ASCAP VS BMI | WHAT NO ONE WILL TELL YOU ABOUT ASCAP ROYALTIES & BMI MUSIC ROYALTIES 2019

[@tyniacoats]

WHAT IS SOMETHING YOU LEARNED THAT YOU NEVER KNEW ABOUT BMI OR ASCAP? Let me know! Also, if you have further questions about PROs, this is the space to ask! :)

[@atuvelman]

Great video! I didn't know they collect from so many countries. I do have one question. In registering works with BMI, a sound recording is not required. How is BMI able to track down royalties of a song without a sound recording?

[@tyniacoats]

@@atuvelman Yes! They actually collect from more countries than 83/93, because some foreign PROs represent multiple countries! That's a great question! BMI tracks songs by title & artist, so it is very very very important how you register your songs with them! If your song is on the radio or a streaming platform, they report the songs used to BMI/ASCAP. & since they actually have the sound recording, BMI/ASCAP use 3rd party companies to match the fingerprint for plays/streams.

[@jenaeadams8067]

Tynia Coats BMI pays more royalties

[@tyniacoats]

@@jenaeadams8067 Yes! I think that is super important to know!! Are you a member of a PRO??

[@jenaeadams8067]

I just signed up with BMI.

[@crookedstilo]

I was with ASCAP for a couple of years and never received a dime. As soon as I switched over to BMI, I started seeing my royalty payments. Good video. Gems.

[@granzglobewalker]

How significant were the payments - a few dollars, 100, 1000? Thanks!

[@Qrayon]

@@granzglobewalker I received about $24 or maybe $45 from BMI. I never signed up with ASCAP, but BMI has a better way of finding out which songs were played. That's how I know that if I had been with ASCAP, I never would have received a penny of that money.

[@drearmstrong7767]

I got music I’m getting ready to push what’s the correct way to do a BMI

[@ButterflyLullabyLtd]

Thanks for sharing. So glad you are getting paid. That is wonderful.

[@BellaRose_Music]

Hi , i have a question i write all my songs myself (nobody helpes me with writing the lyrics of my song) so i am a songwriter... but there is one BUT i use beats with a license. so i have rights to use the beat but i dont OWN the beat (instrumental) do i also need to register as a publisher or will that bring me into trouble with the beatmaker? Do you know this?

[@BeeGreatful]

Thank you for this. I left ASCAP never made a penny. Now at BMI. Never knew the difference after 25 years in the business!

[@bryanslepicka3541]

It's nice to know that BMI is governed by broadcasters and ASCAP is governed by the labels. Now I know who I'm really dealing with!

[@tyniacoats]

Yes, I am glad you find that info helpful. Someone negatively commented about me sharing that information & I could not understand why they wouldn't want to know that info or find it useful.

[@mixahnation1403]

I am with bmi

[@melissiawilliams2536]

@@mixahnation1403 Me too

[@chrisdunnettmusic]

That is just not true...ASCAP is governed by SONGWRITERS and Publishers. Furthermore, it is a board that members VOTE on so members are actually in charge of who runs ASCAP unlike BMI. She in fact did say ASCAP is run my Songwriters and Publishers but she was very misleading in their association with labels. EVERYONE in the Music industry has, or at least tries to have an association with labels...that's who you do business with.

[@chrisdunnettmusic]

@@FiatFunnyYourselfIs I don't disagree with that but there is always a lot of cross pollination in the music industry. Song writers end up working for publishers publishers work for record labels former record label people go into management and so on. I think unfortunately everybody's checks had been getting smaller

[@thedvguy]

I was with BMI back in the 80s. I was told after I signed up that I should have signed up with ASCAP. So I was leaning toward ASCAP when thinking of signing up again, but this video changed my mind. I'll be signing up with BMI again. I am writing again, but I also want to start my own label and music publishing company. I want total control. So I will sign up as a writer, and then sign up my publishing company as well. I kind of like the idea of getting those royalties staggered, as I would with ASCAP, but that's not a big deal. I really appreciate the time and effort you put into this video. A lot of great information.

[@AndreasTabuMuntu]

Back in 2013 I did my due diligence research on both, ended up choosing BMI, joined them in 2014, and been with them since. Back then their contract stated that once you joined them, you'll exclusively be stuck with them for your first two years. And after two years you're free to leave them whenever you want. Don't know if that still applies to this day.

[@ladydignity]

Hmmm....

[@fendiibrwn2162]

It still have that

[@theoriginaljblaze]

15 PRO's & Climbing!!! ILuVMusic!

[@abayesho101]

I'm an award winning Songwriter based in Nigeria. I've been wanting to join a PRO in the United States of America and this is quite helpful. Thank you so much for this beautiful piece.

[@LaNuevaVoz001]

Chile you broke it down!!!!! BMI Here I come!!!!

[@Rarelementz]

Whoever hired you at BMI knew what they were doing, I am joining BMI just because of you..Great Vibez

[@grandphenally3928]

Smart woman drive me crazy, bro 👏🏿👏🏿👏🏿

[@cheshire9384]

Had to pause this video just to give you props. A massive density of knowledge shared in a super understandable format. You rock!

[@bgimusic]

forreal 🙌🤍

[@Swahiliangift70x7]

your comparative analysis of BMI Vs ACSAP was extremely thorough. I'm new to this and wanted to get as much information as possible and you seem to have opened my eyes to considering the pro's and con's of joining either of these companies, before making a commitment to one. Awesome job!

[@StellatheArtiste]

The number one takeaway I had from this was the Article of Agreement from ASCAP and how they can change it which is something I never knew. That's definitely something I will take into consideration. Thanks so much for this information

[@tyniacoats]

You are welcome!

[@goodvibezinChrist]

I agree! I don’t do wavering agreements. I serve the faithful and true Witness.

[@jamieshorter7093]

This was cool....I've never heard anybody, in all of my 40 years, explain these PROs like you did ....Good job young lady.....

[@JayRandomOfficial]

Been with BMI since 2015 as a songwriter, nothing will change

[@SHABRIAENTERTAINMENT]

Have you ever seen a royalty statement from them ?

[@CEVANS5613]

I did not know that BMI and ASCAP were the largest PROs in the world! Thank you for that information.

[@Denver_Risley]

What I learned: There is sooooooooo much money involved; staggering! ASCAP profits more from artists than BMI. Finally, I learned it doesn't cost nearly as much to join as I thought.

[@thestuffoflegenddanielloer7883]

The ASCAP Articles of Agreement is a loophole to manipulate contract terms that i am VERY glad you pointed out. BMI is the Way.

[@KurtRockMusic]

Thank you for uploading this video. I’m now more reassured I picked the right PRO after this video. BMI always seemed like a superior PRO and I still stand by that

[@geishaloca1149]

Hello Miss!! Oh my gosh thank you SO MUCH for this video!!!! Baby Singer/Songwriter/ Rapper here 🙋🏾‍♀️ I was so confused about the differences between the 2 companies but I feel much more confident with my journey now. *SUBSCRIBED*

[@johnnytsunami7150]

WOW! Learned so much about the history of BMI and ASCAP. I think i've made my decision for my PRO. Thank you Tynia!

[@tyniacoats]

Yes, the history is very interesting! Both companies are really good at what they do though & ASCAP has come a long way from how they did business when they first started. Either company is a good choice, it will just all depend on the treatment you get once you're a member! & you are welcome! :)

[@mr.bond2023]

That history lesson is the reason I’m gonna sign with BMI. Thanks for the history

[@spiceentertainment1999]

Very helpful! I feel like BMI is the best choice staring off for me an upcoming artist trying to remain independent but just a need a little bit of inside “game” But NOT from the label🙅🏽‍♂️🙅🏽‍♂️

[@sergiojuarez584]

I feel that let's get it

[@Musician-r5q]

I'm a Member of ASCAP as both Writer and Publisher since 2017.

[@alexandrapelayo1111]

Thank you so much for sharing this. I was seriously about to switch from BMI to ASCAP without really knowing much just going based of some people being with ASCAP. I've had my account with BMI for many years and just last week I had a new Group release one of my compositions in their Debut Album. and was debating whether to register my work with bmi or wait to cancel. But I obviously ran into your video for a reason. Thank you so much!! I can't wait to see more educational videos from you. As composer we need more information and backup! THANK YOUUUU I SUBSCRIBED ☺️

[@DCJNewsMedia]

You be a round the way girl. You straight up cool lady. Ty for dropping the bomb on the truth. Be who you be Sister 😊

[@ROZEGANGTV]

This was literally the best break down & information 🙌that we as independent artist needed to know & I feel so good to understand what he said that it inspired me to continue as an independent artist..thank you my friend you are the best..

[@mfcc]

Very interesting info!

[@maxmooseband5743]

This is from ASCAP's site: "When ASCAP distributes royalties for a performance of your music, 50% goes to the writer(s), and 50% to the publisher(s). If you want to access your publisher’s share, you will need to set up a publishing company with ASCAP." So, if you don't have an external publisher, it's meaningless to say you can join as just a writer, is it not? Are you saying that BMI will allow you to get your publisher's share through your writer account?

[@MsUnity2011]

Thank you for sharing the historical fact about ASCAP. I used to wonder as a child why I only heard certain music on the radio only.

[@tarutran6391]

do you mind making a video about publishing admins like tunecore publishing or songtrust, if they’re worth signing up for and if they are other ways to collect all your royalties, thanks for the vids so far :)

[@tyniacoats]

I don't mind at all! I've actually been getting a lot of questions related to that, so I think I'll make that my topic for my video in 2 weeks. I already have this upcoming Monday's done though. & you are welcome! :)

[@alexbroking9252]

@@tyniacoats I'm thinking bistro kid but let me know if its up im watching all your videos now, :)

[@FlamesAt1000ft]

Finally!!!...some good facts & info clarification!!...Good on you nice lady!!..👍🏾😏🎙🎶🎸✨

[@MrTrumpets]

Thank you so much for making this video. I'd made the decision to sign up with BMI, but wanted to do a little more research. This helped me feel more confident in my decision! :) The music world so do confusing to break into, thank you for making this aspect a bit simpler! :)

[@Maniacdaloc]

Tina Coats Did not in know about BMI paying out more than ASCAP? Very interesting info on the early days of radio and ASCAP, "Hating!"

[@CHRISPYMUSIC_]

This was super informative and helpful, thank you for sharing this knowledge with everyone. As a new music producer, this video was so valuable, thanks!

[@TrueFallacy]

I never knew that ASCAP was run by artists, and BMI was run by broadcasters, thank you!

[@uzeethebovvaking]

I had to subscribe, thanks for the in-depth information. I didn't know BMI had agreements with 93 foreign PRO'S. Thanks!!

[@tyniacoats]

Of course, I'm happy it is helpful to you!! & yeah their foreign agreements actually cover 150+ countries! Are you a producer, songwriter, rapper, or singer? Or all lol

[@uzeethebovvaking]

@@tyniacoats I'm a rapper, also run a Digital label

[@tyniacoats]

@@uzeethebovvaking That's awesome! Do you have multiple artists under your digital label??

[@uzeethebovvaking]

@@tyniacoats Not yet! Just me for now and 2 producers

[@melindagreenidge]

@@tyniacoats could you explain why would BMI request a member from a foreign PRO who they are affiliated with, to leave that PRO to join with them or they would request a split membership?

[@brookthorn4211]

Great A/B! I learned a few things I didn’t know but def should have at this point. My takeaway is that, as a middle man, they both take a bigger cut than they should. This is a time where middleman positions in business are being eliminated because we all know where to find each other now. If my content spins, is documented by data, then why do i still need a big building full of reps to take me to lunch, to connect my phone to my cash? A smaller building with less employees, less fun trip planners and more computers can do the job for….. who knows, 40% less? Everyone’s Napster Moment arrives eventually.

[@ugcbyirie]

I've been searching for helpful information regarding this subject. I was so confused and kinda discourage at the beginning. So glad I found you. Thank you for your help. Lovely outfit btw!

[@tyniacoats]

Aww, you are sweet, thank you!! Don't be discouraged, just keep on putting in the work to move forward! :)

[@JBSDIVERSIFIED]

Please come back home our beautiful and knowledgeable baby. We miss you. Thanks for all of the great information you've given us.

[@marcieandmarksinger347]

Wow! Your energy is awesome and your ability to make everything you say count and always informative is refreshing. Not a wasted minute. THANK YOU!

[@valeriefullilove1031]

I never knew the difference or why one would be better than the other for me. I am with BMI...Now I am happy I have done so - Thanks!

[@weslaycock466]

Great video love it! I had an extra question if I may? You mention that to sign up as a publisher with BMI the cost is $150-$250. At 2:44 you mention you can still collect publishing royalties through your writer account? My question is, whats the point of signing up and handing over extra money for a publishing account if you already can collect your publishing royalties through your free writer account?

[@tyniacoats]

That's a good question! I am adding it to my list for my next video. I'll explain it more in depth then, but a publisher account is good for 1) if you want to be the publisher for other songwriters 2) if you enter into a publishing administration deal or a co-publishing deal (if you are generating a good amount of $$, then a publishing admin can see that through your publisher account & then make a deal with you to manage all of the administrative work)

[@weslaycock466]

@@tyniacoats Thank you for the reply. It really cleared things up for me. Look forward to your future uploads

[@northcoastunit6335]

Can you sign up as a writer account to start with, then change to a publishing account or add a publishing account later on if you have a need for it?

[@KyleOBrienmusic]

@@tyniacoats did you go into this further in another video? I couldn't find it, but am still wondering what the added bonus of a BMI publisher deal would be if I'm already publisher as a writer. Thanks!

[@sontwisted]

@@northcoastunit6335 yes

[@dinosimon4000]

Also, I had NO IDEA that ascap was connected to labels that’s the whole thing I want to avoid thank you so much

[@Einnor084]

Dino Simon U can sign-up azz an idependent artist or label & still have ur royaltiez collected.

[@tyniacoats]

Yeah the major publisher are actually who sit on their board, but the major publishers are universal & sony, who we all know are the major labels as well!

[@dinosimon4000]

Tynia Coats mind blowing, also thank you so much people don’t realize in this line of work how rare it is to get free game like this

[@charlotteskiftun753]

Pf sloan was crucified by his governing label Dunhill (Lasker& Adler )

[@Preezy315]

So should I cancel my membership with ASCAP?

[@blinkinbaboonbiskit]

I did not know the current foreign PRO number. The rest is info I know. I've been in the industry for a while. My BIGGEST TAKEAWAY: how wonderful it is that you're so knowledgeable and teaching this stuff on this forum!!!! I've helped collect a lot of money by consulting with varied musicians. I've taught two classes on this. I am so grateful to you for making this available. you are someone every musician should watch. This is THE MUSIC BUSINESS. They need to hear you. They also need to get THIS BUSINESS OF MUSIC 10th edition, M. William Krasilovsy. I know there are a lot of other books, but this is the one. And your videos. All of them.. Thank you.

[@RFAMNETWORKS]

Thank you Tynia! I learned so much!!! The history of the companies, the free membership as a writier on BMI you will also get paid your publisher money, more European agreements with BMI, and soooo much more!

[@erikrico3699]

Yeah, getting paid at the same time from my publishing and writers may have me moving from ASCAP to BMI in the near future. Major thanks for that info ! 🙏🏾👍🏾💪🏾

[@St3vi2_HOE]

Nice video very informative! I didn't know they collect from that many countries.. But my question for you is what did you do when you worked at BMI?

[@tyniacoats]

I started out as a Research Assistant in the royalty distribution department, so that's how I learned the ins and outs of royalties. I worked with a lot of writers/music libraries who have placements on TV to get them any royalties missing from TV plays. I also worked with publishing admin companies & many hip-hop producers for the biggest names in rap today, setting everything up to make sure they were getting their proper song splits and going back and forth with their attorneys or managers or pub admin. Then the International Relations team picked me up and I was the coordinator handling our relationship with BMI's foreign sister societies, helping the foreign CMOs with their royalty distribution from BMI & helping them find ways of getting their government to establish certain laws/regulations for them to get better pay. Also dealt heavily with managing/amending BMI's agreements with foreign CMOs & many many more things lol, but this is already too long of a comment haha

[@MegaFOUNDATION1]

TYNIA! THIS IS A GREAT AND CRUCIAL INFO. THIS WAS A SIMILAR THING I WAS TELLING THE GHETTO YOUTHS IN TRENCH TOWN FOR YEARS. SOME LISTENED, BUT SOME DID NOT LISTEN AND LEARN. ARTISTS NEEDED TO KNOW WHO GETS PAID AND HOW THEY GET PAID WHILE THEY DO THEIR ACCOUNTING. I DO NOT HEAR YOU SPEAKING ABOUT REGGAE MUSIC, BUT I CAN HELP YOU TELL THAT STORY. FOR YEARS I HAVE TRIED TO EDUCATE THE GHETTO YOUTHS. GREAT WORKS TYNIA! KEEP THIS POINT IN MIND-"INFORMATION IS A COMMODITY".**YOU SAID IT SO RIGHT TO CREATE AN AWARENESS WITH THOSE WHO DO NOT KNOW THE LEGALITIES**. TYNIA- YOU REMINDED ME OF MY LECTURES WITH THE YOUTHS IN JAMAICA OVER THE YEARS. BE SURE TO TELL THEM THAT THEY NEED TO COPYRIGHT ALL THEIR WORKS, AND OWN IT! WHEN THE WORLD FINALLY SAW THE TRUTH THAT REGGAE CREATION COPYRIGHTS WAS LEGALLY CREATED AND OWNED BY ONE WHO WAS NOT IN PUBLIC MEDIA, THE ENTIRE MUSIC INDUSTRY IS NOW SILENT. STAND STRONG MY SISTER, AND STAY SAFE. SO MUCH MISINFORMATION ABOUNDS IN SOCIAL MEDIA.**I WILL SHARE WHAT OUR CREW KNOW ABOUT-"THE TECHNOLOGY OF PENETRATION"- A TERM USED TO CONTROLLING ALL THE WORLDS MUSIC, AND BY WHICH ENTITIES.

[@Wildenfree]

Hey Tynia this is great content, thank you for providing this knowledge for us, especially with having inside knowledge of how these PRO organizations work. 🙏🏾

[@tyniacoats]

You are welcome! Thank you for supporting me! :)

[@Wildenfree]

Tynia Coats no doubt! Keep up the great work! 🙏🏾✨

[@antoniowoodard3949]

1. You are stunning 2. Thank you so much for this wealth of knowledge. It is greatly appreciated & is truly an asset!

[@yungabe_fashoo]

I absolutely did not know Ascap was one of the original PRO's and that it had so much power in the music industry. It basically controlled the market. Although, it does makes sense due to the fact that it founded in the European culture, and they were big on classical arts of music.

[@vibeydeephouseradio]

Super interesting to find out BMI distributed more royalties to their artists even though they earned less (total earned) than ASCAP in the same year

[@Learningstationmusic]

Thanks for the great info! You are very knowledgeable! 👍

[@JuiceCannon]

Didn't know the history of Bmi & Ascap very useful info

[@WillDivide]

Pretty dope. Love your enthusiasm. Theres a sense of sincerity even when discussing what might otherwise be a difficult topic. Well done!

[@twocuptone]

Yu need the biggest hug love and whatever good energy god has for yu #BlackQueen

[@illclinton3923]

I had no idea that BMI has more international connections and actually paid more royalties recently. Based on what you said, BMI appeals more to me, but one thing is confusing: What’s the benefit to being signed with a publishing company or having your own publishing company vs just signing up with BMI as a songwriter? If I am about to release my first album as an independent artist and plan to distribute with Reverbnation, in your opinion, is it more profitable to 1) start my own publishing company and sign up with BMI as a publisher, 2) sign up just as a songwriter, or 3) try to get signed by a publishing company first?

[@DelmarBrowne]

Nicely done ✅ Thanks for explaining on ASCAP vs BMI

[@gphiproductions]

Wooow! 😮 That was a lot of information that you gave in this video however, GREATLY appreciated! 🙂 I'm new to understanding PRO's and I came across your video after doing search upon search. Great info. and thank you for making this informative video! 👍🏽

[@gilleslionnet9533]

All the best from Seychelles islands 🙏🇸🇨extremely valuable information 👌🎼🌷

[@robinbongos]

You are great. Thank you so much for sharing your experience and knowledge. I really liked hearing about the history including who sits on the board of directors at ASCAP & BMI as well as the bit about ASCAP not registering blues, R&B, jazz and Latin in the early years. I’ve been signed up with BMI since the year 2000. No complaints or strong feelings about which PRO is better, or which would serve my needs better. As a regularly performing artist I really like the BMI Live program. Since I am not associated with a publisher I have been under the impression that I should receive the writer as well as publisher share of any royalties. Something you said in this video made me wonder if it shows that breakdown on my royalty statement. One contradiction that comes up over and over is that I hear people say that a writer must have their own publishing company established in order to collect the publisher’s share. Thanks in advance for any comments you can make about any of this. I have subscribed and look forward to seeing more of your videos. All the best to you.

[@itskdn]

So You are getting Both the Writer's & Publisher's Royalty, right?

[@itxdonn1749]

nah this was a genuine video. the world needs more people like you. thank you so much

[@derrellmitchell2125]

This channel is growing sooo fast😳😳😳

[@tyniacoats]

haha I'm glad you noticed! I've definitely been working on it.

[@GRTVO]

Great video, I've subscribed. But didn't ASCAP pull their music from radio back in the day which then allowed BMI members songs to be played instead, which like you stated was the blues, country etc.

[@EricMajiedMajesticMusic]

I learned that BMI pays more, seems to be more user-friendly than ASCAP.. this is vital information!!!!

[@familydiscount-ne5nz]

Tynia we Appreciate your Soul!💙💯

[@erikriversmusic3564]

Thank you Tynia! This was so informative and helped me choose my PRO. My #1 takeaway was that BMI does not charge a sign up fee, whereas ASCAP does. For future reference, do you offer consulting services?

[@kennyblackbird5674]

It's now $75 to sign up with BMI.

[@dannydadude]

THANKS. I WAS WONDERING THE DIFFERENCE. I'LL SEND YOU A LINK WHEN I'M ON THE AIR

[@Dtownsnoop]

Great video, respect people like you who give the real. Very important and Beneficial in today’s society so would like to thank you so much for the advice! Quick question, wish I would have saw this sooner. I recently tried getting a ASCAP publisher/writers license and it accepted the publisher but denied my writers because it said I was a BMI member which I forgot I did a long time ago but it’s inactive because the term was back in 2010. Is there any way I can keep my ASCAP publisher license and renew my BMI Writers license so I can have both active. Or do they both have to be with only one company?

[@hasanisimmons6290]

Everything was helpful. Didn't know anything about anything. You truly simplified it.

[@beloved3244]

Thank you for all this info. I didn't know that ASCAP denied Jazz music SMH. I'll never sign with them...Period. The 11 dislikes are Ascap members

[@tyniacoats]

hahaha you an't please them all! ASCAP is still a good PRO, people just get mad at the truth. I am just the messenger.

[@beloved3244]

@@tyniacoats yes people always hate the truth smh lol. Thank you ma'am again for all this amazing information. I'm a writer, director and music producer out of echo park. I'm always available to collab. Happy New year! Blessings, lovelymusicnow.com

[@woodyfrasier5204]

@@beloved3244 peace what type of genre you do

[@beloved3244]

Woody Frasier Film Scores, Video Games music, classical orchestra music and hiphop/RMB. I’m a concert pianist, Multi instrumentalist. Wbu?

[@woodyfrasier5204]

@@beloved3244 peace my brother I want to get my songs into video games and film I need directions. I'm diverse songwriter do different genres. I have alot of melodies I would like to turn into track. I would like to collaborate with you my email is [e-mail]

[@zephyrkhambatta]

Good one Tynia. I've subscribed and put a thumbs up. The part I didn't know about was how many they're affiliated to, but given this video is 4 years old, who knows now. But either way, thanks for the learning and confirming all the things I've got here on my mind map. Thanks!

[@natcheral4810]

The information is great but can we all agree shortie is a dime‼️

[@Rapgod_Rob]

I didn't know the History behind ASCAP, WOW! I also didn't know that there are now several PRO's to choose from today. Most folks i talk to point to one like there aren't any other way to collect royalties from your artwork. Good job on your delivery, very informational. Thanx.

[@tribeofpole7039]

You are BADD MAMA!!! So beautiful and great advice!!!

[@SilverWolf941]

What if you start an LLC and its individually owned, how much would BMI charge? Is it a one time fee or reoccurring?

[@tyniacoats]

For LLCs, it's a one-time fee of $250. If it's an individually owned DBA, then it's a one-time fee of $150.

[@canadianfunk8235]

Tynia Coats So if I sign up with BMI as a DBA then register my business later that year as an LLC what are the changes or process I would need to undertake in order to ensure my royalties are sound 🤙🏾🐝

[@GlobalPrivateTruthWarrior]

Best video regarding PROs that I've found. COngrats. BTW: White balance your camera, then when you turn off camera, etc, the colors won't change slightly.

[@babypinhead7656]

EXTREMELY HELPFUL WOW THANK YOU !!!

[@tyniacoats]

You are welcome! :)

[@coralbrune]

Thanks I signed with GMI a month ago. Learned about the differences and also about termination of your undesired membership. Plus money payout differences, thanks!

[@AyoMillz]

My takeaway: it’s time to leave ASCAP. I have several reasons why but the collection agreements primarily was enough.

[@freestyleking12345]

Did u make any money

[@amun3theemcee728]

Good looks, I was debating which one to sign up to and I would rather have a contract that is set in stone instead of one that is changing.

[@producedbym.o.o.d5169]

Your Dope! Thank You and this info is extremely necessary and underrated.

[@ItsYaBoy3rd]

I never know about the real royalty breakdown between the 2 companies you are very informative

[@autumncrownetv]

Never knew the history! I would love to hear how do you get that first 100 or 200 with a PRO basically methods to help one earn cash when they are just starting out

[@tyniacoats]

wow that is actually a great video suggestion!! Will keep it in mind for a future video.

[@AlanaTheEmpress]

Great question

[@Qrayon]

When I came out with my album many years ago, I studied what the deal was with ASCAP and BMI. I signed up with BMI because I could see that because of the way each performing rights society calculates what songs were played on the radio and elsewhere, a lesser known songwriter like me was much more likely to get royalties from BMI than from ASCAP. I received royalties from BMI that I never would have got from ASCAP. The royalties were meager, but it's still nice to get that check in the mail.

[@4Paczjkor]

If your a hip hop producer should you join ASCAP or BMI? I hear that BMI is more beneficial for TV/Film and classical composers l.

[@tyniacoats]

Either one is great for hip-hop producers, so the choice is all yours! Both BMI & ASCAP have the best hip-hop producers and do well handling the royalties for them; so you're in good hands either way.

[@iamkingziionproductions100]

As always delivering the best information on music business 😃

[@THEfonzarelliPROJECT]

The part about ASCAP being able to amend! 🤯

[@tyniacoats]

Yeah that's a little scary, but hey; it is what it is! ASCAP is still a great PRO, that just definitely raises a red flag.

[@charlotteskiftun753]

Decieving

[@shawnn5213]

I like your honesty. Very rare in this business. I am also in the insurance industry and there are a lot of similarities in both industries concerning royalties/commissions and contracts

[@jacobolmos2475]

I've signed up with TuneCore and have released one song. Does me using TC as a distributor affect my being able to sign up with BMI/ASCAP?

[@tyniacoats]

Nope, it does not affect your ability to sign up with BMI or ASCAP and you absolutely should sign up with one of them or you will not be receiving all of your royalties.

[@alfreddreamerphotocomics4880]

Enlighten us oh Great One. Feed us knowledge. Bestow the information we need. More more, I want more, damn it.

[@STUDIO66music]

Great Channel :) VERRY GOOD INFO !

[@thevoiceofaustinbrewer8522]

I did not know who I was going to go with until this video but now I know its BMI thanks for the info

[@richarddavis5542]

BMI is $75, ASCAP is free - as of 3-27-2024.

[@kneedeepentertainment7453]

THANK YOU FOR YOUR SINCERE INFORMATION!! I'M GR8FUL AND I EXPRESS GRATITUDE 🙏🏾!! KEEP INSPIRING KEEP EDUCATING AND CONTINUE IMPACTING LIVES ONE DAY AT A TIME!! 🌠🌍🧲🧘🏽🧿🦅🪶🎰🚀🌹❤️‍🔥🤴🏿

[@asavagehandproductions186]

Didn't know about the history of ascap I didn't forget that thanks for sharing real knowledge.....

[@swagnewstv1180]

Beauty & Brains :)

[@tyniacoats]

Thank you! :)

[@jakelong113]

This is gold - just in time for getting my beats channel up. BMI it is!