Youth, Social Constructionism and Governance | Muhammad Anwar and Dr. Pervez Hoodbhoy

[@pervaizalam6191]

Great mind❤

[@gillgarry1442]

Good sir hoodbhoy. Love from India 🇮🇳

[@AzMo836]

It isn't only religions which can cause problems. Any extreme can be a problem. Nationalism can be just as bad.

[@saeedr7863]

Dr sahib, why we want to wipe out all identities leaving only pak identity? people have right to have ethnic, religious, linguistic, and other different identities. If we agree on basics. I mean if we accept constitution of pak, then different identities are just choices and we have right to choose.

[@MadugalaEshwar]

Dr.Sab no one can explain & understand Pakistan the way you describe

[@rakeshyadav3165]

Sir pakistan me mutayla pakistan pdhaya jata but other cuntry ?

[@rakeshbarman3486]

I lost respect for hoodbhoy when he was questioned about if ahmedi are muslims , so much for humanity ,rationalism etc and he was avoiding it and couldn't say directly ahmedi are muslims , shame that such a intellectual doesn't have courage to do that

[@MunawarAzaad2025]

I have saved the video on John Eliya uploaded recently to Watch later. But i cant find it now. I just seen a small cut of it. It was great conversation. Please reload it again. Is Black Hole is threatened due to that program???. Please upload it again or inform about its where about and reasons to delete it. If there is security problem, can you please provide link privately. Thank you

[@simlyexplain]

Silicon Valley is now working revolutionize agriculture and food production with precision farming and data and genetic information to create meat, cosmetics, etc in factory labs)

[@saeedr7863]

Dr sahib, situation of basic sciences is not bad only in pk but in the whole world. Because there is no demand in market for science degrees other than teaching.

[@secularbalochrationalist]

Dr parvez hoodbhoy 👍

[@HimanshuShukla0802]

Pervez Hoodbhoy actually don't know what the meaning secularism not only Nehru even Maulana Himself was not secular not called himself Secular even Indian official constitution was not mentioned word secularism. Second , first of all Hoodbhoy must understand that making ministers in cabinet on the basis of religion is not secularism. And the second thing , secularism is the concept of separation State from religion that's not mean you should make thousands of religions candidate in cabinet on the basis of religion. Maulana Azad was not a competent men for that post . We consider Nehru era as a dark of our history who not only signed for partition but given Kashmir to Pakistan and China. He nationalised businesses which demolished over whole growth for decades.

[@nareshjoshi123]

bravo congratulates to you yesterday my comment on nehru , article 370 removed bitter truth never accepted

[@jashoke5790]

India is very secular today that is the reason for our progress Dr Sab your programs are very helpful but when it comes to India you are far out of touch

[@anujay81]

On question about future opportunities for youths, Dr. Hoodbhoy's Thandi Aahen indicated Hatashaa.

[@ibratnak]

Hoodbhoy gave examples of India and Israel and then tried to twist their development into his own little narrative. Being a security state or being founded for a particular religious community is not as bad as Hoodbhoy or other truth fairies want you to believe. What you'll observe in India and Israel is that they own their country's fascism. Graduates of IIT and Tel Aviv University realize that the only truth that matters is one that serves national interest, while graduates of Karachi Grammar School are under the delusion that absolute truth supersedes everything. I challenge Hoodbhoy to go to India and call Modi a fascist. For every flaw these truthiyas find in Pakistan, there is an example elsewhere of successful governance under that same model (authoritarianism, security state, discrimination etc). The people in those models talk less and do more, while fartistanis are windbags that believe self-loathing and self-hate will magically fix our problems.

[@raghavrrs]

The problem with your argument is, they’re not the ruling class. They have not ruled Pakistan. And what Dr. Hoodbhoy has done and achieved in his career is far more than what you could ever dream of. And I can’t speak for Israel but I as an Indian can assure you that India is not fascist. The BJP is certainly RW, but those concepts are very different and it has its own kind of secularism, one where there’s less chest-beating. You perhaps HAVE to believe that Muslims are persecuted en masse because it makes you very uncomfortable that otherwise Pakistan has no raison d’etre. It’s a coping mechanism. If you really wish to assess the true situation, just look at the WPL (cricket) that’s going on. Look how many women from religious minorities and disadvantaged sections are playing in a league that amply rewards their hardwork. That’s India.

[@pm6127]

Well, modi gets called a fascist everyday in india..

[@simlyexplain]

Jews have a tradition of questioning for melena

[@anujay81]

Congress kept on appeasement policy for Muslims in India to negate Two Nation theory. By the time BJP came to power such need is not felt as the Two Nation theory has been drowned in the Bay of Bengal By Indira Gandhi.

[@sanjaychauhan1116]

10:27 cha cha BJP ka spokesperson hi ek muslim hai 😂😂😂. Under BJP only Dr APJ abdul kalam become President of india ,under BJP only Atal bihari vajpayee went to pakistan also Modi ji visited pakistan to normalise relation but if pakistan continue to send milit@nt in kashmir nothing will happen .You need to change your mindset towards Modi , the modi hatred clearly seen inside you .BJP is a nationalist party ,whose goal is to make india a developed country and end the appeasement policy towards muslims like congress did .We the people of India elected him as our PM ,who r u to question that

[@anujay81]

Ahmadias were in fore front in creation of Pakistan even first Foreign Minister was Ahmadia who vehemently fought for Kashmir in the UN. Now they don't have place in Pakistan.

[@simlyexplain]

Become a nurse and move abroad. There is a big need for nurses in the rich world

[@syedaamirtufail1546]

love you hoodbhai from maqbooza pakistan 🙄

[@anujay81]

Maqbooza Pakistan!!!

[@utubetruthteller]

when there is no space for free speech the society will always remain backward, most Islamic countries including Pakistan suffer from this limited free speech

[@RNDixit-me5uj]

I fear that this channel might be banned by Army/Establishment as it has started challenging the unchecked and power abuse of Generals!!!

[@ibratnak]

Can you name some channels that were banned recently or is Bhagavad Gita your only source of fake news?

[@anujay81]

To negate the feeling that BJP is anti muslims, Dr APJ Abdul Kalam was made President of India. Doudi Bohras are great supporters of Modiji, not only in India but abroad too. Now BJP is wooing Pasmanda muslims and Sufies, who are less radicals.

[@noirdezzir8424]

Tokenism doesn't mean anything. Next you'd say India is a role model for the rights of tribals and women given its current president, while the fact is that recently India has fallen behind Saudi Arabia in gender equality.

[@ssblgm]

@@noirdezzir8424 It looks like you will not be at ease with the present dispensation anytime soon. Prejudice???

[@shammohansood3112]

Why don't you all muslims of all seakts comes to India and saw how

[@aniruddha453]

Like who are indian watching this channel

[@davidsharma9673]

human being makes humanity, man failed to understand this simple fact .

[@gauravthakar8145]

First one

[@anujay81]

Talibans- Deobandi TLP - Barelvi

[@AbhishekChauhan-rj2wc]

India is more secular in modi government and parvez mkes his own theory about the BJP and India, Since he is retired from learning !

[@noirdezzir8424]

I am an Indian and I apologize for the comment above, which is either a demonstration of ignorance or of dishonesty. Saying India is more secular under Modi is like saying Russia is more democratic than Norway.

[@AbhishekChauhan-rj2wc]

@@noirdezzir8424 librgandu

[@noirdezzir8424]

@@AbhishekChauhan-rj2wc yes, keep proving my point with attacks like this.

[@AbhishekChauhan-rj2wc]

@@noirdezzir8424 what a allegation, liberal is playing a victim card !

[@vikasb1400]

The professor is correct. But he should also respect Engineer Mirza Academy who is having world best Madarsa. Also Pakistan has few top 100 Madarsa in the world.

[@zainrao4059]

Too 100 Among what ? Terrorist production 🤣🤣🤣

[@anees419]

Engineer Muhammad Ali mirza does not have want madrsa.