WILLOW vs. ELVIE Breast Pumps | An honest breast pump comparison, which one is better?

[@jazziep1123]

Thank you for being factual, balanced and honest and not pushing a particular pump. I found this to be very helpful!

[@AdingADongALBC]

I love how you just give information instead of choosing which one is the “best”. You let us decide which one most best fits our lifestyle. I’m still indecisive with which one I want to go for but thank you for this information! It has helped a lot ☺️

[@lilac819]

Thank you for getting straight to the point. I hate it when people talk so much and try to be funny or sarcastic. I love this video!

[@heatherhiggins6905]

Thanks for giving the pros and cons and not pushing one over the other. Most helpful comparison I’ve watched!

[@NewLittleLife]

Thanks! That’s always the goal for my videos. There’s really no perfect pump that works for everyone. Let me know what you decide! If you need more help, join the Facebook group :) Www.Facebook.Com/groups/breastpumpreviews

[@chelseyrodriguez9516]

A year later and this video is still helping in helping me decide between these two great pumps

[@allaboutlife3709]

I couldn't stop laughing at the sound the willo made, sounds like my father's 80's printer 🤣🤣

[@amyhedges5189]

Thank you for sharing such a thoughtful thorough review! I’m due in just a few weeks and have really been struggling with this choice. Your insights are immensely helpful!

[@NewLittleLife]

Good luck on your upcoming new addition! I’d love to know which pump you end up choosing :)

[@ashleytacosbabey]

Thank you for including the sound ! I want to breast pump while I’m at work but don’t want to sound like I’m on life support . All the other videos do not show us the sound . Thanks 😊

[@cupofchi_]

😂😂

[@Margaretfogs]

This was SUPER helpful and just what I was looking for! Love how you divided the sections to make it easy to navigate. Thanks for the great content, just subscribed!

[@NewLittleLife]

Yay great! Let me know what you end up choosing :)

[@Margaretfogs]

@@NewLittleLife I chose the Elvie - can’t wait to get it and see how I like it! I used a spectra with my daughter but really need something cord & tube free with two little ones now!

[@LittlewingRN]

-I really appreciate your review. I had the Willow 3 for exclusive pumping in 2020 (my baby was in Nicu and refused to BF from me once she realized she didn't have to work for it from a bottle, lol). I had a Medela Symphony that I would use too. The Willow was great for work but because of constant suction, I think I just got to the point I was tired of it and uncomfortable. I also had issues with reusable containers after 2 months not working and the company sent me tips, those didn't help, I bought new containers and it would eventually not read that I was pumping and not get out of stimulation mode. Given my nips are elastic and stretched very easily, I may try the Elvie this time and hope for the best given its more natural suction. I feel the constant suck on the Willow really didn't help with my let down and I was never fully emptied which I desperately needed to avoid mastitis which I had twice. I liked that the Willow had the bag option too but it got pricey after awhile. Thank you again for the review!

[@talyra8649]

I loveeeee your reviews! - super neutral and practical on the comparison!

[@Daniramm]

I love how you separated your video with the titles so we can just jump to the section we are interested in. Thanks!

[@NewLittleLife]

Great! I was hoping viewers were using that feature! I’ll keep doing it :)

[@Leandrasjones]

Yes!! More videos should do this! Thank you

[@NewLittleLife]

Such a cool feature huh! I’ve been donno it since youtube came out with the chapters feature. I love it too!!

[@hannahwillams9602]

Thank you for saying with the willow containers is the same as being upright! I have watched so many reviews and no one mentions that!!!

[@JanTsCoL26]

I'm only doing research at this point so I don't have any personal experience. But I wanted to point out that Elvie gives you the option of buying either a single pump or double. With the Willow, you don't have that option, you'd have to buy the whole set. For me, that's a pro for the Elvie with the option to get a single pump to try and have the option to buy a second one if needed. I thought that would be great for someone who's budget conscious and also don't necessarily know what their exact situation would be like post-partum. Thanks for making this great video! This has given me more insight into my research 🙂

[@NewLittleLife]

Very true! In fact for me since I’m exclusively breastfeeding and mostly home with my baby, one would be enough. I’ve never actually pumped with both together, there hasn’t been a need. Thanks for sharing!

[@irenejimenez8570]

Valid point . I m actually considering to purchase one. I m home now and so i think one will be good start and save 220 dollars

[@victoriagarcia-damian2527]

I went with a willow. Thanks for helping me decide.

[@augustineevbakhare6546]

I have both the elvie and the willow 3rd gen as well. I had issues with leaking with the elvie so the willow wins on that point for me since I was pumping at work. Also the suction on the willow feels a lot stronger at every level. seems like I get more stimulation and think it will better maintain my milk supply when I go back to work this time. Willow also has flange inserts if your nipple size is smaller than their 2 standard flange sizes. The only down sides to the willow for me is that it is more complicated to use and is louder but worth it for me due to increased mobility w/o leaks and better suction. The direct pump bags are super convenient as well.

[@NewLittleLife]

These are fantastic points on the two pumps. I completely agree!

[@shelleybelly96]

Would LOVE to see the elvie stride also in this comparison

[@SamiSmolboi]

I’m glad you did this. Idk if you’re the rest of this channel is my type of content, but I’m subscribing and gonna binge your videos because I love your voice. It’s so soothing. 💕

[@NewLittleLife]

Aww… thank you! I hope you do find some value here :)

[@tiffanykelly2000]

Thanks for the info! Now I have to make my decision…

[@mackenziewillard9273]

I’m a FTM and thank you for the honest review. I love both of them so deciding is going to be hard.😅

[@felllindsey]

My Elvie leaks a lot. It dosnt stop when it should, and if I move a certain way the container on the bottom seems to bend a little and it leaks. I just ordered the Willow so hopefully it works better for me. I have three kids, two in sports and other activities. I need something reliable, something I can pop in and use on the way to the next obligation, without worrying my short is going to get wet.

[@francyrios1819]

This video is everything!!! Super helpful and to the point. THANK YOU!

[@ntmn8444]

For me, the willow is better. It’s a bit more expensive but being able to be in any position is important. I really need this pump bc I’m a flight attendant, and I want to be able to pump discreetly while working. I plan on also having a pump at home. This would be my pump exclusively for work.

[@NewLittleLife]

Great insight. Thanks!

[@yariortiz8375]

You do really great and smart reviews! Thank you!

[@elzyanne7304]

I’m currently looking for a hands free pump. I want to know if it’s worth the investment

[@maddiemarie33345]

Thank you for such a thorough review! This might sound like a stupid question but what is the best way to store breast milk with closed containment and not bags? I'm a full time working momma and work part from home and part from office and my plan is to pump regularly to create a steady supply for when my baby is in child care on days that I do work. I'm just not sure what the best way to go about using and storing milk from these is.

[@cesiahyarett]

I love your videos, this are very informative. I made my bf watch this one to choose which pump will work better for me. I currently have the spectra pink and omg I love it so far. My neighbor gave us this re used pumps the spectra pink and the spectra portable, i was using the portable for "convenience" and was only able to express 2oz from both breast. Until i saw your videos specially on reused pumps, I started yesterday to use the spectra pink and now im able to express more milk waay more milk. Definitely reused pumps go bad and I couldn't get as much milk. The pink spectra was reused aswell but not as much as the portable. Thank you for your videos.

[@nishatahiliani528]

Thanks for this comparison! A bit long at the start but very informative video :) :)

[@samanthagould9136]

This is such a good overview! Would it be appropriate to purchase only the Elvie or Willow for pumping? I've heard some moms get less milk from these compared to non-portable pumps. But I guess if a mom only bought, say, the Elvie, she wouldn't know the difference.

[@ntmn8444]

I have heard the same. I’ve only seen people use these pumps while traveling, so it might not be a good idea to use these all the time.

[@kristinestortroen7253]

I EPd on the elvie and had a huge output.

[@Maru_loves_mochixx]

So incredibly helpful. I thought Willow was the right choice for me but I’m leaning toward the Elvie. However when I spoke to a willow rep she recommended I get another brands flange as my size was below the smaller flanges threshold. Would that be the case for Elvie as well?

[@NewLittleLife]

Yes, they both have the smallest flange size of 21mm. I’m a bit smaller than that too and have enjoyed pumping with the BeauGen cushions! Here’s a link if you want to see if they work for you. Coupon code: NEWLITTLELIFE for 15% off if it’s something you wanna try! www.beaugen.com/?aff=Newlittlelife

[@Darchellebooksandplanners]

This was very helpful, thank you!

[@NewLittleLife]

I’m so glad :)

[@luisahenao6409]

any videos on affordable wearable pumps?

[@cellyjohnson]

Great review.

[@youacct100]

Would either work if currently using smaller flange sizes? Or can those be replaced with smaller flanges?

[@NewLittleLife]

You can use inserts to adjust the flange size. Willow makes some nice ones!

[@ashleyohayre9577]

Maybe I was using it wrong but in my experience this pump is not for those with inverted nipples it will tear you up. I have the 2.0 so maybe the 3.0 is better

[@ashleylebron2394]

I love this comparison video thank you!

[@shivsheehy]

Do both pumps cater to ladies with a large breast size? I use 32mm flange for the spectra currently. Could I use the Elvie or Willow? Would they accommodate me comfortably?

[@NewLittleLife]

Hmm.. good question. The largest flange size on either of these is 28mm although I personally think they run a bit big, you may email the company and see what they say! As far as the large breasts, either should work fine.

[@taniascaduto4374]

Great video, objective and super helpful!

[@baybiieghennee]

SO HELPFUL! SERIOUSLY!

[@bethj1651]

Thank you so much for this video! So helpful. Im expecting my 4th baby and have exclusively pumped for all 3 of my babies and plan to do the same for my 4th. Im so excited to have some freedom!! I feel like the investment would be sooo worth it. I think I will add myself to your fb group too. Im sure I will watch this video a lot before my 4th baby comes! :)

[@laurenphillips9492]

I exclusively breastfeed and i return to work when my baby is 4mo. Do you know if the willow can remove all of my milk? Ill be pumping every 2 hours. I currently have the Elvis and i feel like it doesn’t ever completely empty my breasts like my medela pumps do.

[@letgo-cleaningupclutterpur4306]

What did you end up doing?

[@thickfitlaurentv5940]

The willow also has a lot of issues and an “adjustment period” I wish you would have mentioned that. Also, wish I would’ve found you sooner. Do you have a video for your number one wearable recommendation? I have a willow and hate it. Looking for another but want to do allllll my research.

[@mecarini17]

I am looking for some guidance. I make about 24-28 oz a day, I am 4 mpp and I pump for about 30-45 mins (except MOTN pump at 60 mins) I used the Medella pump in style and I notice milk does not start flowing really well until I get passed stimulation mode and into expression mode. I really want the Willow so I can be more Mobil for work and baby, but the fact that it doesn't leave expression mode till a certain mark makes me nervous. Do you think I could still get the Willow and not have an issue? or do you suggest Elvie in this case? Please someone help I am stuck :(

[@erc19941]

Thank you!

[@Monopolygirl]

Does this work for someone who needs a larger flange than the typical size supplied. I needed a 27mm with my first baby and am pregnant with me second.

[@NewLittleLife]

I think both have a 27/28 mm flange option

[@thisistheway2]

So I accidently dropped one willow pump in a bowl of water in my sink this morning. Is there anything I could do or is it done for good? 😞

[@kimberlylopez4461]

Let me know what happens please!

[@thisistheway2]

@@kimberlylopez4461 So I ended up leaving the pump standing up with the charging port on the bottom to dry for a few days and then plugged it in to charge. It's been a week since this happened and it started working again today!

[@k.salcidoxx]

did you put it in rice? :o i would've 😅

[@AdingADongALBC]

Idk if it was included in the video but how many ounces do each of them hold?

[@NewLittleLife]

Elvie 5 oz each side, and willow technically 5 oz but you can hack it to hold more

[@sw4276]

Can you make a video about the Elvie Stride?.

[@NewLittleLife]

It’ll be up this week!!

[@sw4276]

@@NewLittleLife THANK YOU so much!! I am a new expecting mom and I just recently found your channel. It is super helpful.

[@jwalpa2011]

Super helpful! Thanks so much

[@cantfindmynose]

Hi! Jut to clarify - both are ok to use overseas? I will be living in Portugal so would need to be compatible. Thanks!

[@NewLittleLife]

I used both when we lived in Belgium! No problems

[@tonyamoken-goswick9982]

Thank you for sharing this has helped me in deciding which pump I wanted to get.

[@nurulfairuzhajiali8532]

Hello Allison. Hope you have a great day. Thank you so much for your review. Super helpful, informative and i love how you don't mind saying that you can't decide on which pump is better. I appreciated that 😊 Been using the Willow 2.0 almost 4 months now and i love it (though the suction was rough at the beginning and lots of learning curve). Now i'm wondering how the suction is on the Willow vs the Elvie? I heard that the Elvie is super gentle (kinda want to get it just to feel it 😅)

[@NewLittleLife]

The Elvie suction is much gentler, yes! Especially in comparaison to the Willow 2.0. Of the 2, I do prefer the suction of the Elvie. It’s hard to describe, it’s probably the gentlest pump I’ve ever used though and I still get great output with it. I have a video coming out next week with lots more information on the Elvie! I’m also thinking about getting the Willow 3.0 to see what the suction is like on the new one, I have the 2.0 like you.

[@blueeyed001]

I bought the willow(2.0 used) I read that the 3.0 is better especially if you have low milk supply. I exclusively pumped with my daughter and I tried so hard for her to latch but I didn’t have the right tools or help.. I am now expecting my son (15 months later) and was curious on your opinion should I invest in the willow 3.0. I definitely had low milk supply and went through a lot of obstacles and I would love for this new journey be a little easier. Thanks for all your advice!!

[@NewLittleLife]

Did you love your willow? If so, sure maybe upgrade! If not, then perhaps invest in a new set up. Are you a working mom?

[@Titanisz]

Would I be able to use the Willow in Europe? If I have someone ship it to here, could I use it with this voltage? I wish it would be usb-C as well.

[@NewLittleLife]

I used it when we lived in Europe just with a wall adapter. (Admittedly, I didn’t use it extremely often) You could also probably order a European cord in the equivalent voltage. Try emailing willow and see what they advise!

[@saraharndt4725]

I haven't found any reviews that include the transition of pump to bottle... Can the bags for willow transition straight into a bottle system like kiinde? Or do we have to pour it into a separate bottle for feeding time?

[@NewLittleLife]

Pour into a bottle

[@ambergaskin7235]

How is your milk output for both pumps, and have you found a decrease in your milk supply using either as if it's not draining the breast completely? I've heard so many mixed reviews about each of these pumps.

[@NewLittleLife]

I had the same/expected output with both of these pumps. I exclusively breastfeed, and just pump occasionally so I have not have any issues. It does seem to empty me pretty completely, although sometimes I have to empty it half way through if it’s over 5 oz.

[@katiakishta4008]

Missed one difference- the oz of milk that each holds. Willow holds 5, Elvie holds 4.

[@TheSaray08]

I bought the Elvie... at first I loved it like the first week. Thennnnnnn it became a hassle to stop, clean the humidity that the membrane collected and then it started getting loud like if it was old. I called customer and they said the parts warped. They sent some new ones andddd it was the same thing. Every 4 minutes I have to stop, wipe the humidity and keep pumping. I want wack to my medela and I am just stuck pumping. Also with the elvie, if you have medium size to big boobs you almost have to hold them in a way.

[@mesaNurse13]

Have you tried the Willow? I have a bigger chest and certainly don’t want to invest in something that won’t work for me...

[@TheSaray08]

@@mesaNurse13 no I haven’t, I hear they are more hands free though but I have no clue tbh

[@TheSaray08]

@@mesaNurse13 ok i went back to the elvie but i tried some different amazon nursing bras anddddd and it’s going much better. I also pumped at the mall on the go. So elvies are not that bad anymore. The bra also lets the elvies breath a little bit more so condensation doesn’t collect and i don’t have to stop every 5 minutes

[@mesaNurse13]

@@TheSaray08 thank you for the update!

[@lindseysee5728]

What pumping bras from Amazon worked for the elvie?

[@jannetfurlong4663]

Love this video. I’m going to message you on the FB group :)

[@DillyDallyDeeleeDallee]

My Elvie tends to leak. I’ve tried diff flanges and the beaugen cushions. Personally I find the Elvie is overrated. Agree with your review, with the Elvie you have to be pretty still. Mobility is so crucial. Should have watched your review before buying the Elvie. Their customer service is not that great either.

[@3Samiii]

I’m currently torn between the two pumps and this comment is so helpful! Thank you!

[@cherishchapman5311]

How many oz does each pump hold?

[@NewLittleLife]

I think I said it in there the exact amount, but around 5 oz I think on both.

[@keeks8817]

Tried to join you fb page but apparently I have to take a class 🤷🏼‍♀️

[@NewLittleLife]

Are you sure it’s my group? Anyone can join! facebook.com/groups/breastpumpsforworkingmoms

[@dddyslilgrl53]

I really didn’t like the willow-no matter how much I sized it, i had no output and there was so much pain!

[@k.salcidoxx]

i always have pain but i lube up with olive oil. that has saved my areolas & nipples tremendously!!

[@shavonnebarnes4773]

do the willow cut off by itself when full

[@kimberlylopez4461]

Yes it does when your about 4.5 ox

[@houseoflittlegiggles5926]

Are both pumps parts able to be sterilized either in a sterilizer or in boiling water?

[@NewLittleLife]

Yes. Not the motor parts of course, but the other parts yes.

[@amidunaway3571]

The manual says you can’t use microwave sterilizer bags.

[@lejlaland2020]

Thank you so much for creating this video! I am actually considering either one of these pumps for the near future, God Willing ❤️🙏🏻 I am a mama to a baby boy currently so either one of these would be handy when chasing after a toddler 😂😂😂😂😂

[@NewLittleLife]

Totally!!! 🤣 Just had my 3rd recently.. so I feel that 💯

[@n.cortez8686]

Are these pumps covered through tricare?

[@NewLittleLife]

Yes! I got my Elvie through TRICARE. Actually I just got a coupon code for $75 off Elvie via your insurance which I’ve never seen before! Let me get the link for you.

[@raebeaute]

@@NewLittleLife 👀

[@raebeaute]

@@NewLittleLife how much did you pay out of pocket with your pump through tri care? They’re asking me for $325. What medium did you order through as well?

[@yashikacolon7986]

May I please get the link?

[@NewLittleLife]

Baby pavailion is who I used! They are specific to TRICARE. There’s a link down a bit in this page as well as some other info regarding choosing a breast pump www.newlittlelife.com/choose-a-breast-pump/

[@slb-v7b]

Hi Allison, I'm a new mommy and just gave birth this last Sunday. So I wanted to breastfeed my baby but unfortunately I had no colostrum coming out and so I just decided to bottle feed my baby since nothing was coming out. Now, my breasts are very tender and feel engorged. Could this mean I have milk coming in soon and if so what should I do to help extract it and possibly build up a stash?

[@NewLittleLife]

Yes, you likely have some milk there. Either feed your baby at the breast or use a breast pump! You can also search some videos on hand expression if you want, but that would be my third choice recommendation for you. You may also benefit from seeing a lactation consultant in your area! Good luck 💕

[@slb-v7b]

@@NewLittleLife Great thank you

[@slb-v7b]

Hi, I had another question. What is the next size flange from a 24mm?

[@NewLittleLife]

These two pumps come with 24mm and 28mm. Willow also makes a 21mm sold separately. Elvie is coming out with a 21mm if they haven’t already!

[@chunniema21]

I had the elvie, would never buy again. Just came to see about the willow! Considering if it's just as the same

[@NewLittleLife]

What did you not like about the elvie? Maybe I can help you decide if the willow would be any better or more of the sane issue for you!

[@chunniema21]

@@NewLittleLife hi doll. Everything you said about it was what I don't like. The battery life is horrible. Mine would only let me pump for 45 minutes to an hour. Then take 2 hours and 45 minutes to charge, the fact that it leaked very easily.

[@risabug7772]

Ha. Willow is currently offering 100 dollars off for healthcare workers and first responders but with all the extra parts you have to buy separately, you'll be spending 500 dollars still 🙄

[@k.salcidoxx]

at least not 600? 😅

[@kristinadechert9397]

Do these work on large breasts? I am a DDD and im having trouble latching with my medela

[@NewLittleLife]

Should work well. There’s a couple posts about these pumps and large breasts in our Facebook group if you’re interested on others experience with them! Www.Facebook.Com/groups/breastpumpreviews

[@carlywetherington6537]

How is the consistency with suction for the willow? My main issue with the Elvie was the inconsistent suction. One session they’d work great the next session one pump wouldn’t have the best suction even when pulling all the parts off and refitting everything making sure everything was tight. I’d replace duckbills and valves and still have issues. Some days my bras would be fine others I’d have to wear the tightest bra I owned to make it have consistent suction. The pumps never seemed to offer the same amount of suction even when pumping at the same speed/power level. This time around I’m leaning towards the willow but I’m starting to wonder if this is just a flaw with wearable breast pumps.

[@haleyeliza5978]

I had this issue with the Willow!! That’s why I’m here for this video. I was hoping to hear Elvie would be better about that. The Willow is a nice pump. I have a love hate relationship with it because it frustrated me soooo much. I know I wouldn’t have committed to pumping for 6 months without the convenience of mobility, however, there was more trouble shooting than there should have been.

[@lainfreefall9715]

The willow on suction sounds like a printer lol

[@NewLittleLife]

🤣

[@Leandrasjones]

Will it work on bigger boobs? Like 32F?

[@trevor_corey8037]

I went with the willow. Unfortunately I regret it and wish I went with elvie. Cons: super bulky- not possible to pump in public for me. I look ridiculous and the light Also shines through the shirt . - expensive, the containers extra $60 The bags haven’t used because the willow is glitchy. Says I pump 4 oz when I only pumped 2 on one breast. Totally off and totally waste of a bag - oz counting is useless in the app , totally useless. It’s so far off -DISCOMFORT.,suction is so strangely painful , yet my right breast pumps nothing out . It ruins my nipples and swells mine up so badly. - only 1 flange size. Elvie comes with multiple. I regret it Updates: For $600 , You get a really inconvenient inefficient pump . I hate it the longer I have it . It’s been a total of THREE WEEKS. The only benefit it encouraged me to breastfeed more

[@taraneel2859]

This was really helpful!! Thank you