Handre Pollard?

Morne Steyn should have been here

Ma’a nonu at 12 and Joost over Dupont

Cullen best 15 ever retallick again better than your picks. Fitzpatrick over wood. Edward’s over dupont because of length of service. Furlong better at prop Nonu better than horan And Cullen much better than blanco

SBW at 12. Not even close. 5 Victor Matfield

Kolbe must be first 😂😂👀

Rupeni caucaunibuca and Jonah lomu for wings!💪

You have to be crazy not mentioning morne stern 2008 2009 2011

No Phil Bennet? No Finn Russell? Completely anglo-centric list

Sexton should not be on the list

Cody Taylor instead of Fitzpatrick....twice the player

No 9 ...definitely the late joost van Der westhuizen

Kolisi plays open side and PSDT plays blindside. You have them in the wrong positions.

No Phil Bennet???😢

the list is a joke Habana should be 2 Jonah 1 and Jason should not even on the 15 position list

Robinson played mostly at fullback, so I don't know how he would count as a wing.

Sexton what a joke has won nothing of significance There’s World Cup winning fly halves not even on the list, NH garbage

Finn Russell is better than mouanga

Owen Farrell is not 4th

Still need to see what the hype is about Dupont. Great player win everywhere and everything. Dupont's disciples should put a lid on it.

I am 40yo and this is my opinion on the GOAT 15. 1. Os du Randt 2. Sean Fitzpatrick 3. Jason Leonard 4. John Eales 5. Victor Matfield 6. Thierry Dusautoir 7. Richie McCaw 8. Zinzan Brooke 9. Joost van der Westhuizen 10. Daniel Carter 11. Jonah Lomu 12. Ma’a Nonu 13. Brian O’Driscoll 14. Brian Habana 15. Christian Cullen 16. John Smit 17. Owen Franks 18. Cian Healy 19. Brodie Rettalick 20. George Smith 21. Aaron Smith 22. Johnny Wilkinson 23. Phillip Sella

Wilk best

No disagreement with Carter & Wilkinson as 1 & 2 but Beuaden Barratt at No10, really? And how is Jonathan Davies in there but no Phil Bennett? Larkham deserves to be higher as well.

JOHN KIRWAN ?????

Pollard should definitely be in top 10

You mean best in recent times. South Africa’s Bennie Osler was South Africa famous flyhalf before Naas Botha

What no butch James 😂

stopped watching it, even as an Englishman i cant believe you could leave out Gareth Edwards - Dupont isn't half the player Edwards was, so not worth watching the rest. Too much recency bias

1. DDA, 2. Bundee Aki, 3. Andre Esterhuyzen. 4. Jordie Barrett, 5. Jonathan Danty

what about the rolls royce andre joubert the best full back

Security Reece will outplay 10-3 on most days, and Kolbe is just on fire this year (and for a while now)… while @Damian Penaud is amazing in many ways, I think Kolbe would be my starter….

So subjective. I’d go (only picking players I’ve actually seen - pro era): Du randt Coles Hayman Retalick Matfield Hill McCaw Vermeulen DuPont Carter Habana Horan BOD Sivivatu Cullen

From Argentina, Roncero, Albacete, Pichot and JM Hernandez

1 Lomu 2 Habana 3 Campese 4 Robinson 5 Kolbe 6 Clerc 7 Howlett 8 Williams 9 Penaud 10 Rokocoko

Only person better than Barrett on this list is Carter

To me, wilkinson is the goat (I am french). In addition, you forgot Christophe Lamaison. Just ask to NZ semi final 1999 what they think about him! The best game a fly half played in world cup.

its amazing Lomu never scored against the Springboks

NOPE THATS YOUR TEAM NOT THE WORLD BEST

incredible you did not put hugo porta

Lomu overated. Could never score against rsa. Campo look like a snail against pieter hendrickse

Ritchie McCaw biggest cheat ever

It’s a shame the northern hemisphere countries regard themselves as the greatest of all time. With only one World Cup to show for it. You picked some good players, but not the greatest. How about acknowledging more World Cup winners, South Africa. They were world champions on the field. Not by opinions.

What about Buns, Little and Josh

I think this team would beat that team 1:Woodcock 2:Mealamu 3:O Franks 4:R Brooke 5:Matfield 6:Burger 7:P DuToit 8:H Tuilagi 9:A Smith 10:Carlos Spencer 11:Rupeni Caucau 12:Nonu 13:B Lima 14:Folau 15:Cullen

O Driscoll is only a student compared to the professor if you compare him to Danie Gerber. Gerber was in a class of his own. Best centre ever.

This is the greatest 15. 1. Os du randt 2. Malcolm marx. 3 whoever 4. Bakkies 5 victor 6heinrich brussouw 7 pieter stef 8 duane, 9 fourie du preez, 10 dan carter 11 Jonah lomu 12. Whoever 13 Danie Gerber. 14 Cheslin 15 andre joubert

How the hell do you justify putting Bryan Habana at 4 when he outscored 1,2 and 3??? What else can you score a wing on other than scoring tries??? 9 more than that little squirrel Shane Williams. 3 more than David Campese 29 more than Jonah :omu

NZ, NZ, NZ, NZ - biased much. Lest we remind you that South Africa has 4 WC having only been eligible for 8 so a 50% World Cup winning rate vs New Zealands 3 in 10 or 30% Your side is totally wrong. PSDT, Cheslin Kolbe would walk into an all-time team to say the very least. As usual, no respect!

Ah Hell nah Cheslin kolbe must be first 🤣🤣😎🙏

A world team that excludes both Colin Meades and Afrikaans Du Preez is not quite the best