You Didn't Listen To Me

[@ivykat9009]

The plaintiff is selling dogs from a disgusting puppy mill and the real victims are the dogs!!

[@VirgoCali89]

Exactly!! She is purposely inbreeding them

[@ivykat9009]

@@VirgoCali89 she should never be allowed to own a dog

[@VirgoCali89]

@@ivykat9009 so true I would report her ass

[@JennifuhhGilardi]

Right, I wouldn’t want the first or any replacement dog from such an awful person

[@donnahanfordnichols6573]

Always, always ADOPT, DON’T SHOP. It’s simple. People who breed & those who buy from them are abominable. Visit a shelter. Eliminate demand, eliminate supply.

[@jeanhartely]

When I was a kid we had mutts-- wonderful, intelligent, HEALTHY dogs. Where did all the beautiful mutts go?

[@atespeach5672]

they're called working dogs for sale and they're beautiful dogs that need a home

[@wcares8062]

I had a couple "mutts" one lived to 17 the other was 22year old when they passed away.

[@jenniehughes6927]

@@wcares8062 I have 6 of them. 10 to 14 years old now.

[@hellowendy1029]

They're called designer dogs 😋

[@AP-uo7sp]

In the shelters probably. Too many irresponsible owners that get free puppies and don't value them.

[@lauramills_af]

If that lady’s dogs have inbreeding and mange she needs to quit immediately! I hate some breeders

[@CeltycSparrow]

Why would ANYONE pay $1000 for a dog that was inbred and had potential health issues? Why wasn't the plaintiff very clear with the defendant and her daughter on HOW exactly the dog was inbred and the health issues. Obviously, if the puppy's intestines were twisted, that is a possible genetic defect. That's not something that just pops up overnight. The defendant could have gone down to the local animal shelter and purchased a dog for $50.

[@2ShayZeeGe]

Pretty much all purebred dogs are inbred and people will pay much more for them. People will pay 15k for dogs that can't even walk or breathe because they look exotic

[@juliettek.9440]

You have a fair point, but as a rescuer and someone whose had bad experiences with shelters it’s not as easy as walking in and picking a puppy. Shelters sometimes ask for to much. They want you to live within distance of a vet, be friends with a vet, have a doggy room, the garden of Eden in your back yard. Etc etc etc. Breeders ask for applications, but it’s more or less a personality test on your part. As well as knowledge of the breed you’re getting. Poodle breeders won’t sell to you if you don’t know what it is to maintain their cost. Pug breeders won’t sell to you unless you know and are in someway prepared for the constant vet visits. Etc etc.

[@melissaomalia9870]

@@juliettek.9440 curious what your "bad experiences" with rescuing was since I've rescued and adopted 4 dogs from different places and literally never once had an issue. Living near a vet is too much to ask?

[@vidamccurdy9764]

I agree,my last 2 pups were from a shelter.the first pup was a purebred american akita.$60 which included all shots,wormed and a future spay when she got older.only thing was i had to research,talk to trainers about the breed and have the acerage to entertain a large breed.wonderful 14 yrs with her.2nd pup from a shelter was $125 which included all shots,wormed,neutered and chipped.7 glorious yrs with him.easy to adopt him.my current pup i got at 9 months from a wonderful family who wanted to rehome her.she was current on all shots,wormed,crate trained which they gave me and all her toys,leashes,dog bowls,etc.i had to pay for spaying only,no rehoming fee,she is now 2 and is amazing.there are great shelters and people who will rehome for 0 or next to nothing who had taken great care of dog before they rehomed.why spend big bucks when there are thousands looking for homes

[@ingesexton811]

Daughter “I don’t want to be involved “ The people’s court “let’s put her on tv one thousand times”.

[@HighMaintenanceMinimalist]

The audience has to sign a release form (or an automatic release is included with the "sale" of their ticket) for use of their image on the show. If she really did not want to be seen, she would've sat outside.

[@ingesexton811]

@@HighMaintenanceMinimalist yeah.... it was a joke.

[@HighMaintenanceMinimalist]

@@ingesexton811 My bad. It read like a criticism.

[@ingesexton811]

@@HighMaintenanceMinimalist no I just thought it was funny.

[@missyrose2154]

She according to the mother is the owner of the dog and paid for it . She SHOULD have been involved

[@charliej766]

I'm angry with myself for wasting 15 minutes of my life watching this absolutely pointless lawsuit.

[@ANGELSURS]

Better than the 1 year pandemic

[@ANGELSURS]

@@jenniehughes6927 Yes sweetness

[@Monika-bc3dq]

Yeah, literally 24 seconds in and the outcome was obvious.

[@beane6426]

Seriously. I think the plaintiffs and/or defendants just wanted a free trip.

[@jessicapearson9479]

Well, it may not be pointless as now millions of people know that the plaintiff knowingly and purposefully inbreeding dogs causing serious health issues and harm to the dogs born. Hopefully, her sales have lessened or stopped all together. So, maybe some good did come out of this case.

[@itsedgaro]

Only if people knew the beauty of adopting and how much love that dog shows you the very 1st day you bring them home. Proud parent of an adopted furry baby and would adopt another one before ever considering buying one. Just my 2 cents

[@mymobilebuddy4392]

You said a lot.

[@NellieKAdaba]

👍🏾

[@benniewilliams9864]

Ee I eeeeeeeeee get Ff e V f free I am praying for you Andrew

[@BeavzMC]

If only people knew the beauty of letting people make their own decisions and not try to guilt trip people into making the moral decision YOU personally believe in, Just my 2 cents.

[@kimberlymoxley104]

THANK YOU

[@rubenmejia9020]

The plaintiff has no business breeding dogs and the defendant has no business buying dogs.

[@Degorff]

To date, we have neutered 90,000 animals, aged 6 to 8 weeks and up. The easiest surgeries are those performed on puppies and kittens 4 to 5 months of age. Surgery times are, on average, 1/3 shorter in kittens and puppies than for their adult counterparts.

[@janayserrano]

@valerie cantdoitnow wait what lol. Those aren’t the only people that may breed dogs. Why are you singling them out? That’s like someone saying, we need to stop polluting the air and you respond with tell that to India. There are more contributors involved lol

[@JennifuhhGilardi]

@valerie cantdoitnow the fuck

[@illidelphian1508]

Ya and after the the lady’s dog dies the seller wants to then sue her! How cruel

[@illidelphian1508]

@valerie cantdoitnow tell them and then what. Does nothing right. Just why?

[@bethsanders635]

This woman has no business breeding anything, including herself.

[@kaeshalae1]

🤣

[@jazzymoni7750]

🤣🤣😭😭

[@nicolemitchell9762]

Lmfaooo😂😂 she look like “🥴”

[@Purpleflower57]

🙂😂😂

[@dinabalumka7880]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@patrickchubey3127]

Go to the animal shelters and take home a dog that will love you with it's dying breath. Screw these puppy mill people. Dogs for profit doesn't cut it with me.

[@sachelleb4930]

I'm sitting here struggling from the beginning of this case with the same question the judge asked. "How does that entitle you to sue someone for something that does not belong to you!!!!!" And another thing...how did this crazy case even make it to court???

[@morbidbeauty_]

13:55 the second her true nature comes through, and then she's stuttering all over herself because she realizes she's lost. RIP Toast.

[@shootingcomet082]

Imagine suing someone for their dog's death.😖

[@Jerry.Luna63]

Doug always kicks their bruised knee in the best way possible

[@Lorcar86]

😂

[@TSears2010]

So chill but so savage every case

[@bhornannawindeedeigh5007]

You said it better than anyone I've ever read the comments of on Dougie Llewellyn. He seems to be a small fellow- not a hefty brute, anyway - and yet he sure can pack a punch sometimes. 😅

[@likeliterally7077]

Neither party seems to be playing with a full deck

[@moneyalways7674]

Or 🦷

[@CleveNative]

@@moneyalways7674 💀

[@jakyla]

the breeders insane. when i heard the details of the case i knew she wouldn't get anything.

[@erikromero1433]

It’s like pulling teeth with these litigants...

[@citytrees1752]

The judge displayed a huge amount of patience.

[@ashleighnycole]

looks like they’ve been pulled already

[@StaceyMilo2011]

Judge Marilyn is going to turn into Judge Judy one day after she snaps from all the BS stories she has to deal with.

[@jessicapearson9479]

StaceyMilo2011 No, she isn't. Judge Judy used to deal with child abuse cases and family law cases. Anyone who deals with such cases gets hardened because it is painful to see the abuse to the children. She was approached to do the tv show and she jumped at it because she was tired of all the abuse cases. This Judge did not have to deal with that. So, no. She will not end up like Judge Judy. By the way Judge Judy is a good Judge. You just forget that Judge Judy and this Judge get the cases, read them and do a bit of research BEFORE seeing the Plaintiffs and Defendants. So they are able to know what is going on and if one or both people are lying. That is why this Judge brought up that what the Defendant said in the papers was different than what she was saying in court. She also, knew that the Defendant lost a previous lawsuit she had tried to bring against the plaintiff. You should pay better attention before you speak.

[@rockypluto2683]

Omg..I wonder how the Judge stays sane with all these crazy cases..

[@heatherbop2946]

I love when she says okay watch this and ask the defendant a question and then back to the plaintiff so how you going to prove it. She usually says this to them when they have a verbal contract instead of written lol

[@idiaakanbi3713]

The Plaintiff has way too much time on her hands

[@CreamIceMs]

So the breeder sold a dog to the girl who is now the owner, and then sues because the dog died? Does she thinks she still owns the dog after selling it? She no longer has rights to the animal... Imagine suing someone because they broke a table you sold them. Crazy!

[@jamieleigh3481]

Depends on the contract and the breeder absolutely can still own rights to the pup.

[@tifahloveshk]

She didn’t want the puppy neutered so she could keep inbreeding the puppies why else would you want to wait that long?

[@linisin2083]

Actually neutering dogs are really bad. And causes certain illnesses.. Neutering When they’re That young could cause infection

[@hln573]

in the case of large-breed dogs, it's actually much healthier for the dog to wait until at least one year of age, minimum.

[@hln573]

@@linisin2083 neutering dogs is not bad, but depending on the breed or possible medical conditions, neutering them as very young puppies can be an issue

[@laurafratoni7931]

Boerbels are such a large breed, if you neuter them before the growth plates close at 18 months minimum, they end up with hip dysplasia and many other issues. They are 150-200 lb dogs.

[@7daysofawkward835]

It’s in the best interest of dogs to not be altered unless medically or behaviorally necessary, But premature spay/neuter(before the age of 18 months to 24 months) actually causes a ton of damage, stunts a dog’s natural growth, females have a 1/4 chance of becoming incontinent, mammary and bone cancer rates rise, and literally so much more. Do the research. It’s absolutely best to spay/neuter at 2 years old if at all.

[@citytrees1752]

Everytime the judge asks the defendant a question, defendant talks about something else. How hard is it to say yes or no?

[@AnneOhn123]

Marilyn screams like a banshee and doesn't listen! So damn unprofessional.. but she is only a TV judge afterall...

[@miamyren]

Sometimes I think they’re so busy trying to think about what to say so they’re not even listening to the question

[@shaunaba3116]

Going around, and around the bush..

[@entheo302]

Meth is a hell of a drug

[@lucy5201]

Why are the defendants busting in the court room like that?! LOL

[@ctilly5859]

😂

[@RealLifeSnowWhite]

Rescues ARE the BEST kind of pets!💯💯💯

[@KarenSpelledLikeTheMemes]

Giant breeds are not the same as smaller breeds. Irish Wolfhounds, for example, should not be spayed or neutered until between 18 and 24 months for health reasons. South African Mastiffs may have the same recommendations.

[@urluvizmyluv1999]

May have? So you don't know 👀

[@KarenSpelledLikeTheMemes]

@@urluvizmyluv1999 I do not own Mastiffs. Therefore, I have no expertise when it comes to that specific breed. Hence, "may have". Do you have expertise on the breed? If so, share your knowledge. Otherwise, your reply to me is strange.

[@shrutefarms4741]

@@urluvizmyluv1999 she is correct so store your condescending attitude.

[@urluvizmyluv1999]

@@shrutefarms4741 lol or what 🤦🏽‍♀️🤣🤣

[@michelehemlokhexwhite4310]

Waiting till females come into heat before speying risks a severe rise in mammary cancer rates.

[@SpiffyPenguin]

What the hell did the plaintiff come here for lmfao

[@dspiffy]

You have my name!

[@AngelizAgosto]

She doesn’t even know lmao

[@bubblegum1948]

The day Karma arrives at the Plaintiff’s door it’ll totally catch her off guard.

[@jaydahaniyah]

I don’t understand why the plaintiff is trying to sue the defendant for her neutering her own dog. Like you got your bread, move on. 😌 Neutering and Spaying is a risk with all animals but a higher risk with this one. Rip Toast 😕

[@BelleBlack1]

I think the plaintiff is trying to say that her getting paid for the dog was only part of the deal, and that her being able to use the dog to make more dogs was the other part. But she couldn't prove it.

[@jaydahaniyah]

@@BelleBlack1 makes sense but I thought she didn’t have breeding rights?

[@BelleBlack1]

@@jaydahaniyah She don't know that lol

[@rubenmejia9020]

@@BelleBlack1 That would probably cause even more imbreeding.

[@Play4keeks]

It really doesn't make sense because she had already inbred the dog so much that it died.

[@supermanisrad]

Don’t buy from breeders! Always go to animal shelters or humane societies

[@JR-gn9ei]

Who are you to say not to buy from breeders, why should people go to shelters, shelter dogs have plenty of issues , live and let live

[@kittylola643]

@@JR-gn9ei Not all or even most shelter dogs have issues. It is disgusting to promote breeding dogs when even puppies and kittens are being euthanized.

[@kittylola643]

@Marilyn Willett The Amish community famously run puppy mills...

[@DeRock401]

Mostly I agree but sometimes people want a certain type of dog / or a puppy. All animals need love. Not just sheltered ones

[@pamelajordan2890]

@@kittylola643 absolutely true.

[@SString215]

Perfect example of someone who tried to use the courts to get back at someone they felt did something bad to them instead of just letting it go. The plaintiff doesn’t have two brain cells to rub together because if she had, she would have understood that this lawsuit would be frivolous and not actionable. She made herself look really stupid. Lol.

[@BuhlouBear]

I prefer adoption if you are looking to give a fur baby a forever home. I also get the idea of someone seeking out a specific breed of dog from a conscience, responsible and conscience breeder. The vast majority of dogs have potential genetic problems that the chances of those problems arising are greatly increased by inbreeding. The suffering that this puppy endured can't be remedied in court though nor will it bring that puppy back. I did not really feel the strong emotions that are evident when someone loses a fur baby. That made me sad, it was heartbreaking that the puppy suffered so egregiously.

[@checkerslane]

This case is like if a car salesman sold you a car and told you not to wash the car for 1 month and you agree but then you take the car home and wash it the next day. Its like the car salesman suing you for thousands of dollars cause you washed the car too soon

[@RiddleTales]

She might be suing to revenge the health of the dog. You're not supposed to neuter big dogs until they are 12 to 18 months old. Neutering dogs at 6 months is an ancient way of doing things - human understanding has progressed. She may also suing because the dog was prone to health issues. Some people choose not to neuter dogs with health issues at all because when you neuter you take away all their good to hormones to live and thrive. Waiting till the recomend medical time was the the least the defendant could do for a dog with health issues / potentially health issues in the future. I guess we will not know what she intended because she was not a clear communicator and speaker. I suppose she was the same way with a defendant.

[@elvickRULES]

@@RiddleTales blame the vets then

[@foxwithtubesox1075]

If you're going to get a warranty for the replacement of a dog, you have no business buying a dog.

[@DisI3oss]

I don't think the dog was the only inbred in that house 🤢

[@quirkya909]

How did she damage YOUR REPUTATION for neutering a Dog SHE bought & paid for….that YOU did NOT make a WRITTEN contract with her on?!

[@hottew_twat3963]

She's been inbred herself that's the reputation she's got now.

[@maryelaine-blinstrubchambe6083]

What beautiful children In the crowd.

[@audreypittman922]

I love how judge M differentiated between children and regular humans. They ARE different 🤣🤣🤣

[@Kait2478]

Imagine buying a vase from the store, accidentally breaking it, and then being sued by the store for breaking the vase you bought. Not 100% applicable because they didn't break the dog. But still. What even

[@dianeeppley1322]

I hate when people dress so disrespectful of court. The defendant dressed like she threw on pants under her flannel sleep shirt and came to court. So disrespectful so sloppy. I can’t trust anyone who doesn’t show the courts respect.

[@CarsonHunter]

This is like Apple suing you for opening your phone. You can't sue someone for tampering with something they own because it says so in a contract. At most, it would just void any warranties.

[@katrinkasanfranciscobayare7364]

"So, what's the best age to spay, neuter, or breed an English Mastiff? The rule of thumb in spaying and neutering is to wait for at least 18 to 24 months. It'll minimize the risks of developing degenerative or life-threatening diseases."

[@Bigcheesymonstah]

"We know when we get them that it's not forever" ... damn, that hit home HARD

[@crystal.holmes]

They themselves turned it into an episode of Night Court. What a "poppy show" as we say in Jamaica.

[@DeRock401]

The nerve of this lady thinking once she sells a dog she has any control over that dog

[@Nameless_mixes]

There are legitimately some people who think that court is just a place where you bring people and get money for it…

[@fjccommish]

That's not a court.

[@walterwurzburger8975]

I was told by the breeder of my Great Dane to not neuter the dog until he was 18months old as some large breeds need the extra time to mature. The Dane wasn't aggressive in any way so the wait was possible.

[@antmac4411]

The dog ain't the only one being in bred 😂...and judge Mathis would've had a field day with this group of people...

[@cjn57]

Why is that ? I know he's efette ,I can't watch/ listen to his voice ... Was he going to educate ya on race,I presume (it's really esp,lol ) . I'm fortunate

[@antmac4411]

Nah he would've called em crack heads 😂

[@Klinkhammer3]

HAHAHAHAHA!

[@birdman7864]

The argument about neutering has to do with when the dog matures. Large breeds mature later and can be harmed (by visual imperfections if neutered early)

[@VampyAnji]

Breeding these poor female dogs, over and over again for profit, is WRONG. SMDH.

[@MonkyPocks01]

Jeans and tartan in a courtroom? 🙄🙄

[@connielikens3415]

Might be all she can afford.

[@stephaniehowe0973]

Flannel & Jeans is common here. Its at Funerals

[@D_Parks]

@@connielikens3415 Stupidest comment ever. I’ve bought designer blouses at thrift shops for $1.50.

[@connielikens3415]

@@D_Parks Thank you! Pretty snobby, huh?? I got ya!!

[@ReggieGurl04]

@@connielikens3415 in a case about paying $1,000 for a dog... hmm...

[@bronwinswartz1112]

Hello from South Africa. This dog is known locally as a boerboel. I adopt I do not shop and am the proud mommy of 3 beautiful adopted babies, a Dachshund, a Morkie (Maltese and Yorkie cross) and an Italian Greyhound. All 3 adopted from the SPCA and I love them to bits. Edgar-O is so right when he says they show you love from day one.

[@DennisMorrison1955]

My goodness that woman's eyes are INSANE!

[@LWWM]

That daughter's 18? Wow, I thought 45.

[@asgb752-belgium7]

You must be legally blind... I feel bad for you

[@dellahicks7231]

You do realize that the woman standing next to her is not her daughter right?

[@putinisageniusdjt1564]

😂😂😂…. I would NOT say 45 but I definitely agree that she doesn’t look 18

[@ryanhogue2917]

I was told by me vet that neutering before 11 months to a year could increase the risks of cancer. I have a rottweiler who is a year old and have scheduled his neutering in March.

[@eileenh28]

None of these people need to have dogs.

[@alexispestorio1600]

I'm disgusted that anyone can breed animals so irresponsibly...breeding should be illegal and should require licensure. There should be a shortage of animals in order to ensure they are all wanted and have a loving home, instead thousands are abused and abandoned everyday. This woman who is inbreeding these animals is TRASH.

[@katalina1699]

Exactly she is repulsive poor dog's

[@EncantaMiVida]

Plaintiff is mad that the defendant neutered the dog because she wanted to breed the dog point blank

[@RiddleTales]

Dogs become weaker and are more prone to sickness once neutered. To neuter as late as possible or not at all is what is best for the healthy for the animal.

[@jolenetoscano4414]

The defendant actually said she was never offered another dog, then produced evidence saying she did...how did the judge miss that!!?

[@tinathomas3288]

Yes totally lied

[@CA-ew2om]

How did this case even make it to the people’s court. Although I’ve seen worse at least this one was a bit entertaining 😂

[@sebastianabsolution655]

people's court has been bad as of late. just bad cases w/ milian monologue throughout the case just 2 keep it goin. paid actors are hard 2 find.

[@mikesteele05]

@@sebastianabsolution655 they’re not paid actors. These are real lawsuits. Production has scouts that look through pending lawsuits and contact the litigants asking if they’d like to settle their cases on the show in exchange for an appearance fee. I’ve been contacted by the show to appear based on a lawsuit I filed, and I got a big old envelope in the mail with Milian’s face as the return address. 😂

[@sebastianabsolution655]

@@mikesteele05 yikes. that must've been scary.😏😏

[@HeatherWho11.10]

@@sebastianabsolution655 I've had family members on this show. My grandma and uncle sued my cousin and her husband, and I know theirs was completely real. But I've seen cases that seem fake, so I wouldn't be surprised if some of them were.

[@sebastianabsolution655]

@@HeatherWho11.10 there you go. reality tv.

[@RileyCullen1]

My daughter named her hamster Toast.

[@stormy6454]

My friend has 2 cats named Fish Stix & Tarter Sauce.

[@casid9929]

Not supposed to neuter over sized breeds until they are grown 12-18 months. If you research why neutering at 6 months began, that was age puppies could survive anesthesia.

[@AP-uo7sp]

Puppies can survive anesthesia at 5 lbs. Having them fixed is usually a shelter/rescue rule. They want to be sure accidental pregnancy doesn't happen. Most purebred owners wait until 18-24 months.

[@KreamyKoncrete]

@@AP-uo7sp if you can’t keep your dogs from getting breeding, you probably shouldn’t be a dog owner. An accidental pregnancy is Similar to a dog attacking another animal, in the sense you arent properly in control of your dog. Sex organs are as important to the overall health of an animal as any other organ. JMHO.

[@imwastedenough]

@@KreamyKoncrete same can be said for humans.

[@elegantfashion160]

These people are creepy

[@jackfisher3906]

Once the defendant purchased the Dog, it is her possession and she can do whatever the hell she wants with it.

[@minipoopuu12340]

The plaintiff look like she gonna have a nervous breakdown🤦🏽‍♂️

[@DC45193]

True lol

[@legatoblues13]

Drugs

[@Mr.EmeraldTheGreen]

I just don’t get it. Breeder INBREEDS her dogs,, that’s wrong. Then has a mange problem, but the woman adopted the dog anyway. I hope his passing was quick and painless. I hope this breeder quits breeding, but probably won’t, all this could be avoided by adopting from a shelter or a rescue.

[@ashleyquam]

$1000 for an in bred dog?! Say what?!

[@Monika-bc3dq]

Only 24 seconds passed and I know she's going to lose...

[@thina5918]

This was one of the most pointless court cases ever. 😂😂

[@Ommizal23]

Why does the plaintiff's facial expressions tell a different story from her words😂 she got "dizzy rollercoaster" eyes

[@sufferedlearnedchanged]

That little Hawaii party was so cute. 😂

[@NicholasBlake84]

A Sad event and two people who frankly don't know the legal system going at each other because someone else told them they should. Neither seemed to really know what they wanted.

[@iris-nx1wt]

I have this same kind of dog... sometimes this intestine thing happens with big dogs if they move to much to soon after they eat, sometimes.

[@CuriousGoodsJessica]

My boss's dog had to have a surgery for that (before the intestines got twisted or whatever) because they told her it was likely to happen since he's very active, he's an Australian Shepherd. So scary for the poor doggies!

[@iris-nx1wt]

@@CuriousGoodsJessica yes my friend lost her big dog to this 2 summers ago.

[@KreamyKoncrete]

Dog in my avi is a Boerboel

[@iris-nx1wt]

@@KreamyKoncrete sweet! My dogs name is Logan he just turned 2.

[@emc4870]

Exactly.

[@AlanFisher1970]

Why does this seem like a PUPPY MILL that needs to be put down and arrested

[@DC45193]

Stop judging lol

[@Play4keeks]

You are 100٪ correct! Why would inbreeding be an issue for an ethical breeder?

[@ninjadogs3389]

@@Play4keeks Exactly if she were an ethical breeder and were breeding dogs that had a family history of healthy dogs with no genetic issues then inbreeding is actually safer then breeding unrelated individuals. I a line has no genetic issues you can safely say that breeding within the family wont lead to any surprising genetic outcomes from recessive genes. In breeding just any dog should never be done though, you have to know the whole family history and health of the family of the dam and sire who will be breeding.

[@alicia0830]

Everyone is pushing shelter dogs in the comments, and that’s great, I totally agree. My first puppy I adopted when I was out on my own was from a shelter. I had him a week and he started having seizures. Took him to the vet: distemper. Had to put him down. It was heartbreaking. Turns out the shelter was knowingly adopting out dogs and cats who had parvovirus and distemper. I contacted the local media who did an investigation and the shelter got shut down. The experience was so awful though, so 6 months later I adopted a puppy from a breeder. We just put him down last year after he lived a long and happy 18 years. We’re not planning on getting another dog any time soon, but we’re sure our daughter will want one when she’s older (she’s 3), and if she does we’ll go to the shelter. So please don’t be too harsh on people who get dogs from breeders. Sometimes they have a very good reason.

[@arinalis3130]

Plaintiff trying to get something out of nothing. Greedy much.

[@emc4870]

Before people on this show make comments and judgements they should speak to an expert instead of what their opinion is. 🤷🏼‍♀️ New research is showing giant breed dogs need to wait until they are finished growing to be neutered which would be around 18 months to 2 years. This is also not a condition that comes from inbreeding, this happens to lord and lots of dogs specifically large breed barrel chested breeds. There are guidelines a LOT of breeders have about being able to breed or not breed, fix or not fix. This would have been a good one for judge Judy who knows a lot about breeding and dogs. On a different subject, she should not be breeding dogs if she can’t stop them from inbreeding.

[@mickm6309]

Thank you for an intelligent answer. Hopefully the information can be passed onto reputable vets.

[@KreamyKoncrete]

👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾

[@Play4keeks]

But why would the breeder sue now?

[@arianefr78]

I find, after watching many episodes of People's court, that people don't answer the questions the judge asks, I find it very infuriating...

[@sakutasu]

A Mastiff is a large dog breed . For large dogs that are very prone to orthopedic injury/diseases we now recommend waiting to neuter until 9-18 months of age.

[@stormy6454]

I read somewhere the "pounds" were overwhelmed after Covid. People got pets when staying home, real life comes back & they just dropped them off. Crazy.

[@casadekreeftpetservices8222]

18-24 months is normal for a giant breed to make sure joints close properly.

[@stephenbanks5952]

Neither of them should be having dogs or breeding dogs. The plaintiff's dogs are inbred and have mange and the defendant neutered the dog too early despite being told not to. Those poor dogs. Shame on them.

[@Shaikhofilm]

This case was definitely based on spite- hatred between the litigants, not anything legitimate. In the previous litigation, warranty is different from guarantee. The plaintiff could have refused to do anything, and then if she lost, would have to give her a replacement, which she is willing to do in the first place.

[@DonziGT230]

The "no neutering" condition lends evidence toward the accusation that the plaintiff wanted to have breeding rights to the dog, otherwise there would be no reason to put that condition on the deal.

[@sherrycarroll8103]

Who would pay 1000 for any dog when the shelters have so many gorgeous , wonderful one. I've only adopted from rescue facilities

[@ldcole90]

Doug said, "Out of spite".... too savage....lol

[@sarahcostolo272]

I wouldn’t be able to look at them in the eye😂😂😂

[@evanscott9473]

That's what they call, 'Double Jeopardy'.

[@KrazyVideoChick]

The Plaintiff looks like she was cross bred

[@sylviabrown7225]

That’s what these breeders get only trouble they have no business making money off these poor dogs

[@Indygrandma56]

Defendant comes in with chip on shoulder and makes her looks bad

[@MichelleLeah]

The lumber jack shirt doesn’t help her either🧐 it’s court

[@Indygrandma56]

@@MichelleLeah true!!

[@granitemoss1451]

True, but I think I understand where she's coming from. She already lost the puppy, paid all those vet bills on a dog that died, and lost her case against the Plaintiff. It boggles the mind that the breeder is now suing HER, over a supposed clause that isn't in the contract. I'd probably be fed up and testy, too.

[@Indygrandma56]

@@granitemoss1451 I agree I laughed when they said plaintiff wants money back..wth😂😂

[@keezjordan1619]

Big dogs will get so nervous and upset their insides turn and twist. Life threatening!

[@alij6940]

I only watch for Doug! Lmao

[@glenncurley680]

I have 2 Cats they were abandon Kittens living under my porch. They chose me and we all love each other and have a great life!

[@wooddome87]

The reason for the 18 month desex could be because there was in fact a breeding clause, hence the lawsuit. The only possible way the plaintiff is damaged is because she couldn’t get another inbred litter from the defendant. How is that not a point of contention for the judge?

[@dbabies82]

You're not making any sense... You want larger breeds to be spayed/neutered at over 18 months old because altering them early can cause severe joint problems and diseases... So issues concerning hips, patellas, knees, etc can effect them early on. By simply waiting, you help eliminate early onset of certain conditions. The breeder knows this so told them to wait before altering. And inbreeding means breeding between 2 siblings or between a parent and child. If they had the dog, there wouldn't be more inbreeding.

[@wooddome87]

I don’t know how my comment “makes no sense”. I wasn’t advocating for any of that merely offering a theory. What you stated doesn’t address the issue I raised of how the plaintiff is damaged. And if the defendant’s dog were to breed with one of the plaintiff’s dogs then there would be a very high chance of inbreeding. It doesn’t seem like she gives a you know what about the gene pool in her dogs....ya know?

[@hall0341]

The desex was performed on the first dog, which was not alleged by either party to have retained breeding rights.

[@khalea1651]

How is the daughter saying that she doesn't want to come up and testify when SHE bought the dog

[@citygirlingraham]

Why would she buy an inbred dog???? I would run in the other direction. And why would this plantiff have inbreeding in her dogs. This is why I will NEVER get a pure breed dog again. I personally have bought a husky from a husky breeder and it was a disaster. Shelter dogs are the best!!!!!!

[@greener336]

@eddiesaviary.com There should be no dog breeders.

[@ninjadogs3389]

@@greener336 Then there would be eventually no dogs, a correction to what you said should be there should be no irresponsible dog breeders. w/o dog breeders there would be no reliable working dogs, such as police k9s, seeing eye dogs, assistant dogs, dogs that can smell for disease, search and rescue dogs. not all dogs in shelters are cut out for these jobs, and it costs a lot of money to raise and train dogs for these, would be a shame to put that money into the dog for them to fail their test to see if they can graduate to being a working dog.

[@teshuahyisreal158]

Judge: How are you entitled to the money Plaintiff: O E A

[@missyrose2154]

If she’s old enough to buy a dog she should be old enough to testify . That 18 year old should have been made to testify if she in fact purchased the puppy. Who cares if she is too distressed to go up there 🙄 Judge took it too easy on her

[@bovinityleak2066]

18 months to neuter is ludicrous. Six months is the absolute norm and a vet wouldn’t do the surgery if it wasn’t appropriate.

[@darlacummings12]

I've had several Great Danes which are comparable in size to Mastiff's. NO vet around here will spay or neuter until they're at least 12 months old.