Charismatic and Hyper-Charismatic, Whats the Difference? w/ Melissa Dougherty

[@matttate9999]

I do believe that we can hear the Holy Spirit but we also hear our agendas, wants, and damage. Everything must be tested by Scripture.

[@rachray83]

Scripture is what the Spirit of Yahweh who is the Spirit of Christ who is the Spirit of the Lord who is the Spirit of God whom is the Spirit of our God and Father, He is the same One Spirit, and Scripture tells us when Scripture speaks we ARE hearing the Spirit speak. The NT literally says, "The Spirit said" and quotes the OT. In the NT the NT writers will say, "The Spirit" says, and they then provide NT scripture. The Spirit is not saying anything new nor different and certainly not contradictory from the word of God, The Bible which was breathed out by God. Also Christ tells us that when He would send His Spirit He would not speak of His own authority. The Spirit of Yahweh is not off doing His own thing, running His own Spirit focused show, but specifically pointing to Christ, shaping & forming the fruit in Christ's people that looks, talks and conforms to the character of Christ, and Christ is called The Word of God. We are conformed to Christ by the Word of God, applied by the Spirit of God, that's His work, His ministry pre Christ's return.

[@michaelbrickley2443]

Matt Tate, and don’t build doctrine on one or two verses. You are so right, though. We will hear the enemy or the flesh or the world. We’re not here to please anyone but Him

[@jeremeydwinell1316]

AMEN AMEN AMEN!!!

[@luciaalcala9409]

I can relate to the video and so many of the comments. I cannot in good faith even think about what i left behind in my last NAR, hypercharsimatic church. I struggle with whether or not to speak to my old "mentor". I am praying and thank you ladies for helping me along this journey. Another Gospel is a fantastic book- I can relate to needing that life boat many times. It was through Gods mercy truth was revealed. I pray constantly and I read by bible daily. I see the error everywhere now. The work is not yet done! Thanks ladies.

[@jasonbryan9056]

Hello how are you doing 😊😊

[@caroleimani9754]

@@jasonbryan9056 Are you a troll...Do you talk to other men?

[@BrotherDave80]

Christianity definitely needs to return to sound doctrine and stop being afraid and tolerant of false teachings!

[@lesliewilliford2179]

Ya im seeing tolerance running rampant in the Church.

[@lesliewilliford2179]

@Desire Of All Nations im not sure what you mean by protestant

[@fnjesusfreak]

@@lesliewilliford2179 Yeah, it's called ecumenicism.

[@lesliewilliford2179]

@@fnjesusfreak really? I thought it was NAR

[@fnjesusfreak]

@@lesliewilliford2179 NAR is a different problem.

[@dodieking7121]

For years, I felt like I was told to read other books other than the Bible because they were promoted as truthful. It is when I started to read my bible first and pray for wisdom that I realized that these authors were telling me lies and that the Bible was my first source to go to for truth. I rejected a lot of what I was taught as I met wise and spiritual mentors who showed me how to really read the Bible.

[@TheBestLife2184]

Evil billionaires, Democrats, & RINOs brainwash us all 365 days a year. In 10 minutes your kids & you can be immune to it. My name is a dotCom website & you should to go there. Expect your life to likely hugely change in 10 minutes or less.

[@melindamercier6811]

I totally get this. I’d had enough with a church I was going to when the pastor actually had us reading a book called “The Story” which is pretty much a truncated 31 chapter Bible in chronological with specific Scripture handpicked to sound more entertaining. I’m not even exaggerating, their own description says: “it allows the stories, poems, and teachings of the Bible to read like a novel. Like any good story, The Story is filled with intrigue, drama, conflict, romance, and redemption - and this story’s true!” Now, this is a great book supplement to the Bible that may help one get a contextual grasp on timelines, but this book was the only book that the pastor ever encouraged the congregation to read faithfully in my time at that church. Apparently he had also done that a few years prior for a Rick Warren book. Never in my 5 years of being at that church had I ever heard him encourage people so fervently to read their own Bibles regularly as he did this book which was basically a chopped up Bible! Then he started making the staff (which included my husband) read Andy Stanley books, and I mentally checked out from that church. I’m so grateful the Lord eventually provided my husband with a different job opportunity so we could freely attend a biblically based church of our choosing. The prosperity gospel along with the grow-your-own-mega-church mindset was seeping into it rapidly.

[@artistart55]

One of the biggest problems today with Christianity is ""PROFESSIONAL CHRISTIAN AUTHORS"" Selling books for financial gain...$$$ Some of today's biggest mega pastors have written 100s of books and study bibles And there networth is in the Millions

[@AbidethForever]

D - can you share those "spiritual mentors" you've mentioned?

[@TRUMP-2024-STF]

When reading this minimum 2,000 year old collection of letters.. how many Hebrew Idioms do you recognize..?? How many culture references can you point out..?? Do you understand Hebrew poetry..?? Do you recognize when your reading picture language..?? And can you understand it..?? When reading this minimum 2,000 collection of letters.. in our English translations that we have.. can you tell what words were mistranslated..?? Or even OMITTED..?? The Bible isn’t a easy read.. it’s eastern.. it’s the complete opposite of how we thing, see our world.. So.. when you say you just read the Bible.. and all of a sudden your enlightened. I call BULL.. until you study all of those (what I said above) and more.. you will know very little.. it’s not a slight.. it’s not a diss.. it’s a fact..

[@monkeypwn77]

Holy spirit walks hand in hand with scripture. He talks with us and he walks with us and tells us things that God wants us to do, but he will never go against the word.

[@considertheravens2024]

Amen!

[@catherinecooper8370]

Amen.

[@karenkalasy8251]

I'm hearing many Christians now saying "Holy Spirit" instead of The Holy Spirit? Can anyone explain?

[@megb6820]

@@karenkalasy8251 someone explained to me that it is in part an attempt to emphasize the fact that Holy Spirit is a person, not an “it”, or “power” or “force”.

[@yeshuaneitheristheresalvat8018]

Correction. Please my Lord Jesus never says or teaches what you comment says. Please show us this. RATHER, FATHER SAYS THE SON IS PREEMINANTt, AND the SPIRIT SAYS "THAT HE (CHRIST) IS TO HAVE THE PREMINANCE!

[@ericokane8136]

When we pray we talk to God. When we study Gods Word, God talks to us.

[@laurasanders5015]

Yes. But He is also very capable of talking directly to us as well. Just like He did to His people in the pages of Scripture. Prayer is not meant to be a monologue.

[@Prin_Cess_007]

@@laurasanders5015 prayer is not meant to be a monologue.? Respectfully, are you sayings it’s more like a phone line to directly speak to God and He audibly speaks back having an active conversation?

[@laurasanders5015]

@@Prin_Cess_007 No, and I would say it’s definitely nothing like a phone conversation! Wish it was!! Most people either rarely or never hear the audible voice of God, although it’s possible. I never have. What I am saying is that communication is fundamental to a relationship. You can’t have a real relationship with a person without communication. The Bible is full of stories of God communicating with His people. Nowhere do we read in the pages of Scripture that we must now only hear from God via the Bible and no other way. If the Bible did teach that, I would accept it without question, because I revere God’s Word. I would say though that the Bible is the main means of communication between God and His people. It helps us to discern and understand the ways and character of God so that if we do get an impression or hear an internal non audible “still small voice” or a prophetic word etc. , we have an objective “measuring stick” to keep us safe from deception. One of the ways God speaks to me most often is to bring a particular Scripture to mind that is needed in a particular situation. That’s another reason it is so important for each of us to know His Word...if we don’t know it, How does He speak to us using it? God can and does speak in all kinds of ways..and a study through the Old and New Testaments will help you see all the various ways he has spoken so that we can know some of His ways of communicating with us as His children. Blessings to you.

[@freshliving4199]

When we pray we hear from God. Be still and know. When we study the Bible, mostly Satan talks to us. God’s voiceless voice reveals to us from within.

[@caroleimani9754]

@@freshliving4199 When we study, mostly Satan speaks to us???????

[@rohanpeart2651]

I am a huge proponent of experiencing the presence of God. I got saved at 15 years old, and had tremendous encounters with God in prayer. I was addicted to drugs, cigarettes and alcohol, then I got saved at a small Church in Baltimore, MD. And God washed all of my addictions away. I do agree that many in hyper charismatic circles abuse the concept of having an “experience” with God. And they value it over studying and obeying the written word. But for me that certainly has never been the case. In fact quite the opposite. The hours I spent in prayer hearing and feeling the presence of Holy Spirit, induced a greater appetite within in me to study Gods word. I was taught from a young age to test the prophetic words spoken over my life by the scriptures. So I never placed a great deal of value on anything that was said by pastors or so-called prophets if it didn’t line up with the scriptures. I agree with most of what you have stated, however, the one thing I take exception with is the statement made by the young lady on the left. “If you’re hearing God speak to you audibly what incentive do you have to study your Bible.” Paul had several encounters where Jesus appeared to him, and other encounters were the Holy Spirit spoke to him. Those experiences never led him to the conclusion, “what’s the point in me studying the word when I have the ability to hear from God audibly?” The revealed word creates a greater appetite for the written word. If it doesn’t then it’s not God speaking to you. And if it contradicts the written word in anyway, it’s not God speaking to you.

[@trevortonner106]

Melissa this is SO on point!!! I have been speaking back and forth with a woman about some of the teachings that she is believing and she basically told me yesterday I have the religious Pharisee spirit... I too have heard her say that we let our minds get in the way. If you see this or anyone else happens to see this please say a prayer that she would be responsive to the gospel. She has been under these lies for 40 years. I am meeting her for coffee this Tuesday and I'm going to show her this video and we are going to talk some things through. I am so passionate about this specific topic and the prosperity gospel... I'm seeing the deception of these play out in my community and it is so sad. Keep it up sisters! I've received harsh criticism about sharing truth, but I'm trying to be led by the spirit and pick the battles he wants me to engage in.

[@robbinsnest6163]

I lean more charismatic but I want to avoid the extremes. If it doesn't line up with God's Word then I want to check it and keep it in check. I always hate hearing the phrase "worship experience." I want an "encounter." I can have an "experience" with anything, because it's just feelings based, but a true encounter with God, in worship, prayer, reading His Word is transformative. My husband shared a sermon by David Wilkerson titled "don't judge your spiritual growth by how you feel." That title in itself is powerful but the whole sermon is a good listen.

[@mary-janechambers3596]

After studying the works of Martin Luther, Don Matzat said, “While I accept a ‘mysticism of the word’ and believe that we actually encounter Christ in the gospel as the Holy Spirit supernaturally enlightens our understanding, I cannot embrace a mysticism which directs my focus unto myself, in order to look within myself.” From the book, Christ Esteem.

[@Monpris0590]

Yep, so can relate...experience was my truth..I remember those days not feeling up to par because I wasn't "feeling" or being "led" as others were.

[@TheBestLife2184]

Evil billionaires, Democrats, & RINOs brainwash us all 365 days a year. Mi naam is a ch*an el.

[@michaelbee2165]

@@TheBestLife2184 Dies your website direct Christians to the Bible or does it direct people just to your website? You've reposted this same comment.

[@TheBestLife2184]

@@michaelbee2165 My previous comment is old so I need to edit it now. Mi we-bs-yte is down now. All I have now is a ch*an-el that is si-milar to the we-b-sy-te. Mi naam leads to the ch*an el, and the ch*an el is and will be much about J-es-us.

[@TheBestLife2184]

@@michaelbee2165 I put my we-bs-yt-e up again. My w-ebs-yt-e is ca-lled Tea-ch Ot-hers Da-ily. Put those w-ords toge-ther as 1 word, add the usual . and a c and o and m. Don't put das-hes in the web-sy-te naam.

[@steelshade]

Those who sincerely get into God's word, the Bible, can always find something new and refreshing, even from a passage read many times before. What a joy to be limited to God's Word!

[@somethingtothinkabout167]

You study the Scriptures diligently because you think that in them you have eternal life. These are the very Scriptures that testify about me, yet you refuse to come to me to have life.

[@mcgheebentle1958]

@@somethingtothinkabout167 No one, especially those who are diligently in God’s Word, believes that Scripture is the source of eternal life. Ironically, the more time I study scripture, the more I know this to be true. When I study scripture, I become more and more worshipful of Christ, and in HIM we have eternal life!! Scripture points us to the One we worship, and again ironically, people that study scripture diligently are usually the ones most attentive to this fact.

[@somethingtothinkabout167]

@@mcgheebentle1958 No one?

[@mcgheebentle1958]

@@somethingtothinkabout167 I am a conservative Bible literalist. I’m proudly Sola Scriptura. And even someone like me (who is admittedly on the extreme end of the belief in Biblical inerrancy scale) doesn’t think we find eternal life in the Scriptures. The people that do believe this probably exist, but I’d consider them (1) in the minority, (2) and not to be Christian. So make of that what you will.

[@mcgheebentle1958]

@@somethingtothinkabout167 I love the verse you originally posted, by the way. Was reading that chapter a week ago or so. And it’s because I take the Bible seriously (which includes taking the passage you originally posted seriously!!) that I indeed affirm that the Scriptures aren’t the source of eternal life. Only the Lord Jesus is. So I’m saying that I agree with you!!! I just don’t think it’s a “comeback” to people that love Scripture, because people that love Scripture also love that verse because they love Scripture!! I hope that makes sense. I was trying to say that it isn’t the comeback that you may think it is.

[@Jmqqqqqqqqq]

This is so good! I came out of the hyper-charismatic movement. I had to literally throw all my experiences /dreams/ visions/ & whatever else.... down at the feet of Jesus and put my trust and let scripture become the authority in my life. When I dove into the actual Word, God opened my eyes to the truth and I’m so grateful to him and for you both because you both put a lot of truth into my life as well. ❤️

[@pjbostic]

Grammatrain performed about 200 shows our first year of touring.we must have had 50 or 60 well meaning people prophesy over us.The thing was however that they all pretty much contradicted each other and rarely would we hear a prophesy that lined up with another one and I can’t say if I remember any one of them ever coming true. After 4 years of touring I became convinced we were prophet magnets. Too bad non of them came true we were supposed to be rich and famous by now! and my family could really use some of that RICH LOL!!

[@woodb51]

I get what you are saying. I have probably heard about 2,000 prophetic words in my lifetime and I doubt that more than 10% were authentic.

[@rosehammer9482]

I am so thankful that both of you are alerting people of these practices that are infiltrating the church. Thank you for encouraging others to pick up the Book and read. I truly believe people will get informed when they do. Sorcery, fortune telling, magic divination are all forbidden. There’s a lot of practices some in the church are doing and they don’t even realize it. Please keep addressing these issues.

[@hommerecorder7003]

vieles von dem ist auch nach europa geschwappt. leider.

[@vanessatamplin7659]

The WORD OF GOD only ! Yes Jesus is enough his word we are so blessed 🙌

[@bloodboughtbigphilr8266]

No problem with charismatic believers allowing the Holy Spirit to have His way and sticking to Scripture parameters. Huge problems with hyper-charismatics who may or may not be saved believers sidestepping Scripture and opening themselves up to the deceptions of 'another spirit'. All things in the church are to be done decently and in order and God is not the author of confusion. With hyper-charismatics, confusion too often abounds and the manifestations indecent and out of order. Gives the game away that God is not among them when the strange stuff happens and more likely to be the work of Kundalini forces in a 'Christian' guise. We need to know the difference between the Holy and the profane.

[@1cor69]

Anyone know HOW to overcome kundalani?

[@BeccaD70]

Love this! Is this a part of a longer video? I’d love to see the whole thing.

[@jasonbryan9056]

Hello how are you doing 😊😊

[@jonathanbarnes3061]

@@jasonbryan9056 Back off man.

[@leighs3439]

I think it’s this one kzbin.info/www/bejne/lZ-uo32shMmfadk

[@martinkelsey275]

First 4 mins sums up very well, this whole " you need an encounter" teaching that is so deceptive/seductive. We are born again, we have the spirit of christ in us, christ in you the hope of glory, we know we have past from death to life, eternal life. So why keep looking for more out there, like oh dear, may be what Jesus did isn't quite enough, may be I'm missing out on some thing. No way, he really has given us every thing we need for life and godliness. God bless every one

[@Sarah-ln4qc]

And he gave some, apostles; and some, prophets; and some, evangelists; and some, pastors and teachers; 12 For the perfecting of the saints, for the work of the ministry, for the edifying of the body of Christ: 13 Till we all come in the unity of the faith, and of the knowledge of the Son of God, unto a perfect man, unto the measure of the stature of the fulness of Christ: 14 That we henceforth be no more children, tossed to and fro, and carried about with every wind of doctrine, by the sleight of men, and cunning craftiness, whereby they lie in wait to deceive;

[@godsbeloved9256]

God spoke to Moses through a burning bush, but he met Paul on the road to Damascus. Two different encounters both of which are in the Bible where God spoke directly. So why are we surprised when someone says that they got a word from God? The apostolic age is still here and spiritual gifts did not cease.

[@RandomBoxingGuy]

“Experience is your truth”…. Is a perfect definition of MOST Charismatic churches I’ve seen. Anytime someone calls out the “demon slayers” or “faith healers”, for their absurd practices, the response is always “Well my EXPERIENCE tells me it’s legit”… or “I FELT something, so I know it’s real.” When Scripture makes it clear our feelings, experiences, and emotions CANNOT be trusted, only scripture can. Scripture tells us the “hearts of man our evil”. Millions of Muslim believe that Allah is doing miracles in their life because of their EXPERIENCE. Millions of Hindus believe the same with their gods. We go off the word of God… not our “feelings” or “experiences.”

[@pastorrandy]

Thank you for this video. As a Pentecostal pastor for 40 years, I have had to deal with this. The first and possibly second generations of charismatics were not like what you have described. Except for the Roman Catholic charismatics, the Protestants charismatics were more into the Word. Things changed in the 1990s when the New Order of the Latter Rain had a resurgence and began influencing independent charismatic churches. Paul and Jan Crouch and TBN didn't help much either.

[@Maranatha7557]

I am Charismatic. I’m wondering, are there balanced Charismatic or Pentecostal churches out there? I have had a hard time seeing that. Either a church will say they are Charismatic, but don’t really use the gifts, or they are NAR or hyper Charismatic.

[@pastorrandy]

​@@Maranatha7557 They are increasingly difficult to find.

[@KarinAllison]

LOVE Melissa's face when hearing about Glennon Doyle's "sinking lower". :) Brilliant. LOL

[@lanes2593]

😂😂

[@victoriachapman5674]

Ya i was just thinking that lol 😆 her expressions are hilarious 😂

[@matasaina2011]

She's still a baby Christian

[@KarinAllison]

@@matasaina2011 I don't know about that. She's way more informed and reflected than some lifelong Christians. This sort of evaluation really doesn't matter to me.

[@cavelleardiel]

Liquid gold sounds like the same verbiage New Agers use for chakra healing, etc. Also, we should be reaching higher as God is in the heavens not lower........I don't want to go there. lolol

[@shanemcguire6428]

experiences in the spirit of God are a real as a pentecostal i can personally testify to that but everything God does are in the confines of scripture in other words the Lord will not speak or show you anything that his word does not back up

[@rh10033]

Exactly. The Holy Spirit still speaks to us and we should be hearing Him in order to live out God's will. But God will never tell us something that goes against scripture.

[@woksaus]

Couldn't agree more

[@catherinecooper8370]

Amen. Charismatic myself. But I do not support the NAR. Many false teachers. The Holy Spirit will not contradict the Bible. We need to test things. Charismatic churches do not teach discernment.

[@shanemcguire6428]

@@catherinecooper8370 oh i do not support the NAR either but you got to have a little discernment on what is real and what is not

[@shanemcguire6428]

@@1john4six what are you talking about man

[@matthewdavidlandberg91588]

I am not a hyper-charismatic GOD centered, spirit lead, Bible believing Christian but I am a spirit lead, Bible believing, GOD centered (Father, Son & Holy Spirit) charismatic Christian!

[@hommerecorder7003]

DAS WÜRDE ICH NOCH EINMAL MIT DER SCHRIFT PRÜFEN. . 1. kORINTHER 8. VERS 6. noch etwas anderes. der heilige geist ist vater GOTT abba . DER VON seinem Geist ausgiesst und weht wo Er will. MONOTHEISMUS. und. der Sohn Gottes Messias ist nicht Gott aber der abglanz von IHM.

[@tgiese209]

Is there another video on this topic of the "knowing". I have Christians around me practicing that and encouraging me to. And I'm trying to learn more about why it's unbiblical.

[@RhemaMinistriesMumbai]

There is a reason why we need the spiritual experience but it must be anchored in the scriptures.. oh how lovely a balanced Christian life is !!

[@toddwinters7066]

As I understand it now, part of the confusion is people (denominations) tend to treat people as one dimensional. They either focus on the intellect or emotional or spiritual and ignore the whole of scripture that guides and teaches in all of these areas, “ Love the Lord your God with all your heart, soul and strength”. God wants all of us

[@EmilyAndersonHQ]

Genuine question, so is there not an experience to having a relationship with Jesus? Have been raised to be in God’s Word daily, but have also experienced His Word to be true & having a personal relationship with Jesus.

[@NewCreationInChrist896]

1 Peter 3:15 “But in your hearts sanctify Christ as Lord. Always be prepared to give a defense to everyone who asks you the reason for the hope that is in you. But respond with gentleness and respect” John 15 8 “This is to My Father’s glory, that you bear much fruit, proving yourselves to be My disciples”

[@nancyyoung9799]

I am as watching Macgyver while watching this. Both r good.

[@lindajohnson4204]

Jesus Himself talked about hearing His "voice", and you can't eradicate that, or change it in any way. Why would we have to? We need to differentiate between the "hearing" He is talking about and the false experiences they are talking about. See, God the Holy Spirit leading, guiding etc: those are experiences of God, too. So to damn experience as the problem won't do, since those experiences of God are profound and we are not to condemn them or belittle them. It is just difficult to talk about the real vs the false, since the devil specializes in counterfeiting the true with very different, ungodly things, which sometimes sound very similar, in spite of the fact that they are experiences of God, on the one hand, and demons, on the other. So why are we not upholding the true experiences of God: the ones the Bible teaches? Besides treating real experiences of the Holy Spirit, as if they were unclean, the failure to differentiate the two, and uphold the true, throws people into a situation in which there is nothing left but human reasoning to interpret the Bible. That is relying on the flesh, since neither logic nor the reasoning done through it are spirit: they are nothing but flesh. Arguments that the Bible is too simple to misunderstand, are, first of all, untrue, but either way, they do not change the fact that relying on logic and reasoning are relying on an arm of flesh. We are told not to lean on our own understanding, much less to deify it, although there are some people on the scene of the comments boards, etc, who try to say that logic is our only experience of God, or that John 1 is trying to say that both the written and the living Word of God is the same as the Greek idea of _logos._ What John was saying is almost the opposite, that Jesus Christ is the true _logos_ which everything was created by, in contrast to the concept in Greek philosophy. Whether we fall for heretical ideas like those, or not, the Bible teaches a supernaturally _real_ new birth, with a real indwelling of the real Holy Spirit. If the word of God is truly the sword of the Spirit, it is not one that He has hung on his wall as a memento, but one He actively uses, to guide us, discipline and comfort us. That's the true teaching of the Bible.

[@jasonbryan9056]

Hello

[@thewholemessprinciple]

Thank you for this great comment. "The Bible teaches a supernaturally real new birth, with a real indwelling of the real Holy Spirit". 💚

[@jimboswell4818]

Interesting topic. Part of the problem comes when a person seeks the gifts just for the experience rather than seeking the Lord ( giver of the gifts) and his purposes. If a person is seeking Jesus with all thier might they will find him. Not only will they find him but they will also uncover the Lords purpose in thier life. The bible is an amazing book as it reveals to us the Characterof God and his purposes for our lives. It is also an intimate way to get to know him if we read it with prayer. Hearing God, seeing visions, having dreams, seeing God in all the circumstances and experiences we see etc is a good way to get to know him too if it all lines up with principles and standards set out in scripture.

[@AndreaVirago]

I was in the charismatic scene for ca a year or so? I was still pretty new to the faith and in my baby stage of being a christian. But day after day i felt more suspicious about it all. It was more about feeling, emotions and experiences. Worship was all about crying and breaking down and ONLY focusing on love and acceptance but not the wrath and justice of God WHICH ARE IMPORTANT. It was more like i like to call it "flower power christianity". I am so glad God woke me up and i was able to step one step after the other back out if this scene.

[@Maranatha7557]

As a Charismatic, and definitely not a hyper Charismatic, i agree 💯 percent that all things must pass the Bible test. I am very concerned about what I’m seeing in the NAR. I know people whom I love that have been blinded by this movement. It’s very hard to fellowship because they now think I am deceived, since I reject what i believe to be the false prophets and teachers.

[@prodigalAli]

2:10 "He gave us a box and here's the information about God" How would you balance that with John 5:39?

[@cherileerogers1650]

The box they are talking about is the entire Bible. You cannot add or take away from it.

[@davidmiller2064]

Well said! Way to pinpoint the type of thinking and the words used in what they believe. Scripture needs to be the filter by which we pour all truth-claims through. It is the glasses by which we view all of life. It's sad that scripture has to "compete" with people's experiences.

[@MJS2376]

Lots of discussion of scripture on these channels. Much appreciated....trying to figure out who collated the scriptures and why did some groups throw out books of the Bible?

[@baruchevenezra7279]

I would love to debate you on this topic. My argument is God foretold that prophesy would continue. Also, one living in temple times heard prophecy then what motivation would they have to study Torah or heard it in the public reading? That argument just doesn’t work. Also Saul and other spoke in tongues, seen vision and so did others in the churches and they studied the Bible.

[@mcgheebentle1958]

Can you point me to the exact verse(s) where God foretells the prophecy will continue? Also, it’s worth noting that during “temple times,” most people weren’t literate and couldn’t read at all, so your point about that doesn’t make too much sense. It’s also important to note that on that point, every single prophecy in the Old Testament was about Jesus.

[@Deedee0007]

I agree with what you ladies are saying... I remember going to a Charismatic Church bordering Hyper in my very young years. The message was more leaning towards "demonstrating gifts of the Spirit = better communion with God". Experiencing the Holy Spirit via speaking in tongues or prophesy was the focus during worship and prayer, and if you did not experience Him like this, there was sin. It formed a type of legalism in the church. I was hesitant to call other more conservative Christians my brothers or sisters in Christ because they didn't see the Holy Spirit in this manner. I say bordering Hyper because they didn't go into "there has to be miracles at each service" or the sort. Actually, I think a better explanation of their doctrine was that although they believed and taught the Holy Spirit is God, alongside the Father and Son, but they treated Him like an experience. In God's mercy though, the legalism was too much for my parents and we left. As I grew older, and coming back to the Lord after a long time away, I realized what the scripture says about the work of Holy Spirit in our lives, that my more conservative Christians are indeed my brother's and sisters in Christ, and my experience with the Lord is not always in prophecy, dreams or a feeling. I do believe the gifts of the Holy Spirit continue today, that the Lord can still speak to you , but in a very different manner. God's will is known to me via His Word vs. a prophecy, and if I do receive one, I take it back to scripture and ask the Lord for wisdom as the Bible tells me to do. They meant well in that church though, in the sense that their goal was the Holiness of God and not just signs and wonder (it was quite a humble church actually, so these signs and wonders weren't exploited for profit), but how they defined how that Holiness was demonstrated was a little misguided. God bless you ladies.

[@thegreatkate3336]

“They treated Him like an experience” That’s exactly how I feel about it too it’s heartbreaking to me 😔

[@brittmatthews7323]

Thank you!! Thank you for the content!! ♥️

[@troyjhinkle]

I am Charismatic myself, but I was taught to weigh every spiritual gift on the authority of scripture and if what is being said or revealed doesn't line up, it isn't from God.

[@savedYESHUAalone]

Great combination, you two.I was backslidden from God, 14 years, I had a SUPERNATURAL encounter with God, I was by myself, and he alone removed unclean spirits from my body, I saw them in the spirit leaving me, I was weeping ,and then he prophesied to me, without words, but with with a supernatural sensation in my arms and RIGHT leg, regarding me playing drums and percussion in warfare worship, I was playing secular music in NYC,New York, full of pagan living.🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻 I have been used by him to play worship music ever since, All Glory be to HIM FOR EVER AND EVER. AMEN PS, I was a drug addict for 5 years during the Vietnam war and also practiced yoga, eastern religion and meditation .Christians today are very un/mis informed about biblical truth.😔😔😔 this will play oyt to the great falling away that is coming, sadly 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻

[@Valdal98]

It is great that God redeemed you so wonderfully. And yes, it is sad that so many are being deceived because they , like Adam and Eve, want to be like God, not servants who are yielded to Him.

[@hommerecorder7003]

@@Valdal98 hier noch eine anmerkung.... was hat man mit Jesus Christus gemacht ?. anstelle Gottes Sohn 1. Korinther 8. vers 6. .macht man Du bist auch Gott. merken sie den trinitarischen trick. der selbe geist wie bei ihrer anmerkung adam eva.

[@Valdal98]

@@hommerecorder7003 I do not understand Deutch

[@oldschoolpreacher5785]

Jesus said we would here His voice. Certainly the devil can speak and our own soul can speak. The Bible does not give us personal instructions on our life decisions. God talks to me about me so I can follow His plan for my life, and on occasion He gives me words for others. I find it difficult to believe that a person can be born again and living for Jesus and not know His voice.

[@sierraarmour]

I’d say the only way to hear his voice is through His Word. How else would you know if it’s Satan deceiving you or if it’s the Holy Spirit, if it doesn’t align with the Bible?

[@oldschoolpreacher5785]

@@sierraarmour well if it doesn’t line up with the word of God then it’s not God. Like I said the Bible doesn’t give us personal instruction on many things, for me God mostly downloads information into my spirit and it comes with a peace that helps me understand where it’s from but often times if I’m not sure it was God I ask Him for confirmation. The enemy can also speak but he can not duplicate the peace of God although he try’s it’s not the same

[@codyvandal2860]

I understand what you're referring to. But that passage certainly does not mean a literal audible voice. It's an illustration of salvation. If you're saved, filled with the Holy Spirit, enduring, sharing the gospel, in the Word everyday and loving God with all your heart mind and strength then when it comes to personal decisions... do whatever you want. If you're truly in the faith God will plant His desires in you and you can use your own God given agencies to choose. You dont need to read tea leaves or look for a dot on a map so to speak. Just a friendly point

[@oldschoolpreacher5785]

@@codyvandal2860 I think it means exactly what it says. I do agree with the tea leaves part of your comment.

[@catherinecooper8370]

@@codyvandal2860 he didn't say you have to hear God in an audible voice. Everyone years God differently I'm charismatic but much of charismania is false. I do not endorse or support people like Bill Johnson because he teaches many new ages and unbiblical doctrines. The Holy Spirit does speak to the children of God. And He will not contradict scripture. We do need to test things. But to say God doesn't talk outside the Bible is to say that God changes, that the Holy Spirit is not a being and grieves the heart of God. We should NOT be united in false teaching. The Bible is our litmus test. But everyone should hear Him in some way.

[@kennethassemiASTRO]

Would our presenters be here if they didn't have religious experiences? Can anyone come to have genuine faith without religious experience? People like Moses and Jonah are commended for their faith but they had extraordinary experiences. Doesn't faith require religious experience?

[@AlreadyTiredOfYou]

It's called gnosticism. It happened to me just a week ago with a friend. It's really saddening.

[@PilgrimStanding]

Hey. I came here to get a better understanding of your guys views on the difference between Charismatic and Hyper-Charismatic. Usually I come away from your videos with a deeper understanding. But this one I either missed it or didn't feel it was distinct enougn as to what in your view is the difference. Other than, both believe in the gifts of the Spirit. But one seems to be after a supernatural experience? Am I summarizing correctly or...how would you adjust that?

[@kelseyann4231]

What I got from it is that both believe in the gifts and frequently use them but the hyper-charismatic is more focused on the experience of the gifts. For example, they could have an experience that is out of Biblical bounds and they use their experience as truth, rather than comparing it to Scripture. Putting their experience above Scripture, making it seem as if they are more spiritual than another. Also making experience necessary to be saved or to have a relationship with Jesus, making others feel as if they are not on the same spiritual level as you if they don't have an "experience or encounter" everytime they worship, pray etc..... That is what my take on the subject and their response is. Hoped it helped you understand a little better.

[@PilgrimStanding]

@@kelseyann4231Thank you for taking the time to explain further your thoughts on what they are thinking.

[@jamesfoster1163]

@@kelseyann4231 It's called spiritual elitism, I became like what you are describing. My spiritual experiences and visions became so damaging to me. I imagined I was abused by a satanic occult group and only in the last year know it was false. Other Christians practicing their discernment would give words to back up this lie. Satan masquerades as an Angel of light. The only way to stay grounded is through the Bible and studying it correctly and in context. It has taken me five years to unravel from leaving the NAR. I still have triggers from so many spiritual experiences, it's like having post traumatic stress. This movement can really screw you up.

[@kelseyann4231]

@@jamesfoster1163 wow. Glory to God that you were able to be discerned Biblically and know the truth. My husband and I are currently going through this as well, learning the truth. It really does amaze me how Satan has gotten into the churches to the point where once you start to pull out Scripture to show what these people are doing is wrong they find a way to manipulate. Jesus did say, narrow is the gate and only few people find it.

[@jhssavedbygrace9460]

Right on! from one who who counts himself as a pentecostal Christian. The Word of God is our Authority. It is closed Revelation. I believe on a personal word from God yet it's always to agree with the Bible.

[@catherinecooper8370]

Me too.amen.

[@robertdouglas8895]

The Holy Spirit is the objective source of truth. It takes the Holy Spirit to interpret the Bible. Without our inner Teacher, all interpretations are subjective. John 14.26 But the Helper, the Holy Spirit, whom the Father will send in My name, He will teach you all things, and bring to your remembrance all things that I said to you.

[@toddwinters7066]

I have had a question go through my mind lately for the studious ones among us. How much knowledge does it take for the “new birth” to happen? How much knowledge did those who Jesus healed, rose from the dead have before their faith was correct faith? My point? We see in scripture God working in the lives of ignorant people (or in Paul’s case violently opposed) to shine the light of truth into their lives and change them.

[@johnlawson910]

I remember reading some where that something was deceitful above all things....what was it now....oh yeah. THE HEART! Too much emotion and experientialmotivation and too little scripture will get you in trouble. Just look through out the word...Adam and eve, Samson, David, Saul, etc. Too much emotion and not enough prayer and scripture leads to a dark path. I of course am speaking from experience too.

[@VJolie3]

Does this keep getting reposted? I keep getting excited just to realize i've watched it before. Love these videos.

[@melindamercier6811]

No, she just grabs clips from the longer interviews she’s already posted. That way if people want to share the discussion on a specific topic they can. Its also a bit of a teaser to go watch the full interview.

[@Kim-Dalton]

I'm a 3rd Generational Pentacostal. My Grandparents were saved in a tent revival in the 1940's. I'm thankful for my foundation and my heritage. I've worked in ministry for most of my adult life and spent years in Africa as an overseas missionary. I'm going to use an "American Colliquialism" for my next statement ------ "don't throw the baby out with the bath water". Are there some believers in the Pentecostal and Charismatic faith who walk on the "fringe"? Yes. Do some leaders "cross the Biblical lines"? Yes. Is God keeping a perfect and accurate record of their behaviors and their actions? Yes. God does call and anoint people like you and Melissa who prayerfully and boldly "call out" those who are apostate? Yes. I realize that your ministry is not easy and it comes with some "heaviness". That being said, I do hope that you spend some time in the future focusing on men and women of God in the "Pentecostal and Charismatic" faith who are living their lives according to Scripture and trying to honor and glorify God. Godly and humble people in the "Pentecostal and Charismatic" faith are out there but they're the ones who never get any recognition. They're the ones who don't strive to be in the spotlight. They love Jesus and they're taking up their cross EVERY SINGLE DAY and following Him. They may not have a public ministry on YT but they are among God's remnant and they are WORLDWIDE. I appreciate all of the "Apologists" that I sub to on YT. One day soon, I'd like to see a "change and a pivot" where the people of God focus more on those who are fulfilling God's purposes than those who are "apostate". God bless you...

[@lai_strength_training]

Pentacostalism is heresy. Your official statement of beliefs says that you have to speak in tongues to be saved. That's adding works to faith to ensure salvation. Salvation is be grace through faith alone. Read the entire book of Galatians.

[@Kim-Dalton]

@@lai_strength_training --- I'm not a new believer. I've been saved for over 45 years. I'm not going to give you my resume or my qualifications here on YT but I'm quite familiar with my faith and I know what the Bible says. I'm in "relationship" with the Father and you cannot intimidate or bully me. My comment is based on facts and not opinion. I pray that you will grow in your faith and learn to trust Jesus even more. God bless you.

[@LadyWeaver]

Amen to this!

[@laurasanders5015]

Kim, thank you!! I’m also a third gen. Charismatic/Pentecostal. What you said is so very true. There are so many solidly Biblical Word and Spirit Christians who experience the gifts of the Spirit AND have great reverence for God’s Word. It doesn’t have to be an either/or scenario...the Word of God and the Holy Spirit agree! I find it interesting that the Bible is full of what some would call “mystics”...people who experienced God personally. There is much in the Bible that calls us to experience God for ourselves. We should not be afraid of that as long as the Bible remains our plum-line of truth.

[@laurasanders5015]

@@lai_strength_training are you aware that there are many Pentecostal denominations? The one I was raised in, The Assemblies of God does not teach that one has to speak in tongues to be saved. I agree this is a false teaching. The group that does teach this (UPCI) has other problems as well...they are non Trinitarian , which places them outside the boundaries of Christian orthodoxy. My husband and I are part of the Vineyard movement which believes in all of the gifts of the Spirit but is more mainstream evangelical theologically. For instance, we believe and teach that one receives the Baptism of the Spirit at conversion, but that there can (and should) be on-going fillings of the Holy Spirit throughout our lives. Blessings.

[@Supsup7777]

It’s been my experience that both charismatics and hyper charismatics read their Bibles.. but yes they constantly want an experience.

[@Rubberglass]

The Desert Fathers and the Early Church were mystical. They believed in genuine union with Christ.

[@strangelove6757]

One must ask if these charismatic "manifestations" or operations are truly of God if they have no value in resisting the indulgence of the flesh.

[@kenjones8083]

Is speaking in tongues needed to have the holy spirit?

[@mattysqueezesofficial]

No it’s not needed. It’s a gift from the Holy Spirit to who he Wills. It’s not something that can be taught either. Not everybody has this gift.

[@brothermanv]

We can't make an effective, logical argument or defense for Christianity if the basis for our faith is subjective personal experience There has to be a Standard greater than us and our feelings-- something we can test our feelings against

[@Daughter_of_the_King316]

Would telling an unbeliever that you were delivered from demons with a body of believers praying over and you were vomiting bc these demons are leaving you be consider mysticism????

[@daviddavidson7266]

What’s scary is when reading the Bible is promoted but the leaders have ways to twist scripture and manipulate you when asking questions.

[@philarevolutionarywarriorp8295]

Yea. Especially on the whole divorce remarriage situation

[@lindamcauley4728]

Like Doreen Virtue?

[@surfcitydeb]

I know a few people who claim to be born again charismatic believers. They always seem to think they have some hidden message for me from God, that they are more "tuned in" because they speak in tonques and have the gift of prophesy. However, every one of them suffers from varying forms of depression and cant get out of bed for days at a time. Im wondering if this is common among charismatics?

[@laurasanders5015]

Nope, not in my circles…and I’ve been in broad swaths of charismatic/Pentecostal circles all of my life. Sounds like you’re running into folks that are somehow emotionally and mentally unstable. I wouldn’t attribute that to belief in the perpetuity of the gifts of the Spirit.

[@mottgirl13]

Weirdly I was unsubscribed from your channel? How did that happen and why?

[@dianecarr4957]

Book of Mormon add keeps popping up on all my Christian channels

[@catherinecooper8370]

It's is false. Smith taught a different Jesus. Compare D and C 130;22 to John 1:1-3 and John 1:14. They are different.

[@BunnyWatson-k1w]

What happens when there is no scriptural reference? There are many modern social problems not addressed by the Bible.

[@matasaina2011]

We need to come to Jesus by faith but , through the Holy Spirit, experience God's healing, love, liberty. We don't chase these things but we taste and see He is good.

[@lesliewilliford2179]

Yes the argument of putting God in a box and all the stubborn tolerance is just annoying. Ok its not JUST annoying its also frightening and sad. 😥

[@Kayrrra]

Experiance should be driven by scripture, experience should be have precedence in scripture.

[@jeffmcclure2603]

Yes - agreed This has been a bone of contention for Jesus followers from the beginning. But, orthodox believers have a very dubious bridge to stand on here. By Paul’s own testimony, he bases his apostolic authority (or even his own self designation as an apostle) and theology on mystical visions of a man that he never personally met. Being critical of modern charlatans is good but needs put in historical perspective

[@qmacsemployee]

Appreciate this. Again we have to read and understand scripture to know what is biblically correct per God. There is no liquid gold in the Bible or Knowing. This is dangerous territory to enter and opening doors where you shouldn’t go.

[@vanessatamplin7659]

God does show his self to us I believe GOD IS doing miracles today in the Old Testament he did many miracles then and he is the same God today I love your channel I really love watching all that you offer and that you share with the body of Christ thank you so much

[@jasonbryan9056]

Hello how are you doing 😊😊

[@thechastainadventures8210]

Is slain in the spirit in the bible? My church had started doing this and I have no idea whats going on. I can't find it biblically. I also am starting to feel like I'm not doing something right or not good enough because I dont have these experiences. On the other hand I know this isn't right. I just need biblically proof. Thank you!

[@Maranatha7557]

I’m Charismatic (not hyper Charismatic or NAR), and I cannot find being slain in the Spirit in Scripture when people specifically received prayer for healing. Of course, we weren’t there, but it’s not recorded. The closest thing i see is when the soldiers came to arrest Jesus in the garden of Gethsemane, and they fell backwards. But they were not believers, nor were they being prayed for. They did, however, fall under the power of Christ’s presence.

[@simplydee4522]

And we wonder why people are turned off by Christians and some Christians struggles. Keep your eyes on Jesus and get into the word for yourself.

[@paulowens8972]

The "music worship" experience is King!

[@lonnieclemens8028]

Mysticism in the Charismatic movement is placing experience above the facts of God's word.

[@billybrown1979]

read 1 timothy 2 chapter open the eyes of truth. be bless and love of JESUS.

[@danielthomasminister]

I want an encounter myself

[@samwa3986]

Really good. This was the most heinous "movement", ever. They are not Christians

[@edvardzv5660]

Reading the books of the New Testament, we probably asked ourselves more than once: *"Why 2000 years we do not see those miracles that accompanied the Сhurch of Christ in the I century, as described in the New Testament?"* Why do the so-called preachers of Christ have to prove that Jesus really existed and atheists boldly deny the historicity or divine origin of Christ? Maybe because the Сhurch of Christ has not existed for 2000 years? The Сhurch does not exist in the form in which it is presented in the books of the New Testament, but there are Catholic, Orthodox, Protestant and other christian sects claiming to be the place of the Church, but they not have the only thing that distinguishes the divine from the human and is characteristic of just the Сhurch of Christ -the reinforcement of the word with signs, that is, miracles (Mark 16:15-20). Therefore, some researchers doubt the historicity of Christ, and some of them are not opposed to declaring him a an ordinary philosopher, teacher. But even if Jesus were an ordinary philosopher, his disciples would be ordinary followers of Jesus. And they would not dare to write about the miracles that not only Jesus, but also his disciples, could perform. In this world, the great fertility of atheism can be explained by the fact that there is no main opponent of critics of the Bible - the Church. If there were the Church in our time as described by the authors of the New Testament books, where miracles are performed, the sick are healed, where prophesied, and the dead are raised, no one would doubt the historicity of Christ. Then there would be the same controversy throughout the world as in the first century - Jesus the Son of God or the false prophet who seduces the world by miracles. As a result, we can say that the emergence and development of christian sects and atheism was the result of the fact that over the 2000 years the Сhurch of Christ did not exist. Find *"The Mystery about the Church of Christ"* video on KZbin. The video reveals the prophecy of the disappearance and reappearance of the Church of Christ before the End of the World. Watching this video will give hope to all who sincerely seek God and will interest those who are not too lazy to think freely. Click on my name to watch the video (The video is in Russian, but English subtitles are included).

[@katherinebarton2555]

Would you say Francis Chan would fall out here now as he openly talked about his seeking for years for God to bless him with the supernatural gift of healing?

[@pastorrandy]

You mean, "the gift to be a healer?" That one isn't in the book.

[@huskythegamerdog3171]

God is above understanding. He is above his attributes, the bible, and all human perceptions. Apaphatic theology has been a way to achieve union with God throughout church history. This is true in both the east and west. Scholastic teaching is important, but the mystic understanding that by unknowing and detachment, you are able to separate the ego from the soul. The ultimate goal is to die to the persona and replace it with the will of God. This is not new age. It's the way of the true contemplative.

[@ApostleOfGod8862]

Excellently put. Doctrine is critical to remaining safe and undeceived, and each and every follower of Christ should spend enough time with Jesus to be taught doctrine DIRECTLY by the Holy Spirit - the Spirit of TRUTH. 1 John 2:27, John 14:26, John 16:13-15 - THIS should be your lived experience with Jesus Christ. The Holy Spirit puts together correct doctrine, and keeps us safe with truth. If you want spiritual experiences, satan is happy to give them to anyone who decides to be part of "an evil and adulterous generation" that seeks after signs and wonders. Why adulterous? Because going anywhere other than our Lord and Saviour, Jesus Christ, is spiritual adultery. The Bible - the Word of God - is part of our armour, and necessary for offensive attack on the kingdom of darkness as well. But we can't very well deal with the darkness around us if we don't deal with the darkness IN us first, now can we? The advice that I both give and follow is this: ask the Lord to surface any areas of sin in you that have the potential to destroy you. Ask Jesus to make those areas LOUD and CLEAR. Once you know the problem, FAST and PRAY for a breakthrough in that area, while using your willpower to try to deny the sin access to your choices. Continue this until you get your breakthrough, since you do NOT want to be destroyed by your own choices. This is one of the few avenues that our enemy has to ruin our lives and destroy us. He can't get past God's power of protection, so he has to get us to open the gates for him. THIS is why you seek the Lord for what your biggest sin issue(s) is/are, and seek His face for a breakthrough against it. The days are coming where you will wish you have done this if you don't.

[@BlueBackflip]

To discount mysticism (you left out communion with the Divine as an aspect of that) is to discount the individuals who literally wrote the Bible. Something to think about. Why limit your own experience of God so much. Yes our ego can get involved and misuse this power. Same with the Bible.

[@williamfranz6639]

Did Jesus commission the Gospels? Did he mention Gospels?

[@steevrush]

FINALLY, NOW I GET IT! You're calling out the NEW-AGE as it has been embraced in the Hyper Charismaniacal NAR - isn't that convenient! - One can substitute the words new age, for what they wrongly suppose that there is some new apostolic thing happening; no there's NOT!

[@kevinbaylon7660]

Yup God gave us His box originally in the form of the Ark of the Covenant, then as the Bible!

[@godsgospelgirl]

8:24 This would be terrible advice for most people with mental health issues.

[@lindajohnson4204]

There are unbiblical experiences that people are going after, and these fit a typical definition of mysticism. But there are biblical experiences of God, which so many so-called discernment people are also defining as mysticism. Since unbiblical experiences are the standard definition of mysticism, in our gospel-believing, Bible believing Christianity, anyway, we should not bunch biblical experiences of God in the same group with unbiblical experiences which purport to be of God, but are really another spirit. That ought to be obvious, but unfortunately, many supposed discernment teachers are teaching that experiences of God the Bibleb teaches us to believe in and anticipate, are not real, denying the words of Jesus, in the very face of him speaking these things so many times. So, sadly, discernment is everyone's job, not just the work of supposed discernment ministries.

[@arajrao]

"sinking" ~~> Hinduism... "The self is within" type stuff...

[@Valhalla369]

This is exactly why i stopped going to charismatic churches and started going to Anglican and Episcopalian churches. Charismatic churches are full people claiming to have revelations about you - people are all trying to be your spiritual guides - it's a form of ego trip for them. Worse still they hold it against you and attack you saying you have disobeyed God Himself when you dont do like they want you too. Also, Charismatic churches are all focused on some superstar preacher rather than Christ and their worship are like concerts with superstar performers - the focus is on them even if they insist they are singing for Jesus. I prefer the traditional Anglican style with choir and hymns.

[@kaeljadondavis2779]

NEVER HEARD IT BETTER. "God has a box called The Bible," and everything we find within is what He's allocated to us. Leave the rest to Him.

[@Vlabar]

Many people who desire to walk in the Spirit actually operate in the soulish realm.

[@laurieschneider5278]

What do you mean by soulish realm?

[@Vlabar]

@@laurieschneider5278 We can connect with people on a soulish level. It's what many fake psychics do. Our soul being our mind, will and emotions. It's sort of like when you meet someone for the first and you feel like you've known them your whole life. A Mormon would mistake that for their spirits knowing the other spirit before time creation. In reality it's our souls making the connection. If you understand soul ties it makes sense. Many people claiming to operate in the "prophetic" aren't listening to the Spirit but the soul.

[@laurieschneider5278]

@@Vlabar Thank you for your response, I appreciate it.

[@laurasanders5015]

True. But that doesn’t mean that we shouldn’t desire to walk in the Spirit. That is actually a command in Scripture.

[@MichaelAndrews-uy1gl]

Charismatics and Hyper-Charismatics...why don't you ladies have an open dialogue with some of these people? That would really be an interesting program. Having an open and honest discussion about their beliefs would certainly show that you are earnestly desiring to help bring them out of their doctrinal errors. After all, don't we want everyone to have a clear understanding of biblical truth? Please consider what I have said. I know you care about these people and desire the best for them, right?

[@antonellamatuszewski6691]

Theology should help us interpret out experiences. Our experience should compliment our theology and give it life. The bible is full of encounters. Christianity is a relationship with the "Living God".

[@kimstoliker2111]

Don't put God in a box. I don't put God in a box I choose to relate to Him according to His parameters that He has set. Doug Stoliker

[@bradharford6052]

I didn't listen to the whole video. I stopped when it was talking about hearing God directly. Folks if you are not hearing God directly you are deaf and blind because His sheep HEAR His voice and they know Him. God is not inconsistent with the scriptures or with the manifestation we have of Him in Jesus Christ but if you think that God is not bigger than the scriptures you don't really know Him very well. I find it fascinating that various people and groups of people raise scripture to a higher level than God Himself but the funny thing is that if you ask for an exposition of a certain scripture or scriptures from 10 bible believing theologians you may very well get 10 different answers of what the bible "Clearly says". So who has the correct interpretation? I am comforted that the Father, Son and Spirit commune with me, teach and lead me and protect me.

[@LadyWeaver]

Indeed, this brings to mind what Jesus said in John 5:39: " You study the Scriptures diligently because you think that in them you have eternal life. These are the very Scriptures that testify about me"

[@claytonsmith1906]

I think Charismatic is an improper term to use to describe what is being discussed many times here and in other conversations. Being compelling (definition of being charismatic) does not associate with the specific umbilical teachings of new age or these churches that place scripture below their own beliefs. We need to address the issues rather than creating an overly broad, poorly defined, category of people. If lack ofadherance to or respect for scripture is the issue specifically call that out. Are people adding human processes/rituals to the Bible that contradict or detract from the work of Jesus and scripture, call that out and address it specifically. Is mysticism or pantheism the problem, call that out etc. Labelling these things as Charismatic is harmful and not true to English. I am aware that you are not the first to use this classification and it is somethi g that Christians have created, however I think it is something worth pushing back on. As those looking from the outside in have a much different idea of what it means to be Charismatic. They likely associate it with a ferverancy for God, emotion, and other things which are not inherently bad and inamy cases we are called to in the Bible. We are called to raise our hands and cry out to God. We are called to lift our voices to Him in Worship. Etc. This was a long rant, but I hope it makes sense. God bless!

[@clm3436]

Yes, God's language to us is the Bible. If we don't understand Him it's because we don't speak His language

[@lai_strength_training]

Incorrect & more incorrect. That's the difference. Go read "Systematic Theology" by Wayne Grudem. Also, go watch "America Gospel: Christ Alone" if you haven't already!

[@jeremymace8671]

You know Wayne Grudem is a charismatic don't you????

[@isabellagang1412]

Reformed people are so strictly doctrine doctrine doctrine but y’all are missing out on the power of the Holy Ghost. You limit Him. I see your point though, it is wrong to go to God just for power... when we go to Him we should simply just seek Him, but in that time seeking Him it would biblically make sense that the Holy Spirit can move powerfully through us. Our eyes need to be spiritually opened, the word of God is nothing without spiritual revelation.