Why the world isn't fair: Yuval Noah Harari on AI, Ukraine, and Gaza

[@ezehernandez]

Wars are about bad decisions... Really smart guy

[@jndee8989]

Yuval Harari - one of the greatest intellectuals of our time. We would be wise to follow his ideas.

[@Fidelista23]

You must be as spiritually sick as he is or do you just read the Talmud regularly

[@NTPSL]

Excellent interview, thank you!

[@ioneeamigo8357]

@NTPSL at 10 seconds. For thousands of years ... they literally did that. So you are starting with nonsense.

[@sergiusvart]

The ww3 taking the hindsight approach began Sept 2020 when Azerbaijan invaded Armenia (with Putin’s consensus) and was allowed to. Proceeding this was Azerbaijan /russia military cooperation 2 days prior to the invasion of Ukraine, with the idea that russia, Turkey, Belarus, Azerbaijan , Pakistan will unite on a new world order

[@MichaelWolfe1000]

I wouldn't be so sure it's just stories...

[@SchlimmShadySmash]

It will always be funny to me to hear an Israeli talk about Russian illegal land annexation.

[@smritisaraswat1709]

@@SchlimmShadySmash I couldn’t move beyond the first few lines where he says this. I liked his books but he is so oblivious to his own position. Once I saw that it’s hard for me to look at him or his work like I used to.

[@RifndjsklljuwhdnchAfacnxla]

Because you don't understand general international law uti possidetis juri which is the foundation of creating a state. Uti possidetis juri states that the emerging state will inherits the borders of previous administration. Since arabs give up on the partition, give up chance to create a state, the only state emerging from British mandate is Israel. Israel officially inherits British borders which includes territories like Jerusalem, gaza and judea sumeria.

[@mamunahmed2506]

Extremely thought provoking...

[@Doro_1602]

Thank you for this very interesting and wise conversation. I foĺlow Yuval Noah Harrari, I have and have written one of his latest books👍. I wish Yuval and all of us at his message will get through to those decision makers.🍀for our own humanbeings sake Best regards.

[@doramio6636]

😡😡😡🙏🙏🥱

[@Wilson84KS]

Ouh my, if you think that this is wise, you really need some decades of intense full time education. Harari with his fragment knowledge and zero understanding is far away from wisdom.

[@ceeemm1901]

@@Wilson84KS I'd hate to see what your "wisdom" is.

[@Wilson84KS]

@@ceeemm1901 You should begin at the very bottom of education and learn to understand text and context in first place, if you can't even follow this context and interpret there something that isn't there, namely me saying anything about me being wise, every other attempts to educate yourself are completely pointless. But that's pretty much like Harari, he and Klaus Schwab basically took what Jacques Fresco said and the Zeitgeist Movement is about and just adapted fragments of it to try to fix capitalism and a lot of nonsensical unfounded gibberish as the philosophy to it.

[@fica375]

The opening statement is erroneous on multiple levels. One country can not replicate what others have done without repercussions for years.

[@AkAk-tk1tg]

He says you cannot just invade and annex another country then mentions putin lol, not much to say about his own country

[@architechofreality]

The interviewer is annoying. He interupts Harari in the middle of serious points to interject seemingly to get cheap laughs or to reassert himself for no good reason.

[@briancase6180]

Thought provoking. As usual. Thanks.

[@lynneeify]

He says that God was limited to natural elements and that he's going to create and transcend organic elements. Has he seen the periodic table which has organic and inorganic elements. There's nothing new and there's not one thing they're going to build that isn't been built from what God already has created in the universe. Let him try let him find something that God didn't create. Let him start from the foundation and get something that's not part of electrons and protons and neutrons and elements of the periodic table. Then he can say that he's transcending God. Have you thought about that? That's his constant claim. Is he that smart when he says he's a scientist. Put on your thinking cap.

[@tobiasminder73]

no smartphone , no digital slavery

[@GeorgeMonsour]

Proving that civilization is unconscious!

[@anuttamaghosh1710]

Great talking... I value each word that you say. Your speech stimulates my brain.

[@ezraorlofsky7809]

I honestly don't understand what is so smart about this fellow. Just stories? What a way to miss the point.

[@j.katyLevin.2684]

And whats the point? What else then stories can it be?

[@ezraorlofsky7809]

@@j.katyLevin.2684 science, philosophy, meaning, morals, art, music, enlightenment, transcendence, charity, humor, engineering, insight, astronomy, wisdom, honesty, love, justice, linguistics, honor, chivalry, piety, coolness, environmentalism... The list goes on. And this is just Bible. Don't confuse a story with a lesson.

[@Sayheybrother8]

We do all things because if the stories in our minds and stories are formed from histories. Interestingly I don’t believe all historical events are just stories.

[@brianmills3983]

This from an advisor to Klaus Schwab of WEF.

[@bobby09288]

Yuval kinda creeps me out. His view of people are completely different than my own . Guess that’s my animal instincts kicking in. 😊

[@ceeemm1901]

Don't shoot the messenger.

[@ronaldtheanalyst3593]

Ooops! . . . Looks Like Somebody's OFF Switch is BROKEN!

[@Northern-Don]

This is REALLY REALLY good!! Thank you!!

[@odikaiopolis2832]

It is well explained in the bible ....

[@wesnermichel6005]

Agreed 100%. Thank you for the positif way of thoughts.

[@Ecotopias]

"A country shouldn't be allowed to annex its neighbour just because it's stronger" Was he thinking of Israel?

[@mannieberhanu3469]

well that's the story of humanity and who says you can't do it if you can...men make rules and break them as well..this is the story of humanity as we know it...wrong write is another matter

[@mariobecker4401]

EXCELLENT presentation again

[@sambaxrock]

SAME thoughts here. It shows how this brainwashed culture permeates even the brightest minds of the colony.

[@rocketscience1510]

He is not right, wars exist because lack of resources too

[@metokyo4960]

67k views with only 1.2k approval. I would say humanity is f***ed 😢

[@alexgoslar4057]

Liberate your mind, with the footloose mind liberator.

[@Lancet75]

The roots of Swiss democratic practices date to the Old Swiss Confederacy, formed in 1291, laid the groundwork for a cooperative and federative political structure among the cantons14. Various forms of pre-modern democratic institutions, such as the Landsgemeinde (cantonal assemblies), have existed since the late Middle Ages, contributing to Switzerland's long tradition of democratic governance. Thus, while the modern Swiss democracy is 176 years old, its foundational principles and practices have been evolving for over 700 years.

[@RobertaSirgutz]

Why not? Israelis have taken and continue taking Palestinian land, with our help!

[@stereonetzz]

what lands are you referring to, west bank settlements, or "from the river to the sea"? just asking... 🙄

[@smajiszrael]

You mean the British Mandate? Or what do you mean by palestinian land?

[@nosteinnogate7305]

What made it their land?

[@smajiszrael]

@@RobertaSirgutz what do you mean by Palestinian land? The old british mandate of palestine? And who are the palestinians? The ones with palestinian passports? Show me one pls

[@mogh2603]

yes , we need wisdom from a man with a husband , his worldview is surely original .

[@ewartemersonyearwood3032]

Democracy is still in BETA

[@spajkic1]

Introduction, first 30 second is enough for me. Speaking about Russian invasion, and ignoring elephant in the room is enough for me to understand where this talks came from. I mean, not seeing American invasion of plenty of countries far, far away, Brits, French army on many places etc.

[@vaultsjan]

How smart are you! I mean congrats!

[@extrastuffing7539]

This kind of deflection. Other people have done bad things so you can't criticize us for doing bad things. Fail

[@spajkic1]

@@extrastuffing7539 I am not leading philosopher, not a public speaker, not acting like big brain, I am just ordinary man commenting on youtube. This Harari is too smart to made mistakes not to speak about pattern and more obvious acts of violence committed by governments closer to him, and to talk about one particular place (Ukraine-Russia). That is pure intentional deflection !

[@vaultsjan]

@@spajkic1 do not beat down yourself. You are indeed very smart!

[@mariatereza4348]

@@spajkic1 yes, it was so disappointing 😔

[@AAA9549-w7w]

24/08/2024 What did he say, his husband went to the Apple store!? Is he homosexual!? Metaphysician & Philosopher

[@mseesea]

@@AAA9549-w7w yes, he is

[@ceeemm1901]

Do you think only homosexuals go to the Apple store? Haha.

[@patatin05]

@@AAA9549-w7w he is and Yuval is open about it

[@Audioobscure]

Same things yuval said at 92nd

[@ceeemm1901]

WTF is "92nd"?

[@chrisfernandes3353]

Um...he said "My husband"?

[@smajiszrael]

yes

[@chrisfernandes3353]

@@smajiszrael Thanks, I found out later that Yuval is openly gay.

[@ceeemm1901]

Yes, welcome to all our Victorian Era listeners.

[@smajiszrael]

@@ceeemm1901 are you being cynical?

[@Peace_upon_us2024]

He loves talk about Russia but not about Israel

[@markwrede8878]

Private ownership rewards the unfair.

[@stereonetzz]

communism? what could go wrong...

[@markwrede8878]

@@stereonetzz We could be stuck with a single party state to resist the private extortionists, as has happened. Wall Street is America's enemy.

[@nikolaykalnakov]

Does anyone honestly believe that political decisions and choices are ever made by "the people"?! Is it not absolutely clear that in any of the so far social structures, the decisions on what is spent where (what is to be prioritised) are made by few people on behalf of the whole? Indeed up until reasonably there has been no technological ability to be any different but today the technology can easily provide the opportunity for decentralising and truly bringing it down to "the people" the decision making process (at least on subjects which affect the majority - like going to wars, climate change and so on) yet all we can see in reality is the exact opposite- super centralisation on global scale and state centralisation on decisions with active reduction of the voice of "the people" often via the " hacking" of the human brain and filtering information... nowadays it is ever more- a few deciding for all with the perverted believe they have the right, knowledge and abilities to assumingly "find" the "right answers" for all and therefore dictate what and how is to be done for all and by all... this is all like looking into a picture but only seeing a single colour conveniently ignoring all that doesn't fit a predetermined agenda.... noting new, I guess.... but there is a way now to get out of this dead lock. All that's needed is a little bit of will. No revolutions - evolution!

[@abdulaijawobah2203]

What about your country (Israel) occupation of Palestine? Yuval you’re not just honest. I respect your academic prowess but always critical about your lack of sincerity!!!

[@smritisaraswat1709]

For any historian to not reflect upon his own position in the work he is doing in itself is unethical. Now, I don’t appreciate his academic work either. It’s dishonest too.

[@BeatlesBowieKrimson]

You asked some great questions but then you insulted your guest at the very end.

[@orwellhuxley6301]

Really, the world isn’t fair?! Is that true?

[@mnemonija]

It's a rationalization for his country. A coping mechanism, once you reject racism. It's unfair, but you know, unfairness happens. It's normal.

[@tomsaunins1]

💯

[@ExploringAmerica2025]

This guy should be locked up

[@nosteinnogate7305]

No he shouldnt

[@hansfrankfurter2903]

How does this guy think isnotreal was founded? Surely not by persuasion and pacifism?

[@czarquetzal8344]

Hahaha. Why even judge an act as unfair? What's your source of morality if you deny it?

[@janetwebb1507]

Dont Agree about Putin

[@janetwebb1507]

His education is in History

[@heraschoice]

And one more think. We are not losing power to AI, we are giving it away. And I hope we will use AI only for good. Nr one think that AI should abolish should be modern slavery. If that is fixed there is enough resources in the world to sustain every single citizen.

[@czarquetzal8344]

Its a deception of the tech industry to control the economic system.

[@davereynolds3403]

yuval - great human being who’s got the Ukraine war sooooo wrong 😑 Ukraine is the Cuban missile crisis all over again … but Yuval hasn’t learned from history - which is weird cos he’s a historian 🤨

[@Robin80898]

Harari wants to be God.

[@Thomas...191]

Goodness... I missed the part when he said that... unless you're projecting..

[@ceeemm1901]

What a lame loner comment....

[@lynneeify]

How can he possibly say that they're going to build something that transcends what God has already done because God has been limited to the organic. Hasn't anybody seen the periodic table which is built of organic and inorganic elements. There will not be anything built that will not be built on what God has already built on.

[@argelmtz]

His country is commiting a genozide and his worried abojt Russia???

[@coco-wd2kg]

this guy is completely overrated. just commonplace bla bla, but well articulated.

[@ioneeamigo8357]

At the second 10, you are already lair 😂😂😂 for thousands of years people do still and robbing and colonial otheres. What are you talking about

[@tobiasminder73]

church of ai, no thankx!

[@ceeemm1901]

No "caps lock"?

[@tobiasminder73]

@@ceeemm1901 ?

[@tobiasminder73]

@@ceeemm1901 chat bot?

[@FatherGapon-gw6yo]

This guy is not very smart.

[@muhammadusama8277]

so true he is a cunning little fox how he underpins what israel is doing with over projecting russian invasion. Someone should tell him that if ww3 would start it would start with israel's genocidal policies.

[@ceeemm1901]

Can you top that comment with something blander and more vacuous or is that your "home run"?

[@FatherGapon-gw6yo]

The only reason he is promoted is because he’s a gay jew

[@amargogi]

Russia using force in Ukraine is visibly wrong. But how do you justify interference and changing elected government in Ukraine, placing foreign armies on its soil, expanding military alliances, etc. How should one respond to such underhanded aggression.

[@maxovgrom]

First and the best way - is not to spread russian propaganda narratives)

[@Бегзат1]

​@@maxovgrom First and smart way is not deflecting the propaganda.

[@endlesssolitaire731]

No foreign army entered Ukraine except Russian army. Ukraine didn't join any military alliances and was invaded because of that. Countries that did this evaded the war even despite having much weaker military on their own, like Estonia or Latvia. Ukraine was backstabbed by Russia in 2014 due to its military weakness and corrupt elites which didn't care about the future of their country, so they never tried to join NATO 25 years ago.

[@Hitchike2galaxy]

This dude is a total fraud.

[@Бегзат1]

This guy always comes with his brainwashed followers. Lol.

[@richardellis2955]

A big brain, or just a pure evil brain?

[@czarquetzal8344]

@@richardellis2955 pseudo-intellectual

[@richardellis2955]

@@czarquetzal8344 evil 👿

[@czarquetzal8344]

That's too much, but yes, I agree, hehehehe 🤣