Prophet Muhammad explains stuff

[@MacrobianNomad]

Its not even a good explanation for the 7th century that the sun goes to "underneath God's throne." Philolaus who was alive between 470-385 BCE suggested the Earth rotates. Aristarchus of Samos in the third century BC went further than the Pythagorean school and suggested the sun's central place and Earth rotating around it and on its axis. Muhammad was just a good parrot who stole from what he thought was sufficient explanation, then would go and have epileptic episode while suffering from Schizophrenia and claim revelations. How can people still believe this fraud in 2017 baffles me.

[@neverobey1477]

Mekavilli SEARCH FOR CHRIST OUR TRUE LORD AND SAVIOUR.. REBUKE THAT ISLAMIC DEMONIC MUHAMMAD BULLSHIT!

[@mlyons31]

Mekavilli Mo also said the sun sets in a mud hole, so Allah's throne must be in a mud hole.

[@AbdullahSameerVideos]

NEVER OBEY Bible is full of errors too. kzbin.info/www/bejne/pp7LlqaDhMdlf7s

[@attilathekhan8570]

Abdullah Sameer the stupid claims of Koran have nothing to do with the stupid claims of the Bible , this reasoning of argument is invalid you need to do better if you want to discredit something staying on topic is required do not try to deflect the discussion elsewhere surely you know this is a straw man fallacy.

[@Steve-eu8bf]

Attila the Khan it's Attila the Hun you stupid

[@blasianmoistcr1tikal725]

Funny thing is that I left Islam during Ramadan lol

[@AbdullahSameerVideos]

Me too. July 2015

[@theblessedkuffar38]

Brilliant ...... I love good news for humanity events . Bless u

[@imranbug81]

For me it was a slow transition and don't know the exact time but very gradually my concerns of the nonsense in religion kept growing but I guess It became clear to me I don't believe when I decided not to participate in Ramadan.

[@nowaysir7576]

i left islam one week before ramadan damn it !!!!!

[@habibaezzat9815]

This is my first ramadan as an ex muslim

[@dannynewton3988]

Another mistake in the Hadith involves men shrinking from the time of Adam. Even if you are an old earth Muslim who believes every day of creation is like a thousand years, there is no archeological evidence that humans are shrinking since the time of Adam. Shrinking or making a human larger has a lot of technical problems that could only be corrected by altering the DNA instructions to allow the survival of the human at a different height. These changes are so profound, they can not be explained by evolution. If a human existed at even twenty feet tall, it would have to be a new species with new DNA instructions. We know that the human heart could handle a change in mass of three to four times normal but only at the expense of mobility. The size of blood cells and capillaries is coordinated so that nutrients and oxygen are distributed throughout the body. The design of the human body tolerates a lot of variation, but not a 15 to one change. If blood cells were expanded 15 times their current size to go through a capillary that was 15 times its current size, you would suffer severe loss of Oxygen transfer and efficiency. You would need at least 15 times more surface area in your lungs thus prompting a redesign of the lungs. Furthermore there would be a problem with the efficiency of cell nutrients crossing the cell wall due to lower efficiency. When you scale things up or down, the mass tends to go up by a factor cubed and the square area goes up by a factor squared. Every action within the body that depends on a ratio of mass to square area would be impacted. Breathing would be seriously impaired since the ratio of area to mass would be reduced to 1/24 th of the original amount. The knee and hip joint would have to be different if humans were larger. This is another example where mass changes are applied to square area in the knee or hip. The original 90 foot tall Adam would have had an exotic bone density. The weight of a 90 foot man would be around 300 tons. The bottom of your feet might have to handle 100 pounds per square foot but if you were 15 times taller, your feet would have to hold up over fourteen times that. The knee and hip joints would have to bear enormous static loads but also dynamic loads possibly five times as large from doing normal activity. A thousand pound man would be about 10.5 feet tall and he would be at the edge of cardiac failure even with a larger heart because of the friction losses in blood vessels and capillaries. friction losses in circular pipes are proportional to the quantity of blood pumped squared divided by the diameter to the fifth power. You can not keep capillaries the same size to optimize oxygenization, temperature regulation and nutrient distribution while at the same time serving a mass that is expanding by some factor cubed . I think the only way around this is to have multiple hearts or lower gravity. The story about men shrinking from 90 feet to what they are today is a lot like the tale From Earth to Moon by Jules Verne. Everybody knows that nobody could survive being shot to the moon by a cannon but you have to go along with it to enjoy the rest of the story.

[@manpreet9766]

My muslim friend who was doing a PhD with me had a debate on this thing that the Adam was very tall. He became angry at me when I told him that it can't be possible and there is no archaeological evidence.

[@terra2805]

I absolutely love this guys common sense. It's so refreshing to see somebody who was born as a muslim (given no choice) questioning things and thinking critically for himself instead of just following blindly. I applaud you sir. 👏👏

[@AbdullahSameerVideos]

Thanks! Actually I wasn't born muslim exactly. I was born Ismaili (a sect of Muslims) but I converted of my own accord to the mainstream Sunni sect in highschool. More here: abdullahsameer.com/blog/about

[@user-sy5rf2sy1p]

Muslims can't handle the truth, instead they get mad at people who think critically about islam..Islam survives well.minus scrutiny..Too bad for islam.in this era of internet..This vital information sinks deep and exposes the falsehoods of islam..Thank you Sameer, just come to Jesus, his arms are wide and open..

[@neffelibatta7658]

Another ex Muslim here

[@robinjoseph4949]

@my toughts There is evidence for the Bible: Archaeological, Historical, secular and manuscripts evidence. I recommend The Case for Christ True Movie by Lee Strobel, God vs Evolution Movie by Ray Comfort and Cold Case Christianity by Jim Wallace as just a few to begin investigating the evidence. Samuel Green debates are good too. See Cold Case Christianity link kzbin.info/www/bejne/pKeypIVnYr57irM

[@MohammadAbdulWahedSiddiq-ji2yt]

He is bladdy orrogant he is born as Muslim but unfortunately actually his place is in HELL fire...you doomed what are talking about universe you are a soul gifted by ALLAH to you...you are little knowledge....you fool abdulah sameer you are big capital F FOOL

[@CHILDRENOFLIGHTMINISTRY]

Dear Abdullah! Wow! You just are very funny and wonderful. Your approach is great and this helps Muslims to learn about the problem of their Quan and Hadith. I wish Musafeel and others present their teaching just as you are doing rather than attacking the Quran, Hadith, Allah, and Muhammad. Yours sweet, convincing and even irresistible, full of facts! Wonderful Job!

[@kivkiv3331]

different people different method, there are no wrong ways

[@xoxo2610]

Mufassil Islam used to show great enthusiasm for Islam. Now he has the same enthusiasm against Islam. He is a charismatic guy to Bangladeshis. His approach is very successful when applied among Bengalis. We need that dose of emotion along with facts, it works. But some of his recent videos like burning quran does no good.

[@fahadbhuiyan8196]

Mufassil Islam is a great guy and his approach to criticizing Islam is mind boggling given that he was a scholar of Islam and the references and facts he points out. One thing that is worth mentioning here is that his burning of the Quran and several other such 'desecrating' acts are nothing but to prove a point and to give the message to the extremists in Bangladesh (I myself am a Bangladeshi ex-Muslim). The Muslims (devout + moderate) in Bangladesh have kept on murdering and condoning the burning the books published by atheists and agnostics and Mufassil Islam have been doing all that not only to attack them on their religious sentiments but also to push the Muslim scholars to come to debate with him. (He have debated a few well-known Bangladeshi scholars and all of them lost which is why the rest of the Mullahs and scholars wouldn't debate with him and instead give death threats and insults in their public gathering on a daily basis). I think the non-Bangladeshis should watch his videos all of it (with the help of a translator perhaps since most of his videos are in Bengali) before jumping on to conclusions about him. @ xox o @ Arega Eniyew

[@xoxo2610]

I am a Bangladeshi ex-Muslim. I know that he was trying to make a point, but Muslims loose interest when someone behaves this way. I lost my religion by reading atheist blogs. You can make people doubt their faith by presenting your arguments nicely, which he does most of the time. I know from experience that burning quran pisses Muslims off too much and they don't want to listen after that.

[@kivkiv3331]

pros and cons

[@ferengiprophet2185]

Your best video yet. Good job, Abdullah

[@steviejongh4511]

You mean if a so-called prophet comes up with total dung, a nother crazy muslim can put some eau de cologne on it and then mohammed is right after all. Sure

[@sayedhussain7955]

im glad im an ex muslim

[@JohnStopman]

@ Hussain: the best of luck to you, brother! Without theism we are all better off!

[@mahashahbaz1264]

Change ur name if u r not a Muslim anymore

[@mahashahbaz1264]

@ateb3 yes he MUST change his name because Abdullah means "servant of ALLAH" and this man no longer believes in ALLAH and Islam. According to him he is now atheist. That his why he ought to change his name. And mind ur language. "Wtf" is not a cool phrase.

[@MayTheRighteousWin]

U must be Shia before. m i correct.

[@riamus7258]

@@MayTheRighteousWin it doesn't matter what his name means. I mean, my name means lion, yet I'm a human... Also, I'm dissapointed that you said that. I thought you said it for his safety.

[@teaburg]

I think this is the best video title you have had yet. Made me giggle.

[@RashidKhan-in6qm]

Informative as always, thanks

[@misterbunga]

Ooji booji booji.

[@riamus7258]

Neanderthals

[@ysammo214]

You will break up with your wife 😂

[@demickyfellow4376]

Odd place for crashposting, but u do u

[@tanjavankessel1872]

Great video, I appreciate all of your work. It has helped me to understand and see through the teachings of Islam.

[@jls_flx_grndlwld3080]

Thank you so much for this wonderful video

[@gerrygwag]

Up to about the 8 minute mark, everything you mentioned was known by the pre Islamic Persian scholars and the scholars of India and China. The rest was not known. Anyway, Ol' Mo made stuff up as he went. By the way, fortunately you would make a very bad voodoo priest. Poor pronunciation of the spells.

[@kivkiv3331]

booji booji booji!!! :)

[@abidallstarz689]

abdullah this is ur best video of all time plz make another

[@AbdullahSameerVideos]

Abid AllStarz sure thing. Will do

[@manpreet9766]

@abdullah sameer I live in Canada. I am an athiest, liberal thinking person. Don't you think left politics in the west deviates from lots of things which should be expected from left. I might be mistaken but left rightfully criticizes Christians, white social conservatives. But when someone criticizes any cultural practice of immigrants or other religions they immidiately label them racist. I understand that they censor criticism to prevent bigotry. But not every criticism is bigotry. I am born sikh and when I moved to Canada I was shocked to find open display of pictures of bhindranwala terrorist during sikh festivals. My family has personally witnessed the atrocities of his group but Sikhs in canada has been brainwashed by people who mostly were part of the bhindranwala group and ran to Canada in 90s. By not stopping Sikhs, canadian government is helping in promoting religious fundamentalism which is problematic for the future of Indian punjab.

[@abdullahisandule8959]

I'm sure a lot of Muslims will tell you that you're misquoting the prophet!

[@dextermorgan6464]

OUT OF CONTEXT!

[@abdullahisandule8959]

I told my muslim friend about the hadith of the meat decaying and he said that he'll accept Hadith over science no matter what science says!

[@AbdullahSameerVideos]

Abdulahi Abdirahman sad

[@steviejongh4511]

A real typical muslim,, it is not about truth, it is about not recognize reality.

[@steviejongh4511]

Yes, in reality Mo invented gravity and was behind the big bang.

[@SandhillCrane42]

At the time any religion that is one formed as such, its followers would have been thoroughly opposed to writing down most of the important stuff, hence myth is like a code, among other things. That's why worshipping an old book is silly.

[@frankwhelan1715]

Of course the worst thing is there has been so many atrocities carried out by people defending this incredible nonsense.

[@richardk5246]

Abdullah, just came across your channel and I love it. Thank you.

[@freemind450]

U r amazing.. u said all what i thinking about it .. i swear since i was 15 years old I had all this questions .. but i fight that mind because i dont god be angry about me hhhhh .. im now left islam with sure its big big lie .. I believe now in love and peace and human rights and pure god if he really available.. but im sure he is not same god in this religion.. best wishes abdullah .. im happy after watching ur video .. keep going bro and don't worry about bad messages from crazy muslims

[@mariussielcken]

the definition between a infant and adult mind is the realization that it is not the center of the universe

[@kayrulrudyne1998]

The more you talk about Prophet Mohamed the more i love Prophet Mohamed and my faith becomes more stronger and i fear Allah. Thanks brother for your videos.

[@jojames6621]

Lol

[@xiiaohao3871]

cope

[@steviejongh4511]

The end is at hand for Islam, this super cool video has killed Islam forever. It was actually this simple!!!

[@aminahrolsdorph8551]

stevie jongh I doubt That.. He maybe drag some people with him. It's highly unlikely since he is ignorance incarnation of both classical old Arabic language & the Science of Hadith. So pathetically seeking fame on KZbin & it's a Trend

[@pioneer2321]

stevie jongh still the fastest growing religion and spreading all corners of the world.

[@pleromicpastry5445]

I think you're right, stevie jongh! RIP Islam.

[@pioneer2321]

superfluous pastry it’s not going anywhere. It’s growing faster than ever. True monotheism religion will never perish. The Earth is only running because humans are worshipping the creator.

[@pioneer2321]

I am Chen what about countries like Australia USA and Canada Lots of people are converting you don’t seem to acknowledge that.

[@hyqhyp]

The hooji booji really drives it home.

[@seanrathmakedisciples1508]

hyqhyp David Wood has a great video titled the white prophet who had slaves or 10 verses understanding Isis

[@therationalhuman8749]

Who's watching and still enjoying this video in September 2019..?Thanks Brother Abdullah.

[@kumarules118]

October 2021 ❤️

[@nasreene9877]

Great great video Loved it keep going my firend 🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹🌹

[@rossini55]

Hmmmmm eclipses. Problem for Islam as in Quran 36.40 it says "It is not for the sun to overtake the moon".

[@Danielcage1]

It's amazing how a person who was once a great advocate to Islam "as he reported in another video" he's now preaching atheism. "Indeed, [O Muhammad], you do not guide whom you like, but Allah guides whom He wills. And He is most knowing of the [rightly] guided" If the prophet peace be upon him told me that the sun is flat, I would believe him. I believe every single thing in the Quran and what the prophet Peace be upon him has said and I ask Allah to let me die a believing Muslim.

[@woowooNeedsFaith]

*preaching atheism* You can't preach atheism because it is not a belief system or a religion. It answers to 1 question only: "do you believe that god(s) exist?" If the answer is "no", it tells absolutely nothing about the beliefs that person has. *If the prophet peace be upon him told me that the sun is flat, I would believe him.* And there's *the problem.* *and I ask Allah to let me die a believing Muslim.* And this even affirms that you want to stick your fingers into your ears and die as believing muslim, no matter what might go wrong if you follow your prophet's example. Here is one of such example: kzbin.info/www/bejne/Zn2oZIR3h898kMk If you think he is making it up, jump to a point 14 minutes and 15 seconds.

[@Danielcage1]

Dear brother, Islam preaches "There should be neither harming (darar) nor reciprocating harm (dirar)" 40 Hadith Nawawi 32. If anything is going to cause harm, it's simply trespassing in islam and therefore it's prohibited. You see, people nowadays think that one of the "possible" ways to attack islam is through mentioning the marriage story of The prophet PBUH and Aisha. They are connecting the 1400 year old Arabian society, Arabian customs and human physiology to the current globalized human society and human physiology and that is preposterous. There is no fixed age in which a woman is capable of marital relationshop and conception of a child and I think that the west has produced numerous cases in which women as young as 12 bore children with no complication, hint "Youngest mother in Britain" and on the other hand elder woman with massive child bearing complications. We should though never allow girls as young as 12 to get married or have children, it's the norm in today's time. Is that against Islam? OF COURSE NOT, does that make me less than a Muslim, Absolutely NOT, Islam doesn't revolve around that, or any other side-matters and i think you get the point. So, Going back 1400 years ago, Aisha reported more than 2000 hadiths "narrations of events and acts" of the prophet PBUH, isn't it the absolute rationality to take her word for any harm caused to her or inflected on her by the prophet PBUH? If you found one, I am ready to "stick my fingers out of my ears" and listen to you.

[@woowooNeedsFaith]

*There should be neither harming (darar) nor reciprocating harm (dirar)" 40 Hadith Nawawi 32. If anything is going to cause harm, it's simply trespassing in islam and therefore it's prohibited.* So this one Hadith will abrogate e.g. all violent verses of the Quran? What about Muhammad's violent acts? Were those against Islam? *people nowadays think that one of the "possible" ways to attack islam is through mentioning the marriage story of The prophet PBUH and Aisha. They are connecting the 1400 year old Arabian society* and todays societies too. Did you see the Muslim cleric with a mark on his forehead? (I left a comment about it...) What do you have to say about his point of view? (and about the conversation before it?)

[@Danielcage1]

I am a Muslim and an Arab, I read the Quran in Arabic, never have I ever come across a verse of Violence that the Quran preaches without a reasoning to it, and mostly that reasoning is self-defense. The quran doesn't state that if somebody slaps you in one cheek you turn your other cheek back to him to slap you even more, this nonsense doesn't exist in Islam. "So whoever has assaulted you, then assault him in the same way that he has assaulted you. And fear Allah and know that Allah is with those who fear Him." 2:194. I would recommend you to go through the verses from 2:190 until you wish to stop. The Quran urges Muslims to be kind and generous toward those who did them no harm => "Allah forbids you not, with regard to those who fight you not for (your) Faith nor drive you out of your homes, from dealing kindly and justly with them: for Allah loveth those who are just." 60:8 "Go back and forth the Verses if you want and read the reason this Surah has been revealed". Muslims are advocated to give food to the poor, hungry and captive regardless of what religion they're affiliating to. "And they feed, for the love of Allah, the indigent, the orphan, and the captive" 76:8 "Again go back and forth the verses". You wouldn't think such verses exist in the Quran, because the media wouldn't propagate such verses, to them it's boring. This is what drives most people to convert to Islam when they read the Quran for themselves to know the truth about this whole terrorisim fiasco. I recommend that you grab the Quran, or just download it and read it with an open-mind. You will find that all verses that you once thought were violent are subjective to events during the time of the prophet PBUH or demands to self-defend in case of an attack. People do make mistakes and have their own interpretation of the Quran, like what lesley Hazleton said when she read the Quran that she knew enough, that is, she would be a terrorist in the Quran. Sneak a peek here => kzbin.info/www/bejne/aYqVgKVmgdGCbMk

[@woowooNeedsFaith]

Yesterday (or day before it) somebody already gave that exact link to me. I was not impressed though. Term which she used - anti-Muslim Islamophobes - is a big read flag to me. I didin't let it prevent me to watched it through though. I can see that you take Hadiths, Tafsirs, and the Quran seriously. Good. At least you are not one of those Quranists who do not accept any other evidences. *never have I ever come across a verse of Violence that the Quran preaches without a reasoning to it, and mostly that reasoning is self-defense.* At least you are honest by saying "mostly". Some others have not been intellectually that honest. *The quran doesn't state that if somebody slaps you in one cheek you turn your other cheek back to him to slap you even more, this nonsense doesn't exist in Islam.* If it did, then we would not have those terrorist jumping around? *to know the truth about this whole terrorisim fiasco.* What do you mean by fiasco? Terrorists are the fiasco, or something else? *I recommend that you grab the Quran, or just download it and read it with an open-mind.* Don't I need the Tafsir also because the Quran does not give the context? lesley Hazleton did not use them, which is her mistake, because she assumed she knew enough of the contexts, I suppose. How would you call her if she wrote yet another Tafsir where she explains the meanings and the contexts of the Quran verses without consulting the older Tafsirs at all? What are the chances that she has _better understanding_ of the context and the background than those early authors of exegesis? *You will find that all verses that you once thought were violent are subjective to events during the time of the prophet PBUH* So the Quran is not timeless book? Then I recommend tossing the whole book away and use your own reasoning instead to guide your choices in this earthly journey. To be more serious. I just don't understand why on earth god would add to his book parts which apply only to your prophet? Why that book is not a guidance for all people for all times? Muhammad's personal guidance should have been totally separate correspondence if it is not meant to be a guidance also for the other people. - Or was it that Muhammad wanted higher justification for his acts and that's why he added those parts to the Quran? *Back again to the guy with the mark on his forehead,* Do you btw know what that mark is? *Simple rule in Islam => Apply the hadith that I have mentioned earlier, if marriage is going to cause harm to the girl,* And how are you going to know (beforehand) if the marriage will cause harm to the girl? *it's up to her guardian to give her away or not* And that is the problem. Knowing how simple minded most of the Muslims are, what are the changes the guardian will make well-advised judgement / prediction if the marriage is harmless to the girl? And does the girl have any word on this issue? Can the guardian give her away against her will? *you still find thousands of moms in the western world at the age of 15, 16 and 17,* By definition, those girls are past their puberty. Quran allows marriage before the puberty, which is totally insane thing to be allowed. What kind of man wants to have a child so young as A WIFE? What other than sexual needs of his such young child - wife - can truly satisfy? Give birth to a child for him? Intellectual discussions? Give advices for human relations? Play with dolls with him?

[@shaleemn]

Recently discovered your channel bro. Awesome job! Had me cracking up quite a few times! Keep it up 👍🏽

[@Islamisthecultofsin]

Excellent video!

[@harsha307]

Which verses were chosen to go in the Quran, and which ones should go to Hadiths? Who decided all this? was there a consensus among the Quran writers' assembly back then?

[@mythias]

Man, the peanuts I am eating almost went all over my laptop when you mentioned the part on orgasms and who the child will look like "whose liquid comes first", hahaha. Loved that.

[@kocbilo]

I am Muslim born and I realized soon enough that I am a man of science and after having doubts for a very long time, it still took me a long period of time to free my mind of this religion bullshit. I still don't eat pork but this is probably just because of habits for 30 years. It is nearly impossible to come out with this in your family or your relatives because people will not understand and they will judge instantly. People will just be disappointed of you and maybe even will avoid you. I am lucky that I don't live in a country where this will kill you. I told my wife that I don't give a shit about these fairy tails and as an Atheist I even like the idea of the La Vey satanism. (I don't believe in Satan as a physical entity but I like some ideas of that like seeing humans as usual animals with desires and freedom and taking care of yourself by not giving shit about people who treat you badly etc.) She told me every time that she will divorce me the second she believes I am a non believer even though she loves me a lot. I could not convince her yet. Maybe she just doesn't want to see it. Even she doesn't want to know my real me or can't live with the idea of me being free. How can you expect a different reaction by others...Anyway thanks for reading if you did. I have nobody to talk to about all this.

[@Mindmergepk]

again mis-quoting here is the complete hadith: The Prophet (ﷺ) asked me at sunset, "Do you know where the sun goes (at the time of sunset)?" I replied, "Allah and His Apostle know better." He said, "It goes (i.e. travels) till it prostrates Itself underneath the Throne and takes the permission to rise again, and it is permitted and then (a time will come when) it will be about to prostrate itself but its prostration will not be accepted, and it will ask permission to go on its course but it will not be permitted, but it will be ordered to return whence it has come and so it will rise in the west. And that is the interpretation of the Statement of Allah: "And the sun Runs its fixed course For a term (decreed). that is The Decree of (Allah) The Exalted in Might, The All- Knowing." (36.38)

[@rabijassi2421]

Mind Merge Data Recovery Pvt Ltd sun rises in the east.

[@heba9978]

Differently worded hadith, but his point still stands. Both hadiths say the sun leaves to prostrate, which isn't true since the sun never actually sets and the earth is just rotating/revolving

[@nendhang]

The sun sets in muddy spring

[@alliedatheistalliance6776]

Love your videos! Great stuff, very informative and hilarious!

[@ravitelagathoti3747]

I really wonder, What is there in Quran if removed the content that already revealed in earlier holy books.

[@240018]

feel sad for a person who thinks our contemporary understanding of the physical world as offered by modern science is 100% correct and 100% fixed and would never change in future ... it only takes you few pages of any text book of science (say biology, medicine, etc.) that the author would say "our understanding is still primitive"...

[@mohithraslana3838]

one thing i can assure you...your understanding of science is very primitive

[@benbisley]

Very informative and worth viewing! (If the sun spends the night underneath the divine throne, the said throne must get terribly hot.)

[@syed3027]

Prophet Muhammad was a Ummi( illitrate- unlettered) how could he write the below verse about moon light being borrowed light...and what was the requirement to write this 1400 years ago “Blessed is He Who made Constellations in the skies, And placed therein a Lamp And a Moon giving light.” [Al-Qur’aan 25:61]

[@AbdullahSameerVideos]

Moon as light is responded to here: kzbin.info/www/bejne/haeqXmlma7Ckrbc

[@LlyneM-rf3gd]

Firasath Hussain Syed That verse does not say "borrowed light" or even imply it remotely. Astronomy was well studied by many knowlegeble people before and during "muhammad's" time. But even with that, "muhammad" gave a child's imagination version of astronomy.

[@sharifahussin787]

Firasath Hussain Syed +every human look up at the sky felt that , they feel bless, that's all.

[@changanikisesa7021]

Thats how youv been guided.May Allah see you again

[@rightwingtrollslayer]

These are great points, Abdullah. I personally think that most, if not all of the hadith are fabricated given that the first collection (Bukhari) was compiled 200 years after Muhammad's death. Here are several more I found in Bukhari which are quite troubling and disturbing: 1. Bukhari :: Book 3 :: Volume 48 :: Hadith 826 Narrated Abu Said Al-Khudri: The Prophet said, "Isn't the witness of a woman equal to half of that of a man?" The women said, "Yes." He said, "This is because of the deficiency of a woman's mind." 2. Bukhari :: Book 4 :: Volume 54 :: Hadith 509 Narrated Abu Huraira: The Prophet said, "Yawning is from Satan and if anyone of you yawns, he should check his yawning as much as possible, for if anyone of you (during the act of yawning) should say: 'Ha', Satan will laugh at him." 3. Bukhari :: Book 9 :: Volume 88 :: Hadith 219 Narrated Abu Bakra: During the battle of Al-Jamal, Allah benefited me with a Word (I heard from the Prophet). When the Prophet heard the news that the people of the Persia had made the daughter of Khosrau their Queen (ruler), he said, "Never will succeed such a nation as makes a woman their ruler." 4. Bukhari :: Book 7 :: Volume 62 :: Hadith 32 Narrated Sahl bin Sad: Allah's Apostle said, "If at all there is bad omen, it is in the horse, the woman, and the house." 5. Bukhari :: Book 7 :: Volume 62 :: Hadith 64 Narrated 'Aisha: that the Prophet married her when she was six years old and he consummated his marriage when she was nine years old, and then she remained with him for nine years (i.e., till his death). Bukhari :: Book 7 :: Volume 62 :: Hadith 88 Narrated 'Ursa: The Prophet wrote the (marriage contract) with 'Aisha while she was six years old and consummated his marriage with her while she was nine years old and she remained with him for nine years (i.e. till his death). 6. Bukhari :: Book 7 :: Volume 62 :: Hadith 52 Narrated Jabir bin 'Abdullah and Salama bin Al-Akwa': While we were in an army, Allah's Apostle came to us and said, "You have been allowed to do the Mut'a (marriage), so do it." Salama bin Al-Akwa' said: Allah's Apostle's said, "If a man and a woman agree (to marry temporarily), their marriage should last for three nights, and if they like to continue, they can do so; and if they want to separate, they can do so." I do not know whether that was only for us or for all the people in general. Abu Abdullah (Al-Bukhari) said: 'Ali made it clear that the Prophet said, "The Mut'a marriage has been cancelled (made unlawful)." 7. Bukhari :: Book 4 :: Volume 54 :: Hadith 516 Narrated Abu Huraira: The Prophet said, "If anyone of you rouses from sleep and performs the ablution, he should wash his nose by putting water in it and then blowing it out thrice, because Satan has stayed in the upper part of his nose all the night." 8. Bukhari :: Book 2 :: Volume 21 :: Hadith 245 Narrated 'Abdullah : A person was mentioned before the Prophet (p.b.u.h) and he was told that he had kept on sleeping till morning and had not got up for the prayer. The Prophet said, "Satan urinated in his ears." 9. Bukhari :: Book 4 :: Volume 54 :: Hadith 537 Narrated Abu Huraira: The Prophet said "If a house fly falls in the drink of anyone of you, he should dip it (in the drink), for one of its wings has a disease and the other has the cure for the disease." 10. Bukhari :: Book 4 :: Volume 54 :: Hadith 513 Narrated Abu Qatada: The Prophet said, "A good dream is from Allah, and a bad or evil dream is from Satan; so if anyone of you has a bad dream of which he gets afraid, he should spit on his left side and should seek Refuge with Allah from its evil, for then it will not harm him." 11. Bukhari :: Book 7 :: Volume 62 :: Hadith 169 Narrated Abu Huraira: (The Prophet) Solomon son of (the Prophet) David said, "Tonight I will go round (i.e. have sexual relations with) one hundred women (my wives) everyone of whom will deliver a male child who will fight in Allah's Cause." On that an Angel said to him, "Say: 'If Allah will.' " But Solomon did not say it and forgot to say it. Then he had sexual relations with them but none of them delivered any child except one who delivered a half person. The Prophet said, "If Solomon had said: 'If Allah will,' Allah would have fulfilled his (above) desire and that saying would have made him more hopeful." 12. Bukhari :: Book 1 :: Volume 4 :: Hadith 234 Narrated Abu Qilaba: Anas said, "Some people of 'Ukl or 'Uraina tribe came to Medina and its climate did not suit them. So the Prophet ordered them to go to the herd of (Milch) camels and to drink their milk and urine (as a medicine). So they went as directed and after they became healthy, they killed the shepherd of the Prophet and drove away all the camels. The news reached the Prophet early in the morning and he sent (men) in their pursuit and they were captured and brought at noon. He then ordered to cut their hands and feet (and it was done), and their eyes were branded with heated pieces of iron, They were put in 'Al-Harra' and when they asked for water, no water was given to them." Abu Qilaba said, "Those people committed theft and murder, became infidels after embracing Islam and fought against Allah and His Apostle ."

[@johnspears6128]

You are cool man a very good presentation we must admit. Keep up the good work, you sound good and sincere. God bless you and we pray for you, amen. Do more of these, as I said you presented well and we think you will have many followers. We personally will listen to you on your blogs. Again thank you and God bless you.

[@lpshastri5587]

Thank you so much for instilling senses in peoples mind. It is amazing that how even the so called educated people refuse to accept the scientific truth and accept sheer nonsense in the name of religion.

[@seanrathmakedisciples1508]

LP Shastri surely you mean come to Jesus and be empowered by the Holy Spirit

[@adeelaart4945]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/epupfqSOa9elaKs kzbin.info/www/bejne/oJWoeq2Ii9CZeLs kzbin.info/www/bejne/b3jGn62XntB8i68 kzbin.info/www/bejne/mIvCq6mAnq1jpLs

[@southparkundersecretwisdom3230]

usually it's not making stuff up but rather he explains things based on what people knew at the time

[@arrahatt]

Is the sun sets below Allah's throne he must be exceedingly hot!

[@MichElle-sd6gj]

Brother you are 1 of the many ex-muslims I appreciate listening to. Don’t stop.

[@FadelSoliman212]

Abdullah, again it is your hyper literalism which causes the problem, you started with a very beautiful hadith which establishes an important rule in Islam regarding dealing with the sunnah of the prophet ﷺ , some of his sayings are legislative and some aren't, Muslims should abide by the legislative because it is a part of the religion but other things that the prophet said or did aren't, for example it is well known and narrated by those who were close to him that he used to like to eat the arm of the goat, hyper literalists like you would think that because he ﷺ did that then it would be rewardable to eat it as well because they are taking him as an example here, while actually these are human traits that can exist in someone but not in others. A vegetarian who follows his ﷺ legislative sunnah is closer to him and to God from someone who eats the goat's arm but doesn't follow his teachings. The prophet's saying regarding the sun prostrating under the throne when it sets can be understood literally or wisely and scholarly, literally as you did and you keep mentioning this hadith because it is an excellent way to attack the prophet through it, but those who comprehend that the word sujoud in the arabic language means SUBMIT, therefore the prophet was saying that the sun submits to God, at a time when people were worshiping the sun and the stars the prophet ﷺ taught that the biggest star actually abides and submits to the laws of God. That's why not everyone who hears your ranting against this hadith of prophet Muhammad ﷺ leaves Islam, or get affected in the least. You have not found what none has found before, people who leave Islam or get doubts through the misunderstanding of these hadiths are hyper literalists, the word is what it is Dear Abdullah and Cheryl, The Quran and the sunnah are in Arabic, therefore the rules of Arabic should apply when we want to understand them, and the rich Arabic language is very figurative and eloquent language, full of metaphors كناية و مجاز if one ignores this aspect he/she will definitely be misguided. Please take a break and look well into the teachings of Islam, without this selectiveness and hyper literalism before you continue damaging families. I pray to Allah for my guidance as well as yours and to make us tools for good

[@jasonleaf9855]

after all the explaination he done and you still arguing about. Why you keep lying to yourself when the proof is front of you that Mohamad made those stories up. It's one thing got to be right HADITH or Mohamad. Start asking question about your religion before too late. And stop making Excuses that it's in ARABIC this or that because WHOLE SAUDI ARABIA BELIEVE IN BHUKARI HADITH

[@Be_Nice1200]

Bridges Foundation-So if English isn't sufficient to learn the Qur'an I'm forced to learn Arabic? Allah is purposefully forcing to learn another language, one of the most difficult at that, to learn and receive Salvation? Kind of unfair don't you think?

[@woowooNeedsFaith]

+Bridges Foundation *Abdullah, again it is your hyper literalism which causes the problem* And you try to avoid obvious mistake by interpreting some words differently? *The prophet's saying regarding the sun prostrating... the prophet was saying that the sun submits to God* So you are saying that "every night the sun submits to God"? So, at the time of the sunset the sun submits to God. But this would make sense only if the earth were flat. On a flat earth the sunset is observed at the same time everywhere on earth and Muhammad's answer would be acceptable. But on a spherical earth it makes no sense because the time of sunset is not single unique event. On spherical earth there is always a place on earth were the sun is setting. That would mean that the sun submits to God all the time, which would mean that the submission is not bound to any specific time i.e. time of sunset. So even with your interpretation the prophet's answer is nonsensical on spherical earth. It does not matter how you interpret that word, because what ever the sun does at the time of the sunset, it has to do it all the time. That's the real problem here. *Arabic language is very figurative and eloquent language, full of metaphors* If this is suppose to be only some other metaphor, then the prophet simply avoided answering the question. Somebody wanted to know what happens to the sun at the time of the sunset, but the prophet responded with nonsensical metaphor? It would have been better to simply say "I don't know." *if one ignores this aspect he/she will definitely be misguided.* You apply this aspect automatically and assume it will solve any possible problem. Because you assume it solves the problem, you won't even notice if there is some other problem left after you have applied your principle. *I pray to Allah for my guidance* There is really simple explanation why this has not worked, and won't. There is no magic man on the sky to listen your wishes.

[@OxAO]

Bridges: said, "hyper literalism" I think your right. we shouldn't take it so literally. Muhammad wasn't literally the prophet of Allah. Got it. That was very helpful.

[@jayola4119]

Mohamed (pissbeuponhim) just make things up for morons who don't care to question things.

[@kishorebajaj4353]

Sameer when u xplain Koranic verses, edicts,etc. The entire world pays attention ,; Your touch of humour to it Your proactive think and thought process Your unafraid stance on a religion hopelessly out of logic, rationale and ground reality. All this of you is part of the oncoming NEMESIS of Islam. Keep at it.

[@kaloarepo288]

Is there an authority within Islam which determines which are the authentic hadiths and which are not? Are hadiths necessary at all? Isn't the Koran sufficient?

[@xoxo2610]

You can't get the context of quranic incidents without referring to other Islamic sources.

[@arraikcruor6407]

The Quran doesn't provide context and many parts don't make sense. So hadiths are used and it is a scholarly consensus which are authentic and which are not.

[@kivkiv3331]

there is no Pope of islam, muslims follow their favorite scholars...

[@SilverSkySE]

Well there is the Quranist movement, who only use the Qur'an as the only source of authority and disregard the Sunnah.

[@kivkiv3331]

quranist are 1 of many movements...the real question is which movement has the biggest following. by the way quranists got problems because most verses doesn't make sense without the hadith

[@gill200s]

Hi Abdullah, can you make a separate video explaining how you were able to reconcile contradictions/errors in Quran and Hadis when you were still a muslim. It will give us a perspective on how religious people think whenever they encounter a contraction or insecurity about their religion.

[@AbdullahSameerVideos]

gill200s lol there's tons of apologetic videos on that already by Muslims 😁

[@gill200s]

Abdullah Sameer Thats true but you can also explain how you were able to challenge yourself on some of the issues and willing to change your belief. I am also an atheist now with a Sikh background and I was quite religious.

[@nurimanjaafar2205]

Eventually u will know the truth when u turn too dust. Fullstop..

[@adeelaart4945]

Exactly everyone can chose what they like but not to insult God.

[@rabijassi2421]

You will know truth too

[@adeelaart4945]

@batshitcrazy007 if 1=1 that's right then why we say 1+1+1=1 or God has human form like us. Truth is always truth

[@adeelaart4945]

@batshitcrazy007 Ali ibn Abu Talib (as) on the Existence of God Imagination cannot reach Him so as to assign Him quantity; Understanding cannot think of Him so as to give Him shape; Senses do not perceive Him so as to feel Him; Hands cannot touch Him so as to rub against Him; He does not change into any condition; He does not pass from one state to another; Nights and days do not turn Him old; Light and Darkness do not alter Him; It cannot be said that He has a limit or extremity or end or termination, nor do things control Him so as to raise Him or lower Him, nor does anything carry Him so as to bend Him or keep Him erect; He is not inside things nor outside them; He conveys news, but not with tongue or voice; He listens, but not with the holes of the ears or the organs of hearing; He says, but does not utter words; He remembers, but does not memorize; He determines, but not by exercising His mind; He loves and approves without any sentimentality (of heart); He hates and feels angry without any painstaking; When He intends to create someone He says, "Be," and there he is, but not through a voice that strikes (the ears) is that call heard; His speech is an act of creation. The foremost in religion is the acknowledgement of Him; The perfection of acknowledging Him is to testify Him; The perfection of testifying Him is to believe in His Oneness; The perfection of believing in His Oneness is to regard Him pure, and the perfection of His purity is to deny Him attributes because every attribute is a proof that is different from that to which it is attributed, and everything to which something is attributed is different from the attribute. Thus whoever attaches attributes to God recognizes His like, and who recognizes His like regards Him two, and who regards Him two recognizes parts for Him, and who recognizes parts for Him mistook Him, and who mistook Him pointed at Him, and who pointed at Him admitted limitations for Him, and who admitted limitations for Him numbered Him; Whoever said 'in what is He?' held that he is contained, and whoever said 'on what is He held?" He is not on something else. He is a being but not through the phenomenon of coming into being; He exists but not from non-existence; He is with everything but not in physical nearness; He is different from everything but not in physical separation; He acts without connotation of movements and instruments; He sees even when there is none to be looked at from among His creation; He is only One, such that there is non whom he may keep company or whom He may miss in his absence. Holy Qur'an 41:53 - "We will show them our signs in the universe and in their own selves until it becomes manifest to them that this is the truth."

[@avimdobal1037]

@@adeelaart4945 😂 1*1*1*...=1

[@ranjanazad01]

you are highlighting some really nice points. good job

[@satyaraja6019]

bro you are a beacon of hope for ex muslims. Stay safe

[@sharegreats2157]

Good video, enjoyed watching it. Regards from Germany.

[@BrianScottGameNight]

1. LOVE you. You're great. Keep doing what you're doing. 2.Stop calling him a Prophet. He was a False Prophet. 3. Shave your beard. it's a remnant of being a Muslim.

[@parkbaekhyun2014]

Brian Scott naah. Islam doesn't own the beard. don't give it that power

[@MayTheRighteousWin]

Hahahahahahaha they are so afraid of Islam. yes keeping beard is the practice of All the previous prophets.

[@MayTheRighteousWin]

@New Age well what u see does neccesaryly be true. it is advisable to trim youf moustache and grow beard. growing beard the practice of all prophets and trimming moustache is advised so that u dont with proudyness on the earth.

[@MayTheRighteousWin]

@New Age u dont know but there were cultures like the byzatynes who use to grow long moustaches n no beard as sign of pride and honour and bravery. In Islam it is not advisable to clean shave moustache but trim it and not grow it long.

[@deathmachine808]

Great content.

[@khagt3826]

اشكر العلم والطبيعة واشكرك شخصيا لإخراجي من الظلمات الى النور. انا ملحد وافتخر .

[@saberihaddad309]

انت جزائري.

[@arrahatt]

If Allah passes wind it might sniff out the sun and the world will end. Please everybody pray hard that Allah has no gas.

[@kivkiv3331]

i cracked up at Booji Booji!!!

[@topgunforpeace6093]

I am like agnostic but i have paranormal experience where I couldn't lift my head while i was performing prostration

[@djellyice1]

two things that strike me odd here . #1 you kept your muslim name : Abd Allah ( translated to Servant of Allah ) . #2 Your accent . For #1 I do get they vibe that you intentionally want to be called that name. Reasons for being of showing the world that you are an Ex - muslim and having that name. #2 I do have a suspicion that accents belongs to someone with a Hebrew language tongue. Listen to Israelis speak english and come back again listen to this guy. #3 He has a muslim styled beard . why ? I thought he left Islam ? oh wait. again trying to show the world oh hey ex-muslim here. The Mosad stops at nothing . If this guy is so afraid of backlash of leaving Islam, why is he publicizing himself with these nonsense arguments ? He's just another fake. Edit : the first Hadith he read about the Palm trees for example . The answer is given to you at the very end of the Hadith . The Prophet himself says it . The question here : does This abdullah sameer person know it and he’s just being sneaky ? Or Is he really that dumb ?

[@youtubestudiosucks978]

1 he got that name from his parents so he'll probably keep it, changing names cost money and is expensive so pay him the appropiate amount of money he ask for if you want him to change it. Give him 20 million if you want him to change his name. 2 you dont magically change accents overnight. 3 you really need to count and that's just a normal beard, muslim style beards are without mustache.

[@rizieqbejat4363]

That's why there are hundreds of Nobel prize winners in Science, physics who were once schooled in madrasah.

[@RamBo-yh3kz]

Wonder what Mohammad was smoking that time.

[@awakenedsight]

Bro if you are truly honest you know that muslim and bukhari are not reliable , and if according to you that these are the gold standard of sunni muslim then only sunni believe in those hadith . What I would suggest for you is to study the life of muhammad without prejudices and stop relying on these fake hadith that you don't even understand. What is the difference between sun setting or going beneath allahs throne , it is just a way of talking . If you with your small mind don't believe that the creator can have a throne do you think a person like muhammad would believe such a thing . The difference between scientist and spiritualist is that science try to dissect thing whereas spiritualist understand things as they are . A doctor has to open up a frog in other to understand how the frog work whereas a spiritual man just observe the frog and look at it as it is .

[@jonathanthainguyen]

I love you lol

[@tanzsam1797]

Muhammad had 12 wives but no children? Yet Abraham was promised to be a multitude of Nations. So where is prophets multitude?

[@seldom7288]

5:51 correction from a cosmology nerd , the sun in-fact does move , it orbits around the center of the Milky Way.

[@ctgtraveller866]

May peace and blessings be with you brother Abdullah Sameer 💞💕🇦🇺

[@sabyasachisabya6574]

oh man! nice presentation. thanks friend.

[@farhanhaq2053]

On the day of judgement we’ll see who’s right and who’s wrong. InshaAllah.

[@ednan9]

farhan haq no day of judgement- all made up

[@govindindurkar3100]

In that Hadith of sunset the word RAK’has is mentioned.what does it mean? Indians believed that during eclipse sun is gulped by RAKSHAS Rahu.

[@killuminaati]

جزاک اللہ خیر کثِیراً🤲🏻✋🏻✋🏻✋🏻✋🏻✋🏻✋🏻✋🏻✋🏻🤲🏻✋🏻🤲🏻♥️🥀

[@BEAMERBMWboy]

Almost bursting with fury: Every time a Group is cast therein, its Keepers will ask, "Did no Warner come to you?"

[@NiflJonne]

5:22 The sun is moving around the milkyway at incredible speed. (I presume that you know this, but misspoke)

[@detoxlady6777]

These are topics of their "Kutbas" or sermons which I have witnessed. Muslims who attend these sermons, which occur on Fridays and which are MANDATORY for males, are cautious of Jews because they believe that Jews will cause them harm owing to these Hadiths. I have found that the more a Muslim is Islamic, then the more he or she will hate Jews because of these HADITHS. Ex-Muslim here. I was a Muslim for 34 years. In my experience, the best Muslims are those who have nothing to do with Islam.

[@AjayKumar-fx1qy]

Great explanations

[@thequranreader1109]

This video misleads Muslims and other nonmuslims who watch this channel. I pray that Allah forgives whatever you spoke about Islam and our beloved Prophet SAW. Going through the comments was a disgrace even wallahi brothers and sisters, what are we promoting here?....Atheism? But let me tell you all brothers and sisrers that I was once ignorant of the deen (religion)of Allah not mine (He has blessed me). I was engaged in the Qur'an and sunnah and it taught me a lot

[@Randomdude-td6el]

If it’s misleading then prove that it’s misleading and the information given in this video isn’t true If you don’t have proof then don’t talk about it

[@stanpski5442]

Abdullah. There is not a single religion that wouldn't be a pile of nonsense. All you need is - common sense, some knowledge and most of all ethics.

[@qasimqamar4996]

A adieu, a adieu O Islam

[@BigHeretic]

It's so simple, why do so many continue in the charade that is religion. Just add some basic enquiry and a bit of logic and the stories melt like a snowball in summer. You've not even got to the heavy stuff yet like why apostates must die just for not believing - how do Muslims square that with their own sense of justice?

[@billannau5872]

Love you. Great stuff.

[@ultrasignificantfootnote3378]

Thankyou for this enlightening video.

[@kasnaidoo8618]

Thank you for sharing your journey. You inspire other lost confused souls who are weak and are being brainwashed, to be set free and live life. This world needs more of you and less of Zakir Naiks. That brother is not helping to make this a better home..yes, We all share one home .. Earth. We breathe the same air. All experience love, laughter , sorrow, joy. What separates us are people like ZN who misuse their intellect and contribute to mental pollution and instability to society. Between our first breathe and our last, is a short journey called LIFE. How we live it impacts on this planet we call home.. Love moves the world❤

[@naimhussain6013]

as a muslim ive always had an issue with the hadiths sunnis are the only ones who follow it, i would love to see more criticisms of it so we can determine what is a "strong hadith" and "weak hadith"

[@lifeloving4771]

Such a lovely informative video. Muhammad manged to insult women and Jews in one Hadeeth. that is a bargain. 2 in 1. well done Muhammad.

[@rossini55]

Can you imagine the conversation between 2 guys back in 7th C Arabia. Dude1: "Hey, mister, your kid looks nothing like you!" (furiously looks for an excuse to save face) Dude2: "Oh, that's because I am so good at sex that my wife always splurges first!" (phew!) CHECKMATE!

[@Atlas9ne]

It means that People of Israel were the first to keep food and meat until it would go bad and get rotten and if it was not for the People of Israel who started this habit, people would not have kept food for so long till it goes bad. This is how al-Abi and al-Hafiz explained it in al-Fath. However; it does not mean that for the people before the People of Israel food and meat never rotted even if they saved it. But the meaning in fact is that the habit of saving the food was not common before them. For the people used to eat and feed others and nothing decayed till the People of Israel came, and they kept saving it till it would get rotten.” So the meaning actually is that these were the people of Israel who started the general practice of hoarding surplus food with them which used to rot and get wasted. Before them generally the people used to collect food only for their own selves. And when they had surplus they would share it with other people (either through charity or trade). So they were actually the people who started the general practice that lead to wasting of food. And he then quotes the report telling us when it so happened; “al-Aini narrated from Qatadah: "the Mann and Salwa used to fall upon the People of Israel, from dawn to the sunrise, like the ice falls. So they would take from it just enough for the day except Friday, when they had to gather for it and the next day (Saturday). But if they exceeded (their need), it used to get spoiled. So their saving used to cause a food waste for them and others." (Takmilah Fath al-Mulhim, Darul Ahya al-Turath al-‘Arabi Beirut 2006 vol.1 p.140)

[@1fagus033]

Good stuff , please keep it up

[@ButterF1y01]

About the sun hadith the answer is .... some of terms mentioned in quran or hadith doesn’t reflects its literal meaning but allah or the prophet had used it to explain in a way fits our brain for example when your little child asked a doctor for some explaining of course the doctor will try to choose a sort of words thats fit with the child brain otherwise he won’t understand

[@taluproperty8086]

I. am so glad that you are doing that wonderful, can you please do all your serios in Urdu too, because the common people in Pakistan don't understand English that way the message willl spread quickly and people will start open their eyes thanks

[@phralvim]

The german academic on Islam Gerd Puin stated that one fifth of Quran is incomprehensible even to arabic speakers. Do you agree with him? It could be a topic to discuss in a video, maybe...

[@ApoIogeticsMan]

The Bible, in stark contrast to all other religious books, contains no errors or historical/scientific facilities. Many have taken it upon themselves to debunk the Bible, and have often become Christians, as a result of their studies and research. As far as God's existence, there not only is a God, there MUST be a God, because the order, complexity, purpose, implied intent in the world and universe can not be explained by any means other than an all powerful, aware being making it happen. Nothing simply exists or becomes without a beginning.

[@alexandermadsen3542]

Nothing simply exists or becomes without a beginning... Except for god. Right? Or was god created by super god? Who would then in turn have had to be created by some sort of MEGA god.. Yea, i see what you're saying.

[@ApoIogeticsMan]

@@alexandermadsen3542 No, God has never begun, He has no creator.

[@thesissolutions132]

May Allah guide you to the rightest path.. Ameen.

[@abdurahmanitani5982]

All the Hadiths you mentioned do have a background story to which they make complete sense. For example, in the first hadith, the prophet Muhammed explains himself later that he said what he said was his own speculation or observation and not from God and apologised to the people ( nothing wrong with that). Actually if anything, goes to show you how humble he is. He could have said something along the lines of " oh, you didn't know how to do it" or " i didn't mean that" or lie " I never said that" etc. , that is proof to show you that the prophet Muhammed is a human being too. Also if you want to go further, God (Allah ) in the Quran reprimands his Prophet Muhammed (peace be upon him) because he frowned at a blind man(search for back story). if indeed, prophet muhammed wrote the Quran or is making up stuff as he goes along.. " wouldn't it make more sense for him to not reprimand himself in his own book??".

[@jackthisout9480]

Abdullah, it just amazes me that muslims can believe these things and are even willing to defend it with all they have. You must feel relieved that you are finally allowed to think what you think.

[@farrukheijaz1026]

Well the first Hadith he translated is wrong, The correct translation is something like prophet Muhammad after getting to know what was going on made a statement which roughly translates to " What then even if they don't do it " It was not an explicit instruction but a simple comment on what was going on but the companions of prophet out of immense respect simply abandoned the activity altogether probably without even him knowing. Now when abandoning the activity resulted in reduced production and they came back to the prophet and told him about his saying and at that point Prophet said "If its a matter of religion then refer to me but if it is one of the matters of this world then you know best" . Arabic is a beautiful language and it takes a good bit of research to properly understand the meaning. some words just can't be translated.

[@mr.m8817]

Knowledge of God’s existence is often taken for granted by believers. The authentic religious experience - affirmed again and again in a Muslim’s daily life - makes faith in God feel so natural as to be assumed. But belief in God and the quest for existential truth is not an easy prospect for many people, especially in a social environment in which faith is derided as superstition, wishful thinking, or even as a dangerous fantasy. In the Islamic tradition, the case for God’s existence is solid in terms of its rational foundations as well as the purpose, meaning, comfort, and guidance that it gives to our lives. The Quran inspires conviction by appealing to the aspects of the inner life of human beings, namely, to the heart and the mind. Intuition and experience work in tandem with logic and reason to arrive at a state of certainty in faith.

[@killuminaati]

ﷺ

[@killuminaati]

ﷺ♥️🤲🏻✋🏻✋🏻✋🏻✋🏻✋🏻🤲🏻✋🏻♥️🥀