Haq hey! On what question is it based on, From this Monday? About why that god punish non believers in the time of the prophet? Meanwhile you have free will for decide to believe? Look I know what your mean or what your trying to go with it... it’s an easy ting to say when you don’t know the answer just let it be.. but it’s more than normal to ask those questions and to try to understand it at least for me it is. I’m interested in those kind of questions sorry that it bothers you but you ain’t going to stop me for asked them or questioning them ✌🏼I’m interested in it. It’s not that I’m struggling with accepting my religion. Questioning it and searching for the answer is a part of the journey yess I lot of stuff are un clear to me and yess I’m bothered about it because it doesn’t make sense for me. I don’t understand why god would punish someone for not believing in him meanwhile it doesn’t benefit god when someone believes in him and what is the point of free will if you’re going to be punished for meanwhile you don’t hurt anybody with it? Bye that point you’re saying that god would punish everyone because they don’t believe? I don’t believe that so yeah but I will make sure that my question will be answered. It’s easy to say just don’t dig in it. I have heard this for years my teachers told me this every time because I always had many questions they say when you are questioning to much it will leads you away from the religion. That is not the case nor the right answer when someone is question certain stuff. I’m confident in my religion, and I know there is a right answer to understand it. We shouldn’t be so insecure to ask questions regardless what it is... I’m searching for it and that should be fine.

[@fushiigso7145]

@Siraj Haq haha hey! You where the one who started it to begin with I’m not mad if you think that 😅 I appreciate your comment tough. I kinda have my own interpretation but I wanted to know what mufti’s view was and if my own interpretation could be something that could be. yes you said it respectfully I haven’t said you didn’t and I like it but I’m still not sure what message you wanted to give but I appreciate it. Well that is than something what we have in comment ✌🏼😆

[@fushiigso7145]

@Siraj Haq lol clarification fushii came from sushi ;)

[@fuadbusari9890]

mufti we need an hour lecture on ibn taymiya ,,,,, he was a disasters to islam

[@ashfaqaslam2971]

1 dislike from ganguteli fans...sorry fan when it comes to one dislike it should be contradicted ....

[@slaveofallah_3820]

Hahahahaah

[@slaveofallah_3820]

Let the haters hate

[@samsmith6279]

Thia is why we need tasawwuf. Imagine if salafis adored the prophet as much as they do their imams. Allah tells us to send salawat to the prophet in the quran. They say oh you can send salawat but not in congregation, its haram. You can remember Allah but not in segregation, that's haram. Dhikr, haram, imagine that. When you do dhikr in a congregation is when' it most spiritually beneficial. Salafis have sucked Islam dry. It's just a shell of it, based on mandatory action and fear. No love. Their philosophy is love through fear. We all know means can never justify the ends. The jews worship Allah for their love of Him not His Wrath. We can learn a lot from the jews.

[@affarokurz1486]

I really miss this abu leys

[@glenbrito2624]

Personally as a Muslim I don't consider Ibn taymiyah a Muslim because he wrote many things against Ali Ibn Ani Talib the son-in-law of the prophet and cousin so and we all know that Ali is part of the family of the prophet who is allowed to come under the cloak meaning he is the family when you send a blessings and prayers upon the family of Muhammad you're sending them on to our lead That's just a fact All Muslims agree with that all of them so it would take me a basically is a non-believer You can pray but if you don't send blessings on the family of Muhammad your prayer is invalid it doesn't matter if you prayed 800,000 times

[@ayanlethesomali7357]

I find it funny how Mufti here has respect for Ibn Taymiyya and Ibn Qayyim but the comments are just the polar opposite.

[@KhalidAli-jc7cv]

Mufti you should do a video about Muslim racism Like racism with in Islam

[@KhalidAli-jc7cv]

@@elprofesor8571 are you sure about that cause there are allot of racists in the middle East and Asia

[@Andalusian_]

@@elprofesor8571 LMAO. Go to UAE.

[@truthseekerBVC]

Syed-ism is rampant in Indo-Pak. Coming from a Syed.

[@KhalidAli-jc7cv]

@@elprofesor8571 Muslims and Islam isn't it the same. Muslims are the people who follow the faith

[@Adrian-yf1zg]

Ibn taymiyyah has a fatwa where he said certain race (turk) women slaves should cover.... Because the black or darker race slaves from the arabian peninsula at time of sahaba were not as appealing

[@AliAbbas-vk4io]

Ibn Taymiyaa was a controversial figure especially for his Khawarij Mentality of declaring people Mushrik.

[@personofcolour6564]

Quote pls

[@latenightrambles6634]

I wouldn't take knowledge from you even they paid me too pal, I guess this is just a comedy channel

[@saiyedkashefshahbazi8844]

😂🤣😂🤣❤💚💙

[@GuruShiya11]

HE pissed off malakies life Imam Shafi did. naughty naughty

[@universe7245]

Why throw a devil sign at start of your video !!!! IstaqfurALLAH

[@umarsyed7538]

İbn taymiyah is overrated by some people.

[@Mevmotto]

It seems he wasn’t a very nice person.

[@mouhamadarab5162]

Muslims and wahabie are 2 different believes. A whabie believes that god is a body that sits on the thrown. A Muslims belives that Allah existed before time and place. Allah created everything and he almighty is not indeed for his creation. A Muslim believe that Allah exists without a place because place is for creations

[@hhhuthhhjj5599]

Mohammed was a wahabi then Because wahabi madhab is correct

[@Ryan-lf6ds]

@@hhhuthhhjj5599 way to hell.

[@hummamkhan8278]

C'mon Mufti sab. That's an unfair assessment. You are describing Ibn Taymiyyah as the Wahhabis would present him today. He was no takfeeri. He just had theological differences on things like Allah's attributes. But I don't believe he made takfeer of many people. Only the likes of Ibn Arabi.

[@farzana6676]

He made takfeer of Fakhruddin Razi and said even the Mushriks, the Jews and Christians, had better understanding of Tawheed than Imam ar-Razi.

[@shahrukhgilani5246]

So Hanbalis are 5%ers? LOL

[@droseyoungestmvp1]

More like 1%

[@shahrukhgilani5246]

@@droseyoungestmvp1 I guess you didn't get the reference

[@ahmadramli8207]

Hanbalis are different from salafis and there is a lot of difference between salafi beliefs and Hanbali beliefs. Hanbalis lie between Maturidis and Ash'aris in beliefs

[@BP-xe7xs]

Thhis guy is an evil Person. How disrespectful he is. Really discusting !!

[@hasanismail3454]

Why were you in jail "Mufti"?

[@Andalusian_]

There is no such thing as “visiting the Prophet”. You cannot make those who are in the graves hear. That’s from the Qur’an. Muslims couldn’t quite do with Muhammad what the Christians did to Jesus because that would be way too blatant, but they found other ways to idolize Muhammad.

[@hammadsiddiqui8421]

Ok whatever mate.

[@NoureddineAteur]

Do you believe in the life on the grave ? Yes or no

[@NoureddineAteur]

@@SR-hu7qr Muhammad is dead. God is alive. Jesus died and god saved him from death, and he his alive because God allow him to live.

[@Abba02]

what is wrong with you. God said even the matrys are not dead talkless of his beloved Prophet PBUH. He is not physically present with us but he is fully aware of our actions. this is one of the many reasons why we believe you don't love and respect the prophet (S.A.W)

[@imgguru1277]

@@Abba02 so the Prophet is omniscient? 🤦‍♂️