Singer Reacts to Postmodern Jukebox ft. Haley Reinhart - Creep (Radiohead cover)

[@AndreaSilvestro]

My music: bit.ly/StreamPainting Support me on Patreon: patreon.com/AndreaSilvestro Please let me know if I should watch more!!

[@bertjones3010]

Was this the first time you'd listen to Haley? or are you familiar with her professional history? She's been my favorite for the past decade or more. She's just got a great voice that hits me just right. I did look through your playlist of reactions to see what type of people you've been reacting to. I think one of the things that impressed me most with your reaction was your knowledge of how and what she was doing in the performance. I know of really only one other vocalists that has the same mastery of their instrument that Haley does. She's European (Dutch actually) and probably more well known from the band were she is the lead vocalist. But, and it because of what I said earlier about your reaction/analysis of the performance, I think it would be more suitable with something from her solo projects. They started in 2019 when she appeared on a Dutch show called "Beste' Zangers". The premise is 7 singers go to an exotic location with a backing band and each week one singer is the "guest" and the others sing songs that have some relationship to the guest. This was the second song I ever heard her sing (the first was a duet on Phantom of the Opera), a solo adaption of Gaga's "Shallow" from a Star is Born. Originally performed as a duet in the movie, Floor and the band, like PMJ change it up for this performance. If you liked Haley's performance (and I see you listen to Morgan James also) you might want to try this one if you run out of Patreon requests. I know you will not be disappointed in discovering this vocalist considering your great taste in performers. Floor Jansen - Shallow - kzbin.info/www/bejne/g2eboZhqlsRssM0si=3tRFT4RG8XHm5G1e

[@bertjones3010]

I posted about the vocalist Floor Jansen and I didn't link you with the band she sings with because of the genre, but i think i will with the caveat that the performance i've linked here is to the video that is the most reacted to video on YTube. Now, while that might not be the kind of criteria that you're looking for, it still has the focal point on Floor's vocals - and in this performance she pulls from a lot of different musical experience to create a most memorable vocal performance. And it's a great video to do your superb analyst on - plus, this performance is nothing like how a typical song is constructed - it would probably be a score you'd hear in a movie. And - their fans will show up in droves. Also, one of the big attractions for fans is watching someone's reaction to this band for the first time. Nightwish - Ghost Love Score, Wacken 2013 - kzbin.info/www/bejne/amjIkGxsZrSEjacsi=0dN3PifWk-8FpPuN **(Please use this link - there are other versions of the same performance but this one is linked to the band's channel where there are NO copyright issues - Additionally, this performance has seven or eight natural breaks that make for natural pause points in which to comment)**

[@corneliusantonius3108]

Have you seen FloorJansen yet with Nightwish?

[@FrancescoSilvai]

This video is beautiful and contains spot-on observations, arriving at the perfect time: just two day after PMJ's 1000th concert. Thank you, Andrea!

[@Hundhammer]

seen them live on Saturday...

[@JeffTokayer]

How is this comment 4 months old?

[@FrancescoSilvai]

@@Hundhammer Wow, you were in Kempten? I saw them in Fort Lauderdale, London, Stockholm, and Budapest this year, and each performance was amazing! I’m sorry I missed Kyndle Wylde in Florida, but it’s awesome that Adam Kubota joined the team for the European tour. He definitely knows a thing or two about bass!

[@FrancescoSilvai]

@@JeffTokayer I requested this reaction video from Andrea 5 months ago. At the beginning of the video, she explains how this is possible.

[@JeffTokayer]

@@FrancescoSilvai So the reaction is 4 months old, but released just today, right?

[@don-music]

Haley is stunning inside and out and one of the greatest jazz blues vocalists of our lifetime. She’s playing a character here but she has huge range in every way, and knows her jazz theory super well

[@fingling8]

Great job. I'm impressed with what you saw. Love Hayley and the dynamics of this song, and the sweet detweets at the last seconds.

[@jcburger733]

Great cover of Creep!! Haley has incredible range and I love her raspy voice!! Thanks for sharing.

[@AndreaSilvestro]

ty!

[@georgelynch6139]

Scott on piano is the founder of PMJ, he composes all their material. My 2 favorites are the tracks “Black” and “Purple Rain”

[@guitar_noodle]

I’ve heard many covers of this song. PMJ and Haley’s version is my fav by far.

[@mikeconway9849]

Great reaction, Andrea! So many different vocal techniques on display in one song. I've seen Haley live and she is an amazing singer

[@AndreaSilvestro]

ty for watching!

[@smirkingguru]

Thank you so much for reacting to this it's one of my fav PMJ/Haley songs...MORE MORE MORE Plz!!! Also, Andrea You have a Killer Voice XOXO

[@AndreaSilvestro]

ty! feel free to stream my music bit.ly/StreamPainting

[@RealDrunkenMaster]

One of my favorite PMJ songs. Haley is such an amazing singer. Subscribed.

[@MRDARKTURKEY]

Recorded live in one take, and this was the first attempt…

[@BryceKatz]

On an off day while on tour & Haley wasn't feeling 100%.

[@theblackdog2399]

Actually, they recorded two takes, but they used the first take and discorded the second take.

[@MRDARKTURKEY]

@ I believe there were 3.. the first was deemed the best…

[@theblackdog2399]

@@MRDARKTURKEY There were two takes. They used the first one and discorded the second one.

[@jamiemacdonald436]

@@theblackdog2399 *discarded. Discorded mean something entirely different.

[@TheMartins-m2h]

Andrea, you have a very astute and trained musical ear. You recognize the subtle nuances of Haley's voice and band. As a novice who loves music and especially Haley I better understand my love for her voice. She excels in any genre be it rock, jazz or blues. Thanks again for your reaction, enjoyed it.

[@AndreaSilvestro]

thanks!!

[@paulf4650]

This is an amazing cover and I really enjoyed your reaction. I know that you're a fan of The Warning so I think you'd enjoy seeing Pau cover this song. Its Pau @ 18, an out of tune piano and a cellphone. She didn't get it in one take, but it was an Instagram challenge and she learned it in an afternoon.

[@JeffTokayer]

Great reaction. This video was done in one take. Not a small feat considering that in the same day Haley recorded PMJs second most viewed video, All About That Bass.

[@robertmongerthe9025]

All Scott Bradley productions are done in one take.

[@JeffTokayer]

@@robertmongerthe9025 in one take, literally. First and only take. What you may be referring to is that all PMJ videos are done in one continuous pass, with no edits.

[@rosskelly8268]

Reminds me of Amy Winehouse. That level of ornamentation only works for top flight singers. Haley Reinhart has great pitch and musicality, and she can certainly pull off all that styling and freewheeling. Key changes are uncommon in recent years, but going way, way back to the 60s, 70s, and 80s key changes were relatively common in charting pop songs.

[@antivanti]

The arrangement was initially made for another singer but she liked it so much that she played around with it in her own time. On a day off while on tour they recorded a bunch of these videos and at the end of the session Scott asked if she wanted to give this one a go. She was hesitant because her voice was tired from the tour and the long session and was a bit sick. Scott asked if she could at least do one take. She agreed to one take. This is that one take

[@theblackdog2399]

Nah, you got your story a little twisted.

[@MattWilliams-yc6jt]

Haley sang Creep a few times with PMJ before before recording. Her first performance was in Lyon France. kzbin.info/www/bejne/anuacnqcgbNpbckfeature=shared

[@theblackdog2399]

Not really. Haley arrived in Europe for her first European tour. Scott told Haley to find another song of PMJ's she could perform while on tour. She picked "Creep". They rehearsed it and Haley performed it for the first time in Lyon, France. That performance, now historic, is still on KZbin to this day. When Scott saw the amazing crowd response to Haley's first performance, he knew then that he must re-record the song with Haley singing the song instead. They next went to Zurich Switzerland and on a day off from performing, Scott rented a studio and recorded several new videos with Haley and several others performing. Meanwhile, near the end of the day, Scott got Haley to record "Creep". They performed two separate renditions of "Creep" and Scott's team used the first recording. No, Haley wasn't really sick at the time except for a little jet lag for a few days from her flight to Europe.

[@tomwalker3746]

1 take!! Amazing! ❤

[@capstan50g]

I liked that snippet of your song, Andrea. Your sound is so assured now, with plenty of style. Haley sings pretty well, too, right? :)

[@AndreaSilvestro]

thanks so much! feel free to stream bit.ly/StreamPainting

[@mldkenny]

Wow, first time I've heard this, stunning.

[@AndreaSilvestro]

so good!

[@NZLatic]

I enjoyed this reaction. It‘s nice to hear someone who is a singer and musician themselves give their take on Hayley‘s incredible voice and her use of dynamics. When you have experienced making and performing music yourself, you can get a real insight that others may not fully understand. Hayley has to be the most underrated singer of recent times, but also one of the best.

[@AndreaSilvestro]

thank you so much!

[@srenasymons3941]

The whole it being a jazzzy swing cover... That savvy and sultry playful vocal she uses is what it's all about to bring that flavour with her performance and I've always found that to be genuine and genius with this type of remix as only certain people can pull it off properly like she has. I saw this video when it first released, being into electroswing and swing remixes for a long time. A shame there isn't more than what there currently is now

[@troy9er]

She is from here near me in in the burbs of Chicagoland. Been her fan for years!

[@jimcrawford3221]

I've loved her singing since her days on American Idol. The logical choice for a follow-up is PMJ's version of All About That Bass. I've watched several reactions to this song. You did a great job explaining your views of the singing and the instrumentation.

[@AndreaSilvestro]

tysm!

[@markhenry8669]

NEXT PLEASE 7 Nation Army W/ Halry Reinhart

[@rickthreebears184]

When she sings the extended section (run, run, run), take note that she does that on the breath she took during ONE beat.

[@doctor_b2802]

This and Korn's version are my 2 favorite covers of this song. They couldn't be more different 😅

[@lettherebmusic4249]

OMG! It's you. Where have you been? Glad I found you again.

[@WoodlandT]

Great reaction/analysis! You clearly have an excellent understanding and instinct for music and performance 👍🏻👍🏻

[@AndreaSilvestro]

thanks!!

[@lynettepascua4730]

Great reaction and I really love your hair today. I remember when Haley was on American Idol. She should have won.

[@AndreaSilvestro]

thanks so much!! appreciate it :)

[@ladyjane8855]

She's a true performer. It's the difference between professional and amateur singers. Mesmerizing.

[@colleenfuller1367]

Great review and insightful - many thanks.

[@t0dd000]

PMJ is amazing in this, but Haley just crushed this. Stunningly good.

[@pierregodbout8778]

hello Andrea, one of my two favorite singers, the other being Angelina Jordan. I like your reactions.

[@orlandoochoada2242]

I don't know how you feel about Prince's cover of "Creep", but his cover of "Motherless Child" is pretty good. Definitely worth checking out.

[@rs-ye7kw]

I thought the short clip you played of you singing was quite reminiscent of Haley's voice.

[@3rdOption-l9t]

[2:28] "I don't have that natural rasp in my voice." 👉 Yet, in your _speaking_ voice, you do, a lot. Even in the sentence declaring you don't, you do... Hmm.

[@KeepEvery1Guessing]

You can hear the drummer too (behind Haley).

[@donnilloyd1355]

I like the Original. But I LOVE this Cover. And Haley Reinhart, she is JESSICA RABBIT, reincarnated. IMO. Great Post.

[@brewswillis9783]

Well done Andrea! Brian Justin Crum does an excellent cover as well. Cheers!

[@macdeluxe733]

Always a pleasure to see some semi-talented singer giving advice to Hayley Reinhart on how it could be done better. Maybe try Freddy Mercury next, that lad could do with some tuition.

[@damianbancks7144]

I love their version of Seven Nation Army too with Haley. Check it out.

[@Daehawk]

Post Modern is awesome.

[@8977jn7]

What was interesting to me is it was a live one take

[@Sunaメ]

hey andrea, can you please react more of soolking songs ? such as ( dalida, youv, milano, zemer etc.. ) i would appreciate it so much

[@jf-be4zy]

If you want to have some fun and see something wild and crazy check out Zhou Shen singing "I'am a Star"

[@NightFogFilms]

Karen Marie did this version 1 year before Haley - kzbin.info/www/bejne/aYbFZKminreFjqs

[@Howie-du7ov]

Ok, and?

[@Howie-du7ov]

I did a version 3 years before Radiohead.

[@Jeremey7]

i know this is off-topic, but hey i wanna learn guitar, but don't know where to start. any tips?

[@AndreaSilvestro]

check out sean daniel on youtube!

[@Jeremey7]

@@AndreaSilvestro thanks!

[@WallisZero-f7b]

O'Connell Point

[@Gergei-xi1bs]

Please listen to Quiet outpost by Diana Ankudinova. Very impressive performance from Nika awards(Russian Oscar)

[@HoltBilly-m8c]

Leffler Way

[@VaughanHermosa-e8n]

Ullrich Brooks

[@LarryCalloway-s7i]

Leopold Lodge

[@VirgilioCajka-z1d]

Marcus Curve

[@BrightPolly-t7w]

Kilback Plains

[@RockefellerHarry-u6n]

Angus Tunnel

[@SandyJulia-r2n]

Kenya Keys

[@allendesalme197]

Hope Japan is treating you well

[@HearstStanford-h2v]

Gregg Plaza

[@captainkangaroo4301]

For a sultry voice you should listen to the studio recording of Fever by Peggy Lee.

[@JeffTokayer]

Or Haley’s version kzbin.info/www/bejne/inqmfZyvmq11qqssi=V0-WJewT4n_C3DBc

[@JeniceIwamoto-r7j]

Fisher Knoll

[@GracieCora]

0943 Edmond Square

[@TerryThera-g5s]

Aurore Haven

[@RosyHlavaty-z3l]

Ella Isle

[@KlaraScheulen-q3k]

Americo Junction

[@VioletRuth-t4r]

Bode Camp

[@HaywoodLena-s8i]

Ali Junction

[@AdamsBrady-c9w]

Franecki Haven

[@EstherBright-f9c]

Alayna Rest

[@warrens1757]

So funny that you say you don't have that rasp in your voice when you sing, but you have so much rasp in your voice when you talk. lol

[@Hundhammer]

[@doctor_b2802]

If i remember correctly, Hailey was sick the day this was shot but still managed to pull this off in one take.

[@warrenburroughs3025]

You really don't have to stop every few seconds to comment or talk over it. Plenty of reaction Chanels can let it play and then talk when it's finished.

[@joenewman6494]

If she only knew soon as she stops everyone starts fast forwarding until she stops talking🤣

[@DefenestrateYourself]

It’s an analysis video, dum dum

[@theblackdog2399]

Do Haley Reinhart and PMJ's "Seven Nation Army" next. You and your audience will be blown away .