Xbox One Elite Controller Series 2: Review

[@PizzaDinosaur]

"Today I'd like to do a Quick..." [Glances at runtime, nods approvingly]

[@TannerGSchultz]

When Tim Rogers threatens to make a "long, weird, nonsense filled video about why you should get a fancy controller in the first place", you know he is not joking.

[@freddychopin]

*Jeremiah Johnson Nod of Approval*

[@MrKchinova]

Exactly what I done

[@boogie6969]

He had me at "No nonsense."

[@cannonkelly87]

he never says that

[@3DGEMAN1000]

10 mins in and I'm thinking to myself, 'Why on earth am I watching an hour long video about a controller that I can't afford?' and then I realise that I'm actually 40 mins in and this guy is an incredible reviewer. Not once have I lost interest like I do with most 8 minute reviews from other channels. Fantastic! More of this guy please!

[@black_hydra1618]

Not only that but there is no ads

[@bluemonday1621]

Tim is one of the most gifted video game sector reviewers, so much so that when I ran out of Action Button game reviews I started looking at his previous work at Kotaku.

[@Traumglanz]

@@black_hydra1618 There is just one long 61 minutes and 12 second long ad! ;-)

[@phrankyou]

Tim, I am shouting you out because I want an hour long video about how manual transmissions are motherly and nurturing.

[@sureetsingh3637]

also feed us the electronic Hamburger ,mother Timothy

[@galacticwarlock2271]

His Looney Tune vs Apocalypse Now vs Charlie Chaplin soundtrack is enough. "Bababa Baba baba That's All Folks!"

[@jasonchristensen5434]

I remember Tim talking about about "manual transmission" components in video games as a reference to extra unnecessary stuff you do when you're doing other stuff. It was utterly fascinating and this absolute tease about a video essay on manual transmissions and motherliness must happen.

[@mysti4131]

I was lowkey looking through the comments when he said that

[@Speblet]

You’ve had your YT account for 14 years? omg you OG

[@melon3109]

I can't find the time to sit down and watch a movie, but I sure as darned heck will watch an hour long video on a game accessory for a console I don't even own.

[@Traumglanz]

Works on PC too, right? ^-^ Time to get my hotas a little cousin. ;-)

[@koosh88215]

What I'm currently doing as well haha

[@graffiti73]

🤣🤣 same here

[@arcanekand]

i suggest you get an xbox one x and embrace the dark side 👺

[@essential5020]

@@arcanekand boosters, kids, old heads, and scammers😭 I love this xbox one x. I came from ps4, this community hilarious.

[@sleepyrhythms6668]

I don't own an Xbox nor do I play on PC, and I just watched a man review a controller for an hour. Not a second felt wasted. Don't change Tim.

[@Alairguy]

"I CAN bench my own weight, AND kick as high as YOUR groin." Best flex ever. Did not expect the second part.

[@galacticwarlock2271]

15:04 He is a kung fu master, has hacked into the FBI database for fun. I know he has a copy of the "Anarchist Cookbook." and might be a time traveler. But he is no gosh darn narc!

[@JSmith73]

Most people can't bench their own weight, so kudos for that as well. :)

[@gchu149]

I see 1 hour review on a controller, I already know it’s Tim Rogers.

[@havoc266]

I’ve been trying to get through this video for 25 minutes. Just realized when I read your comment how long it is 🤣🤣

[@paigehansen8944]

I saw this review and scrolled past it, then I realized it’s a controller review that’s over and hour long and knew it HAD to be Tim. What a treasure

[@4dimensionen996]

This review is so tactile and experiential, this is the closest you can come to knowing how the controller and it’s accessories feel without actually having held it in your hands. Love it, wish there were more tech reviews like this.

[@RobStemen]

What's this Tim is posting? An hour long review about a version upgrade of an expensive controller for a console that I don't own? Welp, guess I'm doing that, then.

[@XZeroKPS]

I don't know how he does it but when I see his name on a video I need to watch it. His delivery is so unique I just enjoy listening

[@andrewhickinbottom1051]

If Tim did a 3 hour video talking about home contents insurance, i'd sure as heck watch even that.

[@pk1715]

haha, same. im 100% sure that id watch anything with tim in it~

[@JP-wm1cc]

Lets start a Go Fund Me for Tim so can get some hot water in his building 💪

[@waxweazel10]

So I thought let me watch a quick review video. Wait what, an hour for a review controller, are you insane. *watches the entire hour*

[@bran_donk]

This has been a satisfying review and even more satisfying spiraling descent into madness.

[@galacticwarlock2271]

It's ok after 5pm he will be at full power.

[@crazedmimic]

I'm gonna be productive when i get home. *Proceeds to watch a hour long review for an xbox controller*

[@baiaili80]

haha. what am I doing. Jeez, I've got to get off my butt and walk to the other room to play my xbox. :-)

[@ghoulie69]

I could listen to Tim Rogers talk about literally anything for hours

[@phartferd5738]

good news!

[@TiRoSu]

This is a good amount of detail. I feel much more informed about this controller.

[@RichMcLaughlin]

I love how tediously thorough this review is. Well done, sir.

[@belphegor_dev]

It is tedious all right.

[@thelaggymonster]

This guy is hilarious! Saw the run time and expected to skip to the end, but loving every minute!

[@SarthakRana95]

I would like to see the interview with the neurologist please Mr. Rogers!

[@runjab]

This is quite possibly the best and most informative review of any device I have ever has the privilege to witness. Thank god for you man.

[@videogameobsession]

"The face buttons were STICK AND STIFFY." - Rim Todgers 2019

[@timstrick84]

on Series 1, they are stiffer though, i don`t like them on the series 2 too mushy

[@Jgreen1983]

I'd watch a big, long, weird, nonsense filled video about why I should get a fancy controller in the first place. Disclaimer: I am not an eAthele.

[@apraetorian9986]

Josh Green if you don’t play a lot , or don’t play very competitively , you don’t need it man. The main feature is the paddles and those are mainly for an advantage in comp gaming. Me personally, after owning several scufs and elite series 1, I could never use a default controller again. I would recommend picking up a pair of kontrol freeks at least.

[@NickelCanvas]

I appreciate Tim Roger's opinions. I like this video. I do not own an Xbox. These are all facts.

[@lucaskane5364]

I am so down for an hour long video on the manual transmission

[@leecroft1983]

Lucas Kane Holy shit, the video is over an hour long !!! I didn’t even notice that, I just clicked on the video. I was expecting a ten minute video on the controller, lol 😂

[@DrWiley-fm3ik]

Tim Rogers is the only reason I'm subscribed

[@galacticwarlock2271]

I don't even subscribe.

[@aceyaeger9041]

Same

[@ajwebb220587]

I’ve literally just subscribed because this guy is amazing

[@KurtiZv]

This is the kind of review I've been dying for - all the others are so fluffy, I LOVE THE GRIT

[@coollobsterr]

ohmyfuccinggod this video is like listening to a 60 year old wine connoisseur praising a 20 year old wine. 🤣🤣

[@user-eo7bz5zk8w]

Its such a good amount of detail that i subscribed. I appreciate how much you told us about it, im even more confident in the purchase. Now it just needs to get here!

[@atomicbrain9401]

Tim, your videos recently are just so next level. I’m sitting here watching and cheering you on like a proud little brother, looking at his older sibling and one day thinking he could achieve his own dreams, as well.

[@frosty9392]

hearing about all the papercuts/minor flaws in a long format is super helpful. now its time to binge his reviews lol

[@ubersky7029]

Fantastic job Tim. No-one gives this much care/attention/mania into hardware like you do. Also, I need a link for that backpack.

[@gumsrevenge]

I love the length of this video like the length of your tarantula fingers. Lots of humor and helpful information. Subscribed!

[@nevermore2148]

" My hands look like tarantula wearing Halloween costume " Lost it there lmao

[@Stark9056]

I have never seen a better review for anything ever in my entire time of watching reviews since I started watching videos anywhere, and now, I expect this from every reviewer. You spoiled me Tim!

[@gralha_]

"No nonsense" 40 minutes later "I gotta stop talking about Gary Oldman"

[@genoalvin]

Best review video I have ever seen. Need more reviews by this man.

[@MrAngerissues1]

I love this guy! He's insane!

[@JonathanMerkt]

This is WAY better than other gear reviews. The amount of detail is perfect for the gear selected. I feel like I don’t need to watch secondary reviews or read any articles about this product after spending an hour with you on the subject.

[@Doctor-Infinite]

I swear if this man told me he played every single game known to man TWICE... I would indeed believe him

[@galacticwarlock2271]

He is the Wilt Chamberlain of gaming.

[@steamyrobotlove]

*Sees a new Kotaku review video* *Assumes Tim Rogers made the video* *Sees video length* ... Welp, guess I'll take a 1 hour break.

[@jamesdeford7975]

I did know about the hamburger thing, but I'm still here to vote for any and all hour-long videos Tim wants to make. Kotaku: this is the content

[@crisangel_0140]

I actually appreciate the hour long review video covers everything in amazing detail . New sub!

[@higguma]

This is more thorough than my parents planning for my birth.

[@Jacob-ss2sl]

"80% less nonsense" *looks at video length*

[@andrewhickinbottom1051]

"Nobody even likes ice levels, Sony". I thoroughly enjoyed this - especially all the off topic tangents like how discussing the weight of the controller led to you explaining to your mom (and us) that you're not a drug dealer and that you have no hot water in your apartment. I genu-LOLed many times throughout this hour and minute. Brilliant! (It was very informative and interesting too - edutainment!)

[@slanty8]

I don't own an XBOX ONE but after watching this video, this cowboy REALLY wants one of these controllers. You have a bright future with QVC if the whole Kotaku gig fails to thoroughly pan out, Mr. Rogers.

[@bopsa]

I weighed them with my digital "kitchen" scale. No clue how accurate it is, but: E1 = 344g (with plug-and-play pack) E2 = 341g

[@yakovhadash]

Tim Rogers’s mom wants to know if you are a drug dealer

[@universal_wisdom3416]

I might need some Peptobismol

[@rscotthopson]

Shared this on my discord. Genuinely the best review of anything I've ever seen. Don't even particularly care about the controller

[@the1UPLawyer]

I have not seen you on the channel before, buuuut this is one of the best reviews I have ever seen. Bravo.

[@blueegg4198]

Yes, of course I'll watch a 1:01:12 video about a controller I will not buy for a console I do not own. It's Tim Rogers.

[@LEGIT_ELITE]

Shout out to the greatest review of ANYTHING EVER. This is exactly what the people needed.

[@iiTzPiNkGo4T]

I wanted to buy the first one but I talked myself out of it, you’ve now talked me into buying the elite 2, and I’m not eAthlete

[@ianrichardson62]

This is the best and nerdiest review I have ever seen and I appreciate it so much! You my friend are a legend! IM not surprised you like the Elite controller so much, it truly a thing of beauty!

[@danielsolorzano8623]

I got myself one after falling in love with my xbox one X. I love it so far. It has easily taken over as my main controller and not just because of how much I spent on the dang thing

[@zbailey]

Same for me man, spot on lol

[@johanloots4646]

Amazing video. If I didn't know it was 60min long I would have never believed it. Even after it was finished I thought wtf....that was quick! Loved it. Well done. Thank you.

[@isaiahtakahashi5741]

Mom: Okay, one more video before bedtime Me: THANKS TOM ROGERS

[@SpencerSoaresIsLame]

this video convinced me to buy one of these guys. i dont have an xbox though and my pc is in the shop. i also bought a stick that plugs into my switch so i can use this on my switch. if you wanna know the kind of weirdos that love your work tim, im going to use this xbox elite controller to play pokemon and mario

[@jadziadax3244]

This is so beyond the realm of things I care about about that I am very convinced I could listen to Tim Rogers talk about any subject for hours on end, as long as he could maintain this level of whimsically pedantic passion. This style of comedy(?) and his performance brings it all together in a way that weirdly reminds me of how I feel watching Stewart Lee...

[@InfiniteHench]

Great review. Right amount of detail. You are hereby requested to make more.

[@victoriauhl1070]

ugh finally someone who cleans their shit for closeups 🤙 also I love a loose snare if you know what I mean

[@aflores278832]

Never seen one of your videos before. I'm subscribed now for just the comedy and entertainment factor alone.🤣

[@AlexW1995]

I want a 15 minute video of tim rogers talking about kingdom hearts 2 fanfiction

[@AlexW1995]

this isn't a joke, when watching this video and hearing the kh2 fanfic joke, i paused it and spent 10 minutes talking about kh2 fanfic to my boyfriend (also great video!)

[@yakovhadash]

with his neurologist

[@keybladeslashw900]

Hey could you explain the joke please, kh2 is my favorite game ever but I'm not a fan fiction guy.

[@AlexW1995]

@@keybladeslashw900 ah I don't quite remember the context in the video but Tim Rogers mentioned the fanfic for kingdom hearts 2, and when kh2 came out and for years afterwards there were so many fanfic put out (most of which was garbage) but a lot of it was pretty good and the characters kind of turned into a fandom version of them. So in game Kairi doesn't get a lot of character development but the fandom kind of collectively created a personality for her through the use of fanfic and bc there was so much time between games whatever expectation we had for kh3 could never meet the expectations of the fandom. So for example, Roxas coming back was written so many times in so many ways, some of which was really well written, that no matter how Nomura wrote it out unless it was a whole other game just about Roxas again then it wouldn't be perfect. And I feel like most people don't like talking about that era bc of the more awful fanfic but it really defined how I looked at the game through middle and high school.

[@keybladeslashw900]

@@AlexW1995 thanks bro I've loved kh2 since I was 7 but never looked into its fan fic

[@ajwebb220587]

This has unequivocally changed my mind away from getting The Razer or the Scuf - great review 🤙🏻

[@futuramaguy42]

I would like a long video about why to get a fancy controller. Thank you.

[@jimblubello7354]

Thanks for the thorough analysis Tim. Also, thanks for the microfiber cloth tip

[@mduckernz]

"Tarantulating" is one heck of a word, thanks for that 🤤

[@julianreynaa]

Thanks for the San José shout out, Tim!

[@pvtcmyers87]

You seriously need to make this a thing. For every equipment review. Ever.

[@JeremiahSpoon]

If Lewis Black was younger and reviewed games / gaming hardware, he'd be Tim Rogers. BRAVO, FRIEND. Great review. Fantastically entertaining.

[@frosty9392]

"you probably have a lot in common with me.. you sad, weird, freak" lol i love it

[@Herrjosefk]

I can't believe it took me until 2021 to discover and fall in love with Tim.

[@ramz1874]

Looks like he's cosplaying as Kojima😂

[@leecroft1983]

Ram Z Yep, would explain why he looks like an arsehole.

[@dudewinnie]

-Siri: "hears Kojima" -Also Siri: "Are you looking for, Hiroshima?"

[@dudewinnie]

Also who is Kojima sounds like a Chinese guy

[@Mr-moo]

More detail. Longer runtime. Perfect review. You are hilarious.

[@CloakedC]

Tim Rogers, I've always found you insufferable and every video with you in it intolerable. BUT this review was very detailed, insightful and doesn't make me want to punch you in the face. Great work, I appreciate your efforts. P.S. Your dog is adorable

[@MrLolKins]

Saw the video. Ordered the controller. Totally sold me on the upgrades. And the indepth AF review format is great. Actually goes in all the shit people would want to know but nobody else bothers to write about

[@neodavie]

It's as though Tim heard me bemoaning the lack of Dadaist gaming hardware reviews.

[@BRITT_ECU12]

After wondering if i should buy, lol i was convinced i needed it and bought the controller while still watching this wonderful review.

[@narcspector]

"nobody even LIKES ice levels, SONY! ....Except... ....... *for me* ." 😂

[@rebeccadraper1171]

WOW! I was just looking up on tips to keep glasses clean, gotta get one of those big microfiber cloths now. Also I would like to see all of the videos suggested, since Tim Rogers videos are the best!

[@QUIXisHIM_]

"This lets you pull the trigger 3/4 of the way. Which doesn't help you win a race." :'D

[@t_r_a_y_e9858]

@Martin Taylor why do you have two first names

[@t_r_a_y_e9858]

@Martin Taylor what retarded country do you live in that Taylor isn't a first name. Either way who the fuck names there child Martin in any country

[@MoustafaChamli]

Honestly, the invite to Tim's birthday party upon receiving the Elite 2 controller was a nice bonus

[@IBODEGAI]

“Ah shit... here we go again.”

[@GrayD_Fox]

I love how Tim talks like a normal person and does not pretend to be hyped about the product, nor act like its a marvelous piece of technology with no problems at all

[@flackbyte]

Normal human man who is definitely not a drug dealer, Tim Rogers, does a normal review.

[@cmdann8]

The sound of my left bumper of my elite v 1: ***crickets meowing***

[@mattthegymratgaming211]

Tim's Mom, if you think your son is a drug dealer... here it is 15:28

[@Racste]

Simply loved to be educated and entertained about the xbox wireless controller series 2 that I simply love!!! You just gave me more reasons to brag about it.

[@ralfrackelhahn8822]

i don't even have or want an xbox or this controller. i just like to listen to him talk.

[@geddy21twelve]

This is the first thing Kotaku has done that hasn't made me groan or roll my eyes. More of this man, please! Your advertiser can have more of my attention in exchange for more of this guy. That is the deal I'm offering.

[@yunyizhe]

If I have a £115 amazon gift card, would it be worth paying that and the rest for this?

[@thecosmicnebula_]

Yes! Got mine yesterday and it's worth the money! Loving it so far

[@yunyizhe]

@@thecosmicnebula_ Getting it tomorrow! :)

[@karl8538]

Nothing combines my love for games and Bon Appetit's KZbin videos than Tim calling this the cast-iron skillet of controllers.

[@andyduhh4278]

I just watched an hour long video about a controller what am I doing with my life

[@bikeac]

YOU ARE ONE OF THE TOP TEN "ELITE" REVIEWERS ON THE EARTH! THANK YOU

[@LiquidSteve89]

Instant unfollow if there’s no mention/cameo of Michael “the controller” Kerwin

[@kotaku]

he is mentioned multiple times, though not by name . . .

[@DanteSeime]

WHAT A RIDE, loved every second of this review.

[@Turboguard]

Only owns PS4 and Switch, watched the whole video....

[@sciencewizard8805]

I own a ps4 too, but I just find the Xbox better except ps4 exclusives. Controller seems better, but both are good. UI on Xbox is way faster and more reliable, esp the store. Easier to find randoms with mics on Xbox lfg feature than PlayStation version of the same. Not sure with new consoles, but Xbox x last gen beat ps4 pro for multiplatform.

[@MaruMalandra]

I bought the controller based on watching this review several times as a fun bit of Tim Content, and after getting counselled by the Stick Mavens over at Discord Dot GG Forward Slash Action Button. Owning this controller and using it daily has been a joy, and feels every bit as good as what Tim describes. Having purchased this for 50% off retail price (thanks, eBay), I decided to put it through its paces. My game of choice was Deltarune, an experience necessitating literally a d-pad and three buttons. I mostly use this to play platformers. I even got an adapter so I can use it on Switch and PS4! Some days I play with it and think to myself that this is the fanciest thing I own. I feel underdressed when I hold this controller. Anyway this video is fun whether you already own the controller or not.

[@XxMsrSzprzxX]

This is one of the best videos I've ever seen on KZbin. I've never watched any Kotaku videos and this is the first time I've came across this gentleman. An hour long video delving into the intricacies of an XBOX controller I might one day buy, down to the sound signatures of each button press. An hour of this. Also you own a GoRuck, I own a GR2 but I still think the GR1 is great, I might actually get one because sometimes the GR2 feels a bit too much. Incredible video, thank you so much.

[@ericmillettcon]

I wasn’t sure if I should throw out my Xbox One Elite Series 2 Controller case so I googled it and found this video. Thanks!

[@jackmstephens]

This man is insane. I now MUST have him review all products I will ever buy in the future.

[@defalive]

> 80% less nonsense > still hour long video You're a national treasure Tim. We should protect you at all costs.

[@friendkerrek]

beatmaker / Tim Rogers fan here, shoutout cuz I like my snare a little loose