WOKENESS is the MOST EVIL Thing You Can Do - Carl Benjamin (4K) | heretics. 96

[@andrewgoldheretics]

Sign up for a 14-day free trial and enjoy all the amazing features MyHeritage has to offer: bit.ly/Andrewgold. Here are your timestamps: 0:00 Carl Benjamin Highlights 1:00 We’ve Always Had Authoritarianism 3:00 The Interpretation of Inciting Hatred 5:00 Humza Yousaf’s Hate Bill Irony 8:30 It’s the Ideology (RAF Diversity Quotas) 12:00 Not Enough ‘Brown’ People at the BBC 14:20 The Death of Colour Blindness & Hunt for Nazis 16:30 Communism: Fabian Society 19:30 Mao & How Critical Race Theory Started 22:20 Do Left & Right Still Mean Anything? 25:30 When Authoritarianism is…Good 27:00 The Town Where The Bears Ate Pets 28:30 Tommy Robinson & Katie Hopkins 32:10 Islam vs British Ethnic Groups 35:10 Decent vs Indecent People (And Keir Starmer) 37:00 English as an Ethnicity Debate 40:30 Ethnicity is Subjective & Abstract 42:30 Is Andrew English? 45:30 The King Who Forced Ethnicities to Mix 48:10 How to Trick a Woke Person 50:30 The Unbearable Lightness of Nazism 53:30 Absolute Equality Not A Good Thing 55:30 Health Care Debate 58:00 Fairness Debate 1:01:30 Could Charity Work? 1:04:30 Things Were Better (Or Were They?) 1:06:30 Gay Debate 1:09:30 The World Hates Children 1:12:00 The Newspapers Colluding Against Elon Musk 1:15:30 The Majority Non-English in the UK 1:17:30 What is the Far Right? What is Racist? 1:22:00 Another Heretics Carl Benjamin Admires

[@____uncompetative]

Well I won't be watching this given its patently absurdly racist clickbait title.

[@matfhju]

@____uncompetative. What exactly is rasist about the title of this video?

[@afuzzycreature8387]

@@____uncompetative explain what's racist about it?

[@____uncompetative]

@@matfhju Learn to spell.

[@____uncompetative]

@@afuzzycreature8387 Learn to Capitalise your sentences if you expect anyone to respond to them.

[@cheechalker8430]

If I become a Chinese citizen, I don’t become Chinese ethnically Not too tough to figure out

[@bieituns]

Yes, if a Siberian Tiger is born in Africa, it doesn't suddenly become an African lion.

[@Vikinglawson]

Even if you were born in China, then had a child in China, you would never be Chinese and wouldn’t ever get a Chinese passport either and neither would your child.

[@peterraab3411]

People that Move to an Area to TAKE OVER and show distance fir the people already living their is an Invading Force

[@philiprowney]

Born in England to 2 Irish parents. Raised in C of E schools, went to Catholic church until I was a confirmed Atheist [ about 8 ]. I say I'm English and Irish. I prefer Britain to British though. [ Britain is just 'from the island' ] I used to say to people saying I'm British, _"Is a Dog born in a stable a Horse?"_

[@Vikinglawson]

@@cheechalker8430 and you can’t become a Chinese citizen, ever

[@Rekaert]

I don't understand why when someone says 'ethnically British' people become nervous and start to question if it's a thing. Those very same people would not question for a second if someone mentioned ethnically Japanese, or ethnically Indian, ethnically Polynesian, but the moment someone says ethnically British or worse, ethnically English, all of a sudden they pretend like they don't know what's meant by that.

[@machtnichtsseimann]

That's the net effect of deeper shaming of European ( "White" ) ancestry and/or the West through Leftist propaganda. Anyone of English ( or American or Canadian of European bloodlines, or anyone with white skin tone, at minimum ) ethnicity captured and overcome with this White Shame must consciously choose to break out of it which includes the risk of others ( of all stripes ) intimidating such a person to shut up, remain self-hating, and compliant like a sheep ( to the slaughter ).

[@raymondturner3952]

Very true, its just another one of their low IQ tactics. They suddenly know exactly who we are when they want to blame us for something.

[@raymondturner3952]

Isn't it funny that they suddenly know who we are when they want to blame us for something.

[@buglepong]

well mr benjamin explained it, its not rational and that goes both ways

[@JWSoul]

Hate to say it, but it is an eraser. It's ok to hate the white man. Sad really and racist.

[@evolassunglasses4673]

The English are an ETHNIC GROUP and this is our ancestral homeland.

[@CardinalNous]

Yes. And having more kids is a MUST as well as defending the home

[@trevormcdonald385]

Leave Australia, Canada and USA than we can have a conversation about ancestral land

[@bobhill4364]

@@trevormcdonald385 Leave it to what? No one wants to see that. Certainly not the millions of others that fled their homelands for a better life

[@CardinalNous]

@@trevormcdonald385 no

[@trevormcdonald385]

@@bobhill4364 it’s not your ancestral land right? So leave

[@bieituns]

George Orwell and Rudyard Kipling were born in India but no one would ever call them Indian.

[@waiki8223]

I might sound heretic but Jesus Christ was born in a barn... And he's our Savior!

[@wobblybobengland]

@@waiki8223 you saying India is a barn? Racist!

[@sandersson2813]

​@@waiki8223 why bring up a fictional character?

[@emily-ti4vy]

@@sandersson2813um no, he was a real person. You might not believe he was the son of god, but that he lived is historically indisputable.

[@sandersson2813]

@@emily-ti4vy I don't deny there may have been a man called jesus, but there is no contemporary evidence he existed and absolutely no evidence whatsoever that any of the stories attributed to him are true. There is absolutely no evidence of divinity, resurrection or miracles and furthermore no one who met Jesus could be arsed to write about him, so at best all you have is an ordinary man called jesus, and due to that, so bloody what? If he was so bloody amazing, why couldn't anyone be bothered to document it? How convenient.

[@Chirimbolos88]

Carl is right 100%. about being 'English'. I can live in Japan 20 years, but I will never be Japanese. Ethnicity and ancestry is what defines being a person from a particular tribe. I was born abroad in another continent. Married an Engish person. I have lived in England for 50 years amongst English people. I don't consider myself English, but 'culturally English to the core'. In a war, I would fight for England.

[@joer9156]

There are not "many" non-White people who have been here for centuries. A very small population of Jews, a handful of Chinese. In 1951 Britain was 99.9% White British.

[@AAWT]

Spot on. There also were a handful of children of high-ranking/privileged colonial families who came to England temporarily to study during the Imperial age - basically the sons/daughters of the rulers of British colonies, who often were local royalty/elite (but they usually went back after finishing education - like Gandhi).

[@gideonhorwitz9434]

And they tired their best to integrate and respect the local culture these new Europeans do not

[@grannyannie2948]

This is happening everywhere though. It was 1986 before I saw anyone who was not of European or Aboriginal heritage in Australia. Now according to advertisements there are no Whyte people left

[@JackRichardsonM8]

​@grannyannie2948 Still doing this?

[@grannyannie2948]

@@JackRichardsonM8 Absolutely, according to advertisements we don't exist.

[@clare2401]

Andrew. I don't get to move to Benidorm at the age of 18, work in a bar, and suddenly, 20 years later, im Spanish. Speaking the language and knowing where the local library is doesn't make you that thing. When it comes to every other country, people seem to grasp that concept, but for England, apparently, it's completely different. We're just supposed to accept everyone and pretend.

[@millosolo]

When you move from one region to another you also don't loose all of your accent or your childhood friends or the memories of that special place.

[@____uncompetative]

@andrewgoldheretics is a racist.

[@joshuaallen7171]

If you had made an effort to learn the language, I don't think any normal person would care if you're Spanish or not. And over time you would just blend in. If you had children there, they would be Spanish. That's how integration happens. But you see a 2nd-generation brown person in the UK and think they can never 'blend in'. That's a problem

[@MidnightInExile]

He'll never understand that. It is against his own (((cultural paradigm))), that is to conceal, infest, subvert, and then drain.

[@sykram]

Our traitor politicians in Ireland are pushing the same lie, that once you set foot in Ireland, you are somehow now ethnic Irish also. But They all call these plantation single aged fighting males, an ethnic minority, even though they number in the billions in there respective home countries. The real minority is the actual ethnic Irish who now number less than 4 million inhabitants in there own homeland. And now make up only 75%of population..our traitor bastards in power are actively engaged in ethnocide of there own native peoples. There is a growing hatred amongst the native Irish people of these despicable self hating Irish traitor bastards, that is going to eventually Ignite. I have more disgust and hatred now for the Irish ruling class than I ever had for the occupying British. At least they were an enemy that United us. These traitorous dogs are experts at dividing us, they have all become legitimate insane, woke Marxist deviants, hell bent on holding on to power at all costs. And if they get there way it will soon be illegal and a jailable offence for me or any native Irish person to publicly or privately express there disgust and hatred for these traitor dogs . No time ever in history have the good guys censored speech.

[@tishgreene8906]

I was born in 1956 and lived in what was called an overflow area of London. If I was walking the same way as someone carrying a heavy bag but I wasn’t actually known to them, I had been taught to offer help. We stood up for people older than ourselves to give them our seat. My Nan would say when I was leaving for home ‘Get someone to see you across the road’. Council houses like the one I lived in were looked after as if they were ‘your own’. Yes Carl, it was a kinder and better place to live.

[@frenchenstein]

Born in '55 (December), I have exactly the same memories of being helpful, observant and useful in day to day life. Wtf happened?

[@lookupverazhou8599]

It's almost like other races are racist.

[@kellynantonacci7885]

@@frenchensteinTV/movies/phones/social media. It’s always been progressively getting worse, but when you add the things above, it’s like putting all of the bad on steroids.

[@ROForeverMan]

Simps.

[@Britboy2877]

All the hate Carl got years ago and here we are today, wasn't wrong was he!

[@josephblue4135]

Many gay men & women do reproduce in various ways. Many straight peopledo not reproduce.

[@theorisoe3630]

Check out the video he did with Jared Taylor a few years ago and see how wrong he was

[@thesmirkinggrape]

He was wrong, check out his debate with Millennial Woes and Richard Spencer. He was very wrong and has come a long way.

[@thesmirkinggrape]

@@theorisoe3630 I think a lot of people are new to Carl, they missed everything from 2015-2019.

[@Fatb0ybadb0y]

@@theorisoe3630 I just went and watched that debate and I think Jared Taylor made flawed arguments. He spoke in favour of racial discrimination. He briefly mentioned the data on IQ differences between black and white americans, then tried to justify withholding votes from black people and forming white ethnocommunities in which white people were allowed to refuse service or employement to people on the basis of their skin colour. I know the data on racial IQ differences, and as ugly as it is, I don't believe it justifies racial discrimination in any way. Don't forget that IQ scores for all races are distributed on a bell curve, meaning that there are a significant number of black people who are smarter than the average white person. A correlation is not uniform and definitive across a group, and the sovereignty of the individual in a meritocracy is the cornerstone of a successful society.

[@natalieelizabeth7877]

So odd hearing Andrew pretend he has no ideal what an ethnicity is, when he talks about being over 90% Ashkenazi Jewish, that is an ethnicity. He also does not participate in English culture, like easter, Christmas and so on because Christian is interwoven with the culture of the UK. It is fine to be an immigrant and a citizen, but it is not OK to pretend there are no indigenous people of the UK. Meanwhile, in other countries of the common wealth the indigenous people get special rights and we are called colonizers and settlers, the double standards are so infuriating.

[@taniacummings9207]

Heads they win Tails we lose.

[@polvoazul]

I thought it was a fair point, he is giving space for the guest to expose his view.

[@polvoazul]

@@natalieelizabeth7877 Fair enough. I guess I prefer this style too, but then again Im just giving him the benefit of the doubt, as I think he (and most people) deserve it. He is not a dumb person.

[@polvoazul]

@@natalieelizabeth7877 I am sorry, looking back I realize I've approached your comment with hostility. Ironically I didn't give you the benefit of the doubt :) These sensitive topics get us worked up and a bit blind to reason. Have a good one!

[@notsocrates9529]

I do not trust him, but I enjoy his guests. His _Early Life_ still creates a lot of cognitive dissonance towards certain truths such as RaCiSm.

[@stevesandford1437]

The Nigerian mother of Kemi Badenoch came to the UK to birth her child on the NHS JUST SO her child would have British Citizenship... (Kemi's Nigerian parents had NEVER lived in the UK, never paid taxes, NOTHING!!!) Kemi Badenoch didn't return to the UK for 16 years. NOW she's eligible to be the leader of The Conservative Party. (As BRITISH as anybody else, we're informed...) xx xx SF

[@Chirimbolos88]

I agree. By law, you should have at least 2 generations behind in order to be allowed to have a political post that could potentially lead you to be Prime Minister of Britain. Same rubbish is happening in the US where a Somalian woman arrived in the US, and after only 10 years of living there, she became a Congress woman. She has zero allegiance to the US. She's a marxist of the worst kind. All she does is to lobby for Somalia and badmouth Donald Trump.

[@____uncompetative]

@andrewgoldheretics is a racist.

[@____uncompetative]

@@stevesandford1437 You sound racist. Please tell me that isn't the case.

[@pennybaker3572]

"Racist" is an amorphous term we've unnecessarily adopted from the European Union. 19:48 m​@@____uncompetative

[@acidtechno]

@@____uncompetativeand if it was a Russian? spy , plants are well documented. I think we are saying the system is open to abuse.

[@cagirl2220]

Everyone can agree who Germans or Scottish are but all of a sudden being English is questioned.

[@reezlaw]

Yeah but is it an ethnicity? It's a nationality for sure

[@haraldbredsdorff2699]

The German and the Scotts get the same bullshit in their home country. Most west Europeans countries have it after years of communist infiltration. But the quick test is easy. If you are asked "what are you?", the first thing you think, that is what you are. And if you ask any of the "new English", non of them will say English. They might say Pakistani-English, but that still mean they are not English, unless you think only "English" when asked. And same with any other group. It is why the African American is such a splitting name. Because, if they are American, they should just say American. But by adding African, they split away from the main culture and will always feel like outsiders. It is why communist supported the African American movement, they wanted to split America into groups that would be fighting. And, they seem to have succeeded.

[@cagirl2220]

@@reezlaw​​⁠of course it. The same way Scottish and Welsh are. In 23&Me English people would get Anglo-Saxon but from the exact part of England they come from.

[@cagirl2220]

@@haraldbredsdorff2699The migrants say British or Pakistani-British. Hardly ever English. The Greatest thing about England is that its language and culture took over the western world. The US, Canada, Australia, New Zealand. That is why no one feels sympathy for the English.

[@sirrathersplendid4825]

@@reezlaw- So, if it’s not an ethnicity, are families who’ve lived in England for centuries unique in the entire world in having no ethnicity? 😆🤣😂

[@shaulkramer7425]

All he wanted to do was play video games...

[@gjthomas9770]

I have been with chickswidicks. I'm telling you, it's the best. Once you chickswidicks , dat becomes ya picks ❤

[@nexiros]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/nJnInYareLCfg9Usi=KWPzasZ9pr9blmjJ

[@ItsGazareth]

He's not alone in that. Experienced my own untimely political awakening due to GamerGate.

[@Valoric]

We all did...

[@zxyatiywariii8]

Same

[@shaulkramer7425]

Sargon was right all along.

[@uk5g262]

Sargon has flipped flopped on his positions throughout the years. The only people to my knowledge who have remained consistent and correct in their predictions and who are being more and more popular as the years go on are the so called “white nationalists” that even people like sargon refuse to engage with.

[@____uncompetative]

@andrewgoldheretics is a racist.

[@AlbertKirilov]

Well spoken and intelligent person

[@Marinealver]

Being correct in assessments unfortunately doesn't grant to power to correct things.

[@KaptajnKaffe]

Well, he did an 180 on his previous close held ideas...

[@hayleylongster4698]

Carl is my long cool breeze on a horrible sticky day. I find him so comforting in these times of crisis and 'crisis'.

[@thermionic1234567]

Nice metaphor!

[@____uncompetative]

@andrewgoldheretics is a racist.

[@joshuataylor3550]

Pretty gay

[@damien_the_commentator]

Just want to say Andrew, Carl and other alternative media are doing the Lord's work. I can't remember the last time I watched the BBC or Sky News. Thank you for all your efforts and here's to both of your successes. 🍺

[@xmathmanx]

It is not clever to pay no attention to the mainstream

[@matfhju]

The mainstream in my cuntery is literally pushing pro Hamas and pro hasbola propaganda.

[@grannyannie2948]

​@@xmathmanxExactly you need to know the propaganda.

[@grannyannie2948]

Australia's Sky after Dark, is bearable, and you need to know the current propaganda.

[@VioletBagpipeSack-xf3ke]

@@grannyannie2948 The polarity between UK Sky and Sky Australia speaks volumes about mainstream media manipulation.

[@Electriclentilman]

English is an ethnicity. They are white , mostly north Western Europeans. It’s not complicated.

[@wobblybobengland]

I prefer 'sons of the greatest nation the world has known'

[@sandersson2813]

it isn't. It's a nationality. There is no Liechtenstein ethnicity for example

[@hardywatkins7737]

More precisely it's the anglo-saxon/britonic admixture Carl mentions. Most native English are between 20 and 40% anglosaxon and the rest predominantly britonic, or so called 'celtic'. It will vary from region to region and individual to individual but those stats provide an average, and i'm hearing that it's been roughly around that ratio for hundreds of years ... since like the 1300s. The English are anglo/britonic not anglo saxon, as you'd expect if you mix a bunch of northern germans with a bunch of britons ... simple breeding logic.

[@sandersson2813]

@@hardywatkins7737 Celtic is cultural, nothing more. There is no Celtic DNA for example and it has been extinct since the Romans

[@hardywatkins7737]

@@sandersson2813 It's just a descriptor but yes, that's why i say 'so called' celtic. How would you describe the ethinicty of the Welsh or Irish? Or the Scots for that matter? What names should we call these things?

[@bieituns]

Yes look at Riots in Leicester a couple of years ago over the cricket when India played Pakistan. Most of these people would be British citizens but clearly their loyalty is to India or Pakistan. I doubt you would see them rioting innthe street if England football team or even the cricket team got beat. They are clearly not British genetically or culturally.

[@chairmanmeow8388]

My mate is a copper in Leicester. I asked why they didn't just arrest everyone and deport them. They were explicitly told to treat it as a protest and not a riot. The two tier thing isn't new.

[@Morphstock]

A police officer in Leicester told me that trouble blew over very quickly then the media started reporting it which quickly fanned the flames. I've lived in Leicester for most of my life , that particular event was very unusual if not unique. I know a lot of Asian people here from both Indian and Pakistani backgrounds and I think to be honest you are just regurgitating stereotypes.

[@astrovarius543]

@@Morphstock The same police who don't enforce the law over non-british people because they're afraid of being called racist? Also, what stereotype? Name the stereotype being "regurgitated"

[@thecoops2329]

​@@Morphstock I also live in Lesta (unfortunately), and without wishing to be rude your talking out of your backside it's a disgusting Muhammadan shithole.

[@bieituns]

@@Morphstock Regurgitating stereotypes? So it was just my lying eyes again that saw them rioting over the cricket? Please stop with your gaslighting and trying to deny the undeniable, Im sick of you people, such manipulative deceitful liars.

[@colly7963]

Andrew, you are one of the best interviewers on youtube. You add to the conversation, ask pertinent questions, don't interrupt, and let your guests do most of the speaking. ❤

[@____uncompetative]

@andrewgoldheretics is a racist.

[@janice68329]

I love the conversations I am allowed to sit in on.... always interesting and gets me thinking in new ways. Viewing issues from a variety of perspectives is the way forward

[@123oddjobspurs]

Yes it’s so refreshing, Piers Morgan just shouts over the top of people and acts like a bully. Andrew is 100% a top interviewer 👍🏼 and my favourite.

[@suspiciousentity9305]

The perspective Carl laid out here couldn't be more eminently sensible and realistic about what human beings are like. Excellent episode.

[@deaconsyxx322]

This will be great! Andrew Gold - Heretics is the best and bravest thing on my newsfeed atm. I am very much your fan Andrew.

[@____uncompetative]

@andrewgoldheretics is a racist.

[@Nukestarmaster]

I am so sick and tired of people going "Why won't you think of the gays", I'm sorry but a relatively fringe fetish shouldn't be politically relevant.

[@Mason58654]

I’m surprised he didn’t bring up black people and women. 🤷‍♂️

[@joshuataylor3550]

It's safe for you to come out now. Be your true self before you die.

[@Nukestarmaster]

​@@joshuataylor3550 Wow, where have I heard that before, lol. The naughties called, they want their ad hominem back.

[@StarboyXL9]

Based

[@superdarklink]

​@@joshuataylor3550projection

[@horacecuffie4752]

I cannot undetstand how people do not understand the difference being a citizen of a country and be in an ethnic group.

[@stalwartteakettlepotato9879]

Because intertwining those two things became illegal after ww2.

[@KeldorDAntrell]

It's stupidity. It's very common. Too common, in fact. I'll go further: It's so common that our specie is likely to get destroyed by it.

[@SvendleBerries]

Its "Schrodingers Argument". Leftists use it all the time where they both understand and dont understand certain things depending on what the argument is. Like how one moment trans-women are real women, then suddenly they dont know what a woman even is. Its the same when it comes to white people. Everybody gets to have culture, ethnic backgrounds, ethnic history...except for white people. Thats also why _only_ white countries get to have "diversity". Oh, theres another one: Colonization is bad when white people do it, but good when non-white people are flooding western countries completely overloading the system and causing chaos.

[@lilmoyinyang5812]

Carl is one of the only people who has stuck by Tommy Robinson from the beginning.For that he has to be respected 👊🏻

[@evolassunglasses4673]

Tommy supports an ethnostate for Israel but not for England....

[@lilmoyinyang5812]

I agree.I am totally against Tommy’s views on Isreal and his support for anti ethno-nationalism but you have to except the lad has balls and he is moving in the right direction

[@MCNOISE666]

​@@evolassunglasses4673I have a lot of time for you, but this is the same tiresome perfectionist bs. We've only just started the fight-back, ffs. You're not going to get the perfect situation overnight. This is simplistic stuff, mate, come on.

[@_nebulousthoughts]

​@evolassunglasses4673 you haven't listened to him much in long form have you?

[@EM-cg4iy]

@@evolassunglasses4673how is it an ethnostate if fully 20% of the citizens are Arabs?

[@reneroo277]

I was lucky - my history teacher, Mr Wilson, loved Russian history. That's what we did in our GCSE year, from the massacre of the Russian royal family, through Lenin, Trotsky and Stalin to what was the present time, the 90s. I'm so grateful to him. When you understand that history, you understand a lot about the appalling behaviour we currently see courtesy of the woke mind virus.

[@Madonnalitta1]

I've been a bibliophile since I was young, I caught the bug of my nan. The Russian classics were the first serious books that I sunk my teeth into. I'll never forget buying War and Peace in Waterstones when I was 13, the cashier said "don't you think you'd like something lighter?". I took great pleasure in returning two weeks later to tell him how much I enjoyed it. It made me happy and sad, and sometimes damn uncomfortable. I found Dostoevsky next.

[@Chirimbolos88]

A non woke history teacher is worth his weight in gold.

[@Chirimbolos88]

​@@Madonnalitta1Well done you!

[@arnoldziffel4943]

Thank you Sargon for being one of the first who was sounding the alarm.

[@____uncompetative]

@andrewgoldheretics is a racist.

[@alanbstard4]

The one who was right was and is Millennial Woes now on rumble and odysee

[@Sentinel82]

​@@alanbstard4 Nah

[@Sentinel82]

​@@alanbstard4 Nah

[@alanbstard4]

@@Sentinel82 true

[@GrandHeresiarch]

The truth is the battle was lost decades ago. Focus on survival as long as you can. All the best!

[@angelmessenger8240]

People are allowed their opinions even if it upsets others. Where has our backbone gone?

[@Sentinel82]

The problem comes when their ideology can't stand up to criticism and scrutiny.

[@YorshZed]

Yes, but they prohibit free speech so we can do that.

[@olibertosoto5470]

My generation tried, failed and eventually grew out of a "wokeness" type of ideology - the "love" generation, the "I'm ok, you're ok, everybody is ok" generation. The disaster of the 60s and 70s hippie communes was a rude awakening to the realities of applicable life. Social media is the big problem now - it makes it easy to be ideological as hell without personally experiencing the real world implications of your "perfect world" dreams. So then, the problem is that other people, not involved in your ideology, will end up paying dearly for your dream. In my time, those implementing their ideology had to personally deal with the consequences - now, those implementing their ideologies can do so far removed from the consequences - like modern drone warfare or a computer game from the living room couch.

[@ChristineMeyer-hs9rg]

Yes that was contrived social engineering as well. They had a lot of youth to play with and the mind control was the same. In the Universities, education, films, music, fashion AND to reject traditional values and a general disrespect for parental authority and influence. Exactly the same formula. This time round it is from a distance and from people who will not directly experience or be harmed by it. Champagne socialists and newly coined "luxury beliefs". Ironic that the boomer generation are blamed for much when they fell for the same pumped out propaganda that the young are falling for now. It's those in power pulling the strings that need to be held accountable. They are very good at getting people to blame each other and NOT THEM.

[@LabelsAreMeaningless]

Ironically, if the hippies were around today, they'd be labelled as far-right. Everyone anti-war and love your neighbour, is labelled that way. They were very live and let live which is closer to Libertarian than what the current woke are.

[@3nertia]

All merely symptoms of capitalism ...

[@olibertosoto5470]

@@3nertia I lived under communism, I escaped. I now see 3 generations of those who live under it and are allowed to travel - the symptoms are shocking. I'll take capitalism with all it's imperfections and symptoms any day without hesitation.

[@3nertia]

@@olibertosoto5470 No you didn't. You lived under capitalist dictators claiming to be communist. You'll take capitalism because you were never actually given a choice rofl

[@exebit9366]

Even as a person who grew up on the Left, maybe even Far Left, always found Carl to be reasonable and balanced. 30 years ago he would have been a centre leftist.

[@robertheritage-i8h]

Saying Islam has anything in common with peace is the stupidest thing a person can say

[@adriadelafuente3648]

Saying a major religion is only warlike because of the 20th century ideological capture of all religions, is the most jewish thing a person can say. I dont have a problem with muslims that stay in their country. I have a problem with idiots who come to Europe and behave like degenerates, be them muslim or christian.

[@nothing-jl2dz]

when i hear religion of peace it's always in sarcasm

[@kbaker9804]

This show just gets better and better with every interview. Andrew and his guests are performing a public service.

[@lolly9080]

All this woke , cancel culture, etc is all coming out of Hollywood and right now Hollywood is about to crumble

[@doetodeer]

You think it's too late for them to correct course? I've been wondering about this. What replaces it? I know we have streaming and online content, but a lot of people still like to go to the movies (as proven on the rare occasion that Hollywood produce something that's not total trash)

[@CurtisJeffries-cd5vu]

​@doetodeer anything can happen I guess. but, I mean, they LITERALLY burned down their own industry. I mean, all this sj stuff, it's suppose to bring us a better world, but wen u watch it, it's some of the most mean spirited, off putting stuff. don't see how this helps anyone. then with prices n Cali, they gotta subsidies EVERYTHING out of state to shoot stuff. it's Goin the way of 1930s radio.

[@TheOriginalFishPond]

No its not. Its much deeper than that. Hollywood is downstream and just a symptom.

[@dantespimp]

Sadly, it's not Hollywood we should be worried about: it's public education institutions. Feminist-critic Camille Paglia correctly predictably all this marxist pro-communist SJW crap would passed down to us from the higher educations' pipeline. She explained a lotta free-thinkers during Vietnam War either burnt themselves out on drugs, got drafted, or didn't bother investing their knowledge/wisdom in higher institutions. As a result, this left behind a lot of brown-nosers/ass-kissers and posers who weaseled their way up the ladder, eventually becoming in charge of government programs like 'No Child Left Behind'. They created the 'participation trophy' era of the late 80s/90s era. And since then, it's only gotten worst. It's no longer isolated to colleges/universities, but now at the elementary level. It's actually insidious. These radical activists are growing their seeds at the CHILD level, just so that by the time these kids reach adulthood, they've fully been initiated into the cult and are passing on this woke ideology onto the NEXT generation with less resistance - all while waiting for the older generations to die out. 'Safe spaces', 'trigger warnings', and gender ideology... It ALL comes from these education institutions, which THEN get picked up by Hollywood (since executives, actors, writers, directors all come from this places). So even if Hollywood crumbles (which is already happening), this bullshit is still going to be fed down our throats, mostly through DEI implemented measures (which is already happening). Of course, DEI will be rebranded as something else while still retaining its core concept (since many people are onto DEI). We need to go after the education systems and hold them accountable for pushing these agendas. The rest will fall into place.

[@BlueInk912]

No Oxbridge intellectuals/academics involved? ? Mmmm

[@ricktusgrin906]

When called FAR RIGHT, ask what it means to be centrist right?

[@mardyroux8136]

Yes.

[@Max_Mustermann]

A centrist is neither right nor left, so "centrist right" is an oxymoron. A more fitting term would be "moderate right".

[@____uncompetative]

@andrewgoldheretics is a racist.

[@Sentinel82]

Or ask what far left is. That usually stumps them too because they don't realize how far the Overton window has shifted left. 😂

[@nisonatic]

A center-right person (in practice) is someone who is allowed to pretend to be right-wing. They accept the left's framing of every issue, and cave the moment the left gets offended.

[@AndyJarman]

"Anti-racism" is a convenient mechanism for the police. They don't have the ability to quell unrest from the immigrant groups. The indigenous British are far easier to control having been raised to expect fair treatment.

[@Madonnalitta1]

Bingo. We'll comply, and the coppers know it.

[@ComplainingIsRecreation]

They DID have the ability, the politicians systematically undermined that ability from 1997 onward.

[@dallassukerkin6878]

I do have to say that it is both painful and glorious to see Andrew struggling with the realisation that some of his dearly held views are rooted in misconceptions if not outright falsehoods. Painful in the sense that it hurts to see someone so clearly intelligent clinging almost desperately to the 'nice' rich Middle Class sensibilities he evidently has. Glorious because he *is* standing and taking that pain in an attempt to see if what he thinks is right is indeed right. Credit to him but it does make me wince at times with the 'lovie' stances, especially given that he is quite well travelled and knows full well that some things that are being inflicted on us here do not occur elsewhere in the world :chuckles:

[@Chirimbolos88]

??????? Too many words, little clarity.

[@____uncompetative]

@andrewgoldheretics is a racist.

[@None-y2f]

First time watching him. He seems like a leftist.

[@dallassukerkin6878]

@@None-y2f Like thankfully many these days he is realising that the political shoes he has worn for many years no longer fit his feet.

[@BabyDogOfJustice]

It easy to argue ethnicity. If a mouse is born in stable does that make him a horse?

[@____uncompetative]

@andrewgoldheretics is a racist.

[@Sentinel82]

Too dissimilar. More like "if a mouse is born in a sewer does that make him a rat?" 😂

[@Sannidor]

@@Sentinel82 IT Crowd rat-mouse bit was underrated.

[@jacobesterson]

@@Sentinel82 All rats are mice from a phylogenetic and taxological standpoint. Muridae, the largest family of rodents, comes from the Latin "mus", meaning "mouse". I get what you mean though lol.

[@kathrineici9811]

@jacobesterson Mice (mus musculus) and rats (rattus norvegicus) are completely separate species. They’re even farther apart than we are from chimps, and they can’t breed with one another. Rats will predate on mice when they get the opportunity to.

[@AnAn___]

British people in India were strongly encouraged to stay in India after 1947 and become Indian citizens. Many did. And these have long been an important part of the Indian elite. In India they (and mixed British / Indian people) are collectively called Anglo Indians. And many are still part of the Indian elite and highly respected. Gerald Gibbs was Air Marshall (commander in chief) of the Indian Air Force 1951 to 1954.

[@streglof]

I think Carl refers to a time when you could leave you front door unlocked without worrying about intruders. Such a time existed until people started arriving from underdeveloped countries.

[@loveoffilm4327]

Thanks!

[@donaldfeger91]

If you say something in public and someone don't like you can go to jail? That's kinda extreme dontcha think?

[@TheUltimegaMan]

Only if you’re a certain ethnic group that’s native. When other ethnic groups do the same the people that complain about it also go to jail.

[@astrovarius543]

@@TheUltimegaMan being white is a (social) crime in Britain it seems

[@Durzo1259]

Not just in public. In England and Scotland you can go to prison for 5 or 7 years, respectively, for saying something "hateful" in private to your friends.

[@doublesh92]

That's insane! ​@@Durzo1259

[@____uncompetative]

@andrewgoldheretics is a racist.

[@hismajesty6272]

Carl’s criticism of Liberalism woke me up to reality.

[@carolynhague7199]

I confirm 60s 70s were wonderful even with powercuts...candlelit nights were fab

[@johnhall-n3z]

I doubt whether your parents liked the 70s much, though. Perhaps YOU were ok with no school two out of five days . And your mum would still manage to make you Smash mashed potato and baked beans while you watched Top Of The Pops with (Sir) Jimmy Savile on telly . Meanwhile your dad was almost socially compelled to grow sideburns and your families Austin Cambridge was broken ( again) . The PM at the time, Ted Heath, was sodomising young boys, killing them, and then throwing them off his boat . Dont talk PuPu . :)). Fewer Pakis though............. Ok . I see your point.

[@otbovertheboard]

How was it for Irish & Black folks?

[@sirrathersplendid4825]

@@otbovertheboard- pretty much the same as it was for the English urban poor. Life was still quite grim in the cities after the war - for everyone regardless of ethnicity. That era didn’t really end until the mid 70s.

[@VioletBagpipeSack-xf3ke]

@@otbovertheboard the economic migrants did fine, they sent money overseas, but who cares?

[@antihebrew]

@@otbovertheboard Who... cares?🤔

[@Obsidiansoul74]

40:30 thank god he said the difference between cultural and ethnic heritage. Anyone can be accepted as a English citizen an d live in a culturally English way. But they are still ethnically what they are born.

[@Durzo1259]

According to the dictionary, Ethnicity: "a social group that shares a common and distinctive culture, religion, language, or the like."

[@reactiondavant-garde3391]

@@Durzo1259 Ethnos, the original term anyway, imply blood relationships/heritage as well. Ethnicity in this sense, and the sense Sargon use it, is a mix of culture and heritage. As example no religion make ethnos, just because I as ahungarian became a practicier of judaism will not make me jewish the same way you will not be english just because you can talk english. Ethnicity is not one thing but a higher order thing composed by lower order things.

[@sleepingphoenix1281]

There's no such thing as an English citizen. Only British. English is an ethnicity indigenous to Britain.

[@____uncompetative]

@andrewgoldheretics is a racist.

[@sonicluffypucca96]

​@reactiondavant-garde3391 I think it's more fair to describe Judaism as a civilizations

[@kingclover1395]

I understand what he means about society being warmer in the past despite the advantages we have now. I'm in my 60s and gay, and I felt more comfortable in society back in the 70s and 80s than I do now. I always felt I was treated very well by most people, and there wasn't all this political baggage about identity that there is now, at least in America, where I live. Something just feels all wrong now, in a way that it didn't before. Relationships between people are not better than they used to be, which is what we're supposed to believe. All of the supposed social progress that we've allegedly made just feels phony and artificial. Even as a gay person, I felt more a part of society back then than I do now. And I felt more positively towards it. Almost everybody I know who's my age feels this way. It makes you wonder what we're doing wrong.

[@ChristineMeyer-hs9rg]

I'm not gay but lived through those decades too and l couldn't agree more. I think we already dealt with the issues and the same for feminism - then after resolution they were hi jacked and repurposed for political ideology. Nothing to do with the benefit of the people involved or anybody else. I wish more people would speak up about this. I call it exploitation because it is. Thanks for posting because if l say it, it doesn't hold the same weight. I do push back on the so called "feminism" which obviously isn't in women's or anybody else's best interest either!

[@CMA418]

As a gay child of the 80s in the US, you and I had a very different experience. It was not safe for me. I'm surprised I'm still here. IMO, relationships are not better because very few people have an interest in making relations better, least of all those in media who have a financial interest in highlighting the worst in people; this channel is a case in point. "Be afraid...of THEM!", "Be angry…at THEM!", "We are doing the good and noble work." 💸 Pick just about any channel and you'll likely find most of the comments are in agreement. Echo chambers are profitable. Healthy debate with nuance and good faith disagreement is not desired nor welcome.

[@Madonnalitta1]

I'm English, and I feel the same.

[@Sneakyhorse12]

We stopped treating people as individuals and many people have been hit over the head with treat them special , they re gay or immigrants or this or that, I am 62 , grew up in rural Australia, I remember there was little racism, and we were watching the gay parade on tv and the gay guy on whose being served and laughing along with and not at. I now just resent anyone making a point of their sexuality or any other victim status, I had a shitty childhood at times , I need to spend my pity on myself , and treat myself well, I can’t afford the mental energy to feel sorry and charity towards people who are usually doing better than me, it’s a more selfish mindset than the one I had as a child , but I’ve learned over the years that the birds who are already strong , chirp the loudest and get more food, and the quiet birds can’t and they die of starvation; I think people just want to avoid engaging others with genuine interest for fear that any sign of interest will encourage the fat birds to chirp, cause we don’t want to feel the resentment of being used up, I know that’s how I feel anyway.

[@____uncompetative]

@andrewgoldheretics is a racist.

[@sweetfreedom999]

Wow, I didn't think I would like this, but it was an amazing interview, and I understand Tommy much better now. He has evolved as an activist but never wavered from his original beliefs and message. He's still brave and cares about British girls but approaching it differently, which is great. Was in tears at the end, his Mum sounds a good, kind woman, and I see where Tommy gets his passion from. He cares, thank goodness someone does.

[@lankyboy90]

Being 6'5", the part where you talk about being tall, really hits home. Tall people get discriminated against all the time. Public transport is a prime example. I can't actually fit in the regular seats on a train or bus. I can't get my knees behind the seat in front, so i need one of the seats where they face each other or one of the "priority" seats for disabled or pregnant women. Will anyone give one of those seats up for me? Of course not, because they just see someone who is able bodied. I can't help my height.

[@joer9156]

As a Jew, Andrew should be able to understand what Carl is saying. Caleb, the hero of Judah, was not an Israelite by birth. He was a Kenizzite.

[@hismajesty6272]

Are you religiously Jewish or just ethnically so? Asking because of the Jesus pfp

[@VesnaVK]

​@@hismajesty6272 by saying as a Jew, joer is referring to Andrew.

[@Madonnalitta1]

He's an atheist, perhaps he doesn't know the stories from his Book.

[@filled_soda]

He understands.

[@simonrae3048]

They should call it inciting 'dislike' . Inciting hatred is another level and anyone with a degree of common sense can tell the difference

[@ElBromoHojo]

Of course it's their own behavior that incites it, not pointing it out...

[@jimbo4375]

It's absolutely insane that people were pleading guilty to inciting racial hatred for venting online. I don't believe many of them actually intended to incite anything, why are the solicitors not telling them to plead not guilty!?

[@SvendleBerries]

Because the solicitors are in on it.

[@annal2740]

Kids were never the centre piece in British society. We had adult only pubs and restaurants, and kids were expected to be second to other adults. We are much more child centric now than in living memory.

[@AlexanderJonesYoutube]

Benjamin’s difficulty regarding the description of ethnicity, culture, and identity can be clarified by examining the ethnogenesis of the English people, which illustrates how distinct groups merged to form a shared identity over time. The development of the Anglo-Saxon identity in early medieval Britain serves as an excellent example of the complexities involved in group identity formation. After the Roman Empire withdrew from Britain in the early 5th century, the region experienced an influx of various Germanic tribes, including the Angles, Saxons, and Jutes. These groups, originating from areas such as northern Germany and Denmark, brought with them their own languages, social customs, and political structures. Their arrival coincided with the weakening of Romano-British society, leading to a period of significant cultural and demographic transformation. The Germanic tribes did not merely dominate or displace the native Britons; instead, they engaged in a multifaceted process of cultural exchange. Some Britons, particularly those in the southeast, were displaced and migrated to regions like Cornwall, Wales, and Brittany, where they preserved their distinct cultural identities. Meanwhile, those who stayed behind in areas controlled by the Anglo-Saxons gradually adapted to the new societal norms. This transformation was neither immediate nor uniform but occurred through multiple stages of interaction, conflict, and eventual integration. The Britons who remained in Anglo-Saxon territories faced a gradual process of assimilation. Over time, they began to adopt the Germanic language (Old English), participate in Germanic burial practices, and follow the social customs of the Anglo-Saxons. Archaeological evidence supports this, showing instances where Britons and Anglo-Saxons were buried together, indicating a degree of social cohesion. In other areas, however, they continued to be buried separately, suggesting that the integration process varied across regions and communities. The point at which these Britons could be considered "Anglo-Saxon" occurred when they were no longer viewed as outsiders by the larger society. This shift likely happened when the Britons adopted enough elements of the new culture and established familial ties through intermarriage, leading to social acceptance. It’s important to note that in some areas, Britons might have been considered part of the Anglo-Saxon group even before intermarriage took place, while in other cases, the recognition may have followed such unions. Either way, reaching the point of intermarriage would have served as an accelerant to any forming social cohesion. This historical process provides valuable insights into modern discussions of ethnicity, culture, and identity. For instance, the Cornish people today present a parallel, where some see themselves as English while others maintain a distinct Cornish identity. This mirrors the past when Britons who remained in Anglo-Saxon territories gradually became part of the Anglo-Saxon group as they adopted the new culture and language, despite their distinct origins. Identity formation is not merely a matter of adopting a different language or set of customs; it involves a mutual willingness to accept one another as part of the same group. In the early medieval period, Britons became part of the Anglo-Saxon community not just by adopting its culture but by being recognized and accepted as members of that group. To address Andrew’s question of whether he is English, the answer is yes, just as the Britons who remained in Anglo-Saxon territories became part of the Anglo-Saxon identity over time. If the group you wish to be a part of accepts you as a member, then you are part of that group, regardless of any ethnic heritage. Identity is defined by a combination of shared values, social acceptance, and mutual recognition. Shared ethnicity may make it easier to view each other as part of the same group, primarily because it's difficult to "other" someone with shared heritage. However, that does not mean shared ethnicity is the only way to become part of a group. The Britons’ integration into the Anglo-Saxon society was a process of adoption, adaptation, and mutual recognition. Although shared heritage can facilitate acceptance, it is the willingness of both sides to redefine their group boundaries and embrace common values that ultimately determines whether someone is accepted into a new identity.

[@sonicluffypucca96]

Even the Bulgarians of Bulgaria are descendants of the mixing of Thracians, Turkish Bulgars, and Slavic migrations over the course of centuries

[@sethd.8381]

On the topic of ethnicity, I think the best test is "Do the people of that ethnicity see you as part of that ethnicity?" For example, I were to move to Vietnam, start speaking perfect Vietnamese, wear Vietnamese clothing, eat Vietnamese food, and fully adopt that culture, would the Vietnamese people call me part of their tribe? Same thing with England. Do the native English people consider you to be English?

[@jacobesterson]

Ethnos, which is the root of ethnicity, means "nation," "tribe," and "race". I'd welcome someone who comes to my country and fully intigrates, but that doesn't make them ethnically English. Culturally? Yes. Ethnically? No.

[@mikeyo1234]

I predicted the unrest a year or two before it happened. I could sense the tension and anger on the streets.

[@markwalters2927]

What an honest, interesting & intelligent discussion. Thank-you.

[@ellenoneill7853]

Some of us are ethnically English and others could be considered culturally English.

[@____uncompetative]

@andrewgoldheretics is a racist.

[@NigelPickering]

I think Carl needs to reevaluate his definitions. He’d do well to consider those two terms more carefully. TBF, it is the only thing he isn’t immaculate in with his thinking.

[@BadMotivator66]

@@NigelPickering i think he's very clear. english is a tribe. you join a tribe by birth or acceptance. ie be native english or can integrate-and be accepted- but english is an ethnonym and to be allowed to live amongst the tribe is a privilege, not a right.

[@jacobesterson]

@@BadMotivator66 "English" as a word on it's own can mean two different things. You can be ethnically English without being culturally English, and you can be culturally English without being ethnically English. The tribe is both.

[@BadMotivator66]

@@jacobesterson no. you join the tribe through ethnicity or can be adopted. english is an ethnicity. a dog born in a stable remains a dog.

[@jarofawesome4621]

14:00 it's even worse than them not being considerate back. It's a net negative because by now they are also actively insulting the people attempting to be considerate, effectively spitting on the person holding the door open for them.

[@davidbuderim2395]

Public health service is an insurance scheme where it is mandatory to pay the premiums through taxation. It's free at the point of service. Private health insurance allows you to pay for a faster and better service if you can afford it and want it. Australia has a good balance of public and private health. I think it's a big mistake to restrict private health or not use it onideological grounds when you can afford it.

[@jaredadams7888]

I'm always blown away that people can think completely differently about something so simple. I would have never guessed someone couldn't fathom what an ethnicity is.

[@longgone6100]

What an interesting conversation, i'm going to have to listen to this two or three times to bookmark the ideas in my head and think them through... thank you for this introduction to Carl Andrew :)

[@rongike]

people need to start employing their right to not get offended by what other people say

[@MCNOISE666]

They do it on purpose.

[@rongike]

@@MCNOISE666 because they refuse to look within to find what's actually causing their misery, so they seek for an external reason to validate it

[@ChristineMeyer-hs9rg]

Narcissism and power.

[@icarusjumped2719]

But then you don't get your victim points.

[@Madonnalitta1]

Offense is taken, not given. Eff them!

[@s3any1977]

This will be a good one 👍

[@____uncompetative]

@andrewgoldheretics is a racist.

[@andymester9661]

If you don't have English blood you're not English you can be a naturalised British citizen with an English accent.

[@Mark.James.]

"The UK used to be like the Shire in The Lord of The Rings" - one of the oddest and most revealing statements I think Ive heard CB make.

[@avengemybreath3084]

That’s literally what Tolkien was portraying. The English countryside - an idealized version. Even today, the English countryside is like a ferrytale to the rest of the world. But not for much longer.

[@jiminverness]

20:57 _"Infiltrated is not the right word" Try *"infested".*

[@icarusjumped2719]

Infected. It's a virus.

[@smelltheglove2038]

What's up with your avatar? You haven't yet realized that it's all a scam?

[@jiminverness]

@@smelltheglove2038 What is it you think is "all a scam?"

[@smelltheglove2038]

@@jiminverness the entirety of the conflict. The fact NATO started it, the funding, the theft, the idea that the US isn't involved. Basically all of it,. really.

[@jiminverness]

@@smelltheglove2038 What do you suggest should be done?

[@stevepearce7032]

Carl's explanation of English as an ethnicity is almost spot on. Only thing I would add to it is the distinction between being English (an ethnicity), Ethnically British (English, Welsh, Scots, NI), a British subject (commonwealth/empire ties), and a British citizen (ethnicity does not matter). What we are living under is the intentional destruction of the difference between a British Citizen and the ethnically British to justify mass immigration and prevent distinction and removal of foreigners.

[@artlein]

Thank you! Well said and understood at a glance. 🙏❤🌻

[@chief_snowman]

Andrew's entire line of questioning about ethnicity is wild to me. Does he really not understand this concept? It's a revelation that English ethnicity exists? It is insane that any of this even needs to be explained. It's obvious.

[@millosolo]

He's j you know. They tend not to understand other ethnicities...

[@darkdawnbringer]

He views us all as gentiles... black, white, english, ugandan, all the same to them...

[@Nathanaelelliott]

Authoritarianism is something that all of us paying attention for years have known was coming but I think it still shocks us when we see it happening because in the west we are so used to a somewhat calm world growing up. Its one of those things you see everyday but still cant imagine your own people actually following through with and that will be a wrong assumption. Whats just as shocking is i grew up with a ton of friends who were politically active and intelligent yet i turned out to be one of the only ones who still is. Ive been warning them for years and lost almost every one of them. Even when they literally see the problem in front of them they deny it harder and cling to the mass delusion. You do get radicalized but not in the way people think. You just become willing to hold to actual principles and you start to realize all these people who are made to look evil in our societies are a lot of times the very people that could save the country. Its why they are attacked so badly. Because they actually want merit, responsibility, and people to acknowledge a problem. Everythings changed. I grew up a teenager who always protested war like the iraq war. I went to all the occupy protests and those views of mine have not changed. I always was against racism of any kind. I was a liberal then and today im called a far right white supremacist. Its been this way longer than most know as a lot of people are just now experiencing this when ive been dealing with it for 15 years. Either way i wouldnt take anything back cuz its better than being ignorant.

[@lisaminnikin7009]

Same boat!! Many friends think I've lost my mind while they're still reading and 100% believing everything in the Guardian. A few have scolded / lectured me like an errant ignorant child which is pretty breathtaking. They genuinely believe they are correct about everything and can't understand that someone may have a differing opinion that could be valid.

[@Nathanaelelliott]

@@lisaminnikin7009 Aw man I truly feel for people experiencing this. It messed with me for years cuz I went from g having a ton of awesome friends to realizing I only actually had one or two. Especially sucks cuz I'm a musician who plays in bands and writes so all my group was artists and musicians too. I grew up with them and yeah in one moment you realize they actually don't care at all. The worst thing is when I actually wa figuring out truth I was so excited that I went and tried to tell them all because I assumed they cared about the truth too 🤣 Was dumb but I dint regret any of it at this point. Some things are more important and I think that's gonna become a major realization to people soon. Just remember that you arent alone and their are a lot of people like you. I am more right now mostly on economic issues and small government but don't let anyone from either side make you feel too much to you let the feeling rule your decision. There are still bad people no matter what group we are around. Clearly our countries need incredible amounts of people who care about our home and people so it's always good to know more people are seeing it. Sorry so long

[@Nathanaelelliott]

@@lisaminnikin7009 Yeah its truly terrifying to realize that they really believe these things. Another revelation is that a lot of people can be confronted with such evidence it should change anyone's mind yet they'll acknowledge it then choose to ignore it.

[@lisaminnikin7009]

@Nathanaelelliott thats funny I used to work in the music business. One of my old mates from those days just dumped me off Facebook for wrongthink. Sad!! Now I live in Canada where we're desperate to get our authoritarian Trudeau out. He froze hundreds of people's bank accounts during the trucker protests and covid! Also is a big fan of censorship (we can no longer post news articles on facebook) and wants hate speech laws too. Just astonishing. I'm.glad there's some of us troopers out here interested in truth. :)

[@crowhillian58]

I feel lucky to have been a child in the 60's teen in the 70's, it was great, but not perfect so I'm not getting dewy eyed about the past. It might be my age ( 60's) but I don't sense any hope for the future of this country, only a dread of what is to come and that is from everyone I speak to and what I can glean off Facebook. Yes, it's not all doom and gloom, we will all have personal triumphs and happy moments but my faith in the political class to lead this country to a better future is utterly gone and I'm glad I'm not in my teens or 20's. I personally live in a great street with the best neighbours who would help each other out at the drop of a hat. Some have moved here from nearer London, others from Europe and further afield but on a nice Saturday afternoon it's not unusual to see groups of neighbours young and older, new to the street or lived here a while, having a chat in the street. 👍

[@maxpeck7382]

Fabian the name of the Fabian society comes from the name of Roman General Quintus Fabius Maximus Verrucosus who used his "Fabian strategy" of not engaging Hannibal of Carthage while making him expend more resources wearing him and his army down to put General Fabius into an improved position vs Hannibal. The term referred to Fabian "the delayer" because that is what he did. The Fabian society knew this history and adopted it to describe themselves and political tactic.

[@nataliehartsock1826]

Just wanted to say good job Andrew Gold. You have managed to be both bold and professional. I applaud your efforts and say please keep at it! Ask the questions! This is the very point of journalism.

[@avengemybreath3084]

Doesn’t it sometimes feel like Andrew is doing a “far right” impression as part of a gonzo journalistic project. He plans to publish a book and a documentary about how easy it is to fool conservatives, look how terrible they are, etc. But then he started to change his mind a bit. So how he has to decide whether to revise the theme of his documentary, OR keep going and maybe do it for real.

[@nataliehartsock1826]

@@avengemybreath3084 I think those are musings of someone with an opinion on the definition of "far right" that is vastly different from the factual definition. Perhaps you are not in a country that is very divided on ideals at the moment🤔 I am. It is very clear to me that the ideals of family values are challenged daily while contradictory laws about age of maturity or consent are upheld by the courts. In America, a 13 year old female knows her own mind well enough that she can transition to male by verbally affirming desires to be male. However, a 17 year old female can not decide she wishes to engage in sex with a 20 year old male. In such a case the male could be subject to arrest, prosecution, imprisonment, and lifelong sexual predator status. If you can't see that applying laws differently to different groups, giving special rights to certain groups, and taking away rights from certain groups is cause for concern, then I would conclude that you yourself are "far left". Also, before the Biden administrations massacre of constitutional law to fit political gain purposes and blatant lies to the public, I was a staunch Democrat. The democratic party's train has derailed and most are applauding the crash. I have changed tracks. All politicians are representatives of big business and billionaire interests. Some are more willing than others to distort the nations laws as well as the principles of democracy to line their own pockets. Follow the money. It always provides the answer. Woke culture is a very profitable business venture for some. I believe Andrew Gold is asking important question that frankly too many haven't been courageous enough to dare ask. My compliment was genuine and I sincerely hope he is not an actor with far left conspiracy documentary plans! Lol

[@avengemybreath3084]

@@nataliehartsock1826 that’s why I put “far right” in quotes.

[@biteingbonobo]

The sad truth is it’s already to late ⏰. The ship for the natives of England, France, Sweden, Germany etc. has sailed. The blindness and hypocrisy of our leading classes have sealed our fate. It’s not a question if, but only when. The future holds diaspora for us. I hope we will be as resilient as the jewish community and we can conserve or cultures in a foreign country.

[@MrCliveado]

With respect I think that would be the case if things continue as they are. But it feels like a war may be coming and out of that, anything can happen

[@jacobesterson]

Take the black pill somewhere else. It helps nobody but yourself.

[@lissyadams6497]

It wasn’t appropriate that he went to prison for the things he’s done wrong. His fraud case was evidence of the two tier policing you were just talking about, in action. A misdemeanour oversight at best it was. Same for this case coming up about the film he put out! Now that’s wrong! We must apply the law equally and fairly and we don’t, it’s that simple.

[@Madonnalitta1]

Tommy Robinson, for anyone not following.

[@benhardwick1102]

Thanks

[@sidanelv-1]

Andrew. I just wanted to let you know how much I appreciate your channel. I followed you on your old one, and now I'm over here. It is so stimulating some things I don't agree with. But that's good because it gives me things to ponder and think over. And that's a good thing. Again, Loving your new program, march success continue on.

[@LabelsAreMeaningless]

We're living through a massive struggle session. It's totally fair to call them Bolsheviks as their Ideology came from those very elites who escaped the USSR. It's an evolution which they felt was more effective in the modern world. The only thing that shifted was their tactics and messaging but the end goal is the same, and that's the thing with communism; the elites who push for the revolutions do not mean 90% of what they say. It's simply a vehicle to start the weakening of whatever they're trying to take over at the time. Their narrative gets tossed in the trash the moment they win. It's simply a vehicle for power and control of the society. Kimberly was a product of the intellectuals. They were the first, not an end result.

[@no_names-]

Remember when the uk refused to let a child get treatment in another country and allowed him to die without trying?

[@uniquehandle1999]

Never heard of Carl Benjamin before, I must say I am impressed and pleased to see someone talking sense. He is expressing what many feel but struggle to articulate.

[@Ubu987]

Surprised you have not heard Carl Benjamin. He is also known by his nom de plume, Sargon of Akkad. He used to run a KZbin channel devoted just to gaming, but certain events moved him towards social and political commentary.

[@SangoProductions213]

I like how you can push back (on certain things, like claiming that UK was extremely homophobic in the past), but still be reasonable. You don't utterly freak out, and you're actually trying to discuss the issue. We need people to argue against who argue in good faith. We really, truly do. I wished for conversations like this - ones I remember from my youth. In my first experience with politics after I dismissed the democrat, because they were a democrat and we were a republican household (little though I knew what that *meant* ), was my mother sitting me down and saying "no, we may disagree, but we hear them out."

[@sn4rff]

another really interesting discussion, thanks for it.

[@Daimo83]

44:00 watching Carl fall into the 'give me your ethnicity or you''re mean' trap is cringe. No, the interviewer does not get to be English if he feels English. It is strictly a question of genetic admixture. Anglo, Saxon, Briton, Pict or Celt. I don't know what the percentage should be because I'm not a scientist. But if you do not have a certain percentage you are not English no matter how long your family has lived in Britain. Otherwise 10th generation Pakistanis in their ethnic enclaves will one day claim to be English. You can be "British" and have a British passport, but that means you're on licence.

[@leonbxxhhxnc]

Ok racist.

[@risinggael1685]

What's racist about what he said

[@leonbxxhhxnc]

@@risinggael1685 being British isn’t about genetics and a black British person isn’t “on license” any more than a white one. Only one of my grandparents is British but I grew up here and am very obviously a Englishman from Surrey. Poorly educated racists can have a problem with that if they want, I’m still here and I still have British citizenship.

[@risinggael1685]

@@leonbxxhhxnc you may be culturally English but your not English ethnicly...which type of "brit" is that one grand parent you mentioned...I'm guessing you see yourself as black.

[@Daimo83]

@@risinggael1685 exclusion is racism to these people

[@avengemybreath3084]

It’s the core leftist contradiction. (1) it is the worst possible thing for any yt group to value its ethnic and cultural identity; (2) but when ANY OTHER GROUP ON EARTH values their ethnic and cultural identity, that is SACRED.

[@rudi5139]

Because for them, they are victims, at the bottom of the hierarchy. Rooted in self-hatred and oversocialization, you often see it in mildy intelligent women.

[@lillielavelle9738]

It is ridiculous. If the left didn't have double standards, they'd have none at all...

[@andymac345]

I was blessed with three children, now thirty twenty nine and twenty eight. I’m also blessed with two grandchildren. The world they occupy is absolutely nothing like the one that I grew up in. It’s not rose tinted glasses, just a fact.

[@lorettakristina6960]

This was a very interesting interview Such a surprisingly fascinating topic and perspective. I love the direction this conversation went. 💙

[@michaeldillon3113]

When I started working in the NHS 40 years ago I was quite left wing - rock against racism , anti nazi league , anti apartheid etc . Working in the NHS it was lovely to meet people from all over the world . What shocked me was to find that pretty much everyone I met were prejudiced in some way . They cared deeply about prejudice shown to them ( rightly so ) but they were almost self righteous about their own prejudices. Even the great Mahatma Gandhi had such views when he was in South Africa . Policies against hate should be built on respect for all rather than single issues which don't confront people who are discriminated against with their own prejudices . ✌️

[@havingfun-u4g]

You can't make policies around an emotion that literally every single human feels at some point in their life. People should be allowed to hate whoever they want for whatever reason. The only issue is if they act on their hate.

[@georgiakerek7999]

Get real

[@mavericktheace]

Thank you for representing Tall people, Andrew! It is a bit silly, but it comes with enough problems that we could complain and act like a marginalized group. After all, the world isn't built for us. It's difficult to find clothes and yes we bang our heads often. The part that gets me is things being put in the back of lower shelves. I cant see back there unless I literally get down onto the ground! And mirrors? Great, I can see what I look like below my neck! And some cars are just dangerous for me to drive :(

[@greatscott369]

There's not enough tall representation and It's clear discrimination. We need to throw soup at something

[@kermitthefrog2311]

I hear you. I have a son who is 6 foot 5 plus extremely long legged, and everything is a problem - showers, cars, beds, airplanes, kitchen counters, desks. Constant bending to talk to people, neck pain, back pain. I’ve told him when he has enough money maybe he should build a house specific to his height lol

[@zxyatiywariii8]

Good points. I'm short but my BF is tall and flying coach is much more difficult for him, whereas for me there's plenty of leg room. Nothing is made to accommodate tall people, but they're not sperging out about it.

[@michaelsorensen7567]

When was the last time someone asked a short person to get something on the bottom shelf? I've been asked to get stuff on the top shelf multiple times...

[@taniacummings9207]

Mirrors, shop counters especially if they've stacked goods on it, high shelves whether goods are at the front or back, trousers, most car drivers' seats... I am just on five feet.

[@ericmcmanus5179]

Look at how nervous and scared this guy is when confronted with the fact that some vlack people in england might not be considered "English". My lord. Total weakness.

[@timesup6302]

Who?

[@kevinjones5001]

I really appreciate Carl's thoughts on "propositional thinking". Helped flesh out some of my own thoughts and feelings regarding there being hazards to rationality.

[@DonutGuard]

I hate to quote a TV show, but this hits the nail on the head. "There can be no justice, so long as laws are absolute... life itself is an exercise in exceptions." - Star Trek: The Next Generation

[@timesup6302]

So what's the point?

[@DonutGuard]

@@timesup6302 what do you mean? What's the point of what, laws? That's a philosophical debate unto itself. I believe personally that the Pre-Platonic Greeks did it best. That is to say, that they recognized that there was a danger of tyranny by legislation.

[@spiderknight9893]

You should consider having Lewis from TIK history on the show.

[@thermionic1234567]

He’s great! That would be a lot of fun!

[@VesnaVK]

That would be amazing!

[@bobhill4364]

It's disappointing to see no one really understand the left and what we are up against. This is not a mere political difference..

[@michaelsorensen7567]

McCarthy did

[@ryanparker4996]

No its a spiritual difference. The Left are literally evil.

[@Madonnalitta1]

​@@michaelsorensen7567what happened to him again?!

[@Mulletmanalive]

The trouble with accepting that Andrew is English is that realistically one can only be one thing and he talks about being Jewish all the time. It very much seems like that’s the most salient portion of his identity, at least as far as the podcast and substack go.

[@bobhill4364]

Yep and they have a long history of being able to live in a society and not assimilate or integrate.

[@sueedwards9334]

@@bobhill4364Clearly not the case with Andrew.

[@MCharlesPainting]

@@bobhill4364 Jews famously assimilate more than almost any group, and actually do pour lots of money into the market. I find it weird that Right-wingers -- clearly, anti-Semites -- heavily focus on the 'problem' of 200,000 Jews in England or otherwise, whilst literally ignoring the fall of England under 20+ million white socialists and 4+ million Muslims, and a large number of radical anti-white black people in London and across the UK. The data is also clear: certain groups commit crime and cause issues for England, and other groups don't. Jews don't cause many issues, and there are very few Jews in prison. You'll likely claim that you're not an anti-Semite, but the mere fact you're obsessed with the clearly-not-problem of the Jews in England as it burns to the ground at the hands of both atheist radicals and Arab Muslims is clear proof. P.S. I notice many are quick to claim Carl as 'English' despite his mixed race parentage. This might further prove an issue people have with Jews over any other group, even when the Jews are being arrested in the streets of London and the criminals and clear enemies of England are not.

[@Chirimbolos88]

He's a culturally English Jew but not an Ethnic English man. But if he wants to call himself English because he feels 'English ' is not going to hurt anyone. I wish all foreigners felt like him.

[@bobhill4364]

@@sueedwards9334 What was his DNA test? I forgot, but I thought it was 95% Ashkenazi. That's not a coincidence. Js are very good at living in societies and never absorbing into the culture. So he'll look English, speak English, but is a J and will remain a J by marrying a J and keeping cultural traits.

[@Economics21st]

Excellent interview. Andrew mostly let Carl talk, but challenged occasionally which made for a more thoughtful discussion.

[@BuilderLee72]

Another really interesting and thought provoking interview Andrew, enjoyed watching along. Take care, stay safe and remain vigilant

[@joer9156]

Andrew, your 5% Iberian may be from Sephardic ancestry, perhaps one of the 1492 exiles who ended up amongst the Ashkenazim. Or it could be from a non-Jewish spouse sonewhere in the lineage.

[@ryanparker4996]

1492 was a good year. It was the start of Spains Golden Age. Take from that what you will 😂

[@honkytonk4465]

Sephardic is not Iberian

[@suereeves5994]

an asian man from yardley was jailed for 2 years this week for using a fake name to stir up racial hatred. i must admit, i didn't expect that, but it's in the paper so it must be true. jess philips constituency.

[@icarusjumped2719]

What "brand" of Asian?

[@aces553]

Love Carl Benjamin ❤️

[@TheMrBranford]

I’m a big fan of your work. Congrats man. You must be very proud

[@liamhenderson3753]

Thanks for the great and informative content, Andrew. I'm always particularly excited to see a new one from you. I like your Therouxesque style.