I gave up on using the soil and just use the hydroponic fertilizer and water for my bin plants. Less weight, mess, costs, and I have clean plants ready to trade to the fish stores for fish and food.
@jonisolis964522 сағат бұрын
I have noticed that many potting soils and compost in bags is not that great anymore since they try to keep making the product cheaper to make so they can make more money on it. Many have a lot of un-composted wood in them in the way of chips, pieces, and sawdust. All of this needs nitrogen in order to decompose so it robs your plants of nitrogen while it is breaking down. You can add more fertilizer to this kind of potting soil and that will help.
@jonisolis964523 сағат бұрын
He you yet tried this fertilizer in your aquarium with fish and shrimp? How that go? thanks
@fallkruzКүн бұрын
i see on the internet that anubias can grow at 6-8 pH. but i want to know by your experience, what is the best pH and PPM level for anubias? thankss
@ruckus1745Күн бұрын
Where abouts are you from? I’m from southern Ontario and I thought I heard you say on one of your other vids you may be close! Great vids!
@aquariumsatbptv33502 күн бұрын
Im jealous, your so lucky to have that healthy crypts
@sa.miguel3 күн бұрын
I noticed that Jack's Nutrients 5-12-26 Part A contains 0.015% copper. I found that copper can be toxic to aquatic organisms, including fish and invertebrates. What can I do to prevent the plants from contaminating the aquarium?
@berenicehickey97553 күн бұрын
Very good vid! Subbed!
@jomaripitallo87214 күн бұрын
What kind of lights are you using?
@Dev-lc4cd6 күн бұрын
Why would an emersed condition present a bottleneck to nutrition access? The nutrition is in the water, and it has constant access to the water in all three condotions.
@emreucar7476 күн бұрын
Results?
@chrisso197310 күн бұрын
Your work deserves so much more attention than it gets. Please keep working on these great experiments and analyses; your work is the best out there for quantifiable outcomes. Thank so much!!!
@fistofthenorthstar901010 күн бұрын
hay. I built this system and hated it. I ran into a lot of problems partly because i tried making it a aquaponics system. But it did inspire a better way for me to do things. I would love to share it with you. is there some way for me to email you a video
@danielthompson320521 күн бұрын
Would love to share pics but ... Utube comments :(
@Widquatics21 күн бұрын
yeah fair enough, you could always shoot me an email with some pics, would love to see your setup! [email protected]
@danielthompson320521 күн бұрын
I did the same ages ago, it's great for my red root floaters. It was a set up for endless but plants are going off in the shade house. Using basics PVC joiners and looking at a bubbler lift. Nt Queensland. australia
@Widquatics21 күн бұрын
Nice, the use of air lifts should work well I imagine as long as the different levels aren't too high. And I agree, the red root floaters and all the other floating plants have really exploded since this video, specifically the dwarf water lettuce!
@steve-adams22 күн бұрын
I once lost a crazy amount of salts by trying to pre-mix a highly concentrated batch for ease of use later on. I blended three separate stock solutions together and boom, a whole bunch of impossible-to-dissolve stuff fell out of solution and the entire batch was ruined. That was a hard learning experience, haha. The word for the chemical reaction occurring is precipitation for anyone interested. I suppose technically you could dissolve the precipitates with an acid or something, then dilute the solution and correct the ph. I don't know if it's worthwhile, or how direct the path would be from precipitate -> acid -> solution -> back to usable fertilizer.
@Widquatics21 күн бұрын
Haha oh yeah I've done the exact same thing, luckily it wasn't too much wasted nutrients but hey, it's all part of the learning process.
@aarox22 күн бұрын
Whats a good height between the top of the tub and the lights? Seems like you have about 8 inches? Or does it depend on the light strength?
@Widquatics22 күн бұрын
I'm not 100% sure what the best height would be, I would imagine it would depend on the strength and spread of the light that you are using. For this setup the height is around 7ish inches, but that is only because I wanted to fit five tubs on the rack and that was the height I was left with after evenly spacing each shelf. Hope that makes sense, Thanks for watching! :)
@jutancross766622 күн бұрын
Thanks for the Videos! Will be following along.
@Widquatics22 күн бұрын
Thanks for watching!
@Seanmmvi22 күн бұрын
Hi Jordan, do you think you could propagate an Anubias and sell it in 30 days?
@Widquatics22 күн бұрын
Hey Sean, I just crunched the numbers on this based on the data collected from my previous anubias experiment. Based on the relative growth rate determined for the highlight grown plants, you should be able to double the size of an anubias plant in around 2 months (58 days to be exact). So, in other words taking a 10g plant, cutting it in half, in around 2 months you would have two plants both 10g in weight. Alternatively, if you cut the 10g plant into three equal pieces, it would take ~3 months (93 days) for those pieces to grow to 10g. It takes a bit longer because the starting size is smaller but you would end up with 3 anubias plants in 3 months, so in a round about way that averages to 1 per 30 days. Realistically, a lot of other variables would impact the growth rate but it gives a rough idea on what is possible. Thanks for watching!
@Seanmmvi22 күн бұрын
Hey Jordan, do you think it is feasible to propagate a Anubias and sell it 30 days later?
@Widquatics22 күн бұрын
Hey Sean, I just crunched the numbers on this based on the data collected from my previous anubias experiment. Based on the relative growth rate determined for the highlight grown plants, you should be able to double the size of an anubias plant in around 2 months (58 days to be exact). So, in other words taking a 10g plant, cutting it in half, in around 2 months you would have two plants both 10g in weight. Alternatively, if you cut the 10g plant into three equal pieces, it would take ~3 months (93 days) for those pieces to grow to 10g. It takes a bit longer because the starting size is smaller but you would end up with 3 anubias plants in 3 months, so in a round about way that averages to 1 per 30 days. Realistically, a lot of other variables would impact the growth rate but it gives a rough idea on what is possible. Thanks for watching!
@Vitamin_Pudding_The_President23 күн бұрын
i hope your channel grows fast because the content is gold
ship some plants to Netherlands xD I pay my self silly buying them
@Widquatics23 күн бұрын
I wish lol I was just in the Netherlands a few months ago, I could have brought you some! 😜Beautiful country btw
@SpyrhoTheOneManArmy23 күн бұрын
@Widquatics aaah damn when your coming back xD
@se590823 күн бұрын
very interesting and helpful video - thx for your efforts!
@Widquatics23 күн бұрын
Thanks for watching! :)
@drewschmidt631423 күн бұрын
You could do a soil analysis to see the difference in nutrients between the 2. Great experiment though. Surprising results
@Widquatics23 күн бұрын
Yeah that's a good point, I'd be interested to see those results! Thanks for watching!
@Businessmindedjamaijan26 күн бұрын
Good going. What is the temperature the plants are growing at?
@Widquatics24 күн бұрын
Thanks! I have a small heater in the sump set to around 76f, but the lights also add some heat to the bins above them, which helps keep the plant roots nice and warm for growing.
@alternativeaquascaping51727 күн бұрын
Ive been using a small submersible fogger in my setup for a while, seems to work really well, would love to see a proper test by you though.
@Widquatics24 күн бұрын
Thanks for the great tip! I'll have to play around with that in the future. Could be a good way to keep the humidity high for more finicky plants.
@alternativeaquascaping51724 күн бұрын
@@Widquatics my rotala did NOT like it lol, but buce, crypts, anubias, and ferns seem to be doing really well. I’m getting submersed phenotype expression in all my plants except buce, they seem to know the difference.
@derekfarealz27 күн бұрын
have you done a side by side of your plants fed this way vs not?
@Widquatics24 күн бұрын
No, unfortunately nothing too formal. It would make for a cool experiment to test out some different levels of fertilizers though!
@derekfarealz24 күн бұрын
@@Widquatics pretty plz 🙏
@profeturulz837328 күн бұрын
Arent aquarium ferilizers ok?
@Widquatics24 күн бұрын
Yeah, aquarium ferts work really well too. The hydroponic stuff is quite a bit cheaper though so is worth it if you are planning to grow many plants this way.
@luizsantos41728 күн бұрын
Bro, your content is brilliant! BIg fan here!
@Widquatics24 күн бұрын
Thanks! Really appreciate the support!
@MyFishAreYourFishАй бұрын
Great video! Cheers from Edmonton
@Widquatics24 күн бұрын
Always great to see another fellow Canadian! Thanks for watching!
@LushAquaАй бұрын
Wow
@AlirezaBarzegar-z2nАй бұрын
Great video! I love the way you present your data with graphical diagrams. 👍😊
@Widquatics24 күн бұрын
Thank you! Glad you enjoy :)
@chrisso1973Ай бұрын
Wow! 1 year’s growth! You could make a fortune growing lumps of wood like that, they’d be worth thousands! Quick question - did this tank have CO2 injection?
@Widquatics24 күн бұрын
Haha thanks, I agree the driftwood does look gorgeous covered in plants, if only they grew a bit faster. And yes this tank did have some CO2 injected combined with a soil capped substrate. It ended up working really well!
@chrisso1973Ай бұрын
Awesome!
@Widquatics24 күн бұрын
Thanks!
@chrisso1973Ай бұрын
Not sure if you’ve considered this, but I for one would love to see this same experiment with Bucephalandra. Would you consider it? 😃👍
@Widquatics24 күн бұрын
Yeah, Buce is definitely on my list of plants I want to start growing and experimenting with. Hopefully soon but I think they will do really well in a setup like this
@chrisso1973Ай бұрын
A terrific piece of science. I love both the passion and rigour you put into this work. Thank you for sharing your insights and please keep experimenting!!!❤
@Widquatics24 күн бұрын
Thanks for your support and kind words! I plan on doing many more experiments, the possibilities are endless!
@chrisso1973Ай бұрын
Brilliant work, so, so interesting thank you!
@Widquatics24 күн бұрын
Thanks for watching!
@GeneralSzadekАй бұрын
Just found you yesterday and was hoping for an update of your anubias experiment. Nice!
@Widquatics24 күн бұрын
Perfect timing, thanks for watching! :)
@goldenkiwicompoteАй бұрын
Can’t wait to see the new scapes you do with them! They look fantastic. Question though, do you ever have any sort of Anubias rot? I know you just propagate the ones you have and aren’t introducing new ones so maybe you haven’t experienced it. I wanted to do something similar to what you’ve done here. I ordered a few interesting kinds of Anubias and some of them have suffered from what seems to be rhizome rot.
@Widquatics24 күн бұрын
Thanks! Actually yeah, I've encountered something similar to anubias rot once. It was after I I harvested a bunch of anubias for one of my experiments and kept them in a bucket of water for about a week (which was probably too long) until I had time to propagate them. By the time I got to replanting them their rhizomes were starting to melt, starting from the newest growth and working its way down to the older growth. But once I planted them back into my setup the plants rebounded and sprouted new leaves from the non-rotten portions of rhizomes. In my case I think it was the lack of light that caused them to start to melt/rot. So hopefully in your case it was just some stress from shipping and they will hopefully rebound once you get them into a good setup.
@jeremiahneal3300Ай бұрын
Great job on the stand build!
@jeremiahneal3300Ай бұрын
Way over kill due to how the aquarium distributes its downward force at the perimeter. With the corners directly over the posts it negates almost all of the force on the span.
@Widquatics24 күн бұрын
Yeah, I agree with that logic. That said, it doesn't hurt to over engineer a bit 👍
@Scaperoot79Ай бұрын
Your plants look amazing! Would you use the same fertilizer for a planted tank?
@Widquatics24 күн бұрын
Thanks, yeah in theory it should also work for aquariums, I've been testing it out a bit and so far it seems promising. Of course it would need to be diluted down quite a bit from the full strength stuff.
@jlathem56Ай бұрын
All that data is interesting but how does the hybrid method compare to the submerged method once the moss is taken fully submerged? I am pretty sure the hybrid method will have less melting than the emerged growth BUT... if there is a significant melting them the emerged method may be better. The end product most likely will be expected to be used submerged and if I have to grow it another 4 weeks for it to convert to fully submerged it may not be worth propagating that way.
@Widquatics24 күн бұрын
That's a good point and would make for a good experiment in the future too!
@dragonsimon1Ай бұрын
Wish you made this a few months ago before I made the stand for my 100. Great vid
@Widquatics24 күн бұрын
ahh bummer lol Thanks for watching regardless! 👍
@levigrech583Ай бұрын
That timber stand looks really good, awesome job Brother im really inspired !
@Widquatics24 күн бұрын
Thanks, I appreciate the support!
@goldenkiwicompoteАй бұрын
I truly hope you plan to fill that with all the Anubias you’ve propagated.
@Widquatics24 күн бұрын
Haha that's the plan! I recently picked up some really nice driftwood so I going to try to cover them in anubias! 😃
@billschwarz1157Ай бұрын
Big jar, window sill, bubble stone, bio-media balls/gravel/sand substrate, rice water, fertiliser, fry powder and a small water change weekly. I keep daphnia, snails (to stop other algae using the nutrients) and blackworm in mine, it's never crashed. Just make sure you're harvesting the livestock, especially the daphnia daily.
@Widquatics24 күн бұрын
Nice! Thanks for the tip. Love that idea of using snails and blackworms to clean up the excess food
@illestproductions2589Ай бұрын
“start by trimming off SOME of the roots” *proceeds to cut them all entirely off*
@Widquatics24 күн бұрын
😂😂
@valjopethmalto3643Ай бұрын
Hey man love your videos, can you make another one about how much proportion and which nutrients is best for plant growth. Thanks man keep doing these types of vids!
@Widquatics24 күн бұрын
Thanks for watching, one of my most recent videos goes into which fertilizer I've recently switched to and covers the proportions. It's the Jack's nutrients hydroponic fertilizer at half strength. It's pretty easy stuff to use, let me know if you have any questions.
@basilrolandАй бұрын
You should space your plants more, the shoots could be bigger with better lighting
@Widquatics24 күн бұрын
Yeah that's a good point, in this case I had way more anubias than I thought so needed to overcrowd the tubs a bit more than is probably ideal.