ALL ABOUT LIVING WITH THE BELGIAN MALINOIS

[@DogumentaryTV]

FYI: RUDE AND DISRESPECTFUL COMMENTS ARE DELETED.

[@evaho5098]

Dogumentary TV I agree I have a malinios and on ur last Belgian malinios video someone was making fun of it so I hope u will make them delete bad comment

[@number1662]

Dogumentary TV This is a great video it exhibits a owner that didn't quite get what she expected but yet still working hard with the dog and it may also stop some one from getting this particular breed if not well suited for it.

[@fadzilicious4411]

I don't believe in internet censorship therefore i challenge my Rhodesian Ridgeback in a fight till death with your Belgian poodle boi. (don't take this seriously ahaha)

[@dr3wbyyy]

As it should

[@Serenityssillyvids]

I like this channel I hate rude comments my friends mom had a Belgian molinio but something happened to him know she has a German shepherd 😁

[@annenna2354]

I applaud this owner for recognizing her mistakes and speaking publicly about them in order to educate others. A really great video for any potential (or current) dog owner regardless of the breed.

[@missylarsson3517]

Her mistake was to get one of the most high maintenance breeds out there and not being prepared for it. She would’ve been just fine if she had gotten another dog as she had experience with other dog breeds. The education here is to read up on the breed and be honest with yourself if it is suitable for you and the things you want to do. Do not glorify the life you can provide for the dog.

[@missylarsson3517]

TheBatKing I think all people tend to bring out their positive sides when they speak to breeders. She even said the breeder was hesitant to sell to her even though she claimed to have an active lifestyle simply because she would not work the dog. It is entirely possible she exaggerated her description to get the dog as well, I think most do. Just saying if she did read about the breed she would’ve quickly realized their overall temperament. Either she ignored it or under estimated it.

[@ianblackburn5025]

No...she's had no experience at all with any dog.....these are high powered dogs...own a male shepherd first i reccomend....then step up.....expect shepherd x 10....

[@weedhigh2564]

She made no mistake, she got the exact dog she was ment to get. Sure she did not expect what she was getting, my family always had high powered dogs before so i was thinking oh a Labbie/rott/pitt mix with Istrian hound, i know those dogs, believe me when mine was growing, the only one trait she really had that was neat was she had a few couchhugger days. Like 1 every month. Other than that, she was always active, even when sleeping the darn dog kept moving her paws like she was running... We had 3 dogs, 2 cats, 8 humans in the house, all of us combined were not enough to tire her most of days, she had so much energy it was unbelievable. As she grew tho i learned to manage her energy, shr got way bigger so tires a bit faster, and now that she is 6 yo she is pretty much managing her energy on her own, she has sort of a schedule made, so i know when she is up for playing and can plan accordingly. She has her hours of the day when she wont stop but others when she would lie in the shade and not give a single bip about anything. She is pretty good at sticking to that routine because its how she likes it. One big thing all owners need to learn at some point its when to leave the dog be a dog and trust that he/she will make the right decision. And no you cant do that first, first they need to understand choices and consequences and that there is not ever just a single choice they can make. That way you can guide them to understand how to react in different situations with ease and have a dog happy with neat manners when you need it to but keep that animal side and instinct for when the circumstances allow.

[@jonathangilmore3193]

I agree. The biggest problem I saw over 15 years of GSD Schutzhund training was understanding that my high drive working dogs needed a clear hierarchy in order to be adequately trained. A clear “fang and claw” hierarchy based on their temperaments, not some anthropomorphized belief in human friendships! You have to be able to convince strong dogs that you are their leader, and that disruption of that hierarchical order will not be tolerated. Friendship emanates from that understanding, regularly enforced if necessary! In time, training that allows these highly driven animals to live their drives leads to friendship through the work! That is why secure obedience, obedience in the face of distraction, precedes bite work! If one wants canine friendship, and who doesn’t, one needs to understand their animal, not to anthropomorphize their animal. Strong dogs need strong adults to thrive!

[@rupninja4358]

I always see so many people say "only experienced Malionis owners should have a Malinouis" How is anyone ever supposed to become a Malionis owner?

[@QQ-dy6dq]

Rup Ninja exactly like you have to have had one before to become experienced Belgian malinois owners

[@annabellehe4307]

A slightly easier breed

[@QQ-dy6dq]

annabelle he no no nooooooooo nooooooo this breed is not like any other dog breed it’s special.

[@thomasathey5265]

rescuing a few training them and re homing them to someone who is committed and ready,

[@Sherlock_The_Corgi]

Cuz mali can imprint a very dangerous behaviour from unexp owners. Atleast admit that with buying mali u must have a training.

[@noeatSLT]

I have a male . He was left on the side of the road. IDK why. He is good boy. I lost my dog as well , and then this guy shows up out of nowhwere. Blessed

[@primalcritters]

Same, solid black at 9 weeks abandoned

[@simphiwevuso6580]

@@primalcritters I can relate ,I lost 8 puppies through Parvo virus,I was so so so heartbroken,a friend of mine brought me a stray dog ,only to find out it was a belgian malinois about two months old.I love my Bruno andd takink a very good care of him,pity we dont have a missing pet beauraux ,otherwise I would have sent it there so that the owner could have his dog back.I just love my Bruno big time.

[@ariw9405]

I appreciate her honesty and candidness about the struggles. Majority of videos about this breed show a military style perfect dog. She is very patient and goes above and beyond to build a relationship with her dog.

[@missylarsson3517]

Well they are “military style” dogs. They are meant to perform work. Those dogs you mentioned are probably working multiple hours a day. Malinois are generally not suitable as simple house pets unless you have the ambition to also work with it every day with activities like nose work, agility etc. Don’t expect to leave for a 9-5 job everyday that doesn’t involve your dog if you get this dog.

[@grandadoboman1995]

@@missylarsson3517last I checked, this dog was developed by civilians aka farmers, for civilian use aka farming. The breed's characteristics only coincidentally made them suitable for military and law enforcement use. Also, a lot of people who have this breed have normal 9-5 jobs and they're doing fine.

[@missylarsson3517]

GrandAdoboMan Yeah farm work is work so I don’t understand your point. Herding dogs in general are bred to work multiple hours a day. There are lines specifically bred to do things like police and military work, but those breeders are serious and would seldom sell to pet owners. The woman in this vid even said the breeders were hesitant to sell to her because she did not plan to use the dog for work and she seems like a very engaged pet owner. I am not saying you need to do herding or military work with a mal but some kind of activity that goes beyond to have it only as company, walk around the block and to leave a dog alone 9-5. People doing that probably crate the dogs because they would tear down the house otherwise from boredom, and it is cruel imo and no serious mal breeder would sell to a person like that. Only backyard breeders who don’t care of the qualities of the breed or for what the dog needs. You can do it but it is very unfair to the dog.

[@neptunesjester4145]

That's what you're suposed to do..

[@neptunesjester4145]

@@missylarsson3517 again, how do you know? You got a mastiff. Not a mal. Both Mals I've had made wonderful dogs for the house. I think you read too much into opinions of others. I know Mals, been around them my life. Any dog will be what you want it to be regardless of the breed if you know how to communicate with it. My current mal has military grade training. She also loves to sit on me and watch tv and cuddle with the house cats. I bet you could tell us about mastiffs right? But if you haven't owned a mal, all you are doing is regurgitating opinions that you've read online

[@nicolawilliams7461]

I am a first time dog owner and chose a Belgian Malinois as my first dog. I had no experience with dogs at all. Lol people called me crazy. My dog and I works and plays hard. My dog is an indoor dog, but know that we only play outdoors. He is an awesome dog and I am happy to have him!

[@zebrapleco7895]

It was horribly irresponsible to pick a BM as your first dog. Hopefully the dog continues to be awesome as an adult

[@pimpdaddyg2081]

@@zebrapleco7895 i love comments like this from people like you who have never owned the breed, and think they know everything because they watched KZbin videos about it. We have a BM girl and she is a perfect angle. It’s all about training, yes the dog has more energy and can be more aggressive then other breeds but with attention, training, and exercise they can still be trained. Love all these armchair dog experts on ever malinois video i see warning people to never get one, when they don’t have the slightest clue what they are talking about and just regurgitate what they saw in a KZbin video.

[@zebrapleco7895]

@@pimpdaddyg2081 I spend 2-3 hours everyday with a BM, you don't know me bro.

[@o_o488]

@@zebrapleco7895 oh damn 2 hours thats crazy wow

[@Animal-Reaction-Clips]

How u suppose to get experiments without first getting the dog lol

[@jasminfesti4755]

why is everyone saying she is the wrong owner for this dog? She is doing everything she can to give this dog the exercise both mental and physical this breed truly needs. Ofc it's not easy owning a Malinois but why mock a woman who clearly is working very hard to be a good owner for such a hard and demanding working breed!? The dog looks happy to me.

[@LM-qs9iw]

Jasmin Festi well that is true bit it is norte about the owner is about the dog, and sometimes giving everything you have is not enough....

[@TBI-Firefighter-451]

As a Service Dog Trainer and Advocate I'd say she is a Perfect Human for a Malinois to Own!

[@privateprivate5302]

that dog loves her she loves that dog. having worked in an animal shelter, a dog HANDS DOWN would rather be WITH their owner than without them no matter the breed, doubly so for this belgian malinois. You are right, people need to back off. She is a dedicated pet mom and a great pack leader

[@tomloudermilk4701]

Jasmin Festi n

[@barbaravance6774]

@@TBI-Firefighter-451 I agree that she is now the perfect owner for her. But, she was inexperienced with this type of dog. And she's lucky that her dog attacking her hands wasn't worse. I don't think these dogs are good for just your average owner. She says she had just started working with her trainer when this happened. And she said the dog was 8 months old. I'm sorry but, she should have had a trainer much earlier! Especially a dog from working dog lines. I know I trained my last GSD for SAR work. And he wasn't nearly as active as a Mal.

[@SweetLolitaStocking]

It's good to hear her struggles. All dogs are not perfect and so are owners.

[@tweetiebird]

She is not documenting her struggles, she is telling you about her journey with a BM and how it developed into the best bonding and loving relationship. You just don't get it! Glad you don't critique restaurants or review movies!!!!

[@bestmoney816]

All dogs have a purpose unlike humans. The owners are the problem never the dog.

[@flop8985]

Dee innit

[@missylarsson3517]

If you get a malinois as a pet I would say this is what you can expect. This is not a bad dog, but it is a high maintenance dog. People need to start reading up on the breed they are getting and stop lying to themselves and breeders about their lifestyles and ambitions. The best thing is to get a dog that suits your lifestyle, second best (that this lady is doing) is to turn your life around and try to accommodate to the dogs needs. Far too many dog owners do not do either of these things and just rehome or have their dog out of control and miserable just waiting for an accident to happen.

[@V1z10n]

@@bestmoney816 Laffs in Pug.

[@HeliosphanXtal]

We are having a Malinois for years now and we trained her that play/excitement is outside and calmness/no play is inside. She knows it very well and even leaves her toy outside the door when she enters the house. Fantastic breed!

[@RampartPh]

my belgian malinois was a challenge at first. but once she reaced 2 years old, she really slowed down. she's learned to control herself although she's got an obsession to walk on the right side of the street. i'm actually bewildered by that.

[@Woodroffski]

That's a responsible dog owner. She can see past her own emotions for the benefit of her and her dog, and their relationship with each other.

[@dustinsmith4068]

She is a thoughtful, responsible dog owner. Being candid regarding her mistakes is super helpful to other dog owners like myself.

[@hannahlanai]

I commend Michelle. She's doing everything she can to make sure her dog has all the exercise and fulfillment she needs. It sounds like a full time job.

[@missylarsson3517]

Hannah Belgian Malinois are full time jobs, that is what they are bred for, to work full time all day without getting tired. You should not get one (especially from working lines) if you are not prepared to spend as many hours as a full time job on it.

[@zebrapleco7895]

@@missylarsson3517 exactly. These dogs are not pets and it’s mental to expect the dog behave like a pet.

[@bikerbud3903]

They are a sun up to sun down dog. Our "Athena" just passed away. The Malinois is a special breed and are a big part of their human's lives. When they are gone, you realize how much of your life revolves around them. Every moment with them is a joy. They will lift your mood no matter how down you are. You don't realize the joy they bring to your life till they are gone. RIP Atena. We miss you!!

[@paulcraven4562]

So true.

[@blacklavoux]

Sun up to sun down sounds exausting 😂 i respect this breed, but not for my introverted quite ass 😂

[@sandeetee8009]

I’m so sorry for you loss. My “Roxy (German shepherd)passed away & we were gifted our “Athena” shes filling our void and she’s so loved already.

[@corone2018]

Sorry for your loss it’s extremely hard 😢

[@georgekim933]

Condolences. I have a female Mali- I miss all my canines- Giant Schnauzer, long hair chihuahua, black lab, German Shepard and a number of mixed breeds. Haven’t met a bad dog, just bad owners!

[@Grassroots_Hegemon]

It's good to see literally no one in the comment section has ever made a mistake with their dog or disciplined/ rewarded them poorly! What good news! That's amazing. And it's also amazing that everyone here , much like the person who sold her the dog, knowing her situation and being comfortable with it, are all Belgian malinois breeders! What good fortune, she probably could have consulted anyone in the comments section and bought one of their fine bred working dogs. I bet if it were your dog it would never bite and would always listen straight out of the birth canal until the day it died and you would never get annoyed or say an unkind word to it! Woohoo!

[@chillinator]

Every Malinois I've ever had bit me at least once. Most of them ONLY once. Consider it the Malinois version of the "shit test"

[@loriw2661]

Calvin Luchs I was going to comment but you said it soooo perfectly!!

[@KP-gq2lw]

Are you on meds ?

[@missylarsson3517]

No but honestly just reading up about the breed you are getting would make you realize what you are getting into. I fell for the mals agility, beauty and trainability but after reading a couple of pages about them I quickly realized it was not suitable to my lifestyle as they are a whole other level than most dogs, even most active breeds. I got an amstaff instead and it was definitely the correct choice. One day if I don’t have to work full time I may consider a malinois.

[@muffycrosswire2757]

@Calvin Luchs- well said

[@MolonLabe-1776]

Wish every owner is like her who is humble, patient, willing to learn to work with your dog, and even better to own up to your mistakes. Such a wonderful and responsible owner.

[@johnskulavik7116]

My son and I got a male that's now 11 months. We had the same problem with NASH. He doesn't like to be told no. Plus he thinks everything belongs to him. He loves people which is a big plus. We go walking in the morning and he goes with my son when he gets home from work in the afternoon. We now realize that affection, consistency and patience is the human side of a good relationship. Long periods of being alone will cause destructive behavior. But since he's never alone, because I'm older and retired, he has adjusted to our family very well. He plays jumping high into the air to catch his toys. Sometimes I play that way with him for two hours at a time. He has energy beyond belief. Interestingly he treats me the older family member with much care and seems to understand I can't do the things my son does. He's very intelligent. I call him "Einstein Malinois" graduate of MIT (Malinois Institute of Technology). We got him a treadmill which is beginning to show promise. We'd never give him up! I'll upload a picture of him soon. He's really a handsome fellow.

[@cynharmon3751]

We rescued our Malinois from the shelter.. they told us he was a shepherd black lab mix.. in retrospect I'm pretty sure they knew what he was but he was not an easy dog for them and so when we showed an interest they gave him to us- literally- no adoption fees. lol My daughter who was almost 15 at the time had recently lost her cat, who was very special to her, and needed another animal, but as this was the second cat she had lost to diseases from being outside (we now don't do outside cats for this reason) she wanted to get a dog.. we only went to look, you know how that goes.. lol anyways, Max was about 4 1/2 months, he looked like a dingo with a black face, now he is one of the most gorgeous dogs I've ever seen-everyone tells us that too, not just me :) he is classic Mal. I did some research and realized pretty quickly what he was and knew we were in for a ride and boy yes. However, we have been told by multiple people who know Mals that he is the chillest Mal they've met and he is just now maybe 2. We have always had dogs, generally big ones, he is big for a Mal- right now he's around 105 lbs (not fat lol) and tall. He is a huge lover, and my daughter is his person. He is her Emotional Support Dog, she has a lot of anxiety and he helps a lot with that. Also, tending to him keeps her on her toes. She trains him, exercises him and is alpha. she only weighs about 10-15 lbs more, but will alpha roll him and bite his muzzle to discipline him when necessary. Generally that's only when her gets too protective of her, he used to bark etc at me when I entered her room. He loves me, but she is his special person. He has anxiety too, but is super smart, so learns fast what we don't want him to do- like chew or bark (we live in a small apartment- he used to have a yard- but is an escape artist because of his athleticism/intelligence) so the walks she takes him on are safer than him being left outside for exercise. She is now on Independent Study (anxiety) and this is best for all involved. Now he has someone with him all the time. also, our neighborhood isn't the best, but I do not have to worry about her safety at all, as he is very protective and scary looking lol. he seems to know if someone has bad intentions, he is super friendly to some and to others he immediately reacts. Sorry this is so long, but he is an amazing dog, certainly not for everyone!! but I feel he changed our lives for the better, and gave my daughter a focus away from herself, and a best friend who is always there ready to love her.

[@georgekim933]

You did a great job with your dog as well as your daughter. Best regards in the future.

[@Cossa3344]

Read the whole thing and I loved this picking mine up next month

[@joysachs9032]

Lovely story . Wishing you all well.

[@chrisnorton3746]

A Malinios has always been my dream dog. As an experienced GSD owner, these dogs are the next level.

[@dude3277]

This has been one of the most informative interviews I’ve seen on this breed.

[@skull6105]

This woman is the perfect example of a “pet home” malinois owner. Too many people think malinois need to be worked in specific sports etc. Anyone that has the patience and dedication to owning this breed can do so. Not every pup in a working dog litter is suitable for the work, we need more people like this woman to take on the pups that don’t quite have the drives for sport.

[@georgekim933]

I don’t see how anyone unless it’s their livelihood would not live with these beautiful dogs. I don’t necessarily think that’s cruel it’s just that this presentation made it very clear that you have to have an emotional bond with your animal. The Malinois is particularly sensitive, and brutally athletic. A true warrior dog. They’ll do anything for their pack and you if you’ve earned it! After her dinner she really likes to play and be petted and I noticed her digestion would kick in and she belches like burping a baby. Her outside speed goes down to idle + to 5000 rpm inside (outside they’re Ferraris and they can spin well over 10k rpm sustained for miles) and she really likes those silly squeaky toys where outside she’d destroy them in seconds, as she can gnaw the leather cowhide off of a base ball in minutes. She dances with the toy flipping it in the air. She bites so fast she can make the squeaky toy seemingly talking. Of course, I know the brutality’s of her jaws- she’s 3 1/2 and 52 pounds, of sinew. I no longer can no longer play tug of war with a extra large black Kong with a nylon woven 1/2” rope (any other rope shed cut in half if I don’t hide it from her). Maybe hold on while riling her up with my voice and trying with both arms to rip the Giant Kong out her mouth. Don’t underestimate the size of those jaws- my little female can mouth a basketball and then puncture it!.. Take good care and don’t forget you’re the driver, the coach and don’t let these working dogs crash because they will! High drive, high athleticism, and high pain tolerance, mine makes me look like a professional trainer;)

[@nehemiasg.a6573]

Every dog need to have their needs covered… she just adjusted this breed to her routine which I find this very selfish.

[@runstreet]

I appreciate her honesty and love videos like this that show regular people living with their dog breed. I’m a very active runner but this video made me realize I’m not active enough for a Malinois. She has so much patience and dedication, very admirable.

[@MK-he1jz]

Wow. Love her honesty and her sense of responsibility!!

[@1ifbyland2ifbysea]

Just cause shes not raising a attack dog doesnt mean she is doing anything wrong, she is training this dog very well for a new malinois owner. Pretty sure having her dog in the home is a lot better then having her in some kennel all night like most military branches. I think they are a good couple and as long as she can handle the alpha role then she will do well as a owner. It's a working dog and if you train her as a family dog and companion she will excel at that job. As long as she gets enough exercise she attention, pretty similar to a border collie. The malinois will protect her home tho. I have both, the malinois protects my collie from heathen stray dogs and they are great companions together with similar energy levels. I say your doing great thank you for video. Its all how you raise your dog and being the pack leader. Alphas come in all shapes and sizes. Dogs are mans best friends.

[@colinkeaney559]

Jared Beverlin military dogs are work dogs they’re not family dogs they’re treated the way they are to keep them in a working line not a play dog

[@thomasathey5265]

they're working dogs, this is a pet dog she has, she should be doing a sport with it atleast, military dogs get high intesity work

[@drainmonkeys385]

Jared Beverlin .... she seems to be doing it good...

[@snes-g2f]

People have a pre-conceived idea of what a breed of dog needs to be like as long as they are happy that’s all that matters. People don’t realize this but most dogs in the military are not used to sniff out bombs because statistically there wrong 80% of the time but they use them to enter a room first INCASE there’s a bomb it kills the dog not the people.

[@SeraphSeph]

@@colinkeaney559 ah so you're saying its ok to treat a dog like trash as long as its their job. Then you get salty if someone adopts it and is trying to treat it well. Outstanding move.

[@lauriebriscoe6983]

I wanted to comment on this documentary, particularly about the lovely woman describing her experiences with her dog Very honest to a fault , .truly enjoyed the informative conversation. Such a good ambassador for the breed both the dog and this owner. Thank you so much Well done 😊

[@chironapolonio]

I've had my one-year-old Belgian Malinois (Kevin) for two months now. They are indeed a challenge, but so worth the effort. Absolutely adorable and affectionate, sweet, vulnerable and excellent guard dogs for the home.

[@Crxql]

chironapolonio my mal is named John. I feel like most mals have human names lol

[@morganv.6128]

Our Mal was Kevin, too. 🙂

[@lorrainelaskosky7785]

This video has me exhausted just hearing how active this breed is

[@mnm291]

I have one and he's like my other dogs. If you are active they will match your energy. My husband is 75 and our pet malinois likes car rides, very mellow.

[@wisdomseeker3362]

I feel she's doing great with this special breed. It's a learning experience and she's very honest and so willing to learn best handling/training for her breed.

[@Ducky190]

well she experienced now.damn lay off the negative comments

[@somerandomguy670]

madariawalls19 Exactly!

[@SuperMichelleDJ]

madariawalls19 I agree, all these people saying she needs experience to own this breed forget that they were once in experienced dog owners. The only way to become experienced with any dog breed is to actually own a dog for God’s sake why do people not understand that?

[@eccross]

@@SuperMichelleDJ The internet makes people brave Michelle, especially those who don't use their own name.

[@QQ-dy6dq]

Enrico Cross I always use my name

[@tweetiebird]

@@SuperMichelleDJ You just don't get it! I recently lost both my dogs 6 months apart and was devastated. One afternoon on my way to the store, I just happened by an adoption event and was drawn in just to look because I couldn't imagine getting another dog. I walked in and my eyes were immediately drawn to this cute puppy in the back jumping up like look at me, come see me and when I did she jumped into my arms put her paws around my neck and licked me crazy and that was it I couldn't let her go. So I rescued her and at the time they said she was an Australian Herding dog mix which I had no idea what that meant so I started researching to ultimately discover she is actually a BM. I plan on doing a DNA test but even the Rescue had to agree she fits the BM breed. I am dedicated to her and a retiree so I have time to give to her and that's an important element because they do require a lot of attention. I couldn't be happier how things turned out on her breed, I knew she was special from the start. I make her a homemade cooked meaty balanced diet which I have spent a ton of time learning about dog nutrition since my last dogs had pancreatitis. BTW, turns out she has some of the best markings I have seen so far in pictures. Black mussel only, black tipped ears, golden torso with black tips, patch of white underside and paws, her tail is cool too hard to explain I call it color coordinated, just beautiful. I may not be experience either, but I'm having fun learning with her and I do know a bit about training so I'm looking forward to a wonderful journey with my Sadie!

[@Nuggett33]

I appreciate this vulnerable and truthful interview and post. Lost my 15yr old boxer mix, waited a year and I just adopted a GS pit mix, but he looks more like a BM pit mix. ... this helped me so much and I look forward to my new addition and working with him. Thank you

[@logike77]

Great share. Thank you! Belgians are indeed the most loving, focused, and intense creatures as canines. My Belgian mix far more trained me than I trained him over the years. You know that distinctive smile on Michelle's face and where it comes from. This breed is a huge responsibility, and their affection and loyalty is incredible. They need you, love you, require constant activity and stimulation. As I single guy, I thought I would never have a kid. Well, I did have a kid in this instance. My dog changed my life.

[@jw2223]

She is so calm on the couch! My guy NEVER is so calm, even after a 10 mile hike! haha, he'll sleep, but if he's around me, he is too happy to relax haha

[@AAS-gw5mb]

Jenn W same

[@mr.sunturtle9205]

Try biking him around local track field for an hour with him as fast as he can go

[@LittleDfan]

Malinois is a working dog, they need a lot of activity. Not just exercise but nose work or something where they must use their brain. Too much exercise can make them overtrained so they are in very good fit, but not able to calm down.

[@mothereric8774]

Mr. Sun Turtle, Lol

[@mothereric8774]

Honestly though biking, sledding, and skijoring are great activities for dogs like this.

[@gets187]

Got mine after her owner went to jail and ive taught her about 10 key commands . I work from home and shes adjusted to a small apartment. This breed is so smart its a matter of your patience and diligence

[@scottriley1913]

As an old man I purchased a beautiful purebred male Australian Shepherd. Holy Cow! You talk about energy. This was work for me, but the most rewarding thing I’ve ever done, they need so much exercise, but 5 years later this has been one of the greatest joys in my life.

[@triumphantape]

I can't stop giggling when I watch these dogs, they are so energetic it's infectious.

[@lilyrose7521]

I’m really grateful for this person to share their story of owning a malinois for the first time! I learnt so much from her and as I’m looking to get a malinois puppy (mainly to do protection training with and to be a friend for my social Border Collie for when I go to work) I appreciate her retelling her experiences so much so I can learn from them! ^^

[@jasper777777]

I had two border collies and one died at 16- so was thinking of getting a Malanois- good thing I watched this video- I'm sticking to border collies.

[@nalabear97]

Collies have the smartness of a Mal, same level I’d say- but Mals are devious little devils and have the energy. The reason they’re alive is basically to be with YOU.

[@Aethuviel]

@@pierrealles2792 You can't dominate a dog into not needing crazy amounts of work.

[@pomponi0]

@@pierrealles2792 Or maybe this breed isn't for everyone? Maybe not everyone is willing to put all the effort in the world to be able to coexist with a breed they already said they don't want?

[@jennyferhatala9559]

@@pierrealles2792 the dominance theory was debunked and showed that is bullshit so yea

[@jennyferhatala9559]

@@nalabear97 nop border collies are the smartest breed from all the dogs the malinois is on the 22nd in the rankings for intelligence

[@jessie5245]

Loved how she understands now that the freedom she was giving the dog in the beginning was actually doing her a counter favor 🤗

[@Deejeezy405]

I have two female Belgian Malinois. I don't do any sports or serious, hardcore training with them, but it is possible to live with this breed as long as you put in the time to get them tired. It takes a lot of work, but it can get done. I love this breed.

[@saralackey3435]

That's what dog parks are for.

[@pleiad7]

Malinois are not dog park dogs. Aside from the fact that dog parks are terrible places in general for canine "social" interactions, they do next to nothing for a high drive breed like the Belgian Malinois. They're handler-oriented dogs that need mental stimulation and human interaction through structured training and sports.

[@Deejeezy405]

pleid7 Thank you. Someone gets it.

[@hansfleer356]

No not really you just need to include them into the family group and ensure that you put the time and effort into exercising them, this does not necessarily mean sports that is just a fashionable thing for some dog owners to do.

[@cinderbearica9939]

I wouldn't recommend dog parks for anyone. Ours got Giardia from ONE dog park visit. The Giardia kept coming back and he ended up with a bad case of Sibo. I believe Malinois have sensitive systems.

[@neptunesjester4145]

Hi! I'm from Santa Barbara California. I've got a pure bred Belgian Malinois, female, 31 months. She's my 2nd. She's run, walked, socialized for 5 of the 8 hours that I work. When I get home, I change and we immediately leave for a 3 hour run and training. This is every night. She knows commands in 3 languages as well as silent commands. She's on a tight diet too. I stimulate her with tracking games, hide n seek (she's learned to hide an stsy out of my line of sight by constantly repositioning herself behind things), we work on agility training and tree climbing and walls. I reward her as I see fit, it according to how someone else does it. I've been with both German and Belgians and prefer the Belgians. My training techniques work great. I see posts from some that make me shake my head. First off, no one out there is above anyone else. Malinois can be for anyone as long as you can put in the time that they need, so don't continue to say for experienced and blah blah blah. That's just stupid. Anyone can learn. I'm 50. Not a 20 something and my mal is attached to me. She visits me at work also. One thing I will say though, if you adopt. You keep it!! Never return an animal. Take the time and learn about it. Returning them depressed them and confuses them and they are very sensitive animals. No one in our home is allowed to fight yell or scream or throw stuff. The kids are in check as is my blood pressure. The animals brought serenity to a noisy home.

[@gamestersparadise9121]

Thank you for this. I just took in a German Belgian mix as a rehome. His parents were moving out of the country and they couldn't stand the idea of taking him to a tropical island. He's so hot natured and almost all black, they were concerned he'd die of heat stroke. He's only been in our house for less than a week (and while there's tension with the other pets) it feels right. Like he's the piece that was missing. I've never had a either breed even though we had lots of big dogs growing up. I can say his need for play is a wonderful reminder that we need to take time and go outside. I already can't imagine him being here.

[@adrianos7334]

I strongly agree with you. My best friend has a Malinois and he's totally amazing. Every morning we run 10km with him. He watches out for my kitten and if she goes to far, he takes her by the neck and brings her back. They aren't only amazing and loving with humans but also with other animals, but they need to be educated, they are only happy if they can run and play a lot or if they can work. Those dogs need to feel useful, they love to learn new things.

[@MB-pd1oo]

Mine is part German shepherd and part Malinois. She is the sweetest, calmest, easy going girl and my best friend.

[@nogedoge]

" ... she wasn't as cuddly as I had hoped for. I wanted something to hold to compensate for the loss that I had." This is an important lesson that dogs are not cuddle-on-demand toys that are here to coddle your emotions. They're animals. It's a good thing this owner tried to correct her train of thought to try to give Bronte(?) a fulfilling life. I hope they're both happy nowadays.

[@rebeccasuraci7666]

My shepherds have all been cuddle bugs lol. My Jack knew belly rub and spoon. Lol

[@imtired2983]

Therapy dogs much?

[@dans3344]

Watched this video a few years ago when our family was giving serious thought to a malinois. After more than 2 years of research and what I thought was thorough education regarding the breed, we pulled the trigger a few weeks ago. WOW! So glad we educated ourselves as much as we did. We thought we were prepared, he's a handful to say the least! Absolutely brilliant, scary smart and as stubborn as anything I've ever encountered. You truly have to be prepared to continuously out think them or frustration sets in quickly. He's already brought so much joy into our home, we wouldn't change a thing!

[@becalmlivelifetothefullest6752]

My Malinois/Husky Mix is just 11 weeks old but she has given us so much joy and laughter we are committed to keep up with her training and being good pet parents.

[@eesaomar]

I have a malinnois she's 12 weeks super intelligent I love the breed and how the function enjoy your malinnois dude there a blessing from God ❤

[@timmanion7459]

I like your story so much . I'm also the owner of a female Belgian Malinois named Maze . Watching your video and looking at your dog was , in many ways like looking at mine as well . The characteristics of this amazing breed are so unmistakable if you know them . My dogs craze is the tennis ball . She likes frizzbies too , but not like the tennis ball . We wake up at 0430 and take a 3 mile run to start the day . I'm retired military, so I have a lot of time to spend with her . She works about an hour a day and then it's all play and exercise, which she gets plenty of . We live in the country on 14 acres, so she has plenty of room to run . I do know what you mean about watching your dog because of coyotes and other animals. They're definitely different from other breeds and do need a lot of quality time spent with them . She's such an awesome dog but can be a bit over protective of me . That's just how she is . She came from Europe from working lines so has that bred into her . Anyway, great story of your Mal.

[@georgekim933]

Sounds like our dogs are the same as well as our background. You made many good points about the dog. I was worried about coyotes as I live close to BLM lands, and after my girl’s 3 menses I figured if she were to get lost (don’t see how as she literally glued to my hip;)) that she’d run a pack of coyotes and I’d see black masked, red fawn coy dogs in the hills!

[@thiagobechelane]

11:46 "I don't have my family members live outside, so I'm not gonna her live outside" - True dog person =)

[@eggthedog]

just because someones dog is kenneled outside does not mean the handler is not a TrUe DoG oWnEr

[@azurecurry4757]

You can say im taking the comment to far but I have a BM that lives outside so I took this comment to heart. Dogs may be house pets but you have to remember they are apart of the wolf family they are wild animals and are meant to be outside.

[@Sandy33569]

Having a dog living outside doesn’t mean someone isn’t a “true dog person”. Ever heard of livestock guardian dogs? Many many people have them to actually perform their job, but they are still a big part of their owners’ lives and love them just the same. The dog just helps them out by protecting their livestock (and the dogs LOVE it).

[@Reggaeshark.]

@@azurecurry4757 agreed. I always say dogs are meant to serve us so if they’re outside as guard dogs then why not. As long as they’ve got everything they need. I’ve a male GS and a female BM. Both stay outside especially at night. They’ve gotta earn their keep and guard outside 😂 During the day I’ll allow them both to come inside for maybe an hour or so then back out. I baby the BM a lot tho since she’s only just turned 1 so she’s allowed to stay inside for extended periods haha.

[@DeniseStamm-b1e]

I don't think any dog should live outside. Totally agree with you. People shouldn't have a dog if they don't want them indoors.😅

[@O8WRx]

This shows how people grow just as much as the dogs grow while you raise them. Dogs are awesome.

[@nonameguy4441]

I have a GSD and we struggled her first couple of months with biting and getting angry with us. It took time, but now she is an absolute doll

[@dashoverton1963]

I was thinking of getting a Belgian Malinois. Thanks for this honest upfront video.

[@ursulaweber2735]

Ich wünschte jeder Hundebesitzer würde sich so viel Mühe geben. Auch ich habe einen Malino ,sie sind sehr anspruchsvoll und liebenswürdig. Sie sind eine großartige Person ❤

[@dawidbachleda]

From first hand experience on raising a belgian malinois as my first dog, this was spot on. Especially even with the little things like the breed not knowing when to stop and telling them when play time is over.

[@bseroy]

What a great story of personal growth. That's what's dog training is all about and where the true reward is.

[@ryanwhisenant2150]

My wife and I just got a Malinois, we are learning amazing amount at the moment. We have blue tick that is about as stubborn as you can get. We did well with him I think. Dammit we are learning things we did wrong. Please, learn this breed before getting them. I have wanted one for 20 years abouts, and we are learning a lot. She is extremely loyal already after 3 weeks with her, as she is a rescue, but please understand they need exercise. They need a direction! My Millie has changed my lifestyle.

[@coffeehouseny]

Thank you for sharing your insights and experiences. It was a pleasure to listen to you talk about Bronte. It's clear you both love and respect each other.

[@kevinadams9269]

It’s good that you recognized the mistakes and didn’t give up! Training and training correctly are to separate things. These fur missiles are the most amazing loving and loyal dogs in the world!

[@nikkip8272]

I had a mix rescued from the garbage at approximately 4 weeks old with a character this bread has. She was sooo focused on playing that she learned a lot without noticing. People were astonished how "clever" and well trained she was, but the truth is all we did was playing with her.

[@Happymali10]

"If you're going to play frisbee with her, you're going to play frisbee with her for a while." As a Retriever-owner, that sounds familiar.

[@rhero1]

Max S. Had a retriever malinois mix. Favorite toy was a half deflated basketball. I’d kick. He’d retrieve. Over and over and over Thought I’d out smart him and get a frisbee. Make him run a long way First throw. Like a bullet. Second, little winded and gave me a second look and then gone again but not quite as fast Third throw I though he was getting tired but brougt the frisbee back with exited body language I throw it, he watched the flight till it hit on the far edge of the field and turned and went into his doghouse. it’s laying there till this day. He made me throw it so I’d lose it. Smart damn dog. Miss you Elvis!

[@democratic_chocolate2067]

Max S. oh yea my golden retriever loves retrieving birds and other animals during hunting season. Retrieving eagles and huge vultures are his favourite and it redirects his energy into something fun and productive

[@pandasrover]

Really enjoyed this. An honest record showing what the breed is like to live with. Lady readily admits when she's made mistakes and tries to correct them and recognises what she needs to do to live happily with her Malinois.

[@sarahs1635]

I'm a dog foster carer getting a 5 month old Malinois x Staffy (my first for both breeds) tomorrow and am very nervous! Not sure if watching this and a hundred other tips/training has made me feel better or worse, but I really love that this woman clearly has made every effort to recognise her mistakes, share with others and clearly has Bronte's best interest at heart. It looks like a beautiful, loving home for her. Well done!

[@RootboundRanch1]

Plz watch Tom Davis no bad dogs army. The dog will learn whatever you teach it. Good and bad.

[@jorgelozano620]

Some say if you see a BelMa sitting for 5 minutes, they've been sitting there for 5 hours from their prospective.

[@NoBody-xx6ii]

lol

[@libertyfarmsiowa]

My Malinois was a rescue and she's the best dog I've ever owned. She's an indoor dog, has run of the house, sleeps with me. There is someone almost always home with her. She's rarely left on her own but if so she just takes a nap. Activities she has participated in with us are: hiking running walking camping boating fishing kayaking swimming and her all-time favorite every day sport indoors and out frisbee. We too have a Mal that plays frisbee in the morning and night before she goes to bed in a hallway and room to room. I also taught her how to play find and seek where I hide her toys in the house in different rooms and she has to go seek them out which is good mental game for her. She has many different toys and knows the names of them all. She is super loving she loves children of all ages but does have very high prey drive she will chase cats, squirrels and any woodland creature big or small. She's so smart funny and loving. She's even had a couple "Lassie " moments. We have committed ourselves to an active lifestyle that incorporates her. She goes on trips with us and stays in hotels. She has an off switch though and the older she gets the more she prefers to lounge. She's seven now and can't imagine life without her. Not a dog for most people. As I said she's with someone nearly 24/7 and is well socialized in our community and well worked.

[@DougHinVA]

who the hell cares about you and your extended story ?

[@lisasmith516]

Well, I do...even tho I was vired bo end. I watched it twice. Boring, but salient.

[@lisasmith516]

Well, I do...even tho I was very bored. I watched it twice, a ciupke of months apart. Boring, but salient.

[@timcox359]

I have a rescue called Yasha too. It's my 1st Belgium. I've been into pit bull rescue & rehab for 40 years. But, Yasha had been abused by a backyard breeder and I had to get her. It's only been a couple of weeks; but, her transformation has been terrific.

[@Janeway1269]

The Merr, Roo2U & Yasha too I liked your "extended story." People cannot get enough info when it comes to the Malinois. Your success involves lots of activity and people need to understand that if they are considering this breed. I don't understand people who go out of their way to go online, just to make crappy remarks. I feel sorry for people who are that miserable. So ignore them. Thanks for chiming in.

[@AnaLKyo]

I just got a mal mix from a rescue recently and he's been an amazing dog. Very alert with high emotional intelligent and super affectionate. I'm not sure with what else he's mixed with but he is extremely calm but observant even as a 4-5month old puppy I can easily take him anywhere with public transport. He is a more sensitive dog but highly trainable so besides a stern "No", he learns best through positive reinforcement. The only downside is that he needs his humans companionship almost 24/7, yes he'll be fine on his own for couple hours but he does start getting more uneasy as more time goes by. I was also looking into doing Schutzen with him at first but since his personality is so calm and loving I will probably change to things like mantrailing or even see if he's able to go through service dog training with me. ♡ Cant be happier.

[@serenitymurphy9701]

What you said about the being sensitive to correction; my malanois ignored me for an entire day for taking away something that he was trying to eat 😭

[@brasinovic]

😂

[@zannahmartell9813]

He held a grudge! That's too cute.

[@JustJulesAgain]

Right?? When anyone leaves the house, that person would get a happy hello home, then pout face for a day or so. She finally grew out of it. 4 1/2.

[@themtgdude486]

My brother decided to get a Belgian Malinois...he gave up on it after a month or so. The dog is now with me, friends and family were telling me to find another home for the puppy but I decided we can work together. I have had him for about five months now. We go to the dog park often and he has a few dog friends that help him get exercise. I think we are doing well but we have a lot more learning to go. Pulling and separation anxiety are just a couple of things we have to work on. He is great dog with lots of energy.

[@joekewl9409]

I really appreciated this video so much. I almost felt like I was sitting down with the owner over a cup of coffee while she described her puppy dog to me. Her Belgian Malinois is definitely a pretty girl!

[@RAMN35]

You are talking about the BEST breed in the whole wide world(at least for me)!

[@gotshpilkes]

I recently lost a field trial Golden Retriever. Not exactly the same, but very similar levels of energy and drive (i.e., off the charts). The solution to all your challenges is stronger obedience. Free play doesn't wear them out, it just gets them more amped up. Every game needs to have rules. Throw the frisbee but don't let her go get it until released. Require that she return to the heel position and release on command. She'll love you more for it (even though you probably don't think that's possible).

[@jodyljohnson8515]

I agree with you...my husband trained USAF mwd's and he taught me the same method as you describe!😉 I could listen to him talk about dogs hours on end and still love it... though I met him at the end of his career, I've seen some of the results of training only. I absolutely love it💕

[@urbanthedk4653]

Are you seriously comparing Golden Retriever to a Malinois in terms of energy level and drive? Dude...this dog is like a pack of retriever puppies on frigging crack. Believe I had both

[@vanthomas9556]

Urban TheDK Learn what a field trial is, it’s not your fluffy golden retriever chasing a tennis ball in the park, it’s a competition between thousands of the most athletic, hard-driving retrievers, most professionally trained, with only ONE winner in the country every year. Winning a single national field trial is a lifetime ambition. The dogs playing those games aren’t Mals but they are damn drivey and will kill themselves doing the job they’re bred for. Like Mals they don’t know when to stop and they do not belong in pet households. The OP is giving solid advice.

[@todd2962]

I truly envy these dogs amount of energy. They just wanna work all day. That’s it.

[@doroti98]

Same story here ,i learned that Malinoas need much patience ...You can train them alone ,even if u have them for the firsf time but no negative emotions to fhem,no agression and much patience and time spending together...Generally they are very good dogs

[@martefact]

W.O.W. Probably one of THE best animal husbandry videos I have ever watched. This video should be played for every chid in every school that 'thinks' they know and love animals. Absolute gold. Thank you for authentic honest reflection and reporting. I adore these dogs and your realism is both grounding and enlightening.

[@amyenman4994]

I have owned shepherds all my married life... that is 4 shepherds... and then we got Malinois. This is an awesome breed. Each dog is an individual. Our first one was a velcro dog who was relatively passive and attached to the family. Our current female is an active and very driven dog from working stock... and has been taught to entertain herself when we are busy or out of the house. I spent two years tossing a tennis ball to her while I worked at my desk. Our Male is an adopted dog that has high toy drive but suffers from anxiety when we leave. Over the past year he has done a lot of damage to our house when left alone even for short periods of time. He has settled into a great dog. The fact is that as a dog owner, it is your responsibility to work with the breed you choose! Would I recommend a Mali to anyone? NO! Do I think that there is something enigmatic about this breed? NO. It is a matter of consistency, training and exercise. If you have an active lifestyle, and have the time to be interactive with your dog, it is a great fit. You also have to teach them to turn "on" and "off" the high drive. It is very simple to do. They Love to train. The love the outdoors. They love to be with their humans. BUT they are manageable and a fun breed to own.

[@annagagliardi2046]

All working dogs are very intelligent and the mal is probably at the top. Love the malinois but it's definitely not for me.

[@danb7958]

Found it difficult to distill the message in this comment, it sounds as though you like the dog but also don't?

[@guinevereofbeauty1581]

Beautiful dog. She is a good dog mom!👑

[@joshuacox581]

These comment are ridiculous! People say that Malinois are for “experience trainers” or “the best trainers” are talking out of their ass! You do not need to be a professional to train a Malinois or any other dog. To train a dog you need: time, love, and patience. You need to put in the time to train your dog. You have to love to train your dog. You need patience. Every dog has a different personality. Some dogs pick up things really easy and some take more time to learn. If you are not going to put time, love, and patience! Then do not get a Malinois or any other dog!

[@series9193]

Joshua Cox fucking well said !! It’s a dog do the work have patience and persistence stop expecting the dog to be a human !!

[@3summerfriends472]

yeah

[@MT-if1jr]

Joshua Cox I agree with the your comment, but a Mal is TURBO. If you don’t exercise them well, they WILL LET YOU KNOW, lol. Mine is just 7 months old and he is going through his growth. You do have to be a strong handler too. I have an intact male and he tests me every so often as does my Dutch. My Dutch is stubborn, but my Mal loves to work and it is a joy to train him. Mals are not like just any dog. Any working line dog needs more jobs and stimulus.

[@MrPrinceredz]

I’m a 4’11 girl with shepherd mix malinois. We sleep together and knows me when I’m sick and if I’m crying when I’m emotional she comfort me. She avoid biting our skin when I say ouch she surrender. When I’m cleaning the house or do household chores she sit and watching me. We run to the hill for 40 mins to an hour everyday. I love her.

[@wholesome122]

Belgians require more research but yeah you can definitely get one as your first dog if you have the right mindset, lifestyle and have done the research. Belgians just aren’t a good match for most people.

[@PatriotPaulUSA]

They really are the best dogs if you can keep up with the activity they require. Congrats on being a awesome Belgian owner of a great dog!

[@jakeshumway9487]

Don't get a malinois unless your prepared to walk it 3 times a day and constantly be taking care of it they are HUGE energy dogs and need almost constant exercise

[@nadejdajeanschmidt1015]

i did have Malinois for 30 years now, it is the best famely dog and most clever dog i ever have. i live in Denmark, there are not so many Malinois as private dogs in my contry.

[@oscarperezgonzalez4193]

I have a Belgian Malinois that I found lost, alone in the woods, still a puppy. He joined my pack of two German Shepherds and a Pit Bull. He is a wonderful dog, he adapted easily and brought a lot of joy to the family. He loves children, and he is very noble and obedient, we just love him

[@Animal-Reaction-Clips]

Oh my god did u find him in hill park

[@TimRHillard]

Cool dog. Cool story. Cool lad. And very well done video. Homerun!

[@sayurikitamura7109]

Good that you didn't let her down during the difficult times. I know what you mean, I got an malinois from a rescue station and it was not always easy, but in the end she was the happiest dog I've seen. I lost her last winter at th age of 14 and it felt like I lost a child and a best friend at the same time. I don't want to miss a second, from the beginning till the end. Well done Michelle 👍

[@jodyljohnson8515]

So sorry for your loss😟

[@sayurikitamura7109]

@@jodyljohnson8515 thank you!

[@ronalddamico2782]

I just rescued a purebread belgian in April. I did a ton of research on the breed before making the decision to adopt him, but still had to be realistic if things were not going to work out. Fortunately my dog trainer has had 8 in his lifetime and currently has 2. I did basic obedience training and he did great. I have not previously owned a malinois. We have made great strides even though things are not perfect, I am dedicated to putting in the time and training him correctly. I walk him an average of 10-12 miles a week. The first week I got him he was lunging and barking at people, but now he is calm, heals good and even sits and lays down without me even giving him the command. He is a good companion for my other dog and I am excited about getting more involved with agility.

[@MotorcycleJosh1]

8:37 MUST HAVE ALL THE FRISBEES!!!!

[@SuperSweetheart456]

I know, right. Just like a Mal. Ha ha

[@Paxindica96]

FRISBEE?? FRISBEE?! FRISBEE!!

[@QQ-dy6dq]

MotorcycleJosh1 you just described my dog

[@coreyhart309]

My Dutchie does the same thing with tennis balls.

[@brittanyfogarty2198]

I am really wanting another Malinois, I miss my boy a lot, we called him a Maligator, a definite fitting name!

[@MrKkdkk]

Majestic af

[@sunseeker4775]

I have had this (miniature, 10k) breed for the past 2 years and she has intelligently adapted to my lifestyle magnificently. She just knows what is required of her at every moment. She's delightful. Energetic, playful, but also can sleep all day if I have to. She does everything I do. She's even walked into the shower with me at times. 😂 A very loyal friend. (And I'm 73.)

[@lorrainelaskosky7785]

What an amazing honest woman...........I admire you with all of my heart........good on you for your dedication....you are a wonderful master

[@wviii342]

Thank you for helping others understand the commitment, time, and attention Malinois require. I wish I could find the equivalent informational video for high drive GSD. These beautiful animals are not for everyone for the same reasons.

[@moonayl7930]

Ive watched a lot of vids of yours but this is hands down the best one yet

[@pizzadude6615]

They're wild as hell, thanks for being friends with this little lady.

[@suiteypies]

This was very informative, thank you so much . I know now that I don't have the physical stamina to keep this breed happy and healthy, which is extremely important.

[@enligh10ed8]

Because of this video, I got my GSD Chuckit! Flying Squirrel throwing disks. The very first throw, I threw it right over the fence. They soar too well, lol. I was so frickin' pissed but I ordered more and now always have backups. They are her favorite toys. She is always ready to play as soon as I get home from work (you should put them in your Amazon affiliate store) thank you. Love this channel!

[@carolluther1625]

The Malinoui are so smart! Glad to hear her sharing of mistakes, no 2 dogs are alike.

[@passion4healing]

What a beautiful dog! You touched on something very important about Belgians. They are sensitive to harsh correction and can be very stubborn. They are also incredibly eager to please. I find that positive training works best with them.

[@Paulina-wg2fv]

So true

[@anya-the-belgian-malinois]

And then she mentions her dog was crying from hard corrections from the e-collar! Horrific training methods! I fail to recognize the connection between positive reinforcement and electric shocks especially when she is aware how sensitive mals are to hard corrections. :-(

[@logansilva8017]

@@anya-the-belgian-malinois positive reinforcement will only go so far because a stubborn dog with high pray drive is going to want to Chase the cat or someother animal more than play with whatever toy you have or eat whatever food you have and won't even hear your verbal command. That's why corrections are important it's the backbone that makes a verbal command have meaning when the dog isn't interested in any rewards you have. The e collar is for when a dog disobeys a known command it's a consequence for not doing what the dog knows it's supposed to do. The e-collar is not for teaching obedience it's for enforcing commands already known by the dog. How else are you going to get a recall at 50 yards when the dog is going for a cat or whatever else? Yelling some verbal command isn't going to work unless there is a consequence for disobeying.

[@anya-the-belgian-malinois]

@@logansilva8017 If that is your reasoning to use ecollars, you would do better beating a dog with a stick after disobeying, which would be less harmful than using an ecollar this way, in my opinion. Otherwise the dog will be fearful and in stress all the time the ecollar is on the dog's neck because the dog cannot know when you will hit him / her again. Ecollars can be reasonably used to recall your dog but only on minimum settings, so the dog gets a "signal", not a shock. Impulse control can be learned gradually, for example you can use a very long leash, at least that worked for me and my mal has a very high prey drive, see kzbin.info/www/bejne/g6mqiaRvadCoi7M Using an ecollar as a tool for punishment is a great way to "break" your dog, I would never use it. I do not remember the last time I used a leash when going out with my dog as I trust she will obey me and so far she does not disappoint!

[@logansilva8017]

@@anya-the-belgian-malinois I understand the long line technique and that is the path taken when teaching the recall. The e collar is only used at a strong enough setting to obtain the results needed when the dog is not following their command. The dog isn't guessing when the shock is coming or constantly worried about getting shocked. The dog knows it happens when they aren't listening. Once the long line has been taken off the dog and you are no longer tethered to the dog you have no way to insure the dog will fallow your commands. In this case you have a potentially dangerous dog that is out of your control that might lead to a person or animal getting bitten. Also your dog can end up in a dangerous situation when Relying solely on a verbal command or a reward There isn't much you can do if the dog decides not to listen. The e collar is that invisible long line and a very useful tool that will only cause as much pain and damage as the person using it same as with a long line or anything else. I personally don't have much experience with the Belgian Malinois or Dutch Shepard but I do have experience with the American Pitbull terrier. With a Prey drive that's so high it's difficult to turn off combined with a pain tallorance strong enough the dog will hang on to a 150lb hog or off the ground on a toy antel someone gets it down. I believe it's for reasons like this the Shepherd dogs Do better in protection sports And work I believe it's easier to get a reliable recall With shepherds As well as controlling the on off switch And a drive that's easier to harness If they went for their toy Like the pit bull goes for a Hog or for a person like the pitbull goes for another dog you probably wouldn't want to have that toy in your hand or pocket. And if your Shepherd went for people Like some of these pit bulls go for other dogs You would probably want an E collar for insurance as well just incase the dog doesn't obey. I've had some dogs that were pretty good as far as recall and reactivity and some that weren't. The ones that weren't would not go off leash with out a muzzle and usually not if another animal was in sight. Also I never had trained for protection of any kind and none of them were aggressive towards people in any way just their pet's.

[@Flackdiesel889]

I really do enjoy your work. This was another great interview with some good insight to the breed. She clearly adores that dog and tries to meet her needs. I think most people have no idea what they are getting themselves into when bringing a mal into the family. Amazing dogs, and I'd love to own one someday.

[@margitaspreeth1296]

This lady really loves her dog, its really sweet to see

[@chefestherkitchen896]

I like your story, I just came on here to look how to grow my Belgium MALINOIS dog

[@seanmolloy9422]

stairs are great to pull that energy down without the owner getting drained. I make my cattle dog touch each step. he wants to skip steps. this combines mental and energy work. You are so right about knowing when to stop.

[@catherinelynnfraser2001]

Love this story of an evolving bond.

[@thomasjackson700]

So awesome. This is so similar to a working line shepherd. They are a handful!

[@JayVincentFitness]

My Mal was the best decision I’ve ever made. Unconditional love, companionship and the best friend I’ve ever had. Just make sure you’ve got a lifestyle where they can spend a lot of time by your side because they need companionship. Mine comes to work with my every day. Oh yeah. And get used to playing a lot of fetch.

[@sarahschmidt38]

Such a sympathetic and honest woman, we need more people like her! :) People who do "everything right all the time" help noone. Educating dogs is even more difficult than educating kids, because everyone says that something else is the only right thing to do and a dog can't talk how he feels, that's easier with kids, also kids can't harm others as a Mali could if he wanted (one bite and you can visit the hospital). We also have a Mali and different people told us totally different things. We felt lost til we finally met an association which really can deal with this breed.

[@Sophia.Morrison]

What a gorgeous dog! I love her and enjoyed hearing your story. I have a working Line German Shepherd (Czech Line). My daughter has told me all about Malonois as she's loves them but I wouldn't get one due to lifestyle. Everything you've mentioned has confirmed her knowledge. You are doing a brilliant job with her.