A Daddy’s Girl Plots The Ultimate Ending For Her Teenage Love | Erin Caffey

[@arkansaninva]

I love how you always choose cases that are less well known and not covered by every single true crime KZbinr. I think it shows you care!

[@Summer09824]

The Dr Phil episode with her was crazy. She’s a cold blooded murderer. And it’s heartbreaking that her dad survived & stood by her when she took everything from him.

[@vutlharimabunda9936]

I don’t think her parents did anything wrong here, yes they were strict but I wasn’t even allowed to date in high school. People in the comments over exaggerate their strictness, they allowed her to see her boyfriend, but put rules in place when they saw the negative influence the relationship was having on their daughter, that’s just parenting.

[@miacantrell5723]

Strict parents make sneaky kids. And there's nothing wrong with homeschooling, but kids still need socialization with others outside the family. Also I find it super creepy when parents don't let their kids have regular relationships with kids their own age. I feel sorry for Charlie bc he got into a relationship with a psycho. And he definitely should have walked away instead of letting hisself be talked into murdering a whole family. But Erin is the true monster and should never be allowed freedom. She is a terrible person and she disgusts me.

[@SG-pu3rx]

Her family is much more so tho, the way they raised her was abusive

[@naivenostalgia]

Thank you for another respectful & informative case video, Zara! You always find the perfect balance when telling these victims' stories.

[@naivenostalgia]

I would also like to suggest the case of Lauren McCluskey, who was a University of Utah student who was tragically murdered in October 2018. Her ex had completely lied about his identity when they first met & refused to let her go when she discovered his lies. She reported his stalking & harassment to campus police over 20 times & they never did a thing to help her. One officer was eventually fired for circulating her nude photos that had been in evidence. Yes, you actually just read that; a police officer sent around nude photos of a murder victim whose case he had worked on. It's a very sad & extremely frustrating case, but I think it's a case that more people should be aware of & everyone can learn from in multiple ways.

[@lieslwright70]

“He always dressed like a cowboy. But it’s Texas so that’s okay.” 😂

[@suzimonkey345]

OMG! Heartbreaking! I can’t imagine surviving but hearing my family plead for their lives! 😢

[@robzombieisvegan]

“really, right outside of a church meeting Erin?” 😂 I’m so glad I found your channel. Each of your videos get better and you show more of your personality in each one 🥰 have a good day 💫✨🫶🏻

[@Bliss31]

Love your videos. I’m a Bailey and Brittney fan and now I’ve found you I have three faves 😊

[@ZaraV]

Yay! Thank you!

[@savannahsally8192]

I was homeschooled though high-school. I wouldn’t say I’m any less social then anyone else.

[@v3rlu5t]

Ya I think that's just a weird bias for ppl who don't really have personal experience with homeschooling ❤

[@Amanda-tp4yb]

Exactly! I was homeschooled and now homeschool my kiddos and if we get any more social I might loose my mind lol.

[@Aprilwyatt0005]

I was homeschooled. My parents were very religious. I had to wear dresses, and wasn’t allowed to cut my hair, or wear makeup, or sleeveless shirts. We didn’t have a tv, and I wasn’t allowed to go to the movies or do anything they considered “worIdly”. I was the lead singer of our church youth group and my dad plays guitar so we went to church almost every night. And twice on Sunday. And they still think they’re religion is the only one that is right. As soon as I was old enough I was gone. Lol

[@itslaylaplays.8869]

Thank you Zara for all your hard work and for just being you 💕

[@zoesautistic]

Your job as a parent never ends. Never, no matter what. I admire Terry & I feel for his life enduring pain. May the victims of this horrid crime RIP🕊️

[@Just_CPaul]

Hi Zara, I always look forward to your cases. Lots of love from Newfoundland Canada

[@sophieelise9519]

I always love how clear your camera is! So satisfying

[@sarahwirgau225]

This is my opinion so don’t come for me, and I am not condoning what Erin did. However I do think that this kind of extreme parenting has caused children to snap like this over and over again.

[@Me-ru6cl]

Nope

[@veronicavillasenor5215]

Disagree. I was raised in a similar way as this girl. I went to church every Saturday sometimes twice. I was never allowed to have a bf and when I had one I snuck it behind my parents back. They never let me go on dates and hardly let me have friends outside of school. I never once wanted to kill my parents. Did I feel like I hated them at points? Yeah, definitely. I would never considering killing my whole family because of it. This girl has a mental issue that caused this.

[@tatiannabaker3943]

@@veronicavillasenor5215e gotta stop comparing our individual experiences and outcomes to other peoples, strict parenting is part of the problem as we’ve seen time and time again. Ofc not everyone turns into a murderer and some people are just evil or crazy but the way it affected you has nothing to do with Erin’s case. We’ll never figure out how to help these people and their family’s before it gets too this if we keep thinking about how we would handle something or how it affected us. Also obviously being overly strict doesn’t help if someone’s already mentally ill.

[@veronicavillasenor5215]

@@tatiannabaker3943 I personally do not think that her parents were overly strict though. She was allowed to have a boyfriend, they had him around the family, then when she rebelled and did not listen to their rules they limited her to see him. They were doing what they were supposed to as parents. Even if I were to take out my experience with very strict parenting from the equation it's very obvious to me that this girl did not have normal mental function. She was told many times to rethink this. Her boyfriend asked her to try a different method. She still chose to kill her entire family. It's ridiculous to minimize these actions as a direct product of strict parenting alone.

[@MrsDetroit622]

No one abused that girl. I was raised strict and I never would have even dreamed of hurting my parents, much less kill them. She said herself her parents were great to her. She is just a rotten apple.

[@PuertoRicanqueen90]

As a Christian this just upsets me.. Im soo glad my parents are open and made sure we were shown every religion and life styles so we could understand and sympathize with others 😭😭 I'm only like 7 mins in but ugh.. My dad was preacher at one of these homeschool Christian churches and he just couldn't deal with their closed minds and eventually left

[@ashleypandey7042]

The dads memoir was the first true crime book i ever read. so so sad

[@MoonCat33]

Also- you’re one of my favs Zara! Keep it up cuz we appreciate you 🎉

[@morrellbrown1123]

I was homeschooled for about 6 months and it was a blast! It was my last few months of high school and my teacher was the best! He was into musical theater and stuff that i was into! He even helped me cheat on my regents exam! But the best part was I didn’t have to get dressed up, I could wear pajamas to class!! Lmao!!

[@suzimonkey345]

“You may now kiss the bride” is the first time my parents watched me kiss a boy/man! I couldn’t make-out if my parents could see!!

[@michelleyardley6513]

I absolutely love your makeup! Beautiful! Also I have been interested in Erin since I saw her on killer women. Your in depth information was an eye opener. I am liking and subscribing. Looking forward to more videos

[@staceevanya]

Hey Zara, just wanted you let you know that I’m so glad to see your channel growing!! Heaps of love❤

[@v3rlu5t]

Me and my brothers were homeschooled but we weren't isolated at all always had alot of extra curricular activities loved it we had more freedom to do school when we wanted tested higher than our peers that were public schooled. Lots of volunteer work for environmental causes had a very rich childhood. And all of us now have our masters mine is in anthropology one of my brothers is aeronautical engineer and another one is an accountant another is in emt and my youngest sibling is a marine biologist. I think whether ur kid is in public school private charter or homeschooling if the parents aren't involved and don't take the initiative to make sure their kids life is rich and full the child isn't going to be happy and they are not going to do well in any part of life unfortunately

[@askmelegim100]

If you are home schooled and isolated, it's being done wrong. Period. I could never home school but know a lot that do. They go on a lot of trips and group activities with other home schoolers so they have that interaction.

[@vickielov]

Hey Zara , thank you for another case darl X xn

[@suzimonkey345]

Thank you!

[@dmwiley5989]

Love your content. In another note....I really like how you do your makeup.

[@mechellebillington4773]

A sonic blast! I love them too!

[@kennedymariaxo]

hi zara, thank you for sharing this case with us ❤

[@TTTori.]

Love all your videos! Been watching for months now and I wait every week for new uploads 🥰❤

[@tinazimmer4304]

I grew up in a very similar situation, in fact when I was around 16-17 years old, I contemplated a very similar thing. The reason being is because of control. I was controlled with everything I said, I did, where I went, whom I was with. And my parents were also deeply religious and I remember many times when I would get upset I was told that if I didn't change my ways I was going to go to hell because the Bible says to honor your parents. So sadly, I understand where this girl is coming from.

[@margaretyork3548]

Yes, whilst I understand the poor deceased parent's goals, they needed moderation. Teen time is such a mix of hormones, trying to understand one's self and anger Unfortunately this type of thing happens more than we know

[@CosmicQuinn]

I think talking on the phone for hours as teens is a great thing. It shows how much you have in common rather than confusing hormones with intimacy. I deliberately looked for my last (and current) partner online because if you can’t engage me in conversation you won’t have a hope in being with me. You can laugh me into bed.

[@thedivyafairy]

my parents are extremely religious and “strict” because of it every time she says “she had to be home at 9:30” or she was allowed to go out with him i think about how my parents would never they have been way more controlling then these parents and i never had these type of thoughts or feelings. i’m 18 gonna move out soon, i realized there toxicity and got myself in a position where i could leave

[@sebrinadunkle741]

I always look forward to your videos thank you for posting ❤

[@tanyachristensen5330]

It seems to me that if it wasn't her family...eventually it would have been someone else. For all the reasons couples break up,one of them wanting to murder a family should be the top of that list. Such a tragedy.

[@naziamathlib2996]

❤❤❤❤yourrr soooo good at this !!!! 💓💓🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻

[@suzimonkey345]

As a parent I can assure you that, “just getting pregnant” as teens, isn’t going to make me happy but it’s better than MURDER! 😮

[@yvyivs6799]

Her parents may have been strict but they were not completely heartless. She was allowed to leave the house and come back. It wasn't a prison. She was re-enrolled in public school because she wanted to return to school. If her parent were so bad they would have said no. She had many chances to runaway even Charlie was willing to run away with her. Her parents let Charlie into the house on multiple occasions they couldn't have been that bad she can rot

[@rachellinton6613]

I wouldn't say that a father who pulled his daughter out of school because she MIGHT be bisexual really loved her unconditionally

[@Crafty_Susie]

I think there should be boundaries your kids can't fun the household. But for her dad to come to her and extend an olive branch, and forgives her for this horrific crime, and she's still lying irritates me to my core.

[@GiovannaRiggers]

I love your voice and your accent. Amazing!! ❤❤

[@MizzMuffitt]

I had very strict parents. They actually removed the phone jacks out of our house and locked the 1 phone we had behind a door that was locked. I moved out the day I turned 18. After years of therapy and trying to have a relationship with this family.... no contact is my answer. Also I'll add my family is very toxic.

[@kcstottlemire]

Homeschooling is basically what the parents make it. For me I never left the house so it was pretty isolating

[@jadenridgely6836]

this sounds like the episode of web of lies i just watched where the teen daughter plots to kill her family cuz they told her no she cant see her older bf

[@rachelrae860]

Hi Zara I'm watching now. You already know I think your personality is everything and I just adore you 🤗❤️🌹🥰😍💋. I've never heard of this case but this is a horrific. I hope and pray Terry 🙏 can get through this. I know that's his daughter but I can't get over how he's seeing her and standing by her side. That's my opinion so nobody come for me in the comments

[@nikkismith9849]

PERFECT TIMINNNGGG!!!! 🎉🎉🎉🎉

[@killianspar]

A sonic blast, girl...and yes we still have sonic 😂

[@fatimaoubijjane326]

I was homeschooled due to the only Spanish school being full. It was the best time of my life. I didn't get along with the students at the Spanish school so I met friends from other schools and I had the best time.

[@mizz2ts86]

Hey Zara girl❤️ Are you talking about the Sonic Blizzard/Blast? I think that’s the name of it😂😂😂

[@vickikay25]

The sad truth is that some people are just born bad. She is right where she should be. I don't understand her Dad, but I am very glad that he survived and remarried. I feel just sick about her Mom and brothers, may they rest in peace. This is very disturbing.

[@rileynavarrette4966]

Super freaky to hear the name of a place I’ve been going to for YEARS and have never heard of this case 😳

[@brittniesteele6146]

I used to work at sonic as a carhop. Sonic is still around. I think you are referring to a blast (ice cream mixed with candy) My 14 year old has a curfew for her phone. The reason being is if she didn't she would stay up all night on the phone. She has adhd so she NEEDS sleep or she is so irritable and just miserable. Because of this she has limits on her phone.

[@sarahwhite4906]

Maybe consider the Diane Schuler (driving the wrong way purposefully (?) on a highway) case.

[@laceyfontenot186]

Sonic Blast! I had an advert of Sonic right after you asked lol I have an unhealthy obsession with Sonic ice

[@ginaaurascott7670]

I did not have any protective parents 😢so I was way too young dating which resulted in a teen pregnancy by a 20yo and years of self destructive behavior and only in the past 10 years of my 42 years here have I realized all of the bad experiences I have had involving relationships which in turn has helped me parent better I think there needs to be a middle line with children and the parent or parents need to be strong when saying No

[@lillaayx-]

Strict parents only push their kids to become sneaky

[@tuszajnojneeg0052]

The thing that got me thinking is when you said her father still stood by her side and believed her story. Also, the fact that you said, she was like an angel and did nothing wrong, makes me think that her parents dotted on her, and they also tried to make her something she wasn't. They thought she was one way, but she really wasn't. Becuase if she was who they thought she was this perfect girl being led astray by Charlie/others, then they are sorely mistaken. She chose Charlie. She liked what he represented. She was probably a fake, putting firth a facade.

[@arianabish5229]

I was homeschool in elementary for a while due to medical issues and I definitely felt alone the only kids I could play with were my cousins I always wished I could go to school and be normal I hated it

[@paohaqui]

Religious trauma made me the perfect victim for all of the extensive abuse I forgived time after time

[@fatamy8597]

them shitting themselves after finding out a girl kissed their daughter 🤣

[@debbiepatrick399]

Hi Zara, I believe rules should be applied

[@maisenbrown196]

My son and his girlfriend have been together since he was 14yrs she was 13yrs. Now he is 20yrs old going strong.....

[@grownuppill264]

I think there were quite a few editing glitches in this episode?

[@suZanna20]

Just found you ❤ loving you 🙏🏻👏👏👏👏👏👏❤️🇬🇧

[@j3n.jen12]

7:27 flurries?

[@brittlh]

As a person raised in a similar household with some pretty nasty mental health problems: I think sometimes the idea of “turn to God” gets more serious signs ignored. I’m not saying to not be religious, just don’t be in denial. I’ve seen videos of her and firmly believe she’s an excellent manipulator and her poor family trusted her. It breaks my heart.

[@sagebryant786]

She was always capable of this. When they got caught she didn't hesitate she immediately blamed Charlie. The cops didn't see her when they first entered the room because she was hiding, she was ready. That parenting really wasn't even that strict like she had a cellphone, a car, a job and in the beginning was allowed to see Charlie. It was only once she started fighting with her mom she lost privileges which is what grounding is. Other teens get mad and slam their bedroom door and ignore their parents not murder them. If she could sneak out so easily they could have just run off. This wasn't a case about abusive overbearing parents it's about a teen girl that just wanted her way. And 5 months then Charlie proposes well he seems to have been a little obsessive. And how do people always manage to just find accomplices like "oh I wanna kill someone will you help ? Hell yeah." That I don't get

[@Hidden_Cat_of_the_Coral_Reef]

I would like to hear about the crime against Allison Baden-Clay. A victim of domestic abuse - the killer got away with it for way too long.

[@suadmohamed1168]

Honestly she was just an evil soul who wanted to have a quick “solution” theres people with far worser parents who would never think of doing something like this.

[@Amy-qe7ti]

❤HI ZARA!!!❤

[@megmelissa8532]

There are all types of Christians and all types of homeschoolers. You cant judge us all based off crazies or extremists.

[@Loganne92]

I bet it was the Abeka program that they used for the curriculum. That’s how I learned to read at 3. I think it’s good when you aren’t going overboard about it.

[@kellyshort1959]

Sonic is less than 4 miles from my house...I love that place ❤😊

[@julierenton9513]

There was too much religion thrown at the kids, any hobbies, interests was based around the church. The first hurdle of possible bisexuality they were removed from school. Kids need to socialise, learn friendship and relationships with others. All that was taken away from them. I know it not nice but I'm not really surprised something like this happened. A bit give and take on both sides works wonders.

[@shelbygonzalez7595]

Are you talking about the Sonic Blasts?? Here in America we still have them! It’s my sons favorite place (:

[@THEREALWILLOWNICOLE]

How can I request a case for you to tell here on your channel. Could you do a story on Nicole Lovell? I covered this on my true crime KZbin channel but I would really love for you to tell her story.

[@MelissaModsMetal]

Girl of course sonic is around, I worked there just last year 😂😂 she was a carhop, and they're called sonic blasts.

[@CarpeNutella]

The drink Sonic is famous for, at least where I live, is Cherry Limeade. But they are known for hundreds of flavored drinks, slushes, and milkshakes.

[@josiemorgan2654]

Sonic is still a thing and amazing. Sonic Blast is their ice cream mixed with toppings 😊

[@kaitlinannwright24]

"He dressed like a cowboy, but its Texas, so that's fine" LOL, are Texans the only ones who can be cowboys 😅

[@terridemaio2926]

Hi zara i saw this case Horrible What people will Do to there own family For A Guy

[@LaurenMcKinney-x3s]

Lol, I think youre thinking of Blizzards from Dairy Queen.

[@MeriweatherDesigns]

When you start out a family annihilator story with “Her family was baptist in Texas” in literally don’t need to hear the rest of the story to know why. Oppression and repression. My mom grew up southern baptist and she HATES church and religion because of it, she grew up thinking that every single thing she did was a sin and that’s a very dangerous mindset. Is also like to add that my mom is the most caring and giving person in her family and her sister thinks transgenders are bad because of God and that assault rifles are more important than their child at school soooooooo you decide who turned out better for their beliefs Not that parents deserve to die! No one does in these stories, there is always a better solution

[@suzimonkey345]

❤

[@ql688]

parents were not even that strict. they let them see each other on a regular basis until her grades were slipping even then they allowed them to see each other just not all the time. I mean what are they suppose to do ? Let their teenage daughter do whatever she wants? Daughter is the one with mental issue

[@vutlharimabunda9936]

Quick case suggestion. May you please do a Video on Moses Sithole. A South African serial killer known as the Cleveland killer. Thanks ❤❤❤

[@dkc09curry97]

I read his name as “shithole” 😂

[@heidiraphael972]

Sonic is still around unfortunately.. their food is horrible here in Florida.

[@suzimonkey345]

🌟

[@suzimonkey345]

🌹❤️🌹❤️🌹

[@kelcieadamson1988]

Growing up could have solved her problem now she’s gone forever. Wow. Romeo and Juliet complex to the extreme.

[@melanieconzachi6643]

Roller skate girl is a carhop Also- sonic has half price slushes if you order through the app so you are definitely missing out Zara

[@crystalcurnew6316]

Hi Zara!!,,homeschooling Always raises a red flag for me,to many kids getting abused at home this way,they hav nowhere to go to tell anyone, they are so isolated. ,happens all the time 😢

[@littlemissliv100]

You might be thinking of Dairy Queen- they have a milkshake called blizzards.

[@Dianira22]

Maybe you’re confusing Sonic with Dairy Queen? DQ has blizzards that they flip when they hand them to you

[@Iamashley80z]

That’s what I was thinking!

[@kristibrown48]

I was actually incarcerated with this monster. Ppl commenting it being the parents strictness is complete BS. This is a soulless evil person… I don’t say this lightly… ironically, her parents being so worried about her being bisexual😂😂 isn’t a issue at this point .. she for as long as she’s in prison will be with women. This woman is and was a calculated manipulative killer.

[@kristibrown48]

And fyi here in Texas… the scripture hanging on the name plaque is completely normal ….. more normal than not.

[@kristibrown48]

Gatesville tx. She was at the hilltop unit until she was 18 ( it’s a youth offender unit)

[@Imnothere888]

Yes sonic is still around and it’s called a “Blizzard,” lol

[@Tuckygurl71]

Blizzard is DQ, sonic does the blast.

[@MeriweatherDesigns]

BLIZZARDS! It’s blizzards at sonic… haha tornados 🌪️

[@daniyelloooo]

Didnt you do this story before?

[@naynaywill]

Regardless, you have to know your kids and parent accordingly. I believe you cant parent every kid the same but you can aet the same morala ans expectations. Some kids need more time or more hands on help, some kids need you to explain using relatable situations. Just like u can't teach all kids yhe same way, you cant parent kids the same way.