Ed Sheeran speaks after winning copyright case

[@blaiseandthebambina]

In one of my first college music classes I had a professor tell me that nobody in the future will ever create 100% original music unless they have never heard music before. We take influences from everywhere and make it our own. Any musician knows this without being taught this but I’m glad my teacher pushed that point early in my studies.

[@gyinagal]

That’s true of all art and literature

[@coolestclaminthesea]

Facts, your 3 favorite musicians will be the biggest influence on your music.

[@skankhunt3624]

​@@gyinagal except with Amy Schumer.

[@haveagreatday9865]

@@skankhunt3624 that’s dumb, Amy did bits on her show that were plagiarized but her writers stole that material. All Amy’s stand up is original and some of the best comedians including Dave attell still stand by her being funny. Carlos mencia on the other hand is shunned from the comedy world because of plagiarism

[@takeyourheart1]

This case was ridiculous, I’m so glad Ed won.

[@dennisjazz5142]

U just don’t like blk ppl

[@henrylee8510]

Didn't sound the same to most of us. He is guilty though, guilty of bad music

[@chrisper7527]

Ed “Elvis Presley” Sheeran lacks talent. He has now set a precedent for other no-talent white boys to rip off black music like the culture vultures they are.😂😂😂

[@LarrySinclairAndBarack]

Ed SHE ran is one of the most obvious ftms out there

[@morales1961]

Ridiculous? Why because Marvin is black snd Ed is White? The guys an untalented thief

[@JPGorski]

Songwriters and musicians everywhere should rejoice over the precedent that is set here.

[@mrswampgass2186]

Congrats Ed, this win is for all musicians

[@joellezima3506]

Right!! This senseless suing needs to stop. The desperate attempts to get money needs to be addressed for what it is, society is struggling and lawyers are taking advantage of it

[@ozzDeveveloperOpenForWork]

Amen

[@erinball7781]

attorneys win here. so much money

[@joellezima3506]

@@erinball7781 even if you win a case against someone suing you, you still have to pay thousands in attorney fees just to defend yourself. It’s ludicrous

[@janesays1278]

I’ve heard that in Australia the side that wins the court case has the losing side pay for their legal bills. This dramatically cuts down on the amount of legal cases and suing culture. I think we should adopt that here in the US, or something similar to discourage all of these frivolous lawsuits!

[@joellezima3506]

@@janesays1278 something like it at least!

[@leothelion8796]

2:20 Lawsuit trial made him missed his grandmother's funeral in Ireland, that's unfortunate. Ed should sue back for emotional damages

[@edenmarquez6535]

Oh its sad!

[@StevenOsburnHollywood]

You can’t copyright a chord progression!

[@thestraydawgs]

Not a big Ed Sheeran fan but in this case, he is 100% correct. ANY rock or pop song is based on SOMETHING that came before it. As Chuck Berry used to say, "there is nothing new under the sun". Every songwriter "borrows" just a little bit from songs of the past. As long as it is not a direct lift (as in "Surfin USA" vs "Sweet Little Sixteen"), there is a LOT of leeway in what you can use that has already been used by other writers.

[@bobbeisabella8893]

Justice!! Thank you to the jury who sought the truth !!!!!!!

[@skankhunt3624]

It wouldn't have been the truth if you disagreed with their verdict.

[@angelkat333]

@@skankhunt3624 K

[@sarkastikb5566]

It’s always the Gaye family that wants to sue ANYBODY that has anything similar to what Marvin made. The 2 songs doesn’t even sound alike…so what the drums and bass are similar, everything else is unique. The Gaye family has created so many enemies in the industry, I wouldn’t be surprised if Marvin Gaye’s music disappears.

[@so.many.obstacles]

It wasn’t his family suing it was the co-writer’s family.

[@crutzigluffae6233]

I've always been a Marvin Gaye fan & think is music is perfect but I didn't hear the similarities between Ed Sheeran's song & Marvin Gaye's song. Marvin made the 70's a wonderful place to live & I will continue to listen to his music most likely until I die.

[@Matches_Malone0]

If you don’t hear it then your ears are off.

[@beenarboy]

Congratulations, Ed Sheeran! A win well deserved!

[@ErikPehrsson]

I’m so happy he won. I was praying for him!

[@dechamo]

Thanks for your words Ed. From all us songwriters.

[@aidanjones1832]

I don’t even like Ed Sheerans music much, but this speech was great and it’s very fortunate he won. W for musicians.

[@elysedewyngaert178]

Congratulations Ed, take a deep breath and keep producing your wonderful music

[@ingalook]

Now they need to review that "Blurred Lines" verdict as well.

[@musicfxmaster4873]

When it comes down to it and the way I remember copyright law, an infringement would take place if you have a sequence of 7 notes with the same intervals between them but it also must have the same exact melodic rhythm.This is actually rare but it has indeed happened many times... In terms of the chords, you can't copyright chord progressions. This is why this is so controversial because most people judge it by what they hear only.. but that's not how it works in copyright law. The law it's technical and specific as to what constitutes infringement but most don't know the definitions of it. An interval (example): the first note in a sequence is C and the 2nd is E.. that's a major 3rd interval meaning that there are 2 whole steps between C and E. If the 3rd note would be an F that would be a half-step interval between E and F (one half-step or "semitone") The melodic rhythm refers to whether the duration of the notes is also the same. A quarter note followed by two 8th notes in a 4/4 bar measure for example... These things need to happen exactly when comparing songs to confirm a case of copyright infringement.

[@Nettamorphosis]

I knew it was a wrap when I read yesterday that the jury got a personal Ed Sheeran concert while he was on the stand… guitar & all! Can’t resist that! (Not to mention the songs were pretty different 😅)

[@danieldaniels7571]

When you listen to Ed live you realize he's not remotely the mediocre pop star his detractors make him out to be. Especially if there's a loop pedal involved.

[@MrBrownnn696]

I fully agree people that sue over something like this have NOTHING GOING ON WITH THEIR LIVES…

[@erikhernandezzz9272]

they jus want money that’s the whole point of suing

[@efreq.6465]

Idk what happened this case but copyright especially in a capitalist country is very important

[@tealquartz]

And it's an embarassment to the the ACTUAL songwriters who they claim to represent.

[@xxlxvelydxeams123xx3]

They aren’t in the spotlight and they trying to steal someone’s shine ✨

[@brandonohara4122]

They say the U.S has more lawyers than X amount of countries combined.

[@jasonfogleman2359]

Amen....he is so right....people need to stop there dumd shit....those songs are nothing alike...they must be acting broke trying to steal off of ed....Ed is the man in this case....commen sense is gone

[@ltandrepants]

their

[@birdflukfc]

case would've been over long time ago. The only thing missing was you the true expert 🤷🏾‍♂️

[@joserrapere5928]

Thank goodness. Pop songs are usually simple chord progressions and are often very similar. I know we hear other songs in them later and may even pay tribute by pulling them in when doing live performances. That does not mean we ever copied them. These progressions are in our unconscious tool chest. This happens constantly. This is an example of mostly non-writers trying to get money off of rich musicians. Still mad at Tom Petty for doing this. And what about the tradition of the "Folk Process?" This is where people did get direct inspiration off of each other's music, and it was a rich, historical tradition. People are just too money hungry and egocentric these days, thinking their art is so uniquely important.

[@oceanoflotion8630]

As someone who knows a few words from the piano practice I didnt take well too, I can appreciate his explanation of the chords being building blocks etc. I'm glad he can move on from this because he clearly loves music to the point of being a textbook nerd about it. 😂

[@badnoodlez]

Nobody owning the color blue is a way better way of putting it.

[@leeannsampson6050]

I wonder if any Marvin Gaye songs sound like any other songs before Marvin's came out? I don't really listen to Marvin Gaye's songs but maybe a handful. I just don't see how any songs can be 100% original given how many songs exist. And aren't the Gaye family well known for suing at the drop of a hat?

[@ccyesornocc7989]

Congrats ED!!!

[@barbvehar8948]

I would like to know why are 75% of these copyright suits involve Marv Gaye?? Love his music, sad his father is an asshole and murderer, but what are the chances that ALL music only has so many sounds and chords. In that case everyone could sue everyone. Greed Plain Greed

[@adventuresconjuan]

These people just wanted money off him! What a shame!! Congratulations ed !!

[@kalijaheyolya-ralph9944]

We love you Ed Sheeran

[@danieldaniels7571]

Rick Beato had a really good analasis of the songs, and the polarization in the comments was disturbing. It was clear to ne that those bashing Ed have never really listened to him. I have, and he's amazing. And this just makes me love him more. I'm so glad he fought this instead of just settling to make it fo away.

[@giustogiusto149]

I’m thrilled to be Ben Crump lose a case! He’s an ambulance chaser just like Gloria Allred. Always show up on camera pretending to care about “victims “. A lot of BS.

[@barbaratrepka5896]

I swear Ed Sheeran looks like Boris Johnson. Congratulations

[@nadiac6042]

Lollll🤔🤔😂😂😂😂😂👍🏻 thank for the laughter 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻

[@peterwells7711]

So glad you win this case Ed! ❤❤❤ you are a great songwriter and singer.

[@boris8787]

But they still won't play his music in the honest town of Chillingbourne. 🚫🎵🚫

[@michaelkallianidis3759]

Thank God, he won I have a concert to go to with him. I didn’t want him to retire

[@dennisjazz5142]

So its ok if he steals a aong because u want to go to a concert

[@danieldaniels7571]

I saw him live in Atlanta a few years back and it was hands down one of the best live shows I've ever seen. And it was all Ed with no backing band or other musicians. Few have the talent to pull that off.

[@michaelkallianidis3759]

@@dennisjazz5142 noooo I mean I want to see him

[@Charlotte_TSilva]

Congratulations! I’m elated beyond measure for you. 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

[@oddmello06]

This speech could have been delivered better...with a guitar in hand and sung to the melody that he was sued for allegedly infringing.

[@amandasoul]

OK SWIFTIES I HAVE A QUESTION Do you think him sneaking in saying just like “nobody owns the color blue? “ is for Taylor. (Seeing as she probably helped him a lot behind the scenes through this since she is used to this type of legal stuff and they’re good friends AND and blue is the clear signifying color that Taylor has used for her ex Joe throughout the years in her music) Am I reaching? Lmao This is all in good fun, so any comments of people telling me how stupid I am I will ignore. Thank you very much.

[@stephaniefridaye9505]

Congratulations, Ed.

[@tealquartz]

LOVE THIS MAN!

[@hellenista]

So happy for him ❤❤

[@kristyhines7443]

Omg this is the Gaye family again?!!! Wtf! I’m glad Ed won, NOW maybe the Gaye family will stop thinking they can sue everybody 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

[@Kennychiwah1]

Marvin gaye is a legend but his family is just greedy first Robin thick now Ed Sheeran.

[@Mrrngglory3043]

Ed you smashed this - speech is spot on!

[@andrewcanoy1708]

The version of "Bad Habbits" feating Bring Me to the Horizon actually slaps pretty hard.

[@shadow_of_thoth]

Probably one of the most unexpected collaborations of all time.

[@th1s1kat]

Yay, Ed Sheeran! sorry you had to go thru this, but its only going to help your sales! 🎉

[@odinhonour2170]

Thank God. These lawsuits are ridiculous.

[@StevenOsburnHollywood]

Like they say, “Everything is a remix!”

[@cherayish]

Congratulations, Ed!

[@jaynewallace8592]

Those two songs were... worlds apart

[@mmhmmmyearight7183]

This family is always accusing and trying to milk artists they actually won against others even though it was bogus

[@miranda13c]

I’m so happy Ed won. ❤

[@samanthafitzgerel4460]

I am SO happy for Ed. I thought the case was so ridiculous from the craft. All musicians use these chords and one person cannot lay claim on them. They just wanted money and didn’t get one red cent!!!

[@Synthwave89]

This goes for things beyond music. Most creative endeavors are not unique, we borrow from everything we consume whether we are aware of it or not. It's how we put our own twist to it that makes it unique in it's on way and the way it brings utility to those who enjoy it.

[@contemplatingwithamaster]

Well said; common sense; let’s just be just. ❤

[@gastanton1]

I hope that they paid his legal costs. this was ridiculous from the beginng

[@michelemoore8951]

I never heard the similarities ever…..❤️

[@kareemabdel-jabbar]

yea they didn’t want him to retire

[@aaronchristiansoriano9889]

Dang. Eds winning. Godbless you Ed.

[@CaptainTeach1]

But it's the exact same song as Marvin Gaye's😒

[@carolc4272]

So glad Ed won!

[@tbagger99]

Musicians all use the same notes. This is a big deal for song writers. It could have turned the music world upside down.

[@GrizrazRex]

The Blurred Lines case was also a farce, but decided that way because Thicke was being an absolute tool.

[@briankronberg]

Time to counter sue and drive these music trolls into the dirt.

[@ddu6831]

They did this before just trying to get a quick buck

[@Chic_Ken]

Lets see who the estate of marvin gaye tries to sue next 😂😂

[@forgotten1s]

This case went on foreeeeever

[@JAPARICAN50-50]

The lawyer on the left is the perfect visual of a lawyer.

[@floridalife2924]

congratulations I’m glad u won u shouldn’t even had to go to court

[@therealjason52798]

He should counter sue! Just to send a message.

[@TC-hh8dc]

Marvin Gayes estate will sue you for saying What's going on?

[@jamestyler007]

He is 100% correct!

[@MrMustard2U]

Hopefully the Gaye Estate will Re Sue this Music Shark Ed Sheeran...Ed don't deserve to make all that money from Flat Out Stealing music from other Artists...

[@penguinwithwifi]

Great news! 👍👍

[@NanaG-s1]

Congratulations Ed !

[@jonnyseablue6911]

I’m glad he won now the culture can stop giving pass to artists like him and let them stay in their lane so these disparities don’t exist no more passes on the set

[@blk3971]

Well said!!!!

[@MrMustard2U]

Those jurors must be tone deaf, Sheeran TOTALLY RIPPED THE MUSIC OFF FROM GAYE....COMPLETE RIP OF THE MUSIC, JUST CHANGED THE VOCAL MELODY AROUND..

[@mariannedressler6784]

Agee… how does this ridiculous claim ever make it to court.

[@thetaylorholt]

These are the type of people who sue for not being told their hot coffee was hot.

[@justoffcenteradmin8305]

Not an expert … couldn’t identify the claimed similarities .. i am pleased with outcome.

[@bi7630]

This dudes pretty cool

[@gatolibero8329]

What happened is a bunch of investment companies bought "partial rights" to songs and artists repositories. Wherever possible, they are trying to make money off that "partial ownership" by suing any artist who creates or created music that even closely resembles that of which they bought. Because in America you can sue anyone for just about anything, including potential "copyright infringement", it is worth it for some of these companies to go after big artists with deep pockets in an effort to make even more money off their investments. America is well known for its rampant abuse of the legal system, but it works and in some cases is "worth" the effort. Remember, the claim can be RIDICULOUS, but the plaintiff still has their day in court. There is risk. In this case they lost, but if it costs them $1 million in legal fees (just a number I'm throwing out there), and they won $10 million in damages, that's a net of $9 million and often, the loser pays the other party's legal fees on top. That's why these things happen. Now, judges are "supposed" to determine if a case has real merit, but in a lot of instances, in more corrupt jurisdictions, they side with the person paying their campaigns and allow cases that shouldn't go to trial, go to trial.

[@t.r.williams9841]

Congratulations 🎉

[@tonya6118]

So glad with the outcome .. ridiculous that it came to this.

[@lindawalker5367]

Way to go ED 👋🥰😜🇬🇧

[@shannonEGBOK]

Marvin Gaye's estate is ridiculous for bringing this lawsuit and so much more.

[@tonymunoz2269]

Its not marvin gaye estate. Townsend estate who “co wrote” the song with marvin gaye was suing ed sheeran

[@JohnRangel-if2qm]

My first time hearing about this was yesterday lol

[@Alexardelean89]

Didn’t that family also try and sue some other artist?

[@diemysene6033]

I’m happy for you

[@tiba242424]

I believe these infringement cases should be presented before a jury of only musicians. Amatuer and professional.

[@TechieXP]

Well I listened to the 2 songs. They definitely have the same beat. It's timed in both cases to a 4/4 measure. If you use a music editor and line up the very beginning, the start is very similar for like the 1st 8 beats. After that both songs are fairly unique. I would however argue the Marvin Gaye song was clearly used for some inspiration. But i didn't see enough substance for a lawsuit to be filed.

[@gasdaoff]

There’s hundreds of songs that use the same “beat” . The people suing are just money whores

[@boohiss]

Hallelujah!

[@dugganater]

Congrats to Ed! Music copyright lawsuits are usually pretty ridiculous. Wish his current stuff was as good as Thinking Out Loud, but we won't talk about that ;)

[@danieldaniels7571]

There are songs that good and better on his last album, they just didn't get radio airplay.

[@henryc1000]

The “loser pay rule” is the only thing that’s going to prevent a case like this from being brought to court I the first place.

[@reneesmith983]

So you really took a fan video and made a case out of it. I hope the Plaintiff has to pay damages.

[@trevy7142]

He thinking out loud…

[@penguinwithwifi]

😁

[@RBynoe-qo2oj]

Long are the days when acknowledgment of sampling other artists is lost. Now we sample and say yup it's my original work if I change the lyrics and a few bars. The reality is most music I hear today comes from days when my parents were growing up and we heard it in the background on vinyl records. I can name that old-school tune just by a few bars and know darn well it was sampled. For those of you that do not have the nostalgia of music from other generations than you may not realize the problem if you have not been exposed to the music but for those of us that have been it's like stepping on those that paved the way for the up and coming artist today to express themselves so freely.

[@danieldaniels7571]

Thinking Out Loud contains no samples.

[@ShredderTainment]

Oh thank goodness!

[@18dcallaway]

Very happy for him!!! Why does it seem that Marvin’s family is always suing?? 🤔

[@willybeama1]

I heard the songs and, while they have a slight similarity, I don’t think he infringed.