2022 Golf R vs BMW M240i vs Audi S3 // DRAG & ROLL RACE

[@Fouskotinis]

Even with the "lower production", I still very much enjoyed this. You guys are legends!

[@Conservator.]

This vid had lower production quality? I hadn’t noticed 😝. Fully agree, just love the content!

[@Conservator.]

Please report Luna and Ashley as unwanted spam.

[@laryan_7]

@@Conservator. thank you.

[@matthewhowell7688]

I actually loved the race in the dark. Gave it a Need for Speed Underground vibe

[@pupak3000]

agree, I don't mind seeing more haha

[@itsnot1984anymore]

my thoughts exactly, AND, I think you could get some great footage with a long exposure video, the headlights leaving trails as the cars move u the track, even better with a high camera platform mounted (obviously the drone can't do it because it's moving), comon lads, make it happen. No one else has done it (from what I'm aware).

[@matthew07shquad31]

The M240i is seriously quick,would’ve like to see a cla45 aswell

[@MaGiCz111]

Yeah that be close, I think the new cla45s would take it slightly

[@Maza75]

Nah it’s just the 80HP difference

[@lloyd.8272]

Well it ain’t quick if I can hardly beat a R in a roll. 🤷🏻‍♂️

[@derkingmitdemding1444]

cla 35 would be the competitor

[@DS-pk4eh]

A35 is within this class. A45 is more with M2 and RS3.

[@kwillee93]

Don’t care about overhead drone shots or seeing the sweat bead down from James’ face, I come for the content and the drone fishing. Great video as always! Really excited for all the new offerings from car makers

[@flacjacket]

I come for the sweat dripping down James' face so this video was a big disappointment for me.

[@manoloorz]

Honestly seeing how James's face transitioned from joy to fear to relief when he spun off the ford GT was memorable

[@ian2372]

The night time races with the lights on is actually pretty cool. We get to see the head light and tail light profiles as well as the interior lighting we miss during your day evaluations. I usually have to go to other channels for night time shots. For once I didn't and your quality is top notch. Well done. Cheers from Texas.

[@Johansans999]

The night setting actually makes this very pleasing to watch, kinda getting NFS vibes.

[@aroundomaha]

The darkness adds mystery to the mayhem. That was fun.

[@benwells2338]

It’s a nice change of pace being able to see glints of the ambient lighting of these cars too. These days, night time driving seems to be as much of an “event” as day time driving, so it’s cool comparing cars on that level as well, even if insignificant.

[@993mike]

Here’s hoping there’s a Golf R 8.5 update that gets an “S3ized” interior to get rid of the crap dash interfaces. Then that would be about perfect

[@flacjacket]

Hopefully I offload my Mk7 R before that happens because the mk8s crap interior/ interfaces is almost certainly boosting my resale value lol.

[@ashwho-6319]

Honestly its not that bad i have a 8Rline and yes it can be annoying to use due to lack of buttons but it does look good. but compared to the 7.5 interior and digital dash it truly is a downgrade. the digital dash is smaller as well on the mk8 compared to the 7.5 how does that even make sense

[@stephenromano6311]

I own a mk8 and trust me, the interior is phenomenal IMHO. The "touch" buttons still require pressure like a real button, and the sliders work as buttons depending on which side you're using

[@juanirving276]

@@ashwho-6319 on the 7.5 the digital dash is very laggy

[@ashwho-6319]

@@juanirving276 I previously had a 7.5 GTI and that digital dash was perfect and I experienced no lag

[@nirfz]

Apart from the extra Moose, the BMW has a torque converter. Torque converters amplify torque at the start.

[@po.russki]

Sounds like they’re better than dual clutch then.

[@nirfz]

@@po.russki Depends on the use case. I prefer a torque converter over a dual clutch for my uses. Most modern torque converters are fast enough for me in their shifts, i don't need anything faster, but i prefer the smoother take off and less wear. (Unless it's a wet clutchpack like Porsche puts in, that reduces wear and is the reason 911s can do launch control starts again and again when most doble clutch gearbox cars want a break for cooling.)

[@po.russki]

@@nirfz yeah makes sense, I like new torque converters but looks like my next car will be a Golf R with DCT. I wonder if it’s as good as Porsche’s since it’s the same brand.

[@nirfz]

@@po.russki I can't tell you if it has a wet or dry clutch system, as the informations i found are a bit contradicting. (On one hand VW says the 7 gear DCT is a dry one, on the other hand they say over 250NM they use wet ones. But my guess is you will get one with a wet clutchpack due to the torque. Anyway, may your car stay "wrinkle free" and you happy with it.

[@julien.biardeau]

Actually filming thoses races in the dark looks pretty cool, with better conditions regarding lighting and equipment it could become great!

[@DaveFogel]

No worries about production value, still better than straight pipes.

[@bkreutze3709]

@throttlehouse wants to like your comment so bad but they won’t

[@or2wheels]

More competition is always better. I love both of them tbh.

[@giow4277]

Like many already said, I didn't notice the "lower production" of this video. Although I love the amazing drone shots and super special effects that are usually used, the thing I love the most is the sincerity in your videos. Take the last few minutes for example, it's like two guys sitting in a bar having a conversation. It doesn't feel forced in any way. Great content as always guys! Keep up the great work.

[@wearethetraffic]

My opinion is the 240 jumps the initial dig race, the uneven horn honks and no starter just make for a sloppy race. Its faster from a dig I am sure but I think the results are skewed a bit for that race. The roll races show much better results where it again its clearly faster. The R in my opinion is the best all rounder there

[@sszhao11]

BMW hunked every time and there is definitely advantage there

[@davidmg7058]

This is just a regular comment to support my favorite channel with the YT algorithm

[@Sashashka]

No matter how much people hate on BMW, they keep doing great. The new 2 series looks great. Almost like a successor to the M3 e46.

[@alexandruandreivasile5041]

It's because they understandably hate the new 4 series and because of it feel the dumb need to hate whatever they make.

[@Chair991]

Are you high? The new 2 series is one of the ugliest cars they've made to date.

[@janneshildebrandt1]

If you think the new 2 series looks great, pls visit as soon as possible! You are in CRITICAL condition

[@mahanlovescars996]

My suggestion for next race is a Mercedes AMG GLC43 vs the new 2022 BMW X3 M40i vs the new Audi SQ5.

[@davidbrown5785]

It would have been closer if Thomas wasn’t the ‘go’ button. He got the jump each time because he knew when the race was gonna start. Fun vid anyway.

[@ThrottleHouse]

If you look Karston’s brake lights go out the exact moment I hit the third horn. The start ended up being perfectly fair. We tried it about 5 times until we got it right

[@Conservator.]

@@ThrottleHouse Good to let us know, Tx! Funny to see that Thomas put on the interior lighting and James didn’t bother 😂. Thoroughly enjoyed this video!

[@Reptil33]

Obviously the most fair thing to do would've been to record some numbers however this was fair for a real world race. The Golf R while having an amazing launch tends to have a big delay when letting off the brake (this is known to the vw / audi group) and the other big thing is, the BMW makes more power because it's under rated (at least 380 to the wheels). BMW is still the faster car and comes with the B58.

[@Conservator.]

@@Reptil33 The throttle response of the BMW in Sport plus mode is extremely fast. They have really nailed it from the ECU, to the Turbo and the gearbox. What also helps is that the inline 6 hardly needs any counterweights to keep it balanced while inline 4 engines need more counter weights and extra balancing shafts to even out the secondary imbalances. Every time I’m still surprised how quickly the BMW I6 revs up.

[@youtubesbichasspolicys5888]

@@Conservator. they’ve been making i6’s for almost 100 years and people put shit on them and hail Toyota like they designed their engines on their own. Between bmw and Nissan they both are miles better, Nissan still being the best of the bunch.

[@Fijilost]

Thank you guys for still giving us the video! Other channels wouldn’t do this because “lower production.” We watch 1320 videos while people drag race in super low lightening. We don’t have any complains. We thank you legends all of you. everyone at throttle house. If this is the last video til after the holidays. Happy holidays. We love you guys!

[@kalagift2575]

I wonder how the M140i would've done, especially rolling

[@youtubesbichasspolicys5888]

Garbage because the new 140i is a piece of trash

[@sejtanskifazoni5752]

New M140i aint faster then this beacuse Bmw ruined 1 series

[@alloveb]

Think he means the previous generation? The current top 1 series is still the m135i. Maybe when it receives a facelift they will use the 140i name again.

[@bissalex]

The current 40i engine is a 6 cylinder engine, the 35i is a 4 cylinder engine. As the new 1 series uses transverse engines instead of longitudinal ones like the previous generation, it can't fit a 6 cylinder engine and there probably will never be a new M140i. Unless of course the next gen 40i will be a 4 cylinder as well.

[@alexringb]

@@bissalex you are right but you didn't mention that the 4 cyl. is 2.0 lt while the 6 cyl. is 3.0 lt. and that's the main point of difference..

[@sivartbook]

The production value is great like almost always, and I know that you guy have high standards for yourselves; but don't sweat it if things aren't perfect all of the time. You are providing hundreds of thousands of us with virtually free entertainment - and many of us are grateful. You are some of the best car journalist/reviewers out there... On par with the big magazines.

[@TheGuyManpodcast]

Thanks for going out there making this video with weather condition and the swimming drone, the BMW is🔥🔥

[@LPDarkSoulsHD]

Was that a LORD OF THE RINGS reference with the drone?? Thomas you maniac 😂😂😂!

[@goodmorning4498]

Didn't even notice that until now. Legendary!

[@DanLMH]

V10 in the intro still one of the best sounds 🔥

[@dewaynesummers8105]

Still better than 99.7% of other review channels even in the dark.

[@gstamenovski]

This gave me a vibe of old school "top gear" stuff. Loved it! I wish u added the drone fishing part 🤣

[@jeancarlo5994]

Don't need to apologize canadian people, the video was awesome 👏

[@SmokeyBear464]

These are legendary reviews that you always have to watch.

[@michaelmarcus509]

Love this video guys, merry Christmas

[@yoitsblazeable]

Even a "low production" video kept me very entertained the whole time. Hope all of throttle house has a lovely holiday break full of family and good health. Can't wait to see all the new models next year! Keep up the great work guys.

[@GioVargasMachuca]

Best well-rounded car review channel on KZbin. I could watch you while cooking for the comedy, sitting down for the information, or while pooping for the distraction.

[@5alm0n]

Really happy that you still put a video together even with the dark and less cameras. You guys are doing great work.

[@dylanfiske371]

There are countless other content creators that clearly don't put this much effort into their stuff. They rely on fancy visuals to make their money. You guys are different. I'm a huge fan of the clear passion for compelling stories etc. Please keep it up!

[@nbb6609]

Great video folks! The night time setting gave us a chance to experience the ambient lighting in the cars as well, which doesn’t often get seen in reviews 👍

[@MrDrivingFaster]

You beat carwow to it. Respect!

[@PinkFuzzyBalls]

Kinda looked like the R & the S3 were handicapped in launch anticipation. I'd be interesting to see them go on a traditional arm drop.

[@sn4rl277]

My thought as well, the lessor HP car should flag start the race. lol

[@jordanhughes3137]

Yeah absolutely, BMW took full advantage of the start 😂

[@quadcoreQ]

This is the drag race I wanted to see!

[@3storiesUp]

Since the demise of "Chris Harris on cars" this is the new King of motor channels on the KZbin. Brilliant as always guys. Much love and respect from Ireland... and eh .. Happy Christmas ;)

[@vroomgc]

Same to you buddy!

[@rishavdeep33]

Your outro is awesome 👌

[@LeJunny]

the new XDrive M240i will give the new RS3 a run for its money! can’t wait to see the beast of the new XDrive M2

[@XwhiskeysX]

So....when are you guys taking this show to Motortrend? Another great vid, as usual

[@tbonetrav18]

Audi needs to take a good, long hard look at itself in the mirror. The shave off its COVID beard, and head out into the world as a new brand. They’ve let all S cars go a bit stale in the power train department. Also, as mentioned, for the price, certain things should just be included at this price point like heated steering wheel. I would argue ventilated seats should be. I’ve seen decade old Nissans with ventilated seats

[@Moh-cs5ck]

Power wise they are limited buy the volkswagen group, other than that agreed.

[@alpenjodel24]

The whole VW group is a disaster atm. Here in Germany, you hear bad things about the internal conflicts of the company every month. The ID cars are a desaster, the quality of all cars went downhill in general, go take a look at the inside of a normal Golf or Polo and then look at what you pay for it. You pay SO MUCH MONEY for little crappy plastic boxes, that literally fall apart once you are out of warranty. And we didn't even start talking about their software issues yet ...

[@Isaiahsucre]

Why buy and S3 when you can tune the a3

[@vroomgc]

@@Isaiahsucre Except there are other things that an S3 gives you that you dont get in an A3 including better suspension and interior and engine internals and turbo. But yes you can tune an A3 and feel happy.

[@vroomgc]

@@alpenjodel24 What a load of bs. Yes they have some issues along with all other car manufacturers. Besides not liking the new infotainment setup the golf r has had way too many improvements done to it that cost a lot of money . But keep shooting your mouth off like you know something.

[@IDontKnow-bb6mt]

Owned a 2018 M240i, one of the most fun, best driving cars, I've ever owned. It was more fun than my 2015 C7 Z51 Corvette!

[@hannaelfar4271]

Golf R for the money

[@antoniohakim3027]

Did u guys use launch control? Nice vid!

[@AndreiAnastasescu]

I watch every week like 10 hours of car reviews on 15 channels and the way you guys present is awesome! So no losses with the crappy quality 😂.

[@djaric]

You guys should include Carson in the intro with a text bubble to the car (or where he is) :)

[@ivannarvaez367]

Love the episode, the “lower production value” makes it fun.

[@pierremartin9048]

Now James you had the pedal squeezed just a we bit when you beeped at 3…….all in god fun.

[@masongist110]

We need a high resolution drag race in the dark next. Definitely gave it that “in Mexico” feel

[@Isandergarcia]

That b58 is something else

[@rextetron]

I'd really like to see a fair start, since now the most powerful and quickest car had a huge jump on the start. Even though it's dark, please try again if some car accidentally jumps the start.

[@b5s4ftw]

That was the worst 1-2-3 ever. You could see the decision on his face to take a jump with an out if rhythm 3 honk.

[@makattak88]

Fun episode boys! Glad you made it.

[@mattspeer01]

Golf R is a rocketship considering the price. It also comes loaded at that price, unlike the Audi and BMW which are strippers at their entry price. Gotta add at least another $10K to the base MSRP to get features on par with the R. In fact, the BMW doesn't even offer ventilated seats or HUD which are standard on the R. Too bad VW had to go with such an ergonomic disaster of an interior in the R, though.

[@josepheverett7158]

Agree with all of that, but it’s just something about the r’s exterior styling that i just can’t get behind either.

[@mattspeer01]

@@josepheverett7158 The GTI is the looker of the Golf family, always has been. I feel like the R should have a more aggressive exterior. Not Civic Type R/WRX STi-levels of stupidity, but still...

[@MrProthall]

It really doesn'T come with anything really. The R is way too expensive imo.

[@mattspeer01]

@@MrProthall What doesn't come with anything?

[@user-ve9tu5rv6e]

The cost cutting and gloss plastic mess of an interior is such a disappointment in the newest Golf, considering the advancements in driving dynamics and handling.

[@PsychicMedium4747]

The production was still professional……I did not even notice the flaws. You guys rock.

[@nathanaelcole8466]

Anybody else notice Audi following Genesis with those awesome wheels?!

[@nickgalaini4152]

Omg thank you guys, I’m trying to get my bud into the new 240

[@hassanger8128]

During the last 3 years, BMW killed the competion with all its rivals in the same series. Now every BMW is the fastest.

[@thefallenvalley4340]

That's what happens when BMW goes 4 wheel drive.

[@Dutil49]

Got a Honda Civic ad popping up while watching this..

[@PsychicMedium4747]

These guys are the best….I laughed when he said in a pompous voice “ I know I won that” it was hilarious. 😂

[@QKvox]

I’ve got an idea for if you do a review of a convertible in winter………it’s “I’m Thomas and I’m cold” after the normal goodness

[@madmaxx8800]

Love the sound of bmw inline six🏎

[@grahambells]

The music ,the weather , cars and James' commentary (started at 1:15) made this video worth watching 👌

[@jj481012]

The night shoot makes everything look so cool. You gotta do this more often just to switch things up.

[@dabarou]

Actually really loved the night race, and the fact that you guys adjusted to the circumstances and still got us a great video. Thanks for doing this!

[@ericokompatzki7110]

At min 7:26 you can see the Audi sending power to the front wheels and then rears as traction is limited

[@yfbgca9492]

OMG! Exactly the three cars I am looking into these days and you guys are doing a drag race with all of them? Yes please!!!

[@jobdoe2051]

Guys, you can’t start like that haha. The one honking is always in advantage

[@alexwelch1520]

You guys are the best guys on you tube. Hope you guys review the Rivian SUV coming out

[@lw2537]

3:03 m240i too late manual gear change. Difference would be larger with a on point gear change.

[@timothycoyne5874]

Great video, guys. Loved the different night time thing, even if it was unintentional.

[@RaceCarFriends]

Quote of the day: "Vw has come along and kicked Audi in the bum" lol!

[@chuckp7970]

Great video! So thats now 2- video comparisons with the M240, when do we get an actual full review on the M240? I need something to tide me over until my M240 arrives!

[@krane15]

Well the BMW has more hp, more torque, and it costs nearly ten grand more. Wouldn't it be the logical winner?

[@dannoyes4493]

Must be tough filming daylight shots above the Arctic Circle...

[@insylogo]

Imagine if they had put the 5 cylinder in the Golf like everyone has been begging for?

[@luisfelipe090909]

Great commitment guys!!! Great video!

[@sinappanis]

The thing I'd like to see on the S3 and this is purely preference, is the flat bottom steering wheel from the TT. I prefer it for driving plus it just lets you get in and out a bit easier with the extra inch or so of room under it.

[@RyRyMTD]

It’s an option.

[@SilverScarletSpider]

i like this video a lot. please do more drag races of cars under $70,000

[@basithph8958]

Wow that M240i is a rocket! Completely smoked both the R and S3!

[@scottw7895]

Extra 100hp tends to do that…

[@stevehuk902]

@@scottw7895 extra 16k over the vw. Anything less than total victory would be an embarrassment

[@papa_pt]

@@stevehuk902 cept in US where it's $5k more. Two completely different kinds of car though

[@stevehuk902]

@@papa_pt here in Canada. I paid 45 for the golf r with the dual clutch. 240 starts at nearly 61. That Saif I have no idea why the golf seems to be 10k cheaper here than anywhere else in the world.

[@mattspeer01]

M240i also is a stripper at its base price and you can't get ventilated seats or a HUD in the BMW which are standard in the R.

[@TheWombatCredenza]

Alright ! TH after dark - love it

[@fl00d69]

Great so more HP = faster car. Groundbreaking!

[@mattspeer01]

So weird, right?

[@dionsalihu456]

More like , three of the cars are in the same category , if they sell for simillar price, youre getting better value for money in the bmw , thats the whole point.

[@fl00d69]

@@dionsalihu456 Similar price my ass - did you even watch the video?

[@dionsalihu456]

@@fl00d69 You must be delusional , they have ~4k difference , and youre getting 80hp more on bmw, I said "similar" not the " same", and better value for money on bmw. Butthurt , if you gonna buy a 44k car, u can buy a 48 as well.

[@fl00d69]

@@dionsalihu456 LMAO That's a weak AF argument. 4k is 4k. Besides, buying a new BMW is inherently bad value for money.

[@hsimpson1152]

This was pretty cool guys. To bad the drone checked out. It also helped to hide some of the bimmer ugly. Great job.

[@orbitaljunkie]

Honestly this was great guys - I always wonder about how cars look like at night, the headlights, rear lights, etc. Would love some included mini-reviews of how well the lowbeams illuminate the road, how the interior ambiance feels, dash colors, etc.

[@27dmon1]

Hey, which one has the best headlights...

[@GLA45Amg716]

Y’all are my favorite reviewers I think I’m leaning towards the m240i ! My first bmw. Usually I hate coupes tho. Just sold my scatpack tho. Thanks for reviewing these wow

[@dylandacasual6866]

I jus sold my scat too and thinking bout getting it also

[@GLA45Amg716]

@@dylandacasual6866 I got about 20k pocketed for my scat. Def want something lighter and AWD can’t go slower after that lol

[@LeJunny]

honestly the new M240i (3800lbs) is great but I think you’re better off getting an M340i (3900lbs) it’s on the same platform, the engine, drivetrain, and transmission are the exact same. the difference in weight is also only 100lbs plus you get 4 doors like you’re used to. I own a 2017 M240i (3400lbs) the previous generation and trust me you’ll love the B58. it’s an amazing tuning platform and you could easily make 600whp out of this machine and outrun even Hellcats. another great tuning engine is the DAZA in the RS3, those cars are amazing. i’m going to he trading in my M240i for an RS3 soon.

[@GLA45Amg716]

@@LeJunny you’re so right .. I’ve been thinking about that. I need to find one in my price range

[@Jeremy.Mathetes]

“Took a little tumble off the cliff.” Y’all are legends with the subtle nerd references 😂😂

[@chrish8487]

That 240i is very impressive acceleration-wise. I would still take an M2 with a manual though.

[@hobokenjoe30]

'They're called trees james' Best line of the film other than the M240i's launch.

[@laryan_7]

Who else is excited for m2 and rs3?

[@amiller2121]

The RS3 is going to beat it handily from a standing start and likely from a roll too because of the transmission (unless BMW give it a whack load of horsepower/torque). Around the track could be a different story though.

[@laryan_7]

@@amiller2121 You could be right but seeing bmw’s new M cars I’m not sure.

[@limitedreach4446]

@@amiller2121 The Old M2 beat the new RS3 from a roll on Carwow, the new M2 will have the S58 engine from the M3/M4 and it’ll be game over!

[@TheKillabobb]

@@amiller2121 New M2 will crush everything just compare a G82 M4 with the new RS3. Performance wise it will be pretty much the same. Bit less power but less weight and shorter wheelbase. Will be around 10 seconds faster around the Nordschleife. Audi was catching up the old M2 with there new RS3 while BMW is 5 years ahead

[@amiller2121]

@@TheKillabobbYou could be right. I don't think the manual version will be able to beat it in a straight line but the auto should be able to.

[@TheTexican05]

Hailing from the home state of Roll Racing, I am proud of my favorite Canadians for getting some roll runs in! 👏 🥰 Wry honest and comparative video. Love you guys. 🍻

[@SilverScarletSpider]

Going to need an Audi RS3 to match that BMW M240i Xdrive AWD

[@RDriver2.0]

The RS3 would crush that M240

[@DL-xf3ur]

Thanks for another awesome video guys! Happy Holidays to you!

[@Conradcockhard]

I've only owned Audis my entire life but they're becoming a joke with their pricing and spec. Also, their interiors aren't taking MAJOR steps forward either. It's getting BORING.

[@arjnarersn01]

Can’t blame Audi for the prices. Everything going up these days. 55k (USD) for an s3 is absurd anyways. They need to bring the s4 avant to the US

[@TheSdvsz]

The new S models are jokes compared to the older versions. Its like Audi doesn’t care anymore

[@Conradcockhard]

@@TheSdvsz couldn't agree more. My supercharged S5 was more fun than the one I currently own. The interior was a step up but now it seems like they haven't really made any changes at all

[@j.e.a.j7925]

You are the best of the best, great video!!

[@rameezahmed3637]

New 2 series looks shitty Change My Mind

[@stevem2323]

Not exactly shitty, but definitely lesser than the previous model.

[@xIcarus227]

This exactly. Looks like a freaking Dacia Logan from the back. In case you don't have Dacias on that side of the pond, it's a budget brand. And I don't mean budget as in Skoda, I mean budget as in Lada.

[@stevem2323]

@@xIcarus227 Nothing on this Earth looks bad as Logan, nothing.

[@xIcarus227]

@@stevem2323 honestly this generation looks pretty good when you think about the fact that it starts at 8k eur lmfao.

[@stevem2323]

@@xIcarus227 Naaah thanks, i would rather have brasilian depilation than drive that fucking thing 😁.

[@xuananator]

Drone fishing: a Canadian pastime usually conducted during the fall or winter months after videographers lose their drones in various types of bodies of water when their batteries die

[@vindevhunta4905]

Ugly bmw...gorgeous s3...awesome vw

[@saurabhmarulkar5316]

James- I am seeing shapes! Thomas- It's called Trees James!!! 🤣😂🤣

[@PsychicMedium4747]

This is by far the best duo on KZbin. Omg I cannot stand the guy from StraightPipes. His name you Yuri…he is super annoying. Their channel has nothing over Throttlehouse.

[@skew9879]

"Despite it's FAT ARSE" I love you James