carmel indiana walk score: 26. roundabouts are good improvements for vehicle safety and great for micro-modal support, but they are generally not a great solution for urban settings, especially not at the sheer quantity that they exist in carmel. there are plenty of acceptable ways to craft streets to be safer for cars but also significantly enhance pedestrian walkability without the use of roundabouts in urban areas
@SophiaWoessner13 сағат бұрын
Never did I expect to get recommended a full video about roads. (That wasn't made by Tom Scott)
@TransitTangentsСағат бұрын
Thanks for clicking on it! Lol. Welcome.
@ianchissy17 сағат бұрын
I think that you can really supercharge a roundabout by adding cheap flashing pedestrian lights- they don’t require a power grid tie-in, as there’s many solar options available now, and it makes a very formal visual “I’m crossing now” statement to oncoming drivers. Roundabouts have a yield to pedestrians that drivers often fail to follow, so making that more explicit is a good idea to enforce legal driving behaviour.
@hobog18 сағат бұрын
Carmel is great but a car is needed to get anywhere outside Carmel
@hobog18 сағат бұрын
Too many new roundabouts in the USA have roads join tangentially and are too big, encouraging unsafe fast traversal. There are also too many with slip lanes. Slip lanes undermine roundabouts for the same reason and for adding conflict points. See Jersey City and Hoboken for great minimal roundabouts Edit: the tangential joins are fine for highways but I've seen them too much in residential/suburb areas with many bikes and pedestrians
@PickleJard19 сағат бұрын
I live VERY close to Carmel (Keystone Parkway is part of my daily drive lmao) and it used to be HELL. Keystone and 31 used to just be pure stoplights and it took me a half hour to get through Carmel (or more). Now? 10 minutes tops. The parkways and roundabouts have dispersed traffic and just made it so nice to drive through. Loved the video!
@physh21 сағат бұрын
Thumbnail typo :D
@TransitTangentsСағат бұрын
Capital/Capitol gets me every time lol. -Louis
@ericbruun902022 сағат бұрын
Very sensible guest. But why do we still have to make the same arguments for decades? The sprawl-industrial complex has outmaneuvered us. In the USA, transit must be voted upon and takes years for an EIS while highways are automatically subsidized. In Helsinki, I have never once had to vote on the several new transit projects since I moved here.
@grahamturner264022 сағат бұрын
Roundabouts don’t necessarily mean no traffic signals, though they only need them under special circumstances. The main use case for traffic signals in American roundabouts is for median transit lines. If there’s a tram line running through the middle, there’s often either a standard traffic light (for streetcars) or railroad gates (if it’s meant to be rapid transit). There are quite a few of those in the Phoenix area.
@TransitTangentsСағат бұрын
Good point! Thanks for watching.
@triaxe-mmb22 сағат бұрын
Everytime i drive or ride around my city and the adjacent ones (Tri-Valley Region in the SF Bay Area), i complain to myself abotu how they have too many 4way stops and signalized intersections when a roundabout woudl work better. Someone should start lobbying the cities around here, lol
@TransitTangentsСағат бұрын
It can start with a simple email to your elected reps/council people!
@bahnspotterEU22 сағат бұрын
5:04 Fun fact about Gdansk: The city is incredibly divided in terms of development patterns. While the older parts are nice and walkable (or even pedestrianised), newer suburban developments are very American in nature, with fast and wide roads, housing subdivisions, totally oversized intersections with lots of empty wasted space, madly long walking routes and sparse, centralised businesses most convenient for car drivers. I was on vacation there most recently in 2023 and really made an effort to see as much of the city as I could, and it was quite startling to see these huge contrasts.
@Lone_Star_LiamLoungeКүн бұрын
I prefer the use of roundabouts not only for the safety but also for the aesthetics of the area. As a former Paramedic-EMT, the majority of vehicular accidents I encountered resulted from some sort of left turn aspect. I do have some concerns with pedestrian crossings but most can be mitigated with proper design.
@TransitTangentsКүн бұрын
Thanks for sharing your experience as a paramedic! I agree on crossings, especially on poorly designed roundabouts, but it is something that can be worked on for sure. Thanks for watching! -Louis
@ianchissy17 сағат бұрын
I think that you can really supercharge a roundabout by adding cheap flashing pedestrian lights- they don’t require a power grid tie-in, as there’s many solar options available now, and it makes a very formal visual “I’m crossing now” statement to oncoming drivers. Roundabouts have a yield to pedestrians that drivers often fail to follow, so making that more explicit is a good idea to enforce legal driving behaviour.
@scpatl4nowКүн бұрын
I don't know why people have trouble with roundabouts. It's pretty easy. All traffic yields to traffic in the roundabout. I think people confuse roundabouts with traffic circles (think DuPont Circle in DC) which can be very intimidating when you are unfamiliar.
@TransitTangentsКүн бұрын
Agreed! But people love to complain about change 😅 Once they use them they start to like the changes though! Thanks for watching!
@jackbates7467Күн бұрын
Big fan of the 15 min city concept, its why I'm moving to the Triangle, so my sports car can stay in a garage and I can take transit everywhere.
@TransitTangentsСағат бұрын
I live near the Triangle and the bike-ability and transit is some of the best in Austin! -Louis
@TransitTangentsКүн бұрын
Want to help support the show? 1. Tell Your Friends. 2. Become a member on Patreon and get access to next week's episode right now! patreon.com/transittangents
@superbrownsheep3777Күн бұрын
I am a resident in Carmel and while I am grateful for the roundabout, our city is facing an issue regarding the future of transportation. There’s been discussion back and forth on transit in Carmel for years. The city used to have an Indy Express bus which got discontinued in 2014. Then in 2016 there were initial plans for the red line to extend into Carmel but that didn’t go through. Carmel plans on operating its own bus system soon but now it’s also being killed off by the recently elected Mayor Sue Finkham. The population of Carmel is over 100K which is large. There’s also much more mixed use development within its city center than before and that is why Carmel needs a Bus system. I want to advocate for transit in carmel, however I do not know anyone in my city which supports transit
@TransitTangentsКүн бұрын
Thanks for sharing your experience! We'll have to look more into the transit side. Maybe a topic for a future episode. Thanks for watching!
@troywootton84582 күн бұрын
I'm glad that you like the transit system overall. There is one thing that you could have done that would have saved you a walk up the hill to the Capitol the Capitol building is located in the free fare zone so you could take in a bus from downtown up to the Capitol building but just think you would have missed memory Grove. That was the part that you were in that you said reminded you of a Hallmark movie and that used to be my neighborhood so I know that area very well. I am going to make one correction the FrontRunner system is considered a regional rail system because it not only brings the commuters from the suburbs it also incorporates areas that are further away.
@TransitTangentsСағат бұрын
Thanks for watching! We did a more recent video discussion the Rio Grande Plan among other SLC related items you might be interested in!
@mjohnson95632 күн бұрын
I moved to Austin from Denver 11 years ago and thus am familiar with the whole up and coming of light rail. In the end the biggest push comes from lousy traffic and that is what had happened in Denver. Nowadays they have a very large light rail network in which large light rail trains are always full to the max with rush hour commuters. So for Austin the question is how to build for the future when Austin will double in size and is part of a region from Waco to San Antonio which has a current population of around 6.8 million and is expected to add an additional 6 million in the next 25 years. In the end it is just a matter of time and things can only be done one step at a time.
@TransitTangentsКүн бұрын
Agreed! Fingers crossed we get there... Thanks for watching!
@lalodaniels13884 күн бұрын
Light Rail failed in Austin in the past because of paranoid pathological liars like Alex Jones scaring everyone into thinking that any ideas that incorporated public transport were secret plans by the Illuminati and the UN to take over America. I remember listening to that dude back in the day go on and on about Agenda 21, just like they go on about the 15-minute city today. Thankfully with people like Alex Jones completely discredited and bankrupt, I think that it should be a lot easier to have a sensible transportation plan for Austin without having paranoid wackos protest it.
@CasualScrub4 күн бұрын
I'm relatively conservative but I'm massively in support of transit. Once you realize how incredibly inefficient car dependent infrastructure is for growing cities, you will want your government to stop spending so much money on it!
@CasualScrub4 күн бұрын
Also, something this video doesn't touch on is the idea that urban sprawl is a threat rural lifestyles. I know there are many farmers and hunters in Florida who are upset with how much of the land they love gets destroyed for bland suburban housing developments. Hunters and farmers not only tend to be right leaning, but they also usually were raised in a car dependent, rural area. They will likely see transit as useless because from their perspective it always has been. But when you put it in the broader context of urban density protecting rural lifestyles, I think you can get a lot more people on your side.
@realquadmoo5 күн бұрын
I wanna see more ads and better marketing from transit agencies, specifically targeting and disproving the assumptions that it’s just a nasty sticky vehicle filled with poor people, because a lot of people think it is that way, and they would literally rather die than step foot in a bus
@tigerphid96775 күн бұрын
Public transit is not freedom. Cars are freedom - go wherever you want whenever you want. Go directly from Point A to Point B. Sounds good to me.
@danielkelly22105 күн бұрын
Nah, cars are not freedom. They have massive negative externalities.
@CasualScrub5 күн бұрын
Due to the cost of owning a car alone, I feel heavily restricted. That's not even considering how unpleasant car dependent infrastructure is for living,which makes it even worse. In rural areas yes, cars are freedom. In cities they're steel cages of traffic hell
@pavld3354 күн бұрын
I've lived in places where I had to own a car. That is not freedom.
@WilConquer6 күн бұрын
Why are we still talking about shared right away bussing. It does not work. We need rail.Due to work home for me is DC, Columbus and Houston these cities could not be more Austin needs to get real bussing is not your solution.
@TransitTangents5 күн бұрын
Buses are definitely part of the solution. I want rail everywhere too, and we'll start to get some rail here in Austin with Project Connect, but it won't go everywhere at least for a while. Until the rail can cover more ground, buses are the option. There are a few proposals at the moment to create more dedicated bus lanes throughout the city. A few are actually being installed right now along San Jacinto and Trinity for new "rapid" routes, but will have benefits for local routes as well that go through the area. In time, a more complete rail system in Austin, with commuter style service between Austin and San Antonio though should be the goal. And if the state can get on board, adding some high speed options between the TX Triangle cities, etc.... Thanks for watching. -Louis
@WilConquer5 күн бұрын
@TransitTangents I partially understand your argument but Austin has 1 million people, and growing and every year we wait it costs more money. We are so far behind the ball. As an engineer the maintenance for buses and capacity constraints offset other business but rail is a long term strategy.
@jackbates74676 күн бұрын
I have recently started adhering to the speed limit universally, and woah boy is it terrifying in some parts of Austin. So many streets and highways had speed limits dropped to sensible speeds, and so few people are following them.
@jackbates74676 күн бұрын
Can't believe I didn't already know about the Grove, would have toured an apartment there if I'd known. Though looking at it now, pretty expensive with barely half decent transit.
@jackbates74676 күн бұрын
Gonna start using "VaporBahn" all the time now.
@Geotpf7 күн бұрын
There is no way to make public transit spending bipartisan. It is government spending on a shared public good. This is 100% opposite of the Republican philosophy of government, if there is such a thing today (beyond yelling racist and sexist curses). Republicans don't like it because it is a large government expense that doesn't involve men with firearms (IE, not police or military). They also don't like it due to it's shared public nature (as opposed to a private vehicle, which is both privately owned and financed and private in the sense that it is NOT shared). Attempting anything like a bipartisan coalition is a fool's errand.
@TransitTangents7 күн бұрын
I have to disagree a little bit. There needs to be effort at getting some coalition of folks on the right on board with public transportation spending on some level, or else every time political office changes hands, funding is at risk, services are cut, maintenance gets backlogged, etc.... then when it switches back we play catch up, etc... etc.... Framing the conversations differently can make a big difference there and I think that Bill explains that pretty well here. In addition, I'll make the argument that roads are a large government expense that are a shared public good. Gas tax and car registrations don't even get close to covering the maintenance costs. Folks on the right generally support roads. At a certain point, everyone is going to realize that you won't be able build your way out of traffic, especially in cities. Getting behind these other options will eventually be the only thing that makes sense. If we can make that argument sooner rather than later, it's a win. Thanks for watching and I appreciate the perspective. -Louis
@Geotpf2 күн бұрын
@@TransitTangentsWell, you're wrong. Especially in the Trump era, there's no compromising with the right. Very few Republicans take transit and that's not going to change, so they won't support it. They will support new roads begrudgingly because they drive on them. But transit, nope. If Trump wins in the election in two days, especially if he gets a Republican majority in both Houses of Congress as well, expect Federal transit funding to drop to zero or nearly so for the next four years.
@jonathanmangum43477 күн бұрын
TRANSIT = BASED AMERICA FREEEEEDUUUUUMMMMMMMMM HECK YEAHHHH AMERICA NEEDS TO BE NUMBER 1 IN TRAINSSSSS AND BUSESSSSS HELLLLLL YEAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHhhhhhhh, TRAINS & GUNS (and responsible gun ownership) are my god given right
@scottmelons7 күн бұрын
The Not in My Backyard generation never fails to keep Austin from reaching its potential as a world class city. So disheartening to hear there are lawsuits against something that will raise the quality of life of the entire city so greatly. A bill to introduce transit connectivity to Austin from round rock was sadly successfully struck down. This community feels so isolated and far from downtown because of its lack of connectivity. Myself and so many others would absolutely love to have the OPTION to get downtown by rail, like Leander has with the red line, from ALL the metro areas. But sadly the oldest generation with the wealth to strike down any quality of life improvements seems to constantly have the upper hand.
@qjtvaddict7 күн бұрын
Stop letting people file these lawsuits have him declared as a vexatious litigant use this against NIMBYS
@jackbates74677 күн бұрын
Barton Springs truly was the example of how not to make a bike lane. Rode around to every BCycle station a while back and that was by far the most terrifying part, constantly transitioning from the asphalt to concrete part of the lane. About to ride start riding to all the new stations, looking forward to riding Barton Springs again and the many other infrastructure upgrades around town.
@TransitTangents7 күн бұрын
Yes! It is sooo much better now. If you are interested in a sneak peak, we rode it as part of last week's episode (Austin Using ONLY Transit). Thanks for watching! -Louis
@jackbates74677 күн бұрын
As someone who commutes partially on a CapMetro eBike. Really helpful for making a tight connection to the train. I'm a big fan, can't wait till they finish the rollout of new stations.
@TransitTangents7 күн бұрын
Support Transit Tangents and get access to early episodes, bonus content and more now on Patreon! Also don't mind the crooked camera in this one 😅. Filmed during last week's episode (Austin Using Only Public Transit) and we weren't able to carry the second tripod all day! Https://patreon.com/TransitTangents
@qjtvaddict7 күн бұрын
Ok why not do your LRT lines elevated so they can run faster and more frequently? Building in the street would cripple the trains.
@TransitTangents7 күн бұрын
@@qjtvaddict Right now they're saying that they will have signal priority throughout, and separated space. Initially it was going to be underground downtown.... but inflation, budgets, etc... Obviously that would be better, but given the constraints at the moment and lack of support from state government thus far, you take what you can get and work on making things better over time. From what i understand it will likely be elevated through a few sections near Congress/Riverside, and down Riverside as it crossed I-35. We'll see though. Thanks for watching!
@scpatl4now7 күн бұрын
It's not just Mercedes, State Farm, and NCR all relocated to Atlanta because they were able to have their headquarters located on the MARTA heavy rail line. There is no light rail in Atlanta, but hopefully that will change if we get LRT on the Beltline. There are 2 BRT lines under construction, but we will have to see how much they adhere to BRT best practices.
@TransitTangents7 күн бұрын
I think he just misspoke on light rail, they're located by MARTA stations though! We want to make it to Atlanta some point soon! Thanks for watching.
@scpatl4now7 күн бұрын
@@TransitTangents Not only that, but NCR ditched Gwinnett County, a suburb that voted down having MARTA expand there in 2021 to come to Midtown near North Ave. station...sweet!
@qjtvaddict7 күн бұрын
Build more heavy rail it’s more effective
@cornelius7387 күн бұрын
Love Marta, just as good as light rail and better in some ways.
@scpatl4now7 күн бұрын
@@cornelius738 Heavy rail is superior. It's just quite a bit more expensive to build.
@petersavage50088 күн бұрын
I went on the Streetcar Network in New Orleans. It was fun. A mix of Old and New Streetcars (Green cars old Red New cars). It was great.
@TransitTangents7 күн бұрын
We actually rode them on an episode a few weeks back! kzbin.info/www/bejne/iYbMfnaHipZqhJIsi=Kdq3dOF0bv5i5jdU
@alexisdespland49398 күн бұрын
marta is a heavy rail subway not light raill oops.
@TransitTangents7 күн бұрын
Good catch, minor mistake, but the point still stands 😅 Thanks for watching!
@njv12348 күн бұрын
Fix i35 first
@mark21028 күн бұрын
Can't help but notice that literally nobody else was using the cycle lanes. I can bet my kidney it's because of how hot it is. Texan planners need to consider the obvious fact that Texas isn't as cold as other transit friendly Europeas. People aren't gonna use the cycle lanes if there's no shelter from the sun. Wide open cycle paths on scorching hot asphalt with zero shade is just not the answer, sorry 😢.
@TransitTangents8 күн бұрын
To be fair, this was at like 1pm on a weekday. There is a counter installed on that street now and it sees high hundreds per day in one direction from what I can remember. It is also no where close to one of the busier bike lanes or paths in the city, although numbers have gone up since they made it safer. Is it hot in the summer? Totally, but especially with e-bikes (Austin has a rebate program on them), its actually not too bad and has been growing in popularity anecdotally at least. Plenty of work to be done still though. Thanks for watching
@SageJustice19699 күн бұрын
You forgot to mention Cincinnati, which has the oldest continually operating farry in the country. It's run since 1786.
@kelseyhuse10 күн бұрын
LOUIS IS RIGHT, JENI'S >>>> AMY'S!!!! (Jeni's is from Ohio but.... it's just so good). However, I will forgive Chris because he did get you to finally eat Raising Cane's.
@Tolya197910 күн бұрын
Mr. Tangents, you forgot to mention the added entertainment-utility value provided by the colorful personalities emoting while riding public transit. Or, you may consider that priceless...
@Why_ask_11 күн бұрын
Used to live in Austin, don’t hold your breath. The current state of affairs is desired by the realtors and other folks who run the town. This is not the first time Austin has tried to bring rails trails etc into fruition, corruption always wins.
@kenhunt515311 күн бұрын
A very car dependent City. Single occupancy is the norm. Aggressive driving. If you are at a crosswalk be careful. So many German brands that have drivers who speed. It would suck waiting for a bus in 95° heat. You should have had more light rail years ago. Now, it's up to the $illions. Widening 35 is comical. The work they are doing now between Austin and San Antonio is old school thinking. You need to get people to live closer to where they work, shop and play. Zoning is either SF or podium buildings. Very few options. If you think it's hot and dry in Austin now, wait 10 years.
@TransitTangents11 күн бұрын
The city is taking a lot of the right steps. A lot of zoning related changes over the last year, incentivizing transit oriented development along the light rail corridors now before construction even starts, major investments in bike infra with really good ebike rebate programs at the same time (anecdotally a lot more folks biking/e-biking over the last few years).We'll see.... -Louis
@highway2heaven9111 күн бұрын
It kind of makes me wonder is the average person really wants to drive everywhere or is it because they’re forced to because of the way everything in North America is designed. Do the people really want highways or just the governments and corporations?
@guy-claudeeleka535112 күн бұрын
3:02 why does Austin has the same shape as Algeria 😭😭🙏🏾
@GumbyStrafe12 күн бұрын
Looking forward to the future of Austin! I’ve taken the rail from Howard into downtown. Then took buses to the library. Most pleasant experience, 10/10 better than driving.
@TransitTangents12 күн бұрын
Yes the experience on the red line is great! Austin with a complete Project Connect will be pretty amazing!
@StLouis-yu9iz12 күн бұрын
Question, why does it say Chrisjonesatx towards the beginning of the video the first time chris talks.
@kelseyhuse10 күн бұрын
that's his twitter handle
@suzanneschreiner514512 күн бұрын
What a great topic to cover and not one that is seen often in urbanist coverage. Maybe you guys could come back sometime and ride along with the kids to the places they are able to go? I'd be curious to hear from a couple of parents, too, about their take.
@RyanS3212 күн бұрын
Love the Transit app. Started out using it when I lived in San Antonio, and I use it still in Houston.
@EmeraldCrimsonShadowPeach2K513 күн бұрын
Number 1 should have been Elon Musk.
@robotempire13 күн бұрын
11:10 are these protected bike lanes? I thought “protected” meant they were physically shielded from cars encroaching on the bike lane
@TransitTangents13 күн бұрын
Very fair question. I feel like the term protected gets used very loosely (I'm guilty of it too). Currently the city would consider this to be protected. I fully recognize that this wouldn't stop a car from crashing through, but setups like this really do a lot to slow drivers down, and make the bike lanes more visible. Right now the strategy Austin is using is doing as much "quick build" type stuff like this as fast as possible in as many areas as possible, with the goal of then upgrading them to more permanent (and protected) solutions when larger road construction is required in the area to save on costs. In a budget constrained world, I actually support the approach. It's gotten us a lot more of these quick build setups all around the city. Great question and maybe a topic for a longer episode! I'll mark this one to be discussed in a quick comment response on Patreon as well. -Louis