1954 High school exchange student debate/forum on religion: India, Pakistan, Thailand, Switzerland

[@sayerihossain8075]

After almost 6 decades, we are so advanced... Today's TV debates: *shouting *loud *abusive *disrespectful

[@aninda2457]

True but in those days, violence and riots were rampant and these people were a minuscule minority representing a large mass of uneducated population !

[@ak5258]

dont dwell on the negatives, every thing has a good and bad side. overall technology has done more good, hence we are having this debate.

[@sayerihossain8075]

Literacy literally has nothing to do with violence that is clearly evident in today's generation.

[@princevegeta529]

And after every sentence JAI SHRI RAM

[@ashishchotani2458]

@@princevegeta529 yeah inshallah, Allahu Akbar is cool Jai Shree Ram isn't . Secular much??

[@coc_champs]

Man every video I watched there is always a Indian who was just too brilliant and amazing speaker.

[@murn3229]

Sadly we've stopped making them here😢

[@ankitranjan5755]

@@murn3229 what made u speak so?

[@andromeda9188]

@@ankitranjan5755 Brain drain

[@somethingnew7078]

@@andromeda9188 not just that ..... Look at how furious as a society we've became today

[@bharatvassee237]

and a total asshole when asked about innovation, human development, meritocracy, and egalitarianism , amazing speakers is what they STOP at... full of Caste System BS

[@Daradajee]

The Pakistani guy is from what was then East Pakistan. A few years later India helped them gain independence from Pakistan and became the new nation of Bangladesh. Rauf is now a Bangladeshi Senior Citizen.

[@sridharreddy8011]

Is he still alive

[@Astor-hu4ly]

correction: India interfered with internal matters of a sovereign country and created a terrorist organization against its army to separate a nation.

[@Saurabh.up81]

@@Astor-hu4ly Still butthurt after these years? 😂😂 Why dont you invite Bangladesh to rejoin West Pakistan? I'm sure they would like to 'rectify' their mistakes and India's misdeeds!

[@somethingnew7078]

@@Astor-hu4ly man just look at those horrible pictures they're so terrifying , pak army asking son to rape his mom after shooting her to death bed ....... Moral ambiguity perhaps ......

[@Astor-hu4ly]

@@somethingnew7078 tu apnay pass rakh apni pics ko, bara forensic karwaya hai tu nay pics ka

[@marqueeog5284]

I believe no politician in India could speak as good as Ram is doing in this debate. Having one religion is monopolistic but accepting all the religions is diversity. And India should always be known for it's diversity.

[@hldkaran1504]

You haven't met many politicians then.

[@Sana-dz8fh]

@@hldkaran1504 no, actually you're not Indian then

[@kamrulhasan3468]

Dude what you are saying sounds very good, I'm all in for religious diversity and freedom of whoever chooses to follow whatever, but it doesn’t necessarily work on practical terms. All religions cannot be true at the same time. Either there is no god, no true religion; or there is one. God cannot be at the same time have a son (christianity), have no son (Judaism and Islam), have 33 million manifestations (hinduism).

[@adityanair3673]

But You should know monotheism only aim is that every human being to believe in their God and it's directly a danger for Diversity . As you can see in Afganistan a particular religion has wiped out every other religion people who were once a majority like in Afganistan It was a Buddhist Majority Country with Hindu's and Sikhs population in Equal numbers

[@Pradyumna-e8r]

@@kamrulhasan3468 That's your idea of God. When you can't prove God, you can view it like anything. 33 or 33 millions. Actually God is not ultimate too acc to Hindus. So I guess that is better answer to Creator paradox.

[@humanentity2214]

Ram is very sharp. He hit the nail on the head between the correlation of communism and literacy by giving the example of Travancore area in India.

[@humanentity2214]

@Mandeep Singh interesting, so the whole 99% Kerala literacy rate is only knowing how to sign your name?

[@humanentity2214]

@Mandeep Singh are you Malyali?

[@RunningWalking12]

@Mandeep Singh Morons like you should also understand two students who represented India in this program were from Kerala - Nalini Nair and Padmanabhan Gopinath.

[@gtyagig123]

@Mandeep Singh british and missionaries reached to bengal, andhra and Maharashtra also ..then why those states didnt become so educated(read/write), why the same missionarise couldnt standardized and made available to all the socio-economic groups of other states also...something fishy..

[@akb7217]

@Mandeep Singh it seems you just celebrated your 10th anniversary 😬😬😬

[@Pythonerate]

man im an american and in every debate so far im stunned by the beauty and eloquence of the indian debaters, with ram truly being the star of them all

[@RAIRADIO]

India has seen so much invasion and diversity, that that experience has given us a lot of knowledge.

[@meme-qw6hl]

And now days people doing what not to pull down indians

[@ITZ_ONLY_YOUR_HIMANSHU]

True

[@Avant-garde1611]

Yeah,same thing i was wondering. Their clarity is astounding

[@shivakumarvakada1880]

Ram was super...his counter questions and reasoning and explanation of Hinduism was superb...

[@theoriginalrudeboy2916]

When he says the plight of the poor is divine and that they deserve it . Sounds kinda like a brahman boy justifying thousand years of oppression over lower castes .

[@Shaan887]

With the assumption that Brahmins were rich.

[@anujchaturvedi6296]

@@theoriginalrudeboy2916 vaishyas are the rich ones, Brahmins are the one with the most knowledge - get your facts right.

[@shivakumarvakada1880]

As per shastras and lord Krishna himself in bhagawat Gita, it's not by birth but by one's actions and character (Gunas)that he belongs to any of the one varnas (Bhramin, Kshatriya, Vaishya and Shudra). Brahmin: predominantly focus on knowledge accumulation, seeking truth and dissemination, does not run behind money or hoard wealth Kshatriya : predominantly Defends people against invasion, wages war. Vaishya : focused on increasing wealth through trading Shudhra: who predominantly follows instructions from others and provides service Eg laborers, farmers, weavers, potters.. involved in lot of physical work What was fluid later became static due and by birth... We deviated from shastras and lord's teachings hence we have become a divided society

[@shivakumarvakada1880]

@@theoriginalrudeboy2916 I don't think he meant that, he meant by attributing our downfalls to our bad karma we find a way to find solace. I however believe he did not give the actual clarification that caste is not a traditional word just like the word India. In our Vedas and Bhagawat Gita it's called varnas into which people can be grouped Not based on birth but by their actions and Gunas( character).

[@purvatiwari5846]

The day is not too far, this video will be used for case study. This is gold and Ram is a diamond ! 🔱

[@adityanair3673]

Har Har Mahadev 🙏🕉️🔱

[@dhruvdust1812]

all his arguments are emotional drama phrased in a sophisticated manner

[@adityanair3673]

@@dhruvdust1812 what emotional

[@dhruvdust1812]

@@adityanair3673 shut up

[@harshitasaxena3417]

@@dhruvdust1812 nice argument

[@anushreekogje4324]

Appreciate that Ram stood by the Very Basic question about The Very Basis- 'Being advanced in what sense' changes the entire scenario!

[@Avant-garde1611]

Made others go speechless

[@deepalimishra682]

i am proud of that Indian guy......... BTW happy independence day

[@studyok6509]

Same to you Happy Indepence Day ❤️🇮🇳 Yep Mr. Ram was amazing here.

[@deepalimishra682]

@@studyok6509 yup.. hez gr8

[@baijayantasenchowdhury9806]

Happy Independence day 🇮🇳🎉 I enjoy watching these debates

[@dj-ux1jr]

Yeh very few minds we have

[@ISLAMICPREACHERAPOLOGIST]

I am a Pakistani, I agree that the Indian was the most intellectual and a much better speaker.

[@prettypwincess201]

Okay no one cares...

[@saumyapant8113]

@@prettypwincess201 why the fuck people are so rude for no reason

[@KeerthanaR22]

❤️❤️

[@azilius5302]

@@prettypwincess201 shutup princess

[@donthidefrommeh5374]

@@prettypwincess201 cuz your parents didn't cared about raising you well.

[@noorjahan315]

India coming to help Pakistan when Pakistan got stuck. :) Very sweet gesture by India.

[@studyok6509]

Yea I also noticed that. 😂💖

[@dentrifications]

Father Always helps son

[@noorjahan315]

@@dentrifications stop this father son nonsense. 🙄

[@amit8835]

@@noorjahan315 yeah i too hate this father-son thing which every indian guy near me calls ...ive met people from pakistan ...they are very generous... just because of some political and military clashes ...whole of the nations develop hate

[@Daradajee]

The guy is East Pakistani, a few years later India helped them to become the independent nation of Bangladesh. The Pakistani young man is now a Bangladeshi Seniors.

[@pritthishdutta6409]

Everyone : God! is ours. *Ram : God is just a means, we believe in reality and truth.*

[@sipp91]

Thats because Ram is most likely an atheist

[@infinite5795]

@@sipp91 many Hindus are athiests as well, because Hinduism has atheistic sects as well, not like any Abrahamic religion.

[@sipp91]

@@infinite5795 and what exactly is the difference between an atheist and a hindu atheist?

[@pajeet-cel3484]

@@sipp91 Hinduism is a way of life not a religion every hindu who truly understands it is indeed an atheist

[@infinite5795]

@@sipp91 In Hinduism, athiests aren't traditionally killed unlike Abrahamic religions, unlike in Christianity and Islam where there are detailed ways of prosecuting an athiest. Even Buddha was an athiest frm a Hindu family only, who wasn't killed by any hindu and this all happened before the birth of Jesus, Christian and Muslim countries are still fighting among themselves as well as historically the same, inquisitions, crusades, forced conversions and invasions.

[@gaurinautiyal293]

*The way he expressed HINDUISM, gave me goosebumps* you literally nailed it!😍

[@adityanair3673]

I wanted the debate to be lengthier

[@gaurinautiyal293]

@@adityanair3673 same!

[@mikasaakm2454]

It’s normal, you are Indian. Most of the comments speaking about the Indian guy are writed by Indians 🤷🏻‍♀️

[@gaurinautiyal293]

@@mikasaakm2454 that’s very obvious lmao! who other than INDIANS themselves do you expect to know the most bout INDIA?

[@ryanmarlin2974]

@@mikasaakm2454 yea, pretty much everyone here is Indian, no wonder everyone here is sacking off the Indian guy.

[@pc_hmk2204]

from this interview i can say that chritian guy is arrogant and sometimes saying non-sense. buddhist girl is ok. but sometimes she don't have proper answers. i really appreciate honesty of pakistani guy which nowadays we won't be able to see from pak. he seems somewhat secular. and hindu guy is really intellectual and answering fluently to almost every question...... but obviously it's just my opinion. everyone have different.

[@randomstuffs844]

Being an Indian I'm so Proud that ram is as awesome as he is in this debate.. He SHREDS the Christian (probably british) ... On the other hand I'm quite disappointed by the one representing Pakistan because he was also representing Muslim/ Islamic idioligy and he wasn't quite able to explain anything

[@ishraknoor8992]

I was somewhat surprised to see someone from East Pakistan( which is now Bangladesh and my country as well). But then I was disappointed as he couldn't describe things with much clarity. Frankly speaking, I think focusing too much in rituals and not on the broader facts of wisdom has made him a bit less intellectual, and such is the case for many other people of this region.

[@Astor-hu4ly]

honestly lolz... you mean you cant beat pakistan no more...

[@vasudhasharma5532]

I live how at 1-2 places the Muslim guy fails to get his point across, even when he has a valid point, and the Hindu guy is able to explain his views, coz well, living with all religions in India, I’m pretty sure he had a well enough knowledge of them too.

[@User-Kaathal]

The girl was sixteen only. The boy from Pakistan was also very young . Besides, language could also be a barrier. The Indian youth was undoubtedly and wonderfully answered not only for himself but also for those two.

[@tiejeevan]

Wow, the way he described Hinduism is 1500% correct.

[@adityanair3673]

💯 true 😊

[@mihamhassan6206]

Yea... Worshiping dolls and cows Is 1500% correct

[@adityanair3673]

@@mihamhassan6206 why do you pray That big black stone 😂🤔

[@infinityxtanishq8712]

@@mihamhassan6206 better than worshipping AK 47s and blowin up on the streets

[@adishripadiyar6438]

@@mihamhassan6206 literally all you had to do was watch the video , shut up and be respectful.

[@friendlyatheist9589]

Their command on English is much much better compared to what people have today especially that Indian guy. I dream to speak like him I'll try more

[@meryembel98]

I believe that these teenagers used to live in privileged housholds where they got a very good education, also in foreign languages.

[@being_artist298]

@Salahuddin Ayubi congratulations 🎉 Rs 1 has been credited in Ur account 👍

[@KD-ye6ce]

@Salahuddin Ayubi अरे विचित्र जीव! महा ज्ञानी पुरुष, इस प्रकार का विशिष्ट ज्ञान लाते कहाँ से हो। पहले वेद और उपनिषद, जिनका तुम उल्लेख कर रहे हो, वो कभी पढ़े भी हैं या बस व्हाट्सएप्प यूनिवर्सिटी से पढ़कर आ गए। एक बार ढंग से अध्ययन करो, तब समझ आएगा कि असली वेद क्या थे और उनमें किस प्रकार मिश्रण किया गया अनर्गल बातों का। मनुस्मृति में जितने श्लोक असलियत में थे उससे ज्यादा तो उसमें मिला दिए गए। है मूढ़, नराधम प्राणी! पहले अपने ज्ञान का तनिक विस्तार कीजिये तदोपरांत आप इस काबिल हो पाएंगे कि आप वेद या उपनिषद पर उंगली उठा पाएं। तुम्हारी भाषा मे तो लिंग का मतलब ही बदल दिया जबकि उसका शाब्दिक अर्थ स्वरुप होता है। हे अनिष्टकारी, अश्लीलता के द्योतक! प्रथम तो आप अपने शब्दों में शीतलता लेकर आये, तदनंतर हम आपसे वार्तालाप करेंगे और आपको वेदों का उचित ज्ञान भी अवश्य प्रदान करेंगे। अगर अब भी समझ से बाहर है तो I have the way which can you understand easily. The way on which you want to go, I will terminate all the exits you want. May you not work as paid media further and change yourself. Otherwise rest is history. जय जय श्री राम

[@djangounchained2754]

@Salahuddin Ayubi now Muslim guy will tell about Hinduism lol.

[@KD-ye6ce]

@Obamium because, everyone want the answer in their own language and I just did the same. And the language is not for exam preparation, This is in our heart, no need to read in a parrot method. The blood give us the Honor to feel proud to Speak, write or learn HINDI.

[@sart5322]

That Indian guy is so cool

[@Shaaan]

was

[@ITZ_ONLY_YOUR_HIMANSHU]

True

[@atharvaphatak5681]

I'm really overwhelmed by Ram's point on every religion IS same

[@mos5139]

This caused our decline

[@atharvaphatak5681]

@@mos5139 no bro, this is why we are different from any other religion, and say it loud proudly! And we have declined economically and socially, but India is still undisputed spiritual preacher of world. Ascends and declines are part of the natural cycle, that what is permanent is ultimate reality of spirituality which can never decline in 🇮🇳. And be happy, for now after 800yrd of decline, our Ascending era has started!!

[@harshitapandey4892]

@@mos5139 So true!! He's no doubt brilliant but he sounds a staunch Hindu who needs to study more shastras.

[@nishantsrivastava2625]

This is nonsense please stop this narrative that every religion same there is difference between dhramic tradition and abharmabhic religion

[@asuraXTC]

Yeah they’re all just huge cults

[@yogesh___]

A proud Hindu......and a proud Indian.....and my representative just given me the huge ammount of confidence..... 👍👍

[@hendostanasmajilyaath5500]

Zok😂

[@salma-nw9fe]

@@hendostanasmajilyaath5500 what is zok in this mister if someone is proud with their identity 🤦

[@6tbrowny430]

@@salma-nw9fe very good....ur a very good muslim😇😇🙏🤲

[@goodguyyt]

@@6tbrowny430 terrorism? Islam=terrorism 9/11 26/11 All because of a fcking book Quran

[@6tbrowny430]

@@goodguyyt I know that...but if there is a good muslim then we should appreciate them

[@Manoeuvrey]

My Man *Ram* counters every point like he's playing with kids out there

[@apoorvparikh3532]

I'm so fascinated by Hinduism, it define everything science, cosmos, mysticism, occultism, spirituality, peacefulness,

[@misbamaniyar2456]

Ha ha m Indian muslim 😂😂 nd as expected I find my brother is too amazing with his skills in this video he is able to define each and everything I don't know about religion much but Indians are best and also they prove that

[@akkkkk813]

Same bro

[@pulkit935]

What!!!! your brother, he might be your grandfather's age now

[@RealCosmosry]

1954: Indians rocking debates 2020: Indians rocking SpellBee's

[@MentalHealthTreatment]

😆

[@AMANSHARMA-xw8qi]

😜

[@jamessteeper6617]

China: Dominating Math Olympiad

[@evenit2816]

i started watching these videos ysterday and in almost every debate the indians have caught me off guard, Ram here seemed so smooth with his arguments

[@madara.3059]

Yeah

[@Avant-garde1611]

And his clarity on these subjects as difficult as Hindu religion which in itself is a Ocean was amazing

[@joelabrahammanoj9741]

I have to say, the Christian guy don't know what Christianity is and The Indian guy is the smartest and more knowledgeable among them.

[@akkkkk813]

And I guess Manoj you don't even know the origin of this word

[@swetashetty941]

The Swiss guy ...is his introduction itself showed how weak his knowledge is and if this is his explanation ..he does more disservice to Christianity,he does not need others to defeat his debate argument

[@VerryJerry90]

@@akkkkk813the origin of what word??

[@akkkkk813]

@@VerryJerry90 he has deleted his comments so I don't think it correct to speak about someone who is not even here to defend himself

[@ainvoid0013]

All religions are one, just differ in nomenclature. This Indian guy ♥️

[@bholenath1421]

Yes. They are just the various Stages of Hinduism.

[@adityanair3673]

@@Pradyumna-e8r It's Universal truth

[@adityanair3673]

@@Pradyumna-e8r No truth is one we need to find

[@sipp91]

That's like saying all sports are the same lmao

[@nishantsrivastava2625]

All religion are not same stop is nonsense please there is difference between abharmabhic religion and dharmic tradition

[@suswsh07]

Bharat (India) have more than 10000 years of history and civilization... We have our own Gurukul system (education system) which totally destroyed by Britisher...

[@MuhammadAli-jd2ut]

Pfft

[@harikishan5158]

@@MuhammadAli-jd2ut shoo shoo fly off extremist!

[@welcome9975]

True

[@devapala879]

was this excellent education available to the so-called lower castes and women?

[@harikishan5158]

@@devapala879 umm yes..according to megasthanese (a chronicler) had stated that people of all spheres could study under gurukul,women as well. AL behruni (also a chronicler) stated the same. However the the ways in which a person can earn money was limited to the occupations of that jati.

[@nefertitibelinda1146]

America and the Western world were VERY fearful or obsessed with Communism.!!! I wonder why... the discussion keeps veering towards communism all the time 😳

[@J7pat7]

It's something that affects us to this day . Part of it is because Communism was sort of code for anything the right wing did not like such as civil rights. You see it even today when they yell communism , socialism to anything they don't like. But also remember that the US and the Soviets were the 2 superpowers in those days .

[@lalahana111]

Well, in my country in Latin American, the most horrible time in our history was the terrorism and they were communist. We’re afraid of communist people. Now a communist won the presidential elections. My country will be dead in a couple of years.

[@ShubhamMishrabro]

Don't you know free healthcare is communist and Joe Biden is radical socialist. And when say Nordics and most world has this it's just high tax but in us if you say this you're communist

[@KakashiHatake-sw2sy]

@@lalahana111 In India too , a lot of killing happens due to extreme left wing outfits , we call them naxals , they are basically Maoist communists , basically terrorists.

[@sreeram4964]

@@KakashiHatake-sw2sy in India its not just commies who commit murder. Religions spilled more blood than communists.

[@Neuroninexis_xyz]

Around 13:15 Ram mentioned that Hindus believe that we deserve what we have today. It is different. We believe that what we have is a function of what we've created - karma.

[@GaganSingh-nx2yv]

It is the same thing.

[@Neuroninexis_xyz]

@@GaganSingh-nx2yv Haan bhai sure! But in that moment in the debate it just seemed as if he's feeling that the entire reason for India's colonization is because of India and that we deserved it. So I wrote what I did.

[@mahimapanwar4293]

@@GaganSingh-nx2yv it's a totally different thing ,karma is not a reward system . "The word Karma means action, as you sit here, there is physical action going on, mental action going on, emotional activity going on, energy activity going on in us. Whether you wake or sleep, 4 dimensional Karma are happening all the time" It Is The 'CONSCIOUS ACTIVITY' ,That We PERFORM ,Which Will RULE The DESTINY Of Our LIFE.

[@GaganSingh-nx2yv]

@@mahimapanwar4293 sophistry isn't going to change the meaning.

[@GaganSingh-nx2yv]

That goes for getting sick?!

[@Letseatwithoutguilt999]

Speaker of India Ram is so well spoken.. He literally gave the exact answers what were asked.. India means diversity and he showed that..

[@RAIRADIO]

Hinduism means diversity and he showed that. India is a just a geography. India is not a philosophy. India stops being India, wherever Hindus become minority. It's just fact.

[@azr_sd]

I want debates to happen like this. Ram is awesome 👍

[@callarpit1]

Wow just wow the "Hinduism is assimilative, elastic and all comphrehensive" and then "objective of a Hindu is to obtain onness with reality and truth. God is a means the reality and truth is an end" Man these jewels from this person is much more than any Godman I have ever herd.

[@ananyaverma1957]

He's just quoting the scriptures

[@RAIRADIO]

Strongly recommend you to read Nasadiya Sukta. Nothing a Hindu says about Hinduism is by fluke.

[@gokulvrindavan1858]

He read scriptures very well. Go through scriptures please. This is the weakness every Indian have and others don't qualified exploit, mislead in the name of secularism

[@moulikas44]

Ram you just nailed it ....😍😍🤩🤩🤩

[@bnagendra9019]

I found some of sadhguru's thoughts on Hinduism The ultimate object of Hindu to attain the oneness with the reality with truth itself and Not necessarily with a god, the god is a means. The reality and truth is the end...

[@theoriginalrudeboy2916]

if u need sadguru to know that u need to study more

[@chaitanyagupta878]

Yes father supreme.

[@rrraynoorrr]

That raises more questions than answers. I wish these experts actually talked clearly when imparting their knowledge. Usually it seems they are deliberately vague in order to look more intelligent.

[@theoriginalrudeboy2916]

@@rrraynoorrr are u stalking me ??

[@kanishkanegi5594]

@@rrraynoorrr what's vague about it?? Lol

[@shubhamshejaval8526]

I think all eastern religions including Hinduism, Buddhism, Jainism, Taoism, etc do not fit in the definition of religion in my opinion. "Dharma" is the right word to categorize them. Indians what do you think?

[@theaveragegamer1719]

Exactly

[@bholenath1421]

Yes. Jai Sanatana Dharma (Sanatani Hindus,Sikhs,Jains and Bhuddists )☀️🚩🕉️🔱📿🦅☸️🙏

[@monke6475]

true 🙏

[@azilius5302]

Actually I'm not an indian but I'll agree

[@adityanair3673]

Yes I can't say about other's but surely Hinduism Jainism is not a religion

[@tab0728]

I have always admired the Indian work ethic and their way of thinking - coming from a Pakistani. I kinda wish we would stop fighting each other and hate on Britain instead

[@harikishan5158]

Lmao

[@ishani.2882]

I AM AN INDIAN AND I WISH TOO INDPAK

[@sarthak8350]

Ya i also think this that Britain has done partition so why to fight with each other And together target Britain

[@AbhijeetKumar-vh1ff]

British stopped their barbaric work.but islam never.

[@harikishan5158]

@@AbhijeetKumar-vh1ff lmao fax

[@forgedude]

Everybody else : _.. God this , God that_ Hindu guy : _God is just means to an end_

[@oreosadventures4094]

LOL

[@ajithm3175]

@@oreosadventures4094 yes. Exactly

[@kantoumanjigang]

hindus accept science and cope with the present, modify their norms. its on them who understand... God won't do anything, he'll show u a path, the choice is yours. but can't let the 4000 year old tradition, culture and scriptures just die... 50% hindus are atheist but they aren't stoned for atheism here... peace always wanted never ever tried to go out of india and capture the world but.... leave it let it end... no one's less stubborn to listen others here, including me

[@thotpad]

The truth

[@kantoumanjigang]

@Yadav Aman bro i mean them who consider or are at least a lil proud to be a hindu are only about 50%

[@squelchtone]

This is the best thing the youtube algorithm gods have given me since Covid started.

[@aleenascaria6851]

the indian guy was the smartest; but he mentioned that indians never socially question their miserable plight because they believe they deserve it... i think that's where the problem lies... It hinders progress in a huge way. This mentality is what taken advantage of by religious groups be it any in india. On that note, the Swiss guy was just not that eloquent, the others were just fine.

[@youttt27]

One must remember that ,it was the mindset that came out of 200 years of colonial rule ( after our country was squeezed out for everything it could offer) and after many centuries of devastating Islamic invasion…Accepting that life is not perfect helps one avoid an attitude of entitlement and self pity.Nowhere to Hindu scriptures say that do not work hard to better oneself.

[@vasudhasharma5532]

I think he meant more like in Hinduism we think that our situation (successful or not) is a result of our actions. We are taught not to work with the result in mind, and just focus on making our karma good. It is arguable that good actions would translate in success in this lifetime or the next (good karma begets good karma)

[@aleenascaria6851]

@@vasudhasharma5532 no, he was justifying the fact that communism cannot spread in india because of the indian religion (and he hugely generalised it by saying hindu religion, but okay) as people will accept their fate despite the social factors against them (economically and socially) because it's what their religion says. They will never question their social positioning. It also points to the still, sadly, prevalant cast system which further solidifies one's social standing and reiterates that you are supposed to only be in this class and not succeed further as that's how we are conditioned. Now, he can justify it because he was in a position of privilege, coming from the upper cast. In fact, he is using these problematic tenets in the religion to say that since we have these values, we can oppose communism.

[@vasudhasharma5532]

@@aleenascaria6851 I was eluding to the fact where you said ‘it’s what their religion says’ …. The thing the religion actually says is that karma and result of karma and how we shouldn’t focus on the result. And currently I rarely see caste playing a role in society even in rural places where I am from. It is used max for arrange marriages, but even for that they usually now advocate for ‘caste no bar’, as in they don’t want the caste to be a deciding factor.

[@bhartityagi8183]

I think what he said is true. As now we all r facing environmental challenges. Whatever we r suffering is what we sown we deserve of our ignorance, our sense of superiority, our arrogance, our negligence. We believe that we hv controlled nature by building dams, cutting the heart of mountains to build road. Able to grow food in most adverse natural condition and more than ever. But after the period of time we come to know that our sense of greatness and achievements r just our foolishness. We r able to grow so much of food with the help of all pesticides nd fertilizer or those lab produced seeds. But know we see after 30yrs that they all r the causes of our poor health, our lands r becoming barren due to their use. Our rivers r turning toxic even the food we eat r not as healthy nd beneficial as we think it might be. And now we want to grow our like we use to grow 40yrs back we all want everything organic, no GMO seeds plant based food. Same with plastic when we made it we thought it make so many things easy now it is choking us. We want to get rid of our own creation one we believed is best. So we r responsible 4 our current situation. Hindu dharma is not just few thousands years old it is older than time. It survive bcuz it believe in change. But it also says everything is like a cycle form where we started we reach back there. It is all bcuz after reaching the peak we lose our visionary mindset and than our downfall started nd we reached where we began everything. It is a way of living. It is as much spiritual nd scientific at same time. In sanatan dharma trees and rivers r worshipped. For that we need to plant trees nd save rivers. We worship animals, birds ,even the smallest creature bcuz and for that we need them. Over the period of time sanatan dharma understood that everything has it's importance nd place in this life cycle. If we tried to change it or remove it . It completely disbalance the whole system. Let's take an ex. To get beautiful plush green grass lawns we started using different kinds of pesticides that eat grass or affect grass growth. But we forget that those insects might be eat by small lady bugs, butterflies which helps to grow beautiful meadows nd daffodils. But our single change made all these things died and in end we hv only green glasses but no plants nd flowers or butterflies or fire flies. In longer term we see how our action effects everything. We need to see long term outcomes of our action.

[@Narikeljinjira]

The gentleman from East Pakistan now Bangladesh was 19 years old at the time. He actually spoke 4 languages and one dialect, Urdu, Bangla, English, Malay and Chittagonian. He enjoyed an illustrious career in the tea industry working for a renowned British tea broker and company which he later became an owner of. He was a much loved and respected person in society, so amiable as comes across in this film. Amongst many accolades over a stellar career, he was also the youngest Honorary Consul at the time for France which he held distinguished until his passing. He received the French order Chevalier de la Legion d'Honneur in 2004 for his outstanding contribution in strengthening relations between Bangladesh and France.

[@deepb249]

He is. Coming from Dark skin hindu converts converted by slave dynasty of india and talking about Islam lol😂

[@Narikeljinjira]

@@deepb249 are you here simply to highlight your own ignorance or contribute some valid insight. I’m afraid it’s the former and not the latter. His forefathers were traders from Yemen, and his ancestry can be traced back many generations.

[@deepb249]

@@Narikeljinjira Bangladeshi are generally liars and thieves. They make up lies and invent things like his ancestors were from yemen as if being from yemen is sign of nobility and superiority. I can understand as bangladesh are blacks k skin hindu converts.

[@deepb249]

@@Narikeljinjira you are the ignorant one. Now he is from yemen as if that is some superior and noble people

[@Narikeljinjira]

@@deepb249 deepak bhattacharya249, if you understood what forefather meant then this would be a different conversation.

[@TheBorneomann]

Ram 12:00 to 12:35 have answered a nearly 2-decade old question for me. I was in India around 2003. Delhi to be exact. I was with a CEO of a big local pharmaceutical company. He is a PhD, educated both in India's top university and in the US of A. We were in a chauffeured and very comfortable Toyota Camry, air-conditioned and all, driving through the busy streets of Delhi. The temperature was around 40 celsius or there and thereabout, and I see many homeless people laying down by the roadside - Many without shelters. I asked - "Dr I wonder if some of these folks could actually die from this heat?" and he nonchalant says - "Yes". I asked if that is a concern for him and I was shocked to hear a rather dismissive - "not much because everyone has a place in the universe" I did not continue the discussion as I felt uncomfortable and I sensed he too felt like not talking about it but that statement lingered in my mind until this video...I think good old ol' Ram finally answers it.

[@surbhijha2486]

Actually that comes from concept of karma that what we have is result of our karm(deeds) in past life or timr and what we will have in future will be result of our present deeds

[@dollartreeshark6786]

And Ram is truthful too without any hesitation whether it shows his religion in bad light or not. Hallmark of a true Hindu is to continue to seek and question. Others act like they have the truth.

[@studyok6509]

Some fellows definitely gonna understand it in a wrong way just like many poor people or I say poor Hindus think that if they are poor it's because of their Karma (yes of course it is) and they CAN'T DO anything to rise above from this poverty.

[@studyok6509]

You with full determination fought poverty and now you are a established businessman, rich, literate it's also because of your Karma. You destroyed your poverty You destroyed your rich successful life You are destroying someone weather they deserve it or not Someone else is destroying you weather you deserve it or not Everything is because of your past lives Karma and this cycle has no ends, cycle of life and death has no ends Until and unless you become a seeker of truth.

[@quratbaloch4480]

That's exactly why they were invaded again and again and so easily

[@niki-sk6ce]

Hinduism is the very first religion and Ram showed that so smoothly...I-

[@madusy6943]

Very interesting and educative debate on religion. The conclusion i make from this discussion is that, Religion exist for the good of Humanity, if it becomes anything other than goodness, then it cease to be religion but something else.

[@Memeixar]

God exists

[@krishnashekhawat7185]

Wow loved your perspective of seeing things ... Your conclusion is quite impressive :)

[@RAIRADIO]

The definition of 'good' varies from religion to religion.

[@Bharatheeyudu88]

ఈ ప్రపంచంలో ప్రశాంతం గా బ్రతుకుతూ, ఇతరులను బ్రతకమని చెప్పేది ఒక్క సనాతన ధర్మం మాత్రమే. జై సనాతనం 🚩

[@Letseatwithoutguilt999]

So much tolerance, so much respect for each other & at the same time so much knowledge.. That's how people should debate ❤

[@viklondon3466]

The Swiss guy's argument was essentially, *But we are richer, so Christianity must be better* ahem.. recency bias..

[@adityanair3673]

😂

[@januaryembers8737]

LMAO🤣🤣

[@yuudesu]

Lol

[@Anshulhe]

Wonder why he doesn't mention many Christian sub Sahara african countries

[@debalinamukherjee7197]

by looting 😂😂

[@a.little.lifeish6295]

I think the Hindus are watching this Video more than any other religion. I just hope and pray that we not only support our religion virtually but also by inculcating the teachings of our religion in our daily lives.

[@roarerinfernate2326]

@Winter Bear well that has not happened until now and will not happen in coming times either . Rest assured.

[@harshilldaggupati]

@Winter Bear just like what Christianity and pislam are doing today

[@mikasaakm2454]

Exactly, all the comment complimenting the Indian guy are all written by Indians persons. So it’s normal that almost all the comment are supporting the Indian guy because all of them are written by Indians 🤷🏻‍♀️

[@harshilldaggupati]

@@mikasaakm2454 same for the hate comments. Written by anti indians like you

[@mikasaakm2454]

@@harshilldaggupati I am not anti Indian, I just spoke about a fact/reality 🤷🏻‍♀️ I have no hate for Indians unlike manny Indians who are hating Muslims..

[@vinodhkona9936]

Amazing Indian guy, proud of u sir...most comprehensive for sure

[@dontbeafraidimhere5421]

ನಮ್ಮ ಕರ್ನಾಟಕದಿಂದ ಯಾರಾದ್ರು ನೋಡ್ತಿದ್ದೀರ ✌️ ದಯವೇ ಧರ್ಮದ ಮೂಲವಯ್ಯ ❤️

[@omkarnaik4424]

❣️❣️hawdu

[@shreeveda]

Excellent discussion! I thank KZbin for getting this on my radar today. 😆👏👍

[@saifaljaaidi9280]

Ram was a display of intellectual superiorrity and philosophical understanding far beyond all of them. I don't think many people of his caliber remain in india now. The white boy was the relentless word salad cringe I've ever heard.

[@TheAshishasawa1]

You think.. Thanks from Indian😊

[@polarbear7]

IIT students of India might be disagree with you there best of the best got selected

[@wisedesi442]

There are many more like him in India , just need to look at right places.

[@rohitrd3234]

Every hindu house has a person like this

[@rajibdebnath9896]

India is full of intellectuals like Ram.

[@ananyaroy560]

Ram is so amazing... His reasoning, knowledge and confidence are awe inspiring!!!

[@sca8217]

Fun fact : The one religion which would let any other religion to be practiced without interference or judgement is Hinduism.

[@User-Kaathal]

One the reasons behind this that nobody can adapt Hinduism unless he or she was born as a Hindu. So, no preaching, no interference.

[@secretscipio]

@@User-Kaathal lol no. Anyone can be Hindu. We just don't like converting people on the tip of sword.

[@User-Kaathal]

@@secretscipio Okay. I didn't know that. And which caste and creed would they belong to? I thought there's no Hinduism without caste.

[@manikarnikak7835]

@@secretscipio sorry ,i can give only one like

[@Shiva_The_King_007]

@@User-Kaathal caste is job...... nothing more than that......

[@stanzinldazes]

I wish the speaker from Thailand to be good bcoz Buddhism is much more to explain right at the introduction. And it is not a religion, it's a philosophy. I loved the speaker from india though. Really good.

[@vikramssctelugu6148]

felt same ... btw i am a hindu ... want to say one thing buddism is not the philosophy it is a way (scientific) to the ultimate truth

[@raj-hf4wb]

Being an indian and hindu.....I need not her to understand the intricacies of Buddhism !!

[@harshilldaggupati]

Hinduism, Buddhism, Jainism, Taoism, and some such religions are not religions, it's wrong to call it a religion, these are called Dharma, or the way of life. Religion are what is Christianity, etc is

[@criscrosxxx]

@Winter Bear she was less fluent with english not "less edcuated" in buddhism

[@harshilldaggupati]

@Supernoone dude, Hinduism, Buddhism, Sikhism aren't religion. They're more of a philosophy

[@nagachaithanya4926]

Wow!! Whoever organized these debates must definitely bring them back. These are the kind of debates that we need and let the youth speak out their minds of the problems that the world is facing today.

[@gopinath_ravi]

//Hinduism which i suppose include all religions, all religions are just the stages of hinduism. // Wowww… Very cleverly articulated:)

[@RAIRADIO]

That's what it really is.

[@ryanmarlin2974]

Uhh, no. Stop the cap, Hinduism is Hinduism

[@quasiosa]

Mark Twain once said- "there's no thought in the world that hasn't been thought of considered under Hinduism...". Sounds like your point also similar.

[@goof.7874]

@@ryanmarlin2974 Hinduism contains Buddhism , Sikhism , Jainism too and has heavily influenced Taoism also.

[@ryanmarlin2974]

@@goof.7874 no, Hinduism contains none of those. It just contains Hinduism

[@rds8026]

If Hinduism and Budhism were only religions in the world , I bet they never fight.

[@avinashs13]

@@apatriot4400 Eh Ashok was a Buddhist who massacred lakhs of Hindus in Kalinga.

[@kallurimedhanand8771]

@@avinashs13 hahaha nice one But with my little knowledge, it can't be said that the conquest of Kalinga (or others, using Kalinga because the myth of him regretting the Kalinga war is out at large) was religiously motivated. Feel free to correct me...

[@avinashs13]

@@kallurimedhanand8771 Nothing to correct here my friend. While I can't say for sure, I also don't think the conquest nor the massacre was religiously motivated. Simply pointing out to OP that Buddhists and Hindus were completely capable of causing carnage. I do, however, suspect that what Ashoka's Buddhist followers did to the Jain and Ajivikas during his ascension MIGHT have been religiously motivated.

[@kallurimedhanand8771]

@@avinashs13 hmm that's an interesting take... I can't talk about it either, because of my limited knowledge of the "things" happened to the jains by Buddhists

[@opai1821]

oh boy you are very wrong on this .

[@faridahmed5566]

That guy Rasul memorized half of the quran but still he has a secular mind.We really need this kind of people in Bangladesh.

[@salma-nw9fe]

Yeah I really appreciate Bangladeshi people are secular love from india 💕

[@BJha-bc2li]

@@salma-nw9fe Are you serious ? Did you forget what happened to that Bangladeshi cricketer who wished us on Durga Pujo ?

[@faridahmed5566]

@@BJha-bc2li Don't get me started.Both countries have as**oles.

[@BJha-bc2li]

@@faridahmed5566 No! We don't have that kindda people who behave like that when Dhoni Ji or sachin Ji wish Muslims on Eid. Better think twice before Commenting.

[@faridahmed5566]

​@@BJha-bc2li Bruh I know what I'm saying.And I know how present India spreading hate against Muslims and how you guys are treating them.In my country no one kills anyone for eating pork.An old muslim guy got beaten and was shaved off beards some days ago at Delhi Jame mosque and there was an app for sales of established muslim ladies.You guys put your hindu flag on a minar of mosque.Our people just bark on social medias,but your peoples make it practical.

[@ro_khumbeu12]

From Mizoram, India.

[@apoorvasingh5475]

I am ashamed of not being able to speak like ram ❤️

[@ami2000vi]

So this happened only 7 years after our Independence...... 🇮🇳 Ram 👏🏻👏🏻

[@sydneydiaries8470]

Hats off Ram,very intellectual man🙏 Who is he? Is ram still alive?

[@आयुष_पराशर]

Sorry No...My uncle had met him once in a confrence.

[@Sarmistha9]

@@आयुष_पराशर would love to know what he was and what did he eventually become. Such a intellectual and intelligent young man at such young age!

[@dev_peace_soul]

@@आयुष_पराशर 😭😭😭😢

[@user-ce4ru1vs2i]

@@आयुष_पराशर what was his profession when he was young?

[@jyothikoduru]

True.. would like to know what he did

[@pranjalcr7]

Props to the pakistani (now Bangladeshi) guy for being blatantly honest and accept the downsides of his own countries, you wouldn't see anyone doing it nowadays!

[@mercedesbenz3751]

Judaism came and settled in India. Buddhism emerged and settled in India. Jainism emerged and settled in India Zoroastrianism came and settled in India Christianity came and settled in India. Islam invaded and settled in India. .. It was possible only under the tolerance of Hinduism.

[@yashvi2048]

Yes 😊

[@tashinamgyal5158]

buddhism was nearly wiped from india.

[@mercedesbenz3751]

@@tashinamgyal5158 its never became dominant in India. Only A handful of the people followed buddhism as a separate religion from Hinduism. Many of the concepts and practices of buddhism were not new for the hindus.

[@quasiosa]

@@mercedesbenz3751 This is a good point, also islamic invaders wiped out a lot of Buddhism otherwise Afghanistan and Bangladesh would have had been Buddhist. And Bangladesh would have had been India's integral part. I hope

[@one-eyedgaming6767]

​@@mercedesbenz3751if there was a Hinduism

[@culture04dc]

Ram was amazing so smart. Smarter than any Filipino but because there is no Filipino there isn't much views because Indians don't need this to feel good about themselves.

[@maitahom9958]

@Harsh _ wtf? when did Filipinos start speaking Sanskrit.....stop disgracing our culture

[@joselitofilipino9618]

@Harsh _ “India was looted way more than philippines still philippines have nothing of their own” what??? Doesn’t matter if you were looted more than us, we still suffered greatly. Colonization & abuses by the Spanish, Genocide & betrayed by the United States, harsh Japanese occupation, and a bunch of others. Its like saying you were punched more than I was and somehow that removes the fact that I was also punched. The Philippines have something of their own, it’s peoples, languages & traditions. Filipinos have contributed to the world, through inventing games like yo-yo to the medical area like the medical incubator. Yes India invented lots of things more than my country, but that doesn’t remove the fact that we have contributed to many things. “Their language has English script, name based on Spanish ruler and culture by Christians.” That shows the fact that we’ve been colonized for centuries, adopting a foreign script doesn’t make a language a lesser valued one. The name Philippines isn’t changed, so what? What’s the point of changing it’s name? So that the government spends more money into changing names of establishments and a bunch of other things with the name Philippines on it instead of focusing on poverty and more important matters in our country? So what if we are majority Christian? What does that even imply? Christianity isn’t just for the white folks or the western folks, Christianity was present in North Africa, the Middle East (Before Islam arrives, it still is present there), Christian communities in the Steppes/Central Asia, and into parts of western China. Christianity has always been a religion of Europeans, Jews, Nubians, Ethiopians, North Africans, Assyrians, Armenians, Georgians, etc... and has since expanded from those previous historical areas where Christianity was rampant.

[@joselitofilipino9618]

@Harsh _ Was* influenced by the Indian language. That has changed due to colonization by the Spanish for 3 centuries. We were not just Hindus back then, we were animists AND Hindus AND Buddhists. We had our pantheons that were inspired by Hinduism and pantheons that weren’t. This depended on the ethnic groups, tribes & kingdoms. Also we didn’t speak ONLY Sanskrit either, we spoke old Malay, and bunch of other languages in the Philippine Archipelagos. “We retained our original culture” and that also has changed. Cultures of peoples from different countries have either changed a little bit or drastically. Even if you’ve retained it, it still has changed even by a little bit. Majority of Filipinos do not have their original cultures & practices, some tribes still do but not majority. To say the Philippines didn’t have any is stupidly ignorant. You can see traces of the original culture in the present culture that majority of Filipinos have. We still have indigenous ancient scripts still alive and some being revived after the Latin script became more popular for the natives back then. We still have celebrations that our ancestors practiced (though a little different).

[@dj-ux1jr]

Oh. This isn't about feeling good his concepts are clear and that's what attracts people. I am sorry i really don't know about Phillipines the socio economic or culture things but i know India and really it's something how it turned out to be even after it was attacked by Portugese moughal and British

[@terrancewatson7739]

Christian Boy, should of been asked at that time, why blacks not been treated they way he would like to treated

[@dollartreeshark6786]

Apart from embarrassing him, it does not help do any good. The discrimination is basically human impairment, and we need to evolve to remove this human impairment to look beyond color of skin, shape, religion, culture and language.

[@prajwalbharambe343]

White people were very racist at that time. Interracial marrige wasn't even legal!

[@chitranjankumarkushwaha4259]

Yes funfact American blacks are christian also

[@shubhanginath4049]

"God is a means" what a statement by Ram ji ❤️

[@JessieR2023]

India has a lot of culture, tradition, and religion that spread worldwide. India could be a country with lot of influences, but have failed due to other problems they have.

[@Progress234]

I agree

[@quiet7632]

The problems that were put on us by the Europeans and Islamics, you mean? We were among the world leaders for millennia until certain groups (euros and muslims) decided that conquest was better than advancement. We are still trying to recover from that. But, ours is an eternal philosophy, so we can handle mistakes from younger children like the Muslims and Christians.

[@qurratulainzehra8760]

@@quiet7632 and before the europeans and islamics, you were such a thriving nation? you had 'untouchability' being practised in your country for centuries...you didn't even share a meal with us Muslims and the Dalits....

[@AbhaySinghChauhan]

@@qurratulainzehra8760 Untouchability was because of social division not religious division, and social division is present in nearly each and every society in today's world as well....

[@Jai_Badri_vishal52]

​@@qurratulainzehra8760 the concept of untouchability is spread by Britishers amongst the Hindus so that they can not be United and fight with each other, and that's the best way for Britishers to rule over India

[@sheshankutty8552]

That Christian guy is sooooo wrong. He said that the country which is very religions will NOT go to war... hahahaha I laughed my ass off...

[@morningsun8387]

Ahem ahem Afghanistan..

[@ellagardener538]

Ironic coming from Hindus that literally voted for a pro rape terrorist organisation the RSS.

[@daverani4944]

Brother only Jesus Christ is the way to heaven...

[@dhruvtyagi7351]

@@ellagardener538 RSS is not even a party...lol

[@6tbrowny430]

@@ellagardener538 haha...u call RSS a hindu terrorist organization.....then go live in Afghanistan

[@AnuradhaSingh14192907]

I like how the Muslim guy brought up equality in Mosques but women are not allowed to pray alongside men in Mosques. So equality only for men?

[@ahmirasad007]

When is equality measured side by side? Men and women are separated, what if someone stared at your family? and focus is God it is not looking at other people or being distracted.

[@ahmirasad007]

Men and women are equal but are not the same i.e. biological

[@ytv31]

Women can pray in any mosque, don't spread lies if you are not knowledgable enough.

[@AAA-vf2qr]

Women also pray in mosques together, but if men and women were to pray side by side and in front/behind each other, don't you think they'd get distracted by each other? Its a known fact that men especially tend to look at women and admire their bodies, so wouldn't having them pray together lead to distractions?

[@ahmirasad007]

@@AAA-vf2qr we follow the way of the Prophet Muhammad peace and blessings be upon him at that time men and women prayed in the same place, and prayed separately. In a household we can pray with each other.

[@jaykay6249]

The woman interviewing seems a bit ignorant . At 16:48 she asks the representative from Bangladesh about the middle east . While Islam is a common feature in both geographies , it would be absurd to expect a Bangladeshi to know the intricacies of the political sphere in the Middle East which is nowhere near it.

[@cp12298]

Bro at that time there was no known name *Bangladesh* He was from East Pakistan

[@RAIRADIO]

East Pakistan was the result, a spin off, of the Khilafati movement from Turkey. So the linkage is there.

[@SakshiSingh-ky8ev]

Ram would be so proud to see many religions living peacefully in India today😊... Not as hindus, muslims, christians, buddhists, sikhs etc but as Indians🇮🇳🇮🇳

[@amalakasthurirangan2382]

4:56 Christian: son of God came to earth to bring salvation Hindu: Here God himself arived💪

[@shyam4971-j3f]

That was frikin lethal

[@ellagardener538]

That makes no sense.

[@dhruvtyagi7351]

@@ellagardener538 That does make sense...just need to understand it

[@malaniyadmello2225]

When we christian say Son of God came to earth, it also means that God himself took a form of human and came on earth as Son of God. This is a fundamental principle of Holy Trinity.

[@dhruvtyagi7351]

@@malaniyadmello2225 Same concept with "Avatar" in hinduism..

[@BK-rj7eg]

Christian: You are born sinner. Hindu: You are born Divine.

[@goodguyyt]

🙏

[@januaryembers8737]

😊

[@mj-ck4br]

Dude 1/2 sentences are as toxic as 1/2 knowledge. The context is different

[@goofyguy6954]

@Hinata hyuga Lol you mean if I go and kill someone still I didn't commit any sin

[@goofyguy6954]

@Hinata hyuga Why God die for our sins. Just because we can go heaven and enjoy our after life.

[@sunnysleep7850]

This is fantastic.. People had manners and decorm in those days. All highly intelligent and well read.

[@deekshavissapragada2592]

Being a Hindi, Indian, I love this video. The counter-arguments of Ram, the Indian representing Hinduism are exquisite. There is always that myth that Indians don't speak good English but he suggests otherwise... This is my most favorite video of all time on KZbin.

[@RajKumarSingh-ff5yh]

Raam is very Eloquent and Prompt in Replying. Rasool is also good and is a bit secular it seems bcz at one time he agreed upon forming a new religion by joining imp things from each religion, which is something a Devout Muslim will never agree upon bcz that man thinks there can be no alteration to revealed word of God and Qur'aan is Last and Final word of God. Mathina seemed less fluent in English but She was not bad as well. The Christian guy Seemed a bit Arrogant in beginning but later he also participated decently. So, Overall this was an Amazing Discussion and I think today u can't really have such a Peaceful discussion so easily but on the Contrary they did it in 1954 that's really Amazing !

[@RAIRADIO]

That's not secular. That's just I-slam 2.0 with the same aim of monotheism and monopoly.

[@100myasharma5]

Feeling emotional as they all would have turned really old by now but there is no option . Wish all would have led a good life 💕

[@animeoniichan117]

All of them are dead.

[@montukarmakar9988]

Ram is just on the next level!!

[@themirror81]

I admire the respect they have for each other's beliefs and viewpoints

[@vishweshwarabs3898]

Without bias I can say the Indian student emerges as the most logical and very fluent in the debate

[@mikasaakm2454]

It’s normal, you are Indian, so it’s normal that you prefer the Indian guy

[@Pythonerate]

@@mikasaakm2454 nah hes right and im american without any indian heritage whatsoever lmao all the indians in these debates make an eloquent and astonishing appeal to truth and logic

[@queenbiatch4310]

I absolutely love these talks. As always, India is beautifully represented with thoughtful speakers, but the other debaters are also pretty good. I only wish there were more constructive debates like these in today's day and time. I would love to listen, and even take part in these.

[@ambercsk1025]

These teenagers were far more intelligent and articulate than stupid politicians today.. this video should be shown to all news channels to learn how to conduct debates...

[@theoriginalrudeboy2916]

Hinndus in India need to listen to what ram is saying about hinduism .

[@AdityaSingh-ti8ct]

Ram has listened to hindus in india thats why he was able to represent hinduism

[@theoriginalrudeboy2916]

@@AdityaSingh-ti8ct It's a good thing that this video is more than 50 years old and Ram didn't hear your corrupted version of Hindutva .

[@divyanidutt958]

Damn. Proof enough you know nothing about Hinduism and Hindutva 😅

[@rrraynoorrr]

@@AdityaSingh-ti8ct Think you're conflating hinduism with hindutva. One is good and enlightening while the other is about as evil and selfish as the rest of the major religions.

[@theoriginalrudeboy2916]

@Dattatreya Jana The world saw the unity of hindutva groups in labour crisis, corona crisis . Don't mix hinduism with hindutva .Shut your trap .

[@ritchybinoo9150]

Wonder where they are and what these teenagers (at the time) are up to in 2021!? they ought to be in their mid eighties by now! As in this clip, they've had debates on topics such as religion, communism, colonialism, social discrimination etc. It's no stretch to say that a period of over 80 years is sure to have transformed everyone of them in unexpected ways to say the least!

[@darshanodedara296]

Pakistani guy after every two sentence "Pakistan is very religious country.."

[@darshanodedara296]

@Black Shadow You should watch video again, or maybe visit an ENT clinic..

[@faiqsabih3215]

Due to early links with atheism, socialism let alone communism never thrived in Pakistan due to religion, bangladesh where he was from had slightly more success with socialism but that was only after a bloody independence. Religion has been extremely important in most of Pakistan's history, and to this day far more people are turning religious then they are turning atheist in Pakistan. So he was pretty spot on when he said that there was no threat of communism for another 50 years because of the level of religiousness in Pakistan. It's not just the Muslims, Hindus and christians are very religious in Pakistan, oftentimes more so. His point was that you cannot comprehend the level of religiousness in Pakistan.

[@marjoriesabanal7742]

Indian guy so good

[@biplovkarna4219]

Rasool in whole debate: **Our people are very religious minded**

[@sam81345]

Yeah everyone noticed.

[@faiqsabih3215]

Due to early links with atheism, socialism let alone communism never thrived in Pakistan due to religion, bangladesh where he was from had slightly more success with socialism but that was only after a bloody independence. Religion has been extremely important in most of Pakistan's history, and to this day far more people are turning religious then they are turning atheist in Pakistan. So he was pretty spot on when he said that there was no threat of communism for another 50 years because of the level of religiousness in Pakistan. It's not just the Muslims, Hindus and christians are very religious in Pakistan, oftentimes more so.

[@Kikiouma]

❤❤❤❤❤❤ I like the way this teenager explains islam better than lots of grown ass tv hosts

[@donthidefrommeh5374]

This was the time where people didn't fight against religion but debated while maintaining the peace.

[@ciao_abhi]

The indian guest is just so sharp and rationalizes very well. I'm not indian and not religious so I say that with no bias.

[@saneetkaul9974]

30% literacy in 1956 and now nearly 70% as in 2021, we came a long way. And we have long way to go

[@And_Cuts]

That's a very slow progress

[@gopinath_ravi]

@@And_Cuts yeah it is. With communism shadowing us, we were slow. It will be good growth from here on :)

[@GaganSingh-nx2yv]

@@gopinath_ravi what?!

[@GaganSingh-nx2yv]

@@gopinath_ravi Bhagat Singh was a communist and well educated.

[@zenith808]

What's the point in doubling literacy when religious intolerance is slowly taking us backwards? The Hindu/Muslim divide has only deepened. So what use education?

[@yashny]

Their names : New York Herald Tribune; WOR-TV; Helen Hiett Waller; Mattanee Mojdara, Thailand; Rasul Nizum, Pakistan; Philippe De Vargas, Switzerland; Vangala Jaya Ram, India; Victor Cavaness

[@ashwinsingh3003]

I am stunned to see the level of education of these legend's

[@nikhita977]

I think we all believe in religion that we follow because we were born in it .. Not many are ready to question their belief system ...

[@RAIRADIO]

When you are a Hindu, there is very little belief involved, because you have to be pluralistic and make room for atheism.

[@priyamangrulkar3309]

I personally love the way RAM explained about hinduism ❤️ he is the best speker ❤️🔥

[@bholenath1421]

@Salahuddin Ayubi lol. Melt away in ur own Pool of lies and Negativity.

[@adityanair3673]

@Salahuddin Ayubi Do you get any sort of Readymade comments from ur madarsa to copy and paste it to Hindu's . Then wait a min I have one perfect reply I hope you get offended Aisha was 9 Year old and Mohamad 53 When they had 🤧 Proof :- sahil al Bukhari volume 5 book 58 number 234 . This one I cannot write her because KZbin will not allow it and will automatically remove my comment soo you can just Google it :- 1. Sahih Al Bukhari 232 . 2. Sahih Muslim number 699 . 3. Suhan ibn Majah , Number 537 . 4 . Sahih Al Bukhari 299,300,301

[@adityanair3673]

Do you get any sort of Readymade comments from ur madarsa to copy and paste it to Hindu's . Then wait a min I have one perfect reply I hope you get offended Aisha was 9 Year old and Mohamad 53 When they had 🤧 Proof :- sahil al Bukhari volume 5 book 58 number 234 . This one I cannot write here because KZbin will not allow it and will automatically remove my comment soo you can just Google it :- 1. Sahih Al Bukhari 232 . 2. Sahih Muslim number 699 . 3. Suhan ibn Majah , Number 537 . 4 . Sahih Al Bukhari 299,300,301

[@adityanair3673]

@Salahuddin Ayubi Wow you have started preaching your own Islam the Whole world Greatest Islamic scholars agree and defend Aisha's age to be 6 when she married and 9 when he 🤧 her but If you still want To come with a new Islam were Aisha age will be 19 then Change the books + start preachings ur Islam and then when your followers will be in Millions like Zakir Naik I will accept ur way of Islam were I Aisha was not 9 but 19 .

[@adityanair3673]

@Salahuddin Ayubi Yes NAIR from Kerala . Any problem with it Mutte ☺️

[@mosamaster]

Indian boy is the brightest in that room. no doubt.

[@mamtabiswas1825]

The thing which bugs me the most about today's world is that in India grown adult men can't have organised debates and discussions without cussing, disrespecting , or mocking someone they disagree with. Like stop already, speak when its your turn (like they teach in kindergarden, remember?) and for god's sake dont let your emotions get the better of you.

[@asdfghjkl33998able]

Exactly! Debates are just group discussion where you present your point of view while listening and understanding what others have to say. If you Don't wanna listen and learn what value they have to add in discussion then look in the mirror and keep yapping.

[@itr8247]

You are looking at the wrong debates then...

[@mamtabiswas1825]

@@itr8247 any recommendations?

[@snailmailmagic]

I so agree. There is so much intolerance and abuse. Even in this youtube comments you can see people cussing other religion or being pompous instead of appreciating the debaters.

[@LOLfestival]

@@mamtabiswas1825 Avoid Arnab Goswami and his tamasha. Republic is good though... A Nationalist channel.

[@sraghu73]

Wow.... Amazing discussion... So nice.. And brilliant...